Decent. Catchy generic sound, but on the back end hasn't aged much.

Kind sweet until the last song, which is so bad and inconsistent with the foregoing that it lost a star

This was not good at all. Y’all must be drunk [in love]

Weird Indian sidetrack mid album

Don’t know that I needed the song straight up repeated.

If you like listening to variations of shitty guitar feedback, this is the album for you.

Crazy takes here. This is a classic album

For Your [Moderate] Pleasure

Nice subtle commentary

Decent.

Fan of the sound of the album (outside of much of the singing), but otherwise could be rough at times.

Maybe hire a singer

Dudes got pipes and there’s consistent musicianship with variation between songs. Guitar sound is a bit grating, I’d like to hear them with modern polish on the recording.

Fine

You could cross the Pacific Ocean in the time it takes to finish this album.

Solid

Never actually listened to the full album, and didn’t realized that it basically contains all their jams.

90 percent is so bad that I can’t give the decent parts any star-based credit

Kinda funk

The worst Radiohead album I’ve ever heard. Any other band and no critic would have put it anywhere near this list

Slash hard carrying this album. Hard to rate because of the highs and lows.

Weirdly good?

Finding this one really hard to rate. Some of that is the weird context of the album, but the production is great and I’ve never heard an album flow from one song to the next as effectively—it plays like one fever dream.

Every member of the band killing it for their part, consistent themes and sound, no bad songs and a few all-timers. An easy five irrespective of Ozzy’s death or its outsized influence.

I’m going to veer from the group and rate this highly, classic singles but even the deep tracks are mostly solid. I wish these ratings were out of ten, because really I think this album is an 8.5, but I guess that means I’m rounding up.

All Along the Watchtower and Voodoo Child truly save this album

Just not good. There’s a huge quality gap between this album and Fresh Fruit for Rotting Vegetables

Realizing that I enjoy live albums. Honestly considering 4 or 5 for this. Also rare that a live album song version is the definitive recording (I want you to want me).

I would ride this album like the haradrim

Not my taste but decent. My heart didn’t find the groove of some of the deeper tracks

Surprised by how little I enjoyed this. Lyrics are good and some solid tracks—but my man, if your voice sounds like that you can’t also be absolutely blaring mediocre harmonica. If the point of an album is to make enjoyable sounds, then shouldn’t your sound be good?

Good.

Halfway through the album I stopped and realized this was rad yo.

It was mostly fine, but that’s about all I’ve got