Album Summary
Rid of Me is the second studio album by English singer-songwriter and musician PJ Harvey. It was released by Island Records in May 1993, approximately one year after the release of her critically acclaimed debut album Dry. It marked a departure from Harvey's previous songwriting, being more raw and aggressive than its predecessor. The songs on Rid of Me were performed by Harvey's eponymous trio, consisting of Harvey on guitar and vocals, Rob Ellis on drums and background vocals, and Steve Vaughan on bass. Most of the songs on the album were recorded by Steve Albini, and it was the last album they recorded as a trio before disbanding in late 1993. Rid of Me was met with critical acclaim, and is cited as one of the greatest albums of all time, ranking at number 153 on the 2020 version of Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Albums of All Time (up from 406 on the list's previous edition).
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
VERY unusual record. I can’t even describe how much I liked it, def one of my inspirations in making music! Really great album! 9.5/10
I got tricked by the classic quiet-loud dynamic in the opening track. I turned the speaker way up and then it all exploded and the baby woke up and everyone was unhappy and it was all PJ Harvey’s fault. I accept no responsibility, express or implied.
Some bad-assery is just well-executed. I am also sexually intimidated.
Can't nobody tell me shit when I'd pop this in my Discman and ride the bus to 10th grade. No, siree.
(3/5) So, our group of four have had three PJ albums in as many weeks. Some of the Reddit forums on this project have noted that sometimes happens. What it's doing is giving me a bit of a Harvey hangover. I like her stuff enough and finding her through the list has been revelatory, but I'm not in **love** with her stuff to go deep diving. I'd honestly say that 4 of her albums is too much. So, this album is super grungy, 90s sounding and I like it for that time and place, but damned if I'm not getting tired of her. DIMERY ducks it up again by giving us too much of something and not moderating better. I think 2 of her's would have sufficed. This and her later "Stories.." would have been a fine showcase of her work, talents, and growth. Now, I'm suffering from the headache and I need a break. It's not her, it's me..
Didn’t thrill me.
Recorded after non-stop touring in support of her debut record, PJ Harvey's sophomore effort captures her in the raw and vulnerable state that followed. The fact that Rid of Me was produced by Steve Albini hones the raw edge of the record because he had a knack for capturing such things. The sparse production makes Harvey's screams and whispers feel like the edge of a nervous breakdown happening in the room with you. As much as I love the record, it certainly feels like it could have been trimmed down a bit. A handful of tracks are probably b-side material, but I'm not too mad at them for hanging around. Even at its lowest point, Rid of Me is a landmark record of alternative rock in the 90s and a standout feminist record. It helped pave the way for acts like the Yeah, Yeah, Yeahs, Elastica, Sleater-Kinney, St. Vincent, Wolf Alice, and many more. Not bad for an album that was all but done in three days of a two week recording session.
749/1001 2026.11.19 🌕🌕🌕🌑🌑
Another PJ Harvey album that I nearly like: the are flashes of something I feel is just beyond my reach but which would be unlocked with a few more listens. I think this is what 'not quite getting it' feels like. I like the rawness and energy of an early PJH album and I like her as an artist. The jury is out but signs are good.
Absolutely terrible.
I didn't quite like this one as much as the previous two PJ Harvey albums we got - I think her talents suit themselves less to this fairly guttural noise rock sound - but still very solid!
Didn’t really enjoy this, especially in comparison to the other PJ Harvey stuff I’ve heard. Like even from the very first song, the production was … not ideal. This is a very low 2.
While this isn't really my type of music, every song on here caught my ear in one way or another - be it a riff, a rhythm, or PJ Harvey going hard as fuck. Loved her energy. Standouts: Rub 'Til It Bleeds • Man-Size Sextet • Highway '61 Revisited • 50ft Queenie • Dry • Snake • Ecstasy
I like this album for sure, but it's my least favorite of hers. I think she did the crunchy distortion stuff way better on To Bring You My Love. This is experimental, but not necessarily in a way that I think elevates the work. Unfortunately have never really gotten the hype around this album in particular.
gostei mas num nivel meio tanto faz, não sei se ouviria novamente
até que gostei, tenho que ouvir mais atentamente
PJ Harvey said, concerning her music, “I like feeling unsettled, unsure.” She has definitely achieved that here. It’s how the music sounds and also how I feel about it! But… I seem to be in a habit of rating PJ Harvey albums 4/5 and why stop now? She has a great edge and was a leader in her class. As with “Dry” (her first album) I grow weary somewhere in the second half. But she has apparently cast a spell on me that leaves me saying, “It’s not you… it’s me.” I wonder if this is a healthy relationship. In any case, I’ll unsettle on 4/5 again because when she’s good she’s really good.
Ehei
its good and weird.
I just don't get this PJ. People really like her, and I ... don't. This just wasn't good, and I don't need to her her again.
Не знаю, у пиджей харви были более близкие мне работы, тут местами тревожно, местами гадко, а где то и скучновато
PJ Harvey has to be one of the coolest women to ever do it.
Omg hi queen! The timing on this project is wild bc I was just staring at her Instagram post with nick cave earlier today. What are the fates doing? // I love her voice. LOVE. And her whole vibe. I don’t know what my relationship is with Steve Albini yet. In Utero grew on me wildly (after thinking I wasn’t cool enough for most of it during my first listen 😂) so I do think I need to be in the right mood/setting. So some of it didn’t suit the sunny suburban walk with Augie dog, but it thrived on a drive. Title track is magic that transcends mood/setting though. And some of the noisiest of noise won’t work for me regardless. Overall, I want to listen to more of her! And like, inject whatever wisdom she def has. And also I want to do this photo. Also her name is Polly Jean Harvey, and she’s the only artist to win the Mercury Prize twice, what a fucking badass.
Raw. Visceral. PJ Harvey has always forged her own identity.
This is just stressful to listen to. The music and production causes anxiety. I don’t know if that’s what they were going for or not but I can’t take it.
A much better muse than musician. This whole album is just annoying - I'm not sure I was particularly keen when I was younger and it hasn't grown on me since.
I pretend to like music that kicks me in the balls, but when it actually does, it makes me kind of uncomfortable.
Bought this on release. It's just ridiculously good.
Muy enojada la PJ
My girl for life.
simply a masterpiece
This was my first time listening to PJ Harvey and oh boy it was a weird experience. I have really mixed feelings about this album. First off this album sounds raw, grungy. Reminds me of Nirvana. Especially when I first heard Rub it till it bleeds, Heart Shaped Box was the first song that came to my mind. The first song in the album, Rid of me starts very quiet. So I increased the volume to hear more of the music and suddenly it got so loud at the chorus, it literally startled me when i first heard it. I wasn’t ready for it. I am really on the middle with this one. On the one hand I really liked the sound of it. It’s raw, harsh, explosive. Even after I finished listening I wanted to listen more to that. First song I played after this was Heart Shaped Box. On the other hand it was veery sexual, at one point I was like what the horny fck is this. Especially Man Sized Sextet, it was a hard listen and I just couldn’t finish that song. Nonetheless this was surely an album that deserves to be on this list. It makes you uneasy in a weird, good way. Also I think the album cover reflects the album perfectly.
Wish we could
muitas músicas não fazem o meu estilo, mas num geral gostei da impressão forte que causou. ansiosa pelos outros albuns desta querida.
I did not find this to be anything special, or interesting.
2.5
I’ve been looking forward to this one coming up. I really enjoyed PJ Harvey’s debut album (first heard through this list) and this one is even better, thanks in part to superb production by the great Steve Albini that is both unvarnished and dramatic. The title track and album opener is a spine tingling start building slowly and ending in a violent emotional catharsis, making it probably the greatest breakup song of all time. The rest of the album is similarly good with all of the songs written by Harvey with the exception of a cheeky cover of Highway 61 Revisited that she included for her parents who were Dylan fans. Lick-my-legs-I’m-On-Fire-tastic!
I know she’s well respected, but I just find her … grating.
Really enjoyable. Starts off with a grungy set of songs with meaty guitar but has a variety of styles and depth that I didn’t necessarily expect from the off. Some quite despairing if not haunting songs dotted in amongst the angst. Will listen again.
Reminds me of my early 20s down a local rock establishment. It has that abrasive, straight guitar noise which seems to bleed into everything, but then has another rhythm layer on top. It then plucks out soft sections which carve out even more fragility in the vocals, despite the limited guitar, making it quite varied in terms of harshness and atmosphere. Hard to explain, but this seems like artists expressing themselves in a very one-directional way. They hear what they play and engage with it. Simple as that. If there was a person carrying their emotions on their sleeve, this would be that person expressing themselves through music. That's how I feel about this. I really enjoyed it and found myself headbanging to it while cooking. A lovely musical meditation experience.
The raw production quality of this album is such a breath of fresh air compared to modern pop music. It's so realistic and expressive rather than overly produced to an inhuman marketing product. The dynamic range is so large I had to turn my headphones up a few notches. It sounds like you are listening into a killer jam session. Musically, its a curious album. I listened through twice and was still not 100% sure what I thought about it, beyond that it is good. It sort of like seeing an artsy independent film. Doesn't have the pizzaz of Hollywood but maybe higher on artistic merit. I'm new to PJ Harvey but I think she will end up being one of the little wins of this project.
Boring
I’m still not on the PJ Harvey bandwagon but there was something compelling enough about this album that kept my attention. I can’t say I really liked it but I didn’t hate it either. Interesting Dylan cover. About on par with the last one we had so sticking with a 3.
Don’t I wish I was rid of her. What’s the obsession with PJ Harvey and this 1001 project? We have yet to hear a good album from her and despite that very important fact we’ve now been served up with three of her albums. Good instruments and whiny lyrics over and over. No thank you.
This one takes a while to get going and that is time I just don’t have to give. I guess I disagree with the critics … again.
A musical modern art piece that doesn't speak too me, too chaotic. I don't like the product, but I respect the risks taken and like the idea of an album like this.
I'm glad to say that I have a more immediate opinion on this compared to Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea. From the first track on, I knew that I was about to get something good and she continued to deliver a strong statement throughout. Better than solid, well-done (8/10, 4/5 on this scale)
Didn't hate it, didn't love it
I was actually excited about this album when I saw it. Her other albums made me a fan and I have known this cover for a long time, but I never listened to it. I was actually a little take aback. This was raw and respectable. Knowing now that her life was literally spiraling it makes sense why this album feels so angst. Man-Sized Sextet almost gave me a nervous breakdown just listening to the despondency of the orchestrations. I really liked the Dylan Cover for Highway ‘61. It was very punk! The follow up 50ft Queenie was even more punk. Key songs for me were Dry and Snake. I definitely get why it’s on this list. When I was younger I probably would have either ignored this album because it was “chick rock”, or fucking loved it (I should have opened my mind and ears). Next time I listen I think I will be more prepared for the tsunami of sound and emotion.
Random thoughts: * I can see why PJ Harvey broke through with this album. Perfect female aggression in the time of grunge. * Is PJ Harvey the Liz Phair of England? * This album was rocking and raw. * Do we need 4 PJ Harvey albums on this list? Not at all. * However, this is probably the one that should be on this list. * I'll definitely revisit this one again.
Despite this artist being named after a sleeping garment, do not make the mistake of thinking this is an album of lullabies.
Great album. Such energy and angst all in one place.
Хороший гранж, грязный, дерзкий и с грувом хорошим. Конечно местам чувствуется фемнизим, но тексты иногда мне и самому понятны, только в противоположном направлении
Look. This album is the equal or better to any of Nirvana's. It's one of those special albums that, if someone tells me what they think about it, I can not only outline their musical taste pretty accurately but probably make a good assessment of their identity. Albini's production is great, the mix is expressively dynamic, I just love the sound of this album. The songs are just nuts musically and lyrically. If I try to find filler, I look at "Hook" for a second, but though it might be the weakest track here, it's still a keeper. If I try to pick a favorite, I basically jump from track to track. Man-Size isn't the answer, just an example, but holy shit it's got everything. On my personal top 100.
Like this more than the previous PJ Harvey sample that was generated a few months back. Dig the raw energy and authentic grunge feel. I can imagine it would have been unreal to see this album toured live. Previously felt like I didn't really get the hype around PJ Harvey but this has definitely changed that perception.
This is peak Polly Jean Harvey and it's so much noisier and more raw than I remember. I love it!
This album would have been my first exposure to PJ (through 120 Minutes and of course Beavis & Butthead) in college, but I didn't really get into her until a few years later on Stories from the City, Stories from the Sea. I know I've heard the Dylan cover but I don't remember where. I thought it might be on the compilation Chimes of Freedom, but that appears to not be the case. I know I don't have "an ear" for such things, but I have never understood the fascination everyone has with Albini's production -er, RECORDING work. This seems to be mixed really quiet and murky like the Breeders' Pod was. There were several times I couldn't tell there was any music and had to crank up my speakers. Maybe it would be better in noise-canceling headphones? "50ft Queenie" was the highlight for me but probably because I already knew it.
I think this is good? But it left me feeling quite uninspired. Might be what I was doing simultaneously rather than anything else, but still.
I just re-listening to this album while making Riley’s playlist. An all timer
Emotional, messy, and unrelentingly horny. This album is a lot, even before you get to the unconventionality of a lot of it. The guitar work is excellent and the production from Albini is a perfect fit. Fantastic record.
Até hoje não consegui me conectar com os discos da PJ Harvey. Particularmente eu acho muito ruim, e esse aqui pra mim é o pior disparado.
Rid Of Me was another really good entry in PJ Harvey's lineup. This one seems to take after Dry way more than any of the other PJ Harvey albums on the list as it has this very rough grunge sound that Dry also had. I really do like this sound mainly due to my love of grunge music in general with my only issues with this album being some parts of it's production and the fact that it did feel like it was dragging a little bit. Other than that though, i really can't think of anything else that this album does wrong, guitars have that rough sound i love, the vocals are great and the melodies are super enjoyable. This was a great album to say the least. Best Song: Highway '61 Revisited Worst Song: Man-Size Side note: Last PJ Harvey album, meaning: 1. Dry 2. Rid Of Me 3. Let England Shake 4. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea
a lot of nothing here for me 1014/1089
I would gave up alternative, I just don’t understand what’s in it.
Introduction to her music. Have heard of her of course but did not expect her early work to be all punk. It was fine punk music I suppose with the Dylan cover in it also. I'd expect her later music to be much better.
Consistently good, and not likely to have me come back to the album. Perhaps not a very detailed review, but some music just doesn't evoke interest in me.
3.75 fantastic, gritty, raw.
So-so
Everything about this was just kind of weird. It’s a weird picture for the cover. It’s weird vocals. It’s weird lyrics. It’s weird music. It’s just all felt weird and that doesn’t necessarily mean bad just weird.
🙄 some chick sayin’ something, who cares
I like plenty of PJ Harvey songs, but I’ve never been compelled to listen to an entire album
First half great second half headache
Am I wrong to think Jack White got a lot of inspiration from this album? Best Song: Man-Size Rating: 8.5/10 Stars: 4
90s alt rock. Strong, agressive and bold.
When I heard "Steve Albini" and "grungier," I really expected to get into this one, despite it being her 3rd entry we've gotten in the last two weeks. Alas, that impression was short lived. While the three works we've reviewed have been rather varying stylistically, I can't say that I've loved any of them, and this one falls somewhere between "Stories" (my personal preference) and "Let England Shake," but it's not getting the nod up from a 3.5/5, either.
223. Rid of Me - PJ Harvey (1993) 10.3.26 Variety: 5 Adequacy: 4 Listenability: 4 Uniqueness: 5 Emotionality: 5 = 4.6 rounded up to a 5 "I'll measure time/ I'll measure height/ I'll calculate/ My birthright" Wow. Our third PJ Harvey album in about two weeks. I think that might be the tightest cluster for a single artist we've had yet. Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea I consider to be her best album, and I gave it 5 stars. Let England Shake was quite good, but only got a 4 from me. Dry is the other one left we haven't gotten to yet, and I honestly do not remember much about it except that I liked it enough to hang on to the CD. Rid of Me I remember liking quite a bit, but it's been so long since I listened to it, I'm not sure how it ranks with her others. I think going forward whenever I finish the last album by an artist with multiple entries I might try and listen to other albums around it and see where everything sits. Harvey is one of those musicians who doesn't seem to have made a bad album yet, my measure, though I have yet to listen to her last two all the way through. And that doesn't even include all the collaborations she's done. I also appreciate that Harvey tries to do something completely different on each album and seems to hate repeating herself. This puts her up in an echelon of artists who have long careers full of experimentation but who still manage to bed and shape that experimentation towards something they still think people would want to hear. She's up there with Bjork, Radiohead, Nick Cave, Beck and a few other big acts to come out of the 90s that managed to stay relevant by adapting and updating their sounds. And I'm pretty sure at this point in time, she's only maybe ten years older than me, so hopefully she has several more decades of putting out cool shit. My memories of this album are very colored by seeing her very striking music videos, and then discovering this album first before I even knew Dry had been out. At the time I think I has also just started listening to Tori Amos, and I found Harvey to be a more raw and muscularly rock n roll antidote to the ( still very raw) piano stuff Amos was doing. But they are tied together in time. Bjork I had already been well aware of, and had maybe primed me for some more esoteric music by talented women. Of hose three I think Harvey has maybe held up the best. Amos I eventually fell off and stopped following, and Bjork I still hear occasionally when my wife picks up her latest. Harvey feels both more approachable than either of those two, and I think straddles the line better between experimental and mainstream, with the other two being pretty squarely over the fence in each direction. Hopefully this one holds up. THE TRACKS Side one "Rid of Me" - The title track starts off with a droning repetitive bit that build and builds until Harvey comes in with her husky, menacing vocals and takes us on a creepy little journey through obsession, possession, and jealousy. When the chorus EXPLODES it's full of anger and power, and it leaves almost as fast as it came in, and gives the impression of danger and harm in way some of the best metal songs are able to do. I'm not sure if it's Harvey herself providing the background vocals, or Rob Ellis or both, but it's creepy and very effective. "Missed" - I've read that Harvey was a fan of Slint and this track has more than a little bit in common with their stuff on the Spiderland album, at least rhythmically, and the repetitive, tense, hangdog guitar lines make the comparison pretty strong. Where she differs is in her embrace of the dynamic range between the cold droning beat, and how full of emotion her voice is. There's also more than a little blues DNA in here, though it's so twisted around and mutated, you have to listen closely. "Legs" - This one dives even deeper into the blues sound, though through a GIANT, ragged punk lens that also feels like it was more than a little influenced by some Noise Rock. The guitar work is maybe the only thing on here approaching the grunge sound, and I still get confused by that being applied to much of any of her work. This has far more in common with stuff like Pixies, or Pere Ubu than anything coming out of Seattle at the time. We get another darkly obsessive, possibly romantic song here, and with more threats of bodily harm and mutilation. "Rub 'til It Bleeds" - More than anything yet, this one sounds like it could have come off a number of later albums, with it's rubber bandy guitar lines, the understated drum work, and Harvey's vocal gymnastics. The Slint influence is still there, and it's the very dry and almost reverbless production sound that ultimately gives it away, and makes it sound raw and frayed and like you're sat on the stage in the middle of the chaos when it jumps up, and they're just playing all around you, Harvey yelling right in your face. As an ode to masturbation, it's maybe not quite up there with "She Bops", "Turning Japanese", or "Dancing With Myself", but it's certainly pretty damn memorable. "Hook" - This one had the sort of Tom Waits-sh, banging on a garbage can lid, hobo band sort of feel to it which was interesting, but all the interesting noises sort of drowned Harvey out of her own song, and it feels like her vocals are barely there. The first one on the album that has back of my neck itching in anticipation of more of the same. This is the type of song I can imagine being much more impressive live. That doesn't translate as well here though. "Man-Size Sextet" - This was very cool and unexpected. Had completely forgotten about it. A sort of re-interpretation of her own song ( still 4 away) and quite the swing, especially as a side one closer. It's sort of like performance art piece, withe the lyrics of that song almost more spoken than sung over top of some very tense strings that feel straight out of a postmodern Krzysztof Penderecki orchestral piece. I can see a lot of people choosing to stop here, and not sure i could blame them. I liked it though. Side two "Highway 61 Revisited" - Dylan's classic (though never one of my favorites of his) is barely recognizable here, and Harvey performs the magic trick of making something so well known into something she absolutely owns. I stopped to go back and listen to the original for comparison's sake, and yeah... I think Harvey's is the better experience. The opening tinny radio sound that then busts into nervous and almost panicky sounding piece that sounds like it's falling down an endless staircase is augmented by multiple dynamic and distinctive sections, which make the Dylan original sound boring. "50ft Queenie" - Harvey gets to tackle some pyschobilly sounds on this one, with some sleazy, crackling guitars the Cramps or the Butthole Surfers would be proud of. And all of it's buried underneath some MASSIVE drum and bass that gives the impression of some crazed revelers dancing around a giant bonfire that's rising ever higher. Also - hand claps! "Yuri-G" - Much as I love the previous track, and the one right after this one - this is maybe my dark horse pick for favorite. The atmosphere is dark and dirty, and the processing on Harvey's vocals give the impression of another obsessed, lost and confused state of mind. And this tie we've got a ton of cool textures like the cello bits, the buzzsaw guitars and the frenetic drumming. "Man-Size" - The actual, legit inarguably best song on the album and one full of awesomeness. The guitar work alone on this is enough to elevate it into 5-star territory, but it's one of Harvey's best and most magnetic vocal performances throughout her entire catalogue. It's sexy, and threatening, and full of a confidence and commanding power you don't often see outside of some of the top tier metal vocalists like Rob Halford or Bruce Dickinson. It's also got a hell of a music video that melted by teenage brain at the time. This is an all-timer, one of many that Harvey has contributed. "Dry" - How can you follow that up? With something that's much more of a standard bit of catchy and simple alt-rock where we get a some more sexual metaphors, housed in a very straight forward dressing down of a romantic partner and their ... inadequacies, that's almost as funny as it is poppy. Well, as poppy as Harvey gets. "Me-Jane" - Some more psychobilly guitar and bass work here on an awesomely crunchy and rhythmically exciting piece that see's Harvey writing from the point of view of Tarzan's long suffering mate Jane. Even in 1993 Tarzan is a reference that was WELL past it's sell date, and the fact that she manages to pull this off without it being a complete joke is nothing short of impressive. That it fucking rocks is just a bonus. "Snake" - Assuming the voice of the put upon women of fiction is a well Harvey is not afraid to immediately draw from again, only this time it's a burner of a track in which Eve ( of Garden fame) gives that damn serpent a piece of her mind. Rob Ellis's drum work throughout has been amazing, but deserves a special callout here, as it's especially explosive. Harvey gets her rasp on and ends up providing some very cool and crazy vocal effects, almost sound like one of those accordion straws when you pull them apart. Crazy. "Ecstasy" - The downright bluesiest track on the album, the guitar riff repeats and bends within an apocalyptic bed of thrashing cymbals and Harvey's emotional and tortured vocals that for some reason reminded me of Lene Lovich in the vibrato and twisted syllables. This really makes me want Harvey to record a punked out blues standards cover album. I can easily see Karen O of the Yeah Yeah Yeahs being a big fan of this song in particular. HIGHLIGHTS - "Rid of Me" - "Missed" - "Legs" - "Rub 'til It Bleeds" - "Man-Size Sextet" - "Highway 61 Revisited" - "50ft Queenie" - "Yuri-G" - "Man-Size" - "Dry" - "Me-Jane" - "Snake" - "Ecstasy" MIDLIGHTS - "Hook" LOWLIGHTS - FINAL THOUGHTS I like that Harvey, whether she may or may not be working out personal issues in her music, never makes it obvious or spells out anything and lets the listener build these narratives out of what at least appears to be dark little vignettes. You get very little stuff form her that could ever be mistaken for an "I feel this way or that" heart on your sleeve type thing that someone like Tori Amos is great at. If Amos is making her narratives up out of whole cloth, she manages to convince you it's real. With Harvey it could be the very opposite, and you'll never know. There remains a wall of ambiguity that I really, really like. This is probably Harvey at her most rocking, and would be the album I'd recommend to someone who was into metal or grunge. I had forgotten just how damn good it is, and would probably put it up right amongst her finest. I think Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea is still her overall most accomplished album that I've heard, and I full expected White Chalk ( an easy 5-stars but not on the list) to beat this out, but now I'm not so sure. This is at least in rival for second best I think. I'll try and find time to work in a full catalogue re-listen before we get to that last one. Unless it also pops up within the next week or two... She's also got a couple of albums she collaborated with John Parish that I don't think I've ever heard, so might work those in as well. Overall an excellent album, and a joy to revisit. Harvey deserves all her spots on the list and remains fully cemented as one of the rock greats. Possible turn-Offs might include: - raw, and dry production sound - lyrics that might have you blushing if you don't wear headphones - lots of left turns into more artsy territory that come out of nowhere You Might enjoy this if you: - dig strong female vocalists - like complex textures in your heavy music - are looking for something that varies in style throughout PLAYLIST ALTERATIONS - Nah FURTHER LISTENING Precursors: - Highway 61 Revisited by Bob Dylan - Trout Mask Replica by Captain Beefheart - Easter by Patti Smith Group - Surfer Rosa by Pixies - Goat by The Jesus Lizard - Spiderland by Slint - Stateless by Lene Lovich Contemporaries: - Debut by Bjork -Last Splash by the Breeders - Under the Pink by Tori Amos - Bricks Are Heavy by L7 - Exile in Guyville by Liz Phair Descendants: - In Utero by Nirvana - Tidal by Fiona Apple - Garbage by Garbage - Call the Doctor by Sleater-Kinney - Fever to Tell by Yeah Yeah Yeahs - Marry Me by St. Vincent - The Record by Boygenius
Our third PJ Harvey album in 15 days. I wish they could've been spaced out farther apart but thus is the nature of randomness. "Stories from the City..." got a 4 from me and "Let England Shake" a three. It was a bit jarring hearing this one right after that 2011 album. "Let England Shake" I said was an album that one does 20 twenties years into your career. Well, this is the debut and it sounds like the album you make when you're at the beginning. Its a raw sound and full of the alternative rock of the time. Its performing angst if not always truly feeling like angst. No surprise, I enjoyed it more. "Rid of Me" falls right in the middle of the three albums we've had, I prefer it to "Let England Shake, but not as much as "Stories..." 4/5
No sir, I will not lick your legs.
with each pj harvey album i get like i her more and more
More dull alt rock from the 90s, *Rid Of Me* is chock-full of overly dramatic singing against unimaginative guitar parts. The antiseptic production by Steve Albini only emphasizes how slight the songwriting is on this record.
Another that can be categorised as influential but not for me
3.5
I read on Wikipedia that Warren Zevon was a big fan of this album, so I was expecting something Zevon-esque. Imagine my surprise when after expecting something like, "I saw a werewolf with a Chinese menu in its hand," I instead heard, "Lick my legs, I'm on fire." After that initial shock, though, yeah this album is great
A while back, I started my own ‘greatest albums if all time’ playlist and this is already on it. It’s frustrating that I was 30+ years late to the PJ Harvey bandwagon, but I’m glad I got here eventually. I'm fortunate that this list gave me PJ Harvey's first album, Dry, first and let me start at the beginning. I've since also reviewed Stories From The City, Stories From The Sea, but I try not to compare albums to the artist's later works when possible. Compared to Dry, this record shows some remarkable growth and a much more focused sound. That's kind of a weird thing to say about an album that Steve Albini was brought in to produce, but it's true. Where Dry felt very DIY and raw, Rid Of Me has about as much polish as you would put on a grunge record in 1992/1993. The little bits of cowpunk twang have been omitted - or at least they're now running through a fuzz pedal so they don't twang like they used to (see "Ecstasy"). Dry was gritty because the recording equipment probably wasn't good but this feels gritty because they CHOSE to make it feel that way, it doesn't feel like you're hearing the recording equipment or the process at all (if that makes any sense), just a band playing themselves into grunge history. That all sounds like I'm giving reasons why this record is better than Dry, and I'm actually not sure I feel that way. Both albums are amazing in different ways and I don't know if I could pick one over the other. That said, Dry had some unrealized potential (mostly in the recording) and I gave it 4 stars for that. This album doesn't suffer thesame problem (at least by comparison) so I'm going to rate it higher. I think it's a case of two 4.5 star records being rounded differently. required postscript: I love to talk about how this album was recorded by Steve Albini in the same remote Minnesota studio - in the same winter(!) - as Nirvana’s In Utero. This one was recorded first and, for my money, it's the better of the two albums. I don’t think anyone gets as excited as I do about this incredibly niche fun fact, but I also don’t think I know anyone who rates Polly Jean as highly as I do. Some day I'll make a pilgrimage up to Cannon Falls so I can see Pachyderm Studio for myself.
It's a wonder how such a bold and forward-thinking album turned out to be so flawless. Everything is just how it should be. Albini's mixing is marvelous, making the most out of every guitar strum and drumbeat. The music demands your attention every step of the way and constantly surprises you with so many little nuggets of creative brilliance. The real star is obviously Polly, though. She offers a phenomenal, charismatic and diverse vocal performance, enriched by great lyricism. It's as blunt and aggressive as it gets, exactly the way these themes should be presented. With all of that said, her subsequent two albums are even better and it's an absolute shame they aren't included in the list. Favourite track: Yuri-G 5/5
I had never spent much time with this one, and it did not move me the way the next four albums do. Still, points for power and commitment.
Tiresome. She was appealing for one album and this isn't it.
Should not be on this list.
Thought I would like this more than I did. There’s something off where the songs feel more like individual statements than songs. Idk
I was really into her when she came onto the scene, I played the crap out of this record! Fierce, unapologetic with something to say/snarl this album is my fave of hers
This is straight-up beef carpaccio. It's so very raw. And for many, it's cringy to their delicate palates. The very thought of uncooked meat makes their stomach turn, but for the rest of us - wow! This one is high quality all the way, with lemon that gives it a zesty kick in the ass. Eat up!
Most albums are released. This album is unleashed. Where her first album was emotionally brutal - Rid of Me matches that brutality musically. The first side especially is the feeling of breaking down and verges on falling apart completely. Voice and drums are right at the edge of falling into the abyss with shards of guitar pushing them ever closer. Side two is tighter and has some songs that could be described as catchy (depending on you mood) before Me-Jane charges in to knock your block clean off. Ferocious. You simply can't leave this album without feeling something.
I don’t know how to really rate this at lowest it’s 2.5 at its highest for me it might be a 3.5 with multiple listens. It definitely going for something just not sure if that something is for me DRY is best track. Light 3/5
Intense, brutal, unique, jarring, kinda' violent. I don't know that it's something I'd pick up for myself but yeah...it's something.
Honestly, putting on Rid of Me feels less like listening to music and more like bracing for an attack. Steve Albini’s production is so raw and abrasive that the sudden jumps from quiet to deafening actually hit you like a punch. Polly is an absolute force here, she sounds feral, snarling and whispering her way through songs about obsession and power with a post-punk blues energy that doesn't care if you're uncomfortable. Some of the production choices, like the screeching strings on "Man-Size Sextet", are definitely jarring, but it all feels intentional. Beyond the killer title track and "50ft Queenie", her cover of "Highway 61 Revisited" is completely unhinged. She takes Dylan’s song and turns it into a frantic, nerve shredding sprint that she makes entirely her own. It’s an exhausting, uncompromising listen that isn't exactly built for casual background music, but for pure, raw intensity, it’s one of her most powerful records.
The energy in this album is inconsistent. You go from one track building momentum, only to throw that all away in the next. It settles near the end of the record, but it's way too late at that point. Also, what's up with the "man-size" thing? Favourite Track(s): 50ft Queenie, Dry, Missed Least Favourite Track(s): Hook, Man-sized Sextet, Man-Size
Ужасный жанр рока под безголосые женские вопли
There’s no shortage of intensity here, but I find myself getting tired of it surprisingly quickly. Harvey’s vocals and the abrasive guitars keep hitting the same nerve until I struggle to distinguish one song from the next. The tracks change; my reaction doesn’t. I don’t need the rough edges smoothed out, but I do need something beyond them to hold my attention. On 𝘙𝘪𝘥 𝘰𝘧 𝘔𝘦, they’re too often all I hear. By the end, I remember the album’s abrasive sound more clearly than any individual song.
A bit of a din but not totally unlistenable
This is very good. Very very good. But not quite a 5. A 4,5!