Funeral by Arcade Fire

Funeral

Arcade Fire

3.54
Rating
30876
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
31%
4
31%
5
22%
Distribution

Album Summary

Funeral is the debut studio album by Canadian indie rock band Arcade Fire, released on September 14, 2004 by Merge Records. Preliminary recordings for Funeral were made during the course of a week in August 2003 at the Hotel2Tango in Montreal, Quebec, and the recording was completed later that year all in an analogue recording format. The album produced five singles, with "Rebellion (Lies)" being the most successful, having peaked at #19 on the UK Singles Chart. The album was nominated for a Grammy Award in 2005 for Best Alternative Music Album. It received widespread critical acclaim and topped many year-end and decade-end lists. According to the website Metacritic, the album had the second most appearances on end-of-decade Top 10 lists, only behind Radiohead's Kid A. In the 2020 updated version of Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Albums of All Time, it was ranked at number 500.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Just had The Suburbs from them a few weeks ago, and I think I liked that one more than this. Their instrumentation and overall composition isn't bad, but a break from their endless doldrums would be nice, as most of the qualities I bounce off of with them are the same that keep me at arm's length from Radiohead. I don't hate either of them, but I don't like them enough to reach for them on my own, either. This one gets the same 3/5 as The Suburbs, I just don't have to round down to get there.

We’ve had one previous Arcade Fire album, “The Suburbs.” It took a while but I ended up finding that one interesting if not enjoyable. Never listened to this one so I have no expectations. I just didn’t get this album. I can tell there is a somberness going on. Not a bleak somberness, but one of held breath, waiting to get to the other side of something. At least that is the vibe I caught. Only it seemed observed through a foggy window. A detached notice. The music was too baroque and shoegazey for me. It lingered too often and irritated my senses. Didn’t enjoy. 2/5

(3/5) I think it took Arcade Fire a while to find their stride and this debut, while good, is far from great. It has a 48 minute runtime that feels longer because there isn't much variance in the music. I don't *mind* that music, but maybe not 48 minutes of it. Like I said on "The Suburbs", that album and "Neon Bible" are their best IMHO. This could have been trimmed from the list.

2/5. Basic easy listening.

Sounds like Arcade Fire. Pleasant and forgettable.

Arcade Fire arrived with a fully-formed sound and delivered their most cohesive and emotional album in one fell swoop. “Funeral” is easily one of the most influential albums of the 2000s, with every band from Florence + the Machine to Black Country, New Road being indebted to its powerful songwriting. Its influence has not been all positive; the likes of Mumford & Sons and Of Monsters and Men may have never broke the mainstream if it was not for Arcade Fire. However, this does show the deep resonance of Arcade Fire’s climactic style, as even taking their basic formula without approaching the writing or performance skills or the virtuosity of the band could bring mainstream success. And ultimately, Arcade Fire execute their formula better than anyone else, giving us a number of the best indie anthems of the 2000s (“Neighborhood #1 (Power Out)”, “Neighborhood #3 (Tunnels”, “Rebellion (Lies)” and “Wake Up”), only punctuated by beautiful ballads like “Haiti” and “Une Annee Sans Lumiere”.

Idk not bad but it’s just kinda been background noise

Nulla da dire. Emozionante e dettagliato, trova il suo spazio specifico e si sa far distinguere

bello bello bellissimo. Un album tanto sensibile e vulnerabile quanto potente e gioioso, un vero e proprio inno alla vita costruito sulle ceneri di un trauma personale legato alla morte. Ancora devo capire certe cose ma sento che sarà un grower, e anche non lo fosse, rimarrò eternamente innamorato del primo brano.

I remember really enjoying this album when it came out. Its still a good album, just doesn't hit me in the same way.

sort of ruled actually 😔

Liked some of the more adventureous instrumentation and lyrics. But no sonf really stood out to me and the voice was too whiny at times.

god, i love indie music. after kate bush’s hounds of love, we’re two for two with 5/5 star albums. this was like sunshine personified. i usually name my favorites but here, for the first time ever, i adore every track, from a-z.

Takes me back to shit life, though, no thanks. But, it is good music.

Nice to revisit. Favorite tracks: Neighborhood #2, Une Année Sans Lumiere, Neighborhood #3, Wake Up

Their best work. Downhill from here.

Glorious

Nostalgic, quality listen. Enjoy the rhythm changes and sound varieties.

Ahmahzing

Indie's first true blockbuster, Funeral was a huge moment in the realm of quirky alternative music. In my estimation, there is an indie scene before Funeral, and there is one after it. 2004 is the year that indie rock went from sounding like Built to Spill and Modest Mouse to sounding like a chamber pop ensemble with guitars. This sound was seriously inescapable for the first 8 or so years after Funeral came out. But how does the progenitor of that elaborate next step in alternative music hold up 20 years later? Having now heard this album twice, I must admit that, for all it influenced, this album is a fairly uneven listen. Some songs are among the very best of the alternative canon ("Wake Up," "Rebellion") while others just kind of plink about for their duration and disappear as quickly as they came. This is definitely a case of a backloaded album, as momentum really picks up after you get past all the "Neighbourhood" tracks. Energy - and song quality - becomes a lot more consistent after #4 if you ask me. Being an indie rock album from a Montreal-based band, there's a lot of build-up then build back down song structuring on display, and lots of unconventional instrumentation like glockenspiel and accordion. This might seem rather plain by today's standards, but it was still a fairly new phenomenon in rock at the time of Funeral's release. As strange as it may sound, this approach to instrumentation was only rivalled by fellow Montrealers Godspeed You Black Emperor, who had broken up by 2004. It certainly gives the songs a little extra oomph to save them from being beige coffee-shop alt rock fodder, but, again, the song quality is fairly uneven throughout. I guess this is a highly influential album responsible for a lot of what we love (or hate) about indie music, but I think, based on this album and the previously assigned Neon Bible, Arcade Fire is fundamentally a singles band that operated in a sphere where the album reigned supreme. Key Tracks: Neighborhood #3 (Power Out,) Wake Up, Rebellion (Lies)

Ok, not great

Fantastic album, definitely one of their best and one of the best albums in the indie rock genre. 9.5/10

An astounding amazing debut. I am biased as a Canadian indie rock fan of a certain age, but early three album arcade fire will always have a special place in my heart. Lights out kills, crown of love, tunnels, rebellion, just banger after banger.

Enjoyment: 6/10 Replayability: 6/10 Cohesion: 8/10 Flow/Pacing: 6/10 Artistic Merit: 6/10 Overall: 6/10 Review: Liked Song(s): Crown of Love, Rebellion (Lies) Disliked Song(s): Recommend?: Probably Not Heard Before?: No

👑🪶💡🔦🪦

I get the feeling that this is an increasingly a ‘you had to be there’ sort of album (especially with the Win Butler allegations), but damn if this doesn’t still take my old ass right back to 2004. Almost makes me remember what it was like to feel actual optimism.

nem hallgattam vegig kellet sirjak, amugy eleg uncsi

260. Funeral - Arcade Fire (2004) 11.9.26 Variety: 5 Adequacy: 5 Listenability: 5 Uniqueness: 4 Emotionality: 4 = 4.6 rounded up to a 5 "Our bodies get bigger but our hearts get torn up/ We're just a million little gods causing rain storms" This is one I heard exactly once I think when it came out, and then maybe not even the whole thing? I know for sure the only track I recognize is the first one. It's a good one, and I do like several of their songs over those first few albums, but I'd be hard pressed to recall the titles or which album they came from. We just recently had Suburbs, which was a very mixed bag for me, with some great tracks, a ton of deadweight, and even a few stinkers. I gave it a 2.8 and rounded up to three for the obvious artistry on display. It just felt pretty depressing for the most part and super repetitive, and only the best of the best had anything to make them memorable for me. And I'm a person who enjoys himself some very morose music. Radiohead, Elliott Smith, Nick Cave, and Neil Young are among my favorite artists. But their sad stuff doesn't make me feel more depressed. The worst stuff on The Suburbs just felt miserable and hopeless in a not good way. So while I'm going into this with low expectations, maybe I'll be surprised and this will be more of the stuff I liked from that other album. It's a weird order too, with three albums total on the list we started with the last chronologically, jumped back to the first, and will be ending in the middle. So it goes. THE TRACKS "Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)" - Yep, this is the one I remember. It's driving and melodic and has an underlying kind of anthemic patina of "big important feelings" that bands like U2 and (briefly) Live and few others are capable of. It's as emotionally affecting as it is catchy and easy to bounce up and down to in an arena setting. Which I want to say was something that made these guys unique at the time. An indie band who could pack an arena with appropriately thrilling and giant pieces like this. Who else was doing that at the time? The Flaming Lips had a taste of it with "Do You Realize" but that ultimately proved to be a blip for them I think and they quickly wore out their welcome. Not a fan of the parentheticals, but this is great. Hopefully there are at least a few more like it on here and the high can be sustained. "Neighborhood #2 (Laïka)" - Not as catchy, but still just as driving and big and memorable enough, this one has some gimmicked vocals that add some flavor and a bit of a wall of sound vibe to things. The lyrics make literal sense, but they are of the sort that's so very specific and lacking in context clues that you have to imagine it was not written for the audience per se, but to satisfy some personal need or work out some feeling out. You get a somewhat abstracted portrait of a brother who wills himself to be an outsider it seems as falls into a cycle of failure and lashing out. Maybe? The trappings were nice enough that it didn't quite matter. I expect there to be some sort of dynamic shift coming up or this swing for the fences style is going to start getting repetitive. "Une année sans lumière" - And mission accomplished. This one is a much lighter, gentle and a bit wistfully pleasant. It's half in French and with the heavy reverb on the vocals it's pretty hard to make out any lyrics anyway. It's got a relaxed and bass heavy rhythm to it that feels bright and poppy, which especially makes it stand out from the stuff on The Suburbs. Near the end it revs up into overdrive, but stays in a nice mid ground that doesn't feel abrasive or jarring at all, and gives the feeling of a sudden sprint towards... something. "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)" - This one starts in the "epic" mode but we get instant dynamics with the Modest Mouse-esque vocal delivery and the added xylophone accents. I still can't understand a lick of what's being sung apart from the occasional line and that's ok as it's got oddly charming syncopated drums that add a manic feel. The chugging, stuttering guitar work reinforces this desperate vibe, and by the end the vocals catch up to this desperation with some raggedness and when the violin comes in we even get some sad notes. I find myself very surprised by my reaction to this stuff so far and was expecting more of the bloat that we saw with The Suburbs. "Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles)" - Some swirling ambient, orchestra warming up sounds open this one, and then an pretty acoustic guitar joins in. The vocals are a bit more discernable here, but the reverb remains and the atmosphere is still very strong. They go small on this one though and it's a good bit of variation. All the intense important feeling is mainly down to those strings and the airy, almost spacey vibe that they give to what might otherwise be a cute little folky number. This one was lovely and warm and felt hopeful, which was nice, even if the lyrics still had some darkness. "Crown of Love" - This one reminded me a bit of Elliott Smith with it's very open emotionality and the it's sweeping and sadly pretty pure pop chorus. It's a simple love song about yearning and forgiveness and it does a great job of plugging into the form without feeling too cliched. It goes melodramatic at the end, but by then the song has earned it, and it rises to almost E.L.O.-ish heights by the final third. When the tempo increases and we start getting a disco beat by the end I was all in. "Wake Up" - Another one that I recognize! That opening chorus hit and I was like "hell yeah!". I can imagine this one being the big closing number at their concerts ( edit: apparently it was) with it's huge "OH OOOOH OOOOH OOOH" sing along moments and the equally big and plodding beat. The lyrics seem to prefigure the whole bittersweet nostalgic mourning of childhood that the Suburbs reaches for but never really pulls off. The harp was a nice touch, and I love how it morphs into a Motown beat towards the end. My only criticism at all is the placement. Big unforced error to not close the album with this one. Can they carry it on hoe though? "Haiti" - This was nice and light and a needed changeup with Chassagne providing lead vocals on a bouncy and very atmospheric pseudo-dance track. Her similarly ( I think) placed track off of Funeral was a highlight of that album, and the synth pop elements here go down smooth. Upbeat and supremely catchy with a deep sadness in the content. Just how I like it. "Rebellion (Lies)" Well hell, there's another one I remember. This one even had a somewhat memorable music video with the band marching through some suburban neighborhood and playing a maybe less nefarious Pied Piper role with the neighborhood kids all joiuning in their little parade. The song is exciting and full of melodic hooks, and feels like the track that must have minted them as it's got everything they're good at in one go. It's driving, big, catchy, highly emotional, and rousing and gives a feeling similar to "Kids" by MGMT. "In the Backseat" - The closing number is another Chassagne lead, and it's quiet and delicate and feels like a mournful bit of meditation. When the electric guitar finally comes in the emotion shoots through the roof. It's a beautiful palette cleanser and a more than solid closer. There's a bit of Bjork DNA in Chassagne's delivery, but the music is all stirring and grand. As much as I like it though, I still think "Wake Up" should have been the closer. HIGHLIGHTS - "Neighborhood #1 (Tunnels)" - "Neighborhood #2 (Laïka)" - "Une année sans lumière" - "Neighborhood #3 (Power Out)" - "Neighborhood #4 (7 Kettles)" - "Crown of Love" - "Wake Up" - "Haiti" - "Rebellion (Lies)" - "In the Backseat" MIDLIGHTS - LOWLIGHTS - FINAL THOUGHTS I'm on a streak, baby! Three albums in a row of JUST highlights. This comes after Patti Smith's Horse and Neil Young's Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere ( both probably beloved by these guys) and I've got my fingers crossed it'll keep going. This album felt bright and catchy and much more cohesive and tight that Funeral, and I'm glad the band had something in their back pocket to keep me from writing them off completely before we hit that last one. All my confusion as to how the band got to the cultural and critical space they occupied by the time of Funeral is all answered on this. It's very easy to see why they would have felt like some sort of clarion call to all the little Pitchfork goblins who were likely nearing exhaustion at having to listen to the umpteenth garage revival album. Taken together, it's still a bit of a mixed bag, but I've now seen more good than bad, and am a bit more likely to investigate the rest of their catalogue. I have the distinct feeling that by The Suburbs maybe they were getting high off their own supply and starting to believe all the things critics were saying about them. Hopefully they had a come to Jesus moment like U2 before then and took a step back after that. We'll see if Neon Bible falls more into this camp than that one though. Possible turn-Offs might include: - plenty of bittersweet feels if you prefer your rock music to be happier - a lot of quiet moments in between the louder stuff - more than a shade of self-importance in the delivery You Might enjoy this if you: - sad indie music you can jump up and down to while singing along with the chorus in a stadium full of a few thousand other like-minded dorks - sweeping and epic feeling music that is not afraid to go big on the emotions - driving catchy numbers that also have a tiny bit of depth to them PLAYLIST ALTERATIONS - Surprisingly, no. FURTHER LISTENING Precursors: - Out of the Blue by E.L.O. - The River by Bruce Springsteen - Heroes by David Bowie - On the Beach by Neil Young - Little Creatures by Talking Heads - Power, Corruption & Lies by New Order - The Lonesome Crowded West by Modest Mouse - Clouds Taste Metallic by the Flaming Lips Contemporaries: - Oracular Spectacular by MGMT - Sound of Silver by LCD Soundsystem - Return to Cookie Mountain by TV On The Radio - The Hazards of Love by the Decemberists - Twin Cinema by the New Pornographers - The Fragile Army by The Polyphonic Spree Descendants: - High Violet by The National - Hospice by The Antlers - A Deeper Understanding by The War on Drugs - No Shape by Perfume Genius - Being Funny in a Foreign Language by The 1975 - Strange Desire by Bleachers

Previously unknown. Meh.

Also kinda sad and melancholic. Not what I usually listen to.

Good album, interesting sound. Vocals is strange for me, but not bad.

I liked this more than The Suburbs and can’t quite give it a 5. I enjoyed it throughout but I also don’t find myself wanting to come back to it much. Some albums you hear and then want to hear again quickly and this one doesn’t grab me but I like all of it and can’t really find much fault.

Неплохой, приготовил под него хороший ужин, слушается легко, но не очень запоминается

It was fine

Not gonna lie, this would sound like trash in an arcade

very average

Some good songs but similar sounds

Their albums eventually fell off, and I don’t like Winn Butler, but this album is great.

gosto muito deles, mas esse álbum não tinha ouvido. gostei um tiquinho menos agora talvez?

melhor do que o meu preconceito indicava, mas ainda assim não é lá essas coisas.

An easy 5 for me because of the era I am. For whatever they can rightfully be derided as, this era of Arcade Fire was filled with joy and melancholy, and I love that. The swelling choruses of Power’s Out and Wake Up, the weight of Crown of Love. I’ve been spinning this for 20 years and won’t stop now.

Это хорошая авторская работа, заявка соответствует ожиданию, я действительно поприсутствовала на похоронах, но не близких к реальности, а тех метафоричных, которые мы рисуем у себя в голове

Yet another meh. Not bad, but not great.

Господи, такое говно этот аркейд файр, вот ни сколько не сомневался что я услышу всё то же шаблонное миллениальское говнище с этим annoying ass голосом. В тот раз я был добрее и поставил 2, в этот раз оценка будет ниже.

Have never heard about them so it is like at first hearing. I like good indie albums and this is a very good one.

Great album, a powerhouse of a genre and at a time but difficult to listen to it now.

Great album. Great band

I was not going to listen to Arcade Fire, but my daughters and their classmates did, and they loved them. A smart high school teacher at least takes a listen and when I did, and I found out why told me why. This is a solid album that paved the way for the excellent indie rock of the 2000s and 2010s. It is a must-listen for music fans.

Great album. Just a shame that Edwin Farnham Butler III has been credibly accused by multiple women of sexual misconduct and assault. Also his name is Edwin Farnham Butler III.

not much of my style didnt liked much

Think I might add this to my library.

Good, but not my favourite Arcade Fire album. Love the sound but there doesn’t seem to be anything exceptional to me here. 3/5

Great album, always expertly produced and put together, sweeping songs and harmonies, some of the most interesting music to come out of the early 2000s indie scene.

definitely sounds like an album rym/pitchfork would cum buckets over, and i tend to be quite partial to that stuff lol favourite songs: une annee sans lumiere, neighborhood #3, in the backseat least favourite song: none

Ahora si

Arcade Fire present an important question: how annoying can a piece of music truly be? Between the awful, compressed production that aims to grate and Win Butler's horrible excuse for a vocal performance, Funeral becomes an endurance test. Will I manage 47 minutes of listening to this without bashing my head against the wall? The odds are growing against me with every passing second. There are a couple of positives, though. Win Butler doesn't sing on some tracks (the closer is actually a pretty great song), the lyrics are mostly compelling and it's shorter than Suburbs. Only Neon Bible left and I can ignore this band for the rest of my life, God help me.

Nothing special but fine

Solid album with some bangers

Lit! Think I am more of a Suburbs guy, but that is probably cos I listened to it when i was 16. Would maybe like this more if I listened to this in my developmental years, who knows?

nie pamiętam go ale polubilam kilka

This just isn’t really my kind of sound. I’ve never been a big fan of that early-2000s indie/alternative style, and this album leans hard into everything about that era that usually loses me. I can hear that there’s a lot going on musically, and I get why people connected with it. The arrangements are big, dramatic, and clearly put together with a lot of care. But for me, the whole thing just felt too self-serious and overly earnest. Nothing here was awful, but very little made me want to hear it again. I know this is considered one of the defining indie albums of the 2000s, but it mostly reminded me why that particular sound has never done much for me.

Beautiful

Good album, started of not so good got better as it went on Lead singer reminds me a bit of Jeff Buckley Bass after wake up is on fire 3 stars is harsh could be 4

Det var meget nice tøs a'

* 34 Hold da op en enerverende vokal. Meget opslidende. Heldigvis for Arcade Fire drikker jeg en fremragende vasket etiopier lige pt. Den gør det hele lidt nemmere. Lille 2'er.

Jeg bliver aldrig Arcade Fire-fan. Der er noget med hans måde at synge på, der næsten bliver lidt ulideligt :) Resten er jo egentlig fint nok, men ikke mega interessant imho 2.6

kan egentlig meget godt lide Arcade Fire - og om ikke andet må man rose dem for at have været meget modige da de valgte forsanger, for det er godt nok en... unik sangstil. Synes også der et par gode numre i mellem her, men er nok mere fan af deres senere udgivelser. Lå nok egentlig på en 3'er, men jeg har alligevel tilføjet 4 af numrene til min egen playliste, så selvom resten af numrene måske er lidt mere intetsigende, må det alligevel være nok til lige akkurat at klemme sig op på en 4'er

Living dead

A stunning debut that redefined alternative pop and hip influenced more bands than just about anyone since the Velvet Underground. Iconic.

Was kinda hyped, but nothing to write home about, the sound never was that interesting to me but by the end it was just really boring.

Used to listen to it a lot. Then stopped. Some of the tracks still are effective, but maybe I'm less into earnestness now.

Solid album. I really enjoyed it. I’m a fan of the band and the three albums on this list are really good. Probably their best three albums, a nice run.

Not coming back

The album itself is four, maybe five stars. When it dropped it was massive. There was a sincerity to it that was instantly captivating and not captured again in anything they released after. I love this record. For the purpose of this list, one star is what it gets, because multiple sexual abuse allegations can not be condoned. It is sad how many times I have had to write something similar on prior reviews and I only just broke album 600 recently.

Album would be great without the caterwauling, whining, wailing vocals. the woman that sang on the last track should have sang the whole album

nostalgic for a time when I first really started listening to music, searching it out on weird torrents to put on my iPod.

I liked this one more than my last Arcade Fire album. The indie rock sound is nice, I just never feel all that pulled into the album all the way. Still a fun listen.

I loved rebellion and the soaring instrumentals on wake up but rest was a flop

Just a whole lot of whining hooting hollering whimpering and whinging.

3.909565217391304

average alternative music

2000s indie, fine for what it is but I find it dull. Canadian Coldplay.

I have to say five stars. This is so amazing, when it was released it felt like nothing I'd ever heard before. In my travelling years, I saw a lot of these guys live and it was always euphoric. Wake up is an all time anthem. What a record

Of course it's a perfect album! It's a shame Will Butler is a douchebag. It used to be my favorite album. It's been a long time, but I still love it, it's too perfect to be hated. Yes, it's a popified version of post-rock, but you gotta be a monster to not get into it. It's perfectly crafted, joyful music pieces.

Pretty bland. Decent instruments on a couple tracks but nothing stood out enough to me. Also the singing was annoying. A generous 3/10

Big meh. Only one song I liked. 2 star

I thought it sounded nice but wouldn't say any of it has stuck with me

Really annoying voice one of which is linked to an incredibly shitty person. The instrumentals were a little fun at least.

Tuesday, 21 October, 2026 Great album. A few dud tracks, but the hits are amazing.

I forgot how much I love this album. Its from a specific time of my life. But the Neighborhood #3 Power Out still kills it no matter the time of life.

I like their instrumentals and sound a lot but I feel like their songs would be better without vocals. Like their lyrics and singing don’t add anything to what would be really good music.

Made me sad and nostalgic but in a good way. I always thought the arctic monkeys and arcade fire were the same but I’m glad I know better now

more whiny boys who can't sing being propped up by better instrumentals and melodies than they deserve

Didn't grip me how it used to.