After The Gold Rush by Neil Young

After The Gold Rush

Neil Young

3.6
Rating
28765
Votes
1
3%
2
11%
3
30%
4
32%
5
23%
Distribution

Album Summary

After the Gold Rush is the third studio album by the Canadian-American musician Neil Young, released in September 1970 on Reprise Records, catalogue number RS 6383. It is one of four high-profile solo albums released by the members of folk rock group Crosby, Stills, Nash & Young in the wake of their chart-topping 1970 album Déjà Vu. Young's album consists mainly of country folk music along with several rock tracks, including "Southern Man". The material was inspired by the unproduced Dean Stockwell-Herb Bermann screenplay After the Gold Rush. After the Gold Rush peaked at number eight on the Billboard Top Pop Albums chart; the two singles taken from the album, "Only Love Can Break Your Heart" and "When You Dance I Can Really Love", made it to number 33 and number 93 respectively on the Billboard Hot 100. Critics were not immediately impressed; the 1970 review in Rolling Stone magazine by Langdon Winner was negative, with Winner feeling that, "none of the songs here rise above the uniformly dull surface." Village Voice critic Robert Christgau was more enthusiastic, saying: "While David Crosby yowls about assassinations, Young divulges darker agonies without even bothering to make them explicit. Here the gaunt pain of Everybody Knows This Is Nowhere fills out a little—the voice softer, the jangling guitar muted behind a piano. Young's melodies—every one of them—are impossible to dismiss. He can write 'poetic' lyrics without falling flat on his metaphor even when the subject is ecology or crumbling empire. And despite his acoustic tenor, he rocks plenty. A real rarity: pleasant and hard at the same time." Critical reaction has improved with time; by 1975, Rolling Stone was referring to the album as a "masterpiece", and Gold Rush is now considered a classic album in Young's recording career. In 2014, the album was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

I've lost count of how many albums we've had so far involving Neil Young, but I know (a) it's a lot (too many, I'd even claim), and (b) I'm glad this one was included. I've never really been able to enjoy Neil Young's voice/singing style, but listening to this one I really wish I could enjoy his quavering whine to make the experience even better. Regardless, there's plenty of great songs it doesn't really matter, with only a few relative duds ("Till the morning comes" is probably the only lackluster attempt, although his cover of "Oh, lonesome me" isn't nearly as good as his originals). It was also fun to read the extensive Wikipedia entry that describes how the entire album was going to be at one point the soundtrack to Dean Stockwell's sci-fi/dystopian screenplay of an "After the Gold Rush" movie that never got made; eventually only the title track and "Cripple Creek ferry" had any connection to the screenplay (which helps explain some of the weirder references in both of those tracks, although I have to admit that until today I'd always assumed the latter song was "Cripple Creek fairy").

New to me album though "After the Gold Rush" is a favorite song due to its incredible blend of allusion and illusion: the brilliance of lines like "I was thinking about what a friend had said and hoping it was a lie" and "I saw the knights in armor coming, saying something about a queen." So as I started listening to the album, I began wondering if I could justify giving it 5 stars on the strength of that one song. Thankfully, "Southern Man" and "Don't Let It Bring You Down" came up and it was an easy call.

Well this assignment really fucked my day today. Now I have to cancel everything and go on a massive Neil Young bender until night falls and the moon arcs and eventually day breaks and my fever breaks along with it and I collapse, exhausted. Don't want to, but I have to. Fuck! What a goddamn pain in the ass this shit is! Huge step forward from Everybody Knows This is Nowhere. Massive, like on a different level as a songwriter and confidence as a player and band leader and producer. This album launches a trio of incredible, legendary, miraculous studio albums with Harvest and Tonight's The Night. Damn. After you listen to them you'll better appreciate why my PhD advisor wept when she read my dissertation on the artistic leap forward he took in this period. This album is super helpful for Neil-o-phytes, too, for if you don't love this album you probably needn't invest any more time in his many, many albums. Either way, Don't let it bring you down It's only castles burning Find someone who's turning And you will come around

This marks my second Neil Young entry in the log following On the Beach, and I'd say this is miles better than that record. The lyricism really delivers here, with themes that feel far clearer, more focused, and structurally cohesive overall. The album features several genuine standout tracks that pull you in right away—"Only Love Can Break Your Heart" and "Birds" are absolute highlights, alongside the sharp arrangement and intensity of "Southern Man." I will admit that On the Beach has a much raw-er, more unpolished edge to it, but the songwriting and melodic clarity on this record feel significantly more elevated. On the weak points, the primary bottleneck holding this back comes down to the vocal execution. While the song construction and instrumental setups are great, the vocals themselves are lacking—they simply don't capture or push the full emotional and architectural potential of these tracks. The delivery feels slightly under-realized on certain passages where the songwriting demands more range, control, or dynamic presence to match the weight of the arrangements. Overall, After the Gold Rush is a major step forward in terms of songwriting focus, melodic identity, and thematic clarity compared to On the Beach. The standout tracks prove how strong Neil Young's compositional instincts are when the melodies hit, but the vocal limitations keep it just short of absolute perfection. Because the vocal performances hold back what could have been an elite set of songs, this album lands at a strong 4 out of 5 stars. Favorite Tracks: "Only Love Can Break Your Heart", "Birds", "Southern Man"

I'm a Neil Young fan. Rust Never Sleeps is one of the best albums of all time, and has two top 10 all time songs to my tastes in Powderfinger and Pocahontas. I grew up on Harvest and There Comes A Time. I even loved Americana. But, for all that I'm a fan, his discography is huge and there is A LOT of it I haven't touched, including this. Hailed by many as his best, and I've never listened. And... I can see why fans and critics rate it so highly. The title track is an absolute killer. From the steel that destroyed our forests, to modern day depression, to dystopian hope. We move forward, but to what? Southern Man feels like a prelude to his later work with Crazy Horse, and it's a great track and, again, powerful stuff. And don't get me started on Birds. It's in my rotation now. No doubt. Great stuff.

Currently giving this one a second listen. Neil Young is one of the hidden gems I've come to appreciate from this generator, but the info here inclined heavily towards folk country which sounds like a bullet to the temple. Fortunately, it was a pleasant experience. Neil sounds like maybe one of Elmo's cousins, which isn't exactly a selling point, but doesn't cost the experience much either. Maybe I've just been properly exposed to his sound. I'd say half of the album is ok, easy to leave on as it's playing, and the other half is tracks I'm genuinely happy are playing as they're getting on. Songs with a sick groove, sweet melodies, curious lyrics if you happen to pay attention. I'd buy this record for the right price, but what's really happening now is I'd probably buy myself a Neil Young record blind as long as it doesn't make a hole in my wallet. He's got a great track record, even when I'm not that into it. As far as this one goes, I might listen on a rare occasion, this isn't my typical vibe, but I respect it a lot, I can appreciate it during and after its play. 3.5/5

Oh, After the Gold Rush. You have one, maybe two incredible songs; everything else is unimpressive at best. Yet you remain one of the most celebrated folk outings of the last however many years. Why? Why is this the case? I don’t think I will ever understand. “Tell Me Why” is beautiful. It is the album’s best song hands-down. It is the only unmistakably incredible song on the album, at least to me. From there, “Southern Man” and “When You Dance I Can Really Love” both also stand out as awesome, but the former feels as if it’s on autopilot, and the latter isn’t much more than a really fun, sweet little joint. I also really enjoy “Cripple Creek Ferry,” but it’s short! So short! It’s less than 2 minutes long! It’s very pretty though. Other songs on here, the title track is cute, yet Young’s vocals can grate, and it’s much too simplistic. “Birds” has a similar problem, it’s very forgettable. The entire album can tend to be actually. “Only Love Can Break Your Heart” is very pretty, though I don’t love love love the hook. I don’t know. The album is pretty and it’s cute. That’s kind of it… This album is a pretty necessary listen. That much is obvious. It is not very great though. That is what I will say. 6.8/10 DOES IT BELONG ON THE LIST: YES REASON: place in history

4th (of 7) Neil Young albums I've gotten and I can honestly say this might be my favorite one so far. Thats not saying much by my standards as I still don't get the hype around Neil Young as an artist but this album wasn't as boring as some of his previous ones I've gotten. "Southern Man" is still a bop after all these years and I also found my self digging the intro track "Tell Me Why" which I think set up my enjoyment of the rest of the album. The short runtime doesn't hurt it either. This album had a low bar to clear when it comes to me liking a Neil Young record. Did it clear it? Yes, but not to the point where I'd call myself a fan. Maybe album 5 will do it. 3/5

After The Gold Rush is my favorite non-Crazy Horse Neil Young solo album. Some of the song titles sound kinda familiar but i don't think i have heard any of the actual songs before. And those songs are quite good. They sounded really nice and had some good musicianship all around. They also went by pretty quickly as well never at any point dragging. Neil's voice and songwriting are quite good too even if the vocals do have a few moments where i'm just not a huge fan of them. I feel like if Neil didn't get way to into his singing during those points, this album could have been a 4. But as it stands, it's getting a strong 3 Best Song: I Believe in You Worst Song: Cripple Creek Ferry Side note: Last of the Neil Young albums, which means: 1. After The Gold Rush 2. On The Beach 3. Harvest 4. Tonight's The Night

Wow. Lots of songs that I didn’t know he wrote have been covered by other artists. And the whole thing about “Southern Man” creating “Sweet Home Alabama” … what an impact.

Solid NY album. The opening track is fantastic. High 3s.

Day 100 Contrary to what Lynyrd Skynyrd said, a Southern man DOES need him around anyhow Fav track: Southern Man

Actually hurts to listen to this

Some of Neil's best on this one. Post drippy hippy, mostly!

#21 This is the exact album that might come to mind when thinking of a folk rock album. Why is the second half worse than the first half??

Neil Young always gives me that early 70s vibe. I found this album a great listen to just sit back and relax. The songs had a low key melody to them. I recognized some familiar ones like Southern Man and Don't Let It Bring You Down.

First time I heard the title track I thought it was shit but its really grown on me along with the rest of this record. Easily one of Neil's best. Favorite track: Southern Man

sublime!

An absolutely GOATed first four track run. Rest of the album's good too.

Surprised by how much I liked this. Generally, Neil chaps my hide. But I can’t deny. This is good. 4 Boolean: True

they don’t let poets sing real bad like kermit the frog anymore and it’s our loss

As always, I don't know what it is about Neil Young but his music just grabs my attention. I'd give him a 7/10, but I don't like his voice. Rating: 6/10

unfassbares album sehr guter flow bei diesem album bin paff

All a bit too much of one level and that level is subdued. Not a bad lidten just nothing to get excited about.

I had been putting off listening to this all day as I knew I’d not enjoy it much; as it turns out, this wasn’t the worst Neil Young effort I’ve heard so far. I still don’t like his voice, and he sounded out of tune on the title track, but, in general, I had this down as being worse in my head. But I do hope that’s the end of the Neil Young albums now, because enough’s enough.

No thank you very much. I still hate his voice. But the actual music is sometimes fine (she says grudgingly). 2/5

highs and lows but my fav mood so far

I'm not usually one for folk but Neil Young might be an exception to that, I like this one quite a bit though I don't think it's my favourite of his. Still a light 9/10. first listen tracklist ranking: 1. Southern Man 2. Only Love Can Break Your Heart 3. Tell Me Why 4. When You Can Dance I Can Really Love 5. Birds 6. I Believe In You 7. Don’t Let It Bring You Down 8. After the Gold Rush 9. Cripple Creek Ferry 10. Oh, Lonesome Me 11. Till the Morning Comes

Un género en sí

A very good album through and through, loved every track, even the short filler ones were really solid. This one is either a four or five star, I just love this style of music. Neil Young has a special way to make a sound sound amazing

Was alright

really good songs

Not bad, not terrible either, a bit weaker than the album I found and have been listening to here before, so a solid 3 from me 🙃

Back to back Neil Young just strengthened my distaste for the music. It’s like the random generator sensed my disdain and tried to challenge it. LOL no but seriously, I don’t care for his music!

OK, but a bit dreary in places.

Not my favorite Young album. Several songs on it I don't need to hear anymore in my life. His vocals are front and center in this one and as we all know they aren't particularly good. Strong songwriting and lyrics as always.

easy morning listening. not bad! not a huge fan of his voice

It wasn’t a bad album by any means, instruments were gorgeous just wasn’t really a fan of the vocals or the genre.

1. 5 2. 5 3. 5 4. 5 5. 4.5 1. 4.5 2. 5 3. 4.5 4. 5 5. 4.5 6. 5

The best Neil Young album and one of the best albums of the 1970s

Classic album. Some great song writing here.

Usually I don't mind Neil Young, but this album was rough for me. The title track especially made me cringe, for some reason it seemed to highlight how nasally and shrill Young's voice is solo. And the rest of the album just seems to be written with a level of angst that I just can't seem to enjoy. He's a great songwriter, and I do think the album is well produced, but I just can't get into it. I might try again when I'm actively feeling low, see if it manages to connect then.

Overall: 10/10 Yet another Neil Young album with no skips. I don't believe the man was this perfect musician who never made a bad album or anything like that, but this is one of those ones where I find it pretty undeniable that it deserves a spot here. Maybe not as mindblowing as Harvest, but it's pretty close. Fav Song: Southern Man

Some stand-out tracks and I recognise his contribution (see my other reviews, blah blah, sorry but I'm over 750 albums in); I just find it a bit dreary in places.

I prefer this to Harvest but it suffers the same fault for me. Too much Neil Young all at once. The standout songs really stand out, and are up there with some of my favourite songs, but I feel no drive to relisten to the whole album.

Neil Young sounds like Herbert from Family Guy

Perfectly fine. Nothing wrong with it. Pleasant to listen to. But nothing standout

After the gold rush. Canada

Not my kind of music

Really liked this, great for blank

468/1102 not a lot to say about this one, it was alright, had a couple highlights but otherwise didn’t move me a lot faves: Southern Man, Birds, When You Dance You Can Really Love 47/100

First album doing the 1001 albums that I had to skip some of the tracks. Really not keen. Is Neil Young like Marmite? I know some people absolutely love his work but it's not for me. Oh Lonesome me and When you Dance I can really love were tracks I did listen to all the way through. Good riff on When You Dance. Cripple Creek Ferry is nice and catchy finish, if somewhat a little short.

I've actually heard more of these songs than I thought I had. He plays a lot in the shop that I work at, so I had mixed feelings about listening to him because he's kind of overplayed to me (that's not to say I don't love "Old Man"). I really loved this album and not even especially for the songs I'd already heard. I REALLY liked "Oh, Lonesome Me" and "Don't Let It Bring You Down."

This is one of the Neil Young albums I'm most familiar with and one I still reach for often. I love the fractured, vulnerable, reflective mood in the record's quieter moments, and the shaggy, ragged southern rock of tracks like Southern Man and When You Dance. His voice always seems to divide opinion but I love it - sometimes frail, sometimes powerful, always unique. This is a captivating album that really stands out in his back catalogue.

Young is clearly a great songwriter, but as a musician I just can’t get into him.

The reason I got into folk music

a bit bit sad, but not the listen on repeat to drown my feelings sad its more of the listen to quiet my soul and feel nostalgic

The only other Neil Young I've heard has been Rust Never Sleeps and I... didn't care for it. I've heard much better things about this album, so I really hope I enjoy this one much more. 01. Tell Me Why Actually a really nice introduction! A really smooth, and catchy track! 02. After The Gold Rush I don't think I'm a fan of his voice. That being said, I think this is pretty good. Not the best thing ever, but good enough for a heart. 03. Only Love Can Break Your Heart Neil has a real knack for chorus', I'll tell ya w'hat. The verses are serviceable, but that chorus is fantastic. 04. Southern Man By far the best Neil Young song I've heard thus far. Best verses, best chorus, and phenomenal instrumentation. 05. Till The Morning Comes Really short, but fun. Nothing too noteworthy. 06. Oh, Lonesome Me Neil, I don't know how to tell you this, but you're a cuck. Anyways, it's a pretty normal song, both sonically and lyrically. 07. Don't Let It Bring You Down A really great one. Beautiful lyrics, with gorgeous instrumentation backing it. A shame how short it is. 08. Birds Actually gorgeous. Reminds me of a church hymn, but better! Is really beautiful, and I think his best vocal performance yet! 09. When You Dance I Can Really Love The lyrics were really boring, but the instrumentation is pretty good! Not a lot to say about this one. 10. I Believe In You Too basic this far deep in the album. Not bad, but forgettable in the grand scheme of things. 11. Cripple Creek Ferry Cute closer. Not much to say. I much, MUCH prefer this over Rust Never Sleeps. I had a bad first impression. I apologize, Neil. I was not familiar with your game. That being said... this still isn't perfect. Is closes with the three weakest tracks to me, and has some super forgettable ones. Still really, really enjoyed it.

I really enjoyed this!

I really like Neil Young and this album is... Fine...I guess. I mean it's pretty good but I'm not sure why they chose this one to go in the book?

Bon album, même si les voix me paraissent particulières defois. Il reste très touchant

Neil Young is a good lyric writer, but there's just nothing catchy about the music. His voice is too whiny and the songs are mostly just drab. It's not necessarily a bad album, it just doesn't strike me for intentional listening. "Only Love Can Break Your Heart" and "Don't Let it Bring You Down" were probably my favorite tracks.

laissez moi tranquille avec neil young

Just not a big fan of his voice.

I like Only Love Can Break Your Heart but otherwise it’s just fine for me

Not really my cuppa tea. A bit boring to be honest

Neil good…you…meh

Day1019 - only love can break your heart is such a great song on a great album

really enjoyed the vibe! the whole album sounded like slow dancing after a long day, slightly sad but still comforting. my first 5 star review 🌟

I came into this album expecting 'Harvest Moon', but was met with something much more clear cut. Unfortunately, the album has a stripped back style which I don't find very suitable for Young's vocals. They overpower everything, including the incredible lyrics, but it was nice to occasionally get a cool guitar solo in the mix, like on 'Southern Man.' I think I prefer Young's vocals on tracks that are more soft and hazy, as this just felt a little abrasive.

First half is so good, 2nd half is just ok

It wasn’t for me, and I found the vocals quite jarring if I’m honest

This is nice!

One of Neil Young’s best albums, so good. Big Neil young fan over here though

Neil Young is one of the most prolific songwriters of the 20th and 21st centuries and this album showcases all of the best things about his music: thoughtful, pared down, and moving.

Neil Young never gets old…

Pretty okay - nothing to write home about. Some of the songs were decent

3.5* Not bad at all, but strangely felt like a step down from EKTIN - just a bit sleepier than I wanted ballad-wise!

From the first warbling notes, I knew I'd dislike this. Neil Young is so popular, and I'm not sure why.

Not bad.

Very cool, just a lack of anything really captivating. Fun listen but not one that I'll reallyremember 3

Not a bad as the other Neil Young albums I've been served up. This one I could listen to. Still doesn't get a high mark though.

Thai was sweet. I’m not sure I’ll listen to it again. I never really understood the Neil young hype but this was an easy listen and I’m glad I listened.

really good, liked the instruments, and neil young's voice is pretty unique enjoyed plenty of songs 8-9

Que rico !

One of the plethora of solo studio albums released in the wake of the debut C,S,N & Y 'Deja Vu' album. Of the four this has been by far the most enduring and acclaimed work and was evidence that Young was the most productive talent from that group and had solo ambitions beyond the other three that has been evidenced in the ensuing fifty years. The title track, Don't let it bring you down and southern man are famous tracks, the latter getting a response from Lynryd Skynyrd on 'Sweet home Alabama'. I feel the album is a step on from CSNY but not as strong as Harvest. The road to greatness was well underway for the perpetrator.

Boring ahh. It's like listening to the same songs; I don't like the way his voice sounds. It reminds me of that image of SpongeBob singing for some reason. Would not listen to it again. 1/5

This list is determined to make me like Neil Young. This was more listenable than the other albums of his I’ve had, so maybe he’s growing on me. Mission accomplished

If you can get past Neil Young’s thin, reedy, occasionally falsetto-y wail, and start to focus on the strengths of this album, you’re actually in for an enjoyable ride. Musically, it’s kind of whatever; standard fare 70’s soft rock (ish) builds around guitar and piano, but the the talent of Young’s lyricism is the real reason for the price of admission. Reflecting on personal themes like love and heartbreak in songs like Only Love Can Break Your Heart and Oh, Lonesome Me, as well as social commentary on racism and climate-induced societal collapse in Southern Man and After the Gold Rush, we get a broad swath of topics to chew on. No pseudo intellectualism here, everything is kind of just put in front of you to digest on your own. I’m gonna lump this into the same category as Bowie or Dylan, where you’re there for the songwriting (much) more than you are for the singing. 7/10 Favorites: - After the Gold Rush - Only Love Can Break Your Heart - Oh, Lonesome Me - Birds

Took me much longer than anticipated to finally give this album a proper listen and it deserved every second. The wholesome nature of folk music warms my heart whenever an album of that nature is up for a listen, this album is no different. There are times when we start to get storytelling but it never quite finishes the story, Southern Man for example, however the songwriting is the strength of this album and one that I will find myself coming back to listen. Favorites: - After The Gold Rush - Only Love Can Break Your Heart - Southern Man - Oh, Lonesome Me Rating: 8/10

Just feelin a 3 idk

Easy listening pop. Not bad.

If you remove "Only Love Can Break Your Heart," "Southern Man," "Don't Let It Bring You Down," and "I Believe In You," After The Gold Rush is just okay.

A bunch of these songs are bangers if you listen to their cover versions.

Not bad but gives me nothing.