Reviews (page 9 of 9)
Out of 1000 the first 25 had two for Neil young and two were belle and Sebastian. This algorithm sucks. Another great one. B&S are fantastic.
Not really anything positive I can add for this album unfortunately. I found it supremely mediocre and extremely boring. None of the tracks sounded like they differentiated from each other and each song was like listening to a replay of the last. The first and last songs could be passed as the same without too much convincing. In addition to this the music is mediocre and nothing to get excited over. I honestly fail to work out how this album would make it’s way into any top 20,000 list let alone 10001 of all time. 1 Star
I listened to this yesterday but didn't remember a single thing about it. Was better upon second listen, some surprisingly nice tracks
3.5/5 I think I should listen to it again. It seemed promising
Shameful that I have never listened to this album. I'm more familiar with Sinister and Catastrophe Waitress. This album is beautiful and I love it.
Mary Jo
Different, not too shabby
I liked this within the first 10 seconds. The vocals are a combo of folky, lovely and depressing. I like how the different well played instruments move in and out and the many style changes including a very captivating electronic tune (Elec Ren) after which the instruments really come alive on “Could be dreaming”. To top it off, just when I was thinking I had it w ambience, Mary Jo ended and did Tigermilk. It's nice to see cool school projects that don't involve blowing shit up.
Pues, me gustaron 5 canciones de 10.
I'd have never paired Beauty from Beauty and the Beast with the crab from The Little Mermaid, but Disney have done it here and it has resulted in a fairly okay record. It hasn't blown my mind in the same way a collaboration between Scar and Princess Jasmine would have.
false
Good album. Non offensive, enjoyable.
On first listening I was disappointed. I was prepared to really love it. It was good, but not exceptional. I've listened to it 3 times now, and it's grown on me.
'You're just a baby' is Robert Plant's favourite from this. The guy loves babies. Not in a good way.
I've always had a huge soft spot for "twee-pop", despite absolutely hating the term twee-pop - I'm sure NME are to blame, they usually are. The world would be a little less fun without the jangly indie of twee bands from Talulah Gosh to the mighty Los Campesinos!, and Belle & Sebastian are up there with the very best of them. This isn't their best album but it's a strong debut, especially considering it was thrown together in a week and none of them had played together before recording. Oh, and the album cover is a woman breastfeeding some sort of toy tiger fish, so there's that.
Awesome
Det kan et eller andet
good album, didnt really pay much attention to the lyrics but nice background music
"I gave myself to sin, I gave Myself to providence and I've Been there and back again The state that I am in." (The state that I am in) "Tell Veronica the secrets of the boy you never kissed" (Expectations) *heart emoji*
Good.
Pues batstante chido, no esperaba pasármela bien con algo que en mi prejuicio suena a "rock indie". Supongo que por el eclecticismo del album me pareció chido, un poco de todo, ruido, synth, cuerdas clásicas, post punk vibes, ondita alternativa. Favs: She's losing it, Electronic Renaissance que está chida la idea, y My Wandering 0Days are Over. Mood: cuando dujeron I Don´t Love Anyone... I really felt that.
Nice angst & humour in the vocals. The first thirty seconds had me chuckling. I like the addition of strings & horns to some of the songs. It gave them a mid-sixties feel and more of it would have reduced the overall sameness of the songs.
Ok
Perfektes Debut, der kalifornischen Schotten, mit gleichbleibend hohem Niveau in puncto Songwriting, eigener Handschrift & Alltagsgeschichten wie aus Indie Movies entlehnt, die erst noch gedreht werden mussten. Ihre Ästhetik bedient sich in Verweisen auf französische Nouvelle Vague, Jonathan Richmans Ringel-Shirt mit Halstuch und Literatur im Allgemeinen und dabei sind sie so aufreizend mühelos stilprägend, denn ihr leiser Tonfall war im Britpop des Jahres 1996 eher die Ausnahme, Quiet is the New Loud als Mini Hype noch nicht erfunden und auch mit nur einem Finger den Nuller Electroclash ("Electric Renaissance") mal eben angestupst und wieder im Schrank versteckt. Vor allem aber haben sie vieles andere überdauert, sich bis zu einem gewissen Punkt ("The Life Pursuit") weiterentwickelt, bis es einfach nicht mehr weiterging, ohne sich selbst zu karikieren. Werde immer etwas melancholisch horny wenn ich eines ihrer frühen Alben höre - ganz unabhängig von diesem Cover. schmachtende 4.7
Hier deutlich festzustellen: ein gewisser 90er-Bias, vermutlich einfach wegen des intensiveren Erlebens und Erinnerns einiger Platten (Pavement, Blur, Massive Attack, Faith No More, ...). Hier allerdings liegt der Fall anders, ich hab Belle & Sebastian so richtig erst Anfang der Nuller auf den Schirm genommen und auch da zunächst nicht besonders groß. Wäre also leicht gewesen, das hier mit einer lockeren 3 durchzubewerten, ABER: das geht natürlich nicht, nein, hier nun wirklich nicht. Da sind NUR HITS drauf, "gut gealtert" wäre eine Beleidigung weil die meisten von denen sind sogar noch besser geworden. Glatte 5, klar verdient.
Sweet and almost soothing tracks. Nothing really struck me, but strong across the board.
Not bad, but not really good. I thought it'd be better. But it was OK. Nice way of finishing the work week
One of the best Belle & Sebastian's albums. A great indie example of 90's
Bland to my ear.
Somber and delicate melodies accompanied by piano and guitar. The first half wasn’t the most exciting for me personally. I enjoyed Electric Renaissance quite a bit. Decent album, but I prefer the Scottish Indie Pop group’s “Write About Love”, although it is like splitting hairs.
I kind of like the soft pop sound.
Pretty cool. Need to listen again when in a sentimental type mood
So twee and light. But beneath those delightful melodies lurks some sharp satire and hipster angst.
It’s just ok. Nothing special but also nothing bad. I wouldn’t feel like I was missing anything if I’d have not heard this album and I think I’ll forget it quickly.
This is one of my favorite albums by one of my favorite bands
Ok
The album peaks in the first half. Expectations through to I Could Be Dreaming are the standout tracks. The latter half of the album seems to mould into one and the songs don’t stand out as much. Still a half decent album with interesting lyrics. It’s very listenable (probably driving through the countryside) but it could be better based on the standard of the first half.
Aquí soy muy parcial, porque Belle & Sebastian ha estado entre mis bandas favoritas de la vida, desde la prepa que los conocí. Este no es uno de mis discos preferidos de ellos, pero tiene todo lo que uno puede esperar de ellos: algunas buenas letras, muchos instrumentos, moods variados y como toda esa vibra ""indie"" que se puede pedir. Antes, "Electronic Renaissance" era casi que mi top del disco, pero ahora pienso que la que más quiero del disco es "I Don't Love Anyone" por afinidad personal. "The State I Am In", "I Could Be Dreaming" y "Expectations" completan lo que más disfruto de este disquito. En fin, pues claro que mi sesgado 10/10.
Cool debut album from one of the first indie bands to warm our hearts. Twas a refreshing listen!
Not my style
Not the biggest fan of indie, but I found myself enjoying the songs and harmonies on this album. A good album overall.
This is an upbeat and folky pop style inspired album. An accent on the main singer adds a sense of rawness to the soundstage whilst the use of taps, claps and drums allows for a more playful and rich tone throughout. Just as the style of the album is started to be understood, an **Electronic Renaissance** in the form of a mid album breakup shakes things up. The mixing of this track is raw and unfiltered, presenting harsh trebles and highs, a radio in the shed experience. Suddenly, we are back into the earlier album with a happy style guitar riff paving way for the ballad style **‘I could Be Dreaming’** The use of tremolo and echos throughout the song provides a warm feel to the track. Powerful tracks and voice complete the powerful backing to the song. The vocals provide a surprising rounding and polish to the outdo of the song, solidifying the ballad experience. Suddenly the tempo drops in a reflective outlook on life as shown in **We Rule The School**, make the most of your life and think back to the times as a kid. This vocal emphasised track intertwines with various musical melodies to represent the different paths of different people. Powerful lyrics presenting a powerful message. **My Wandering Days Are Over** has a sense of refinement, a reflective look back on life with a feeling of the journey through life. We can hear about the path the lead singer has taken, the wisdom he has gained along the way. The music is less playful, more serious and the addition of brass represents the subtle seriousness of the track. **I don’t love anyone** and **Mary Jo** are just not worth writing about, a weak end to a could be great album.
Niet slecht, maar niet helemaal m’n ding
I did not enjoy this.
Reminds me of 2000 - Hope St. Always preferred Boy with the Arab Strap, think the pop jangle of Dirty Dream #2, sold me on Belle and Sebastian.
Almost decemberists sounding. Pretty cool!
I liked this album, it was a mix of Elliott Smith, mountain goats, and....i wanna say Spoon.
It grew on me pretty quick... I liked Expectations and The State I'm In the most, though the rest of the album was enjoyable as well (Electronic Renaissance probably the least). Mellow style and engaging lyrics.
Upbeat, and diverse with rich tones and sounds
dont like
I don’t love it, didn’t hate it. Decent background music.
good soft indie
okay. might give me an existential crisis???
Album was so, so, but their later music was much better!
Not a great album to me. The music is tame and not very 'creative' basic tunes. The singing is what made me really not like this. It's not so much singing as narrating over some instruments and there doesn't seem to be and flow in the lyrics. It sounds like you asked someone how was your day and as they told you there was some music in the backround
I really really enjoyed this. What a gem.
Beautiful
meh
It's a very different sound and style than current Belle and Sebastian, that's for sure. I would equate it to a less ambitious Abbey Road, maybe? I know it's a bit cliche to compare a band to the Beatles, but that was my thought while listening to it. I appreciated how things got a little shaken up into electronica halfway through the album, but I enjoyed the A-side more than the B. Favorite song is The State I'm In, least favorite is I Could Be Dreaming.
sad indie vampire weekend
Laaaaame
Beetje slappe indiepop, niet echt mijn ding
I listened to this
There's nothing wrong with this album but it's not my kind of music. Just a noninteruptive scottish pop.
Beetje saai
Incredibly strong for a first album. I didn't LOVE it like I've loved their newer stuff, but I was very impressed. Some of the lyrics are a bit out-there and sometimes uncomfortable, but the soundscapes and overall composition is exciting and unique.
I thought this was a solid debut for them. The melodies are pretty catchy and they straddle the line between cheery and depressing with the combination of their instrumentation of lyrics. Favorite Track: The State I Am In Least Favorite Track: Mary Jo
Nice. Nothing stood out to me though.
It's a soft, sweet, and wistful album. If it was a tad more twee it would be too saccharine for me but this is juuust right! This Aussie gives it four arvo cuppas out of five.
it was fine. good walking music. the contrast between the lyrics and sound was interesting but not groundbreaking
Not sure about this one
infelizmente o feeling sinister é melhor...
gay, kinda Ok guitar so far, Cant stand it
Fun bouncy indie pop, but very tremulous vocals
3.1
This album made me feel nostalgic for University and I adored it, but I've never heard it before today. I love the violin and orchestra feel of it so much. Big highlights- Electronic Renaissance, She's Losing It, and We Rule the School. But every song rocks.
First 4 tracks are phenomenal. Enjoyed them a lot, great lyrics and music. 5th song started to get more electronic which didn't work as well for them. Most of the rest of the tracks were ok, nothing too memorable though I really enjoyed the final track May Jo. 3.5
5/10 I didn't really vibe much with this, but it was nice enough as background music
Mellow kinda boring
Reminds of The Kooks, or a decomposed JoyDivision. 3.5 stars
A bit too much hippy/indie for me, but not bad. Liked to opener and "We rule the school"
Love this one, Thanks for introducing me
This is not my kind of music but it was fine on a rainy morning. I don't think I'll listen to it again on my own but I won't shoot it down if someone throws it on. It was too slow for what I'm used to. Since I dont have an ear for the music, it seemed to blend together. I liked Electronic Renaissance, The State I Am In, and My Wandering Days Are Over.
A decent feel-good indy album.
Didn't really feel this one
false
What a cool little album. I'd heard of Belle and Sebastian for a long time (I think starting with High Fidelity), but I don't know that I'd ever actually listened to them. It was certainly different, but very fun to listened to. Solid alternative pop music 4/5
Ahead of its time, but in a direction I'm not a fan of
not for me
eh not for me
Entertaining and enjoyable indie pop with some good harmonies and melpdies
Good bit of folk music there nice mellow stuff.
Lækker vellyd og feel-good easy listening rock pop. Absolut et genlyt værd
indie pop, twee pop
Mainitsiko joku unimusiikin?
I don’t know what this was but +1 star for the cover album
Beautiful, eclectic indie pop album. Everything fits together and is meaningful with each second passing. Each song has a life of their own and presented in their own take. A musical journey of an album that set up an unique, intriguing sound from this group. Stand-Outs: The State I Am In, We Rule The School
Yeah very mellow indie with some dark undertones.
Heel chille popmuziek met zowel mannelijke als vrouwelijke vocals. Soms wel leuke teksten.
Uhhhhh... It's good
Pretty mid but wasn’t a fan of the vocals which seemed as if they were punched in on an intercom. Plus the percussion mix was way lower for a good chunk of the album
It’s put together well enough but nothing really grabs me here
I called this album, "the album that launched every indie band in Washington state," and I think I stand by that. It wasn't bad, just wasn't super memorable to me. Could see why people like it and wouldn't be opposed to listening to another by them. Favorite tracks: "Electronic Renaissance", "She's Losing It"
Very lovely. That's all I can say, really. I appreciated the atmosphere. 4.5, not quite 5 though.
Listened before
Really diverse set of offerings here. Astounding that it was recorded in five days as a school project. It’s like proto-Sufjan.
ok this is a hipster's dream. boring folky songs with very light marching beat drums, singer(s?) never raises his voice high enough to know if he can actually sing or not, general sound like the postman pat theme. So inoffensive it makes me want to go commit crimes just to make up for how fucking boring it is. 2/5 because I pity it more than I outright hate it.