Album Summary
Whatever is the first solo album by the American singer-songwriter Aimee Mann, released in 1993. "I've Had It" is one of the songs featured in Nick Hornby's book 31 Songs. The album, with special note for the song "4th of July", was included by Elvis Costello in his "Costello's 500" list for Vanity Fair. It has also been included in the 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die list.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
When you're watching a teen drama, there are moments when a girl discovers her boyfriend cheated on her, or a boy finds out he missed the Varsity team, or a boy, and his friends are caught getting drunk at a party. Now, after these moments of conflict, you know that music that plays when the characters are trying let the moment sink in right after we see it happen on screen? As a reminder, it's usually some acoustic guitar, and the wailing voice of a woman that puts you in a happy-sad mood That's this album in a nutshell. Favorite Track: "Jacob Marley's Chain".
Avril Lavigne for the Gen X.
Coffee house drivel
This was pretty basic as far as 90s female singers. She has a great voice and I enjoyed a few of the songs, but overall fairly boring and unremarkable.
This falls into the generic, alternative female singer songwriter 90s bin. Interchangeable with many others and nothing to make it stand out from the pack.
She's a nice singer, but her tendency to write songs in a too-high key leaves her sounding strained through songs that are otherwise pleasant (except for "Jacob Marley's Chain," which is a terrible gimmick song)
My 1 star review of Sheryl Crow was: “Perfect for anyone who thinks the music in your local garden centre is too edgy.” Aimee Mann is for people who think Sheryl Crow is still too edgy.
Perfectly fine and beige. Standard 90s American female singer songwriter. Could've been anyone is the standout song. 3 stars
Number: 315 Familiarity: Aware (2) Rating: 3 Before: ======= I don't think I knew about Aimee Mann until I saw her on a Portlandia episode many years ago where she played herself but she was working as a cleaning lady and was cleaning Carrie and Fred's house and although they were fans they were also being really nitpicky about the cleaning. So I thought, wow, if they like her so much as to have her on their show she must be really cool. Well, anyways, I guess eventually I listened to some of her music and ended up "liking" 2 songs apparently. Oh, they're the same song, just 2 different versions of "Wise Up" which are not on this album for today's listen. So, to my knowledge, I have never listened to this album but I probably at least skimmed through it before. During: ======= Hm, starting off with "I Should've Known", this is pretty good. It's more my style nowadays than it would have been back in 1993. After : ======= Mostly I didn't care for it all that much. I'd give it a low 3.
Good pacey start. I lost focus during the back half, but would listen again.
I’ve been unfair to this in the past. It’s a great album and her songwriting and performances are super strong. Feel like this had a big influence on lots of music I like
incredibly pleasent
Just really generic
From the cover thought this might be a bit alternative or rocky. Wrong pretty straight down the middle country. Pleasant enough but a bit bland
medio triste y darkk
I only know of Aimee Mann through Magnolia and what I know I like. This album was more upbeat and poppier than I was expecting and sounds very 90's. Whilst I really like her voice none of the tracks really resonated with me in the way Wise up / Save Me do from Magnolia as they were generally all a bit too jaunty and poppy.
sounds like early '90s, American, female singer-songwriter, AOR. Hello Melissa Etheridge, Sheryl Crow, Jewel, Natalie Merchant. Does what you'd expect. I'm sure it's 5-stars if you are into this style, for the rest of us, its fine without doing anything. It's not Voices Carry, which was a corker of a moody tune.
trosku zmes twilight bella trosku demi lovato camp rock 👏👏 trosku doma film kde v americkej vesnicke pestuju obrovske helloweenske tekvice a hlavna protgaonistka spieva v garazvoej rock kapele ale whatever neurazi nenadchne klasik
Nagyon nagyon jó szövegek de a dallam nagyon ismétlődő. Ugyanakkor jobb felkapott taylor Swift album lehetne mint Taylor xdd
Intelligent songwriting, great voice, jangly guitars. Loved it.
(5/7) nice
Perfectly fine pop rock if that's your thing, but it's not for me
Just ok. Nothing memorable and it all sounded the same by the end. Most songs felt formulaic. Nothing bad just meh.
I can hear how artists like Courtney Barnett owe a lot to Aimee Mann, but I couldn't connect with this record. It felt like it was following a pop-rock formula that just doesn't work, even though some of the lyrics are striking, and her singing is fine.
Man this was some 90s movie montage karaoke kind of stuff. No one was bad in terms of unskilled but the whole thing just continually washed out into saccharine nothing in the speakers.
I'd never heard of Aimee Mann before today's listen, so *Whatever*, her debut solo album, seemed like a good place to start. This album comes with some pretty impressive recommendations. "I've Had It" features in Nick Hornby's book *31 Songs*, while Elvis Costello included the album in his *Costello's 500* list for *Vanity Fair*, particularly praising "4th of July". That's some serious praise, so I was looking forward to seeing what all the fuss was about. Unfortunately, I don't quite get the hype. There's nothing particularly wrong with *Whatever*, but I found much of it fairly basic and unremarkable. It sounds like a lot of the female singer-songwriter music coming out of the 1990s, and nothing really makes it stand out for me. It's certainly no Alanis Morissette. There are positives, though. Aimee Mann has a lovely voice, and when the songwriting is good, it's really good. "4th of July" is a great example. I can absolutely see why Elvis Costello liked this one, as it sounds like something he could have written himself. "Say Anything" and "Stupid Thing" are also really enjoyable songs. My biggest issue is that the album becomes less interesting as it progresses. The first half has some decent tunes, but the second half starts to drag, and I found myself losing interest. There's nothing particularly offensive about the music, but equally, there's not enough here to make me want to come back to it. Overall, *Whatever* is a perfectly pleasant album with a handful of good songs, but I was expecting much more given its reputation. I can appreciate Aimee Mann's voice and songwriting talent, but this one didn't do much for me. A fairly forgettable listen, unfortunately. Favourite tracks: "4th of July" is easily the standout. A great song with a real Elvis Costello feel to it. I also enjoyed "Say Anything" and "Stupid Thing". Least favourite track: "Jacob Marley's Chain". A bit too whimsical for my taste and, frankly, a bit crap. The second half of the album generally didn't do much for me. Album artwork: Cool album cover. I love the DMs!
Favorite Track: 4th of July
Some honestly pretty great early 90s pop-rock, bordering on emo; I can easily draw a line between this record and a lot of mid-2000s emo-pop acts, especially an artist like Avril Lavigne. There were some pretty fantastic cuts in the mix; 'Say Anything' felt a bit more progressive and dynamic than you'd expect out of your typical alternative cut, and 'Fifty Years After The Fair' was just a straightforward banger that I really enjoyed. And vocally, Aimee Mann is pretty convincing in this alley; she delivers a pretty well-rounded performance all things considered, with that very much necessary emotional teenage cadence. Very much of its time album still, despite its more visionary "attitude", but I was shocked at how many of the songs I enjoyed here. Nothing too, too special, but definitely a hidden gem in this list for me.
Interesting voice and lyrics. Strong song writing. But it felt more intellectually stimulating than emotionally moving.
Sleeve is ok. Can you imagine the a&r man in a drunken stupor saying ‘ I’ve found the new Joni Mitchell’ ?
Beliebig. Austauschbar. Nebenbeigedudel.
It's alright. Not my style but some interesting lyrics. 5 outta 10
Still think this is her best album start to finish. My first 5 star rating.
I liked this a lot actually. 1/2 of it was meh but 1/2 of it was completely fabulous
Yeah, it was kind of “what ever”.
I'd call it beige, but I prefer beige.
Solid female 90s rock album but not the genre-defining masterpiece that many people claim it to be.
Aimee Mann - whatever (1993) My thoughts exactly. I’m 3 songs in and I’m not sure I can arsed to sit through all 52 minutes. Bland alt-pop which sounds exactly like 1993. I’m giving it 2/5. Will come back and edit if it improves ⭐️⭐️ Edit - no change to the rating. It’s only getting 2 stars as it was not overly offensive at any point (despite the stupid piano and hidden 5 second track at the end)
Pretty solid album.
Choosing this as the one Aimee Mann album on the list is straight up bizarre, but the song craft is solid and it’s fun to hear early Jon Brion production flourishes surrounded by more overtly nineties touches.
Pretty good pop album here
This is bang average for the 1001, middling pop rock singer songwriter. '4th of July' is a good song but stands alone as being worthy of this.
Bueno
Back in the 90s we had to sing just a little badly sometimes to prove our authenticity. This had a few okay songs but mostly I didn't like it.
Inderdaad "whatever", saai
2,5
This album is fantastic. Has a very Brandi Carlisle vibe. I had never heard anything by her before. The songs have a lot of depth lyrically and interesting stuff going on sound wise. Definitely one of the better surprises so far of this whole experiment! Not exactly my type of music that I seek out, but I have no problem putting this on. It’s good stuff. Rating: 9/10 Stars: 5/5
I finished listening to this 15 minutes ago, I already can't remember it. There was singing? And instruments, too, probably. Lyrics, for sure. But, gun to my head, that's about all that I can tell you. Truly a contender for blandest thing on this list, as well as most baffling inclusion.
Not as amazing as the Magnolia stuff, but fun to hear
Found her because of Magnolia and never went backward into her catalog, so this is a fun choice.
Pleasant enough but she did better solo work later
I mean, like, it's okay I guess ... Whatever ...
大人のポップって感じ。AORとは全然違うけど、洗練はされてると思いました。好きな人はまじでめっちゃいいんやろうな、と思いました。スザンヌ•ヴェガとかにも近いかも。
Was quite interested to listen to this one. Know the name, couldn’t name a single song of hers though. Christ, what a disappointment, turgid, and had to fast forward some of the songs I found them so bad or grating. Ended up not finishing it. Talk about expectations being completely wrong.
This iwas a nice suprise - I'd not heard of her before but I'll definitely look out for more from her.
Beautiful album
A few songs on this really stood out to me - overall a great listen, it built a nice cozy vibe that somehow made me feel nostalgic
Was ok :) 3.3
I could see myself loving this in another life. Like change .000001% of my dna and im all for it. Just without caring about lyrics im missing out on a large part of this. But what I do hear is nice. Its nice little singer songwriter stuff. She has a nice voice. She picks good backing instrumentals. I just dont get enough from that. It reminds me of some other stuff weirdly. Some specific song I can't remember sounds alot like that werid English on the persona 4 soundtrack. Bonkers connection but I cant unhear it. Its ok to even great but I just didnt get much out of it. Maybe something else she's done hut this is just meh
Quite nice for an album for angsty teen girls 3/5
I don’t think that I’ve come across this artist previously but I may have as she has come from that secret production line of safe but slightly edgy female singers that they have in the USA. Sounds just like the rest. Another case of ‘What the hell’s this album doing on the list!’
Inoffensive but dull. heard it all before.
I couldn’t get into this. Aimee Mann may be a fantastic song writer, but her music is boring.
Bit meh rly
the solo debut album of aimee mann, a musician who co-founded new wave group 'til tuesday. she wrote a lot of material during her time in the band and right as she split from them; she had been trying to break her contract with epic records for a frustratingly long amount of time before finally venturing off to do her own thing. compared to the group's new wave endeavors, her solo work is more guitar pop than anything else. initial critic reviews were generally positive, but commercial success was modest. well, let's see. the album has a bright and poppy sound, but a lot of the lyrics are blunt, direct and pretty straightforward. i feel like if i wrote pop music, the lyrical content could be similar to how she does it. sometimes the music gets a little folksy. truth be told it sounds like just about any pop rock album that could come out 20 to 30 years ago. little flavor, little zing... there's a little bit of something, but there's a good amount of nothing. feels like something that could play at my mcdonald's. this music doesn't really challenge me as a listener.
Not really sure why this is on this list. The album isn't bad or anything, but there are so many other 90s alt rock ladies who were more influential and do many other albums that were more interesting. Low 3, I got bored.
I couldn’t quote focus on the lyrics (was driving) but could tell they were high quality and not generally lazy. The music also seemed more creative than generic top-40 pop. But nothing drew me in. I didn’t think “oh, I need to come back and listen to this track so i can focus on it.” A 3.
uh no. not a must listen
3.5
Im having a hard time determining what it is that makes this any different than any of the other "alt girl" early 90s albums other than the fact that we knew Aimee from the 80s in 'Till Tuesday. Similar songs with mid tier vocals. Honestly this sounds like the band from a bar scene in any 90s movie I dont understand the critical love for Aimee and this is no different. I dont dislike it, I dont like it. After today I will forget this exists. 2 stars.
Aimee Mann is an exceptional lyricist. Her songs are full of vulnerable people whom others are attempting to break.
Aimee Mann's first album after the dissolution of Til' Tuesday is lighter and brighter than the album title would lead you to believe. Whatever, partially co-written with then boyfriend Jon Brion, was a critical darling at the time and stood in stark contrast with pop culture trends that were shifting from grunge and alternative rock (like the still popular acts Nirvana, Pearl Jam, and The Smashing Pumpkins) to hip-hop (Wu-Tang Clan and Snoop were on the rise). As it didn't really fit in with the zeitgest, Aimee Mann's debut was met with lukewarm sales and flew under the radar. Thankfully she wasn't discouraged and continued on to be a prolific, award winning songwriter. Some of that future greatness is present on Whatever but is often obscured by busy production, leaving the more stripped down tracks to do the heavy lifting. It's positioned more as a stepping stone in her discography rather than a destination.
I really like Aimee Mann's other stuff but this feels like a work in progress, the songwriting is not as sharp and the hooks don't hit as well as her later material
Decent album, not sure who she reminds me of really, not unique, but ok
It makes no sense that this is on the list. Offensive through its inoffensiveness
Good Lord, this is BAD; like, "should we do something to help the nice lady stop embarrassing herself in public?" bad. And that sucks because she seems like a kind hearted, interesting person. She should’a just stuck with cleaning houses in Portland.
A pretty decent album with no really weak songs. 4 stars or B-.
10/8/26. Couldn't get into this one much either. Some interesting lyrics, but thought a lot of the music blended together in a way that it became a little exhausting.
a classic from my early 20s
Fun, nothing special though
Great songwriting (sometimes in what would maybe considered the alt-country/roots vein these days, which kind of surprised me based on what I know of Aimee Mann's other work) and trademark observant, witty lyrics.
i liked this. the lyrics were cool, the sound was very 90s, but in a good way
Ekassa biisissä oli jotain koukkua mutta muuten äärimmäisen tylsä albumi. Aivan keskinkertaista ysäri-pop-rockia. En keksi, miksi tämä albumi on listalla. 2/5
Приятный поп альбом, встречал я в этой подборке альбомы куда хуже
Not for me. 1/5
Saturday, 3 October, 2036 Great record! Could have cut four songs and fit u see 40 mins.
This is a great debut that is pretty special to me. It shows off her songwriting and voice and features Jon Brion as producer. His gift for arrangements and interesting instrumentation elevates everything. This is the most Beatlesque of her albums and has an XTC or Squeeze feel to it on many of the songs. Really not a bad song on it. It's my favorite of hers by a pretty wide margin.
Mann's voice is a pleasure to listen to, resonant and warm and impossibly clean sounding. Lots of evocative lyrics and credit to whoever's on guitar, nothing earthshaking but lots of perfectly placed little solos and riffs that complement so well.
Pretty underwhelming. Maybe just had to be in the right mood for it, but when I listened I couldn't get into any of it (felt like I should've been in coffee shop). Slightly annoyed at how often "Jacob Marley's chains" was sang
Aimee Mann is one of those artists that everyone has heard of, but nobody can name a single song by her. She's been around for ages, so presumably she continues to sell and have fans, but nobody is really sure why. It seems silly then that someone like, say, Natalie Imbruglia isn't on the list. Her debut was a massive smash hit, and while far from her best album, it's certainly the one you would include when considering 'must hear before you die'. There's a couple of songs in the middle of the album I'll happily listen to again, but ni standouts, nothing that grabbed me like a pop song should, or stuck with me like something with more substance should. In short, it's fine. It's an album by a person. Some good lyrics, her voice is okay if unremarkable, and the music is tame, pleasant enough, MOR fare. I don't know enough about Mann to say how importsnt or influential she has been - she's basically a non-entity over here outside of her appearance in Buffy, but even that would have had more impact if anyone cared about her or her music.
I had to quickly get acquainted with which part of the 90s music scene we were in with this one, and after I adjusted, I found this okay. I think I expected a different vibe based on the cover. Aimee's voice isn't necessarily my favorite, but her songwriting skills are pretty great for a solo debut. Still, there was something about the clash between hard rock guitars & her vibrato that just didn't totally work for me. It felt a little too disparate, in the same way that I sometimes have issues with artists similar to this. I really want to like this kind of 90s music, but I'm not quite there yet. Favorite tracks: Could've Been Anyone, Put Me On Top, Say Anything
Anonymous alt rock with colorless singing, this bloated relic of the 90s is the very definition of inconsequential. In addition, Mann dooms her already threadbare songs by bringing on Jon Brion to co-write and co-produce, ensuring that any possible spark is extinguished by Brion's overwrought approach.
Nice 90s adult contemporary. Your Meredith Brooks, Liz Phair, Michelle Branch type. Not a lot to say- it’s pleasant, if a bit long. ⭐️⭐️⭐️
More boring sheryl crow
Whatever indeed
I've heard of Aimee Mann before. She co-founded the Boston-based new wave band 'Til Tuesday with their hit single, "Voices Carry", before disbanding it to pursue a solo career. She was more interested in playing "acoustic guitar music" than the new wave stylings of 'Til Tuesday, and that attitude is apparent on her debut, Whatever. To be clear upfront, as someone who has listened to numerous female singer-songwriter records before, this album isn't anything new or striking to me. Sure, Aimee is fully capable of writing some decent hooks here, and her singing voice is rather pleasant. Plus, her stories of heartbreak, rejection, and dealings with the music industry aren't as straightforward, making use of some nice imagery; invoking the 1939 New York World's Fair to highlight how things haven't gone well for her and her partner in "Fifty Years After the Fair" is a good example of that. But given how prevalent female singer-songwriter music of this stripe had been at this point - this came out the same year as Sheryl Crow's Tuesday Night Music Club and Liz Phair's Exile in Guyville, both also included in the 1001 Albums books - I can't in good conscience say this album particularly stands out, aside from maybe the Beatles-esque horn and ornate piano accompaniment on the closing track "Way Back When", followed by noodling around with flutes on the brief hidden track. It's at least something different. I still had a good time with Aimee Mann's solo debut, and I know she continued to develop as a solo singer-songwriter, if the songs off the Magnolia film soundtrack are anything to go by.
God this was boring I did not at all like this. Can't even bring myself to say much more other than it wasn't the absolute worst thing.
Whatever
It was fine, nothing outstanding tho
Mysalbum som mest gled i bakgrunden. Inte riktigt något speciellt bra eller dåligt. Ganska standard album men som det var ju inte liksom inte dåligt