S&M by Metallica

S&M

Metallica

3.25
Rating
25217
Votes
1
9%
2
18%
3
29%
4
26%
5
17%
Distribution

Album Summary

S&M (an abbreviation of Symphony and Metallica) is a live album by American heavy metal band Metallica, with the San Francisco Symphony conducted by Michael Kamen. It was recorded on April 21 and 22, 1999, at The Berkeley Community Theatre. This is the final Metallica album to feature bassist Jason Newsted.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

I actually quite liked this but my god 2 hours is too much for most things

S&M As is customary I need to say that I think both Enter Sandman and Master of Puppets are excellent songs, but my tolerance for the rest of their oeuvre is pretty much exhausted now so this was probably never going to land for me. It’s not a terrible idea to try and add orchestral drama and flair to their songs, but as so many of their songs are harmonically and melodically barren that there isn’t much the San Francisco Symphony can really do, other than add to the superficial juvenile bombast of it all, and it all ends up feeling rather pointless, particularly once the guitars kick in, Lars clodhops gracelessly around his kit and James Hetfield starts gurning for his life, and over the course of 2 and a quarter hours it certainly feels needlessly self indulgent. There also seems to be no real sense of interplay between the band and orchestra. Metallica are just playing their set as normal while the orchestra separately but at the same time play string and horn arrangements of the same songs. I was hopeful Enter Sandman might be good, but I don’t think the horns really work. The only successful songs are Nothing Else Matters, mainly due to the band being relatively restrained and it being one of their better melodies and The Ecstasy of Gold, principally because it’s not a Metallica song and we can really hear how great Kamen and the orchestra are. Obviously not much in this for me, but the orchestra does stop it being a basement dweller however so I’ll go 2. 🌉🌉 Playlist submission: The Ecstasy of Gold

It was a bold move and it paid off. Metallica didn’t need an orchestra to make their music epic but it pushed their songs to new heights. This album also captures the band at a time before their catalog got too bloated. In anddituon to the heavy metal staples is includes the best stuff from the Load era plus 2 new songs (both great). This album plays like a Metallica greatest hits but with a symphony. Pretty epic.

no se no me gusta metalica

very good

I do not remember hating this as much as I did listening right now...

The hype for this album was wild to see. The local radio sent a guy to the show just to review the concert. There was a midnight release and a line down the block for it. It might not have been the first paring of a symphony and a band but it was one of the biggest. Clif would have loved it. It even has a sequel album done 20 years later. That said I love this album. I wish there was more symphony but it's fun. Some songs are elevated because of the full symphony and others you don't really notice as much. Not a shock as thrash metal tends to be loud and fast. Still I thought it was well put together and presented. Well worth a listen. Great album

All I can say is great instrumentation. Unfortunately it’s hard to accurately appreciate these songs as I haven’t listened to the originals yet. Having this live collection here now ultimately ranks lower than it might have in a smaller digestible form. 2hr 13m is too long for a compilation of songs I’ve never heard before.

All got a bit samey and monotonous after a while. Thankfully the fantastic tracks like Nothing Else Matters still stand heads and shoulders above most of the crowd. Couldn’t be bothered to listen to the entire 2+ hours of this. Got through 45 minutes and then just skipped to same favourites to make it feel better. Overall, not worth the time.

Well this was a pleasant suprise - have always avoided Metallica (RIP Napster) but this was pretty damn good

A really good live album. Just a ton of character

Starts out with some nice Morricone by the symphony alone, goes downhill from there. Superfluous in a world where Apocalyptica exists.

This was such a brilliant move for Metallica to make in the early aughts. It significantly broadened Metallica's audience by softening the tunes a bit through the (really wonderful) orchestration but also, then, showing off how great the songs are. Weird to think of it this way, but in many ways this record achieved what the Black album attempted but didn't quite manage: It made Metallica into a pop group.

Does it deserve a spot on the list? I don't think so. Do I love this anyway? Yeah. The orchestra fits so well. No Leaf Clover is a great new song introduced on this one. Outlaw Torn is my favorite track. 4.2/5.

Classic rock with a symphony!! I like it

I really liked this at first, and I'm not a massive fan of Metallica to say the least, but it soon got very samey. And it's bloody long. When will bands learn? More is less.

04/11/2026 I am surprised myself that I'm rating this as low as I am. It's a brave album, but it just sounds disjointed and clunky unfortunately. Spotify listeners: 33.9 million

Long, and doesn't feel as interesting by the end. Overall, enjoyable listen

WAY too long, but I actually enjoyed the orchestral background. The novelty was interesting.

Classic.

Would've been higher but it was too long

It's Metallica. Anything they have done after 1986 has been a pile of shit.

Not as bad as I was expecting with some definite toe tappers on there. It still felt a bit one-dimensional and like it should be soundtracking a scene. In a road movie or similar. Too long for anyone but an ardent Metallica fan.

Favorite Song: One Least Favorite: Hero Of The Day

Not to keen on Metallica, don’t particularly like live albums either. 2 hours of a combination of both was a bore

The first and final few tracks are excellent, the middle feels repetitive.

ganska bra ändå

Really cool album, I don't know how I never knew about this. Especially liked For Whom The Bell Tolls and Wherever I May Roam until I focused in on Lars Ulrich's drumming. Poor guy was struggling to keep up and sadly his tempo and overall drumming ability is very subpar. Kirk and James carry so hard

"S&M" feels like an odd choice for this list. While it is a bold concept and Michael Kamen’s orchestration is fabulous in places, it does not consistently match or surpass the studio originals in say the way Deep Purple's "Made In Japan" does. Metallica has never released a live album that is widely recognised as definitive and seminal. Perhaps this list is an attempt to redress that? "Live Shit: Binge & Purge" is musically superior to "S&M", but its expensive, bulky initial release format made it inaccessible to many fans, which likely ruled it out for this list.. That said, "S&M" is far from a poor record - it is a very good, four-star album. At its best, it brilliantly proves how compatible Metal and symphonic arrangements can be. The absolute high-water marks of the set are 'The Outlaw Torn' and 'Bleeding Me', alongside 'No Leaf Clover'. It is also no surprise that 'The Call of Ktulu' works brilliantly. Disc one 1 "The Ecstasy of Gold" (5/5) 2 "The Call of Ktulu" (5/5) 3 "Master of Puppets" (4/5) 4 "Of Wolf and Man" (4/5) 5 "The Thing That Should Not Be" (4/5) 6 "Fuel" (3/5) 7 "The Memory Remains" (4/5) 8 "No Leaf Clover" (5/5) 9 "Hero of the Day" (3/5) 10 "Devil's Dance" (3/5) 11 "Bleeding Me" (5/5) Disc two 1 "Nothing Else Matters" (5/5) 2 "Until It Sleeps" (4/5) 3 "For Whom the Bell Tolls" (4/5) 4 "– Human" (3/5) 5 "Wherever I May Roam" (5/5) 6 "The Outlaw Torn" (5/5) 7 "Sad but True" (4/5) 8 "One" (4/5) 9 "Enter Sandman" (3/5) 10 "Battery" (4/5) Total - 86 Average - 4.1 459/1001 242/459 albums reviewed were new to me.

I think the concept of this album could be cool, but it was so long. I also feel like this was kind of a shift with Metallica in their music and I liked the stuff before this album came out better than the stuff after.

This was big in my house when it came out

This album was released in 1999 and is heavy metal music accompanied with a symphony. Someone will think this album is "epic" but I think it was a bad idea to add a symphony. The heavy metal edge is lost making this sound like a cheesy over the top movie soundtrack. They wrecked Enter Sandman which is a song I really like. To make things worse, it was way too long. This was one of the hardest albums for me to get through. I like some Metallica songs but this album shouldn't be on this list.

2.3 out of 5 for Metallica and the San Francisco Symphony. The only song that kept this one out of the trash heap is Nothing Else Matters which is a song that works with a symphony orchestra. The rest of it sounds odd and bizarre, and not even their classics from the golden age of Metallica can help them. It just doesn't work. It's ironic that the album leads off with The Ecstasy of Gold. Keep mining, Metallica, you'll get rich someday. Also, Kill 'Em All, Ride the Lightning, Master of Puppets are the only 3 Metallica albums that people should listen to before they die. Why is this garbage on here?

I didn't know what this was going to be before I started playing it - at first I thought "well, that was unexpected" but after a while, it sounded very much like a novelty. Ironically, it's perhaps the thing that makes this unique (i.e. playing live with an orchestra) that leaves everything hamstrung in a kind of contrived polishedness. After all, what flexibility do you have when you're shouldering a whole fucking orchestra? Not a lot. It's a big sound, but a lot of the urgency and aggression gets lost and is invariably replaced with cliched naffness - as edgy as a football. It's Metallica sure, but Metallica you could take your Mum to see. Supported by James Last.

Metallica at their most self-indulgent - and that is saying something. 2+ hours of Metallica is a chore, unless you're a superfan. And I don't really think the orchestra setting adds a lot here, unless you're one of the above-mentioned superfans. So yeah, not really essential for the casual listener. Almost redeemed itself at the end, finishing with One, Enter Sandman and Battery, but just too much overall.

I would like to suggest a universal ban on declining musical acts releasing orchestra-backed live albums. Are we supposed to think that just because you hired some strings to back you that we should take your music seriously? Should we ignore the fact that you're gilding your old hits because you have nothing new to offer? Do you think we're not going to see this as a shameless cash grab? Judging by this album's success (and inclusion on this list) I guess the answer to all three is Yes. I actually think the strings detracted from, rather than added to, what the band is doing. There was a moment on The Call of Ktulu when I started getting pulled in by a pretty great guitar solo. But then the strings came in and ruined the moment with overblown and unnecessary pretension. This might be the least essential album on this whole list. Not the worst, but unnecessary in every way

You can put lipstick on a pig, but it's still a pig.

A really cool idea for an album, but I don't think anyone needs to hear this before they die. It's not bad, but it's far from classic Metallica, and at over 2 hours long it's a bit of a slog.

These symphonic collaborations have been very popular. I have a friend who used to arrange them for the Denver Symphony Orchestra. He said he always wanted to bring in Frank Zappa, but he wasn't sure the orchestra could keep up with Frank musically. I'm pretty sure they'd have had no trouble with Metallica.

So boring

more enjoyable than standard issue Metallica is to me, honestly, although I found myself wishing this had come out after St. Anger to see how bad that shit sounded, even with orchestral backing. a bit too long, felt like I was listening to this album all day. the orchestral sound seemed to waver between Bond Theme and like an Egyptian leitmotif? like Prince of Egypt soundtrack. the track name "No Leaf Clover" and the ending of Battery where he shouts out the conductor with a huge Hetfield YEAHP had me cracking a smile. these guys are unintentionally goofy as hell. didn't completely love it but didn't hate it. glad I heard this strange thing.

I’m sure the Metallica purists disapprove of this album but I enjoyed the hell out of it. 3.1

It’s an interesting concept and I’m a big Metallica fan. Bought the CD back when it came out and only listened to it once, so this is my first time revisiting it. I’m not a fan of live albums, so that’s a mark against it. It was much too long to listen to in one sitting, but I get why it’s so long. Overall, outside of a few tracks, I didn’t really enjoy it much.

Inte för mig

I really wanted to give this the good old college try but I already know I hate Metallica and then I find it’s a fucking live album and STILL I gave it a go but I made it through the first two pretentious instrumental tracks and thought yano what? Life’s too short. DNF.

Great listen, amazing how the two seemingly different genre's of music have similar elements and mesh together well.

Very good.

Metallica have been one of the disappointments of this process. I was aware of them and the regard in which many people hold them and i was looking forward to discovery them. Unfortunately I have not had my Metallica epiphany. I find them rather dirgy and monotonous. Adding strings does not really elevate them - they just act as backing and very much secondary to the drums/ guitars. Overall vibe is very much James Bond background music. Enjoyed Enter Sandman and Nothing Else Matters -but only marginally more than the album versions. At c 2 hours it all became rather tiring.

Dilutes the thrash, adds nothing, and a really long boring set

It was okay, I have not heard many Metallica songs beforehand. This was just a bit too long for my taste. I am curious about the rest of the Metallica albums on this list on their own more.

i had no idea that this album existed, and yet here it is and I am in complete awe. i love a genre mash up, i love when artists feel free to experiment and try new things. this album, on the surface, sounds like an impossible task. a full symphony orchestra with one of the most famous thrash metal bands in the world... how could that possible be enjoyable or good? well, this album absolutely knocks it out the park. every track is brought to a new height, as each melody is layered in a new casing of strings, woodwinds, and brass. the drums are bombastic, the solos are still incredible, and James Hetfield sounds amazing. i think if you turn this on for the casual listener, they would have no idea that it was a live album until you hear the audience start to clap in between tracks. in my opinion, this is where music is at its best. talented artist taking things that they are passionate about, and transforming it into something new. i'm not even the biggest Metallica fan... and I believe that this album is truly something special. easy, easy, easy 5 stars.

Absolutely impressive and this would have been an incredible show to attend in-person. The live album is a little long, but that just means the attendees got their money's worth listening to Metallica's greatest hits performed along with a professional orchestra. I'd probably give this four and a half stars for length alone, but its worth rounding up to five.

This is like ordering a salad with buffalo sauce as the dressing. I like both of those things, and when you see it on the menu it sparks your interest, but just like the buffalo sauce, Metallica overpowers the symphony throughout this album.

what a shitty album cover. but great music. but for an album for 1001 this one is too long. ofc you get a great album if you put togehter ALL hits of a band

The name is Hetfield...James Hetfield. Kind of sounds like it should be part of a Bond movie soundtrack. More cacophonic than symphonic.

What I haven’t seen commented on in the reviews for S&M (what a terrible and stupid name), is that, by playing with the San Francisco Symphony, the musical quality of Metallica’s compositions was ‘validated.’ Anyone who’s ever tried to play Metallica songs knows that the speed and complexity tends to be on par with the more challenging of the canonical composers. Despite the super-heavy nature of Metallica’s palm muted riffs, their guitar solos often dip into into a sublimity where even a doped out metalhead can taste very old, traditional, melodic roots. Who else is stopping a song like Master of Puppets midway through its calamity to tell a quiet, harmonic story of the brief bliss sandwiched within the brutal grip of addiction? Who else would begin two albums with a psych-out gentle, classical feel before melting our faces off? It isn’t a big jump to align Metallica with a symphony orchestra. Now, the issue is, does it work? Sometimes, I feel like the symphony plays incongruously with the main song, and while not cacophonic, they don’t add much as much as they detract. With the exception of Ecstasy of Gold, the symphony never has a stand out moment. The best parts continue to be the base song being performed by the original band. Therefore, the symphony (the symphony!) becomes just a mere gimmick. Metallica’s best song, One, is completely muddied up by the symphony, and I think, deprived of all its power. Then comes the song choice itself. S&M had the disservice of coming out post Load, which I think is the beginning of Metallica’s downfall. With the exception perhaps of Hero of the Day or Fuel, any song that isn’t one of their classics would have been better served with another track from the Ride the Lightning-Black Album era. I imagine Metallica naturally wanted to perform their newer stuff, it’s just that nobody likes those songs. I would’ve loved to hear Fade to Black on here. Fight Fire With Fire, Orion… So, final consensus is- this is interesting, but I’d rather listen to the albums. I’ll bump it up a star purely for nostalgia, as a good friend of mine was really into this concert, had the DVD, and we listened to it a lot circa 2000-something.

No. 439/1001 The Ecstasy of Gold 4/5 The Call of Ktulu 3/5 (2x) Master Of Puppets 3/5 (2x) Of Wolf And Man 3/5 The Thing That Should Not Be 3/5 (2x) Fuel 3/5 The Memory Remains 4/5 No Leaf Clover 3/5 Hero Of The Day 3/5 Devils Dance 2/5 Bleeding Me 3/5 (2x) Nothing Else Matters 4/5 Until It Sleeps 3/5 For Whom The Bell Tolls 3/5 - Human 3/5 Wherever I May Roam 3/5 Outlaw Torn 2/5 (2x) Sad But True 3/5 One 3/5 (2x) Enter Sandman 3/5 (2x) Battery 2/5 (2x) Average: 2,93 There have been great uses of classical orchestras in popular music. This for me just didn't really work. The two music styles didn't really harmonize, just played side by side. Also the length is just too long.

overdose 6/10

I grew up in Metallica. This is an interesting listen but I don't think it's worthy of the 1001 Albums honor.

ok to be fair i was ready to dismiss this as something that shouldn't even be on the list given it looked like it was gonna be basically just a regular live album, just a band playing their hits, and for over 2 hours at that. but then i started listening and realised i'd somehow overlooked the part where it's got the whole "orchestral" thing going on? so like, fair enough i guess. the thing is though..... i still don't really get why it's on here other than symphonic metal being kinda popular around when the book was compiled?? but i'm sure it's not that cos if it was then like, why is nightwish totally absent from the list??? idgi. and to be blunt: 2 hours of metallica is a big fucking ask. they're already pretty mid in their home genre(s?) of heavy/thrash metal, and although im sure the spectacle of seeing them perform with an orchestra was probably a big deal at the time, we're reviewing the audio-only version of that here. and i don't really think the rearrangements on this album are much more than a sidegrade to the originals. sorry! idk maybe im missing something. maybe i'm just too used to "orchestra with electric guitars and a drum kit" given that's been half the soundtrack of like every modern sonic game since 06, and a shitload of other big budget games besides. but i'd much rather listen to "his world (theme of sonic)" on loop for 2 hours than put this on again. what a waste of my time....

This was better than I expected, but mostly because the songs were good to begin with and not because the orchestra added anything special.

I appreciate Metallica but I just don’t like the genre

I loved this when I was like 14, it holds up pretty well too.

We like Metallica and although brave, adding an orchestra makes every song less good in our opinion.

I bought this CD for my best friend for his 16th birthday, but then he got two copies as gifts so I kept one. This is one of the few live albums I like because it was doing something different. It was a one-of-a-kind moment for the band and it was captured beautifully. No Leaf Clover even got a fair amount of radio play at the time. This is a huge double album and it’s not something I listen to end-to-end very often, but when I do I always enjoy it.

I would have preferred this album as a studio endeavor and not a live recording. I wanted to be able to soak in the orchestration and their contribution to the music so much more than I felt I was able to, and live albums are never my cup of tea. This is Metallica, their most popular numbers and a few oddballs with a symphony. I don't think it realistically contributes anything novel to Metallica's catalog nor to the metal genre as a whole. It's also 2 hours long so you have to really enjoy it from the jump to want to listen through the whole record.

It's Metallica plus an orchestra, which is definitely a gimmick, but ends up being a little better than JUST a gimmick. Probably a lot more enjoyable if you like Metallica in the first place. The orchestral arrangements and performances are great, which is to be expected from the San Francisco Symphony. My favorite is probably "The Ecstasy of Gold", which isn't even a Metallica song. There are a few places where even the presence of a conductor can't keep Lars Ulrich on a steady tempo. Overall, this is another well-executed-but-not-my-jam 3 star album.

Interesting concept. I’m not entirely sure the strings add all that much. I’ve never been huge on Metallica but there are some nice slowed down versions here. I like that it’s just a little bit toned down. Nice bass lines too - shame the bassist didn’t continue after this. Enjoyed it tbf and would actually come back to it in future. 4 stars.

A bunch of Metallica songs in an alternate, still-fun coating, you don't need to prefer them over the originals to have a good time

It's over two hours long. We're already in hot water here. It's a live album. Ugh, fine, but it better immerse me in the concert as much as possible, as if I was there. Yikes! It was recorded the day after the most deadly school shooting in United States Of America history. Who the hell has a concert on a Wednesday? The main act is Metallica; not exactly the most friendly band to working class people. The band has always given me the ick. It's not looking good so far, but hey, at least it includes an orchestra. I've listened to enough Serj Tankian to appreciate a symphony-metal hybrid. I really enjoy the contrast, but I'm still not convinced it will be done well because it's Metallica. After listening to this marathon, I will conclude with the following points here. First of all, there is absolutely no denying this has one hell of a track list. It includes arguably the top ten greatest Metallica songs of all time, and a beautiful cover track for its opening. Second of all, it absolutely deserves to be in the books. It's unique, and unforgettable, if nothing else. Metallica fans, let's call it a truce, and agree to the rating. Favorite Track: "The Memory Remains".

I really liked this. I've often thought that metal and orchestral music have many parallels (intricacy/virtuosity, drama, rhythmic activity), so this pairing makes sense to me. I love orchestral music and all of the different textures and timbres that are possible, and I think that addition enhances Metallica's sound and makes it more interesting for me. If I'm listening to pretty much anything and I hear a french horn, that's gonna make me like it more. The sound isn't really classical, but leans more towards movie music and honestly really reminds me of wind band music too. It's definitely gimmicky and a bit cheesy, but I kinda always think metal music is cheesy. I think that aspect is part of the charm and I bet this would've been a really fun show to see in person.

I bet this will be Karen’s favourite Metallica album. I was pretty psyched to see it made the list. Teenage me had the entire Metallica discography. So I have listened to this one a fair bit as a result. These days I don’t listen to them as frequently but I still enjoy their music. I’m glad this one made the list because it stands out from the rest of their work for obvious reasons.

There are some great songs on this album. But, over 2 hours for a live album/concert is crazy. I had to take multiple breaks while listening to this album

This is like a vegan corndog (I've never had one but hear me out), its not bad. Got some nice flavour to it, but it will never be as good as a straight up corndog. Its something thats already working trying to be something else, just give me Metallica, and then I will go listen to some orchestral music to follow.

Could have been great

No one needs to hear this before they die.

Lowk hate Metallica

That’s a whole lotta Metalica. Better with the SFSO behind them as the metal is toned down somewhat. S&M has got their hits, a bunch of similar sounding fillers, and some screachy violins. Liked it better at the start of the experience, but it went on too long. I get that it’s a live concert so they have to capture the entire evening, but unless you’re at the concert... Really wanted to shut this one down by the end of it. (2.49*s) Free pass for live album, hopefully S&M2 doesn’t make the 1001 List.

Well, Metallica sure can put on a kick-ass show, especially with a back-up symphony. Band sounds great live...close to studio level. Hetfield got a perfect voice for metal. The songs do sound very similar though with the last few standing out. I'm sure this concert was an amazing event and at over 2 hours...epic. Still not an album though. 1001 concerts you should have been at...make a separate list. 2.32 stars.

I'm usually pretty harsh on live albums for this list as I feel they mostly miss the point as must-listen albums before you die. The majority of live albums are just a re-packaging of previously released content, often worse versions of them, unless they are tied to a pertinent world event or something more significant within a band's history. S&M at least brings something entirely unique and novel to what I expect from Metallica and the heavy metal genre as a whole. Pairing Metallica's heavy hitting tracks with a full orchestra is something I haven't heard before and genuinely did offer me a new angle on their catalog. I give them credit for their creativity and assembling a pretty effective album by enhancing their tracks with the help of the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra. Together they simultaneously "soften" their music and add a new layer while still maintaining the character that made it stand out in its original form. While I'm not the biggest fan of Metallica I absolutely understand their importance in music history and appreciate some of their mainstream stuff. S&M was actually a really nice way to take in 2 hours of thrash metal and enjoy the accompaniment. I enjoyed quite a few of the S&M versions more than the originals. The splicing of the various pieces of the orchestra made me appreciate more the way Metallica layers its main pieces while still leaving room to add strings, horns, percussion, etc. I'm sure there are some purists who find this album to be a weak-ass side project that lost the essence of their whole allure but I for one mostly enjoyed it. I'd be interested in a similar project from another act to see how it holds up. For what it's worth, S&M was a pretty fun listen. It may be a tad long, but even at a 2-hour playtime I didn't struggle through it. This is a good example of an album I probably never would have heard even though I was familiar with the artist and plenty of the original songs without this list. 2.68 stars

Metallica has 1 good album and this ain't it

This isn’t bad, but damn did it feel like it lasted two days. It’s a lot of that sound. Slow melodic guitar like I have an audience with the queen, then heavy metal with teenage edgy lyrics. The orchestra accompaniment made it better for sure.

blew me away.

The type of Symphonic Metal that I do like! This is decent, the faster, thrashier songs with the orchestral back up are brilliant, but the slower numbers DRAAAAAG. Makes me feel like I’m listening to Pearl Jam or something, and I’m not a Pearl Jam fan. If this was half the length and cut the fat, I’d consider a higher rating. Probs a 3.5 for me but has to on here be 3 as I can’t quite give it a 4. Sorry fellas :/

It's an incredible album, probably my favorite album by the band. It was a great example of how a live album should feel different from studio recordings, but it sacrificed nothing in audio quality. This was one of a small book of CDs that I kept in my first car.

I already love Metallica, and this takes my favorite songs and adds a fucking orchestra to it HELL YEA, I’ve already listened to some of it so I knew of this, but just to actually sit down and listen was cool, because it adds extra texture to some songs that benefit allot from it, the thing that should not be is so epic in this version

What in the needlessly baroque, the grotesquely rococo, the please don’t make me do 133 minutes of it is S&M? After an intro section that recasts the plainly onanistic as searchingly profound, we get both a live version of “Master of the Puppets” and an orchestra playing at the same time. Not “together”, just near enough one another to justify an inflated ticket price. Despite what’s suggested by the punning title, there is no catalysis in S&M. This is a negative-sum game, a symphony only of inhibitors. The stinging groove that opens “Human”, deep into the record, serves as a perfect example. Devoid of any extraneous musical ornamentation, it just slaps. Here for all to enjoy – or not, whatever – are the buzzsawng riffs, heavy palm muted chugs, throaty “oohs” and shoulder-popping dynamics that is Metallica. Take them, leave them, it doesn’t really matter. The fact is, you know them. S&M is a failure. Not because it isn’t Metallica. Not because it isn’t a good use of a symphony orchestra. Not because the songs suck, or because either party isn’t bringing their version of 100% to it. It fails because it just isn’t very good. Everyone loses. Ooooh.

Music for Chris Angel to flip around to

Mulig dette fortjener å være her på grunnlag av at det var en begivenhet som mixet høy- og lavkultur på en spennende og til dels vellykket måte. På låter som Master of Puppets tilfører strykerne en dramatikk som virkelig komplimenterer låta, og jeg ville ikke sett bort ifra at det er her Dimmu Borgir plukket opp ideen da de begynte å spille inn med ymse philiharmonisike på starten av 2000-tallet. Problemet til S&M, er at Metallica er aktuelle med Load og ReLoad -- to skiver som er uniformt anerkjent som blant deres aller dårligste, og utvilsomt de dårligste som forelå da denne konserten tok plass. Spor fra disse tvilsomme tvillingalbumene utgjør sånn 50% av låtutvalget. Fuel står seg som en meme-låt (gimme fue, gimme fie, gimme dabbadabbadaaaa), men alt det andre er kjedelig på det beste og kjempekleint på sitt verste (balladen Hero of the Day er like ræv som tittelen hinter til at den kommer til å være). Om man stripper ut låtene fra (Re)Load i tillegg til låtene fra Black Album (som er punktet hvor Metallica begynte å dabbe av som metal-band, til tross for at den skiva er elsket av mange), sitter vi igjen med to spor fra Ride the Lightning, to fra Master of Puppets, og to fra Justice. Ingen fra Kill 'em All. Dette er albumene som gjorde Metallica, med sporene som harmoniserer desidert best med orkesteret, og at de utgjør en så liten del av låtutvalget synes jeg er for dårlig. Det er derfor ikke lengden på albumet som er problemet. Dette er et konsertopptak fra et band som spiller lange konserter; det er feil å klage på at de spiller i to timer i denne kontexten. Problemet er låtutvalget. Og mixingen. Jeg pleier ikke å ha noe problem med hvordan Hetfield synger, men på disse låtene synes jeg han legger seg altfor høyt i pitch og vokaliserer for mye. Sounden til alle instrumentene utenom strykerne har også altfor lite diskant, som om de har fått high enden kutta med et low pass filter. Noe som får et band som burde være hardt til å høres softere ut enn de egentlig er. Dette, sammen med et ganske ræva låtutvalg, gjør dette til en langtekkelig og skuffende lytteopplevelse. Om det fantes rettferdighet for Metallica, tenker jeg dette er en toer. Men jeg hyller faktisk ikke Metallica for selvsikkerheten sin da de valgte å spille for det meste låter ingen egentlig liker. Og for at det skal finnes rettferdighet for de som har fått minste uttelling for mildere forbrytelser, så blir det dessverre én altså. For dette var langt og sjeldent bra.

Det føltes som en evighet, så sjekka jeg hvor langt jeg hadde kommet. Ikke halvveis i første disk engang. Måtte ta med meg lytteøkta på bussen hjem, ble selvbevisst og håpet at ingen hørte hva jeg hørte på. Hetfield høres ut som han er på autotune hele veien, det er helt jævlig. Orkesteret og bandet høres ut som de er på to helt ulike innspillinger. Ikke et vellykket sjangermøte. Høydepunktet var Ennio Morricone. Plata minte meg på hvorfor jeg er Megadeth-fan istedet

Live albums are a mixed bag for me. I appreciate the classics like Johnny Cash at Folsom Prison and Nirvana Unplugged, mainly because they add something extra to the classic hits we loved. Well, its hard to give something a new layer quite like classic orchestra to thrash metal. I will say, I really liked Wolf and man rendition and it was cool seeing the extra layer of sound to the song. I think its hard to really be too harsh on this album because its not a super serious album, its moreso just a cool crossover of sounds. And all things considered. I enjoyed it. But I wont unleash all the stars for this in my rating. However, its important to remember, music is supposed to be fun and entertaining, and this was a very intriguing listen. 3/5

Listens: 1.5 Standout Tracks: Master of Puppets, The Thing That Should Not Be, Enter Sandman, Battery 2 hours is a lot, but I can't really get too mad at a 2 hour live album. Imagine going to see any band live and they play a 37-45 minute set. And then this has the additional added benefit of being paired with the San Francisco Symphony Orchestra. That's pretty damn cool and really elevates the music in my opinion.

good songs, don’t like it live

This rips. Flat out. Not much more than that. The symphony is an unbelievable addition. I’m sure there are other bands a symphony would pair well with. But adding the cinematic flourish to an already massive sound is just incredible. Listen to this.

this was lowkey fun w/ the orchestra

I love this album. I've never really listened to Metallica - always seemed too head banging for me and it's likely that thier albums would be but the combination of their music with the softening of the orchestra is crazy good. 4.5