Loved this. Ship me off to another galaxy, I’m ready 🌌🪐

Master lyricist Fun fact, “This Is Hell” is used when Gilmore Girls’ (most important??) character Jess Mariano is first introduced in the series 😂 “Still Too Soon To Know” is a heartbreaking song, so is “All the Rage” in its own way (“Don’t try to touch my heart, it’s darker than you think” 👽)

I just…don’t care

Have listened to this a million and a half times and it never gets old. Wish I had done a proper active listen this time through since it’s been a while

No notes 💯💯🔥🔥

More like 4.5 but this is so fun so here we are

Just really holds up. The perfect length at 34 minutes - it could have so easily been overwrought and drawn out but it isn’t

Good if you’re frantically cleaning your home, at a 90s rave, coding, or a 90s teen romcom soundtrack…and not much else

Pretty sure this would have been a case of “way more fun live” at the time it was released, but sadly I’ll never know Also way more into the back half of this record

More like a 3.5, solidly middle of the road - only here for the hits to accompany a drive down the shore lol

Straight up not having a good time

Realizing how much respect I have for Led Zeppelin being precious about their licensing while listening to this 😂 Sweet Emotion is the only bright spot

Justice for half stars, this one is a 4.5 for me

Very fun! Not likely something I would return to repeatedly though

Peace Sells 🔥 Really enjoyed this! I know very little about Megadath but their influence on sum41 is really evident

Painful, quite frankly

Simon without Garfunkel just isn’t my thing; Duncan is the one redeeming track for me (I’ve always found Me and Julio completely insufferable and this listen didn’t change that 😂)

I appreciate the absurdism but this wasn’t really for me

Not memorable. Wasn’t as into this as I was Peace Sells…but also wasn’t in the mood for this vibe today so that could be part of it 😂

Was going to say no notes, 10/10, an all-time favorite (although not my favorite NY solo effort), but instead: 1. Hilary, shoutout number 2 in like less than a week to Mr. Kessler and 7th grade language arts class (will explain this more in the group chat tomorrow) 2. Extremely eerie to listen to this record today specifically (looking at you, Southern Man and Don’t Let It Bring You Down) 3. Damn does NY know how to write about love and heartbreak or what 4. Listened two times in a row because how could I not 😍 alright, Brett out

Not particularly memorable. Decidedly not music for the masses (ba dum tss) Giving this a 3 instead of a 2 because I like “Never Let Me Down Again” and the funky music theory of “Pimpf”

Pour toi, Hilary : C’est un groupe assez cool, j’en profite pour écouter quand je suis au boulot, mais pas beaucoup plus. Je ne sais pas si c’est un compliment ou pas, désolée Air 🙃 Comme j’ai dit dans le group chat, c’est pas mon album préféré - je préfère la bande originale de Virgin Suicides

Meditative - I listened to this as I was falling asleep so I don’t feel like I can give it a fair rating, but I’d say somewhere between 3ish and 4ish

Perfect from start to finish. As I said in the group chat, a gorgeous listening experience 🌑

Enjoyed this

Made me feel like I was 15 and ready for a show at Maxwell’s; i.e., really enjoyed this! Muuuuuch prefer it to the stuff that came after (thinking mostly the singles off the 2008 record), which I’ve always found extremely annoying. Also feel like the music supervisor for The Hills licensed the crap out of this 😂

Love Willie 🥰 such a lovely record

🔥

I liked this a lot in college, but I’m not in college anymore 😂 Ball and Chain still rips though This is another case of .5 for me, would rather rate 3.5 but going 3 because I’m not feeling generous today

Nothing memorable for me here although I appreciate it for what it is

Was expecting to really enjoy this and instead found it tedious

Loved this. Ship me off to another galaxy, I’m ready 🌌🪐

Unsurprisingly way better on a second listen with headphones but the cheesy corn is still getting to me

Straight mid. Love “I’m A Man” and “Does Anybody Really Know What Time It Is?” (s/o NJ 101.5 as mentioned 😂) but unlikely to be something I revisit regularly

Beatlemania for life, baby The only reason this doesn’t get five stars is because it was an executive mistake to have them record so many covers

Dropped off in the middle for me but overall I’m here for it because of the little bits and pieces of beautiful instrumentation - “layered and hidden at the same time” is what kept going through my head as I listened Also big Oasis vibes on “Melody Calls” and generally a lot of late-stage Beatles influences And last but not least I really enjoyed feeling like I was back at NYU in 2006 walking to and from class listening to “Catch the Sun” (Why am I giving Doves so much attention when this is like a 3.5 for me?)

Listened to this too early in the day to be able to appreciate it much but I did like “The Rage”

Loved this, more please

Make it stop

Justice for half stars!

So goofy and fun, will definitely revisit

The back half negated the front

Meh

Sign me up for more

As I said already, my flavor of weird

This is where I’d appreciate half stars again - it really starts to rip from “Come Out and Play” on

Listened to this passively so I don’t think I can give a fair rating but it’s obviously beautiful

Not my favorite from these guys but “I’m So Bored With the USA” is a whole thesis statement

Started off strong (love love “Keep On Movin’”, very motivating way to start my morning) but really lost steam as it went on with the exception of “Back to Life” - probably not something I’ll return to. Also very clear how much Jungle was influenced by this

3 for Buzzin Fly

Zero notes (pun intended)

This is a 4.5 for me, justice for half stars etc, but I love Queen Harry too much to round down here

Ugh

Nothing memorable here for me

So Radiohead coded! I found I’m way too familiar with this record to listen to it with fresh ears, but very interesting to see how the end of “Everything’s Not Lost” foreshadowed their sound from their later career. “Trouble” into “Parachutes” is also clutch. We were all always playing “Trouble” on the piano in the common room of my high school lol Tbh can’t wait for A Rush of Blood to the Head which will surely be on this list!

Liked this more than the other Tim Buckley but didn’t listen super closely tbh (“Once I Was” is really nice though as I mentioned in the chat! 🥺)

Master lyricist Fun fact, “This Is Hell” is used when Gilmore Girls’ (most important??) character Jess Mariano is first introduced in the series 😂 “Still Too Soon To Know” is a heartbreaking song, so is “All the Rage” in its own way (“Don’t try to touch my heart, it’s darker than you think” 👽)

Pleasant

Pure feel good even with the heartbreaker “Somebody Loves Me” Torn between 4 and 5 here

Another tossup between 4 and 5 for me, and for shame, I do prefer Carole King’s version of “(You Make Me Feel Like) A Natural Woman” because I have a soft spot for songwriters getting to perform their own work. Also really made me look forward to whenever Tapestry will show up on this list

Brash and sexy, bring on the noise

I feel foolish for not knowing how Joy Division-coded Interpol is until listening to this I have to be in a verrryyyy specific kind of mood for this but I do really enjoy it (“Disorder”!!)

Just fine

I just…don’t care

Really conscious of the misogyny/machismo of the lyrics in this in a way I wasn’t when I was younger 🫣

Bedbugs ARE scary!

As discussed, couldn’t separate art from the artist on this one :( would give a 1.5 lyrically but 3-4 for production and I’m feeling generous this morning so I’ll go with 3 overall

It’s a stone cold 5 for me, even with how much I loathe “The Girl Is Mine”

Sexy as hell, no notes

Nice but probably not something I’ll revisit. The music supervisor for Grey’s Anatomy probably would have gone bananas over this record

Begrudgingly liked this a lot more than I thought I would

I just don’t care enough sorryyyyy

You all already know my thoughts in detail about this

Keep your electric eye on me, baby - one million fives out of five

This dropped off toward the end for me which is the only reason I’m giving a 4 instead of a 5, really loved the energy here

Nah

Boring and unoriginal. I’ve always found “hard to handle” extremely annoying. The more I listened the less tolerable I found this hence the 1

Not quite a 5 for me but close

I see what this is but it’s not really for me

“The O-Men” into “Kuntz” is a whole thing, let alone the final track 😨

This is another case of between 3 and 4 for me

I loved this! So fun, would definitely revisit. “Ain’t That A Shame” was a surprise, I didn’t look at the track list as I listened

Another one with Scorpio Energy, proper noun, but not necessarily my favorite

In the end…meh. Hilary got it: it’s aggressively fine

Nothing here is memorable to me among these jammy jams…got to the point where I was straight up annoyed by the noodling/posturing and didn’t want to finish, hence the 1. Sorry, Janis 🤷🏼‍♀️

Straight mid

“Bigmouth Strikes Again” is good, “Some Girls Are Bigger Than Others” and “Franky Mr Shankly” are grating

I want to listen to this again many more times and then write a dissertation on it

Way too long and he’s 👎🏻👎🏻👎🏻 but still gets a 3 from me for “New York, New York” and a few other nice moments throughout 😬

I wanted to like this more but I was definitely not in the right mood for it, although the fish cakes song made me laugh. Their influence on Interpol and Franz Ferdinand is really evident

4.5 if I could!

Made me lol multiple times, ultimate fuckboy record

Wanted to knock this down to 3 for a few reasons but it’s undeniably excellent, so here we are

The one-two punch of Longview and Welcome to Paradise rips

I know “The Loser In The End” is controversial because it interrupts the black/white May/Mercury concept but I love it. This one would get a 4.5 from me if I could. It’s not absolutely perfect but it nearly gets there, and it’s super fun to listen to knowing where their journey took them after this

Straight mid for me

Too much content about heartbreak 😭 something I need to be in a very specific headspace to listen to/revisit because a lot of it is tough to listen to

Abby put it perfectly - this record is interminable, BUT it’s also excellent and I don’t have eloquent words for how much I enjoy it beyond that it gets my Paul Hollywood handshake of a 5

Another example of the environment where I listened impacting my vote 😂👙⛱️

Clutch. The spoken monologues are all excellent and aged really well - the only reason this doesn’t get a 5 from me is because “Pussycat” didn’t age super well 🫠

Enjoyed this more expected! Musically more often than lyrically - one or two big duds didn’t mean this was terrible on the whole

Larry’s description put it best

Reliable Willie!

Aggressively fine