Sep 08 2025
5
Was thinking the other day that maybe I should have added Sunbather as my pick instead, so first off thanks for adding this album and righting my wrongs.
It seems a logical combination - take the thrashing instrumentals of metal and combine it with the reverb-drenched guitars of Shoegaze. Somehow, this was the first LP to execute on that premise and deliver ‘blackgaze’ to a degree that I don’t think has been matched since, even by Deafheaven on their later releases.
Every element of this album is tuned to fucking perfection. The production is air-tight, allowing the instrumentals to claim what seems like infinite space. And claim they do – the drumming is surgical but raw, the bass absolutely pounding, and the guitar lines expand until you’re enveloped in beautiful, pummeling melody. Clarke’s gnashing vocals will turn off the prudes on this project, but you can’t deny they seem to emanate right out of the sonic wall of midrange that erupts out of each track.
It’s perfect order that sounds like absolute chaos, each of the main tracks a colossus that feels at once towering but fluid and agile. The LP’s composition only heightens its sense of scale, the contemplative interludes allowing a bit of breathing room before your head is forced back underneath the waves. What makes Sunbather truly revolutionary to me, however, is its unshakeable melodic grip. Metal is known for the minor-key, doom and gloom chugging that gets heads banging and mosh pits roiling, but the second ‘Dream House’ springs to life it’s clear this is no fugue. I’ve yet to find a track that matches the absolute triumph, power, and joy that’s invoked on the opener, which still feels like a breath of fresh air even a decade on. The rest of the album dips into darker territory (this is Deafheaven, after all), but even at its darkest the chords still ring out clearly and there’s a complete sense of musicality, not just distortion. Look past the gut reaction to the screaming, and you’ll find absolutely beautiful progressions and genuinely incredible artistic statements at the core of this album. I venture folks here will chafe at the interludes, but even the one with drill noise has some incredible piano going in the background.
The more I listen to this album (which is frequently – ‘Dream House’ is a go-to driving/workout/fuck yeah kind of song), the more I’m certain this is one of the most important releases of the 2010s. Rarely does an album transcend its genre-trappings, but Sunbather does so in such extravagant fashion to sound at once orchestral and refined while being an insanely fucking raw metal LP at heart. This album absolutely deserves to be on the official 1001 and has already made it onto the Rolling Stone and NME Top 500 album lists, so again a massive thanks for getting it included here.
👍
Sep 04 2025
1
I sure am deaf now
1
👍
Sep 07 2025
5
The album wouldn't have you guessing this is such a heavy album. It goes all over the place with the heaviness and the pace, but it just all fits.
Loved it
👍
Sep 29 2025
5
Wholesome album about bathing in the sun! Summer vibes and fun for the whole family! 5/5!
👍
Sep 13 2025
4
Great metalgaze album with dark atmospheric soundscapes. Sounds like Sigur Rós, Mogwai and Godspeed You! Black Emperor, but more in a metal format.
👍
Sep 15 2025
4
Crazy that this is 12 years old now. I've never really though too much of the -gaze suffix of blackgaze, since it mostly boils down to heavy reverb instead of the effects soup that goes into true shoegaze band. It does create an atmosphere though!
👍
Sep 08 2025
4
I listened to their latest album earlier this year. Got a lot of great reviews. I heard it, I understood the importance, I got why people enjoyed it, but I did not like it. I feel the same for this album of theirs. Once again, I respect the whole of it, but it just isn’t my thing. I wish I could enjoy this. Glad that so many do. 4/5
👍
Sep 10 2025
4
Soundscapes rather than songs, with barely any vocals, but all the more evocative and atmospheric as a result.
👍
Sep 03 2025
3
These guys copped a lot of heat when this came out for not being "true metal" or whatever. Maybe it was because the cover art looks like it's going to be a pop album? Who knows. I think it was also decided that their fanbase was mostly hipsters, not guys in BATTLE JACKETS. Either way it's just mildly boring and tends to drag on in that way anything inspired by post-rock does. 3/5.
👍
Sep 10 2025
2
This was a little polarizing of an album to me. I thoroughly enjoyed the guitar work and instrumentals as a whole. Very dreamy, laid back yet forceful. Then the limited “singing” occurred which was just screaming unintelligible sounds. If this was merely an instrumental album I would rate it higher than what I just listened to. 5.2/10
👍
Oct 13 2025
1
Nothing evokes the serenity of basking in the warmth of our sun quite like being screamed at for an entire hour.
👍
Sep 03 2025
3
Little too much screaming but I liked the big sounding instrumentals. Probably won’t listen to them again though.
👍
Sep 05 2025
3
A bit screamier than I usually like, parts of this were still interesting to me. Not my cup of tea but I didn’t loathe it.
👍
Sep 08 2025
3
Rating: 6/10
Best songs: Irresistible
👍
Sep 10 2025
3
Cold
👍
Sep 12 2025
3
Absolutely loved Vertigo
👍
Sep 14 2025
3
Not sure about the "blackgaze" thing, sure it has quieter melodic interludes, but so does Metallica. Anyway this stuff always falls apart for me on the shrieky vocals, I just don't like it. It renders lyrics meaningless, making the vocals just a type of instrument, and one I don't care for the sound of. Which is a shame since for the most part I liked it musically.
👍
Sep 16 2025
3
An interesting experiment of mixing metal with the sort of ethereal soundscapes of (cribbing from another reviewer here) Sigur Rós.
Mostly successful!
👍
Sep 02 2025
2
I gave this a full week before listening again as I had a headache and wasn’t in the right frame of mind last week, coming back to this fresh I can feel my headache coming back.
👍
Sep 04 2025
2
What the hell man? 50 minutes of unintelligible screaming?
👍
Sep 18 2025
2
Music was ok. The screeching not so much
👍
Sep 22 2025
2
That's too bad. I really like the guitars on Deafheaven's "Sunbather." But I really don't care for screaming as the sole vocals. All the bits without the screaming are quite good and would be a high 4 stars without the rest.
👍
Oct 14 2025
2
Just, why?
Fascinates me how some music appeals to people.
👍
Sep 07 2025
1
Blackgaze, post-metal, atmospheric black metal. ¿Por qué grita sin sentido? Si fuese sólo instrumental, estaba hasta bien... Así, un 1.
👍
Sep 15 2025
1
Jag brukar försöka lyssna med ett öppet sinne men det går inte. Det är ett hemskt album.
👍
Sep 16 2025
1
The kind of Metal that I don’t need in my life and very quickly had to move on from
👍