Album Summary
Either/Or is the third studio album by American singer-songwriter Elliott Smith. Either/Or was recorded in several locations, mostly in Portland, Oregon – while Smith was still a member of Heatmiser – and was produced by Smith, Tom Rothrock and Rob Schnapf. Either/Or was released on February 25, 1997, on the Kill Rock Stars record label, following Heatmiser's dissolution. Book-ended by its two singles, "Speed Trials" and "Ballad of Big Nothing", Either/Or did not chart in the US, but was acclaimed by critics. Director Gus Van Sant was highly impressed with the album, incorporating three of its songs; "Between the Bars", "Angeles" and "Say Yes" along with a new song, "Miss Misery", into the Good Will Hunting soundtrack. "Miss Misery" was nominated for Best Original Song at the 1998 Academy Awards, and was performed at the televised ceremony in an abridged version by Smith, backed by the house orchestra, briefly propelling him into the international spotlight. In 2020, the album was ranked at 216 on Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Albums of All Time list.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Whispery and angsty.
Good music to fall asleep to if the goal is dreams about what a better place the world would be without you in it.
Whisper singing will just never be my thing. I liked this more than several other things I’ve given 2’s, but not enough to give it a 3.
Suuuper boring to me. Sounded like just some random guys whole jam session by himself. Found his voice to be whiny. Definetly not a fan.
It was ok. One or two highlights but overall fairly pedestrian.
This album was far too consistently melancholy for my taste, I know he’s known for that but would one happy song be that hard?
Νice ballads that did not knock me off
Don’t know how many times this challenge is going to make me reference my SAD, but here’s one more.
Most of the songs sounded the same to me.
Elliott Smith was the quintessential 90s indie singer-songwriter, and this album is the one that everyone who drives in that lane try to release. Downcast yet hopeful, its focus on his life in Portland after a trying childhood. His background in philosophy is present in the lyrics, specifically angst and despair. The fact that he played all the instruments on this album is certainly notable.
Very whiny and boring
I didn’t think I would enjoy the album based on his voice but as it went on I realised his voice is actually quite beautiful, I added a lot of songs to my playlist
Might be his most consistent album. First half is better than the second, even though Say Yes is one of his best
boring
At some point in the past I liked this stuff. But it feels like a napkin blowing through an empty weed-strewn parking lot and then it's gone.
good will hunting!
Sweet, delicate melodies that do not mask the turmoil underneath
absolutely beautiful
I’ve heard positive reviews about the artist, I am satisfied myself. Favourite Tracks: “Pictures of Me”, “Rose Parade”, “Speed Trials”.
I wasn't a fan of the last Elliott Smith album I got but did find bits of it okay (Son of Sam was quite catchy). But this one I got no enjoyment from whatsoever. Was all the parts of Figure 8 I didn't like and none of the bits that were okay. Just too dour for me, got no enjoyment from it unfortunately.
This did very little for me but wasn't actively unpleasant.
Found out I only like songs from other albums of his
This album puts me in mind of a challenge you could do, with any given album. Take an album you've never heard of, and grab your handy-dandy globe and century-long calendar (I know you've got them to hand, surely, you're holding back on me). When you finish the album, point to where on the globe and when in time you think the album was released. This is, obviously, a stupid challenge that offers very little reward. The last thing I am suggesting by typing this all out is that you should do it. I bring it up because, I think if somebody actually did this, they'd get this album bang on. This, to me, is an album recorded and released in the shadow of Nirvana and how that dominated the Pacific Northwest sound. It is a cultural moment that has faded. The music holds up, but it is of an era. I am not saying this is a bad album, I do not believe it is, but I do believe if everything about this album was the same but it released 5 to 10 years later than it did, it would not have found its way onto this list. It would have missed the bus. I find it very hard to see eye-to-eye with the critics on these sorts of albums, because their reviews and mine are forged in very different fires. Elliott Smith is an artist I have never heard of popular in an era I wasn't present for, with a legacy stretching out of that moment. I don't think he is essential listening for my money. He is not bad to be sure; his music is chill and calming, the album isn't demanding and is short enough where I could probably go again right now, it washes over you and, at least for me, doesn't leave too much behind. Well constructed and well received at the time, but not for me and not for today.
Marko - 3 Sara - 3.5
It was pretty much what I expected, melancholy solo guitar with whispery singing. I was worried his vocals would be grating after a whole album, but it was fine. Most of the album just kinda flowed by without any songs standing out (except Say Yes, which I already loved), but I get the feeling I'll enjoy it more when I relisten... I'll find out the next time I'm feeling moody.
Feels like an acoustic version of a previous album or something, all the songs sound alike. Not a fan.
One of my favourite albums, excited to re listen
The voice is as thin and whispery as anything Taylor Swift ever set to vinyl, making it somewhat of an acquired taste. That said, this album is not without its low-key charms. Favorite track: I liked the imagery of “The Rose Parade”.
Boooooringggg
I mean it's not an earth shattering discovery but it is a nice album, I can understand why I wouldn't have bothered too much with in the day but it is a good 'singer-songwriter' listen now, ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Not my favorite of his. Say yes is great but the rest is too quiet for me idk if it’s the mix or his whisper singing but it’s all too same-y.
This is great. Based on his reputation I thought it would be a sad dude with a guitar moping around. There was some of that which is why it's not higher but I wouldn't even say its a majority. Great songwriting and catchier in places than I expected. Also you can very easily see the influence he had on Phoebe Bridgers
Sung by Smith in a near-hush most of the time, the performances on these songs are so restrained that the emotional impact of these tracks is essentially neutralized.
Understated, good songwriting. I’ll have to come back to it because it’s kinda subtle. I enjoyed the eclecticism of Figure 8 more. But the sound and songs are great.
Best Track - "Pictures of Me"
Not impressed. Must have done a few ludes before sitting down to put this album together.
Meh
Iets meer middelmaat dan X/O
A serviceable indie pop rock album. It was fine I guess, nothing really blew me away, but a couple of the songs were catchy. 3/5, nothing I would come back to on purpose, but wouldn't turn it off if someone threw the album on either.
Sounded ok, but forgot it was on tbh
7.5 A nice collection of mostly sad songs, but theres a warmth in here. Highlights: Between the Bars Pictures of Me Cupids Trick Alameda Speed Trials
Dull
This album is really surprising, and one that, at the end, unfolds to be better than what it may seem at the beginning. But, first of all, and as much as I love a good acoustic album, as an acoustic record, it has the mistake of being too insipid at certain moments. It just tends to be mellow, warm, pleasant, sometimes to the extent it does not transmit anything or has nothing actually interesting to offer. But, it has something interesting though. It has some great, beautiful melodies and really good songwriting. Some instrumentals are wonderful, and it really flows so well. If it were not because of some melodies, the album would be unremarkable, bland and even bad. But it combines perfectly all its elements, and, although it fails in some songs to really get to something good, most of the songs are pretty good. And the whole project is pretty bold and enjoyable, with some interesting switches to more energetic tracks. It has a little bit of everything an acoustic album can offer (even though it is not acoustic all the time, or even purely acoustic as there are some other instruments and arrangements that escape what could be considered actually acoustic), and it really feels like an immersive experience. So, at the end, it really wraps everything sweetly.
I thought this would be some charming indie but it was more like some dude whisper singing with his guitar and it got boring quickly
favs: angeles rating 0.4/5
Interesting I guess but I have no idea why this might be considered to be in this list.
Good start to the week! Not an album to get the blood pumping, but chilled and delicate. Favourite track: Say Yes
First listened on 22nd and 23rd February 2025. Favourite song is Speed Trials.
Very melodic acoustic guitar with soft vocals, cosing the ears and giving a warm feeling.
Ok
I think if I were listening to this at home in a focused headspace I'd feel the lyrics and atmosphere and rate this higher. But alas, while trying to work and filter out distracting noise, this is not getting me going one bit.
Tonia is a big Elliot Smith fan, so I've gone to great lengths to like his music. I've listened to a few of his albums multiple times. I got high and did a candle-lit deep listening session with his self titled album. I even watched the documentary. I think the genius of Elliot Smith is lost on me not because he lacks talent, but because we just have something very different in our life experiences. I can tell his lyrics are poetry, but I've never had a line jump out at me. I can tell he's doing something totally unique with his sound and with the production, but it just doesn't resonate with me. The hazy, lo-fi tint on everything is cool, but to me, it makes his work all sound kinda beige and homogenous. One thing I'll say to his credit - it's the kind of music that can be great for a particular moment in time. For example, "Needle in the Hay," is the perfect song for the cutting scene in Royal Tenenbaums. But outside its place in a movie soundtrack, it just isn't my cup of tea.
Somehow this album is musically more interesting yet overall a much more boring version of the band Fountains of Wayne. I hear the brilliance, the song writing is immaculate, but the meekness of his voice loses my attention. Giving it 3 stars 6.7 out of 10.
This album is exactly why I find this project so rewarding. Going in, I had a neutral impression of Elliott Smith at best, and a negative one at worst. I’d always associated him with whiny, depressing, tortured, emo-adjacent music. My only real familiarity with his work was “Needle in the Hay,” which features in one of the greatest needle drops in movie history in The Royal Tenenbaums. I love that scene and that song, but I never had much interest in exploring the rest of his catalog. Well, consider me completely converted, because this album absolutely blew my socks off. What surprised me most is just how brilliant a pop songwriter Elliott Smith was. I’m hearing influences from all over the place, particularly Big Star and the Replacements, with these perfectly crafted little power-pop songs full of irresistible melodies and hooks. “Ballad of Big Nothing” might be my favorite track on the album, and it’s probably the clearest example of that Big Star influence. But there’s also this fascinating spectrum between Kurt Cobain and Fountains of Wayne that runs throughout the record. “Pictures of Me,” in particular, sounds like quintessential mid-‘90s alternative pop-rock. I hear early Fountains of Wayne, Harvey Danger, even a little Oasis. I’m sure Elliott Smith would hate some of those comparisons, but I mean every one of them as a compliment. And then there’s the influence in the other direction. I can hear so much of the indie rock that would emerge 10 or 15 years later in these songs, particularly bands like Yuck and Foxygen. Built to Spill comes to mind as well, although they were contemporaries rather than successors. There’s this wonderful combination of ragged, sometimes fuzzy guitar sounds and meticulously constructed melodies that connects all of these artists. The songs feel intimate, loose and almost effortless, but underneath that simplicity is some genuinely sophisticated songwriting. They’re just incredibly catchy little earworms. Of course, the Elliott Smith I’d imagined before hearing this record is here too. “Between the Bars” is much closer to that fragile, melancholy singer-songwriter reputation, but what a gorgeous song. It’s one of those rare pieces of music that seems to hit some secret emotional button in your body and can practically reduce you to tears. “Landslide” by Fleetwood Mac has that same effect on me, as does “Needle in the Hay.” It’s difficult to articulate exactly why. Something about the melody, the vulnerability of the performance, and the way it all comes together just reaches right into you. It’s devastatingly beautiful. What makes Either/Or so impressive is how effortlessly Smith moves between those two worlds. On one hand, you’ve got these infectious, almost joyous-sounding pop melodies, and on the other, this tremendous emotional weight. Sometimes they’re both present in the same song. And none of it feels forced or inconsistent. I came into this expecting a collection of sad, whispery acoustic songs and instead discovered a record that draws together so many of the things I love about guitar-driven music. I enjoyed this album so much that when it ended, I immediately played the whole thing again. Back to back. That’s about as strong an endorsement as I can give. This is absolutely a record I’ll be returning to, probably many times. What a fantastic surprise, and what an extraordinary songwriter. I couldn’t have been more wrong about Elliott Smith. 8.2/10
This might be a time of my life sort of thing but usually I am quite a fan of albums so forthcoming with their melancholy but this album was sort of uninteresting. The songs that were different in tone ended up being my preferred choices. It might be that my preferred presentation of sad songs has adjusted over the past few years, and that this album was really transformative almost 20 years ago and I've heard too much of what it does in other places to properly appreciate but for me this is well written but just not my flavour right now. Best song(s): Ballad of Big Nothing, Cupid's Trick Worst Song(s): N/A Rank compared to everything else so far: 52/81 (above Back to Mystery City, below Foo Fighters)
Ein Album zum Tagträumen, aber dabei träumt man sich auch bisschen weg von der Musik. Wenige ups and downs bei dem Album, aber ansonsten fine. Gesang war eher mid.
incredible chill
A folky indie listen. The first song had a darker feel to it but then the following tracks kind of picked up the pace. A couple also gave me some sufjan stevens vibes. It’s a moody album, wasn’t surprised that some of the sings were part of the sountrack of a movie.
I know Elliot Smith well. He is a singer-songwriter. This album is very good. Elliot Smith is a great songwriter. He is full of existential angst. His vocals are good. His song have an acoustic guitar sometimes with musical accompaniment. Some of the songs on the album are outstanding: pictures of me, 2:45, say yes and rose parade. In particular, rose parade is a gem. All the songs on the album are good. This is a great album. Five stars
Fragile beauty, perfection.
Yet again, I find myself surprised at how much I enjoyed listening to Elliot Smith. Raw, and lyrically devastating. He’s not an artist I’m going to actively seek out, but I’m glad this project has given me a chance to listen to his music.
My biggest revelation during this project has been Elliot Smith. Figure 8 remains the only album I regretted giving a 4 to and a few days later upgraded to a 5. In fact it's the only album (at around 50% complete) I have remarked at all. His voice is lovely - it's such a mix of indie rocker and so fragile you think he might breakdown in tears at any minute. The music is beautiful. The lyrics are gorgeous but frequently heartbreaking. Lyrically, I particularly enjoyed the chorus to Alameda ("For your own protection over their affection nobody broke your heart, you broke your own 'cause you can't finish what you start") and all of 2:45AM which is just painfully sad. He was such a great lyricist. I'm not going to make the same mistake as last time, given that I listened to this, then immediately listened to it again (and then had another run through of the, intermittently Beatlesy, Pictures Of Me). 5/5
He's so strange and sad. Very good album tho would recommend
Sad boy music and not in a good way
Good Will Hunting !?
It's a pretty standard idie-folk singer/songwriter album. It's got some acoustic ballad stuff and a couple of full band almost folk-rock stuff. It's not bad, but I'm not sold that it's a "must hear" record. It's alright, not great.
Ok
No thanks
I don't have a whole lot to say about this one. It's not my vibe at all, but I do applaud his skill as a songwriter. The lyrics are amazing as poetry, but the music and his vocal style kills the presentation for me.
I couldnt end it...
Insightful, wonderful, great, amazing. Added two songs to different playlists. I adored this album.
the subdued section of music that includes hushed lyrics, simple production, and depressing lyrics rarely ever engage me. this album only perpetuates that feeling in me. the one song that I actually added to my playlist was one that consisted of a livelier sound that felt far fuller than the rest of the tracks. Notable Tracks: - Ballad of Big Nothing
I don't have anything bad to say about Elliott Smith. This album has a nice vibe. It's just not something I'm going to put on very often
I had heard the Figure 8 album by Elliott Smith as that came up earlier in this exercise, but was not previously familiar with this album. This is an Indie Rock album. It's pretty lowkey: the vocals are prominent and the instrumentation is understated. The songs are pretty good and he has a great voice. I would listen again.
I love the lyrics, and the simplicity of the music. I do think the style of instrumentation helps with the vulnerability this album has, but melodically it doesn't really resonate with me
Chill folk
I'm a lyrics person so I very much enjoyed this album. Carefully & well thought out words, which I appreciate. You can tell he was still very raw in his approach and there were times where I wish he gave us more with the production and his voice - the albums was sometims hard to follow. Highlights: Between The Bars, No Name No. 5
Quite liked it!
Interesting.
Soundmässigt behagligt att lyssna på. Låtmaterialet var bra men inget som faller mig i smaken bortsett från sista låten på skivan. Mysigt att ha på i bakgrunden! Åker sannolikt in på iPoden trots en trea i betyg, bra album att ha på i bakgrunden vid jobb eller bara allmänt chill.
It hurts to listen to Elliott Smith but there is loss in avoiding such beautiful music because of the pain it causes. Art connects us with our feelings and his tragic loss only makes Either/Or that much more poignant. This is a solid, gorgeous set of songs and now it is haunting too.
boring
it was raining while I played this, pretty fitting. Very acoustic, mellow, sad
It took me most of my adult life to date, but Elliott Smith is becoming one of my favorite songwriters if the '90s. His music is gorgeous, fragile, and often, *extremely* sad. Elliott smith has, in my opinion, written a solid few of what I seriously think may be the saddest songs of all time (King's Crossing anyone), but even outside of these songs, there is something magical about Elliott Smith's music's sadness, where it can genuinely put you in a bad place if you let it. And you may think this is a crazy thing to appreciate in a songwriter, but you have to respect how hard that is. It speaks to some kind of rock solid, deeply honest emotional core at the heart of his music. Regardless, Elliott Smith is also one of the vanishingly few artists I regularly listen to for whom I'm more of a song listener than an album listener. So I was a little surprised when I spun this and it was just wall to wall Elliott Smith classics. The hit rate here is staggering, the majority of songs on this thing could be an essential piece of a film soundtrack, and *many* of them are. Speed Trials, Alameda, Ballad Of Big Nothing, Between The Bars, No Name no. 5, Angeles, 2:45, and Say Yes are all classics, and basically perfect Elliott Smith songs. I was kind of staggered by this line-up, it's *crazy*. At this point you can probably have guessed, but I'm giving this a 5.
Bit bland but listenable
This is so bland and forgettable I'm not even sure I've listened to it. The audio equivalent of tofu.
Pretty depressing but in a nice way
Fine tekster, kan se for meg å nyte dette på en rolig søndag
Lowkey hushed.
Perfect. Don’t listen to after a recent break up.
I like the idea of Elliot Smith more than the actual music. However, "No Name #3" from Roman Candle is one of my all-time most-listened-to songs.
He's an ez listening singer/songwriter to enjo on a Sunday morning. Nice smooth delivery of his songs.
My first time listening to a full album by Smith; I am very struck by a distinct soft flyover sound - the angst of youth discovering meaning. I can see why the lyrics connect with so many people. It's not what I would call "happy" music; no radio-friendly hits. The sound is however very intimate, with Smith playing every instrument. Rest in peace.
I instantly fell in love with Elliot's music when I heard it on Good Will Hunting on the late 90s. These were the days you'd hear a song in the middle of a movie, try to remember a lyric that you thought might be the title, and hope you remembered what it was in the closing credits so you could pause the tape or DVD to read the artist's name. Then you had to go to the record store and talk to the music nerd at the counter to see if he knew the album it was on. And this particular one, you just couldn't find. Fortunately a few years later, I got a good internet connection (for the time) and Napster? Limewire? Something like that. This music has been with me a long time. I just listened to two or three albums of his is in a row earlier this year. Anyway, I love his delicate vocal delivery, how well he conveys his soul and his thoughts, that he's a one man show, and...like literally everything about his music. There isn't a single thing I don't like or could suggest to improve. This is perfection. My inability to articulate how much and why I like this album is frustrating, but fortunately I don't have to do a good job on my review to be able to listen again. Thank you Elliot. I wish I could thank you for how much and how many times you have moved me over the years. ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
I found this dull as ditchwater. Not the kind of music I would have gone anywhere near back then, so certainly won't be doing so now.
Definitely some layers to dig deeper into on this album.
I didn't like this album. Maybe it would grow on me, but the first listen brought nothing.
I listened to this one on repeat. And it got better each time. What a great discovery! Favorite track: Speed Trials
Another Elliott Smith, I did like hos other album, though this one is too slow
I've somewhat avoided Elliot Smith for most of my adult life, which is odd, because I do listen to and greatly enjoy a lot of artists and music he had a clear influence on, but a couple really insufferable people in my personal life have listed Elliot Smith as their favorite artist, so it's mainly been spite avoidance. That being said, I can totally understand why someone who first listed to this as a teenager in the 90s might develop a bit of an obsession. But for me this is a decent album that has a tendency to get a bit repetitive. Most of the songs are just sad vocals with acoustic guitar softly strumming in the background, but I did enjoy when it goes a bit louder or adds more instruments. Standouts were "Between the Bars" "Rose Parade" "Cupid's Trick" and "Say Yes"