Album Summary
Hot Buttered Soul is the second studio album by American soul musician Isaac Hayes. Released in 1969, it is recognized as a landmark in soul music. Recorded with The Bar-Kays, the album features four lengthy tracks, including a 12-minute version of the Burt Bacharach/Hal David cover "Walk On By" and an almost 19-minute long version of Jimmy Webb's "By the Time I Get to Phoenix"; both songs were edited significantly and released as a double A-side single in July 1969.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Super cool album, Hayes and the Bar Kays indulge themselves in extended jams over these four pieces. Really enjoyable.
such a perfect album except the horrible aberration that is all 18 minutes of “by the time i get to phoenix”
Was heading for a 4 based on first three tracks, last one pulls it down to overall 3.
From the the ashes of the 1968 Atlantic legal binfire - during which Stax lost the rights to all of their masters, including all of the Otis Redding back catalogue - Stax kickstarted the label by recording and issuing 27 albums at the same time. They needed content fast, and Isaac Hayes, who until that point had been a writer and producer, delivered... at some length: this wonderful record, made with Hayes' complete control could absolutely not have been made by committee. But the question is: how can one man make four tracks last an entire LP? Firstly, give him an orchestra and let him go wild with the arrangement. The lush orchestral funk arrangements have some unusual touches (particular shout out to the oboes), and feel more like four through-composed symphonic movements. It's in the style of other elongated funk jams like "The Ghetto" (Donny Hatthaway), "Papa Was a Rolling Stone" (Temptations), "Woman of the Ghetto" (Marlena Shaw), or the later Philly soul sound, which followed the same template: if the groove is good enough, an orchestra can fill up ten minutes easily. But in this case, the short-scale hamony of the original songs becomes architectural: he spends nearly nine minutes on the Amin7 first chord of "By The Time I Get To Phoenix", which shouldn't work, but it turns out, if you're Isaac Hayes, you can just hold an Am7 chord for nine minutes..and it just makes the resolution all the sweeter. Secondly, he lets the band jam out some wicked solos, like the fuzz guitar solo which kicks in before the "Walk On By" vocal has even started. Or the oddball, almost Reich-ian piano solo in "Hyperbolicsyllabicsesquedalymistic", over an understated but absolutely in the pocket Bar-Kays rhythm section. Thirdly, by reimagining the songs' narrative - in the case of "By The Time I Get To Phoenix", the song and its writer become part of the performance, with Hayes simply a vessel between the song and the audience. It's a brilliant trick, and one which owes a lot to another extended live musical form - the evangelical sermon: Hayes is the preacher here - "THE SPIRIT OF LOVE!". It's slightly at odds which the perception of this record as the first of the "baby maker" slow jam genre, later popularised by Barry White, but on this record it's not pervy. They're romantic tales, but they're devastatingly sad, on the whole. As the man himself says: "it's a deep tune"....and it's sublime.
Do you want to hear 4 songs spread across 45 minutes? Surprisingly yes yes do
If I'm being consistent I can't give this one a pass while I savaged Rush's 2112 a while back. Self-indulgent songs that either belabor the musical point, or never reach it, is an issue throughout. Soul Prog. It rambles, it drags, it whines, it moans. Sometimes total creative control can get you a Pet Sounds. Most often it gets you a record that needed someone to stand across from the musician and make the "Hurry it up," gesture. Would I add it to my modest record collection? No.
MASTERPIECE INCOMING🔥🔥🔥 Walk On By→10/10 Hyperbolicsyllabicsesquedalymistic→10/10 One Woman→10/10 By the Time I Get to Phoenix→10/10 best→Walk On By worst→By the Time I Get to Phoenix overrated→none underrated→One Woman overall→100/100 I was probably in another dimension for 45 minutes. I'm pretty sure I was studying though… The composition is so overwhelming it blows my mind. I can’t say it’s a no skip since there are a few parts that require a bit of patience but honestly, who cares? Everything else is delivered with incredible quality, and if you can’t stand those parts, just listen to the single cut. It’s available for streaming.
Four tracks, two of them epics, and it never feels long. Hayes takes pop songs like "Walk On By" and "By the Time I Get to Phoenix" and slow-cooks them over patient, hypnotic grooves, with the Bar-Kays locked in and his own keys and arrangements steering. The long spoken intro on "Phoenix" should be a problem for someone who usually shrugs at spoken word, but it works because the delivery is warm and intimate, and the band keeps simmering underneath it. "Hyperbolicsyllabicsesquedalymistic" is the funk workout and "One Woman" is the tender closer, so the record has real shape front to back. It's a record you cue up by choice, and it sits comfortably next to your other fives in soul and funk.
Final track almost half just talking! Whole thing for me just too long noodling around. Pretty boring in the main.
This was on for a 3 for a while, but the 9 minute spoken word intro on the fourth track dragged it down to a 2 as I don’t think I’d put it on again.
You cannot deny that Walk On By is an absolute banger with the violins followed by the funkiest beat with that distortion guitar. A song about a guy crying public should not go that hard. Just a sensitive guy with too much pride. The rest of the album (other three songs) is pretty good. Interesting setup for By The Time I Get To Phoenix.
Jeez there's a nearly 19-minute song on this album??? Omfl. Okay. I was gonna give it 2 stars cuz the long songs really aren't my cup of tea, but I'll give it 3 stars because the backstory in "By the Time I Get to Phoenix" is actually lowkey gorgeous. But that song is just WAY too long. But it's pretty. So 3 stars.
Funky psycedelic soul stuff
Incredible album, also did a deep dive on Isaac’s influence in hip hop which was cool to learn
5/10. Great voice. Great band. But these tracks really didn’t need to be that long.
Big quite bowl me over and the 8 minute open word intro was a touch trying
Lo volvería a escuchar, me encanta cuando el jazz blus se mezcla con el rock
Enjoyed the style more than I thought I would. Walk On By was the standout because I recognized right away it is featured in Doja Cat’s Paint the Town Red. lol
"hello children" 🧑🍳 it's not bad wasn't able to give it the shake it deserves i suspect it definitely has the soul vibes tho
Sounds like Shaft! Not a surprise when you learn that the music from Shaft was Isaac Hayes! Not for me, largely because it just makes me think I am watching Shaft...
Some great tracks on this, some others ramble on a bit.
Genre de rock/jazz. Assez consistent comme vibe. Clairement un album concept.
very very jazzy
Smooth and funky and Isaac’s version of Walk on By is superlative
Bro this is spiritual
Fire!!
This was excellent. Definitive soul - but with the explorative sensibility added. A very under-credited artist who deserves to be considered among the greatest ever.
очень приятный вайбик, реально душевно. ну только в последней песне можно было вырезать пиздеж на 9 минут в начале и сразу переходить к пению, было бы вообще супер.
This album was really great! The first two tracks were pretty cool and the last to were especially great in my opinion. They all have some great guitar, piano and vocals. I also spotted some organ/electric piano stuff at some parts which was pretty great. There’s a part of me that can appreciate the NINE MINUTES of speaking in the final track, By The Time I Get To Phoenix, but come on, do we really need that in the record? My opinion is no. That part aside though, the actual song is genuinely amazing and beautiful. Definitely my favourite of the record. Good job Mr. Hayes!
My first thought was "man these are some LONG songs for soul, but maybe they'll be worthy of their length." I did like the songs. There's some nice guitar on some of them, and Isaac Hayes' keys are great (especially the organ). The songwriting is pretty good, too, though 2 of the 4 songs are covers. The length of the songs did end up as my main complaint. It feels like they get through the actual song quite quickly, and then just keep jamming on one or two chords for 8 minutes. It's a little much for my liking. And that's without mentioning the 8-minute spoken-word intro to Hayes' cover of "By the Time I Get to Phoenix." It's a cool intro, but I imagine hearing it every time you want to listen to the album (or even just the song) is a lot. I'm not the BIGGEST fan of soul in general, but I thought this album was just alright. ----- #0044 Heard on: 11 Nov. 2026 Rating: ★★★★★☆☆☆☆☆ (233 / 378) Favorite track: Hyperbolicsyllabicsesquedalymistic Least favorite track: By the Time I Get to Phoenix
Alright soul. Could feel some emotion. Got distracted first time and all I remember is long song that felt like spoken weird and thought it was kind of weird. Had chance to listen to again same day, which I rarely do, and less bothersome, enjoyed the album
Yesyesyes here here here here. What a voice, what a mood. And 45 minutes of feeling cool 4.2/5.0 Best Song: Walk On By
Absolutely outrageous stuff, hot buttered soul indeed. Every song is perfect, i loved this
Ridiculously close to a 5 here but the 8-9min talking into on track 4 seriously cost it. Great album, love that orchestral sound. 4/5.
עיטוי יפה🥘🎊😍
What a tremendous album. It took me by surprise how much I enjoyed it. After a while I get bored of soul music. Not this time.
I’d expected more from Isaac Hayes 😐 Two stars…
Musically beautiful, but the long tracks made it all feel a bit shapeless to me, and the smooth sexiness is hard to take seriously these days.
Just on the cusp of a four-star review
This album is not for me but I can absolutely see why so many people love it. As a bonus, I rediscovered Beyonce's Lemonade album because "Walk on By" is sampled and it was driving me crazy trying to figure out where I'd heard it before.
Fantastic album. Takes soul into the sensual direction of the 70s Philly sound; but retaining the super tight playing of Stax and the southern sound. 9/10
This is a great Jazz forward soul record. Theres a lot to like here and the long song format lets you get into the slow burn.
All right, “Walk on By” has the bass note hits that made the beat of Biggie’s “Warning” so that’s already cool. There is a lot of noodling on this album, mostly instrumental but the big story in “By the Time I Get To Phoenix” counts. It’s a good thing Hayes’s voice is so compelling or it might’ve been a bit over the top. There are only 4 songs on this album but it’s plenty. They are all good and performed well. I liked “Wak on By” the most, but the actual musical but after the story in “Phoenix” is also great. Hayes’s voice is so distinct and it carries all of this. The instrumentalists are great too but he takes center stage.
One of those, made ubiquitous by the screaming gaggle of middle age women who are crushing. Prefer the soundtrack to shaft but 'Walk on by' remains a standout
Very good, liked the four longer song format. An enjoyable listen.
This album is pure soul, beautiful orchestration and wonderful lyrics, with two of the best cover songs to grace music. Isaac Hayes did an astounding job on this album, so I'm obliged to give it a 10/10.
No favorites here but cool to hear where some samples originated
Loved the grooves. But, 19 minutes singles are a lot
Nice but a bit too noodle for me
Storytelling talent and interesting from start to finish; passionate
Fantastic buttery stuff. The chat in the last song is so long.
Smooooove.
Such a great album. Soulful, bluesy and so different. Isaac Hayes's voice is low, smooth and very emotional. It sounded like the track Walk On By was the beat for Notorious B.I.G's Warning. Loved how short the album was but still had a lot of variety. Favorite tracks were Walk On By and One Woman.
Yep! Walk on by😍
Amazing, walk on by man visvairāk patika
You want to break the drought your city is having. Put this album on and the moisture level is going to increase by 100%. Isaac Hayes being the OG take your panties off music man makes sense, but the 12 minute Burt Bacharach cover and 19 minute cover of Jim Webb is just tip top chefs kiss awesome. If you don't make it to the last song you're going to miss out on one of the greatest covers I've and you will ever hear.
Probably not best listened to through earbuds on my desk at work. I can get the influence this had, but wasn't really my jam. (Dionne Warwick's Walk on By is my go to version)
I hear constant praise heaped on Walk On By but round of applause to the other 3 tracks which are all just as good IMO
My junior year of college, I had a hellish summer internship at an advertising trade magazine in Chicago. One of my duties was to deliver copies of it to agencies around town, so every week, a driver and I would hop into the boss' surprisingly crappy car and he'd play a cassette copy of Hot Buttered Soul. At the time I only knew Isaac Hayes from Shaft (I was on a blaxsploitation kick), and it blew my mind. I made my own crappy copy of the driver's cassette, though subpar fidelity cannot stop Hot Buttered Soul. I love this whole thing, even the never-ending "rap" at the beginning of "By the Time I Get to Phoenix." Essential listening.
The cover of Walk On By was epic. The rest was just fine.
Truck Turner
- this was not what I expected at all, but in a great way. the first two tracks felt like they were breaking the mold in some way, although they did seem to go on for a loooong time (granted, perhaps that's a limitation of our modern attention span or a feature of the genre) - the orchestral portions of "Walk on By" did a lot in making it seem much more dramatic, which I enjoyed, and the bass portions were interesting (especially the sections with multiple high notes) - I found myself not paying attention to the vocals at all and just jammed to the instrumentals for the first two songs. I guess that's why they've been sampled by so many artists (I recognized the same riff from "2 Wicky" right away) - "One Woman" was just a fairly normal soul track, nothing special to me, but I really enjoyed the storytelling portion of "By the Time I Get to Phoenix." it felt like a sermon in some parts, with the drums providing some tension in the background - still, transitioning from the very upbeat first two tracks to a much more mellow portion wasn't the most engaging. I was having a great time with the first two songs, then that excitement kind of dropped off, despite the final song ending in a triumphant way - p.s. my husband had to tell me Isaac Hayes was Chef on South Park (and also a member of scientology), I feel betrayed
Definitely another vibe record, one to put on and chill to, great grooves and obviously Isaac’s voice is outstanding.
His voice and the music both sounded great.
hot buttered rum and chocolate salty balls?! sign me up. this album is so good. hot lengthy soul jams.
Smooth
I didn’t know this record or the artist. It has been a pleasant surprise finding great music, with a lot of feeling and taste. Makes me want to dive deeper into his discography. Man, I love Soul.
HELL YEAH minus one star for long ass songs
Eerste helft goed, 2e meh
Chill, me gustó
Why is this on the list? Like it’s fine but it’s a chore and it’s not something I had to hear. At all.
Bleh.
Always meant to try Isaac's music after knowing him as Chef my whole life and here we finally are. I can confidently say I was SLEEPING on this man's musical talents oh my lord. Again, my frame of reference here are the silly songs he sang for any given South Park episode so I had no idea how intricate and beauitful his actually music would sound. Like already this man had an incredible singing voice, but fuck man these instrumentals are just so god damn pretty and funky all at the same time. I was intially intrigued by the fact there are only 4 songs here. Even with the length of all 4 it still was interesting to me. The moment Walk On By gets going though I knew I would really love this album. There is not a single dip in quality this entire record despite the length of any given song. Hayes' vocal delivery is smooth and buttery the entire time, hitting both soulful and sensual moods as called for throughout. Great vocals obviously do a lot for a soul record, but these instrumentals are just gorgeous underneath his performance. Every instrument here sounds incredible, the keyboards are loud and perfectly setting the mood. the percussion is setting the exact time to make everything fall in place, the guitars are lively and create electric moments, the bass is so clear here and the groove its setting is infectious. Every element here works together and build immersive pieces of art while still having their own identity and moment to shine. Glad this project finally gave me the push to stop procrastinating on this listen becuase I discovered an album I fully loved. What a talented creative this guy was and to think I only knew one small section of his work in entertainment. RIP Isaac (Chef) Hayes
Isaac Hayes' Hot Buttered Soul is a game of two halves. Side 1 is a masterclass in cinematic, psychedelic soul—dripping with funk and backed by the razor-sharp playing of The Bar-Kays. Unfortunately, Side 2 shifts into slower, traditional soul that loses that energetic momentum. Structuring the whole record around just four tracks—including 10+ minute versions of "Walk On By" and "By the Time I Get to Phoenix"—feels overstretched, especially since nearly the entire tracklist is made up of cover songs rather than originals. That said, Hayes has an incredible voice and the band is undeniably tight. Knowing the album was rushed out under immense pressure after Stax lost its back catalog adds interesting context, but overall, it didn't fully stick the landing for me
Didn’t expecr to hear the riff from Massive Attack? Never knew the original. Absolutely stunning album.
Would be better without the last song
An absolute classic
Smoooooth. Only four songs but all bangers
Fav song: Walk On By
Incredibly easy to listen. Just put it on and chill Best tracks: all are great Rating: 9.5/10
Fave💖 shoutout CHEF
bellissimo
The cover of by the time I got to Phoenix has me dead. Lets get the song going bro.
very nice 8/10
Gold, been a big fan of Isaac Hayes since hearing his theme from Shaft. The sheer vibe that this album oozes is just too smooth.
Pelado capoeira
Walk On By - radio edit is on my favorite song list. The unedited version gets a bit meandering.
Sounds pretty good for the most part, definitely better consumed as an entire album with the long tracks, but the overall sound is pretty iconic.
Solidan albumcic. Soul uvijek dobro paše duši. Najbolja pjesma mora bit zbog imena: Hyperbolicsyllabicsesquedalymistic
Hey chef
By the time i get to Phoenix was absolutely mesmerizing, so glad i listened to it
I could have done without the ultra-long intro to By The Time I Get To Phoenix, but this was a nice smooth listen.
Had a good time listening to this one. Fav track: “One woman”
Very classic, clearly influential soul. Though goddamn are the songs long and there’s a lot of talking. It’s also very freeformy from time to time, which I like.
Omg, a non-white artist on this list? How did that happen!?
strong points were really really good, but overall felt a little flat, I imagine this album will get better with more listens
Overall, I feel pretty neutral about this album. It kind of faded into the background as I was listening. The bald head featured so prominently on the album art is a funny choice.
Parts were good
Unexpectedly cool album. Makes sense that this guy made the theme from "Shaft" cuz this music could go real well with a 70s crime thriller movie or something of that sort. Really good band and nice soul vibe
It does it's thing well. I can see how the last two tracks could be a bit divisive, and I personally wouldn't reach for it, but I get it.