Spy Vs. Spy: The Music Of Ornette Coleman by John Zorn

Spy Vs. Spy: The Music Of Ornette Coleman

John Zorn

2.26
Rating
21940
Votes
1
35%
2
25%
3
23%
4
11%
5
5%
Distribution

Album Summary

Spy vs Spy: The Music of Ornette Coleman is a 1989 album by American composer and saxophonist/multi-instrumentalist John Zorn, featuring the compositions of Ornette Coleman performed in the brief, intense style of Zorn's hardcore miniatures. The liner notes thank Ornette and Denardo Coleman, Mick Harris of Napalm Death, Ted Epstein of Blind Idiot God, Pil of Lip Cream (a Japanese thrashcore group), The Accused, Craig Flanagan, DRI, CBGB, and "the New York-London-Tokyo Hardcore Triangle". The cover artwork was created by indie comics personality Mark Beyer (of Amy and Jordan fame). The album itself approaches free jazz from the perspective of hardcore punk, particularly taking note of the contemporary innovations of thrashcore and grindcore. Zorn would later pursue these preoccupations in the thrash jazz group Naked City. Like some classic free jazz albums (Free Jazz, Ascension, Archie Shepp's Mama Too Tight), different saxophonists improvise simultaneously in stereo. Tim Berne appears on the left channel, while John Zorn is recorded on the right channel.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

There is talent in there, I’ll give it that. Unfortunately it wasn’t used to produce music.

It did get better over time, but I didn’t like it

Not quite my tempo.

I don’t know what rating to give this. It’s so interesting but also almost unlistenable

Listening to this gave me a nostalgic memory of the much loved Commodore 64. Firstly there was a Spy v Spy game that was fun and secondly that distinctive hissing sound when the games were loading was almost as annoying as this album!

An album I've never heard, with a bad reputation amongst generator users. But I've liked some other 'unpopular' albums, so not too daunted. I read Wikipedia about the album and a bit about John Zorn. (Detour into the new-to-me idea of musical compositions that are "game pieces", oh wow.) Forewarned and semi-briefed, I start listening. It's so intense from the start, I suspect I may be able to listen to one track at a time and be happily attentive, but not able to listen to it straight through? See how I go. (Disappointed it's not hardcore-with-guitars - had to go back and read again the actual instrumentation here - now I understand how come so much drums - credit to the drummers that they're so in step - SMH at reviews here that mistake free jazz for chaos.) Turns out I listen to the whole album straight through, with enjoyment. They're all intense, definitely not "all the same" or "unrelenting" - and it does get more accessible as it goes on. The word 'violent' (used in the AllMusic review) seems quite inappropriate. I don't know Ornette Coleman well enough to recognise the pieces, I can see that some are quite relatable in their expositions. I'll give this album points for technical skills as well as chutzpah. It seems I find thrash free jazz more accessible than straight free jazz - I expect I will listen to this again. It's not just Very Good, it's (at least) Pretty Wonderful, 9/10.

I began this album wondering quite how I was supposed to listen to it. John Zorn takes the music of Ornette Coleman, hands it to two saxophonists, two drummers and a bassist, and plays much of it with the speed and aggression of hardcore punk. The result is extraordinarily difficult music, but I soon realised that it wasn’t simply a matter of five musicians making an enormous racket. I could hear the organisation beneath the apparent chaos, even if I couldn’t immediately work out how it functioned. What followed was one of the most interesting listening experiences I’ve had during this project, because the more I understood what I was hearing, the more the album changed for me. There’s a problem with albums where one jazz musician plays the music of another. All too often, they become exercises in respectful archaeology. The musician carefully interprets the original compositions, demonstrates an understanding of their importance, and perhaps adds a few ideas of their own. There’s nothing inherently wrong with that, but it can overlook something fundamental about the original music. Some of these compositions were shocking when they first appeared, and we’ve gradually become so familiar with them that we no longer hear what made them revolutionary. Take Thelonious Monk’s Brilliant Corners. Heard against the jazz of the mid-1950s, parts of it sound like a stubby-fingered man throwing an entire jazz ensemble down a staircase. The rhythms are awkward, the melodies take unexpected turns, and the musicians seem to be negotiating obstacles that nobody had previously thought to put in their way. Yet we’ve had seventy years to become familiar with Monk’s musical language. We recognise the compositions, understand something of their construction, and hear their influence in later jazz. What was once startling has become part of our normal musical vocabulary. Ornette Coleman presented a similarly profound challenge towards the end of the 1950s. His approach to melody, harmony and the freedom of individual musicians upset many established expectations about how jazz should work. But by 1989, when Zorn released Spy vs. Spy, Coleman’s music had been around for thirty years. It was no longer simply the sound of somebody challenging the established order. It had become an important part of jazz history. That creates an interesting problem for anyone attempting to pay tribute to Coleman. How do you communicate something of the original shock when your audience has already absorbed so much of what once made the music difficult? Zorn’s answer, at least as I hear it, is to make the compositions difficult again. Rather than carefully reconstructing Coleman’s musical world, he takes the original material and subjects it to a completely different set of pressures. The influence of thrashcore is obvious in the speed, aggression and brevity of many of the performances, but there’s something more interesting happening beneath that extraordinary assault. The first thing I noticed was that the compositions hadn’t disappeared. On W.R.U., Coleman’s themes remained recognisable even when the playing seemed to be pulling in several directions at once. The same sense of an underlying musical argument emerged elsewhere, including Blues Connotation and C & D. The musicians weren’t simply abandoning the compositions in favour of unrestricted improvisation. They seemed to be taking the musical material apart and putting it back together in a different way. I found myself thinking about the structure of a conventional pop song. Imagine a song consisting of a chorus, followed by a verse, another chorus, another verse, and so on. The different parts are presented one after another, and the listener follows the development through time. Much of jazz operates through a comparable sequence. A theme is established, individual musicians take turns developing it, and eventually the group returns to the theme. Now imagine playing the opening chorus, then playing three different verses simultaneously, before returning to the chorus. Instead of the musical ideas developing one after another, they’re folded together so that several developments happen during the same stretch of time. That’s how a surprising amount of the first side of this album sounds to me. The music is incredibly dense because what might ordinarily occupy several minutes of separate solos has been compressed into a single period of collective activity. But that explanation alone isn’t sufficient. Simply playing four different solos at once would probably produce an almighty mess. What I could hear was something much more organised, with the musicians apparently responding to one another even while pursuing different musical ideas. I began trying to construct a model that would explain those relationships. The simplest way I could imagine it was as a tree. At the bottom sits the bassist, providing a common point of reference. Two branches lead upwards to the drummers, and above each drummer sits a saxophonist. Now imagine that the four musicians above the bass are each developing a separate solo. Instead of those solos following one another, they’re taking place simultaneously. The important feature is that the relationships between the musicians run in both directions. Each saxophonist is influenced by their drummer, but also influences what that drummer plays. The drummer responds to the bassist, who is responding in turn. Meanwhile, the musicians on the two branches are listening to and affecting one another. There are musical relationships running upwards, downwards and across the tree. Each player is developing an individual argument while constantly having that argument changed by the contributions of the others. I have no way of knowing whether Zorn and his musicians actually organised their performances in anything resembling this fashion. I’m not claiming to have discovered their working methods. This is simply the most plausible explanation I can construct for what I’m hearing. It accounts for the remarkable sense of simultaneous independence and cooperation, and for the way the musicians can apparently be doing completely different things without losing their connection to the composition or to one another. That brought me to cubism. In a cubist painting, several different views of an object can be presented together. But it isn’t simply a matter of placing separate views alongside one another. The different views affect how we understand each other and change our understanding of the whole object. The artist creates something that couldn’t be seen from any single position. Zorn’s music seems to achieve something comparable, but with time rather than space. Several different developments of the same composition are presented simultaneously, and their relationships change as the musicians respond to one another. There’s an important difference, of course. In a painting, those relationships have already been worked out by the artist. Here, I hear them apparently being negotiated as the performance unfolds. It’s as though the different views in a cubist painting were continually changing in response to one another while we looked at them. This also means that the process isn’t merely one of compression. The individual musical arguments aren’t necessarily the same arguments they would have been if the musicians had taken turns. Their development is changed by the fact that other musicians are developing different ideas at the same time. The act of putting the music together in this way changes the music itself. It’s an extraordinarily interesting idea, and it explains why I became so determined that this album shouldn’t simply be dismissed as noise. It isn’t noise. Absolutely not. It’s organised along rather hostile premises, but it is organised. The problem with the first side is that the organisation is often almost impossible to follow at the speed at which everything happens. I could hear the themes, identify the different lines and occasionally recognise the musicians coming together, but the next burst of activity would arrive before I’d fully understood the previous one. It was exhausting. I admired the playing and became increasingly interested in the musical ideas, but intellectual interest and musical enjoyment aren’t necessarily the same thing. There were moments when I understood what was happening without particularly wanting to hear any more of it. And then came side two, which changed my experience of the album completely. The remarkable thing about the second side is that Zorn doesn’t abandon the principles established on the first. Instead, the music begins to open out, giving the different ideas more room to develop. The result is not simply easier to follow. In several places, I thought it was absolutely fantastic. Feet Music has an almost rock-based stomp to it at times. For a moment, I wondered whether the musicians had abandoned their complicated approach and settled into something much more conventional. But as the piece developed, it became apparent that the strong rhythmic foundation was simply making the opening theme more obvious. The variations were still being layered over one another, and the musicians were still pursuing their separate but connected musical arguments. The difference was that I now had a much clearer reference point against which to hear them. I thoroughly enjoyed it. Broadway Blues offered something different again. There was a wonderful expansiveness about the performance, a sense that the music had room to stretch out without losing the relationships that held it together. I could hear the individual contributions more clearly and follow their development without having to struggle through the sheer weight of activity. It was becoming possible to enjoy the music on its own terms rather than constantly trying to work out what was going on. Then came Zig Zag, which provided one of my favourite moments of the entire album. Towards the end, the musicians suddenly come together for an astonishing stop-time ending. After so much music in which the players seem to be pursuing separate arguments, the precision of their collective playing is remarkable. It’s the sort of thing you might expect from a tightly rehearsed big band, and it makes the underlying discipline of the performances wonderfully clear. But then, having apparently finished the piece, they go back and play the ending again. It’s the old Count Basie Orchestra trick from April in Paris, where the band reaches its conclusion and then decides to give everybody another helping. The stop-time ending was impressive enough, but that extra lap was delicious. It was also funny, in a wonderfully musical way. After all the apparent disorder, here were five musicians showing that they could come together with absolute precision and then have a bit of fun repeating the trick. More importantly, it made something explicit that I’d been hearing throughout the album. These musicians weren’t struggling to maintain control of their performances. Their ability to pursue separate musical arguments depended upon a tremendous degree of collective understanding. The ending of Zig Zag demonstrated that understanding in a form that was impossible to miss. It also made me reconsider the first side, where the same relationships had been present but much harder to hear. The final track, Mob Job, settled the argument for me. Its slower tempo and greater length allow the saxophonists much more room to develop their ideas, while the bass and drums continue producing a glorious racket underneath them. But the racket is still organised, and the relationships between the musicians are easier to follow because everything is happening at a more manageable pace. The same musical approach that had been almost overwhelming at the beginning of the album was now producing something I found thoroughly enjoyable. Slowing the music down hadn’t made it less interesting or less complex. It had made the complexity easier to hear. The players could develop their ideas more fully, and I had time to appreciate how those ideas changed in response to one another. By the end of Mob Job, I was no longer trying to persuade myself that the album was worth the effort. I was simply enjoying it. There’s a useful distinction here between making music complicated and committing to an idea. During the same week’s listening, I’d been frustrated by Neil Hannon’s A Short Album About Love, where I often felt that the arrangements were supplying a beauty and emotional weight that the underlying songs hadn’t earned. Hannon seemed rather too pleased with himself for dressing up in the grand gestures of singers such as Scott Walker, without always delivering the emotional substance that made Walker’s performances so powerful. I’ve heard Scott Walker, and Hannon is no Scott Walker. Zorn presents almost the opposite problem. His musical idea is so extreme that it risks making the record unlistenable, but he commits to it completely. There’s no sense, to my ears, of an artist merely dressing up in the clothes of a more adventurous musician. The performances follow their chosen approach with extraordinary discipline, even when that approach makes life very difficult for the listener. And on the second side, that commitment produces not just a clever demonstration but some genuinely wonderful music. What I find most satisfying is that the album’s difficulty seems to serve a purpose. Coleman was a revolutionary musician whose work had gradually become familiar. Zorn takes that familiar music and finds a way of making it strange again. The speed and violence of hardcore punk, the overlapping solos, the competing rhythms and the constant changes between the players all contribute to an experience that challenges the listener’s normal expectations. I can’t know whether reproducing something of Coleman’s original shock was precisely what Zorn intended, but it is certainly the effect the album had on me. And judging by some of the reactions I’ve encountered from other listeners, that effect hasn’t entirely worn off in the decades since its release. There’s something rather wonderful about a tribute album that doesn’t simply ask us to admire the original artist. Instead of carefully preserving Coleman’s music as an important historical achievement, Zorn treats it as something that should still be capable of causing trouble. He doesn’t merely reproduce the notes. He finds a way to restore some of the difficulty and surprise that made those notes so important in the first place. This used to be difficult music. John Zorn makes it difficult again. What changed during my listening was not my understanding of the album’s basic approach, but my ability to hear what that approach could achieve. I began by recognising organisation beneath an almost unbearable amount of musical activity. I gradually developed a way of understanding that organisation, through the folding of musical time and the relationships between the musicians. Then the second side allowed me to hear those same principles producing groove, space, humour, precision and genuine pleasure. I wouldn’t pretend that the first side became easy listening, or that I expect to return to it frequently. Its speed and density remain exhausting, and there are limits to how much effort I’m prepared to expend simply to follow a piece of music. But the second side was a revelation, and I adored several of its performances. The album didn’t simply reward the effort I’d put into understanding it. It changed the nature of that effort, until something that had initially seemed almost impossibly difficult became a source of considerable enjoyment. I finished with a much greater appreciation of Coleman’s strength as a composer, Zorn’s determination to do something genuinely different with that material, and the extraordinary collective ability of the musicians involved. Above all, I finished with the sense that I’d heard an album which had challenged me for a reason, and which had eventually justified that challenge. It’s a rare thing to hear a record that makes you work this hard and then rewards you with something as simple as the pleasure of five musicians playing brilliantly together.

Facilmente la peor forma de jazz que he escuchado (OPINION PERSONAL), simplmente este estilo no es pa mi

What in the sweet name of jesus is this?! The is genuinely awful, mindless noise. All the instruments used in the making of this album need therapy. Terrible in every way.

Just sounds like straight noise pollution. Way too much going on that it becomes less technically impressive and more so just annoying and stressful. It's got neat moments, but this is so far off in what I want to hear. There's not much identity for me to grasp on to beyond the sheer chaos.

This is the most stressful jazz I’ve ever listened to. It’s almost more impressive how fast they play. Not for me but wow

I couldn’t find this album but I did find a compilation of the songs of Ornette Coleman that Zorn used and that was a pretty good compilation.

This is a lot to deal with. Loud, dense free jazz with 2 saxophonists and 2 drummers battling to drown out the poor bassist. The first half of the album is just pummeling cacophony, one after the other, before it finally opens up a bit in the 2nd half. I actually enjoyed ‘Feet Music’ and ‘Broad Way Blues’, but by God, it was a journey to get to that point

Not for me 1/5

Otro que no tengo donde pija escuchar y dicen q es malisimo, 2 y a tirar

It's insane that this is here, and there are no albums by Ornette Coleman, what a huge miss. That said, I really can't hate too much, this album is just really good, Ornette Coleman or no.

If this is music then it is beyond my understanding.

The one flavour John Zorn is honing in on with Spy vs. Spy is very much my thing. There is no two minute slice of this album which is anything but great, but all together it’s too relentless, too suffocating. I could do with some calm before the storm, or a breather between moments of mania. Instead, various iterations of this one idea are densely layered together in an ultimately unsatisfying way.

Head-scratching inclusion. John Zorn is obviously a very prolific and interesting composer in his own right, who has worked in a variety of different genres of music, from Jazz to Classical to Rock to Klezmer and Easy Listening. So it boggles the mind why the album chosen is one that features none of his original compositions, but rather only works by the great Ornette Coleman. What's even more baffling is how did this one make the cut while none of Coleman's own work is represented. True, this is pretty unique in this list, with its very aggressive approach to free-form jazz, but it would be helpful to listen to some of the original pieces before to get more context. So, I would recommend going for Coleman's 1959 classic The Shape of Jazz to Come, at the very least. And if you want a Zorn project that does this style in a more fleshed out manner, go with the self-titled Naked City album. Or if you want Zorn doing someone else's work, there's The Big Gundown, where he pays tribute to Ennio Morricone. Key tracks: Good Old Days

Kikka Korea ja Jussi Pattitussi vääntää melkosta settiä. Onhan tätä jollain tavalla pakko arvostaa, mutta ei tätä toista kertaa kyllä kuunnella pysty.

Hehe napalm death, mutta jatsina.

No voi vittu. Nyt oli rajua paskaa. Vielä piti erikseen tubesta kaivaa, ilmeisesti Spotifyssä ollaan sen verran viisaita, että on sanottu että ei tämmöisellä kuralla ole meidän alustalle asiaa. Jos ei olisi ollut taukoja mökän välissä niin olisin luullut että tää oli yksi 40 minuuttia kestävä biisi. Ei jumalauta!

Too much for me

это что за кошмар. кто решил, что это обязательно надо услышать в своей жизни? мне и так головной боли хватает, спасибо блин нафиг. включила трек с самой высокой оценкой и он хотя бы на музыку похож. все остальное - едва ли.

Is it a good sign when the YouTube ad break is more enjoyable than the album itself?

No thanks terrible

I'm not sure I'll ever seek this out to listen to again as it's a lot, but I thought this was really interesting. Thrash/punk jazz? Nice to hear something completely different.

I think albums like this are the reason my Dad hates jazz.

Could not find on Spotify and don’t care enough to look

Challenging listen for sure, but seriously impressive. All five are unbelievably good and to perform something like this takes serious skill. Behind the cacophony there actually is structure and synchronicity between the dual drummers and dual saxophones, and the fact they can go so buck wild and still lock in together for the melodies/phrases is commendable. This is a hard one to rate for these reasons but I think it’s much better than most of these reviews indicate.

Intense chaotic phrasing with layers of cacophony that perplex the listener. Is this a stunt? It can’t be, it’s too tight and the sound is still structured in a way that.

Jazz, sehr hektisch; 1989 -> 2

This one is challenging. It starts of as a cacophony and then slowly mellows out about midway through. The second half was far more listenable than the first. I think this album would really benefit from having the text from the book as to why it was selected because I really have no clue.

Even when I'm not into it, I always like when the generator throws me something completely different. I'd heard John Zorn's name before, but was unfamiliar with him work, except knowing there was some experimental bent to it. This time, its experimental jazz, already cribbing from the free jazz of Ornette Coleman. I do respect the hell out of this. The cacophony of 2 competing saxes and 2 competing drummers starts to give me almost thrash metal vibes, which is not a bad thing. But all in all, this is not music I'd play to listen to in the future. It's a tad too chaotic for me. Just a curiosity that I'm glad I've met its acquaintance at least once.

Das widerspricht meinem Verständnis von Musik grundlegend. 1/5

Punk jazz. Dig it.

No tracks would play on spotify

Finally some Art

I had to go to YouTube for this album. Okay, here's the thing - John Zorn seems like the kind of guy who doesn't give a shit what I say about him or how I classify his music. I mean, I could say he's an avant-garde jazz musician/composer/producer who specializes in the alto saxophone, but that short description doesn't do the man justice. After all, you don't grow up in a musically eclectic family, immerse yourself in experimental composers like Ligeti and Stockhausen during your adolescence, teach yourself orchestration, immerse yourself in free jazz, drop out of college to perform your own experimental music in the New York underground art and hardcore scenes, collaborate with other artists along the way, and not turn out to be a unique, curious individual. Eventually, Zorn broke through with The Big Gundown, a radical reworking of compositions by Italian film composer Ennio Morricone, which even Morricone himself endorsed. Naturally, Zorn continued down this rabbit hole, reimagining the works of other accomplished artists, including, for this record, Spy Vs. Spy, the compositions of free jazz founder Ornette Coleman. Now, let me get this out of the way - yes, Ornette Coleman should have been included in the books proper. Given his influence in jazz improvisation, you would think that at least one album would have been included, even one as obvious as The Shape of Jazz to Come. But I digress. Instead, we have to settle for John Zorn's compilation of decades of Coleman's works, mostly squeezed down into fast-paced, hardcore snippets. Accessibility is pretty much thrown out the window from the get-go with "W.R.U.", and your mileage will vary on how many whiplash improvisational passages you'll tolerate. As someone who likes both jazz and hardcore, I admittedly dug this bizarre fusion. At the very least, Zorn's production and arrangements of Ornette's compositions were surprisingly well done. I can still pick out individual elements in his ensemble even at breakneck speed. I especially enjoyed how Zorn and Tim Berne seemed to duel with each other on alto saxophone over the rapid-fire drums and Mark Dresser's frantic, low-end bass. That said, yeah, it does become a bit tiring after a while when the pace is kept so fast. Thankfully, the tempo slows down starting with "Feet Music", where the chaos and complexity of the ensemble are fully taken in. I found it particularly mesmerizing when one of the saxophones almost acted like a violin for the opening scene-dressing of "Broadway Blues" before the players let loose. Then we follow that up with the decrepit, atonal dirge of "Space Church", the jovial tremoloing on "Zig Zag", culminating in the weirdly smooth "Mob Job". So yeah, call me crazy, but I ended up enjoying Spy Vs. Spy for the most part. John Zorn continued to pull and find inspiration from other artists' works, along with concocting his own experimental compositions and helping other artists achieve their own improvisations, including Slayer drummer Dave Lombardo and Faith No More frontman Mike Patton. That's pretty cool.

Svårlyssnat kaos, men en jazzig kärna som hindrar det från att vara det absolut värsta jag hört.

Inte bara oljud. Men mest.

This was something I didn’t know I needed in my life. Thank you. Too bad the only way to listen to it is through a youtube playlist where every song was uploaded by a different person. Worth it though.

Maybe it was my Sunday Scaries but this gave me terrible anxiety. Incredible talent, did not enjoy listening at all

It feels like the mantra for this one was “All Gas No Breaks.” I’ve been enjoying the jazz entries of the list though this one didn’t hit quite like the others have.

I’m actually glad to have listened to it, but I’m even happier that I never have to again

Favorite songs: none This album is an absolute hard pass for me.

Incredibly loud, but a journey nevertheless. From what the hell, to God no, to bopping, to why am I doing this, to is the disheases done, to doing it and resting in the thought that it was interesting even if I'll never listen to it again

Not streamable, not reviewed

I'm assuming this made the list because it was the first whole album where every musician played a different song at the same time.

Couldn't find the album on streaming. Listened to a couple other songs and it's very much not my jam.

Cacophonous

Ok ended up listening to this on YT and the first time an add popped up i thought we had another Kollapse on our hands. I liked this but if i was not choosing to listen to it it might have felt like hell on earth so idk how that fits into a review.

Yeah wow I had a good time with this. Here’s a sentence I’d never thought I’d type: Feet Music was my favourite.

I can appreciate this is objectively good and also recognize that I don’t enjoy listening to it.

No thank you. Not sure I even made it through the first track -- honestly, who can tell when one track ends and another begins? -- before I started skipping around. Which was made even more annoying on YouTube (not on Apple Music) because of the frequent interruptions for truly idiotic ads. Perhaps the worst attempted listening experience for this project so far.

Hardcore punk free jazz. Nice. Welcome to Jazz Club. Yes, deserves its place on this list and definitely an album to listen to before you die. But just the once.

I actually had so much fun with this album! I hated it at first, it was so abrasive and annoying, but then it just like clicked with me and I understood it? When that happened I spent the rest of the album really enjoying myself. Theres not a single standout piece from it, you just have to listen to the whole thing to really get the full experience from it. It was a great time though, and it makes me feel like Im starting to understand jazz!

I wanted to like this - but really just don't - 1/5

Flaps. 0.5

Jazz played at a million miles an hour. This was just too mental for me to wrap my head around. I did find it interesting though as I'd never heard anything quite like it before.

Yesterday we had puppy therapy day at my office. I spent 20 minutes in a small enclosed space with half a dozen puppies who ran around, jumping on me, my colleagues, and each other, and generally being full of energy. If those puppies were magically transformed into a jazz band, I'd imagine the music they produced would sound like this album. Energetic, kind of all over the place, almost formless. In a word, frenetic. I was prepared to hate this album, seeing it as something to be endured, a cacophony of saxophone noise with no discernable structure to it. But the more I listened, the more I kind of felt like there was some structure, some method behind the madness. It wasn't enough to get me to actually enjoy the album, but enough to stop it from being actively bad. I still think free-form jazz is not at all my cup of tea, but I think I've come away from this experience with the ability to see how it could be someone's cup of tea

medio pesado. ademas lo tuve q escuchar en youtube. tiene buenos momengtos, pero no me genero un deleite

More interesting than 90% of the jazz albums on this list, and more brutal than a lot of the metal albums here too. Free jazz and hardcore is a combo that's hard to make boring. I appreciate that this was on the list because otherwise I'd have no idea stuff like this even existed.

This is the kind of music that nightmares are made of. You get a bunch of really talented musicians and have them all make noise "together" that's not melodical or pleasing to the ear in any way, and then drag it out for extended periods of time. And then, in this case, someone comes along and says, "Listen to me do it FASTER!" So it's more painful but in less time, so I'm not sure which is worse.

Some people would describe this album as just noise, others will talk about the genius of Zorns chaotic arrangements of ornette colemans music as being a joyful cacophony of sounds that challenge the listener to really get into what is going on underneath…. I agree with the “noise” crowd… i’ve never understood Jazz, i never will if this is among its best offerings.. an album for your dads most pretentious prick of a mate

Music for the mosquitos of NOLA

Oh boy, I had hopes for this album. I thought spy Vs spy might be fun. I was wrong. This was not my type of album at all. Also, Spotify did not have this album and I had to listen to It on YouTube. I'm beginning to think if Spotify does not have the album, I probably won't like it.

This album had me both fascinated and anxious. I can understand why this is on the list, but I'm very on the fence about whether I like this or not, so a 3 it is.

I couldn't finish this album. I'm sure they are having a great time but listening to this made me nauseous.

Can’t work out if I just listened to the same noise over and over again or if there was anything different between the tracks.

An example of the worst kind of jazz, noise jazz. I don't like it in rock, there is no reason jazz would be any better. I suppose at least it's all instruments and not random weird noises. But without melody or any sense of song structure, it flails IMO. Not for me.

I am usually positively surprised by obscure jazz albums no longer available on Spotify, but this was just too much sound for my brain to comprehend. Although I am sure it was immensely impressive musically, I just couldn't find a way to flow with it and enjoy it. I am genuinely sorry!

Good lord what a schizophrenic start. I was not on the right drugs for that Luckily the rest of it mellowed out a bit, but still.

Very chaotic. It's a pretty good album. It's very unique. I don't really know what else to say about this album. It has a very unique sound. I don't know. It was interesting.

Listened on flight home from SFO. Chaotic random and disorienting. I’m sure it’s great to people who are familiar with jazz. I am not one of them and would never again put this on. 1/5

I didn't really care for this. I'm more into smooth relaxing jazz. This was like a bunch of screaming.. didn't even finish it.

"Right these are the notes John gave us, as soon as we've played them all we can go home, press record and play...... GO !!!" If only they'd paid them by the hour. Missed opportunity.

7/10 (dropped to 3 from 4)

#119 - John Zorn - Spy Vs. Spy - The Music of Ornette Coleman ⭐️ You have GOT to be kidding me right now.

Well that was uncomfortable. I like weird things and I like jazz but this felt like assault, brother. I've been physically abused in the ear. I gave it a fair shake, I can't think of any situation in which this would be in any way appropriate. Brenda says jazz makes her nervous. This would make Brenda have a seizure.

*1989. Jazz. *So much aggressive horn. So annoying. Ahhhhh. RATING - 4/10

There’s a difference between avant garde and dogshit. This is the latter. 0/10

What the actual fuck was this!! 41 minutes of my life wasted on the most unhinged, chaotic, and awful album I've ever heard. A tortuous listen from the jump and the pain never stops. I have nothing good to say about this... NOTHING! Rating: 0/10

Never a good sign when the album isn't on Spotify. This got slightly more tolerable as it went along but yeah I'm going pass, dawg.

This is music for musicians and people steeped in self-loathing.

This was an intense listen, but I'm kinda here for it. Maybe thrash jazz is my thing?

Delightful.

This is glorious. It sounds like complete chaos but somehow... not? Almost like independent machines that occasionally have their parts line up... really fun! :)

Free jazz might be a little too chaotic for me. Glad I don’t have YouTube Premium because the best part of this was the ad palate cleansers throughout.

i have a lot of john zorn in my collection. masada, electric masada, book of angels, some film and play stuff. dude is prolific at writing and honkin’ on that sax. not an everyday listen but a fun take on ornette coleman’s material.

Unfortunately, this was the last album I needed to listen to, to complete this list. I still don’t like jazz.

Oh my. This is one of the best albums I have heard on the list so far. It is definitely an album I should have heard before I died. Jim Zorn decided to take Ornette Coleman and turn him into hardcore music. The twin assault of the saxophones is a bit much at first but it’s so beautiful to really listen when they are playing the same and then differently at the same time. The assault of the double drummers. I find the beauty in heavy music and it’s here. Yes it’s loud and a bit much but if you listen there is something really beautiful being played in both sides. This something you have to listen to instead of putting on in the background and expecting it to play. You have actively listen to hear the beauty under the brutality of the assault.

Not my vibe

Only available on YouTube.

This album is an interesting take on free jazz with a hardcore punk spin as it was described by Zorn. I would say at times it sounds like organized chaos and other times it was more melodic and tolerable. Overall the album seemed disjointed and more of a jam session that an actual full recording. I give it a 4/10 and that means 2 stars from me.

This gets more hate here than it deserves. It’s a tough listen I’ll give you that and it’s hard to evaluate on a couple casual run throughs. But if you peel back the layers there are some interesting things happening under the noise.