What's Going On by Marvin Gaye

What's Going On

Marvin Gaye

3.94
Rating
29756
Votes
1
1%
2
6%
3
24%
4
35%
5
34%
Distribution

Album Summary

What's Going On is the eleventh studio album by American soul singer Marvin Gaye. It was released on May 21, 1971, by the Motown Records subsidiary label Tamla. Recorded between 1970 and 1971 in sessions at Hitsville U.S.A., Golden World, and United Sound Studios in Detroit, and at The Sound Factory in West Hollywood, California, it was Gaye's first album to credit him as a producer and to credit Motown's in-house studio band, the session musicians known as the Funk Brothers. What's Going On is a concept album with most of its songs segueing into the next and has been categorized as a song cycle. The narrative established by the songs is told from the point of view of a Vietnam veteran returning to his home country to witness hatred, suffering, and injustice. Gaye's introspective lyrics explore themes of drug abuse, poverty, and the Vietnam War. He has also been credited with promoting awareness of ecological issues before the public outcry over them had become prominent ("Mercy Mercy Me"). What's Going On stayed on the Billboard Top LPs for over a year and became Gaye's second number-one album on Billboard's Soul LPs chart, where it stayed for nine weeks. The title track, which had been released in January 1971 as the album's lead single, hit number two on the Billboard Hot 100 and held the top position on Billboard's Soul Singles chart five weeks running. The follow-up singles "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)" and "Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)" also reached the top 10 of the Hot 100, making Gaye the first male solo artist to place three top ten singles on the Hot 100 from one album. The album was an immediate commercial and critical success, and came to be viewed by music historians as a classic of 1970s soul. Broad-ranging surveys of critics, musicians, and the general public have shown that What's Going On is regarded as one of the greatest albums of all time and a landmark recording in popular music. In 1985, writers on British music weekly the NME voted it the best album of all time. In 2020, it was ranked number one on Rolling Stone's list of the 500 Greatest Albums of All Time.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

He seems to be a bit confused at the beginning of the album I hope he figures it out One of the most beautiful and political albums of the time. Only true love can conquer hate.

Still kind of feels like a miracle this album was ever made

thank you marvin gaye

Mmh, I actually liked this less than I expected, since it is held in such high regard. It is really beautiful music, don't get me wrong, but to me it did not feel like more than that. Maybe it was a bit too slow for me? The album is not bad at all of course, and I can certainly see why this is appreciated so much. Maybe it will become a favourite of mine as well after some more listens.

Good but just a bit too slow and sleepy for my preferences.

I know it's sacrilege to critique Marvin Gaye, but what would make this album a 5 for me is one track that breaks the pattern. More anguish or rage or passionate love or joy to provide contrast to the otherwise lovely Autumn day album

Good, easy listening.

I've been waiting 2 1/2 years for this album, and have heard nothing but praise for it. Over that time, I've had 2 other Marvin Gaye albums on this list, and I enjoyed them, but wasn't crazy about them, so I was starting to get worried that this album was overhyped. Thankfully, that is not true, this album is great! I love the production, the songwriting, and the singing, all around a great album. Mid 5!!!!

Great, meaningful songs written from the heart. An important album that is also smooth as silk.

Um clássico atemporal que figura entre os melhores discos de todos os tempos.

i wonder why it is considered the best album of all time by Rolling Stone Magasine. That said, it's a phenomenal Motown classic that still sounds fresh 50 years later

I always thought this album was overrated due to how much it leaned into being a snapshot of American (underline that word) history. A lightning bolt caught in a bottle which Americans ate up, and in turn defecated a turd with a sign that says "best album of all time (or close to it". I get the idea of being emotionally invested into something and getting your heart strings tugged into loving something, I'm a victim of that, just look at my top-rated albums, but something that can't even cross the neighbouring borders should not be even put on the same street as the Pantheon of greatest albums of all time, let alone be let inside. That was me before I heard this album. Nothing too new to me, mind you, I always had that habit of taking revered albums with a spoon full of salt. Most of the time I was right, but on a faithful day sometime last autumn, that all changed. A guy who sells records around the town I'm studying in has a tendency to have a few gold nuggets, be it in wisdom, old musical stories, or in the currency of those aforementioned records. Sometimes it was 70s or 80s Yugoslav rekkerds, sometimes it was All Things Must Pass for 25 bucks, and sometimes it was full of absolute junk that's overpriced to the point of laughter. You never know with this geezer. One of those records was the album you've stumbled upon here, minty first UK press, promotional copy. "How much do you want for it?" "20 bucks." I was on the fence for it. I thought, even if I didn't like it, I could at least triple it on the open market. And just before I could make up my mind, he said: "Take it home and listen to it, if you like it, bring the 20 bucks tomorrow." I took it home, put it on the platter, and my god was I blown away. I instantly realized why people love it. This is dream soul. Nothing sounds like this beautiful piece of hazy lush soul that doesn't rely on bombastic melodies, and/or piercing sexy vocals, but on sensual sounds and calming instrumentation. Oh, and the whole "American history" thing I yapped at the beginning? Scratch that. My father, who only knows how to say "Hello" and "How do you do", thought this album was one of the most beautiful soul albums he's heard, and he's one of those guys who doesn't even like soul. I consider that a huge stamp of approval. This is an album with objective "good-ness" to it. Marvin pierces the ears of those who don't want to listen, and the hearts of those who don't want to feel. And even after listening, if you still aren't on the right side of good music, I have no words for you. You are truly lost. I often think about the fact that he gave me the album on his own personal accord. I could have stolen it and never bring it, or the money back. I think Marvin was smiling on that day from the skies above. Partly because of me being an honest bloke, and partly because his music is finding new audiences from generation to generation

My first Marvin Gaye album. I really enjoyed it- Gaye has a great voice, and the songs are filled with emotion and commentary. Well crafted and surprisingly succinct.

Welp, was hoping I'd get this one a little later than #57. I've heard ONLY good things about this album, so I'm hoping for the best. Especially because I loved Here, My Dear. 01. What's Going On Really smooth, and really pretty introductory track. Not my favorite Marvin song by any means, but pretty damn good. 02. What's Happening Brother Much prefer this over the opener! I like these lyrics quite a lot, and I find the instrumentation a lot prettier! 03. Flyin' High (In The Friendly Sky) This singing will make you fly (pun intended). Really gnarly vocals, period! Favorite so far! 04. Save The Children A really strange track, and I'm conflicted about it. I don't care for the spoken word parts, but the rest is fantastic -- especially the lyrics. 05. God Is Love Actually really love this one. Too bad it's so short. :( 06. Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) This album is much more retrospective than I thought it would be. This another key example. Really great track. 07. Right On Besides the instrumental section near the middle, I didn't find it very interesting. 08. Wholy Holy I like that it's a slower jam, but I personally believe Marvin works better on faster, more up-tempo tracks. Just a me thing. 09. Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) Why the fuck is this still so relevant. Incredible song, and a great way to close this off. I believe that this will be an album that will definitely grow on me the more I listen to it. I do these rankings based off a first listen and a first listen alone though. And on a first listen, I found the first half MUCH stronger than the second. Still an incredible album; would give like a 4.8 if I could.

Great Music

sehr coole, chillige musik

Too many albums I can't write notes for all of them

Mittwoch, 11.11.2026 In der Philologischen Bibliothek und beim rumlaufen in der FU

right on made me thought i had a problem w my car

It’s not too long and not too short. It’s a perfect album

Today it’s usually cited as top five greatest albums of all time…It deserves that.

What IS going on? A valid question still, 50+ years later. But back in 1971, Mr. Gaye posits the question amidst societal turmoil, suffering, and overall injustice in the only way he knows how to fight: via song. It's an ever flowing album that probably wasn't created with singles in mind, but did so anyway. It's best consumed as the whole 35-minute pie, however, each track seamlessly cycling into the next as Gaye mourns about the environment, vet disillusionment following the recent Vietnam War, and urban poverty among other subjects. If you think about it, it kind of sounds like one long and continuous song. I'm sure a soul/R&B concept album was quite novel for the time, but who else than Marvin Gaye to make this work? Especially with the smooth progressive soul backdrop...

I don't know if this deserved #1 on the 500 Greatest but it was a nice album.

Rock solid album experience. Goes pretty far into gospel but it’s chill. I love the overall vibe of this work - feels very cohesive

This is an album I would need to listen to several times to really appreciate. It is a technically-sound record, and I appreciate Marvin Gaye as an artist, but this isn't a genre that I can listen to regularly.

I only really know the big hits and so it was nice to hear a full album from start to finish. I like his voice and melodies. What’s Going On is definitely the standout track for me. The gospel vibe through much of the album added some extra colour and context. I probably won’t listen to this much again but it was still a good experience.

very good, very classic. very romantic

Heerlijk

Really liked the end few songs of this album

Lovely though not my favorite Marvin Gaye.

An absolute classic. Being in essence one flowing track both works in its favor and at times as a bit of a detriment. But absolutely solid and worth listening to. 4/5

Fantastic. Still holds up together soulful and serious while remaining completely approachable.

Not really my thing but still very good.

Marvin Gaye — What's Going On (1971) 6.5/10 — ★★★☆☆ I went into What's Going On knowing its reputation as one of the greatest albums ever recorded. Coming directly after Al Green's Let's Stay Together in my listening project, I was curious to see how these two classic soul albums would compare. The first thing that impressed me was the album's flow. The transitions are so seamless that I occasionally didn't even realize one song had ended and another had begun. As someone who appreciates cohesive albums, particularly in progressive rock, I can absolutely respect what Marvin Gaye accomplished here. Unfortunately, I had a much harder time connecting with the individual songs. I understand the historical significance of this album and the importance of its themes, especially considering when it was released. But historical importance doesn't necessarily translate into personal enjoyment. Some of the lyrics, particularly on "Save the Children," feel a little clichéd to me today, even if they were considerably more impactful in 1971. The religious themes on songs like "God Is Love" and "Wholy Holy" also didn't resonate with me personally. I can appreciate the sincerity behind them, but the music itself wasn't compelling enough to overcome that disconnect. There were definitely highlights. "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)" was easily my favorite track, with a beautiful melody and an arrangement that immediately grabbed my attention. I also enjoyed "What's Happening Brother" and the darker, funkier groove of "Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler)." Then there's "Right On." I actually liked the underlying music, but the repetitive scraping percussion became so distracting that it seriously hurt my enjoyment of the song. Once I noticed it, I couldn't stop hearing it. Ultimately, I think What's Going On works better as a complete musical statement than as a collection of individual songs. The production, atmosphere, and transitions are impressive, but much of the music simply didn't grab me. My track ratings averaged a 6, but I'm giving the album an extra half-point for its exceptional cohesion. I understand why this record is held in such high regard, even if it isn't one I'm particularly eager to revisit. Favorite track: "Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology)" — 8/10 Track average: 6.00/10 Final rating: 6.5/10 — 3 stars.

Хороший альбом, возможно текста меня не сильно тронули из-за незнания языка, но музыка приятная

Name of this album really sums up my life right now. Also did I say I don't like soul (and funk). But guy is good I'll give him that

Suuuuch a beautiful album. Gaye was in his emotional-somebodies-got-to-say-something bag

The album sags in the middle a bit given that several songs are just reprises of the title track, but this has three all-time greats What’s Going On, Mercy Mercy Me, and one of my favorite songs of all time, Inner City Blues). I don’t love the sanctimonious religious message in God Is Love, but I love most of it so much that I won’t dock a star for that.

what's going on is how much I'm not enjoying this album.

It’s just so soulful and the album basically sounds like one continued awesome song. Loved it

High 4, easily his best album on here

I thought Marvin Gaye was supposed to make sexy music. Nothing would kill the mood more than singing about saving the children and Jesus. 2/5⭐️ 299/1089

What's Going On - 5/5 What's Happening Brother - 4.5/5 Flyin' High (In the Friendly Sky) - 4/5 Save the Children - 4/5 God is Love - 4/5 Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology) - 4.5/5 Right On - 4.5/5 Wholy Holy - 4/5 Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) - 4.5/5 An album which could have been yesterday and whose themes would unfortunately still be true. An immaculate and smooth piece that really makes you wonder along with Marvin about what is really going on and what needs to change. Overall: 5/5 Favorites: What's Going On

Highlights: What's Going On, What's Happening Brother, Save the Children, God Is Love, Mercy Mercy Me, Inner City Blues Peak soul right here. I love how he talks about modern problems of his time in this depressive way. The tracks nicely flow into one another, as if they were one. The style is consistent throughout them, but they aren't monotonous. There's always the smallest of changes that differentiates it from the rest. The sound is wonderful and his vocals fit them nicely. Worthy of a revisit.

This really might be the best album of all time. 5 - but really this album is infinitely good Boolean: TRUE

What's Going On (5/5) and What's Going On derivatives (2/5)

Pretty good. Quite chill and slow music. It would be good for slow relaxing mornings maybe cooking something.

Listening to this, I understand why this album was so influential for the r&b/soul genre. It is done incredibly well - from his silky vocals, the perfectly stacked backing vocals and instrumentation and the intentionally curated ambiance of each song... it is timeless. Favorite Tracks: What's Going On Mercy Mercy Inner City Blues

Flyin High 1001 Albums Generator 379 (10/26/2026) Definitely one of those albums that when you hear it for the first time, you immediately understand why it's a classic. From the first verse of What's Going On, it's clear that Marvin Gaye and all the musicians who played on this album are just operating at such a high frequency. Silky smooth and beautiful. 4/5 Favs: What's Going On God Is Love Mercy Mercy Me Least Fav: Wholy Holy

харошій джаз блюз вау

Now this is the Marvin Gaye album I've been waiting for. Adroit messaging, great grooves, and soulful vocals make this an absolute 4-star album for me. I already knew this album pretty well (I do in fact own the vinyl and love to spin it to cultivate a vibe), and my favorite tracks haven't changed from those I already knew, but still a very enjoyable listen for a Friday afternoon. Favorite tracks: What's Going On, Mercy Mercy Me, Inner City Blues

This one was fine, nothing really stood out to me

pretty music but nothing i would personally listen to in my free time

SOO GOOD! marvin gaye has always been an incredible artist so i knew i was going to like this

Wow. This is so good. So good I got it twice. That's nice.

There's some beautiful, soulful music here, but there's also a bit of tepid material. Still a strong recommend.

A slightly overrated album? Well, the first and last song are classics, but the rest are not that special. Still, it is quite pleasant as background music. I bump it up to 4* rather than down. Favourites: What's Going On and Inmer City Blues

Day 2 of Tragic brilliance.

Rumours is #1 on this list, and this is Rolling Stone’s most recent #1, so I had to live with this for a bit. I don’t want to continually compare it to Rumours through this review, so I’ll say this — Rumours is #1 here because it’s accessible for anyone, and this is Rolling Stone’s top because it’s a critics dream. This could just as easily be a novel, an epic poem, or any highly sophisticated piece of literature. Honestly, that’s how it should be listened to. Despite yielding quite a few sweet, smooth soul classics, this is not a collection of songs, it’s a linear story. Throughout the album, the groove returns to something similar to what’s going on, the opening track. Each song flows into the next, and there are several points where you don’t know the track has changed. It’s the story of a veteran coming home, seeing how different America is, struggling with drugs, and expressing frustration at the way society treats veterans and civilians in general. Natural fact is, honey I can’t pay my taxes. Oooooooo it makes me wanna holler. This is a goddamn masterpiece and I never really knew it. I’m discovering soul & Motown as an adult, and each step further lights up my brain just a bit more. Like I said, there are some grooves on here that will get folks moving, but if you listen, my man is preaching from the mountain, and it all holds up today. That’s why it’s deserving of a top ranking, and I’m sold — I’ll certainly offer this as an option in the conversation of the greatest album ever. Incredible. Only shame is I’m only six months in and I’ve already reviewed this and Rumours, so we reached the top a little prematurely. All downhill from here.

Was recommended this album several times... only knew mercy mercy me but it didnt disappoint

whole house confused

The 1st track is a 3/5, I enjoyed the track, but it's not something I would add to my main playlist. The 2nd track is a 3/5, I enjoyed the track, but it's not something I would add to my main playlist. The 3rd track is a 3/5, I enjoyed the track, but it's not something I would add to my main playlist. The 4th track is a 3/5, I enjoyed the track, but it's not something I would add to my main playlist. The 5th track is a 3/5 short song about how God is merciful. The 6th track is a 3/5, I enjoyed the track, but it's not something I would add to my main playlist. The 7th track is a high 2/5, it isn't a bad song, I just don't like the cranking noise I hear in my right earphone. The 8th track is a 3/5, I enjoyed the track, but it's not something I would add to my main playlist. The 9th track is a 3/5, I enjoyed the track, but it's not something I would add to my main playlist. I would give this album a 3/5 I enjoyed the songs, but they weren't stuff I would go out of my way to listen to, so I'm not going to add any of them to my main playlist.

*listened before the project* *the guy who didn’t know what’s happening in this world.

Iconic no notes

An album whose message resonates just as deeply today as it did 55 (!) years ago, when it was first released. What’s Going On is a defining statement - not only Marvin Gaye’s finest work, but one of the greatest albums ever to grace our ears. A healing transmission for our troubled times, created by a troubled artist. And what a towering, life-affirming, love-affirming achievement he gave us. Transcendence. Bliss!

Love the voice and the messages of this album, not so big into the christian messages Fav songs - What's Going On, Save The Children 3/5

This album has a texture you can feel with your ears. Favs: What's Going On, God Is Love, Mercy Mercy Me.

Idk how I haven't listened to this album alone but it's damn amazing. He really set the tone with this project. And listening to it in 2026, I'm hearing samples that I've heard for years and years in other music. Just utterly timeless.

Another all time classic. One of the first themed R&B albums. The whole thing just works as one big song.

Favorite track(s): What's Going On, What's Happening Brother, Flyin' High (In the Friendly Sky), Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology), Right On, Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler) Of course it stands up on relisten, but I couldn't help thinking of There's a Riot Goin' On the whole time. Hopefully I see it someday soon. Heard before Previous rating: 9/10

it was good, just not the type of music I'd listen to

Not my jam but still good

I mean, it's pretty much perfect isn't it. I could pick the odd hole if I was being pedantic, but fundamentally it's the absolute pinnacle of this style. Immediate 5.

Why I picture myself in NYC when I listen to this?

Not my favorite but omg so much better than the last two

I understand why this gets all the accolades since it was a Motown artist breaking out and talking about what’s going on (if you will) in the world after years of mostly lovey-dovey hits across the Motown family. The songs here are quite fine but this doesn’t quite get to a 5 for me. Will this be another Purple Rain where I spoil a 5 across the board?

I’ve listened to this many times and each time I wish I could love it the way so many people do. The title track and “mercy mercy me” reach those heights, and I think everything else is good.

Hands down one of the greatest funk/soul albums ever made. Top three for me with Superfly and Cold Sweat--can't pick an order between those three masterpieces. Clean 5/5 and superlative on every level.

#6: Marvin Gaye - What's Going On. I think this is the one album I have not heard a single bad thing about. If the internet music community ever claimed a "perfect" album, this would be that album. I won't be as lenient however. If this album pisses me off I will let it know. Track 1: What's Going On. Ooh this is fun. The vocals sound empowering and exciting and the chorus is an earworm. Wowie this is a good opener. 8/10. Track 2: What's Happening Brother. Marvin seems very confused with these track titles. Another pretty decent track. Nothing really to complain about but also nothing really noticable for me at least. Also finally the most popular track isn't the worst. 7/10. Track 3: Flyin' High (In The Friendly Sky). Fitting title as this shit is making me levitate. Also is it just me or does this production remind me of some of Tyler, The Creator's songs like FIND YOUR WINGS or November? 9/10. Track 4: Save The Children. I can't believe Marvin Gaye predicted Generative AI being used in schools. Jokes aside this song resonates with me something different. I grew up in time to watch all my favourite childhood places. Swimming centres, local parks, food markets, corner stores. All either reduced to rubble or just another boarded up building on the high streets. This song reached into my soul and revived something in me. Save The Children. 10/10. Track 5: God Is Love. GOD IS GOOOOD! GOD IS GREEEAT! GOD IS GOOOOOD! 7/10 Track 6: Mercy Mercy Me (The Ecology). How could an album so happy and jovial sounding be telling me "Yo, ya'll fucked up and humanity's gonna die in a hundred years once I'm gone" at the same time? 9/10. Track 7: Right On. There are few songs I consider rewarding of a 7+ minute runtime. Acrid Avid Jam Shred by Aphex Twin. I Want You (She's So Heavy) by The Beatles. Track 8: Wholy Holy. Now he's just ripping off Geordie Greep. SMH. Jokes once again aside this track isn't doing much for me at all. It's just kinda...meandering. 5/10. Track 9: Inner City Blues (Make Me Wanna Holler). The most serious sounding song on the album. Kinda an odd choice to end the album on a mostly dour note after several tracks of hope and encouragement. Still a good track though and probably my favourite sonically. Just kinda of a weird note to end the album on. 9/10. Overall I can see why this album is so praised and beloved. With only 1 real dud in it's whole tracklist I can see myself coming back to this frequently. Favourite Track: Save The Children Least Favourite Track: Wholy Holy Overall: 9/10 (⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐)

Musically, this album is a masterpiece. It is just that none of the lyrics hit home because I wasn't here when this album came out. That being said, I will probably listen to this when I need to cry. Marvin Gaye has maybe the best voice in music history and he uses it so f-ing well. Even with that though, I still love the sax solo in Mercy Mercy Me and the flute in Right On. I also love that this album is not first half carried and that it has many of its hits throughout. The songs did feel kind of similar though so I don't think I can give it a five even if it win like 80 million awards. And it's also a little bit too short. Highlights: Mercy Mercy Me and Right On Honorable Mention: What's Going On 7/10 stars

Don't remember much but this was some nice soulful music for how nice and rainy it was. Better than Frank Ocean? Favorite(s): God is love Least: Flyin' high 2.5/5

Fav: Right On, Mercy Mercy Me L: Save the Children 3.5 I don't have much to say about this one. Cover: 3 Pretty standard Name: 3 Minecraft Parody: Minin' High (Above Diamond Blocks)

Very nice full album Lovely songs

The GOAT

Already just listened to this lmao. When it’s actually doing a fully done song it’s peak, but there’s a lot of nonsense imo. Well not nonsense but like… why am I gonna listen to anything that isn’t What’s going on, God is Love, and Mercy Mercy Me?

Unbearable. Except Inner City Blues.

An album of historical significance, pleasant enough. Title track is a classic and his voice is sublime. But a 3 nonetheless

A classic that still holds up.

Such a seamless flow. Almost like it’s all one big song. Lovely as always, all the same problems prevail.

This is #day791 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and... here's to my second Marvin Gaye record. Not so long ago, I revisited Let's Get It On and bumped it up to a 4. Now, What's Going On? It was fun to learn about the concept, and the tracks do flow into one another almost unnoticeably, but it's all just too soulful. Musically, side B is more adventurous, if you will. If I had to pick which album by this guy to revisit, I'd most likely put on Let's Get It On. Let it be a 3 out of 5. Looking forward to #day792.

Nice and smooth