Album Summary
So Much for the City is the debut album of the Irish indie/pop band The Thrills. It was released on 27 May 2003 and quickly achieved success in Ireland, spending 61 weeks in the top 75 of the Irish Albums Chart. The album also won 'Album of the Year' at the national music awards. In an interview, lead singer Conor Deasy explained the band's inspiration for the song material: Those songs are our ways of picking us up because we were kind of miserable. We were dropped by our label. And the towns are put [in the songs] as a way of escapism, as opposed to documenting little tales about what happened when we went there. When we put in a title like "Santa Cruz (You're Not That Far)," it would literally pick us up a bit. The album was nominated for the 2003 Mercury Prize but lost to Dizzee Rascal's Boy in da Corner. The album was included in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. The song "Santa Cruz (You're Not That Far)" was ranked by Q Magazine at number 550 on their list of the 1001 best songs ever made. The song "Say It Ain't So" appeared on US President George W. Bush's iPod in 2005.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
This was relatively bland while not being bad. 3 stars.
Irish guys have no business singing this much about California
A sort of Irish Wilco kind of thing, but wanting to be the Beach Boys for some reason. The song writing is pretty solid but the pedal-steel is sometimes a little too insistent for my liking
"The song "Say It Ain't So" appeared on US President George W. Bush's iPod in 2005." Je sais que je m'arrête sur un truc osef, mais qu'est-ce qu'on est censé comprendre ? Est-ce qu'il y a eu un leak en 2005 des playlists de George Bush ? Est-ce que c'est censé être bien ? Pourquoi est-ce que c'est considéré comme suffisamment significatif dans l'histoire de cet album qu'il le met au même niveau que les classements du groupe dans diverses publications déjà elles-mêmes plutôt louches ? L'article utilisé comme source par l'article de Wikipédia était caché derrière un paywall, on ne le saura peut-être jamais. Bref, en ce qui concerne l'album, j'ai pas trouvé ça incroyable et c'est entré par une oreille et sorti par l'autre. Non pas que j'ai trouvé ça nul, c'était même sympathique, mais pas assez pour me laisser une impression durable. Je ne suis pas sûr de pourquoi ça figure dans la liste, encore une fois.
O, Ok, it’s just like some kind of background music in a random cafe.
Belle and Sebastian vibes. Cool stuff.
hm ich kenn sie nöd s tönt sehr noch indie 2000er mit banjo und so. flaming lips type? ah sie sind us irland? mir gfallt don't steal our sun bis etz am beste. no cool so de viertel hämmere dings. deckchairs and cigarettes tönt cool ussert sini brechend stimm holt mi etz nöd soo ab. bin mit de stimm nöd warm worde aber s isch meeega 60er revival mit moderner produktion und super cool gspielt glaub e vieri.
Number: 312 Familiarity: None (1) Rating: 4 Before: ======= I think I've heard of them? Maybe, or not? During: ======= Oh, they're Irish? Could have fooled me. After : ======= Pleasant enough but nothing remarkable. Not sure why it's on this list. However, indie twang is right up my alley these days so I could listen to this again, and I think I will. I ended up adding 3 tracks to my 2003 list.
One of the few albums that hasn't grown on me. In fact, quite the opposite. For an Irish band, they ain't half trying to sound American. Songs about American cities, steel guitars, then the banjo kicks in. I thought they were American until I looked them up on Wikipedia. This album was all sugar on first listen, but like a stick of rock, I could feel my teeth starting to rot by the second playthrough. 2½
Decent piece of Irish music here
More British mediocrity, yay... Retro rock without a single distinguishing mark that would make it stand out from the pack. Definitely not essential.
Decent, a little boring. He sounds like he is trying to go for Neil Young voice vibe. Not entirely sure he pulled it off.
This was pretty cool and mostly enjoyable. Kind of just generic indie rock. Nothing to complain about. I think I would like it more if I gave it a few more listens? I liked it a lot. Chill, vibey, surfy. I listened to this while I made breakfast today.
Santa cruz (you're not that far) - 3 Big sur - 3 Don't steal our sun - 3 Deckchairs and cigarettes - 3 One horse town - 3 Old friends, new lovers - 2 Say it ain't so - 3 Hollywood kids - 3 Just travelling through - 3 Your love is like las vegas - 3 'Til the tide creeps in - 3
I was a fan and saw them twice, this album has aged well - a nice breezy americana vibe
Twangy country adjacent music with harmonica is always going to be a tough sell for me. Unsurprisingly I didn't like this.
Lidt moderne banjo-folkrock. Der gemte sig et par velkendte numre imellem.
Definitely sounds indie. They're from Ireland, talking about California. Songs aren't bad, just not memorable or interesting. 2.2/5
Not bad, not great. Doubt I'd listen again.
Sucks
Imagine if The view was an Irish band. Yeah, it’s like that.
I was going to write a big review using descriptors like derivitive and poor modern copy of... but lets just get down to it. While the harmonies of multiple voices are nice the leads voice is not pleasant on its own. Everything sounds like stolen bits of old songs by the Beach Boys and Neil Young mashed together and I dont mean that in a complimentary way. I guess this strikes a chord if you like a more modern version of the california folk pop of the mid to late 60s or if you were too young to have really heard any of it. No new ground is being broken here and there is no need for this on a list that could contain the vast options of music available.
Was George W. Bush having one of their songs on iPod enough of a reason to put this bland album on this list?
Enjoyment: 9/10 Replayability: 8/10 Cohesion: 8/10 Flow/Pacing: 8/10 Artistic Merit: 7/10 Weighted Average: 8.2/10 Review: Now this was an absolutely pleasant listen. I've never heard of The Thrills, but they have the kind of music that I was hoping to discover with this list, much like when I discovered Fleet Foxes earlier on. I will be listening to this many more times, I can already tell. Liked Song(s): Santa Cruz (You're Not That Far), Big Sur, One Horse Town, Old Friends, New Lovers, 'Til The Tide Creeps In Disliked Song(s): (None) Recommend? Yes Heard Before? No
Album 1098. “Nominated for the Mercury Prize” remains an undefeated harbinger of pure shit.
This was an interesting listen, kind of reminded me of Flaming Lips a bit. I'm overall a 3 here but it's a pretty good album.
???
The problem here is the rating system. This is better than some of the dross I have given a 3 but not as good as the albums I have rated a 4. So it's a throur for me
Even if this band were playing across the street for nothing, I don't think I could be arsed to go and see them. Unless they were handing out free beers, then I might consider it. Still wouldn't have a good time though. Not the worst album on this list. Just all a bit meh.
Just a bit boring.
Oooh, nostalgia
Very meh
This was perfectly fine for what it is, which is something I'm not fond of. Thus a 2.5
Now that was some bullshit. But still significantly better than Mariah Carey’s bullshit.
Not as good as I remembered. Some lovely songs but very samey.
Not what I expected... fuckinh hate the singer's voice with a passion
So many great songs on here! This encapsulates the 2000’s indie scene perfectly, and there’s some songs on here I can call some of my favorite! I’ll have to check these guys out more on my own time sometime soon.
la definición de mid, 2,5/5
All the songs sound the same
Dreamy Country surfer music about California from Ireland. Who thought that would be amazing? If Weezer decided to make a country inspired album after Pinkerton. A Wilco vibe. It really is confounding that this somehow works. They have songwriting skills that Nashville would kill for. Their songs do tend to blend together but if you're down with what they're putting down. It's all good. A pleasant surprise. 4
Cool, but not thrilling
This was pure nostalgia for me. When i saw it i was really confused how this was on the list but glad i relistened as i really enjoyed it again. Highlights were the singles.
Another band I never followed. But they're really good.
Not too bad some good songs
Haven't heard of them. Truly unremarkable and inoffensive indie music. Just boring. Nothing more I can say about it 2/5
Soft och behaglig musik, Big Sur och Your Love Is Like Las Vegas bäst. 3,5 av 5.
Solid listenable but a bit of one pace and feel.
Really fun, right up my alley. Not sure how this one passed .e by back in the day, tbh.
Ehh I’ll come back to it. First impression vote- 2.8
Temu Beach Boys
Good stuff. Somewhere right in the middle of country and alt-rock, with plenty of space to hear the lyrics.
Hmmm. Zj sm pri četrtem komadu ("Deckchairs and Cigarettes" - k je soliden, boljš k prejšnji komadi). Vajb je očiten, late 60s American pop, me je pa glas pevca oziroma njegovo izgovarjanje besed zmotilo že fakin takoj. To je nek ta early 2000s način petja, k mi že takrat ni potegnil. (Ne bi dojela sama od sebe, da so Irci.) Ugh no, k nek Beach Boys tribute band. S prbližn tok inovativnosti, kokr ga cover bandi imajo - nič.
So soft, it wouldn’t be even in the 5.000 best albums.
eh not bad
Blandly inoffensive. Out of context it would be perfectly fine. It's competently played and breezy. But the context is that this is an album you absolutely must hear and that couldn't be further from the truth.
What we have here ladies and gentlemen is the Silverchair of indie rock.
Good chill sound. Reminds me of Elliott Smith
1.83
It sounds like an Indie Rock/Pop album. It's a pretty good album and it sounds really good! It's got it's own unique sound that it can only really fit into the broadband genre of Indie music. Wonderful album!
Yeah I’m gonna pass. I really question how some albums get on this list. You’re telling me this album is in the same category as Hendrix, The Beatles and Stevie Wonder? Yeah…sure, Jan.
This sounds like an Irish knockoff of Guster mixed with a bit of Doves. It's pretty bland overall, and nothing here really stands out enough to make me want to give it another listen.
Loved this, Nice indie/chill rock sound
This album could be the poster child for this UK- centric list. An album that reaches number 1 in Ireland and top 3 in Scotland and the UK, and does fuck all in the rest of the world. It’s about what you’d expect from some local bar band, provided the town was very small, and the bar not the best one in town, and the patrons too drunk to care. And it takes 7 of them to make this flaccid drivel.
Dimery clearly needed to fill his last few spots with recent albums for the first edition of the book, looked at a list of somewhat well-reviewed albums from 2003, and randomly picked out this super forgettable album by guys who went to California once and musically just copied the Flaming Lips.
The Thrills' debut album start off with three upbeat tracks. They're clearly indie pop songs, very giddy and bouncy, but there are plenty of country elements in all of them. They feel very jammy, and go on stomping for quite a while after it feels like the last chorus should have ended. The fourth track introduces the second kind of song here, which is half country ballad, half indie rock piano ballad. Like the others it kind of stays in its lane and feels a bit long. Nothing much changes after that: this is very fun indie pop that doesn't do anything that will wow you but also doesn't make any mistakes. The vocals sound like an emo Wayne Coyne and can enhance the songs in the right places. Not super memorable, but still an enjoyable listen.
70s folk radio vibe; nice album.
Generational run by this site right now. This is my 4th 5 star in a row. Everything just clicks here. It’s a little spooky and sad and happy when it needs to be. Perfecto
The Thrills sound more like Americana than Alternative, but since they’re from Ireland, does that make it Irishana? Irelanda? Whatever you want to call it, I’m not entirely sold. I’m also not a huge fan of their lead singer, who sounds like he wandered in from The Flaming Lips and somehow ended up fronting an Americana band. So Much for the City was fine. Nothing offensive, nothing particularly memorable, and certainly nothing that moved any mountains. It came, it went, and I’m not sure I’ll be missing it.
If you need something so middle of the road that you forgot you even started to listen to it, this one's for you. Big Sur seemed familiar for some reason, but I can't place why. I didn't find this particularly exciting or interesting, but you might.
This music makes for nice relaxing background music, the lyrics are definitely background music worthy. A lot about their time in California
Santa Cruz (You're Not That Far) - 75 Big Sur - 78 Don't Steal Our Sun - 77 Deckchairs And Cigarettes - 77 One Horse Town - 76 Old Friends, New Lovers - 73 Say It Ain't So - 82 Hollywood Kids - 68 Just Traveling Through - 71 Your Love Is Like Las Vegas - 73 Till The Tide Creeps In - 72 Plans - 74 So Much For The City - 73
Big Sur
I cant finish this, I hate the singer. It's a bit unfortunate because there is some fun genre mixing going on but it gets dominated by a strong western vibe which pushes it into indifference for me. Also, fuck the singer.
Actually really enjoyed this. Very pleasant listening
If this twee Belle and Sebastian rip-off wasn't so preoccupied with name dropping Californian cities it would have scored higher for me. Shocking to find out they're Irish and, frankly, I'm not sure if that makes the California obsession better or worse.
i like what they're doing with this album enough, but we get it...you went to california. some of their songs also felt kind of repetitive, but liked "old friends, new lovers".
Not on Apple Music but need rating to move on
redelijk
With the exception of the vocals (you can tell they're not Welsh because there are seven of them and HE'S the best singer) they nailed the sound; and it's really well recorded. But there is nothing original, memorable, interesting, or emotionally engaging going on here. Classic Dimery that (700 albums in) Yacht Rock is unrepresented, but I should listen to this weird, 2003, imitation of the vibe.
Wasn't awful, but also wasn't interesting. The lyrics are very bad at times too.
A significantly worse version of Bright Eyes Best Song: Big Sur Rating: 5/10 Stars: 3
I got this album the day after The Monkees. Which band was the fake one singing light airy Beatles-inspired pop songs about a 1960s California that never existed? I’m so confused… 2⭐️
Larping at its best, but the music isnt (2.0/5.0)
This sounds like almost every other pop rock album from the early 2000s. Some are done a lot better. Rooney and Fountains of Wayne better have made this list if this album did. 1.5/5
It’s repetitive, with one of the most grating vocalists on the list in my opinion. That wispy and whiny voice does not work well. I did enjoy the steel guitar layered throughout though.
Judged this album by the cover and got exactly what I expected. This is some of the most 2003 sounding indie rock I've ever heard. Common sense and taste prevailed in handing the Mercury Prize to Dizzee Rascal’s Boy In Da Corner, an album thousands of times more listenable than this dross. I’m so bored.
This one reminded me of early college days watching The O.C. Turns out that the band was on an episode playing 3 songs. It really conjured up some nostalgia.
4/10
I couldn't get through 3 songs. Just did nothing for me.
Had never heard of. But enjoyed it
It was ok. Slightly dull repetitive lyrics. I’ve never heard of them before. 2.5
Interesting. Sounds like Drive By Truckers but Irish?
Trashy yankee wannabe
Listenable, but not great or memorable.
music is love
It started out good and I really liked some of the first couple songs. After that however it kinda fell off and became mediocre at best.
It was... okay. It started out nice but dwindled down relatively quickly and became really unremarkable. Had so much potential, it's sad.
I don’t think this album belongs on this list, it strikes me as extremely derivative and cutesy and borderline cynical but I am extending grace and choosing to believe that these Irish lads were just that overwhelmed by California. I’ve from the west coast and have never understood the allure of the Golden State but if you’re from Ireland I guess I can see the appeal. Anyway I don’t think it deserves 3.5 stars but I’m giving it 3.5 stars anyway because I am not a discerning music consumer and I REALLY enjoyed listening to it lol my neurons are activated by the jangly indie sound and Flaming Lips lite vocals like the monkey in that meme picture. Will presumably disappear completely from my memory by Monday but I played it in the background all day and it was super duper easy listening. And then I put on Yoshimi Battles the Pink Robots for the real fix. Second act montage needle drop in my biopic: “Plans” (cheeky cheeky to have a little hidden track in there)
Help! I’m trapped in a filler episode of Scrubs.
Fellas, they're calling it the most los angeles california album to ever exist Despite my general grumpiness about media where it seems like the world begins and ends in southern california, I really liked this album. I am a sucker for harmonica, lush instrumental layering, and harmonization, and this album really delivered that with some jangle. Its cute, its sweet, I can imagine putting this on for a day at work if I wanted to roleplay being some mediocre white guy with soulful eyes working a dead end office job in the early 2000s. Really hard to choose between three and four stars for this one, but the more I sit on it the more I feel like its a four to me. I liked it, it was sweet and soulful. Likelihood that the members of this band lezzed out IMO: tricky tricky one, they seem very soulful and tender which makes you think they might be being tender with Each Other, but honestly the amount they sing about LA, which is in my mind the straightest city on earth (I don't want your opinions these are my opinions) makes me give them a 1/5. womp womp. sometimes the soulful ones are straight.