It was much more alternative and experimental than I expected, but I only had a passing familiarity with Wilco. I think I liked it

Interesting but somewhat repetitive. Lots of funky drummer with electronic dance vibes. I was grooving, but not earth shattering

Really interesting. Especially the vocals that weren't Freddy

So great! Solid vocal performance plus great backup vocals

I didn't love this. Most of the songs were kind of gutless. I like the edgy vocals of Ray Charles but most of these were early 60s easy-listening style

Incredible album.

Really good album! I had heard the classics from the Greatest Hit comp, but there was more really good stuff on here.

Oooh! So fun! very talented musicians and I enjoyed the swing vibe

Not super exciting. Roadhouse Blues is the best but I didn't get into the rest

Pretty incoherent as to theme. Are those girls nasty or are they independent?

This album was a bunch of fun. It was mostly right up my alley for grungy 90s rock

I want to like Radiohead but I can't. It just all feels so pretentious

Lots of good competent jazz-tinged pop rock. No real excitement

Fun 90s punk

Good Bacharach standards, well sung. It just goes on a bit too long

I love this album so much. I thought it was just nostalgia but a fresh listen confirms it.

Wonderful!

Phenomenal players, but the lyrics in most of the songs are just so stupid.

Classic!

It's got Bohemian Rhapsody and my wedding song.

Couldn't listen to this. Not enjoyable

Incredible vocals

Once you get past the annoying synching/unsynching opening and closing tracks, the rest of the album is really solid. Good beats. Halcyon is a standout

Some of the tracks are quite good, but this drags in places

I knew nothing about this album, but I was pleasantly surprised. It was a cool stripped down vibe. Easy going heartbreak

Not really for me

It's fine, but it's not a great album overall. Superstition is super, but lots of fluff

I appreciate what this album is trying to do, but the style is not for me

I just can't

Such a good vibe. I came into this cold with no expectations, and was bopping and dancing within the first couple of songs. It's an early 60s movie vibe, redone for the modern ear. More like Kingsman The Secret Service than James Bond. Groovy baby

I was surprised how much of this is just hard rock blues. It's great!

Unlistenable. I tried

It's a fine album but not my taste

A classic! It has its flaws as a performance, but captures an event

It was much more alternative and experimental than I expected, but I only had a passing familiarity with Wilco. I think I liked it

Perhaps the literal best

Interesting but somewhat repetitive. Lots of funky drummer with electronic dance vibes. I was grooving, but not earth shattering

Amazing!

I appreciate this for what it is, but it was not for me

There were moments when the jazz was working for me, but the unlistenable opening track, plus the vocals ruined it. Since I managed to enjoy some of it I will grant it 2 stars

I was conflicted until I found a way to listen to this that wouldn't put any money in Kanye's pocket. This was my first listen and, although I have enjoyed individual works by Kanye, I hadn't experienced this as an album. It was like very little I had listened to before. I didn't expect the humour, the skits, the contrast between self-deprecation and self-aggrandizing. The rhymes are so good, the beats are amazing. I listened to every word of the 1 hour, 20 minute album and at the end I just felt sad. This album made me laugh and gasp and dance, but I felt sad for what the man is today. I don't know if Kanye in 2005 had the same opinions and beliefs that he has today and was just good at masking them, or has untreated mental illness and 20 years of fame changed him into what he is now. Since I'm rating the album and not the man, this is 5 stars. A 5 star album for me has to be something that I genuinely enjoy, but also appreciate for a unique approach, or a groundbreaking effort, or a contribution to music that deserves recognition. 5 stars doesn't require perfection but it does require innovation or creativity or generational talent. I see no reason not to recognize that here while boycotting the man in 2025.

Probably my favorite album of all time

I expected to like this more

I realize I've never listened to this group before. I enjoyed it a whole lot

I just can't do it. It feels like a novelty act

Unapologetic folk album with the power and vibrato of Joan Baez's voice to carry it through

So fun! Kind of dumb but I'm loving it. Pop punk rhyming couplets without much of a point beyond the songs itself

This feels like The Who trying to figure out who they are. I didn't expect the blues tracks. The stand-out standards are by far the best songs (My Generation, The Kids Are Alright) where you really see the direction they will eventually go. The rest is fine and you can hear Keith playing those drums which is what I need. Not my favourite though.

I've been typically lukewarm on Lana Del Rey, although sometimes the big sweeping songs like "Ride" have swept me up. So I've never listened to a full album of hers until now. This was very impressive. Her voice was interesting as she moved from the highs to the lows. I'm still not convinced she's a good singer, but many of my favourite singers aren't technically good singers. The music and the production of some of the songs is nuanced and subtle, but still engaging. And the inclusion of "For Free", not exactly the best-known Joni Mitchell song, made me emotional. A fantastic conclusion to the album, tying together the themes and subjects of the songs that came before.

A classic! The one miss is "I'm in Touch With Your World" which sounds like an elementary school band trying to write a Talking Heads song. The rest of it is just a delight. Nearly every track is a classic rock radio hit, and the few new-to-me songs were great as well.

Tough one today because I was moving and grooving to the rhythm, and then I started listening to the lyrics. Oh no. Between the casual racism, the misogyny, the sex stuff and then the weird sex stuff, it's hard to find something to love. Still, I was grooving so I can't say I hated all of it

It's a great live album

I just could not get into this

I'm not the audience here.

Hits me in my 90s grungy heart.

I just do not have the space for this in my life

Really boring and overly mellow

I disliked this, but that seems like a failing of mine

Goofy fun

Purely subjective, but this was the vibe I needed today. Ask me tomorrow and you might get a different answer. This album is beautiful and cool.