Album Summary
Clandestino is the first full-length solo album by Manu Chao, released in 1998. The album contains many soundbites throughout, two of which are bits of a speech by Subcomandante Marcos and, like Chao's subsequent albums, was mostly recorded by the musician himself in various locations around the world, using a small laptop—which is referred to in the liner notes as Estudio Clandestino. The French edition of Rolling Stone magazine named this album the 67th greatest French rock album (out of 100). The album was also included in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. The album was ranked number 469 in Rolling Stone's list of the 500 Greatest Albums of All Time in 2020.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
I really enjoyed this! Satisfyingly lo-fi, catchy, distinctive. Even though I don’t speak the language, I found myself enjoying the lyricism, if that makes sense.
This mosaic music is charming, has a chewiness as if the tape was rubbed with a coin, but seems to lack a centre, trading in comfortably familiar styles far past the tumultuous, sometimes riotous environments that they emerged from. Reference to revolutionaries are set-dressing, homemade margaritas drunk in bedrooms decorated with that old Ché Guevara poster. You know the one.
"..the 67th greatest French rock album.."?! Say no more, fam
I've come to the conclusion that the language of lyrics in any music is not supremely important. I speak a tiny amount of French and Spanish, certainly not enough to understand the majority of the meaning in these tracks, but that didn't materially affect my level of enjoyment. Who knows, maybe if he had sung in English it would have been worse. Musically the album is ok, very sparse instrumentally, nothing groundbreaking. I made it all the way through so it's a minimum of 2 stars, but I can see why some people may rate it more highly than me.
Mid. 2.5/5
A big surprise Wasn't expecting much, but this one grooves. Few stand out tracks but more impressed by recurring musical themes, particularly in the first half. Will probably keep this one saved and come back to it more then I would have expected.
What an excellent mix of different genres. This album would’ve never been on my radar, but it’s as brilliant as it is diverse. Also this was the only album that could restore my hope in this collection after hearing Sweetheart of the Rodeo by the Byrds.
Bilingual punk rock for the global audience
Some was pretty cool, some sounded like a cartoon singing. Rounded up from 3.5 because I’m tired of giving threes to “must listen” albums.
Typique chansons mexicain, ressemble un peu à du buena vista club. C’est pas mal la même vibe tout le long
It is always interesting to see how other countries adapt to sounds that did not originate within the borders of their respective home, but Manu Chao's interpretation on Dub music mixed with his very alternative and unique take on Latin and French music is very intriguing to say the least. It doesn't feel as sunny as a "beach album" but it also doesn't feel as fluffy to be a "stoner album" either, it ventures around between those two loose labels as a much more contemporary and exploratory dive into the culture surrounding Manu Chao. As much as I enjoyed the relaxing feel of this project, not a lot stuck out to myself and it really just helped pass the time more than anything else. I am obviously missing context due to the language barrier this album has, but if the lyrics are anything like the music itself then I don't feel like I am missing much. A very interesting look into Manu's balance between his French upbringing and his, at the time, his life in Spain. So cool to see two very different cultures blending together even if I didn't really care for it too much.
I have not heard this before and I have never heard of Manu Chao before. So this is mostly reggae and has a bit of that 90s reggae sound that I really don’t like, but there’s some unconventional instrumentation that improves it. There is one problem in that it’s still 90s reggae. Luckily it’s broken up by some exploration into cumbia and for lack of a better term, worldbeat, so that it’s not so repetitive. With all this in mind I can safely call it a decent album even though it’s 90s reggae, with the exception that I don’t plan on listening to it again.
High 3 , I like the vibe and low fi production
How delightful to be reminded of the existence of 'Bongo bong'. A hit if ever I've heard one. While the rest of the album is in a slightly different style, it compliments it well and is a cheery, inspiring listen. It's definitely an album you want to have heard.
Manu Chao gets a high 3, some great stuff here, good vibes all round but not quite my flavour
Lowkey circular.
A nice enough bit of world music but it felt like it lacked a bit of identity and was trying to cater for too many markets.
Was expecting to hate it, but this surprised me a little. ‘Bongo bongo’ sounds like a Gorillaz b-side, ‘lagrimas de oro’ like something from the Burma Vista Social Club. The more reggae influenced stuff I could take or leave a lot more, but there was at least enough of interest to warrant listening to.
Yeah, it’s OK. I get why it’s on the list. It’s not my thing, but it’s different, and I guess it makes sense. So, sure. It’s not another Beatles album, so…success.
This album brings back memories. It’s a bit quirky, but cool at the same time. It gives me a feeling of summer. Some of the songs sounds a little too much of the same. Favourites: Bongo Bong, Clandestino, Mama Call and Mentira
Disappointingly modern. I blame the 1990's over compressed and desire to lo-fi things. This music is so lively and bright you can't dull the things that makes it special. Its not a TOTAL spat on the face of the genre that constantly inspires me. But, it certainly is not what I want in my Latin American/Spanish music. So bearing that in mind its fine for someone just not a cunt like I.
Manu Chao’s masterpiece Clandestino is an absolute banger of a record that effortlessly bridges linguistic, cultural, and sonic divides, proving that music needs no translation to resonate on a profound emotional level. Even for a listener who might not fully grasp every Spanish or French lyric, the album is a masterclass in cohesion and vibe, marching forward with nearly zero misses from start to finish. It kicks off with an instantly gripping hook on the title track and the steady momentum of "Desaparecido," before launching into undeniable highlights like the infectious, hypnotic groove of "Bongo Bong" and its brilliant, seamless transition into the French-language companion piece "Je ne t'aime plus." The journey continues to unfold through inspired textures—from the groovy percussion and captivating background spoken-word rap on "Mentira..." and "Lágrimas de Oro," to the catchy, inventive musical elements packed into "Malegría"—while cuts like "Welcome to Tijuana" and "Mama Call" keep the energy vibrant and unpredictable. Beyond the individual tracks, what truly elevates the album into legendary status is its immaculate production and sequencing; the pristine recording, mixing, and mastering allow every field recording, acoustic strum, and eclectic sample to breathe, all while the tracks flow seamlessly into one another to create a singular, immersive sonic landscape that wraps up with the cathartic, perfect wind-down of "El Viento."
perfecto para viajes sin lugar a dudas
Manu Chao is at that conjunction of spheres that also includes Bohdi from Point Break, Hansel from Zoolander and every white guy with dreads who's ever played ¨Redemption Song¨ on acoustic guitar at a party without anyone asking him to. There's a certain type of Euro/Latin trash person who smokes bad weed and hops the metro turnstile and talks about ¨making party¨ and I had an ex like this who changed my life a bit. Lame, maybe, but also really fucking cool.
This sound just isn’t for me I’m afraid.
Sure don't know who this is for, but it is not me.
La musique en espagnol a une saveur particulière qui marche bien avec moi, mais c'était un peu trop lancinant pour aller au 5
Nah
Have no idea how this album made the list. It is all over the place and I am not surprised that I never heard of this artist.
It was pleasant to listen to, but not really something I’d choose to play.
Good Latin record
spanish
Generational Banger
Felt kind of like vacation beach music. Something playing in a beach cafe in the Caribbean. Not offensive, but just hard to get excited about.
Warm and well-made. Kind on the ears. Something that was nice to listen to but I won’t be revisiting; it feels a little scattered and the massive compression gives this a same-y feeling rather than a lofi charm. You can hear that it was made on a laptop, which I respect the effort of but struggle with the resulting production.
Thoroughly enjoyed this - played twice.
un énorme classique
Piiiiiiiiiiiiiingggg... Radio Mano Papa Chango! Dit album kwam alweer bijna dertig jaar geleden tot ons en was meteen een frisse explosie van vrolijkheid, meertaligheid, positiviteit, gekke stemmetjes en relaxte ritmes. Wereldmuziek in Latino-sfeer kortom, van deze Fransoos. Ik had deze al heel vaak gedraaid en daar ga ik vrolijk mee door. Als je deze plaat luistert, is er nog hoop voor de mensheid. Te espero siempre mi amor, tequila sexo marijuana, el viento viene, el viento se va.
De beste albums zijn vaak degene die herinneringen oproepen en Clandestino van Manu Chao is zo'n album. Bijvoorbeeld aan een youth hostel in Barcelona, waar dit 24/7 draaide bij de receptie. Overigens werd dat hostel aangeraden door een zure broeder aan een zure broeder, maar deze had er niet bij vermeld dat het een soort ondergrondse kelder was in de rosse buurt van Barcelona. Of de herinnering aan een weekendje in de Ardennen, waar veel Jupille en belgische specialiteiten werden genuttigd, terwijl we de boef probeerden te grijpen met een potje Scotland Yard en een andere gast een kathedraal van een luchtbed probeerde op te pompen. De humor is voor de insiders die erbij waren, want dit zijn gedeelde herinneringen. En zo kan ik me best voorstellen dat meer mensen dit hebben met Manu Chao, want die vierde echt zijn hoogtijdagen rond de eeuwwisseling. Als je de muziek nu hoort, vind ik het toch verrassend tijdloos gebleven. En ik heb het idee dat ik dit album over 20 jaar nog leuk en verfrissend ga vinden. Easy 5 sterren.
I expected a pity party and got a bar fight with feelings. Big glam energy, big emotions, zero Morrissey chill. Spins: 2 Playlist Additions - You're Gonna Need Someone on Your Side - Glamorous Glue - We'll Let You Know - We Hate It When Our Friends Become Successful
No more bongos
Meh musical arrangements and performances. It's not for me, but perhaps it would appeal to those that are on the communist spectrum. We are avoiding putting Massive Attack's MEZZANINE on the list to make room for this?
Very surprised this album made the list and also very surprised at the number of songs I recognized. It was definitely a happy listen that made me feel funky vacation vibes, but ultimately I was not super impressed. The songs felt samey and some of the talk-singing was a bit silly.
This one initially had me excited, but that slowly went away as the album progressed. Overall, he is quite talented to be able to draw so many musical styles in along with different languages to make something like this. With that being said, I felt like there was an overall sense of quantity over quality - a lot of the songs didn't feel distinct from each other and there wasn't anything in particular in my head where I was like "wow, that was something!" An easy, fun listen, but nothing spectacular to me.
A classic album of its genre that i already knew. Very nice vibe, always enjoyable to put on in the background and just get lost in the music.
I didn't dislike this but it didn't capture me enough to pay too much attention to it. It just filtered away in the background.
Better than Coldplay
Even if I take out the fact that I despise the guy for being a useful idiot y un mamaguevo chavista, It’s sad that, with so much great music from LatAm/Spain, this album makes the list. I doubt this one would even make it to my 1001 list of hispanic music
So far the number one worst album.
Nice
5/10
Fun and chill. A firm 3. Favorite track: Luna y sol
Loved it!
I really enjoyed this style of Latin music, way more than reggaeton. Great vibe in all the songs and the artist's voice and enunciations really go out with the music
Not really for me. I can almost see what he was going for, but it never really takes off.
Honestly way better than I thought it was going to be. I have no idea what he's saying, but I could feel it
Meh
Really liking this one. Good vibes and good beats. Wasn't expecting the english then the french but what do i know.
started to really blend together with the same beat
genuinely good and fun thank god!
2/5 https://rateyourmusic.com/release/album/manu-chao/clandestino/ I fucking hate that bongo song. So many of my colleagues at my student job used to play that song to death and I always hated it. So no, I was not exactly excited to listen to this. But, I gotta be fair, it was not as terrible as I thought. I still hate the bongo song, and I didn't at all care for any of the other songs whatsoever, but it was at least not as grating as the motherfucking bongo song. Except for his Portuguese pronunciation of menina. There's no ñ in the word man.
Bad enough listening to rap in English ...
This is what I imagine Hermanos Gutiérrez would sound like if they sang lyrics, so I was shocked to find out that this man grew up in Paris. This was a fun listen. Throughout the album, I went from grazing in the Spanish countryside, ripping through tiny, busy streets on a Vespa, all the way to fiesta mode. 4/5, will be listening again when I touch down for Euro summer.
que asco, hasta ahora lo peor que escuché
niezle no niezle fajne
This held my attention from note one all the way to the end. Great mix of styles, cool samples from TV and everyday life, and a great composition overall. I'll add this to my personal collection ⭐⭐⭐⭐
Mostly Spanish pop/hip hop, pretty fun
Jag är en regelbunden Manu Chau-lyssnare men jag hade inte lyssnat på detta från början till slut. Ett album som passar för de flesta tillfällen!
Jeugdsentiment
Zou ik normaliter niet zelf opzetten, maar wel goede vibes :)
It’s alright
Spanish reggae is a combo I never knew about til now, but it's some good stuff. 4.5 bumped down to 4.
I’m at a 4.5, and I’d love to leave it there, but I think I’m gonna bump it down to a 4. I mean, you can’t say it’s not entertaining. I love the flow of this album, as it demands your attention for the full 46 minutes. It’s nearly seamless from track to track, and it keeps up a pretty good pace. It’s a surprisingly cohesive album for as many topics as it touches on, as many languages as it’s sung in, and for as wildly differing the production is from track to track. It’s hard to believe this is from 1998, since it usually feels like a ‘70s album. By all accounts, it shouldn’t really work, and yet it just kinda does. However, I’m bumping this down to a 4 because I think it loses some of that glue near the tail end of the album. I loosely understand the idea of this being the tale of a roaming, wandering traveling musician who’s going around & just soaking up everything the world has to offer. It’s sort of a biographical album, and I admire the ability to capture that so well. I just think it starts to peel apart around “Día Luna...Día pena”; either that, or I simply lost track of where we were with this guy. There’s definitely a narrative of searching for love & community throughout the album, but I think it shrinks a little too much to just his perspective. It feels like the album strips too much agency from the larger world he’s crafted & built, focusing on his people, his loves, his wants & his desires, along with an inability to grab them. Granted, I’m going off of Google Translated lyrics here, so maybe I’m just entirely wrong about that. For the record, I think it’s a great album. I just think the experience & the immersion of it takes a hit when it seemingly shrinks to his world view taking center stage. It also might just be the repetition in some of the shorter tracks finally piling up to a point of mild frustration by “Minha galera”, which is probably the most ‘eh’ track here. When he’s looking at things more broadly, with a greater showcase of the world he’s traveling throughout this album, there really is something kinda special here, and embracing that through multiple languages & musical styles is something I haven’t heard before. I just wish it stuck the landing all the way through. Hence, a 4.5 that I’ll begrudgingly bump down to a 4, no matter how much I admire this. It is absolutely something people should hear before they die though, and it’s very deserving to be on the list. Maybe with a bit more time, this could go back up to a 5.
Alltså det är charmigt, svängigt, spännande, men ändå hugger det inte idag i mig. Inte nu och inte då, när det begav sig. En trea
Story behind some of his shows are so interesting and cool, I would have loved to have gone to something unique and ephemeral like that. Music is fun and up tempo, with drips of Reggae thrown in but also it's own identity apart from that. Its the kind of music you can bob your head and shoulders along to easily. Island getaway type music while cruising around on a rickety sail boat with close friends. Great music, great story.
nothing to say. Perfect
Had a good time but nothing really stuck to the wall for me. Should definitely be on the list, just not something I’m going to return to.
I liked this.
its nice and the songs transition very well
I always find it quite difficult to rate albums that are not sung in my language as it’s hard to connect with the intent and vibe etc. For the most part I was enjoying his voice and music except in the 2nd song there was a sound effect playing through out that sounded like it came from a video game. I spent the whole song trying to work out which game it was. Galaxian maybe? Anyway I digress. I am not sure where he sits in the Royal Family hierarchy but once he proclaimed himself The King Of Bongo Bong I was invested!
Fue un bombazo en su época. Merecido impacto pues sigue siendo la obra maestra de Manu Chao.
Manu Chauuuuu Ohhhhhhhh!!!! OMG they were masssssive back in the 90s when they came out, they were huge here - Alberto, the guy who ran the weight room at the gym in Perugia played it eeeeevery day for at least a year, I know every note damn him LOL they are so much fun, such an innovative album and sorry but I LOVE that at times they're singing in 4 languages, right up my alley
This is the giddy feeling when you are holding someone's hand for the first time. It's a mix of excitement. A quickened heartbeat. While also being being comfortable. Belonging. Two emotions moving together in rhythm.
The unbridled musical multiculturalism that MC honed with his 80s outfit fully blossoms on his solo outing. This is the sound of travel. No matter where you in the world it feels like something you could here in a local cafe, coming from an open window or a passing car. This is music on the move informed by a man defined by motion. Who - upon turning home to France after many years had some stories to tell. And what stories and sounds they are. Language aside - this album communicates as it communes.
Was solid, had moments that I thought it was going to break out into a grander or weirder style.
In the first half I thought this would be a 4 star, but it turns out I got about a 30 minute attention span in this genre. By the time it was done I thought it had outstayed its welcome.
For the most part I really liked this. I have no idea what the music was about but it was a vibe.
I really enjoy the genre of Latin Alternative. Admittedly, my first run-in with it was the Ween song “Voodoo Lady,” but this album here matches up nicely. Combines a lot of great Latin aesthetics with a lot of great elements from other genres that makes it a very easy to listen to album. Also, like many others, my main exposure to Chao’s work is his song “Me Gustas Tu,” which I obviously love. Title track “Clandestino” is great, somber and slick, and songs like “Mama Call” are super pretty. Generally the biggest problem is just that all the songs sound the same after a while, and there’s too many songs without enough variation. It’s not bad at all, but I kinda wish it was 10 minutes shorter. 7.6/10 DOES IT BELONG ON THE LIST: SURE REASON: IMPACT AND QUALITY-ish
Screams 90's in lots of not great ways, hit still manages to be a decent record. I guess probably expanded a few kings when it game out but suspect it's had zero lasting influence. I don't love it but struggle to find a reason to knock stars off
This was refreshing. I was a little confused by the language switches as I hadn't heard of the artist before, but the switches actually kept me more engaged.
La verdad es que es bueno, pero es inevitable asociar este álbum a puros mochileros, personas que se creen hippies con escucharlo en bares de mochileros y asociarlo con esa vibra. Entonces lo respeto, pero creo que está demasiado quemado y sobrevalora val
Naw not really
FUN TIMES
Actually quite good reggae!
latin pop, 1998 -> 3
Where do i go to dance salsa? It was kinda vibey, but nothing I'd listen to daily. (2/5)
2/5
Went in with lower expectations but was pleasantly surprised. This was a good Sunday morning listen while working on some computer work. Even left it on repeat for a few listens.
Fun, catchy, summery, breezy, and trilingual! Did not disappoint.
Catchy, me gusta. I'm raised on 40 oz to Freedom so kind of a sucker for this kind of low Spanish singing. Makes me want to rekindle my torrid affair with Duolingo.