Had some absolute bangers and some absolute ear violators, but I appreciated the genre blending nonetheless.

More organ tbh, everything was good but nothing great

I liked it, but can't say I loved it. 'Care of Cell 44' was good, then it lulled until 'This Will Be Our Year,' the best song on the album, saved the last four songs.

Expected more out of Paul, Band of the Run is a great song but otherwise underwhelming

Absolutely loved the poetic lyrics and the ambition of the album, but as interesting as it was, the music itself simply fell short

Found this enjoyable but not optimal. Samples were cool but lyrics lacking.

One of the best listens so far. Overall quality music, loved his voice over the lyrics. All songs were enjoyable.

Enjoyable. I’ll probably never listen to this album again, but it was good while it lasted. Classic indie rock vibes

This album was the first in this list where I’ve genuinely enjoyed listening to the whole thing. No track was boring and every song made me engaged. The Killers are a phenomenal band and this is them at their best

Yes, this one gets 5 stars. Maybe it’s not a full 5 star, but it’s damn close, and I’m going to round up anyways. Sound was absolutely killer, this album will forever and always get me hyped up 🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪

No hate to Joan, but 1 hour of Joan is a lot of Joan, even if Joan is an absolutely phenomenal vocalist.