This album was so so so so fun to listen to that it just deserves a 5. Will 100% be listening again. Funk just hits on another wavelength that other genres don’t

Had some absolute bangers and some absolute ear violators, but I appreciated the genre blending nonetheless.

More organ tbh, everything was good but nothing great

I liked it, but can't say I loved it. 'Care of Cell 44' was good, then it lulled until 'This Will Be Our Year,' the best song on the album, saved the last four songs.

Expected more out of Paul, Band of the Run is a great song but otherwise underwhelming

Absolutely loved the poetic lyrics and the ambition of the album, but as interesting as it was, the music itself simply fell short

Found this enjoyable but not optimal. Samples were cool but lyrics lacking.

One of the best listens so far. Overall quality music, loved his voice over the lyrics. All songs were enjoyable.

Enjoyable. I’ll probably never listen to this album again, but it was good while it lasted. Classic indie rock vibes

This album was the first in this list where I’ve genuinely enjoyed listening to the whole thing. No track was boring and every song made me engaged. The Killers are a phenomenal band and this is them at their best

Yes, this one gets 5 stars. Maybe it’s not a full 5 star, but it’s damn close, and I’m going to round up anyways. Sound was absolutely killer, this album will forever and always get me hyped up 🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪🇮🇪

No hate to Joan, but 1 hour of Joan is a lot of Joan, even if Joan is an absolutely phenomenal vocalist.

Amazing album, honestly wanted more of them though. Incredible band with some of their best all-time tracks here.

Didn’t have a ton of expectations going in, but this was a pretty solid album. Exited to hear the other Radiohead on the list, hopefully then I can make a more informed opinion on this album.

All I can say is meh. Catchy, groovy, but nonetheless meh.

I honestly loved this album. This is what this list is all about—finding awesome albums that I would’ve never found before if I was just listening. 4/5 because after a while it felt repetitive but there was enough variety where I enjoyed the whole listen. Would definitely listen again 100%

Monday, Monday and California Dreamin' are absolute classics but the rest of this album didn't do it for me unfortuantely. Somebody Groovy was also a great song but the rest just didn't hit. I'll definitely listen again later to rerate but for now its a 3/5

One of the better front-to-back albums we’ve heard so far. The live performances are pretty unbeatable, especially if it’s one from Johnny Cash. That man knows how to put on a show.

Solid, would definitely listen again to rerate, listened at like 9pm while reading a book so my attention wasn’t fully on the album

Another solid album, was a lot more accessible and fun of a listen than I originally thought looking at the Wikipedia

I had some preconceived notions about metal but this was just class musicianship. Those dudes know how to PLAY and I’m all here for it

1 hour of mid ambient noise

Songwriting and composition were fantastic, I simply just didn't jive with the music

It was alright…like I don’t know Imagine is a great song but the rest was….ok???? Maybe my expectations were too high for a former Beatles member

Nick Drake has one of the coolest vocal styles I’ve heard, and along with his guitar and other backing instrumentals, his music is absolutely superb. I will say that my only criticism is I think the violins or woodwinds sometimes overpower the song, which is ok but I’d prefer to hear them in a more subtle setting. High 4 and definitely will be listening again

I simply could not take these guys seriously 😭 At least the last 3 songs redeemed the album

Solid stuff, I vibe with Desert Blues

This album was so so so so fun to listen to that it just deserves a 5. Will 100% be listening again. Funk just hits on another wavelength that other genres don’t

Album went from chamber music to borderline reggae in parts of the last song. I appreciate the ambitious effort but it’s simply too spread out to be cohesive. Long, drawn out songs didn’t help the case either

First 4 songs have some iconic sound samples, then the album fades drastically in the middle, and picks up with the last 3 songs. Solid but I don’t think it’s his best

Iconic songs, iconic voice, iconic album. 10/10

Pretty solid album, just not refined enough yet to be as solid as the later stuff in the punk rock era

Solid album, didn’t think it was anything crazy though. Probably won’t listen again but good while it lasted

Phenomenal childhood nostalgia, their hits were absolutely fantastic and the other stuff was pretty good too.

Loved the horns throughout this one, but nothing caught my ears especially throughout. Solid and enjoyable though

Really loved this, great sound from them. Only thing stopping me from giving it a 5 is how similar-sounding some of the tracks are, would’ve liked to see some different stuff in there

Sub optimal listen, had hopes up seeing “Latin funk” on wiki page but simply too commercialized

So many good 80s hits on here. Enjoyed and solid overall, just not music I’d really listen to enjoyably for myself

I can appreciate how new this sound was but there seemed like no variation besides a few songs, just couldn’t get going with it

No hate to M.I.A. but this was simply buns, had to split up listening to save my sanity

Pretty solid but nothing special, had some good listens on there but just sounded like the average 60s folk album to me

Can’t believe people called this pretentious, a great transition between 80s bands and 2000s bands

Absolutely loved this album, such a unique listen, nothing like I’ve heard so far on this list. Yes, the 15 minute tracks can be long and repetitive, but they are well worth the wait for a patient listener

Enjoyed all the classics but didn’t resonate with me enough to get the full 5

Much groovier, jazzier, bluesier than I expected, but some tracks fell flat

A strong 4, first half was super strong but faltered towards the end

Reading these reviews talking all about how he’s a bad guy but if it weren’t for him we wouldn’t have that iconic Top Gun scene so gotta slide this a 3

Although I can’t lie that a lot of these songs sound similar, they’re all insanely good and the musical talent in not just Frank but also the band is incredible and for that I give the album 5/5

The hits were hitting and the rest was…well, missing

Never got into this tbh

About halfway thru rn and it’s a vibe but don’t think I could listen consistently

Only Stevie Wonder could make an album this diverse and make it sound coherent. Very good listen

An album full of sounds generated by a first grader arranged in a pretty decent way

It felt like hearing the evolution of Cheap Trick in the album, very cool to hear I Want You to Want Me and Surrender back to back here