Sayonara.

Classic, but definitely not classy.

Soooo bad... but nice to dust off the 1.

Sounds like the soundtrack to a musical I don't want to see.

Eeesh. What was cut from the list to make room for this...

The title track might be my least favorite, but enjoyed most the others.

This is not for me.

This earns 2 stars solely for "Praise You" because "The Rockafeller Skank" was a fun flashback for only about 60 seconds, and I don't ever need to hear anything else from this album.

Still not a full Tom Waits convert, but I did really enjoy this one at times. Very unique, and definitely benefits from multiple listens.

Been a while since I've listened to this one, but still holds up.

Never heard of this band. Their vocals are not for me, and I did my best to hear past them to avoid giving this 1 star. Ultimately settling on 2/5 because, at times, the music was pretty fun.

It's probably a sin to say that this was just "pretty good," but a few of the standouts were covers and the rest were good, but not amazing.

I wanted to give this more than 3 stars, but could barely justify even that. Maybe with more listens and a closer attention to the lyrics I'd appreciate it more, but it ended up being too easy to ignore.

Fun album and all new to me excluding the Shaft theme song.

Musically a 6/5, lyrically a 2/5.

Better than I expected, but I consider it more of a fun listen than a great album. Whenever I heard the cheesy deep voice near the end of "Fine Time," I couldn't help thinking of Jemaine from Flight of the Conchords.

Not for me. The vocals were hard to stomach, and the music was pretty blah.

Great album, but not sure it's the masterpiece many claim.

Not for me, or maybe I'm just not angry enough.

Kind of sounds like a punk version of Bowie. Not bad.

Interesting mix of styles, but pretty fun.

Some songs were kind of cool, but overall not for me. And "Cars," despite being the most popular hit, is one of my least favorites.

Not great. Some decent and catchy, some weird, and some just bad. 2.5/5

Strong start, but overall it was good, not great.

Not horrible, but glad it's over.

Good, but wasn't my favorite. Ok music with clever lyrics, but somewhat repetitive.

Not bad, but I'm not sure why this is a "must hear" album. Sounds like pretty generic 80s pop/rock with hints of country/folk. 2.5/5

Hard to review an album in a language I don't know, but the music was nice. 2.5/5

I mean, it's fine for what it is, but hard to understand how this is a "must hear."

Good stuff. I had never heard of The Charlatans, but they immediately reminded me of Oasis (or maybe it's Oasis that sounds like them... not sure because these guys never made it big in the US).

Very entertaining.

Cool space trip. Wish the captain didn't yell so much. Will I take it again? Unlikely.

A lot going on, and a lot of fun.

I've never been a fan of Rod Stewart's voice, but this album was surprisingly great as a whole.

Good, not great.

The hits are great (thus 4 stars), but the rest are meh.

Decent back half redeemed an unimpressive start. That voice though...

Super.

I guess this world is not for me.

This was different, but had a cool, mysterious vibe that really sucked me in. Good stuff.

Pretty bland 90s rock, and nearly every song is 2-5 minutes too long. Sounded like bad Foo Fighters at times.

I did not like most of the first two tracks because it sounded like too many instruments competing with the others. However, from "Spanish Key" on, this was great.

Great stuff, but -1 star for Wars of Armageddon and a slightly indulgent opening track.

Here we go! The good songs are so good that even the mediocre songs ("Adam Raised a Cain" & "Prove It All Night") can't pull this down from 5-star territory.

Dare I say it's too folky? I had never heard of them and did enjoy parts, but I'm not buying this as a must-hear album.

I'm not much into jazz, but this was great.

Fun album from a band I've never heard before. Psychedelic Hobbiton folk rock? Why not.

Great from start to finish.

Not exactly my kind of music, but it grew on me. I kinda dig the minimalism.

Interesting music, I guess, so it gets my default 3/5 for albums in languages I don't understand.

I've never understood all the fuss over Radiohead, but I'd also never heard this album through. Great stuff.

I forgot how great this album is. Time to listen to more Beach House.

Not for me. Perhaps I'd like it more if I were playing laser tag instead of working.

Great harmonies. Very soothing.

Almost tempted to lower this to 4/5 because it's a little cheesy and I've heard the best songs too many times, but it's just too good.

Good, not great.

Silly lyrics and dumb skits, but I liked some of the jazzy music.

Interesting, but sitar doesn't do it for me.

Harmless, easy listening, but nothing outstanding.

I didn't HATE it, but please don't make me listen to them again.

Excellent first half carries a weak back half.

High-energy rock with tons of cool organ, but the screaming?

Meh. Decent at its best, but painful at its worst. I would genuinely be embarrassed if caught listening to this again.

I hadn't heard most of this album before. Neil Young's vocals are always a little grating, but he mostly makes it work for me.

Been a long time since I've listened to this album, but I like it more than I remember.

Out there, but great stuff.

I appreciate how the music lets her voice remain the star, but you can really hear the weariness by this point in her life. Still good, not great.

Classic, but definitely not classy.

Just ok. Never really got into Leo, and more familiar with his work via covers. This one's a bit too heavy for workday listening, so I'll have to give it another shot. And he does go by "Leo," right?

Fun punkabilly.

Overrated. Good, not great.

Meh... won't be looking for Vol. 5.

Fun, I guess, but most of the songs lack a strong enough hook or chorus to justify such long solos.

Sounds like the soundtrack to a musical I don't want to see.

Conflicted because this should be an easy 5, but it's hard to enjoy listening to him now.

Probably the best Green Day album, and I almost gave this a 5 for the nostalgia effect.

I did not like this. Stressful and repetitive. Only gets 2 stars because I like the album cover art.

I hadn't heard any of these songs before, and this album seemed a little boring upon first listen. However, it really grew on me as I gave it a couple more chances w/ headphones.

Easy 5 and I'm not ashamed to say it.

"Imagine" has to be one of the most overrated songs ever, but the rest of the album holds its own.

Pleasantly surprised, but not in love w/ the vocals.

Ok, but not really for me. Cool? Sure. Do I need a 16-minute drum solo? Probably not.

A little repetitive, and probably too angry for normal listening, but still kinda fun. Now let's go destroy something.

It's fine, but nothing special.

Nothing special, at best, and I'm starting to suspect some heavy British favoritism in this list...

Really enjoyed the mellower, jazzy songs.

One of my favorite live albums.

I really like the multiple guitars, but something is missing that I can't quite put my finger on. Great, but feels a bit like a poor man's CSNY.

Perhaps the most approachable of their albums. That said, I still have to be in the right mood, and for whatever reason I'm usually not, but then a couple songs in... and they got me.

Pretty awful, with the exception of a couple songs.

I like how he sourced samples from a range of genres, and overall this works for me.

Great album, but it's Turner's voice that takes this from 3 to 4.

Classic, and quite bold considerings it's largely a love album to George Harrison's then-wife...

I guess Rush just isn't for me. They seem like talented musicians, but I'm not sure if what they're doing is always in service to the song. And I just can't get past the singing.

Not as bad as I feared, but almost... Here's hoping this is the last time Todd Rundgren shows up on this list. PS, a 10 minute song w/ 4 titles is 4 songs.

Hard to take this album seriously. Two good songs, a few ok songs, and the rest are silly or skits.

Disappointing. I was expecting more than a high school battle of the bands, but I suppose I can hear how they've influenced later bands.

I probably need to revisit this on a different day because I struggled to get through this one. Music keeps this from being a 1, but I don't understand the critical acclaim for what's basically a one-note album filled with threats and gunshots.

Classic. I'm into their signature guitar sound.

Never gets old.

Fun and genre-bending. Good, not great.

The "hits" were always a bit grating to me, but I was pleasantly surprised by the rest of the album.

His first album is probably still my favorite, but the songs that dial back the psychedelics are great.

Not for me.

Nice discovery and change of pace.

My favorite Grateful Dead album. Timeless.

A little embarrassed to admit it, but this is a great album.

Musically fine, and I really like the gritty solos, but that's about it.

Nothing noteworthy, and not for me.

Is this a joke?

John Prine is pretty good.

Had this on repeat for a bit thanks to some surprisingly good songs. I'll need to explore more.

Never considered myself a Billy Joel fan, but this has most of my favorites. Some really creative arrangements.

Maybe I'm just charmed by the novelty, but this is great.

A bit of filler, but 4 stars on the backs of Alive, Black and Jeremy.

Classic.

A few tracks maybe shouldn't have made the cut, but still...

Kanye can be silly, but this is pretty good.

This was so bad that I have to assume it was just a mean joke, right?

The music is meh but the cover art is ew.

This was my first time listening to any Queen album start to finish, and it did not disappoint.

I really liked this and picked up some mellower Father John Misty vibes.

I'm in no position to rate this album, so... 3?

Not for me.

There are some 4- and 5-star singles here, but I've never been a huge fan of the album's concept as a whole.

Not terrible... but definitely not for me.

As good as it ever was.

With the exception of Mr. Soul, this was all new to me and I really liked it.

The music took me on a fun little adventure, but the singing/lyrics made me want to turn around and go home.

Great album, and all new to me with the exception of a couple songs.

While I'd prefer a gift NOT involving Spector, this is good.

Good, but a bit too ominous for regular listening.

Not for me.

It's not bad, but a low 3.

Never a bad time for Otis.

Groovy.

Repetitive and exhausting, but cool if I were fighting a bunch of Agent Smiths.

A bit chaotic, but not bad.

Nice, but maybe a little bland.

I can excuse a little of Springsteen's cheese because of this one's timing and sentiment.

A few great songs, but this still isn't really for me.

Overrated perhaps, but hard to argue against a 5.

I think this aged poorly. Sounds like robots banging on garbage.

I'm not sure I'd call it "must-hear" music, but it's not bad.

One of the easiest 5s so far.

What a wonderful treat.

Not my favorite, but had its moments.

Had its moments, but won't be returning for more.

Solid punk, I guess. Not exactly for me.

For whatever reason, I just can't get into it.

Surprised by how much I liked this, and more than just the hits.

Not bad, but why are we including compilations?

Some of this wasn't bad, but a lot of it was a lot of bad.

This sounds like good musicians made songs to prove they were good at music. Not for me.

By the hammer of Thor!

Incredible. No one knows how to build-up a song like The War on Drugs.

Pleasantly surprised, and I could definitely listen to this again.

Peaked with the first track, and not much for me after that.

Not bad, but nothing special. I've tried to get into Billy Bragg before and it's just not for me.

Wish I had listened to this sooner.

Fun, but not for me and not must-hear.

Kinda jazzy and cool, but minus one for her Spotify stunt.

Good, but unremarkable.

Got those earworms.

This was new to me, and not bad, but nothing remarkable.

Some 4- and 5-star tracks for sure, but A LOT of filler.

Not for me because I find it rather repetitive, but I can't say I've ever really given metal a fair chance.

It's fun and I appreciate the energy, just not for me.

A couple ok songs.

I was not looking forward to this, but really enjoyed it actually.

Pretty good, if unspectacular.

Come on, it's THE band.

Different, but I think this would grow on me.

Clearly dated, but still great stuff.

Solid 90s

Classic.

I could listen to a lot of this.

Fine, but pretty cheesy and not really my thing.

Cool stuff.

Hmm, they kinda lost me w/ "All About Love"

Greatness.

For someone like me who doesn't quite "get" jazz, this was great.

Was leaning towards 4... but then 'Wake Up' started.

I was counting the minutes on this one...

A lot of lyrical nonsense, but how can I not...

Great, but not greatest.

Now I know what all the fuss is about... not much.

Better than I expected.

No.

Good stuff.

A bonus star for being unique, but overall not for me.

Nice funk.

Delightful, and most of what I know him for.

I mean, come on.

Delightful.

Too much creepy cheese.

A true delight.

Eesh, no thanks.

Eh, not bad, but peaked with the first song.

Had its moments, but not my cup of tea.

Better than I feared, but I wouldn't consider it a must-hear album.

Wasn't bad musically, but lyrics toggled between cheesy and incredibly offensive.

Delightful.

This was, surprisingly, not bad.

At 1h 20m, it serves up both a lot to like AND dislike, but even at his worst Prince is still entertaining.

Delightful. Plus, I had no idea Carole King wrote some of these.

This was a neat discovery.

5 for the album name, 2 for the music, so... 3 overall.

Kinda into it.

You know it.

Great stuff. And the first time I've heard The Band sampled.

I could listen to this all day... and pretty much did.

Yes.

Not bad. Interesting backstory, but less interesting music.

Not bad. Starting to see what all the fuss is about.

Not bad, but not for me.

I have a bit of a love/hate relationship with U2, and this album is no exception.

A little hmm and a lot of meh.

Delightful.

Delightful mix of styles.

Creative and great for working, but not something to which I can actively listen.

Not bad.

This is a joke, right? A very bad joke...

Interesting, but not really for me.

Lots of hits. Lots of misses.

Good, not great.

Nice of the community center to let them do their album cover shoot inside.

Nope.

Not for me.

Easy 5.

Dig the funk.

Not bad, but not amazing.

Took a couple listens, but really liked it.

At least it was quick.

Good 'n' cheesy.

Pretty cool.

Good, not great.

Yes.

Not bad. Must hear? Nah.

Not great, but at least it was interesting.

Good stuff, and great energy.

Not bad.

I don't like this as much as I used to, but still a classic.

Kinky, but not my favorite.

Meh. Had its moments, but not many. And the 8-minute story time wasn't one of them. Although it sort of pains me to give this a 2, I can't justify a 3.

Easy 5.

Neil Young at his gritty best, self-righteousness and all.

Soooo bad... but nice to dust off the 1.

Not terrible, but definitely not for me.

Musically, it's not horrible... but that voice! Ugh.

Good stuff.

Love it, but maybe more of a 4.5

Not terrible, but this vocal style definitely isn't for me.

I had never heard of Ride, but this was pretty good.

Musically interesting, I suppose, but lyrically silly. Not for me.

Great stuff.

Good, but never understood the hype.

A few throw-aways, but mostly great and perfectly odd.

Easy 5, and this one ruined the curve.

Cool as ever.

Cool stuff.

Good, not great.

Inoffensive, but makes James Taylor comparatively sound like punk rock.

Not bad, but not for me.

Solid stuff, and it had been too long.

Fun? Definitely. Good? I don't know.

Very impressive debut full of hits.

Solid 5 despite two songs that are twice as long as needed.

Good stuff.

How am I *not* giving this 5 stars?

Good stuff.

Good, not great.

Good, not great.

Yeah... not for me.

Cool music and energy.

Count me in the likely minority that are not fans of Stevie Nicks' voice, but this is undeniably great.

I do have to be in the right mood for live albums, but when I am this one is a solid 5.

Cool, but the fuzz is a bit much.

Meh, not for me.

Interesting pop-punk, although not my favorite.

Here's a little 4.

Getting some cheap Doors vibes, but I mean way, way, way cheaper. I was going to give this a 2. However, when I saw the average rating was somehow above 3, I knew I had a job to do...

Good, not great.

There's never a wrong time for Fleet Foxes.... which is why I'm never allowed to DJ at parties.

I forgot how good this album is.

Lemonade, anyone?

Promising start, and interesting blend of styles throughout.

This was pretty hard to get through.

Not bad... just not for me.

Good, but no amazing stand outs.

Not for me.

Cool stuff.

I hear the Flaming Lips comparisons that a lot of people have made, but yeah... not as good.

This was new to me, so we'll see how it holds up to repeated listens. For now, I'm really into it.

Never heard of Mayall, but cool stuff.

Either a 3 or 4 depending on the day. Caught me on a good one.

Fun, but I can only handle the funk in moderation.

Not for me, but not bad.

Must hear?

Not a bad voice.

Excellent.

I can see the appeal, but not for me.

Some of the best background music I've ever heard.

Fun jazz.

Don't love it, but I appreciate the new discovery.

Good, not great.

Fun.

Slightly repetitive, but I'm into it.

Ok start, rough finish.

Cool music. Shallow lyrics.

I'm trying to imagine hearing this with fresh ears, but these are many of the songs I'm sick of hearing.

New the name, but never heard her sing. Good stuff.

Pleasant surprise!

A cool little bit of rockabilly punk + Lou Reed + early KoL

I think this had potential, but it just didn't work for me.

First time actually listening to an Elvis album. Great stuff.

Way better than I'm Your Man, at least.

A 4-star start with a 2-star finish.

Kinda cool, but still not my cup of tea.

Yes.

Meh. Overrated, so here's an overly harsh 2 to help correct that.

I'm sure plenty of people could tell me why I'm wrong, but this is just too repetitive (minus a couple fun ones).

A generous 3 stars based on only being able to listen to two tracks...

Pretty cool, but makes me regret giving Khaled 3 stars yesterday.

Into the music, but the rest was kinda meh.

I'll probably look back one day and regret giving this a 4 instead of a 3, but it just feels right.

Cool music, but not a fan of the vocals.

Kind of interesting, but not for me.

Dare I say a bit of a letdown... good, but not great.

Meh, felt generic.

Overrated, but solid. I can't fairly give this any less than a 3.

Had its moments. About 3-stars worth of them I guess.

Catchy, but a little too silly for me.

Meh.

I'm not sure what this was, but it started great and went downhill fast.

Pretty bad, right?

Sad, subdued and solid. Maybe more of a 3.5 than 4, but whatever.

Perhaps the most pleasant surprise thus far.

New to me, and not bad, but not my cup of tea.

Definitely interesting...

Could I really be a Black Sabbath fan?

Perhaps more significant than good.

Nope. I was going to be generous and give this a 2, but then "Milky Cereal" sealed its sad fate.

Genre-bending and it works.

I'm into the grittiness, but it got repetitive. And rough vocals.

Wonderful, just not wonderfullest.

I'm really digging the tone of this one.

Perhaps they're not as one-dimensional as I thought...

Rated on skill, this probably scores high. Rated on a listenability, less so.

Eeesh. What was cut from the list to make room for this...

A Friday with The Band? How delightful!

Not bad.

Generic, and bad. Especially that title track...

It seems like he threw everything at this album... and it works for me.

Forgettable.

Good, but my favorite parts are always the fleeting guitar.

Given that I only knew "There She Goes," this was a lot better than I thought.

Not for me. I was leaning towards giving just 1 star, but then I cranked the volume up and discovered a little more... 1 additional star, to be exact.

Good, but never understood the hype.

Great stuff.

Great, but capped at 4 for me because it's mainly covers. Still, he made each his own.

Generally delightful, but difficult to rate.

Some good ones, but nothing spectacular.

Not exactly for me, but pretty impressive for '74.

Cool stuff.

Clever, gritty and folksy. Sign me up.

Pretty good, and not at all what I expected.

Things are starting to get weird, and I'm here for it.

Might be a 5 if not for some rather odd inclusions.

5-star beginning + 3-star finish = 4 stars

Don't think twice, it's a five.

Could we please have The Kinks every week?

Pretty bad, with a few exceptions.

Sits right there between a 3 and a 4...

Back half keeps it from 5-stars, but still great stuff.

Fine, but nothing really stood out.

This was fun.

I'm happy for the people that get this, but I am not one of them.

Great stuff, and I'm convinced this would have a higher overall rating if A) the band's name were The Rolling Stones, and B) the album art weren't so terrible.

This one was draining.

Not bad, but a bit of a letdown.

Excellent.

Not for me.

I've always wanted to like this more, but could stand for more rock and less opera.

Not overthinking this one.

Feeling properly funksticated.

Cool to hear how it all started... even if Elvis didn't write any of it.

Good stuff.

Interesting, and at times even good, but I don't need to hear any more.

Great stuff.

Yes.

Not for me.

I checked a handful of times to see if this was almost over. Not only was it a 'No' every time, but I was still on the first track... Not for me.

Digging the punk sax.

Impressive debut.

Probably pairs nicely with a tropical drink.

I'm into it, but seems a tad overrated. Perhaps you had to be there.

A big more somber Bob, but I'm digging it.

A lot of covers, but maybe it's hard to fault that in the 60s.

Decent start, but lost me about halfway through.

Vocals aren't for me, but interesting guitar.

Great blend of country, soul, R&B and pop.

It's not *bad* so I'll hold my 2... but maybe I just don't like prog rock. If it's an acquired taste, I can't see myself ever listening to enough to acquire a taste for it.

Good, but a bit disappointing outside of the obvious hits.

Easy.

Not for me.

Too influential to be just a 2, perhaps, but not good enough for a 4.

This is... not bad?!? Surprised me a bit, but still not crazy about the singing. 2.5

Cool, but a little eerie for everyday listening.

Love it.

Pretty far out there, but cool.

Not bad, and ~400 albums in, it's definitely my favorite prog rock thus far.

It's fine, but nothing memorable.

Tricky one. It's greater the bluesier and Kinkier it ventures, but it just doesn't live up to the hype.

Not for me. Kinda gives me the creeps, along with a dose of anxiety.

A lot of this is great, but too much "what's this button do" means 3 is where it's at.

Grew on me. Besides, shades at night?!?

Not exactly to my taste, but the hits are great.

Probably a 3, but Alanis kinda scares me.

It may be influential and/or groundbreaking for its time, but it's not for me.

Cool discovery.

Yeah yeah.

Much more than the one-hit wonder I thought she was.

Very pleasant, but capped at 3 for being all covers.

Their act is a bit exhausting, but fun. And definitely deserves to be on this list.

Solid 3.

Some good hits, but not "one of the greatest live rock albums of all time."

Catchier than most of the metal so far, so I get the appeal.

Cool stuff.

Cool grooves, but too much self-indulgent cheese.

Had a hard time with this one.

Cool music and instrumental pieces. The story? Not so much.

The title track might be my least favorite, but enjoyed most the others.

Influential perhaps, but not for me. And I should be subtracting 1 star every time groups mention their own name.

2 stars, which is probably more than this deserves, but less than the number of times I had to apologize to my wife for what she had to overhear.

Hadn't heard of them. Now I have. That's a mostly good thing.

I was in the mood for this today. Very cool.

Great, but assumed this was older. 4

5-star filth.

Cool stuff.

Not great, Bob.

Inoffensive, but a little dull... and just not special enough.

Not sure what the fuss is about, so... not for me.

Maybe even a 4 if not for the yelling...

I don't know what is happening, but I like it.

Better than I expected with fun music, but cheesy lyrics.

Cool, but unremarkable.

Great album. Approachable, but with caution.

Live albums are tricky to rate and seem a bit like cheating... but their energy is great.

I don't love Rod, but I do love the guitar tone.

Not terrible, but kinda lame.

I definitely thought this was My Chemical Romance or some early aughts emo band... oops. And what a pleasant surprise!

Good stuff.

Not bad, but not for me.

Meh, not for me.

Meh.

Cool to hear a different side of Pink Floyd. Very Byrdsie...

Great album, but I think the myth has surpassed the music.

5ish, but not quite.

One great song + a few ok songs + several that were two minutes too long = 2

Not for me.

Truth.

I can't listen to a full album with this voice. I get it, you have range. Reign it in.

When some music hits you, you do feel pain.

Good, but nothing spectacular.

Interesting, but not for me.

Meh.

Cool.

I tried, but the singing ruins what would otherwise be an ok album.

A couple fun ones, but kinda bland and repetitive.

Cool, but not outstanding.

Easy 5.

Not for me.

I get why it's on the list, but this is pretty bad.

Cool music. Crazy dude.

Cool, catchy stuff.

Ok, I guess, but nothing exceptional.

It was a good day for some Paul Simon.

Great stuff.

Had its moments, but a little too juvenile. Maybe I'm not punk enough.

Love the attitude and vocals, but in moderation.

I could listen to this all day. In fact, I pretty much did.

Not for me.

Ignoring what came after.

Meh.

Good, not great.

Not bad, but not for me.

Not bad.

If I'm just judging the music and not the man... easy 5.

Not the most interesting, but then again, neither am I.

Meh.

Meh.

Zzzzz...

You missed.

Unexpectedly epic...

Excellent, but not their best.

Swampy sweetness.

Never knew about this collab. Pretty cool.

What am I missing?

Kinda digging it...

So... we're just letting everyone in now?

Nope.

Strong start that turns generic...

I'm not ready to give this any more than a 3 after only a couple listens, but this is the type of stuff I love finding through this list.

Doing my part to bring these guys back down to earth.

Forgettable.

Cool stuff.

Nothing special.

Ok at times. But only ok, and not many times.

I'll stick w/ the candy.

Fun, but probably won't revisit.

Cool stuff.

Must hear? Not here.

1 because I'm feeling generous.

Kinda fun, but kinda happy it's over.

Feeling it.

This cat could ball, man.

Good, but carried by a stronger back half. 3

Not for me.

Good, not great.

Sayonara.

Kinda cool, and probably a breath of fresh air in 1996.

Almost a 5.

Meh.

Cool, but 45 songs? Too much chaff.

Interesting, but don't love these vocals.

High highs, but low lows.

Not for me.

Not for me.

I have a soul and therefore can't give this bubblegum any less than a 4.

Teases, but ultimately fails to deliver.

Cool mood.

Cool stuff.

Holds up. Hopefully I can still say that in another 30 years.

Better than I expected.

Not for me.

A couple duds, but mostly great.

It's fine, but nothing outstanding.

Very cool. Albums and bands like this are the reason I'm doing this list.

Cool stuff.

Hmm, is it good because it's actually good, or is it good because I'm being told it's good. Either way, not as good as they say...

Cool stuff.

Too soon?

Too fun for any less than a 3.

Cool, albeit rough. Maybe that's why it's cool. Maybe I have no idea what I'm talking about.

I've been too generous lately, and this is just not doing it for me.

Probably very influential, but not exactly my cup of Joe.

That tiger'll hunt.

Not for me, but the hits are ok.

One annoying hit and a lot of meh.

Good, but not amazing.

Cool, but unremarkable.

If there's a U2 album worth owning, this is it.

Good, and I'd probably like it more after closer listening.

This was a treat.

That dog'll hunt.

I don't know, man. It's not the worst, but this is not for me.

Cool stuff.

Meh.

A weaker 4 perhaps, but a 4 nonetheless.

If I'm in the mood, 5.

Better than many, but worse than most.

Don't love her voice...

Nah.

Great stuff, and my first time listening to their debut!

I don't get it, man...

Phew, finding neither screaming nor "Imagine" was a relief.

Just when you think each song is about to end... you get 6 more minutes of 2-star music.

Good, not great.

Not for me.

This could not have ended soon enough. Not for me.

The vocals made this a chore.

Zzzzz

Had its moments. I need to explore more, but we all know that isn't happening anytime soon... so here's a lazy 3.

Meh

Cool, but I like my psychedelia in small doses.

Had its moments. 2 stars' worth, to be exact.

Good stuff.

I'm not sure why I was surprised this had vocals, but I liked it!

I won't criticize it.

Great stuff.

Were they serious with this one? Not for me.

Unremarkable.

Irritating and captivating at the same time. Need to listen more, but not today.

Too much stinky cheese.

Meh.

Not for me.

Had its moments, but don't need to revisit them.

Refreshing, but not my favorite. I get why it's on the list though.

Meh

I wondered if this might make the list. I long for the days of old KoL.

This album was largely responsible for pulling me out of a deep classic rock rut.

Kinda into it... does that mean I need help?

Meh.

An amazing album full of 5s and 3s gets a 4.

An amazing album full of 5s and 3s gets a 4.

Not for me. Proof that good musicians don't always make good music.

Not bad, but nothing to bring me back.

Good album with some incredible songs, but lots of skips.

Fun. Worth further listening.

Small doses. Here's your two, Rufus.

Starts at a 5, but downhill from there...

Unremarkable, but fine.

Hit the spot.

Not for me.

Them there Byrds gone country!

Unique, but never my favorite.

A time capsule for the mid-90s.

Nah.

Too preachy. Also, not good.

Kinda cool, but not for me.

Some cool stuff, but not enough of it.

Meh.

When life gives you lemons, sell crack.

Too much cheese.

Nope.

Not for me.

Meh.

Felt like the same song over and over again.

Now I know.

Not sure what this is... other than pretty bad.

I forgot how good his solo debut was...

Meh.

Rave on!

Sorta creepy, but I still had to see where it went...

Kinda cool so it gets the default foreign language 3.

Good, not great.

Not the one-hit wonders I thought...

I have *not* missed this guy.

I could smell the cigarettes through my speakers.

Next.

Meh. Definitely wouldn't make me want to explore more.

Perhaps more influential than good?

Not for me, but nice butt.

Love the hits, but don't need to revisit the misses.

I've probably given a 2 for worse, but I just can't...

Not bad, but not great.

Meh.

Scattered, but solid.

Yep.

Hit the spot.

Easy.

Yep, sounds like British punk.

Late to the party, but happy to have discovered these guys.

One great song, a few ok tracks, and a lot of noise.

Not terrible, but I slept through most of it.

Good, but probably needs a deeper dive than it got today.

Meh.

Not for me.

After 600+ songs my scale is so broken... this is probably a 4.

Fun, but overrated.

Right there between a 3 and a 4...

Not bad.

Not for me, but I'll bump to a 3 because it doesn't sound like '76.

Not bad, but unremarkable.

Listened all day.

Not for me.

Not bad, but when it's all said and done, I have a hard time believing this is a must hear album...

5.

Dare I say... not bad?

Not bad, but three must-hear albums by these guys?

Great blend of what had come before and what was yet to come.

Incredible debut.

I mean, if I have to listen to Metallica...

A bit of a guilty pleasure, and now I need another shower.

Cool for its time, I guess.

Meh.

Smooth.

What a joy!

Meh.

Not bad, but unremarkable.

The novelty is long gone.

3 great tracks is enough for a 3 today.

Had some moments, but not for me.

Solid 3.

Lots of sameness, but still an easy 4...

Cool, but not really for me.

Actually, not bad.

I don't get it.

Interesting enough for a 3.

Love this album, and had no idea it was so popular.

What even is this?!?

I just listened yesterday and already forgot whether it was good.

Nah.

Good background music if I'm ok being bummed out.

I dig it.

Solid 3.5

Not bad, but not exactly for me.

Classic for a reason.

What even is this? Bluesy folk jazz? I dig it.

Talking Heads vibes. Not bad.

Don't hate on this just because you hate someone else who likes it.

Why not?

I'll be kind and round up to a 3.

Not a fan of the medieval folk sound.

One-trick pony.

Solid 3.

At the start of the Spotify era, didn't we already knew most of what we now know about MJ? How does this have so many Spotify plays?

You're breaking my heart, Cat.

Ahh high school... Nope.

I like it.

Kinda cool.

Meh...

Same-ism.

A jolly good listen.

I'll give the original a 3 and the Spotify recreation a 2.

Pretty fun.

Keep looking because I am certainly not its audience.

Deserves more listens and more stars.

Meh.

Too dull.

Fun discovery.

Not for me.

One ok song and mediocre filler.

3.5

Meh.

It's fine, but inching towards overrated by the album.

It started out ok, but quickly nosedived.

I can dig it.

Meh.

Yes.

Interesting collaboration.

Cool stuff.

Not for me to judge but here I am.

There's always a couple tracks that only the Beatles could get away with, but overall still amazing.

Meh.

I need to listen more to fairly evaluate anything past the singing but ain't nobody got time for that.

MBV is not who I thought they were... but still not for me.

First ever full listen and I dig it.

Simple and superb.

Nah.

Others did it better.

It's something... 2.4

Unremarkable and not for me.

Not bad... 2.5

Sure.

Nope.

This kinda worked for me.

This hurt my ears on mute.

Not really sure about this one...

I'd probably like this more over time.

Very strange. Didn't hate it...

Digging it.

Someone has a case of the samesies.

Nothing special.

A few standouts but a few too many snoozes.

Not for me.

Not bad, but all over the place.

I much preferred this to their debut.

Kinda digging it.

Not for me.

Just a little too meh for a 3.

Cool stuff. I was not expecting so much jazz.

Meh.

Not me...

What... was this?!? Kinda digging it.

Generic 2-star rock.

Not bad, but the kind of album you don't need to pause when you leave the room for a moment.

Classic.

Distinctly D-O-DOUBLE-G.

Doesn't hold up as well as I hoped, but still an easy 3.

Yes he's got a gimmick, but unremarkable.

High schooler music written by grown men. That said... it's not bad.

You don't need a weatherman to know which way the wind blows, and you don't need a music critic to tell you how an album sounds.

Yikes.

Not for me.

The fuss is justified.

Good, but a bit blah.

I've heard worse. Plus, nostalgia points...

Great voice. Good songs.

Simultaneously soothing and unsettling.

Funky salsa? Kinda digging it.

3 because why not?

Not bad, but hardly a "must hear" Bowie album.

Fun ride.

Didn't hate it. How's that for a ringing endorsement?

Surprisingly complete album.

Not bad, then kinda good, but then it got kinda bad.

Solid dad rock I guess.

Still good.

Meh.

Kinda digging it, and at least it wasn't as cringeworthy as others.

Neil Young being Neil Young.

Fun enough for disco, I guess.

Good vibrations.

I can feel the energy.

I shouldn't like this so much but it sucks me in.

Has its moments.

Overrated? Probably, but who cares.

Meh.

Goo enough for a 3.

Cool stuff.

Really good (with a few exceptions), and I'd probably grow to love it.

This is a strange one, but I'm into it.

Solid but not super.

Solid but not my favorite.

A weak 3.

Strong enough for a 4.

Meh.

Had its moments, but not for me.

A strong 2, if there's such a thing.

Is this prog rock w/ an edge?

Ahh yes, the sounds of Old Navy.

Has its moments.

Meh.

Not great, but people seem unnecessarily harsh to this. Has some element of the Kinks or The Who that I dig.

I don't know what I thought Jurassic 5 was, but it wasn't this. This was great.

Blah

I don't get the hype.

Great stuff.

Cool stuff.

As I checked to see when the first song would finally end, I realized I was already on track eight...

Meh-ican Music Club, amiright?

Not for me.

Dark but good.

Good enough for a 3 at least.

Like it but don't love it.

Maybe there's something here.

Not for me.

Started strong but fell off.

Meh.

A weak 3, but I think it would grow on me.

Cool stuff.

Great stuff.

Not exactly for me, but sounds like they're putting it all out there.

Not bad, but overrated right?.

Ok, but a bit repetitive.

Why'd the funk stop so soon?

Unremarkable.

Meh.

Great start to finish.

Twangedelic.

I've heard worse, but it's been a while.

Not for me.

Why?

Kinda cool.

Pleasant surprise.

Unremarkable aside from "Sweet Emotion"