The Madcap Laughs by Syd Barrett

The Madcap Laughs

Syd Barrett

2.6
Rating
23379
Votes
1
14%
2
34%
3
34%
4
13%
5
5%
Distribution

Album Summary

The Madcap Laughs is the debut solo album by the English singer-songwriter Syd Barrett. It was recorded after Barrett had left Pink Floyd in April 1968. The album had a chequered recording history, with work beginning in mid-1968, but the bulk of the sessions taking place between April and July 1969, for which five different producers were credited − including Barrett, Peter Jenner (1968 sessions), Malcolm Jones (early-to-mid-1969 sessions), and fellow Pink Floyd members David Gilmour and Roger Waters (mid-1969 sessions). Among the guest musicians are Willie Wilson from Gilmour's old band Jokers Wild and several members of Soft Machine. The Madcap Laughs, released in January 1970 on Harvest in the UK but not released in the US until 1974, enjoyed minimal commercial success on release, reaching number 40 on the UK's official albums chart. It was re-released in 1974 as part of Syd Barrett (which contained The Madcap Laughs and Barrett), which saw the first US issue of the two LP's. The album was remastered and reissued in 1993, along with Barrett's other albums, Barrett (1970) and Opel (1988), independently and as part of the Crazy Diamond box set. A newly remastered version was released in 2010.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

I often forgot the music was playing, and I wasn’t very impressed when I tuned in

I had listened to this previously and I remember being confused by how amateurish it was. It’s no less amateurish but the ramshackle nature of it is what I actually like. His voice is cracked and broken, the guitar playing often bodged but the songs are great little pearls of psychedelic pop and are strangely singalong. A lovely little oddity

Look, just because you used to be in Pink Floyd and took a lot of drugs, doesn't mean you can make good music. Shite.

I have nothing against experimental albums that include these kinds of raw, unfiltered studio recordings/demos, but I also believe you need a certain level of artistry and talent to pull it off. This has neither.

Weird as expected but it's weak and tossed off. Just sounds like demos out to disc. Needed a little less acid and a little more discipline.

He truly was mad.

Not a great album at all. Not a lot of substance there and pretty boring. I would choose this album over Trout Mask Replica but that isn't saying a lot.

This is one of those one word reviews: amateurish. Ok. I'll keep going. There is something compelling, I know, about including little mistakes on a piece of art. And then there's including so many mistakes that your audience can only assume that you never got enough good takes out of a song to compile something worth listening to. There are some nice sections to this, but if I had a dollar for every time Syd accidentally mutes his guitar strings when he doesn't mean to, or doesn't switch to a chord when he should, or screeches through a complicated melody instead of singing it gracefully, I'd have a million dollars. It isn't unlistenable. But it also isn't very good at all. Pretty emblematic of an album that only earns - TWO STARS

In the better moments it is reminiscent of the first Pink Floyd album y of course. Those are rare, though. Most of it sounds like bad demos with mad lyrics. Interesting, but not very good.

Some vocal tracks were lovely; others had me questioning who told this guy he could sing. 2.5/5.0

The mediocrity of this album is killing me why is it so bland holy. I would compare it to just plain white bread but at least thats got sweetness in it.

Look I have the utmost respect for a madman musician. For context my favorite guitarist is John Frusciante. But, I have to be critical and unfortunately Syd on his own isn't quite Pink Floyd. Maybe its influential but psychedelic music is touch and go with me. It was such a prominent fad of the decade that occassionally it ends up being generic. Roger Waters, Richard Wright and ultimately David Gilmour, Syd's replacement made the band I know and love more than words. So Syd, mad respect but lowsy album. Lay off the LSD and focus on production.

If I weren’t as interested in Pink Floyd lore I don’t know if I would appreciate this as much. Definitely messy, but also compelling and has its great moments.

I was excited by this but I was only excited because of who he was and the novelty soon wore off. A few interesting songs but mostly this was just not a good album.

Review - not listened to any Barrett era Floyd, or his solo stuff. This album's sort of exactly what I expected. Some quite good songwriting and performances at times, often undercut by intentionally odd production or writing or performance. The sort of music a very good song writer dealing with the onset of a mental illness might create. The good songs really are very good, but there's a lot of dross to wade through between them at times. Score - 6.5/10 Need to listen? YES

This has been a brutal week of albums and this doesn't help the situation. I am a huge Pink Floyd fan, but the Syd era was too weird and too psychedelic for me. Nothing to hate about this album, but nothing that really stands out either. The first track is 5:02 long but it felt like twice that much time. Why does this get included in the Top 1001 albums I need to hear before I die? I asked AI and wasn't satisfied with the answer, it's a pity-inclusion really. Weak. Nothing worth listening to twice. It's boring and monotonous to a fault. 2 stars.

Seems like a directly fine but not great early PF record. I don't really hear anything particularly special or interesting here

I usually like psychedelic rock but it felt so rough and unpolished, I just couldn’t get into it.

Somehow, this music seems more suited to a vaudeville show than a concert stage. The songs are definitely a bit strange, odd, and not at all ordinary. "The Madcap Laughs"—yes, I think that fits. The whole thing feels rather childlike, chaotic, perhaps even psychedelic. Whether I like the songs, I'm not so sure. A friend lent me the album decades ago. Back then, I was more surprised than anything else. I liked the cover, and I'm still surprised by it today.

This is a tough one. Syd has talent and some of the songs are solid, interesting psych rock with a lot of charm and whimsy. The record is really inconsistent though. A lot of the guitar playing and singing crosses the threshold of charmingly rustic to sloppy. It also doesn't feel like an experimental musician taking artistic license (like how someone like Zappa would make music that is deliberately unpleasant), this feels like the people behind the deck saw someone who is severely mentally ill going through it and deciding that letting it be sloppy would result in a curio. Between that quite ugly quote from David Gilmore about how he wasn't sure if he was punishing Syd or portraying him as he was and the inclusion of outtakes, the circumstances behind this album feel quite ugly. While the album isn't without merit on Syd's part, the flaws are obvious and it feels exploitative. Not sure how I review something like this so 3 stars it is.

Hmmm... I do like some oddball psychedelia. But this is maybe a bit too much for me today.

1.5/5 I didn't really enjoy his voice and it was a little boring for me.

Another weird personal album from a founding Floyd - hard to get into or pull much from this. Sometimes pretty hard to listen to, even the better moments got to be grating. More instrumental like parts of Octopus would have been welcome

I'm convinced that no one would care about this album if Syd hadn't previously been a member of Pink Floyd. If It's in You is an absolutely terrible song with somehow-worse-executed vocals. For the most part otherwise this was pretty forgettable.

I didn't realize who it was and my review was going to say "this is what I imagine what would happen if Robert Plant was emo and untalented" and after learning more about this I'm sticking with that review

I’m a big Pink Floyd fan, but the earliest stuff featuring Syd Barrett has always been a bit hard to take, and the band’s music improved significantly once he was ousted from the band. His solo work isn’t very good — weak melodies all around.

Not quite as bad as I would have expected. A few tracks sound more Beatle-ish (complimentary) than Pink Floyd-ish (EXTREMELY pejorative). Harmless but not worth a 2nd listen.

Didn’t really have fun listening to Syd Barrett have a mental breakdown for a half hour? He didn’t really sound like he wanted to make this album, so why should I want to listen to it?

madcap yes, laughed no. so bad in places, I exclaimed aloud.

I can't explain this album. It's just sorta mid...

boring and weird

A drawback of having written, recorded, produced, and collaborated with a variety of musicians since the early 1990s is I can spot pretty easily when something simply isn’t working and that is *everywhere* here. I don’t know that I would call it exploitative as some have, the guy needed a push and help from his friends, but a handful of tracks aside, none of this should’ve been released. Not because it’s “the sound of someone losing their mind” or whatever but because this material isn’t even out of demo phase yet! It is the very familiar sound of a songwriter trying to find where the chords go, but not yet finding the right order for what’s in their head. Even the abrupt stops and such are bookmarks or aural notation for a future, more fleshed-out production. This is not a genius work.

A weird album with a big historical value that's kind of difficult to listen. If you're not interested in Pink Floyd at all, I can't imagine this album doing anything to you. Otherwise, it's a must listen, even if to scratch your head a bit.

Is this serious? This is silly and childish.

Needs Gilmore/Waters to control his weird

A lil strange but all-around cool.

It’s ok I guess, but not very interesting either.

Interesting, and I did enjoy parts of it. 2.5

Ich weiß nicht. Hat ein paar Momente und lebt sicher von der starken Eigenwilligkeit. Ist aber stellenweise auch echt sperrig. Ich geb mal 3/5 und muss das sicher nochmal hören.

Das hat mit leicht genervt. 1 Stern noch nicht, aber kurz davor.

Tästä ei oikee mitään jääny käteen. Onneks oli aika lyhyt kokonaisuus

Olipahan kuollettavan tylsä tämäkin. Roskiin.

Joo en tiiä. Periaatteessa tässon hyviikin settejä välissä, mutta monelta osin jää aika RAAKA (ei raju vaan paistamaton) kuva. Tyhmähän se on tuotannon perään itkee, mut itken varmaan nyt enempi sen säv.sov. homman perään. Jää viilinki, että on pitänyt kutoo palasista kokonaisuus ja osa biiseistä on sit vaan mitä on. Kuiteskii oon tämmösen raakile-ilmasunkin ystävä niin ei tää nyt niin kamalaa ollut ja varmaan kunnon jyystöllä vois yhtyä frusiantteihin ja coxoneihin ja sanoo että IHANAA PARRETTI IHANAA.

No oli kyllä ensisijaisesti ihan hemmetin tylsä levy. Ei huono, ei hyvä - ainoastaan ihan saatanan tylsä.

This wasn't great. There were moments in the song writing, but I can't get into the vocals at allllll. This is a 1.5 album Liked Songs: "Terrapin" , "No Good Trying" , "No Man's Land" , "Here I Go" , "Golden Hair" , "Late Night"

Likte denne mer enn jeg hadde forventet. Sterk 4'er

En syk mann og hans gitar. Og det er akkurat det det høres ut som. Ganske trist å høre på.

Veldig glad i det her. Feel og If It’s in You høres rett og slett uferdig ut. Dem skal æ aldri høre igjen.

Kul improsession.

Mitgründer von Pink Floyd. Rausgeflogen wegen seiner psychischen Probleme, verstärkt durch seinen Drogenkonsum. Klingt wie ein Demoband.

Dude just doodles on guitar for a bit

I found this album to be incredibly dull - fair play to those that like it, but 37 minutes of it felt like two days.

Donovan-ish, a little beatles-ish.....

This record has a gloriously authentic, unhinged nature, and for good reason. It might be morally questionable to say this, but if Syd Barrett hadn't succumbed to his lifestyle choices in quite the way he did, this album wouldn't be half as good. As it is, for better or for worse, it feels like a genuine snapshot of an extraordinary but troubled life. The meandering, poetic, circus-like psychedelia feels entirely natural, effortless, and utterly uncontrived. It's part of a much bigger, and very sad story, but in isolation, this record is a thoroughly absorbing delight.

I should probably know the Syd Barrett, Pink Floyd rock n roll story, but I don't. I can see how this whimsical slightly rambling (is it lo-fi before that was a thing?) album could be irritating but in the right mood it is quite endearing. It helps that the late great Jacko from the Adelphi Club used to regularly play "Love You" and familiarity to this also helps ferment positive vibes. All the same not really something I would rank as truly great.

Isto dosta dosadan album, ali bar nije neslušljivo kao mnogi drugi tu. Zapravo solidnih 2/5, 4/10

O sea, no se cual es el trasfondo del disco, pero la verdad que es duro de escuchar por tramos. Entiendo las letras, la disonancia del sonido y los sonidos casi folk psicodélico que forma, pero realmente lo hacen complicado. Entiendo que puede gustar y entendiendo el contexto crece, pero no así cuando lo escuché 2,5/5.

3/10 Alguien que le enseñe a afinar a ese tipo por favor

Would not be on my list. His was a tragic life. Music to hear once.

To answer the review before mine: Syd Barrett was a genius. To my mind, nobody in British rock has quite matched the way he paired the dark, psychedelic despair of modern life with the whimsical, almost childlike melodies of nursery rhymes (OK, except maybe David Tibet). Anyone who has doubts about the ethics of releasing this album should dig a little deeper, because the story surrounding Barrett at the time of these recordings is, well, complicated, to say the very least. There are differing theories about what caused his mental state to deteriorate. Heavy LSD use and the pressure of becoming famous so young clearly played a part, and according to Irwin Chusid’s Songs in the Key of Z, his home was constantly full of guests taking drugs. Chusid also points to childhood trauma that his bandmates believed would catch up with him one way or another: his father died when he was 15, and his mother was both a constant source of stress and someone who pampered him. Whatever the cause, his increasingly erratic behavior on stage and in the studio led the band to essentially drop him and replace him with his longtime friend David Gilmour. What I didn’t know is that FIVE different producers worked on the sessions behind this album, its follow-up Barrett and the later outtakes collection Opel. It began because Pink Floyd’s managers at the time, Peter Jenner and Andrew King, split from the band to stick with Barrett after he was quietly pushed out. Convinced he could still make great music on his own, they persuaded EMI to let him record the songs he had ready. After a false start in 1968, EMI’s Malcolm Jones revived the project a year later. The sessions went well for a while, until it became clear they were anything but. Barrett was allowed to mix tracks on his own despite warnings that he shouldn’t be left in the studio unaccompanied, and the Soft Machine members brought in to back him couldn’t figure out what he was doing, among other problems. Eventually, Gilmour and Roger Waters stepped in to finish the album, fearing it would otherwise be shelved. In essence, this album is as good as it could have been, given Barrett’s mental state and the strain on everyone involved. This was the late ’60s. People didn’t understand mental health the way we do today, and I feel everyone involved genuinely hoped to give Barrett and his career a boost, seeing him not only as a talented songwriter but as a friend. The more you unravel the story, the sadder it gets. So, my opinion? I love it, but it’s so frustrating to listen to. Frustrating because these songs are so dark, melodic, experimental, unnerving and creative yet sloppily put together. Frustrating because they feel like demos rather than polished masterpieces, and we’d never get anything better. Frustrating because it makes me think of everything he could have written afterwards and never did. Whether it’s the hair-raising folk ballad “Terrapin”, the tragic “Dark Globe”, the brutal cacophony of “No Good Trying”, the hesitantly pretty “Golden Hair”, the noisy folk rock of “Long Gone” or even the garbled start of “If It’s in You”, every one of these songs pulls an emotional response out of me. It’s a hard listen, but an essential one. I'm so glad this list included one of THE most well known outsider albums of all time. The death of the ’60s rocker has never been better documented than here. Give it the attention and love it deserves. 4.5 stars.

Was Syd Barrett really a genius? Or was he mythologised because of his status as an acid casualty who never realised his full potential? Pink Floyd’s seminal albums came after his involvement ceased and based on the evidence here it appears that Gilmore, Waters and Wright as a collective are a far superior songwriting team. There were a couple of decent melodies but they are ruined by shoddy playing and poor production, overall I kept thinking of Listen to The Flower people by Spinal Tap who clearly took inspiration from this and albums like it. 1.8

Awful. Not way would this have made the light of day if it wasn't for him being in pink floyd.

I can't really put into words what I like about this album. All I can say is that I thoroughly enjoyed it. Favs: No Man's Land, Here I Go, Octopus

Ridiculous ramblings of someone who's head is blown up from ass kissers telling him he's some kind of genius.. I work with someone like this and this album sounds like something he would make.

Essential primarily as a cautionary tale. Drugs are bad, kids. Don't waste your potential by forgetting to drop in on reality every once in a while. Maybe have some friends who aren't on acid give you some feedback on your new music before you release it.

This album perfectly captures a sadly unraveling mind - from the weirdness of the music, it's mad variety, the great album cover; it's a nice little package of strangeness. You can also definitely tell Robert Wyatt was involved with some of the childish sounding music, but it really fits. I can understand why some people might despise this record, but in its context it's a great snapshot of Syd Barrett.

a bit of a tough listen. theres a lot of good here, but some of it makes you wonder if the people who gave it the green light were also suffering a mental break.

At its best, this album sounds like the Beatles if they were kinda bored and making music just for the paycheck. At its worst, it sounds like your coworker drunkenly doing karaoke in a shady basement bar on a Wednesday afternoon.

pouco inspirado, bem superficial, sem alma mesmo e, quando tenta aprofundar, parece bobo, fraco.

Favorite lyric: “Oh baby, my hair’s on end about you” I came into this thinking “well this might be a struggle,” having not heard it in a very long while and remembering all the sad stories about Syd Barrett. What I thought I’d remembered from hearing this in the 70s was that it was like some of the songs on the early Pink Floyd records that I used to skip in order to listen to stuff like “Astronomy Domine” over and over. But this seems more spare, with odd little lyrics and weirder, occasionally arrhythmic arrangements. At times it feels like a stripped-down Neutral Milk Hotel. I didn’t come into this expecting to give it a 5, but here we are; I really enjoyed it.

Most one star albums are failures of ego or talent. This album is a failure of those around Syd. It’s painful to listen to at times. It is the sound of Syd Barrett coming apart and it probably shouldn’t have been recorded or released.

Naw, not feeling it

Worth a listen simply for the story of who he was. Even though he was a founding member and principal writer/singer, PF’s best work came after he departed. Was he crazy? Probably. Something sad about this silly work here, but oddly appealing too. Shine On!

It's stylistically reminiscent of the Beach Boys or the Doors, slowed down and casually sung over, with minimal production and an overall unpolished vibe. There are glimpses of brilliance here, snatches of lyrics or chord progressions that surprise and delight, but it never quite coalesces into something more. The second half starts to degenerate into less organized songs, half-composed fragments, studio outtakes, and badly-sung stuff that should probably never have been released. (Parts of "If It's In You" sound like stuff that was cut from "This Is Spinal Tap" for not being funny.) It's a cliché to say it, but if Barrett had been able to maintain some mental stability he probably would have been a hall-of-famer.

Cool that this is the lead singer of Pink Floyd

I don't get it man. I'm convinced if this was an album by someone who wasn't a famous musician no one would care about it. Boring, self indulgent, us white people really be out here putting whatever the fuck to tape and calling it art.

Yeahh I’m not surprised all of Pink Floyd’s good music came into existence after this guy left the band I can see some unique ideas in here, and honestly there’s parts that sound pretty damn solid. Guitars and bass are great and I think some songs are just weird enough to work. The production talent of most of the rest of Pink Floyd is absolutely working overtime There’s some real bad stuff about this. I think it’s pretty boring at times and there are some truly abhorrent tracks on this (listen to If It’s in You). His vocals are not great, and absolutely bring this one down. Long story short I just don’t think there’s any genuinely good songs on this one I think this could absolutely be cool with some smarter design choices, but this one definitely fails a bit. The whole story with Syd Barrett’s pretty sad, but I’m not factoring that into my rating at all. Without the bad songs this would be closer to a 3 but I can’t ignore them

I haven't really listened to the older Pink Floyd works and I can't comment on what he did for the band, so the troubled-but-talented mad genius angle is lost on me. It's just nonsense music; disjointed snippets of a guy going through it. It's the same thing with Wish You Were Here where Syd Barrett's psychotic breakdown has become a romanticized part of Pink Floyd mythos. It's troubling to me on a conceptual level, and audibly, it also really sucks.

Not great. I'm a Pink Floyd fan, so I wanted to like this, but didn't.

This album and Syd Barret in general has it's/his own genre and own time signatures and special chord structures which makes it really unique to listen to. Really enjoyable stuff and wacky enough to really separate it from anything else. It's kind of hard to rate this with the same standards as "normal" music, but in it's own category it's perfect 5/5 album!

This album is on this list only because it's Syd Barrett. Boring album.

terrible

#493 / 1089 Heard before? ❌ Revisit? ❌ I've heard Syd's music before, but have not actively listened to a full album before. It was what I expected, but not as weird as I remembered. He has a style that doesn't really work for me too well, feeling I had before playing this one and this just reinforced it. Not for me, sadly 2/5

This a truly awful. Feels ghouish to listen to it.

Syd Barrett was a genius, and his story is tragic. What might the great band Pink Floyd have achieved if Syd had been able to stick with them? On the other hand, that tragedy also influenced the band’s work. It’s all very speculative. In any case, I was looking forward to the album. You can hear echoes of the early Pink Floyd in some places. Unfortunately, the album ends up being a bit disappointing. Even the contributions from Waters and Gilmour to the album couldn’t change that. 3/5

Occasionally the sound is on par with early Pink Floyd, but more often the songs feel unfinished, both in writing and arranging/recording. I can’t help but wonder what this album could’ve been if Barrett was in a healthier place mentally.

Pretty weird. I know the rock scene at the time had a lot of space for stuff like this though. This isn't so far off of the Lou Reed stuff around the same time.

Disappointingly little laughter.

most of it i could listen to in the background - and wouldn't be too bad at that since it is fairly laid back - but some of it has some... questionable vocals that pop out a bit too much for me

Started strong, but got repetitive. Liked the first 3 songs

This wasn’t good (maybe for sad reasons?)

Honestly feels a little unethical at points, especially the second side but what it mainly exposes is Syd’s singular genius. He basically created a whole style of songwriting, but never really got to revel in any of the success of his talents.