Album Summary
Before and After Science is the fifth studio album by British musician Brian Eno. Produced by Eno and Rhett Davies, it was originally released by Polydor Records in December 1977 in the United Kingdom and by Island U.S. soon after. Musicians from the U.K. and Germany collaborated on the album, including Robert Wyatt of Soft Machine, Fred Frith of Henry Cow, Phil Manzanera of Roxy Music, Paul Rudolph of Hawkwind, Andy Fraser of Free, Dave Mattacks of Fairport Convention, Jaki Liebezeit of Can, and Dieter Moebius and Hans-Joachim Roedelius of Cluster. Over one hundred tracks were written with only ten making the album's final cut. The musical styles of the album range from energetic and jagged to languid and pastoral. The album marks Eno's last foray into rock music as a solo artist in the 1970s, with nearly all of his following albums showcasing more of Eno's avant-garde and ambient music, which was hinted at on the second half of Before and After Science. The album was Eno's second to chart in the United States. The song "King's Lead Hat", the title of which is an anagram for Talking Heads, was remixed and released as a single, although it didn't chart in the United Kingdom. Critical response to the album has remained positive, with several critics calling it one of Eno's best works.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Wacky but I liked it
I prefer his instrumentals over his vocals
do love some of these songs, by the river is freaking beautiful bro prefer his ambient stuff tbh
probably his last song-oriented album (someone will correct me here). I do love a spot of Eno so this was a great start to the day. The session player list is enviable, top drawer stuff.
First half was like his funky off-beat Talking Heads stuff and second half was like his ambient work! I like.
Normally I think of Eno as a producer for others, so I don’t know if I’ve listened to his solo stuff before. This was interesting. A lot of good ideas, fun electronic with still a bunch of pop but also feeling missing at the same time; like it wasn’t cohesive. Still enjoyable but not amazing.
Apparently I really do fuck with Brian Eno? This was great, I really enjoyed it
Much better than I expected! Backwater and Kings Lead Hat personal favourites.
nothin rlly did it for me on this one but it wasnt a bad listen
Pleasant enough but not really something i would listen to out of choice.
eh
Brian Eno voor de zoveelste keer. Een beetje new wave, een beetje keyboarddromerigheid, wat valse akkoorden, wat rare zang. Soms lijkt het serieuze muziek, dan zitten ze gewoon weer wat te rammen. Vervolgens speelt ome Brian weer een slaapliedje voor ons. En voor de zoveelste keer had 't van mij allemaal niet gehoeven.
Inmiddels is mijn ergenis aan Eno's muzikale fratsen wel bekend. En ja hoor, het eerste nummer heeft gelijk weer zo'n geluid. Ik associeer het met een veer. Toch kan ik dat nummer best doorkomen. Er zit toch iets meer balans in dan er was bij zijn vroegere albums. En die langgerekte tonen van zijn ambientperiode zijn er nog niet. Uiteraard juich ik te vroeg. Kurt's Rejoinder heeft beide: én een raar ritme met wazige geluiden én de lang doorgetrokken tonen. Dit is een album dat wellicht een overgangsperiode markeert. Het combineert de ellende van de jaren '70 Eno met de ellende van de jaren '80 Eno. En samen is dat ineens toch interessanter. Dit is het enige album onder zijn eigen naam, dat redelijkerwijs in deze lijst staat. Het is veruit het beste van de 5 albums in deze lijst. Afgerond naar boven, denk ik zelfs dat dit wel 3 sterren waard is.
Brian Eno is altijd verraderlijk, want hij probeert soms iets teveel te vernieuwen en te experimenteren. Het valt hier gelukkig best mee, of ik kan het goed hebben vandaag. Op het eerste deel is het vooral poprock met artsy fartsy invloeden. Ik hoor oa een soort Bassie en Adriaan achtergrondmuziekje. En komt David Byrne nog even om de hoek kijken, dus dan weet je in welk hokje het te plaatsen is. Op deel twee krijgen we een voorproefje te horen van de ambient die Eno later is gaan maken en tot in den treurnis heeft "geperfectioneerd". Nu vind ik dit dus nog redelijk toegankelijk en soms zou ik het zelfs sfeervol durven noemen, in de positieve zin van het woord. Al met al wordt er volop geëxperimenteerd, maar vaak is het zo dat als dat experiment niet te ver door wordt gevoerd, je nog best luisterenswaardige muziek overhoudt. Ik heb hier totaal geen moeite mee gehad. Prima 3.
Dancey and then drifty.
Diverse and groundbreaking
I liked it more than I expected I would. “Backwater” and “Kurt’s Rejoinder “ are bouncy fun. Lyrics are nonsense but the sound is fun. His, I guess according to Wikipedia write up, pastoral sound was good but did not entertain me as much as the jauntier fare.
That must be the forth or fifth album by Brian Eno to appear here. Most of them were pure bullshit, especially that one with the airport sounds... christ... anyway, but just like the previous one, this one is not bad either. I just hope that 1001albunsgenerator doesn't keep on pushing this guy's whole discography until I actually really enjoy it, cause it ain't happening. 3 stars.
The opening track could be off any of the Bowie Berlin trilogy - not surprising given Eno's heavy involvement there and the overlap of musicians. Backwater is very lyrically clever - maybe too much for its own good. Kurt’s Rejoinder is a funky number but again the lyrics are pretty nonsensical In general the album is very musically accomplished but it leaves me pretty cold. Kings Lead Hat is much better, a driving song with a sense of purpose. There’s quite a bit of the Talk Heads sound here, which is interesting as Eno would produce three albums for them over the next few years. Here He Comes is a mellow number with simpler accompaniments and some nice harmonies. Julie Comes continues the theme. Some hints of the ambient works to come, a node to late era Beach Boys and Pink Floyd The last three tracks are all pretty chilled out ambient stuff and I much prefer this to the proggy opening of the album. I’m sure Music For Airports must be in the 1001 list somewhere so I’m looking forward to that. Overall I’m glad I listened to, it had some enjoyable moments especially towards the back end of the album, but don't imagine I'd race back.
KING'S LEAD HAT PUT THE POKER IN THE FIRE IT WILL COME IT WILL COME IT WILL SURELY COME
I had heard of Brian Eno before, and I know he's highly regarded by music critics, but I wasn't familiar with his music. I wasn't sure what to expect, but this album got off to a great start! "No One Receiving" was funky and cool, and it immediately reminded me of Talking Heads. I liked "Backwater" even more, and "Kurt's Rejoinder" kept the fun going. "King's Lead Hat" sounded the most like Talking Heads, which is fitting since the title is an anagram of their name. I do prefer David Byrne's vocals, but I was really enjoying Eno's music. Then there was "Here He Comes," which I also liked a lot. By that point, I wasn't even comparing Eno to anybody else. I was appreciating his music on its own. Unfortunately, the rest of the album was a completely different story. "Energy Fools the Magician" did nothing for me, and starting with "Julie With...," the album completely lost my attention. The remaining songs were so slow and atmospheric that they were practically putting me to sleep. This is one of the strangest albums I've rated so far because five songs are easily 5-star material, while the other five are 1-star songs for me. That averages out to 3 stars. If they had just switched "Energy Fools the Magician" with "Here He Comes," I could have enjoyed an entire side of the record without ever having to flip it over! 😂 Rating: 3/5 stars Vinyl Verdict: NO BUY I really enjoyed half of this album, but the other half just wasn't my jam.
I simply lack the spirit for experimental and avant-garde music. Rating: 2
Probably my favorite of his so far. Pop first half that gradually transitions into more mellow. Don't really understand what makes him special but I guess it must be something technical that eludes me
Wow what a difficult album to rate, the last 3 tracks were subtle, beautiful and exactly what I love about Brian Eno. 10/10. A good chunk of the middle though, the more pop oriented stuff, I really didn't care for. I guess maybe on some artistic level he makes you sit through the more jarring loud stuff to get the pay off of the clam reprise at the end. We'll worth the wait, but I know what part I'll come back too.
This was an interesting album and one that was clearly written and sequenced with the vinyl listening experience in mind. Side one was funky and a bit anxious feeling at times. It reminded me of the Talking Heads. The transition to side two was a bit abrupt, but the music on side two is a lot more atmospheric and ambient and points to where Brian Eno’s music would head next.
Es raro pa mi oir esa faceta de Eno, igual no me gustó
Some great tracks and some fillers. Worth a listen
Still not the biggest Eno fan, but this was palatable.
A bit random at times, verging on being good but not quite making it as an album
The poppy stuff like "Backwater" and "King's Lead Hat" isn't bad, but I'm more interested by the back few tracks where it dips into a more ambient, moody style. I'd pick "Through Hollow Lands" and "Spider and I" as highlights.
very nice
One of the best Brian Eno albums I’ve heard so far
Didn’t like or dislike this. I’m more of a fan of Eno’s ambient electronic stuff.
1,8/5
It’s OK but he’s better producing than making music.
The album that got me into Eno’s art rock side! Probably my favorite record in his solo catalogue. Feels like Richard Dawson (one of my favorite 2010s/20s songwriters) took a lot of inspiration from this record’s time traveling adventures. Excellent.
A Seriously boring album. 2 stars or D-.
I have never heard this Talking Heads album before. I like it enough to give it a 4, but I like Remain In Light and More Songs About Buildings And Food much more.
rico
#507 / 1089 Heard before? ❌ Revisit? ❌ Oh, how much of the 80's sound was on this Eno album, again I might add. His stuff was really groundgreaking, or rather copied from a lot, I think both might be equally true. Regarding the sound, 80's kind of ruined this sound for me, but I tried to give this album a fair change regardless. It feels a bit... uneven, as far as the music goes. I wouldn't call any of it my favourite, but some of the tracks resonated with me quite a lot, while some some almost seemed to fight me. I'd like to give it 4 but feel it's not that for me and 2 feels like I'm being dishonest, so a luke warm 3/5 it is, sadly.
Infelizmente não desenvolve muito, exceto no final do álbum que tem um gostinho. Dito isto, Gostei de “King's Lead Hat”, “Through Hollow Lands (for Harold Budd)” e “Spider and I”.
achei o melhor do brian até agora, por ser mais rockzinho e tals. bacana.
Side 2!
I may have to give this album another listen. The first few songs sounded like music he performed with Roxy Music. Then for the rest of the album, the songs were more ambient. Those are the tracks that I need to pay more attention to.
2.5/5
It wasn't terrible! Just wasn't memorable
Pretty cool. Good voice, interesting tracks here and there.
Its ok...
can't remember anything of it
Better than the last one, but not really my thang.
I like Brian Eno's ambient music, his forays into David Byrne's world music library, and some of Roxy Music. This, I liked much less.
This was recommended to me a few months ago. I listened once, liked it, and loved Here He Comes. Then I forgot about it and probably had albums on this list to catch up on. Glad it showed up on this list. It expanded my already deep appreciation for Eno.
I liked this a lot. More so the uptempo tracks like King's Lead Hat than the slow fade of the last few, but even those were good.
5/5 - This really drew me in. Listened to it three times today. Can see the Talking Heads connection, and it tickles my audio brain.
I surely prefer the more avant-garde Eno. But, weirdly, I found the more rock-influenced first half of the album to be the more interesting here. The vocals really worked. The second half of the album . . . lingered a little too long.
Its just too much and not enough at the same time. We are trying to make a deep point but the music just gets confusing and doesn't go well together so I can't really pay attention to what he is saying. Its not unpleasant but just nothing that I can connect with. At times it feels really pedistrian and rudimentary so it just really loses its depth for me.
The description said this was his last rock album before his transition to ambient music, but half of this already feels like ambient music, so the album itself feels like it's transitioning. Which is kinda neat I guess, and there was some cool sound experimentation happening throughout. In the end though, I found it disjointed and boring and I didn't really understand it as a complete album.
I was previously familiar with Brian Eno but not this album. It's beautifully weird as only Brian Eno can be. The sounds are lush but the song structure is still more traditional than his ambient material. This was cool and deserves another listen. I would come back to it for sure.
somehow missed this eno album, but damn it is really good
music is love
Feels very experimental and sporadic. I did not enjoy the first song, the rhythm and structure gnawed at my ears. I also did not like the second song, for similar reasons. That being said, it was an improvement to the previous track. By the third song, I started to realise that this was how the entire album was going to be. Not good. Slightly scared, I kept going. Only to be mildly confused by the next song. Was it better than the previous songs? Yes. But was it enjoyable? No. Moving on to King's Lead Hat, the change of tempo and style almost gave me whiplash. An album doesn't have to be completely cohesive, but Brian Eno's approach definitely pushes boundaries. Maybe those boundaries were there for a reason, though. Still, this song was my favourite of the album. After that, I lost track, but what I do remember is not liking it.
Oh weird, the guy who has produced a bunch of music I love and has otherwise been an influence on a lot of things I enjoy has good non-ambient solo albums, who could have seen this one coming? Very into the first half because it reminded me of his future collaborations with Byrne and Talking Heads (not just because of the song name), and then in turn very into the second half because once you ease into it, it’s a more lush openly-emotional spin of his incoming ambient work. All in all, feels so much like an album where you’re going back to find an origin or a turning point so it feels bold and new but also comforting in impact.
The experiment failed
Some interesting ideas on here, but at no point did I feel like it was a necessary album to hear.
Check out the new ENO documentary its pretty cool.
A very interesting transition from his early art rock work to his more well known ambient pieces. 4.5 bumped down to 4.
I’m at a 5. Imagine if you will, two little spiders. They’re looking up at the sky. They can’t hear anything. Their purpose, for that night, is to produce a web so they can try to catch one fly. And yet, when they sleep in the morning, whether they’ve successfully caught that fly or not, they dream of something bigger. They dream of a ship, sailing a thousand miles away. Imagine if you will, that very ship. There are two people there, looking up at the sky. They can’t hear anything. Nobody’s passing it. Nobody can see it. Nobody’s picking up on its radio signals. They’re left to wonder if they’ll ever be seen again, or if time will leave them all alone to be forgotten. And yet, somewhere out there in the world, are two little spiders that can see them so vividly in their dreams. Brian Eno manages to make a world driven by ambition on this album. It’s got every side to that ambition. Some people totally lack that ambition & find themselves stuck in a bored rut. Some people lose their ambitions & find themselves only able to live in the past. Some people’s ambition is through pledging themselves to a religion that may never pay off. It’s a fascinating look at the world, while also managing to mix in some of Brian’s eccentricities to represent his own ambition – there’s a song that anagrams to “Talking Heads” that makes no sense, a song driven by the sounds of his vocals as a driving force, and a pair of instrumentals that feel like medieval noir & a walk through a barren wasteland. It seems like even the title itself references ambition, seemingly referring to the world before & after science. I think it’s a little fair to say that for most people, we’ve gotten so comfortable with the world at large that it’s hard to find the spark to keep innovating. And yet, somewhere out there in the world, are two little spiders that have that spark just to catch a single fly. It’s something we need to keep. It’s a miracle that Brian Eno managed to get that out of my brain, but I think scaling it down so effectively in the last track really framed the entire album for me. It feels like a perspective we all need. It also helps that it’s so nice on the ears to listen to. It’s 40 minutes that explore ambition in a way that I happened to really enjoy, and I’m so very glad it’s here as our final solo Brian Eno album on the list. I think it’s a 5, and frankly, a bit higher.
No m gusta
Brian Eno. Enough said.
He should never sing, his voice is weak and watery. The music is overindulgent at best, boring at worst.
It’s good to see him playing his ideas out. It was as varied and interesting as I would expect if not to the level of the bands he produced.
Excellent. Another album that rewards you if you stick with it. Music for Airports was my first, and for a long time- only, exposure to Eno. Roxy Music was hit/miss for me, but I enjoyed this album.
This started off so funky, but the singing/speaking was so weird. The last three tracks (By the river, through hollow lands, spider and I) were really pretty. Overall, pretty meh, but the last 3 tracks bumped this up to 4* for me.
It was OK. Brian Eno has a very specific sound, and this deviates from that, but was more generic than his typical sound.
Something I never heard before. Surprisingly good and you can also hear the future of his music. But an essential album? Not sure about that.
Interesting to hear his influence on Talking Heads or their influence on him.
Interesting to hear new wave, not what I expected from Brian Eno
Brian Eno is one of those names I've heard over and over again for years but I've never sat down and listened to his music. Clearly, that was a big oversight because this is a really fun album I can definitely see myself listening to again.
Trippy; sometimes electronic, sometimes folk. Lots of interesting noted [and unnoted] features. A cool listen!
I'm pretty familiar with Brian Eno’s breadth of style, from his glam rock days to his soaring ambient compositions, but I’m new to this album. It’s interesting to get a glimpse of his work right on the threshold between those two forms of expression, coinciding with his production work for Bowie. Frankly, that work is more powerful, but this album had some pleasant surprises, at moments evoking the Grateful Dead or Ringo Starr.
What a cool find! Brian Eno is an Ambient/Electronic Guru. Adding a bit of rock and roll flair to it makes it all the better (most of the time). This album is so Floydian and I think that's what I like about it. Favorite Tracks: "Here He Comes" and "Through Hollow Lands"
Good background noise
I've somehow skipped Brian eno for the whole of my life, not what I expected. Not horrendous
NO! NO MORE BRIAN ENO! SHIT!
Im stunned I scored it this high. But its a well balanced album
Can't really discredit any of the work he did. He's a genius and the genius is on display here. It kind of just feels like one of his many 70's albums here. It's good enough but doesn't really stand out to me. The novelty of this Synth driven experimental Pop was already a bit less in the late 70's. Can't say I was all that wowed by it this time around.
You learn something new every day: today I learned that I've been mixing up the names 'Brian Eno' and 'Brian Setzer' for a long time lol. I was confused when the album started because it didn't sound like I expected, then realized Brian Eno is a completely different person who didn't have his own "orchestra". Despite my mix up, I liked this a lot. I enjoyed the variety of songs and found it to be a pleasant and fun listen. I'm going to look into more Brian Eno.
Interesting as I had never listened to Brian Eno. Nice start to a long day in London
First time listen. Loved it.
I just had an Eno album a week ago. I'm kind of bummed to get another one so soon. Notably, this album is more ambient and calming than the other album I had. However, it's not any better, though the vocals are less grating. The songs tend to lack hooks, unlike the ones on his more poppy debut that I had earlier. It is interesting, but not enough to make it a properly great album. This album is ranked #22 of 27 albums for 1977. Other 1977 albums rated by me: Rumours(1/27)-5 Exodus(2/27)-4 The Stranger(3/27)-4 Out of the Blue(4/27)-3 "Heroes"(5/27)-3 Lust for Life(6/27)-4 Talking Heads '77(8/27)-4 Low(9/27)-3 Marquee Moon(11/27)-4 Aja(12/27)-3 Zombie(13/27)-4 Bat Out of Hell(15/27)-4 My Aim Is True(16/27)-2 Peter Gabriel(17/27)-3 The Idiot(18/27)-3
I liked the very peaceful songs, but some of the other ones were kind of boring.
Worse than the Beatles and worse than the Talking Heads. Don't really get this one.
Eh. Had some good songs, some were boring. I could hear his influence on Bowie for sure tho!
Really enjoyed the ambiant songs on this album
And for today's "final album," we have my last Brian Eno album of the list! I've gotten to understand Eno's talents pretty well with all of the albums he's involved with on the list, and I've got to say that his talent is absolutely remarkable. Whether he's producing for a different artist or working on his own material, you can trust that Brian Eno's work is going to be ahead of its time and exciting to listen to in one way or another. When it comes to Eno's own albums, I'd say that Before and After Science is one of the better ones I've heard! It's not quite as good as Another Green World, but I think this one might be my second favorite. Granted, it does take a lot of cues from Another Green World, but you know what they say. If it ain't broke, don't fix it. Before and After Science does something pretty interesting, where the first half is mostly filled with bouncier art rock tracks, while the second half is on the more ambient side. Honestly, you can't go wrong with either side, though I do find the second half to be more appealing personally, with songs like "Spider and I" and especially "By This River" being some of the best on the album. The first half's got some fun songs though, with "King's Lead Hat" being the best of the bunch, though that song totally cheats by having a Robert Fripp guitar solo. Eno's voice is more present here than on Another Green World, and I think that might be the biggest reason why I don't enjoy this one quite as much as that album. Brian Eno's voice isn't bad, but it's not particularly strong either. It works well enough, but it doesn't go beyond that. Other than that one issue, Before and After Science is a really cool album. It's kinda the best of both worlds when it comes to Eno's rock side and his ambient side. I could totally see this being someone's favorite album of his. But as for me, it'll go at number 2 on my tentative Brian Eno album ranking. Great stuff. High 4/5.
una canción wena. ahora pude saber su procedencia.
This has a very Talking Heads vibe, and I dig it. Not quite as organized or refined, perhaps, but still enjoyed.
Sparky, punny, urgent - music pointing to the future
#451 The first half of this album, and particularly the first track have a Talking Heads vibe. I immediately checked the year of release to see where this falls vs his time working with Talking Heads and was slightly surprised to learn it was 1977, the same year as their debut. He certainly had a big influence on Talking Heads and notably across some of their best albums but clearly Talking Heads had an influence on him too since he named a track King’s Lead Hat (an anagram of Talking Heads). The second half of the album is much slower and reflective, which I found enjoyable but it drifts quite far from that quirky and anxious energy that sets it up. Spider and I rewards patience, and the right mood, and closes the album perfectly I debated between 3 and 4 stars and ultimately landed at the latter, probably helped by a 2nd listen which was mostly due to being forced to listen to it in a few parts first time round and I needed a more focused listen. Heard before? ❌ Would I revisit? ✅ Listen before you die? ✅ Fave track(s): No One Receiving; Spider and I Rating: 7/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️
Nice contrast between the rhythmic songs and the softer textures. Really interesting sound.