Who is this for

This feels very situational for me. Like I probably would like it more in the car or in the background at a house party. ETA: I did in fact listen to the back half of this in the car and I did like it more!

Not like, offensive to my ears but def not returning to this one

Damn you really had to be there

Bono, the best to ever do it. The vocals on With Or Without You 🥰🥰🥰💀💀💀 Only gave it 4 stars bc the back half falls off a bit for me

I'm not cool enough for Blur

Fabulous

When people say "the vibes are immaculate", this is what they mean. An incredible debut

This could have been so corny but it never tips into schmaltz

Extremely my shit!!!!!!

Praise You rewired my brain as a preteen Love Island rips

The global reviews for this are unnecessarily harsh! That being said this is extremely my shit

Absolutely did not do it for me, surprisingly. I felt like a need to be MORE of something – more glam rock? More theatrical? More blues-y? I would have loved The Passenger had I not heard it in 1000 commercials

Hold me closer Tony Danza

In retrospect, listening to this while answering Slack messages was probably not the best environment for this album

Steely Dan seem like the biggest dorks but I’m more endeared to them every time I listen to them Midnite Cruiser rips

Fine but forgettable. Sweet Emotion still rips tho

I can see why people like it but at the end of the day Radiohead just isn’t for me

Fun and funky. How is it that I’ve never heard of these dudes!!!! Obsessed with the way percussion and saxophone are used on this album Amazing band name

Proud of myself for listening to this one I mean, it is what it is

Who is this for

Delightful and calming, who can deny Paul Simon

I like all the scritchy scratchies

One of my favorite voices in music Title track 😍 and Birds 😭

Not my favorite flavor of new wave

Moody in a late '90s way, I dig it although it’s not something I will return to

I know I'm not really supposed to actively listen to this, but I paid attention and it's great Feels like I should be in the cooldown section at a yoga class

Would be massively improved with a different vocalist

Southern rock by way of The Strokes. Everything here feels very samey

An example of something I would have never listened to if not for this project. It’s wild how little I know about Willie Nelson. His 18th album???????

We are lucky to live in the same time as Trent Reznor

Jazz like this always makes me think of Christmas Title track is the best one

These little bells are making me craaaaaazy

Love me some Jackie Jormp-Jomp

Not a fan. It had its moments musically but this guy’s voice is too grating. I will not be returning to this.

Absolutely not my bag baby

Totally fine. Finding through this project that jazz isn’t really my thing but I don’t find it aurally offensive or anything

Beep beep boop boop Would be nice as background music in a museum or something Great band name

The Beach Boys really walk that fine line of corniness but the instrumentation and production here is so layered and interesting it cancels it out

My kind of noodling

I see why girls in the 60s were going absolutely nuts over this

I mean, pretty much exactly what I expected

“Lost Souls is considered by many to be the best debut album since Oasis' Definitely Maybe” Who is this “many” Like the most boring Coldplay imaginable. Back third of the album is slightly better but not by much.

Enjoyed this much more than I thought I would

Not really my favorite flavor of this type of thing but I’m not mad about it. Ended up being pretty fun as the album progressed. Title track is catchy

In my younger years, I probably would’ve enjoyed this more but it’s not really my speed these days Like the tracks Sister and Cliche

A welcome reprieve from everything else we’ve been listening to. I needed some funk Higher Ground and Don’t You Worry ‘Bout A Thing are evergreen bops

Only three stars because it’s not my favorite Foo but Dave Grohl’s musicianship cannot be denied

The longer it went on the more I liked it

Not my favorite kind of noodling. I won’t be returning to this.

Impossible to divorce from my nostalgia (which is a toxic impulse IYKYK). Millennial is gonna millennial unfortunately.

Very atmospheric with cool vocals. I can appreciate what’s happening here but’s it’s not for me

Praise Lady Miss Kier!!!!!!! An absolute vibe, both of and ahead of its time.

This ain’t it I appreciate the level of artistic integrity here, but I will not be returning to this

This gets a whole extra star for Come Out And Play

Beautiful and theatrical. Excellent production.

Timeless and tight. A fun listen.

Opening with Gimme Shelter is a flex You Can’t Always Get What You Want, one of the all time great songs Everything else was totally fine!

I liked it more as it went on. A 90s time capsule.

Dated. Not doing it for me. That being said if it came on in a supermarket I’d be groovin

Meh I don’t know, the vibraphones are really throwing me off

Too cool

Deeply, deeply uncool. I felt all 36 mins of this

Not my thing

Beautiful. Hating on Chris Martin or Coldplay is a tired take

No thank you. This was excruciating

A classic for a reason

Nile Rodgers, the man that you are

This feels like music that’s from a museum exhibit that you have to listen to using those big puffy headphones

Sexy muzak

Not a lot of memorable hits but even mediocre Stevie is great

Haven’t listened to this one in years so it was fun to revisit. A unique artist with a lot to say.

So boring

Beautiful

Impeccable vibes

The instrumentals are rad but the flat singing is bothering me I’d probably really like this as a sync in a movie

Probably a blast live

Snooze

Too samey and sounds very dated in 2025

Sorry guys, I love this shit 🤷🏻‍♀️

Kind of a vibe but not the vibe I was feeling today

This ain’t it

What can one say about Rumours that hasn’t already been said? An instant 5 star album. TIME CAST A SPELL ON YOU BUT YOU WON’T FORGET ME (I know it’s not an official track but I had to)

Not for me

I liked it better the more it went on

Fun! I like this vibe. Would have been a 3.5.

This feels very situational for me. Like I probably would like it more in the car or in the background at a house party. ETA: I did in fact listen to the back half of this in the car and I did like it more!

It’s aggressively fine!

Would have rated this a 3.5 but I’m rounding up. Courtney Love is pretty cool

Nothing groundbreaking, pretty mid You lose a star when you’re a sexual predator

Spooky scary!!!!!

😬😬😬😬

Genuinely great

It’s not my first choice of Queen albums but I’m not mad at it

Not as fun as some of the other metal albums we’ve gotten so far

Boring!

We’re only ~10% into the list at this point and we’ve gotten so much psychedelic rock 😩😩😩😩😩 No thanks

Ended up liking this more than I expected to

Just not my thing

Cool as hell

I need a cocktail

Not for me dog

Why?

Not as bad as I was expecting it to be but I also realized I confuse Slipknot and GWAR a lot

Imagine this being your FIRST album

I dig it. Cast a hex on me Siouxsie!!!!!

I mean of course it’s great, I can enjoy it from a distance. I probably would have appreciated it more if there wasn’t 3+ hours of it.

I liked the more blues-y stuff but overall this is not for me

Cue a Liz Lemon eyeroll

ABBA’s cool as hell There’s a sense of urgency to their music that I can’t quite put my finger on but it makes it so fun to listen to

Pointy!!!! This would be a 4.5 but I’m rounding up

Had some interesting moments, but ultimately not for me

Went back and forth between a 3 and a but ultimately gave it a 4 because when it was cooking it was really cooking

Ultimately it didn’t hit for me. It felt pretty uneven. Maybe I need Nilsson in smaller doses?

Not really my thing. Did I really need to listen to this before I died?

🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻

This slaps

I mean sure why not

Should be a 4.5, maybe a 4.75

I can see how they’ve influenced basically every band I love

Fred Durst has negative charisma Not interesting enough to justify all of Fred Durst’s “get a load of me” posturing

Booooring

I fucking hate The Doors

Music I’ve heard in movies and commercials (complimentary)

I just don’t really have a lot of feelings about jazz

I love noodling

Still fresh and cool 35 years later

I like the instrumentation and lyrics but his voice is just a tinge too off key for me to really enjoy it

Everything Bruce does is imbued with so much heart and emotion and feeling, it makes for such a special listening experience Jungleland 🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻🤌🏻

I liked this way more than I expected to

Not like, offensive to my ears but def not returning to this one

I wonder if there are still teens out here listening to this for the first time and having their minds blown

Nice vibes

Lost me at some parts More like a 3.75 for me

*British voice* what a wanker Just barely a 2. Consider yourself lucky Julian Cope

Not an enjoyable experience There were a few moments of clarity but not enough to cancel out my 1 star rating

Yeah sure why not

Feels weird to have this AND Back To Black, which is so much more of a complete artistic statement Cute album cover though

Imagine is the least interesting thing happening here

I guess I’m a CCR fan

First half I was giving it a 3, upgraded to a 4 in the back half

Did I need to hear this before I died, not really

Ain’t nothin but a party y’all

Whenever I give music like this a low rating it makes me feel very uncultured. That’s not Fats’s problem though.

Might as well put me in handcuffs because I sure do love The Police!!!!!

The skits kind of slow the momentum but this is a lot of fun

Normally I find banter in a live album kind of annoying but this was pretty charming

Damn you really had to be there

Sure, throw another psychedelia record on the pile, who cares I liked the last three songs, but not enough to give this a higher score

Discovering my love of 80s thrash metal through this project