We're Only In It For The Money by The Mothers Of Invention

We're Only In It For The Money

The Mothers Of Invention

2.46
Rating
23145
Votes
1
24%
2
30%
3
26%
4
13%
5
6%
Distribution

Album Summary

We're Only in It for the Money is the third studio album by American rock band the Mothers of Invention, released on March 4, 1968 by Verve Records. As with the band's first two efforts, it is a concept album, and satirizes left- and right-wing politics, particularly the hippie subculture, as well as the Beatles' album Sgt. Pepper's Lonely Hearts Club Band. It was conceived as part of a project called No Commercial Potential, which produced three other albums: Lumpy Gravy, Cruising with Ruben & the Jets, and Uncle Meat. We're Only in It for the Money encompasses rock, experimental music, and psychedelic rock, with orchestral segments deriving from the recording sessions for Lumpy Gravy, which was previously issued as a solo instrumental album by Capitol Records and was subsequently reedited by frontman Frank Zappa and released by Verve; the reedited Lumpy Gravy was produced simultaneously with We're Only in It for the Money and is the first part of a conceptual continuity, continued with the reedited Lumpy Gravy and concluded with Zappa's final album Civilization Phaze III (1994).

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Not great, but this album has certainly had an effect on me. I managed to get the word ‘discorporate’ into a work Teams call about cyber security yesterday. Today I’m going to try to mention ‘hot poop’ in my year end appraisal.

On the one hand - a deliberately uncomfortable listen, skipping from orchestral to doo wop to saccharin 60s pop with no rhyme or reason, wilfully awkward and smug. On the other hand - a necessary outlier in our listening smorgasbord. Life isn't all cheesecake, listening isn't all smooth and easy. I am giving this five stars for being difficult, despite being so pleased with itself.

I had a friend who lived Frank Zappa. For a while, he was a professional jouster at the Renaissance Faire. Died too soon. Never did care for Zappa myself, though, but adding a couple of stars for the memory.

No matter how much you hate Boomers, Frank Zappa hates them more. This is unlistenable garbage except for weird flashes of irritating genius (Water Turn Black, Idiot Bastard Son, Chrome Plated Megaphone). A monumental work of assholery. I can't give it zero stars so I'll give it four. Don't @ me.

The Sgt. Pepper parody that's also a genuine artistic statement — Zappa using the Beatles' format against itself, the satire aimed at hippie culture, the music industry, censorship, and everything else within range. The intent is clear and the historical importance is real. None of which makes it enjoyable to listen to. Where Hot Rats earned a three for genuine craft underneath the indulgence, this one's deliberately confrontational chaos works against the listener rather than with them — the satire landing as exhausting rather than funny, the abrasion purposeful without being pleasurable. A two for a record that didn't connect on any level, delivered without ambiguity.

interesting project, but not musically enjoyable for the most part in my opinion.

Not for me 1/5

Smug chaos in tonal form.

It got better towards the end, I would have enjoyed it more if there was less talking/skits. 2.5/5

It’s so smug and pretentious.

Just . . . write good songs instead of trying to be clever and avant garde and all this unlistenable nonsense. Whatever drugs Zappa was on were as much the wrong kind of drugs as the drugs George Clinton was on were the right kind of drugs.

Honestly don't know what to do with this one. I suspect, to truly appreciate this album you need to take as many drugs while listening to it as they seemingly did while making it! I know a few of the bigger Frank Zappa hits, but have not listened to an album before. Not sure I will again. It's a 2, as it was vaguely interesting in parts.

Weird, uncomfortable and experimental. Deliberately so, but an intented difficult listen. As an album and a piece of challenging art it works pretty well. But as a vehicle to listen to music less so. I was probably most frustrated by the great musical ideas and hooks that were deliberately not developed, just tossed away as if they were easily replicated else where. Frank is clearly a genius, but in a very specific and deliberately weird way. 4 for the art, 1 for the music. Rounded down.

"We're Only In It For The Money." Yeah, Frank, I gathered that. I wish you'd been in it for the artistry, honestly. I generally like Zappa, but this is about as appetizing as a hot beer. I get that he's trying to take the piss out of society and pop culture of the time, but today all the jokes fall flat. Try again. This album is neither influential nor necessary. My Rating: 1/5

nagyon erdekes! foleg a suttogos elemek

Maybe I just don‘t get it. But my main issue is: Even parody songs should be good songs, not just parodies.

I like to think I'm pretty tolerant of different types of music but I just can't understand this. Someone made this. They actually spent time recording this. They presumably took time writing it. Editing it. Someone paid for this to be recorded and pressed. People listened to it. Enough people enjoyed it to for it to make this list. Yes it's Frank Zappa but still. Is there a rating less than 0?

Based on others ratings and the things being said I went in thinking this was going to be a very hard listen. Really, I am no fan of Zappa, so this looked… scary. But man, I almost want to give it a 5! Holy shit is it funny! My god, lmao from track one! And this was released in ‘68? God these guys were on it. Right down to the freaky Laurel Canyon killings/ serial killings that hadn’t happened yet. Yeah. This is consistent AND musically interesting. In it for the 5. Despite myself. Gotta love this project! 5 Boolean: TRUE

Im going to talk about this listening experience in therapy

yeah this is ass

Necessity is the mother of invention. That Mothers Of Invention album was not necessary

Frank Zappa may be a musical genius but this music give me a headache.

I can see why people would not like this. It’s an album that requires all your attention to understand the meaning behind the recording tricks and satire that Frank Zappa was trying to convey. I think it’s a masterpiece.

This one was too out there

I love me Zappa, but I also hate me some Zappa. This one is way too artsy and a little too far out there for my tastes. 2.5⭐️

This one is a little too 'out there' for my enjoyment and spinning it again and again....but I see its value on the list.

Frank Zappa is like a box of chocolates - you never know what you're gonna get. In this case, technically speaking, it's hip-hop/gangsta rap: someone spouts socially critical lines laced with the occasional obscenity, while rather monotonous music featuring various samples plays in the background. So is “Flower Punk” a diss track aimed at Jimi Hendrix fans? But back to today’s topic: is “We’re Only In For The Money” comedy? Technically speaking, maybe - much like a beef steak is a meatball. In my view, this recording is the first - and to date, the only - variety album that you absolutely must hear. Those who like easy listening will probably see it differently, but this list obviously isn’t meant for them anyway.

Like a patchwork demo reel of all things that 60s mixing booths could offer, Frank Zappa is on full weird mode. Through today's lens, his message lacks subtlety, but I'm sure he was edgy for his time.

Come for the satire and stay for the incredible musicianship. I knew this was Zappa but I had no idea he made something so beautiful and perfect outside of his solo work.

An album making fun of hippies sounds fun, but it’s so hard to find the same things funny 60 years later. I didn’t really like this

The Shitty Beatles

I dig Zappa. Hi catalogue is weird and often difficult. He has produced an abundance of bueatifully composed and excellently executed pieces that he seemed just fine to purposefully trainwreck. He has legit ruined some of my favourite Zappa tracks (*I understand irony, thanks). An artist's imperative I guess. There are some sweet spots here, but this particular self indulgant slab misses as much as it hits. A little too much wankery for my tastes though I did appreciate the challlenge. Three stars for a one of a kind.

Очень странный альбом, немного чувствуется сатира на хипарей. Но эксперименты с шумами аля Aphex Twin довольно таки интересные

A 39 minute joke....ha, I get i

1 star I hated listening to it.

that irritated me. frank zappa pisses me off

Best thing about this album is that most of the selections were short. Not a fan! Seriously most of this album is not songs but random bits of noise strung together. What a waste of time as far as I'm concerned.

I don’t get it…

I was entertained.

Dogshit.

It’s not all bad, there’s some good satire and biting lyrics, but it’s hard to catch when musically a good amount of of this sounds like…hot poop

This feels like a perfect use for 2 stars.

Personally just cause you satirize a popular album. I don’t think you that makes your album worth listening too.

Im Tired of this grandpa!

Put this one off for a while after giving it a listen half heartedly when it first popped up on the list and I thought WTF. On second listen today weeks later I still think WTF but actually the music isn’t bad, the seamless links between every track make it flow really nice and the more I listened to it the better it got. Do I really have a clue what anybody was on about? No, but at the same time it didn’t matter. It was fun, it kept me listening and I enjoyed it. Best track- ‘flower punk’ who knew the Minions existed years before the big screen! Worst track- ‘what’s the ugliest part of your body’ not kind mate, not kind at all 😬 6.5/10

The Mothers of Invention - We're Only In It For The Money I listened twice to make sure my ears, or brain, weren't malfunctioning the first time. Truly the weirdest album we've been dealt from this list so far. And we've had some pretty 'off-piste' stuff. But it is hard to not be enchanted in some way by this collection of hippydom pisstakes and critiques if the shallowness of psychedelia. And to think this was being written and performed simultaneously with the very world it lampoons shows just how on the ball Zappa and his crazy gang were. A hundred ideas all squashed together but some real musicality, some adventures, some real laughter. I enjoyed and I'd ride this ride again. Best Track - How the fuck do you pick one cos each track is like multiple tracks on its own? Let's say Concentration Moon cos a loved the 60s LA pop pastiche it repeatedly broke into. Worst Track - The Chrome Plated Megaphone of Destiny. This one was too much even for me. 7.5/10

Didn't do anything for me

This whispery start is giving me the ick. This is all a bit mad? Old school experimentation not really doing it for me. 2.5 stars

Way too 'zany' for me. No chance I'd listen to it again

Enjoyed this, though probably more thematically than musically. The critique of SF/CA from both the left and the right (some parallels to K. Dick's Black Iron Prison) also seems highly applicable to current times, albeit through a slightly different lens.

Well, that was interesting in a trippy bat shit crazy kind of way! I listened to it on headphones and had to pause it on several occasions as it was too much sensory overload! Very distinct. Not sure I’d play it at the mythical Cafe Kelvinos though.

Frank Zappa group. Very experimental with moments of genuine talent throughout

Reverso ácido del Sgt. Peppers. Más asequible que Hot rats o Freak Out! Toda una crítica a la puerilidad del movimiento Hippy que sigue aún vigente con el movimiento Woke y en nivel político actual. What's the Ugliest Part of Your Body? es una delicia que se repite a lo largo del disco. Flower Punk es una de sus joyas, por letras y por complejidad. The idiot bastard son tiene efectos que para sí quisieran los Floang Lips. Lonely little girl es lo más accesible que haría Zappa en su vida. Mención a parte su portada, con referencia al Sgt. Peppers y en la que participó el propio Zappa y Jimi Hendrix. Entre las figuras notables que aparecen en la portada se incluyen Lee Harvey Oswald , Lyndon B. Johnson , Franz Kafka , Big Mama Thornton , Lon Chaney Jr. , Sgt. Fury , Cal Schenkel , Ginevra de' Benci , Jim Leavelle , el Papa Pablo III , el Conde Orlok ( Max Schreck ), George Liberace , Eddie Haskell , Ed Wynn , Eric Burdon , Pauline Butcher (secretaria de Zappa), Lloyd Price , Rod Serling , Richard E. Byrd , David Crosby , Theda Bara , Gracie Allen , Mary Martin , la Estatua de la Libertad , Herb Cohen , el Capitán Beefheart , Nancy Sinatra , Hieronymus Bosch , Sandy Hurvitz ( Suzy Creamcheese ), Elvis Presley , Albert Einstein , Gail Zappa y los padres de Frank Zappa. [ 30 ] Otras figuras incluyen a los padres de Frank Zappa, miembros de la familia, asociados, profesores de secundaria y compañeros de clase...

Absolutely batshit, my dad’s kind of music. He saw them twice in the 70s

Classic Zappa.

A very unusual yet fascinating experience. I’d only heard Zappa away from the mothers before and this is different; it’s 60’s and flower power yet diametrically opposed apparently, and yet still heavily anti-establishment. Silly and weird yet also quite political. Not sure I’d revisit but glad I went there.

Some people will tell you that putting We're Only In It For The Money and Method-Tical Man together, on a playlist, on shuffle is madness. They are FOOLS!

Gibberish

Nigh unbearable to listen to but I can always respect bullying the Beatles. As they deserve. 3.5 rounded down to 3.

The musical embodiment of jealousy. Get over it, Zappa. Paul’s on Amy Pohler’s podcast discussing his life and career and how he loves being a goofy little Brit who loves Bob Dylan. Zappa is Diogenes, mocking and throwing his shit on the wall. Paulo don’t care.

I don’t know if I should give this a 4 or a 6. It’s not “perfect” but in a way that feels like they hit the perfect level of ridiculous weird. Perfect skewers of the flower child generation from folks who look to be part of it. Lyrics were always pointed and ridiculous and the music surprised me. Pleasantly surprised me sometimes even. I was caught off guard when I was like “huh, what an interesting instrument choice and seque between musical ideas. I wonder what this track is called?” I turn on my phone screen for it to say HOT POOP and a backwards voice rants about being prejudged for having long hair. So ridiculous and I loved it. Last track felt like being swallowed by the abyss. Now I’m wondering, what is the ugliest part of me?

Listen, I’m fully on board with mocking the hippie movement, criticizing it, and calling out its superficiality—it did real, reprehensible damage to American society. I just finished Houellebecq’s The Elementary Particles and thoroughly enjoyed his scathing takedown. That being said, this ain’t it. This is music for people who live for creating in-groups and out-groups. Music for people convinced they’re simply smarter than everyone else. Music for people whose favorite novel is still The Catcher in the Rye. Yes, The Beatles are popular. No, that isn’t a bad thing. If the Mothers of Invention had gone full Weird Al Yankovic—or actually sat down and tried to write a good song—this might have worked. As it stands, I’d hate to be locked in a room with someone who genuinely enjoys this.

A freewheelin' collage of pig noises and late-60s soundscapes. Fun and sometimes funny ("the ugliest part of your body is your mind"), but it doesn't prove anything except...Frank Zappa couldn't write songs like Paul and John, lol. Kinda superfluous to make fun of a group that A) already critiques both sides of the political spectrum and B) already has a great sense of humor about their public persona and art and C) always maintains tenderness. I'm sorry, Frank, but I'd really rather just listen to Sgt. Pepper. Go make more free jazz stuff--you're better at that (probably?). Get outta town!

This was an interesting mix. A good parody of a lot of the stuff that annoys me about 60s hippie pop but often put together with music that is a better version of the stuff it was parodying. I think they leaned into messing with the vocals and production a bit too much, to the detriment of the actual song quality. Probably all felt like the right choices when high as a kite. Frank Zappa's talent is clear but the actual album isn't one I'd rush back to. 3.5.

Not sure what all that was about. A take on Sgt. Pepper, I believe, but it was pretty nasty. Really messy concept, all over the place with the music and singing. Feels like they were making it up as they went along, and I don't like the master either, sounds fuzzy and I can't distinguish a lot of the overlapping instruments. Vocals too quiet for the most part.

Feels like it's trying too hard to be different and it's largely not that good... Bits and pieces of interesting stuff here and there but that's about it. Are they trying to take the piss out of the Beatles? Kinda all for that, but not sure this is even a good job of doing that 2

Nope, again

Not for me - 1/5

Fucking hippies mother fuckers.

Probablemente el álbum más raro que escuché. No creo que lo vuelva a escuchar.

I get the point it's trying to make but at the end of the day I'm never listening to this again. DNF

This was interesting to say the least. I liked some of the crazy music, I did not care so much for the crazy noises. I guess I would have liked it in 1968 when this was new, difficult to judge from todays perspective.

Day1010 - i’m glad to hear this album, not because it’s great but frank zappa is a genius and he deserves his voice heard

Dad, I'll be honest I don't get this one that much

Might have been hilarious, once...

Odd. Darkly silly. Inventive. Musically brilliant at times. It’s not a relaxing album to listen to but it’s good, and worth investigating. You may enjoy it less than me, but you will feel something towards it. Anything but bland.

STRAIGHT noice pollution. Some good harmonies

I love the idea and the imagination of this. Not really tracks you could pick out as outstanding. You really have to listen the whole album through as it kinda plays like one long track. At times it's unsettling and lucid, other times kinda funny. But it's interesting experimentation that doesn't feel completely like music but a different thing all together

Rock de hippies perché, un peu marrant, ça m'a fait penser à Nick Cave/Grindeman dans leurs morceaux les plus perchés

J’ai rien compris Mi chimpmunks mi beatles

Je mets 3 parce qu'il y a du très bon et du très mauvais (ou plutôt du très bizarre) mais quelques sonorités m'ont plu quand même

I hated this on a cellular level.

No fav song

Might be my fav Zappa album? Idk this one is just endlessly quotable for me. It’s a weird one without being so up its own ass like later Zappa albums. I love tight-assed Zappa too but there’s something really loose about this record I enjoy.

(Strong 7/10) A concept record that satirizes hippie culture and mocks conservative political stances and even crticizes the kent state shooting. It's quite an amazing thing to come out at this time, and also for it to be as well-loved as it was. I think conceptually the album succeeds where some of the music kind of gets lost in the absurdity. The sound collage and music concréte that separates some of the tracks gets a bit too silly and off putting for me, but honestly that's Zappa for you. I think there's other stuff from him I enjoy better overall, but this one is pretty solid.

Glad Zappa gave people this option in the late 60s.

Ok so obviously the first and last tracks are garb, and the track titles are stupid. But lowkey... some of these songs are good. I kinda get it. I was expecting to give this album 1 star but I understand the concept. It's interesting to me. What was it like to live through the hippie movement and be artistic but now in league with that movement? Zappa could have been a super commercially successful artist but he just didn't give a rip I guess. Kinda a bummer to me, but oh well.

Not a fan, never been, never will be. I just get tired of the whole snarky, we're smarter/cooler than you. I mean, just play the shit straight instead of being a holier-than-thou smartass. It's better than Trout Mask Replica though (but not as good as Safe As Milk or even Mirror Man. It's at least 2x as good as any ABBA/ELO, there's that). For the most part, this is just an exercise in Frank's masturbating "brilliance". Which I don't actually like. 2 "I did actually listen to the whole damned thing" stars.

This was really weird too

I mean this is shit right??? Absolute garbage, hot poop is the way I would describe it. How in good conscience do you say this album is better than Weezer blue album for example? Just pretentious assholes who think listening to this is cool. Hipster bullshit. 1/10 Top song... None, it is shit. Didn't you read above?

Ugh. Utter bobbins

This album is straight garbage. It’s not good, it’s not influential, it’s just straight up bad.

Well that was something

Frank's semse of humour gets a bit stale

So much of Zappa's output comes off as novelty songs, but I appreciate the skewering of all subcultures of the time. I'm awarding an extra star in appreciation of all the times I listened to this record stoned out of my gourd.

Better than most Beatles albums lmao