Wish You Were Here by Pink Floyd

Wish You Were Here

Pink Floyd

4.3
Rating
31898
Votes
1
1%
2
4%
3
13%
4
27%
5
55%
Distribution

Album Summary

Wish You Were Here is the ninth studio album by the English rock band Pink Floyd, released on 12 September 1975 through Harvest Records and Columbia Records, their first release for the latter. Based on material Pink Floyd composed while performing in Europe, Wish You Were Here was recorded over numerous sessions throughout 1975 at EMI Studios (now Abbey Road Studios) in London. The album's themes include criticism of the music business, alienation, and a tribute to founding member Syd Barrett, who had left seven years earlier due to his deteriorating mental health; Barrett coincidentally visited the band during the album's production. Like their previous record, The Dark Side of the Moon (1973), Pink Floyd used studio effects and synthesisers. Guest singers included Roy Harper, who provided the lead vocals on "Have a Cigar", and Venetta Fields, who added backing vocals to "Shine On You Crazy Diamond". To promote the album, the band released the double A-side single "Have a Cigar" / "Welcome to the Machine". On its release, Wish You Were Here received mixed reviews from critics, who found its music uninspiring and inferior to their previous work. It has retrospectively received critical acclaim, hailed as one of the greatest albums of all time, and was cited by keyboardist Richard Wright and guitarist David Gilmour as their favourite Pink Floyd album. It reached number one in the US and UK, and Harvest's parent company, EMI, was unable to keep up with the demand. Since then, the record has sold over 20 million copies.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Ladies and gentlemen, we are floating in space

When I was in college if you didn’t like Pink Floyd you didn’t “get it” - according to self proclaimed music experts. The same experts who would light up a joint and listen to The Dark Side of the Moon with the lights off. These people also claimed you had to listen to their entire albums and not just singles. I like some of their music but I do not worship at the alter of Pink Floyd. I may like them better were it not for those pretentious a-holes in college.

Nothing to add to all the other comments really (the positive ones anyway) - a thing of beauty.

primera vez que lo escucho. me encantó de principio a fin. este álbum tiene la mezcla perfecta de instrumentación y voces. simplemente perfecto

I know this album was a struggle to make, and backing up the greatest album ever really messed with them.. but this is a masterpiece.

I felt like this was cohesive and really showcased their musical talent Playlist add: “Wish You Were Here”

Me erizó la piel, me hizo llorar Generador de sentimientos y emociones fuertes. Sin duda uno de los mejores álbums de la historia. La historia acompaña y se refleja en sus letras, junto a una performance sonora maravillosa, tanto Gilmore como Waters , Wright y Mason crearon una obra de arte maestra.

esta bueno (4.5/5)

Hace tiempo no escuchaba este album. Me puso contento escucharlo devuelta, le presté mucha más atención y disfruté cada instante, mucha atmosfera. Pierdo un poco el criterio cuando se trata de Pink Floyd, pero es que es un desconche. No es mi favorito pero es muy destacable. Cada canción es un viaje. Icónico. Podría hacerme el interesante, el profe culoroto que no le pone a nada 12, pero creo que le voy a poner 5 estrellas. 5 estrellas y no es su mejor disco, así de grande son estos tipos.

Not to brag, but this is my second Pink Floyd album this month. It’s immaculate. Absolute perfection from start to finish.

Great album, perfect length

I wanted to like this more, but ultimately I just 'eh'd it. I know Pink Floyd is a deep dream-like journey and all that, but this slow rock just makes me forget it's happening in the background or want to play it at 1.25 speed.

why is there a 9 part song that sandwiches the other few?? halfway thru pt 1-5 this is indeed quite epic. i feel like im in a sophisticated james bondy movie. oh theres words now. i like the guitar. doesnt need words. "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" is allowed to have 9 parts. this is epic. 4.5 would listen again as a whole- I really like how all of the songs blend

I respect the work and I see how great album it is. But it doesn't touch me. I'm not a pink floyd fan

definitely the pink floyd album that’s the easiest to listen to. shine on pt 1-5 and wish you were here are the obvious standouts

Schade dass es so früh gekommen ist. Wish you were Here ist eines meiner absoluten Lieblingslieder.

Pure perfection. I listen to this album a lot. Even so, getting the chance to listen to it again as part of this random 1001 generator made me smile. (10/5)

Short and sweet

Maybe I'm just not a Pink Floyd person, which kind of makes me sad.

This might be the one I like best.

(song 1) This feels classy and melancholic so far. Whiskey at 2am type shit. (Still song 1) Dang this slow build, sax break, the pace is picking up, it's musically interesting, but everything gets to shine, it's bright and clear like a mountain river while still feeling plentiful and impactful. So far, I love this! (song 2) Am I getting reverbed synths and echoing artificial steam! What luxury! Somehow this feels at home in a video game. Excuse me while I turn up the volume. There's some very Metal elements in the song structure here that I also really appreciate. (song 4) First one I think I've heard before. Mandatory radio-friendly ballad? It's nice though^^ (song 5) What in the Persona 5, this goes so hard. Ice cold acoustic guitar, haunting synths and groovy drums & el-guitar. My only complaint is that not all the songs were 15 minutes long. I want more. Good thing they have an extensive discography for me to explore. I haven't actively sat down to listen to Pink Floyd since I was in Junior High, where our arts/crafts & science teacher obsessed with them, while I don'd remember much, I remember it was vibes. This was more than I could have hoped for. Far from dated, it feels ahead of its time. Maybe even ahead of 2026 too, much like a lot of 70's music.

Part of my life

Getting two of the best albums on the generator this early into the project makes me worry for what I’ve got over the next few years, but this is absolute cinema.

3rd and hopefully final album from these guys. I haven’t said so before, but I’m not a fan and believe me, I’ve tried. I rated the other two a 3 and a 4, but truly thought they were both 2s also. This album in particular has always bothered me. I don’t “get it” and that’s fine by me. It’s not deep, stop pretending it is.

Deserves more than 4 stars but it will always be penalized for not being Dark Side.

8/5 fuuuck så bra

What really else is there to say about this album that nobody’s said already. Its nice and atmospheric. Great album to end my 9 day streak of not giving anything 5 stars.

Fantástico

Excellent. Really enjoyed it.

I don’t know. I’ve heard it how many thousands of times now. It’s still sounds great to me. As familiar as it is, it still sounds fresh and Davis tone and frat work is natural and intuitive and still deeply original to himself. I don’t need to listen to it again we’re on repeat, but it’s still hits and end on the occasions when I do listen to it. such as this morning.

How many people had the college experience of being told they needed to listen to full Pink Floyd albums under the influence of some kind of illicit substance, to REALLY understand their message? Did I ever do it? No, and I still don't think it's necessary. But I do really enjoy both the band, and this album. What I think Pink Floyd is best at, is building atmosphere and space with their music. Listening to this album, it creates a mental environment and evokes imagery easily. Its the soundtrack to a film the music shows in your imagination. The one drawback for me, is WYWH ends too quickly. Its and album that leaves me wanting more, which is probably a good thing. There's a razor thin margin between ending an album too early, and making the listener think they didn't get their money's worth, and an album going on so long it overstays its welcome. This album, for me at least, is a tease; I think it COULD have easily been longer, and remained an amazing album. And then I consider that I could just be talking nonsense, and Pink Floyd knew exactly what they were doing.

My favorita Pink Floyd album

PF at their finest. More Floyd than DSotM, and never matched again later.

I enjoyed listening to this, and I do believe it will grow on me. It sets a wonderful atmosphere, and the title track is absolutely 10/10. I didn't come away from this absolutely loving it though which surprised me. Favourites: Wish You Were Here

Fantastic Rock Album, shifting the standards of how conceptual and coherent an hour long piece of art can be. Not as groovy as I like, tho.

Previously known. Title track is worth 3 stars alone. They're one of the few groups that can get me to just along with a song for 14 minutes.

So fun actually I really enjoyed it Trumpets add even more solemnity It’s hard to notice the switch of tracks in the album

I wish it wasn't here. I fucking hate Pink Floyd. Self-indulgent boring SHIT!

This is my first Pink Floyd record that parents brought to me (on CD). Until then I only new 'Another Brick in the Wall Part II' song and was quiet disappointed that it was not 'The Wall'. It took me a lot of time to fall in love with the album. 'Have a Cigar' was my favorite. But eventually, Shine On moved to number 1 favorite. My favorite Floyd's album. Only 5 songs, but each one represents the best they have to offer: cosmic psychodelic sound, acoustic ballads, agressive rock

brilla diamante loco

A stellar album that I've loved since middle school. I remember that it didn't capture me in quite the same way as Dark Side of the Moon or The Wall when I first listened to it, but over time, it has certainly cemented its place in my heart. The title track is one of my favorite songs in their whole catalog, and features a crucial riff in my journey as a guitarist. And I think where I've soured on the long epics from other prog rock bands (I'm looking at you, Yes—yes, you), Shine on You Crazy Diamond (all the parts) is incredible start to finish.

Title track is great, but probably the least "Pink Floyd"-y track here. I recognize the other stuff is probably "great" in some abstract sense but it just doesn't move me.

long but worth it

I always forget how much I enjoy this era Pink Floyd. The atmosphere and space in their music was ideal for my morning coffee and headphones with early light shining through the windows

Listened to this walking near Sausalito, looking out at the SF skyline. Is there a more devastating album in existence than Wish You Were Here? absolute masterpiece

#500 What a way to bring up 500 albums! Not that I’ve spent masses of time listening to Pink Floyd but this is one I know and like. Heard before? ✅ Would I revisit? ✅ Listen before you die? ✅ Fave track(s): Wish You Were Here Rating: 9/10 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️

Sonically speaking, an amazing album. Really very good.

Cualquier palabra que agregue a esta obra maestra sólo empañara su genialidad

This is obviously a classic. “Shine On You Crazy Diamond” (Parts I–V and VI–IX) is one of my favorite experimental rock pieces of all time. Along with the heartfelt, slightly heartbreaking title track (with Gilmour on vocals), these loving and tragic tributes to Syd Barrett are all-time classics. The fact that Barrett himself showed up at Abbey Road while they were finishing “Shine On...” (and that his bandmates didn’t recognize him at first) only adds to the surreal aura of the album. That said, “Welcome to the Machine” and “Have a Cigar” are still woefully overplayed on classic rock radio, which is ironic, since both songs criticize the corporate relentlessness of the music industry. They’re good, but those synth sounds are getting a bit dated. And let’s be honest: Pink Floyd did everything possible to get bigger and richer, and this is their political response? Sorry, Roger Waters, not buying it. This is where he really started to get insufferable as a person, no matter how good the stuff that followed was. So, three of the five tracks are the melancholy perfection this lineup was known for. That’s a 3 for me. Nice to revisit, but no need to listen to it again any time soon.

one extra star for musical merit but this really doesn't do it for me

Dark Side of the Moon is a top 10 all time album but this is a worthy follow up

Шикарный концептуальный альбом, можно слушать как фоном, так и более вдумчиво. Welcome to the Machine - лучший трек с этого альбома для меня. Ну и это первый альбом, получающий от меня 5 звёзд

Beautiful and powerful. Gilmour gets 5 stars by himself.

Mmmm much better prog rock. 43 minutes and only 5 tracks?!? One of the great “must listen under headphones” albums for me.

There are a few albums where I like every songs but rarely do I feel like I have to listen to the whole thing, top to bottom. This is one that I do. I love all 5 tracks but as a whole, it's a masterpiece. 5/5

Yet another installment in Pink Floyd's continuing series "Being A Rock Star Is Hard!", WYWH tries a little too hard to outdo its predecessor in terms of being big and dramatic but ultimately ends up with long stretches of just-OK synth noodling and guitar soloing that sounds tossed off rather than tightly constructed. Yet for all of its shortcomings, the album works remarkably well as a unified piece that maintains a consistent atmosphere from start to finish.

they went downhill on this one and never came back until the wall.

One of the rare instance where I think I'd only listen to it in album form. Some great instrumentals but definitely more of a commitment to engage with.

aside from a few nice lyrics about their troubled former bandmate i am totally unmoved by this on first listen, bludgeoning and ostentatious as it is. have never listened to phish but there's a part of the last track that sounds exactly like what i feel like phish sounds like. the rest is also not so good. onto the next!

If you’re only putting 4 songs on an album, they better be damn good. Luckily, these are.

Just a masterpiece.

Listened three times through… forgot how great this entire album is.

4 & 1/2 stars. One of the greatest songs ever written and performed.

Я очікувала більше, але мені сподобалось

May be the best Floyd album

Wish it was not here......

This is a fascinating album to me. They made it known they didn't want to just "make another dark side of the moon" and they didn't want to "just sell records" so they made THIS. Completely uncommercial, completely different than their previous work, while still successfully communicating their stances on what they don't agree with. So I would consider this a complete success from their standpoint. From my standpoint, it is a masterpiece sandwiched between wasted space. Both Diamond songs are boring and feel uninspired. But that is half the album! Then the middle, Machine, Cigar, and Wish you were here, each one an 11/10, masterpieces. Have a Cigar is my all-time favorite Pink Floyd song. And what is cool is those three songs are so on the nose, not even trying to be vague about their topics, but yet not pretentious or preachy. Only Pink Floyd can pull that off. I this Welcome to the Machine is a sonic gem. I think Cigar is a blues masterpiece. WYWH an emotional beacon. Phenomenal songs. But half the album kinda sucks, so I can only give it a 4.

When i think of Pink Floyd alblums obviously Dark Side of the Moon is at the forefront and overshadowes (pun intended) this alblum. After listening to it again I am notvsure why. This is a classic ans definitely deserves without a doubt to be on this list. We'll above average.

Classic Floyd… long mellow songs. Nice relaxing music

I never knew there were only 5 songs on this album. Or that Shine On You Crazy Diamond had 9 parts. That’s a few parts too many and too few songs. Certainly a classic of the genre, but they were pushing the friendship by the end. Rounding up to a 4/5. A headphones listening experience.

Yeah, 4. Can’t say much more than what has already been said.

I may be more impressionable because this is the first Pink Floyd album I've listened to in full, but wow. Most enthralling album experience I've had in a hot minute.

I liked it…when they sang.

Unbelievably good, I could listen to this all day. Actually, I think I did.

Completely deserving of its status as one of the best albums ever made.

My favorite Floyd album. 5 stars.

This album is amazing. I didn't realize it was so packed with hits - only 5 songs and every one of them is great.

It was interesting listening to this two days after “Gates of Dawn.” You get a real sense of how they evolved and progressed as a band, in this much superior outing.

Sad to be disabused of the mistaken expectation that ‘shine on you crazy diamond’ isn’t by Neil Diamond. ‘Wish You Were Here” is good but way too whiny on every other song - or noodly in a guitar wank I just don’t enjoy.

Probably top 5 album for me, just perfection

This might be a brutal take but I do think almost all Pink Floyd sounds the same, but I love it.

thoughts: - I am notttttttttttttttttt listening to two 13 minute songs - good but also whatever, not my thing, though I appreciated how easy it was to listen to

De cover van dit album blijft ook werkelijk legendarisch! Wat een album, ik heb dit gewoon 3 keer geluisterd vandaag. Soms wat lang, maar elke keer genieten. 6 sterren.

Ja gewoon een heel goed album. De kracht van Pink Floyd zit naar mijn mening in de opbouw van de muziek. Geen ABAB structuur maar een lineaire structuur. In dit album zit dat nog meer dan dark side of the moon en the wall. Wat er voor zorgt dat die andere meer bekende nummers heeft, maar deze vind ik als geheel album wel beter. Ik heb er van genoten en ik ben er in blijven hangen.

Ik heb de hele dag niets anders willen luisteren dan dit album. Shine on you crazy diamond raakt diep. Wat een impact heeft die song, kan er haast om janken, en alleen daarvoor zou ik t al 5 sterren willen geven. Ik heb er haast geen woorden voor, ik vind het zó mooi. Het is ook niet dat ik het allemaal voor de eerste keer hoor, maar door de challenge leer je wel je aandacht terug te brengen naar de muziek, en wat dat betreft heb ik de muziek van dit album nooit zo beseft als vandaag. Ik vind de gitaar van David Gilmour magisch, ik vind de synths en keys subtiel en gelaagd. De saxofoon in shine on you voelt alsof je weer door je neus kan ademen nadat tie een week lang verstopt heeft gezeten. De composities zijn zo mooi uitgedacht dat je haast vergeet dat t maar 5 nummers zijn. Ook vet dat shine on you crazy diamond aant eind nog terugkomt. man man man, wat een song, ik ga t weer aanzetten.

Just 2 lost souls swimming in a fish bowl

Ihan hyvä meditatiivinen kokemus

The best of the Floyd albums I've heard so far (although I've not had Dark Side of the Moon yet). I enjoyed it, but I'm not sure it was enough to get a 5.

Shine on You Crazy Diamond og LSD en solskinnsdag ved elven. Core memory unlocked. Ikke at man trenger psychedelia for å høre på Floyd; musikken er knapt nok psych på dette punktet i karrieren. Noe av essensen fra tidlige expedisjoner i karrieren deres, da de fortsatt utforsket sonisk territorium noe friere og mer chaotisk enn de er kjent for fra gullrekka (Dark Side of the Moon tom. The Wall), må ha blitt overført til den orchestrerte og mildt progressive art rocken. Av alle stoner memes der ute, er joint og Dark Side på platespilleren i tennårene definitivt et av de mest vedvarende. Bønne eller ei, så er det musikk som åpner noe i de som hører det. (Et eller annet om generasjonell kultur og evig tilbakekomst.) Har tilbrakt mange timer i kjelleren og forsøkt å lære tittelsporet på gitar. Tror fortsatt jeg kan det. Dessverre klarte jeg aldri å spille solopartiet. Har heller aldri anerkjent hvor mye synth som er med på denne skiva. Richard Wright får sine 40 minutter i rampelyset. Ish. Vanskelig å ikke gi mvp til Gilmour på denne.

Det er ganske sirumpa greier, det går altså så sakte. Det blir helt boogie woogie på andre del av "Shine On". Mens "Welcome to the Machine" høres parodisk ut, selv om det kanskje er fordi Pink Floyd har vært så innflytelsesrike som de har vært. Tittelsporet er fint.

פשוט מופת

Best album of one of the greatest bands of all time. Every note, every sound as you move up the guitar string is intentional, a band operating at a completely different level.

Pink Floyd – Wish You Were Here (1975) On Day 302, this monumental record arrived during a heavy, personal time of mourning following the sudden loss of my high school seatmate and friend. In the midst of processing that absence, the album's core themes of empty space, grief, and lost souls resonated with immense emotional weight. While differing in narrative scale from The Wall, this project stands tall on its own ground through flawless thematic focus and immaculate production. "Shine On You Crazy Diamond (All Parts)" exemplifies the peak Floyd experience—sprawling past the ten-minute mark with towering synthesizer textures, weeping guitar motifs, and the unforgettable, haunting tribute of "Remember when you were young, you shone like the sun." The mechanical pulse and technical ambition of "Welcome to the Machine" offered a chilling sonic departure, while "Have a Cigar" delivered a poetic, cynical funk groove exposing the naked reality of industry exploitation. Anchored by the fragile, universally aching title track, the record functions less like standard music and more like a transformative theatrical journey. #LLG. A timeless, deeply moving masterpiece. A definitive 5/5.

I’ve heard this before and I own it. This is probably my favorite post-Syd Barrett album of theirs, though it might be Meddle, and now I’m gonna have to listen to both of these to decide. I had this on tape in middle and high school and listened to it a lot as a sullen teen before getting into punk. My brother in law uploaded his entire Floyd collection on our itunes some years back and I’ve relistened a number of times since then but probably last heard this maybe four years ago. I like how they split Shine On You Crazy Diamond into two sections that bookend the album, and it’s a pretty great song with the mix of psychedelic drones and prog blues and the three song in the middle are all great as well, with a good mix of psych droning, classic rock, and just the right amount of prog where it doesn’t get overindulgent. And it’s just a little over 40 minutes so it doesn’t drag on like some 70s prog does. I’m probably letting nostalgia take hold but this album still sounds fantastic to me.

What if we tried to capture the same lightning in the bottle that we got for comfortably numb? We can do that slow build-up, some spacey noises, a subdued vocal that fits Roger Waters' range, then we'll make it 5 songs but two of the songs will also be five songs? Great idea man, have a cigar! [scene] Ok this album is just fine. It's got that standard Pink Floyd soundscape with the synths and the guitar and everything's flowing together and you're smokin' weed and you're into this spiritual groove and before you know it 45 minutes has passed and you had a good time with your buddies. And that's about it. The lyrics are not good and it doesn't really go anywhere, but I guess it's fun while you're hanging out. I dunno, doesn't seem particularly special. If you like Pink Floyd, great, you're getting more of them.

Just like most of pink floyd, i think the actual songwriting and playing here is incredible, but its just too slow for me to find enjoyable. Not to be one of those people whos like "wahhh the intro is too long so i hate the song" but man some of these songs REALLY drag on. I dont have a lot of time in my day to sit down and intentionally deeply listen to music, so when i spend it listening to a 10 minute pink floyd instrumental, its just not pleasing. Theres definitely some emotion-evoking bangers here though. I cant say a lot about Shine On You Crazy Diamond because i just didnt enjoy that ~25 minute total song that i feel didnt have a lot to it. my favorites were 'Have A Cigar" and 'Wish You Were Here' just because they're short and sweet, which is crazy im calling it that because they're still 2 minutes above the average song length, with a very lengthy solo at the end. Pink Floyd almost always feels like it could be a emotional ending to a movie or something, this is great music if i was like hiking and just had a bunch of time to soak in some cinematic music. I do kind of respect it for not making the vocals a focal-point of every song. Some of these songs make the vocals feel like a surprise instrument solo that adds to the song rather than carrying it. Overall, sounds pretty cool. 'Wish You Were Here' is one of the greatest sounding vocals/lyrics ive ever heard in a song.

a fucking gem

Да, мне понравилось, это было красиво, но... просто но, немного не мое, но я еще буду слушать их