Reviews (page 2 of 16)
This is one of my favorite Pink Floyd albums and one of the greatest albums out there. Just two quick comments: - The production still sounds great and current in 2026! - Richard Wright doesn't get enough credit.
1975 experimental rock Welcome to the machine Have a cigar Wish you were here
There was not NEED to listen to this again. It’s one of the few albums I own in every format except maybe wax coil, though I am looking. I chose to listen again because it’s one of the Top Pink Floyd albums and one of my all-time favorite albums. I had heard Wish You Were Here early on and liked it. I had heard Shine On Pt 1 on the K-2 soundtrack but didn’t appreciate either until it was in context of the full album. This album had the perfect mix of instrumentals and vocals. David Gilmore’s guitar tone is perfect. Roger Water’s lyrics are personal and enduring. Wish You Were Here is a classic written for Syd Barrett, made only better by the entire album. I honestly could listen to Shine On Pt’s 1 & 2 back-to-back and be perfectly content. This is a near perfect album (okay, …perfect) that will stand the test of time. If I wanted to introduce someone to Pink Floyd, I’d use the Wall. If I wanted to solidify their respect, I’d give them this on headphones. I think I’m going to listen again right now….
Random thoughts: * I've obviously listened to this one so many times. This is by far my favorite Pink Floyd album. * Absolute classic and is one of the all-time greatest albums ever made. * I'm not sure I have the words for how amazing this album is. * I wanted to sit down and give this a listen with my undivided attention but that didn't happen. I still re-listened to this anyway but with a few distractions. * This album never gets old for me. It would be one of my dessert island records. * Hats off to Roy Harper for providing the vocals on Have a Cigar. * I need to get this one on vinyl!
Perfect album
Prog rock continues to be a genre that I'm unsure of. On the one hand, I'm not against mostly instrumental songs, and it's even okay when they're long sometimes. I guess I just can't say that I love it like everyone else seems to. This album has good instrumentation that borders on beautiful at times. I'm already familiar with the Foo Fighters cover of "Have A Cigar", which I've decided I like better than the original because it's more hard-hitting and straightforward and less spaced-out (also the original seems to end kind of abruptly). The best songs were the ones that were the longest and seemed to have the most care put into them (both of the "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" tracks). Certainly, it's an album that requires multiple listens, I think.
Awesome and anyone who disagrees is wrong.
Favourite songs: Have a Cigar, Wish You Were Here. Really hard to pick a least fav. I grow to appreciate David Gilmour with each day.
This is one of those rare perfect albums. I’ve listened to it hundreds of times and never get tired of it. Brilliant.
On the one hand, 2 of the 5 tracks on this album (Welcome to the Machine, Have a Cigar) are basically just filler compared with the rest. On the other hand, the remaining 3 tracks are amazing. Music to test speakers/headphones/drugs to.
This was an amazing journey. The production is next level, some of my favourite sounding drums and band I’ve ever heard, songs are so well put together, the open and closer are a vibe and I can’t get enough of it.
Pretty good, I really liked the +10 minute songs
Favorite Floyd. Love the crazy diamond book ends, welcome to the machine, does some of the coolest shit sonically you’ll ever hear, mostly if not all analog synths creating new sounds, beautifully weaving into traditional rock band elements is the apex of what this band does best. Have a cigar is, no research take, but the perfect sequel to Money, and not sure if it’s a different time sig (drums sound 4/4 but the bass and keys are throwing me off) and genuinely a top 5 bass line for me. Last note, maybe the greatest album cover of all time. 5 out of 5 10 out of 10.
Another one of my desert-island records. The first and last tracks, the two halves of “Shine On You Crazy Diamond,” might be this band’s absolute high-water mark. Which is effusive praise considering the album that preceded this one is, rightfully, considered one of the greatest records in the entire rock canon. But the atmosphere here. The searing guitar leads, the sinister lyrics, the madness and tragedy of Syd Barrett, the synths, the sheer weight of it all. Gorgeous. A cathedral of rock. Just when you think David Gilmour can’t bring you any closer to the edge with his playing, he grabs you and rips you over it. That opening verse is brutal. Kills me. This is the ultimate stoned-with-really-good-headphones experience, which happens to be one of my favorite experiences. The way the chorus of “Shine On” hits like a full fucking heavenly choir. Then a sinister laugh and a sneer, followed by an absolutely incredible saxophone solo. As it fades, we’re left with the low rumble of machinery. Something ejects. Something whirs and buzzes. I can hardly catch my breath. It feels otherworldly, like something is hovering just beyond our perception. And then those ominous acoustic chords announce the arrival of “Welcome to the Machine.” And that’s just the opening track. “Welcome to the Machine” is a sinister exploration of the mind. The processed vocals, the searing synthesizers, everything building and escalating until I can practically feel my heart beating. It’s frightening in this post-apocalyptic, science-fiction kind of way. The age of the machines. Humanity enslaved. Terminator robots scouring a devastated landscape for the last remnants of human resistance. We jack into a neural simulation and dream of the world before. The machines keep humming. Something speeds away. Something is ejected. It’s terrifying and magnificent. And then “Have a Cigar.” That funky riff! One of Gilmour’s best. The cynicism of the lyrics is delicious. The band is fantastic, that’s really what I think, and oh, by the way, which one’s Pink? We’re riding the gravy train! Gilmour tears the house down again with his solos. So melodic. You can sing every single note. Those bends! That tone! Nobody makes a guitar speak quite like this man. And the way it all zaps down to near silence at the end, the channel changes, and suddenly we’re listening to a tinny radio playing the opening guitar of “Wish You Were Here.” Fuck. Just hearing that G-centered acoustic riff breaks my heart. The little acoustic solo that follows is so simple, so pretty. And then some of my favorite lyrics of all time. That devastating sequence about trading your heroes for ghosts, hot ashes for trees, cold comfort for change, and ultimately exchanging a walk-on part in the war for a lead role in a cage. What an extraordinary way to describe the surrender of your ideals and freedom for the illusion of success. Fuck. Fuck. The slide guitar after the first verse has George Harrison written all over it. So restrained, so achingly beautiful. And then the culmination into the chorus. Huge. Massive. Heartbreaking. Cathartic. I want to sing this with 100,000 people in a stadium, the way people sing Oasis songs, every voice joining in until the whole place shakes. And then the wind blows fiercely. Waters taps out those ominous bass notes. Something is coming again. The second half of “Shine On You Crazy Diamond” is a perfect preview of where Floyd is going next with Animals, another one of my favorite records. In so many ways, this album is the ideal midpoint between Dark Side and Animals. Synth-driven, progressive, electronic, satirical, biting, but still maintaining the tight songwriting and radio-friendly melodies without disappearing completely into an acid trip. Screaming guitar harmonies over synthesizer leads. Everything building and building, settling into an irresistible groove. The riff returns, followed by those heartbreaking lyrics wondering where this lost soul has gone, whether he’s near or impossibly far away. And then the absolute ecstasy of that enormous, shouted chorus. Shine on, you crazy diamond. From there, we’re drifting again, fading into space and time. Funky jamming. Dark Star and Terrapin Station at once. The music rises and falls in these extraordinary instrumental passages, everything peaking and receding, wave after wave. Just when you think the band has reached its climax, another wave comes crashing down. Until finally we’re washed over by vibrations. Sinister vibrations. Sorry, Brian Wilson. These aren’t good vibrations. This is music for the moment the villain takes his throne in hell and places a crown of thorns upon his head. And yet, beneath all that darkness and grandeur, there’s this overwhelming sadness. A band mourning its lost friend, mourning its innocence, raging against the machine that made it successful, and producing something almost impossibly beautiful in the process. The whole record feels enormous and deeply personal at the same time, somehow both a warning about the future and an elegy for the past. Fuck, dude. Is this better than The Dark Side of the Moon? Jesus la weez. 10/10
cara só wish you were here presta kkk álbum bizarro
Masterpiece on grief. Never been into Pink Floyd but Wish You Were Here is magnificent.
This is a 5 all day long. Full stop. Not sure anything more needs to be said. The more reasoned debate is which Pink Floyd album is their best. With each passing year I come to appreciate more and more their earlier material but there can be no denying this is at or near their top form. How these two sat down and created this - the notes, the pacing, just all of it: pure genius. Perhaps its best they couldn’t figure out how to age together so that what we do have couldn’t be diluted (ala Rush). 5/5
4.5/5. Great album. Not my absolute favorite Floyd but it’s very iconic. The band are in tip top shape and the songwriting here is masterful. Roger’s lyrics are heartbreaking, yet relatable. The shine suite and title track are the true highlights to the album, but every song is great. Took me awhile to get into the Roy Harper led Have a cigar, but the riff has really grown on me. Gilmour’s solos are all masterful, encapsulating the slow but tasteful style he’s known for. Richard Wright’s keyboard modalities are the true hero of the band, and this is no different for this album. Not my favorite Floyd album overall, but its strengths are undeniable, and its universal accessibility no doubt make it very personal to many people.
reminds me of my son; love him so much and this is one of his favorite bands… i cNt help it that i am biased…. however this is classic Pink Floyd and is a great record…. next to Dark Side of the Moon it is one of their best.
This music is moody, heady and meanders. I wonder if they play the songs the same way twice. It encourages daydreaming.
9 out of 10 album and Gilmore is God
Love this album
such a surreal album, 'welcome to the machine' was my favourite. the synth on that song was amazing
I’ve had a couple of Pink Floyd albums in the past few months, and I think that the over saturation does them a disservice on the list. When there’s so much emphasis on how great all their albums are, it simultaneously makes them all feel interchangeable in how much you need to pay attention or care. The music wasn’t bad, but I just don’t really see anything that amazing here like other people seem to see.
Another listener - on this very site regarding this very album - said PF was better to hear albums than songs. After having this one on heavy rotation yesterday, I agree, dear reader! Can't wait to hear it again in the proper room of sound.
Peak
Nice.
it's true, i was raised by a dad who listened to dad music. and i loved this at a young age. sue me.
10/10
Underwhelmed, honestly.
I have always really liked "Wish You Were Here" (the song) but have never listened to this album in full. Absolutely couldn't have told you there's only 5 songs. Some meandering moments but also some classic moments.
PEAK
I do not understand the allure for Pink Floyd. This felt incredibly average and borderline boring. 2.5/5
Some classic stuff on here if you are a fan of Floyd. 3.5
Not bad, actually
not my first time listening to it!! amazing album one of the pioneers for the rock genre 10/10, no complaints :)
Very calming
4.5
Classic Pink Floyd album. They have others I enjoy more but honestly this really nothing wrong with this “Shine On You Crazy Diamond I-V” and the title track are both classics but honestly I think the song that makes the album stand out even more for myself is “Welcome To The Machine” it’s the song that made me buy this album back in the day in the first place. “Half A Cigar” is a good fun track but think this type of song was done better on “Animals” album with “Pigs (Three Different Ones)” but this is still great The next section of “Shine On Your Crazy Diamond” to end the album is good but isn’t as great as first time around. Definitely weakest track but again still good Gonna go 4.5/5
Spectacularly and beautifully built album. Truly a privilege to get to listen to it.
7/10 - I get why Pink Floyd are so big but really one of the best albums out there? Maybe I need another listen
My college roommate used to run music in phases. There would be a band and that is what we would listen to. A lot. On repeat. At some point, it was Pink Floyd. And specifically this album. Shine On You Crazy Diamond was the song. It didn't take long to really burn out on Pink Floyd. But listening now, many years removed from always picking that CD in the changer, it's obvious why. This is good. Really good. Probably better than Dark Side of the Moon or The Wall good. How I wish, how I wish you were here We're just two lost souls swimming in a fishbowl Year after year Running over the same old ground, what have we found? The same old fears, wish you were here That right there. That may be one of the best verses ever written. Five stars, no guilt.
Cried
RIP Michael.
I think I’ve heard more dudes at bars and parties and in the wild cover wish you were here more than I’ve heard the actual song. Pink Floyd is one of those bands that it is undeniable that they’re one of the best bands of all time, this album is indisputably incredible, I just do not care about it. I’ve never meant it more when I say I fully get it, I see it, I appreciate it, but Pink Floyd just does not click for me. Dark side does more than most but even still, you have to be in such a specific vibe for this and I have never found myself in that vibe.
Skvelé
Nothing to talk about, just Pink Floyd and the pure juice of progressive rock, sorry for that, but easily 10 out of 10
This is #day789 of my #1001albumsyoumusthearbeforeyoudie challenge, and... here's to my fourth and final record by Pink Floyd. My favorite Pink Floyd album, which I only heard for the very first time in what must have been 2008, when I got the Internet at my parents' home. I was 18 then. I don't know what there is to say about this album, really, that hasn't already been said. Put it on and get carried away by the music. Otherwise, this is a 5 out of 5. Looking forward to #day790.
Spacious synth based prog that is obviously technically very good, but also incredibly dull at the same time.
Uno de los mejores álbumes de todos los tiempos y en lo personal, mi favorito de Pink Floyd. De los pocos discos que considero un 10 absoluto
Damn good
'Wish You Were Here' is an album carried by its title track, which has poetic and thought-provoking lyrics as well as one of the coolest guitar riffs ever, which my dad often plays. I enjoyed how reflective the music was of the 70s, but its futuristic vibe was not fleshed out enough to make the synth inclusions not cartoonish ('Shine On You Crazy Diamonds'). Bringing occasional acoustic moments to the forefront was nice, but I often found myself bored waiting for these fresh moments. The vocals were quite strained and unpleasant at times ('Welcome to the Machine') although I did enjoy the crescendos built by winding synths. I wish there had been more of the lyricism displayed on the title track in the rest of the project, which is predominantly a looping and one dimensional soundtrack.
Gay Pink Floyd be like “How I wish you were queer”
The epitome of everything great about Floyd. One of the greatest albums of all time. I don't think I need to add anything else.
Awesome album! Have a Cigar was my favourite song
Long time since I listened to this. Back then I wasn't keen as I was still mainly into short punchy songs with a strong hook. How will it fare now I'm more into longer tracks and have the context of 345 other albums listened to? First struck by the production, particularly the guitar tone is gorgeous and every bend (and there are many!) pitch-perfect. 2nd thing is how ballsy PF are to have a 5-6min slow build to the opening track. Pushing the boundaries of prog. I don't remember a sax solo on Shine On! Welcome to the Machine sounds like Comfortably Numb. Very interesting user of synths with a phaser (I think). Around this time Kraftwerk sounded like robots while this synth is very emotionally expressive Wish You Were Here has long been one of my favourite PF tracks. Best track - Welcome to the Machine, Wish You Were Here 4 stars - it is very hard to look past the history, fame, and prior knowledge of an album like this. I may just be paying lip service
holy fuck that synth trumpet is crazy for a 13 minute song it's doing a great job of keeping my attention OOH THOSE HARMONIES Wish You Were Here is truly the standout, everything else is aight not a big fan of Welcome to the Machine 3.5/5
I always felt this album's reputation as one of the all time greats was a hard sell for me. "Have a Cigar" is a fine rock track, but being one of only 5 songs on an album of this magnitude, it definitely sticks out as a little underwhelming. Similarly, "Welcome to the Machine" has always felt a little weird in the tracklist, which is a (cheesy) synth odyssey, with some really clunky lyrics. It's just a little too dramatic for its own good, although I think the climactic synth solo is captivating. I always felt this song would work better on a longer album, one with more opportunities in the tracklist to not make the All-Synth-Melodrama track stick out. Perhaps more songs that have synth workouts to make it more cohesive. That leading into a straightforward blues rocker is just weird. Title track? No notes there. The first half of "Shine On" is great, emotional, and sets a tone that it just swims in. The second half, while good too, of course, kind of loses the emotional momentum of the title track (and the I suppose even the first half) when it hits the bluesy soloing section. Feels much less epic than it could've been. I love Pink Floyd, and I feel weird giving this album either a 3 OR 4. But this album just isn't cohesive enough to live up to its reputation. I still listen to this album a couple times a year, though!
Absolutely a great album.
oooo definitely loved it and good album to introduce an album. First song, the instrumentals was off the chart
Probably one the best albums ever made. If not the best album ever made. Easy one! So: 5/5
A great album... Every song is a classic. Pink Floyd at their most heartfelt, with great lyrics throughout. And maybe the best album cover in rock music.
SO ENJOYABLE.
Easy 8 (I clicked the 5th star 3 times). All time classic, up there with Dark Side.
One of the easiest ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ I will give out in this whole project.
Great vibe, not for casual listen. Would be good with a light
Fantastic album, one of PF's best
Well, what can you say about this? One of their greatest albums. Yes I can understand that if Prog is not your thing you might not appreciate this album. But I do. Supposedly an allegory or tribute to original band member Syd Barrett he turned up at the studio unexpectedly and unannounced on the last day of recording. Shine On is a classic piece of music. And after Roger Waters tried many time in vain to get the vocals right on Have A Cigar. Mr Gilmour got his mate Roy Harper, who was always hanging around the studios, to give it a go. And he nailed it first time. Any way, this is one of my 2 favourite Floyd albums. So there can only be one score from me.
An absolute masterpiece from start to finish. Immersive stuff.
Could this be better than DSOTM? Its close! The title track is probably their finest song, both parts of 'Shine On...' were a great example of predominantly instrumental experimental tracks which just make you float in a virtual SDT. My only gripe is the vocals on 'Have a Cigar' I'm not sure they were Gilmour's, unless he had throat problems or something when they recorded it.
Another absolute classic. Pretty much the pinnacle of what Progressive Rock can be. Haunting, emotional, captivating- it really draws you in and keeps you motivated. Combined with the lore behind the album- it really is top tier. Even my least favorite on the album (Welcome to the Machine) is still a good song with interesting motifs. Overall- fantastic album
Individually, tracks are great. But a little redundant over an entire album
#248 I love this album, and I’m a passive fan at best. Like this is one of those albums you put on to hang out and chop it up with people. That’s the case with a lot of Floyd which is hard to say about a lot of bands. Like I am not a big prog guy but Pink Floyd definitely get a pass because it feels like their music is atmospheric and welcoming than a band like King Crimson or Yes , where the latter feels like nails on a chalkboard. I’m not going to do a hit or a miss, or gem because the album only has a handful of songs. Just enjoy the thing.
I think I listened to this 3 times in a row. So good... No notes.
One of my favorite Floyd albums, and with such beautiful music. The tribute to Syd Barrett is touching. Some of David Gilmore’s best guitar work. Roger Waters best song writing.
I love it
My favorite band. One of the best songs of all time in the title track, and the others are amazing too. Shine On drags just a little at parts, but still.
Short piece of perfection. The perfect antidote to being detrained at Nuneaton.
In the true spirit of 1001, I set aside my prejudices and found myself enjoying some of this, notably Wish You Were Here and Shine On You Crazy Diamond. While still not really my thing, it reaches 3 stars.
Hard to give this anything other than 5*. Genius.
The one where where the band makes a killing while moaning about the industry that makes them a killing. Accusations of cant asides, difficult to give this less than 5 when it contains Shine On and Wish You Were Here. And introduces the central character of Another Brick whilst they're at it. 5*
Did you think it would be less than 5 stars after listening? Pink Floyd may be the only band with multiple perfect albums. This is debatably one of them.
A lot going on tbh
Good listen when stoned.
The best Floyd album and it's not close
Do I even need to say anything
This release as a whole is unreservedly a masterpiece. I would say, though, that still, the three tracks in the middle of the "Shine On..." hamburger are a bit of an extended interlude, as the renowned hit is indeed the best by far here. And I would highlight the first half of SOYCD. The way that the sound is building is spectacular. The whole composition is outstandingly multi-layered and imaginative. The rest of the material is fine too. I felt like "Welcome to the Machine" was a bit off, souding like a song too experimental and perhaps not finilized the way other songs are. "Have a Cigar" and the title track are great, like much of this album, they have this smooth transition. What is notable here is the prevalence of instrumental music, something really strongly utilized. This music gives you the sense of swimming in warm water, or flying, something like this. It is so thouroughly composed that it has the ability to bring you elsewhere, and this is the primary reason why the release is deserving of the highest rate. I found the track order apt. The album artwork is excellent (been a fan of it even before this full listen). So, not much to add here, Wish You Were Here is iconic for a reason. Honestly an A– here, but from the standpoint of musical art value, it likely is one of the most important releases on the list.
Great album.
I can objectively note this is very good, esp the first track I love the guitar, but I never really put Pink Floyd on. I enjoyed it tho.
Sure, it's a great album. I also had this album cover on a poster in my dorm room. Thought it made me edgy. I think I've kind of outgrown it, however; the poster and the album.
I would imagine that this album in particular was incredibly hyped in the lead up to its release. And it's definitely garnered it's own reputation in the 50+ years since as a worthy follow up to "Dark Side of the Moon". A lot of what you hear here acts as an ode to the troubled former member Syd Barrett, but those pieces (each part of "Shine On You Crazy Diamond") require some of that context in order to be truly effective. Otherwise, they pretty much just operate as your usual, lengthy, noodling prog rock pieces. The title track is pretty self-explanatory and hit harder, I felt. The subtle sound effects used all throughout make a larger impact than you think. Can't really get there with calling this a 5, though.
Yeah no wonder this is #7 on the global rankings Pink Floyd has a truly special ability to just absorb you in the world the create in their albums better than any other prog bands. Shine on You Crazy Diamond takes like 5 minutes to go anywhere but it the way it escalates and builds is just unbelievable. Have a Cigar is like the complete opposite side of the spectrum, but it fits so well on this album and is just perfectly executed. Obviously the title track is otherworldly too; it’s got some of the most iconic lyrics in musical history and that emotion is imbued throughout the entire song, right down to the guitar riff. I actually like how they split Shine On into two parts, and I think it’s a great way to end the album. I love the transitions between songs and how natural they feel; the transition between the first two tracks is perfect. Waters and Gilmour’s vocals work wonders, and obviously the instrumental execution is about as close to perfect as you’ll get I don’t really have any complaints; I think the closest thing I have is that Shine On You Crazy Diamond takes just a bit too long to get going, and Welcome to the Machine, while still a great song for building the album, is a bit behind the rest of the album. This album kinda sent me on a bit of a discovery journey; Prog is usually a bit controversial among music fans, with a lot of people knocking other bands like Yes and Rush for being pretentious, but Pink Floyd’s big 3 albums have almost universal acclaim; why is that? I think the answers pretty simple; just listen to them. They really don’t have an equal
Its moody and introspective. I absolutely adore the sound 70s synths, where they havent figured out how to process the sound and theres a rawness. The subject matter is great too, talking about absence. "Two lost souls swimming in a fish bowl" is a great line, both grand and mundane, taking feelings that everyone has and presenting them in a way thats so understandable. Genuinely great. I listened to this so much in college and remember the impact on my own art. No one else can make music like this.
If your track has 5 parts maybe it should be 5 tracks
Outstanding
Classic album, zero question. Wish You Were Here induces chills every time. Shine On is a crazy 10 part epic as well. Best track: Wish You Were Here (others are great too) Rating: 10/10
A bone fide classic, no issues with a straight five here.
⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐ Innehåller enligt en av mig världens bästa låter, Wish you were here, håret på kroppen reser sig när jag hör den. Vet inte vad det är för det är till synes en ganska enkel låt men det är något med anslaget och texten som gör att jag blir väldigt berörd när jag hör den. I övrigt ett album som man bara kan sätta på luta sig tillbaka och försvinna bort, få spår men alla är bra det blir en 5a. Bäst är Shine on you crazy diamon pts 1-5, Wish you were here, Shine on you crazy diamon pts 6-9
A classic. I don't want to listen to it all the way though, at least not often, but def a classic.
Rounding up to five stars.
Un classique . Qualité > quantité. Chaque musique a une histoire , les sonorités , la voix brute rendent l’album envoûtant.
Rien a redire
Classic GOAT album
yes.
Wish You Were Here Pink Floyd 1975 Genres: Rock Styles: Psychedelic Rock, Art Rock, Prog Rock 1. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I–V) (★★★★★) -Contexto: Homenaje a Syd Barrett. La letra habla de alguien que "brillaba como el sol" de joven y quedó atrapado entre la infancia, la fama y su propia mente. El tono es contemplativo, con una intro de sintetizador larga y una frase de guitarra de cuatro notas que Gilmour tocó y Waters tomó como base para escribir la letra. Es una despedida melancólica, no un reproche. -Frisson -Fav 2. Welcome to the Machine (★★★★★) -Contexto: Crítica a la industria discográfica vista como una máquina que fabrica y manipula a un joven artista. La letra tiene la voz de un ejecutivo dirigiéndose a un músico ("bienvenido a la máquina"), con un tono frío, mecánico y opresivo. El sonido usa sintetizadores y efectos de fábrica para reforzar esa sensación. 3. Have a Cigar (★★★★★) -Contexto: Sátira de la industria musical. Un ejecutivo elogia a la banda por interés económico y no sabe ni quién es quién: "¿cuál de ustedes es Pink?". Es cínica y con humor ácido. La canta Roy Harper, no Pink Floyd, y funciona como una voz ajena que expone la hipocresía del sistema. -Fav 4. Wish You Were Here (★★★★★) -Contexto: Canción sobre la ausencia, en parte dirigida a Syd Barrett. La letra pone en contraste cosas opuestas (cielo e infierno, jugadores en una pecera) y termina con un deseo simple: que el otro estuviera presente. Waters dijo que no es solo sobre Syd, sino sobre estar ausente de la propia vida y de los demás. El tono es íntimo y melancólico, con guitarra acústica. -Frisson -Fav 5. Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI–IX) (★★★★★) -Contexto: Cierre de la suite con menos letra y más instrumental. Retoma el homenaje a Syd con un tono más pesado, con bajo destacado y guitarra en primer plano, y va apagándose hacia un final más sereno. Sirve como despedida larga del disco. -Frisson -Fav -TOTAL = ★★★★★ (5)
I bought this record the day it came out in 1975 and still listen to it from time to time. The two halves of “Shine On You Crazy Diamond” are of course what makes this album - the first part with that immediately recognizable blues riff, then the second with that guitar again but darker, stranger, and more insistent with the bass thrumming in the background and then the keyboards at the end making it seem like something being played in a church. But the rest of it is essential as well, the title track being one of those songs where the lyrics really hit me emotionally. I remember a day a decade or two ago when I found myself starting to cry in one of the tunnels under Waterloo Station as a busker started playing that song. A comment about the cover: I saw that documentary about the Hipgnosis firm that did this cover, and the guy who’s on fire was actually on fire when they did that shoot. I had always assumed that it was some sort of photo processing trick that achieved that, but nope.
Not my type. Music was good. Singing wasn't
This album just makes me wish we were all here listenin to it together!
Classic bro wow mama mia i am a bit unc coded innit
Perfecto.
Great songs combined with pleasant background noise while working.
I'm not sure how deeply I dig Shine On, but Wish You Were Here could carry a much weaker record.
(Light 8/10) Has grown on me some Yeah this is a band I've never been super duper into, and this album in particular has evaded my praise for a minute. It just always felt overrated as hell to me. Upon hearing it again today I'm starting to come around more on it. I do really like the instrumental aspects of this record. The crazy diamond songs are phenomenal instrumentally. The guitars especially are impressive, but the overall atmosphere and sonic textures really sell those songs for me. "Have a Cigar" is incredibly funky for a Floyd song and the bass and guitar really go hard on it. I'm not too much into "Welcome to the machine". Conceptually it's pretty good, but it feels like a significant chunk of the album's runtime is dedicated to this spaced out track and I find myself really disassociating during it, and not in the way I think was intended. Still there's some cool things that happen in that song, but given the transition from this to "Cigar" it makes the album flow a bit too jarring. I'm also not super crazy about Roger's voice on this record? He sounds like he's way out of his range singing on a lot of these tracks. It feels awkward. The only time I was compelled by his voice was on the title track; which by the way, deserves the hype. It's definitely one of the greatest songs ever recorded. His voice is appropriately weary-sounding and if there's any Floyd song that would move me to tears it's this one (again trying not to think of when my father passes away, see my Cat Stevens review). Altogether I think this album is pretty good, but sort of inconsistent given the relatively short runtime and limited batch of songs. This LP shows why PF were considered masters of their craft, but I think as far as album listening experiences go I might prefer DSotM to this one overall.
best floyd album 10/10 best song - have a cigar
A soundscape to escape to
J'ai préféré The Wall and The Dark Side of the Moon
Solid album
No song should ever be over 10 minutes long. If, has it finished yet? was an album.
Pretty essential album and would definitely come back to. At the same time it would be really nice to see the different parts of Crazy Diamond be split kind of like how they did Another Brick in the Wall on their other record. 8/10
Any single song on this album would be enough to make a five star album and yet there's a whole album of them.
Love this one.
Favorite Song: Shine On You Crazy Diamond Least Favorite: Welcome to the Machine
oh dear. i've always told my husband i only like one album from pink floyd (he loves them) and that was dark side of the moon. unfortunately i have to swallow my pride and tell him i also liked this one a lot. i definitely like it as an album, all one piece. is it self-indulgent? sure. but it's self-indulgent in the way of still-young men wondering how they got here and clearly mourning their friend. i added it to my music library. 5/5
hard to deny
Pink Floyd were the pinnacle of prog rock. It’s hard to describe exactly, but when you listen to other prog rock bands from this time it feels like they’re just imitating Pink Floyd’s sound. Maybe it’s an authenticity that comes through in the music, not sure, fucking awesome album nonetheless
It's definitely a little indulgent but besides Welcome to the Machine, I think most of it works. Have a Cigar is a classic
Not my favorite of Pink Floyd's 70s output - though this run of Pink Floyd records we've seen gives me renewed appreciation for their creative energy with regard to their songwriting. The thematic, emotional content of these albums are universally interesting and Wish You Were Here is particularly affecting since so much of it is about Syd Barrett no longer being in the band and the delayed response/recognition of that. But what they do on Dark Side & The Wall & Animals impresses me a lot more.
Nothing bad here, but it is a bit exhausting. A soundtrack for a day which is not today, I think.
4 y medio. Si no es de los mejores discos de la historia, pega en el palo.
One of the best album ever made
Another one I've definitely heard growing up.
No Words! One of the greatest albums of all time. Nothing can beat "shine on you crazy diamond" in the greatest artwork of all time contest.
An all-time classic.
Really great album. Might be the first time I heard it all the way through. The last song was the best.
Cool album cover
I never realized how much the guitar work on Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts 1-5) sounds like it could be the background music for a seducing scene in a 1980s made for TV skin-flick that takes place in Florida. And then there's a sax solo?! C'mon! I received this album on the 51st anniversary of its release. I love the 3 middle songs a lot. Might be my top 3 favorite PF songs. I love the Primus cover of Have A Cigar. I never really cared for Shine On - and adding 23 minutes to the radio edit never helped things.
За исключением Wish you were here, эта пластинка не содержит ничего интересного для моих ушей
In 1968, Syd Barret left Pink Floyd due to his erratic behavior and declining mental state. In 1975, while Pink Floyd was in the studio, he showed up to visit them. He was unrecognizable. At the time of his visit, Pink Floyd had been in the middle of mixing “Shine On You Crazy Diamond”: a tribute to Barett, painting him as a youthful artist ruined by fame and the ruthless music industry, which accelerated his struggles with substance abuse and possible schizophrenia. It’s a multi-suite, grand track that acts as opener and closer, perfectly bookending the album. There are only five songs, and none of them waste a single note. Each centers around themes related to Barret’s departure and the band’s own struggles with fame. They range from personal to apocalyptic—from the tenderness of “Wish You Were Here” to the impending doom of “Welcome to the Machine” to the sardonic “Have a Cigar.” It’s a thoughtful, emotional dystopian about an artist having their passions thrust into the factory of consumerism and constant scrutiny. The tasteful guitar and warm synths, when combined with the sounds of cars and static, make the album feel like stepping up to the edge of a beautiful seaside cliff, only to look down and see the stuff of nightmares just over the edge of the drop. There’s never been a more beautiful obituary written about somebody who’s still alive.
Incredible album. The title track is perfection. The others are all great, too, even if there are some moments that don't really hold my attention all that much.
10 stars
One of my favourite albums anyway, so an easy 5 stars for me. Shine On You Crazy Diamond demonstrates just how good Pink Floyd are as musicians, even before the vocals kick in after 8.5 minutes! Headphones on, get lost in the musicality, and think about what a tribute this was to their "lost" friend, Syd Barrett. And then, just for good measure - a couple of tracks saying "fuck you" to the music industry and record execs. Amazing! This is the sort of album people don't/can't produce any more, sadly...
Superb listen 👏🏼 I actually haven’t heard any other Pink Floyd albums from start to finish other than the Dark side of the Moon so it was a treat to listen. Also dug the anti music industry/corporate world message, was quite funny to listen to it yesterday while working for a corporation 😂 Tops are Welcome to the Machine, Wish you were here, and the intro shine on you crazy diamond.
The soundscape, guitar/keyboard tones and instrumentation on this are close to perfect. The themes of loss and the take on their realities of the music industry make it an emotional album. So much DNA of Pink Floyd in many of my prog metal favourites. One of my favourite albums of all time. 5.
this is probably the single hottest take i have but 2/10, i just hate pink floyd, this album is a monument to their self aggrandisement. genuinely so bad
Ahead of today’s listen to Wish You Were Here, it’s fair to say my relationship with Pink Floyd has not been a happy one. I’ve never really been able to get on with them. The Piper at the Gates of Dawn was a 1/5 for me. I described it as “wanky middle class pop music” and struggled with the odd lyrics, lack of storytelling and general weirdness. More recently, I listened to The Wall, hoping it might finally be the Pink Floyd album that changed my opinion. It didn’t! Again, I found it overblown, overly experimental and far too pleased with its own cleverness. At more than 80 minutes, it felt incredibly self indulgent, although there were flashes of brilliance, particularly “Comfortably Numb” and “Another Brick in the Wall, Part 2”. I think the problem is that what Pink Floyd do well just isn’t what I want from music. I love strong songs, melody, hooks and storytelling, whereas their long experimental sections and sprawling concepts just aren’t my thing. So today we have Wish You Were Here. It’s one of their most celebrated albums and only five tracks long, so perhaps this would finally be the one to change my mind. Based on my history with Pink Floyd, though, I wasn’t holding my breath! Unfortunately, it hasn’t changed my opinion. There are two genuinely great moments in “Have a Cigar” and “Wish You Were Here”, but outside of those I found myself having exactly the same problems. The longer tracks are drawn out, overly indulgent and, for me, just boring. “Shine On You Crazy Diamond” might be regarded as a masterpiece by many, but long instrumental passages like this are precisely where Pink Floyd lose me. The frustrating thing is that when Pink Floyd actually give me a straightforward song, I can really enjoy them. “Wish You Were Here” is beautiful, “Have a Cigar” is a great tune, and I already know I like “Comfortably Numb” and “Another Brick in the Wall, Part 2”. Maybe I’ve finally worked it out. Pink Floyd’s greatest hits might be the Pink Floyd album for me! Favourite track: “Wish You Were Here”. A genuinely beautiful song and easily the highlight. Least favourite tracks: The long, drawn out sections of “Shine On You Crazy Diamond”. Exactly the sort of Pink Floyd I struggle with. Album artwork: I love it. Iconic, strange and brilliantly executed. Possibly another example of me liking Pink Floyd’s artwork more than their albums!
9.8
The best.
A slow start, peaking in the middle and slowing down towards the end of the last track. Was aware of one track on the album, and enjoyed majority of it. Start felt mystical before lyrics kicked in.
Very good. A little synthier than the music I normally enjoy but I did really like it. I wonder how much of that is familiarity with it. My dad is a big fan of this album and also Wish You Were Here does just get played a lot. But I think a lot of my enjoyment comes from the guitar playing and the emotions that I think the music carries. Fav song: Wish You Were Here Least fav: Welcome to the Machine
Better than dark side of the moon for sure (I know I rated it higher but I regret that now). Still not quite mind blowing but some really nice riffs in here. Also the cover art is absolutely superb. Specific rating - 4.2 Fav song - wish you were here Least fav -have a cigar
I have been listening to WYWH since I was 14 or 15, and like with Dark Side, I can dream every second of it. I remember biking 20km to school with my friend and singing "We're just two lost souls swimming in a fishbowl, year after year"—in fact, the whole song—and this is 35 years ago. This album is nestled in my brain, and I actually might not even have to put it on to relive it. It is another masterpiece of classic Pink Floyd in their heyday. Of course their sound had changed over time, especially since Syd Barrett had to leave the band. "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" is about Syd, but he hardly responded to it when he made a visit to the studio during the recording sessions. A very tragic story, unfortunately. But this album is just perfect, nothing else to say about it as it has been said a thousand and more times by several generations of music lovers and critics. Obvious that this is in the book. 5/5
Start to finish, this is a masterpiece.
# Album Name: Wish You Were Here # Artist: Pink Floyd # Rating: 5/5 # Comments: Amazing album. Some of THE best songs of all time. The skills on this band are crazy. # Top Tunes: SOYCD / WYWH / The machine # Would I listen to it again? Yes
“Wish You Were Here” feels like one of those albums that’s really deep without trying too hard to prove it. The music is dreamy and a little melancholy, and you can definitely feel the themes of missing people, losing connection. I may not understand every layer of what Pink Floyd is trying to say, but I know this album has a mood—and somehow it gets better every time I listen to it
Absolutely goated album
Ох бай зе вей вич вас Пинк Пидарасы сначала довели и выгнали из группы старину Сида, а затем написали об этом альбом
It isn't The Dark Side of the Moon, but I have nothing negative to say about Wish You Were Here. It's another amazing release from Pink Floyd.
Been a while since a complete listen. I would listen to this album again and again for shine on you crazy diamond alone Highly recommend listening while driving facing a sunrise as I did for this most recent listen
I think I listened to Dark Side of the Moon a few times ages ago (thanks Dad) and a few songs from The Wall. That's my Pink Floyd knowledge. Super interesting to learn the backstory going in. Even with the very 70s prog sound there's something kind of timeless about the emotional landscape. (I also love that it's a tight 45 minutes lol) If I'm learning anything through this 1001 albums thing, it might be just how much of a soft spot I have for 70s music.
Sublime
Great record, the title track and Shine On are keystone 70s rock songs, the definition of classics. Have A Cigar is the only song that might be considered slightly below par here, everything else is top notch although can see how some might complain it's a bit noodly and long in parts. 9/10
The 5est 5 that ever 5ed
I really liked this. Pink Floyd kinda kicks ass. I really appreciate the Shine On suites.
I liked it.
A brilliant album with unique to Pink Floyd sounds. Some great songs.
Fuck yes 5 star bitches
- really like have a cigar and title track - shine on you crazy diamond pt 1-5 goes on for too long lol - don’t really like songs that are all/mostly instrumental - interesting to listen to the original after hearing so many songs and albums be influenced by this (ex. a beautiful memory) - like the transition to shine on you crazy diamond pt 6-9) - beginning of soycd 6-9 is so good - really really enjoy the parts of soycd where they actually sing
I'm the furthest thing from a Pink Floyd fan, but it's hard to argue against this body of work. Damn, do I gotta go deep on these guys now??
I am a musician, i am really into all kinds of things related to music, i do listen to lots of albums and songs and artists and think about what i hear, how its been produced and what its trying to imply. The problem is, i probably don't know how to write them down as legitimate reviews, which are actually reasonable and have lots of arguments to support them. This is the first album on my journey with this tool : https://1001albumsgenerator.com/ Shine on you crazy diamond (Pts 1-5): Really good and ambient start, really sets a mood, the guitar is really beautiful and then when the song just explodes on with all the instruments it creates a feeling like no other. The first guitar "solo" is creative, skillful and definetly David Gilmour. The guitar solo after another solo is just simply beautiful. It follows really great from the solo while being its own person. It fits really well with everything else in the song and is a masterpiece. The singing works in the song, the "you were caught in the crossfire..." better in my opinion than just "shine on you crazy diamond". Then there is another great guitar part. Then follows the same pattern, until the saxophone solo. It is also very good overall, the melodies are interesting and the style changes a bit halfway. The song ends on a fade out, blending into Welcome to the Machine. Welcome to the machine: Quite an exotic start with the factorial sounds. Then there comes a good guitar with synth sounds out of this era. The synth bass sounds really good, with every one changing between left and right channels. The singing is good, the athmosphere at 2 mins 27 is unreal, the great guitar, synth sound, unique sounds and the bass. The new synth at 2 50 is also nice to listen to even though high. All the generated sounds mixed with a traditional guitar really set this song apart from the other songs in the album, and to my knowledge also from all songs from this time. The keyboard synth solo at 5 mins 15 onwards is while not by playing very hard, the sound itself and all the stereo effects already make it very impressive. The song ends with a first accelerating then decelerating tone (rising and sinking), followed by a thump (possibly a car door being closed) and people laughing at a social function. Have a Cigar Great riff with acoustic instruments followed by the same unique synth sounds playing a melody in unison with some bass element. The other bass part after this in the verse is quite funky and good sounding. The entire song sounds good, pleasant to listen and the opposite of bland. The guitar solo at ~3:20 is another impressive masterpiece, using many techniques and being very versatile with the melodies. It is very interesting, nice to listen to and just overall great. The song ends with a sudden extreme high pass and the full sound moving between left and right. Wish you were here: It starts with the same high pass as in have a cigar, being only on the right channel where Have a Cigar ended up. At 1 minute the pressure is relieved by an acoustic riff in the left channel and finally chords being played to both ears. The singing and lyrics are very emotional. The chord progression, instruments and just the song overall creates strong emotions, which really depend on the listener. Right now, i miss the people closest to me but am happy i will see them in a relatively short time. Shine on you crazy diamond (Pts 6-9): Ambient start, good instruments and melodies. At 2:27 when the song becomes faster-perceived and the guitar solo really gets going the song becomes even better. The guitar solo is just beautiful, with it being so long and still impressive the whole time. The occasional harmonies really flavour it. Then the song changes and becomes the same as the first shine on you crazy diamond. Then there is a new guitar part, which is really beautiful. The background harmonics and the Rhodes-keyboard are so good sounding they make you just immersed in the music, the groovy clavinet with all the layers before it just makes it even better. Groovy guitar, clavinet, rhodes and bass with the synth melodies whining around makes this a very unique portion of the song. It starts to slowly fade away with pads playing chords, then a new part starts. It features emotional chords on a piano, a saxophone and synth pad in the background. The saxophone melody really makes you think. The long solo ends on a long major chord, changing more torwards happy from longing. On this chord, different instruments play small melodies, but eventually it all fades away and the album is over. The album is stitched together really well, i really enjoyed listening to it and writing this, i was studying for a test at the same time so i most likely missed some things and this was my first real review so i definetly made lots of misinterpretations. Thank you so much for reading this far! If you have any thoughts about my review, I would appreciate a response to this from you.
Surprisingly more Air than Radiohead.
The opening minutes are amazing. I was absolutely loving the sort of cosmic, spacey ambience. Then the “rock” started and that’s always where Pink Floyd kind of loses me. Still on the whole a mostly enjoyable listen.
Some very cool ethereal music mixed with some surprisingly emotional parts. To me, it’s clearly their best album, and I think it shows them at their most vulnerable.
A very intentional album that's iconic for a reason. Beautiful music, lots of emotion.
The cornerstones of this album, shine on you crazy diamond, are great, as is the title song. The other two are just filling.
Una cumbre indiscutible del rock progresivo y el arte sonoro universal que ha envejecido bien como un monumento de perfección formal, hondura conceptual y belleza atemporal. En el plano de diseño sónico, la producción en Abbey Road logra una arquitectura insuperable que da claridad absoluta a cada textura, articulando sintetizadores modulares, pasajes acústicos cristalinos y grabaciones de campo con un balance espacial impecable. La interpretación colectiva despliega una fuerza y calidez que transmiten una autenticidad sobrecogedora, imponiendo una autoridad superior desde el primer compás. Cada pieza que compone el disco se erige como una obra maestra: el lamento cósmico de "Shine On You Crazy Diamond" con las icónicas cuatro notas de guitarra de David Gilmour y los teclados envolventes de Richard Wright; la crudeza visceral e hipnótica de "Welcome to the Machine", cuya pulsación maquinal e industrial resulta conmovedora hasta los huesos al denunciar el vacío del engranaje moderno; la ironía rítmica de "Have a Cigar"; y la intimidad desgarradora de la pista homónima "Wish You Were Here", donde la fragilidad acústica abraza la ausencia y la memoria. El álbum se consolida como un documento profundamente conmovedor, crudo y real que funciona como un lúcido y sutil llamado a la conciencia sobre la alienación, el duelo y la preservación del alma humana. Por su capacidad infinita de fascinación en escuchas continuas a lo largo de horas, días o ciclos enteros, su constante sensación de paz y fluidez lo vuelve un refugio óptimo para múltiples usos, destacando como un catalizador incomparable para el trabajo creativo, la conducción y la más honda reflexión solitaria.
one of my favorites that I don't listen to anymore #musicsky #albumsky
I like this, it's really easy listening and great music. Two listen throughs in a row is too much though.
The greatest. 10/10
Easily one of the best albums ever recorded. Makes me realize that there are at least 4 Pink Floyd albums that I would rate 5/5 stars. Listening with good headphones/speakers is a must. So many cool details, perfect melodies, and the best sounding synths I’ve ever heard on a rock album, by far.
Have I listened to this album before Yes How familiar am I with this album Very familiar How do I feel about this artist? I really like Pink Floyd when the mood is right Pre-Listen Thoughts: I already know I’m gonna love this one Favorite track(s): Title track Post-Listen Thoughts: This album is just so good. This album changed my perception of Pink Floyd. When I first heard the guitar intro to the title track, I knew I had to do a deep life into the artist and I was not expecting it to be Pink Floyd. I had a lot of misconceptions about them and this album changed that and made me a fan. This one is a 6/5
Definitely need a better listen to appreciate this more fully. But, of course, this was great! Maybe slightly prefer Dark Side of the Moon (I'm basic) but that might change.
On most days (and this day is no different), this is my favorite Floyd record.
云里雾里
Feels like a huge buildup for the title song, which is obviously a fantastic tune. Good journey, love the opener also
29/08/2026 I don't really have anything to say about this album to be honest. It just hit the mark. Spotify listeners: 28.4 million
If nothing else, this project is teaching me that I don't like Prog Rock. Really believe Pink Floyd are at their best with a traditional song structure such as 'Wish You Were Here.' Which is a great song and the album cover is a classic. But the 'Shine on You Crazy Diamond' split into 2 songs for some pretentious proggy reason named Parts 1-V and parts VI-IX can fuck right off. 3 stars.
Wish You Were Here is so good it outweighs the rest being bad
I feel real shame to say I have never listened to any Pink Floyd before at the age of 39 other than the tracks I’ve ever caught on the radio. So this is going to be an experience.. ‘Shine on you crazy diamond’ had a 9 minute intro before we even heard any lyrics and what a 9 minutes it was, bending guitars and a feeling of just getting lost into the underbelly of the genius. Then the vocal hits and it goes up a level yet again before ending with a mesmerising sax solo. ‘Welcome to the machine! An absolute masterpiece, it felt like somebody was looking into the depths of my mind and pulling out my soul but my word did it feel great! ‘The cigar’ another great track, reminiscent of Queen at times, never a bad thing! ‘Wish you were here’ high hopes for the title track after the first 3 tracks and ur does not disappoint, why have I never listened to this band before, I feel like a complete musical loving fraud as this is actually moving me like not many bands have before. You can feel the love in every pluck of guitar, every lyric sung and every drumstick beat. The closer woah it’s ’shine on you crazy diamonds’ parts 6-9 meaning track one was 1-5 that is cool and explains the variants and that sax solo was clearly its own part, I absolutely love that they gave intentionally broken it down but put it together like that and the 2 end tracks felt like perfect bookends to those 3 tracks in the middle. Best track- ‘welcome to the machine’ Worst track- ‘the cigar’ tough choice but out of the 5 this would have to be it I think. 10/10
I love Pink Floyd, and I love this album. Especially Shine on You Crazy Diamond.
great album, the soundscape is great lyrics are deep, good listen but wouldn’t be a daily listen for me, its more of a artistic piece then something to listen to on the train, i understand why critics like it but im not cultured enuf to reciprocate the same love for this album
Probably my favorite pink Floyd album of all time. I have a poster of this album from when I was a teen
Beautiful album, layered deeply with fantastic tunes from front to back. With the meaning of this being in relation to Syd Barrett, very sad turn of events. The synth on this album is magical, layered in with some great grooves from the guitar. Wish you were here was definitely a standout. Shine On you crazy diamond (all parts) was also a masterpiece. Perfect album if you ask me. Definitely one to listen to before kicking the bucket 9.5 or maybe even a 10/10
Understand the hype now. Might be higher if I listen more. 9/10
Out of respect.. it’s supposed to be very good I guess. But for me this is 100% not a 5. So a low 4 maybe.
oooo i feel like im gonna get a ton of flack for this. i think that dark side is better. i know this is their kinda more commercially successful one, but i think as an album you gotta listen to it in one shot. i think that ultimately detracts from it sadly, that you can't just jump on it i guess overall, its beautiful, but i also think the mixing was so weird on wish you were here.
My favorite of the three Pink Floyd albums we’ve had so far and another that I want to listen to on blast with noise cancelling headphones. Even the longer tracks didn’t feel like they dragged on the entire time and Wish You Were Here is such a classic. Easily five stars and I will listen to it again soon.
This might be the coolest way to follow up one of the biggest albums of all time. They make a record breaking album with Dark Side of the Moon and then follow it up by not only acknowledging a former band member, but saying that they wish there could be here to celebrate it with them. Really cool concept. The music isn't as good as DSotM, but I'm still a sucker for Pink Floyd.
Brilliant
easiest five yet
Always a classic, not their best but very good.
- love the flow between songs - panning and atmosphere is amazing - synths and progressions
First pink floyd album i’ve ever sat down and listened to, i liked it, very euphoric but very long instrumentals and i wasn’t expecting so little vocals and so little tracks
Eh. Liked cigar and wish you were here.
Great Album
Such a masterpiece
5/5, duh
It’s so good :,) I gotta admit I’ve never been a big Pink Floyd fan, nor do I think I actually got what the were all about, but hearing the album all the way through has mad me see how good it is. Crazy stuff
Ну типа, сложно будет сказать что-то новое про Wish You Were Here, чего вы не знаете. Культовый альбом, культовая обложка, запись посвященная Сиду Баррету и все такое прочее. Поэтому мне хотелось бы чутка поговорить про PF как феномен. Группа довольно сильно отличается на фоне всех остальных больших прог-рок групп того времени, безусловно они имеют лицо и свой стиль, один мой товарищ даже настаивал на том, что он воспринимает их как "психоделический рок" нежели прог, с чем я не согласен, но тем ни менее, это заставило меня задуматься. Когда я слушаю: Gentle Giant, Jethro Tull, Genesis, King Crimson, Focus, Yes, Frank Zappa, группы и исполнители с крайне разными стилями и идеями, но все их объединяет одно: большое количество сложных полотен с постоянными сменами музыкальных размеров, полиритмии, множество заимствований и вдохновений основанных либо на современной академической музыке либо на старой, классической. Что из всего этого мы видим у Pink Floyd? В основном, это концептуальный характер записей и восприятие многих композиций как сюиты с несколькими большими музыкальными секвенциями, хорошая работа с пространством и музыкальной архитектурой, но Флойды гораздо больше зиждяться, как раз таки, на наследии того самого психодел-рока ну и, я бы сказал, блюза. Как таковой, особенной музыкальной сложности в Флоидах нет, (подчеркиваю: в сравнении с другими группами жанра) И вот как раз по причине того, что группа либо специализируется на каких либо высказывания и концептуализме (сюжет, нарратив альбома) либо на создании особенной атмосферы (долгое развитие, тягучая последовательность, как в этом альбоме) ЛИЧНО МНЕ разбирать творчество Флойдов с композиторской точки зрения, с точки зрения того, как работает мелодия и куда она идет - не так интересно, как множество других крайне талантливых прогрессив команд, но куда менее известных чем Pink Floyd. ОТ ЧЕГО, мне кажется забавным когда люди не совсем зарывшиеся в жанр прогрессива, считают PF вершиной, не зная и не слушая другого. От чего же и довольно скоро, Флоиды стали восприниматься мной как группа entry-level'а, и в общем-то, это даже и не плохо. В конце концов, главное не быть как особо надоедливые фанаты Radiohead что считают что Том Йорковское детище, это чуть ли не второе пришествие Иисуса в мире высокогоконтекстного, концептуального, великого искусства, и что он делает, СлОжНеЙшУю, ГлУбОчАйШуЮ музыку. Ну, быть может если только до этого ты на репите гонял Линкин Парк и Грин Дей, тогда да, такие группы как рх и флойд - считаются чем-то непостижимым. Ладно, чёто я распизделся, вряд-ли мой поток мыслей кто-то будет читать, Wish You Were Here - отнюдь не плохой альбом и звучит он отлично, я здесь скорей говорил про сосаети и свое восприятие жанра после его изучения.
OBRA MAESTRA. Y no se dice más porque lo mejor es sentirlo, escucharlo y deleitarse en él. Canciones favoritas: 'Shine On You Crazy Diamond, Parts I–V' y 'Wish You Were Here'
It’s not my favourite Pink Floyd but it’s still just so good.
This is less an album than a full on journey. For me, it is like this. You are walking down a long hallway and each song is a door that opens up into a room full of wonderful lights and colors and things you've never seen before. Or maybe things you had seen before but not quite in the same way. And as you are pulled along this long corridor and visit each room, the shapes and colors add up to a subtle impression of meaning and you realize that yes, this art. You are experiencing something instead of merely listening. By the end of it all, you're not quite the same person as the one who started. And you are better for it. When the final notes fade away, you sit there in silence for a bit and try to piece together what you have just heard but by that time, it's already gone and all that is left to do is listen again. And again. And again. Each time, you find those wonderful rooms sitting there, waiting for you again. Just you.
Goat
It lives up to all of the expectations.
Really liked this! It didn’t stop sounding really nice! Something is keeping me from going full 5-stars though. If i ever figure out what that is, maybe i’ll revisit and revise.
Legendary album, just from the intro it lifts your soul up, up in the sky. Damn, this is bliss. The album is just nice from start to finish. The screaming guitars at end are so cool.
Favorite songs: Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I–V), Welcome to the Machine, Have a Cigar, Wish You Were Here, Shine On You Crazy Diamond (Parts VI–IX)
entiendo el mambo y que debe haber sido paloyo escuchar esto en el 70, pero no sé si me gusta TANTO?
Stellar.
- oh boy, the first Floyd on my list. the title track is overplayed enough on radio stations to probably merit anyone writing off the entire album, but I'm curious how a conscious listen from beginning to end will change things - it's hard to decide on a rating because I've heard this album so many times before, but in trying to remember my initial reaction ~15 years ago, I think only a 5 can suffice: it's bookended by similar motifs, it's got lots of different musical textures going on, the guitar solos are solid, and it was different than anything I'd ever heard before in 2009-2010. that initial blast of synth in both ears in "Welcome to the Machine" still gives me chills
Lived up to it's reputation
Great Album. No notes.
Dit is toch veel beter dan TDSOTM
Eerst Dark Side Of The Moon en nu mijn favoriete Floyd album, wat een geluk. Tip: Op de 50 jarige anniversary editie die pas is uitgekomen staat een complete SOYCD (alle 9 delen achter elkaar) met een nieuwe stereo mix, absoluut de moeite waard om even goed voor te gaan zitten.
I guess I’m officially a Pink Floyd fan now! I loved how layered and atmospheric this album was. Even the longer songs never felt like they were going nowhere. “Welcome to the Machine” and “Have a Cigar” had some great things to say about the music industry, and learning the story of Syd Barrett gave “Wish You Were Here” even more meaning. Five stars and an easy vinyl buy!
5 star all day babyyyyyyy!
Goosebumps everytime when the first riff arrives... Just Great!
2026-08-17: Didn’t realize I had listened to this entire album before. Never characterized myself as a Pink Floyd fan but damn I like it now. Nice mellow listen.
dark side of the moon is better IMHO
I didn't know I liked pink Floyd
finaly an album i actually know 9/10 near perfect allbum all songs are amazing not a miss
뭐라 쓰지
This album is kind of crazy for the instrumental to vocal ratio (much higher than I expected). I knew excerpts of these but not the full 12-14 minute tracks. Maybe my attention span has been ruined by radio cuts but I think I prefer them shorter. Love the effects & the classic guitar lines are definitely ear worms.
2.5
wow.Just wow. idk why i hadnt listened to this any sooner. Its different from the long intros to the silence and then sudden sounds to get ur attentions before the song properly starts its different in a good way and i can see why pink floyds is such a popular and influention band
Feels like I'm main character in game far away. During the instrumental parts it's a montage of me and my life and the when the lyrics come, it's my inner dialogue. First 5/5 listen
Classic! But ageless. This album sounds fresh and catchy, complex, futuristic and soulful.
Only 5 tracks but it's 44 minutes long and not a wasted moment. Enough said.
5/10
Epic album. You don't need 8 or more songs when you have a song with 9 parts and epic solos. And on top of that you deliver one of the best campfire songs of all times, for all of those we wish were here.
Pink Floyd как всегда на высоте. Все их альбомы, которые я слышал - прекрасны. Хоть альбом и довольно размеренный, но музыкально настолько шикарен, что затягивает тебя в поток и не отпускает до конца. Если бы я оценивал альбом по сравнению с другими от них - был бы на 3м месте. Как музыка в абсолютном сравнении - 10/10. С треками было настолько сложно, что я забил на свои же ограничения. 1) Welcome to the machine 2) Wish you were here 3) Shine on you crazy diamond 1-9 По итогу добавил практически весь альбом как в основной плейлист, так и в дополнительный.
Топ. Качественный отрыв от предыдущих альбомов в списке невозможно игнорировать. Очень хорошо. Топ-1 - Wish you were here Топ-2 - Shine on you crazy diamond (pts 1-5)
Music for planetariums. I first heard this album in a planetarium and it was the last time I heard it. Until now. It’s great for planetariums as a background music to movies about stars. It is honestly as boring as Steely Dan. It honestly and without hyperbole, is the lamest excuse for a record. There is nothing compelling about this. An album of extended noodling divided into segments that bore each other. Just shit. 💩 0/5
Als Tribut zu Syd Barrett und als Kritik an Unterhaltungsmusik natürlich toll. Wish you were here ist ein Meisterwerk. Als dummer Hörer habe ich mit dem ganzen Midtempo Rockgehabe und den ständigen Space Synths aber meine Probleme. Und das schleppende Drumspiel, das standig dum dum dedum etwas neues, heftiges ankündigt, aber stattdessen kommt nur noch mal ne Variation majestätischer Herrenrock. Lyrisch viel Empörung, aber mir fehlt die Wucht.
Finds weirdly gut obwohl ich die langen Instrumentals hassen wollte. Aussergewöhnliches Album mit coolem Vibe.
Yea good.
I want to give it a 4.5 honestly. Pink Floyd is one of those bands I’d tell myself to get into eventually but kept putting off. Welcome to the Machine was a personal favourite on this; huge sucker for all things industry commentary. I really enjoyed how despite the lyrical vagueness of the album overall, you still felt as if you were immersed in a sort of universe of its own kind. Big fan of the instrumentals. Add a half star system already..
I wish you were here
After The Dark Side of the Moon, this is my favorite Pink Floyd album!
Wish there was more.
another classic pink floyd album
Easy one here. 5 stars. Brilliant from start to finish.
Just fantastic from beginning to end. Personally I'm glad that Gilmour was outvoted on the idea of not having Shine On … bookend the album.
SO MUCH BETTER THAN DARK SIDE OF THE MOON For context, I hated that one and gave it a 2 This one rocks so it's a really high 4
A true masterpiece and harmony of sounds, lingering somewhere between the hard rock and psychodelic sound; and when Ian Gillan finally awards us with his voice, after the lengthy instrumentals are over, the eargasm is complege 🥰
I've probably listened to this too much as the songs have become slightly thin. But still all a great album. And sad too.
Oh. Well it’s a 5. Shine on you crazy diamond. Crazy, just had solo Syd Barrett that was quite sad, really. That opening has to be one of the most amazing in all music that I know. Hard to say how much I love this album. It’s so beyond a 5, it’s transcendent. 5 Boolean: TRUE
One of my absolute favorites. It’s like a warm fuzzy blanket every time I listen.
the most beautiful 44 minutes of my life
#57 - Pink Floyd - Wish You Were Here ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ It would be ludicrous to attempt in a microblog such as this to summarize the masterful greatness of this, the magnum opus of Prog Rock and easily one of the top ten best albums ever made. Wish You Were Here is a masterpiece of really staggering proportions. It’s Pink Floyd’s follow up to The Dark Side of the Moon, and it somehow eclipses even that brilliant piece. Every note, phrase, lyric, sound effect and literally even moment on this album is exactly perfect. It could not in any way be better than it is. Shine On You Crazy Diamond is enough to earn all five available stars, and it’s not even the best song on the album. That honor is reserved for the title track, which also happens to be the best sone of all time. Mix in Welcome to the Machine and Have a Cigar, and then the second half of Shine On and you have something so staggering good and great and powerful and meaningful that it would be hard to imagine Pink Floyd ever topping it. Amazingly, only four short years later, they did. But that’s a discussion for another day. Wish You Were Here is most certainly a story about Syd Barrett, but it’s also so much more than that. The pressures of the music industry, the pain it causes to exploited artists and the loss of a friend are all heavily explored. I was so excited to see this pop up as my album of the day. I could have written this review without listening to it again, but I listened to it twice, just to make sure that everything that I feel about it and stated here is as correct as possible. And it absolutely is.
A wise friend of mine once said that Wish You Were Here is the best album of all time and I think I'm starting to agree
Shiiine onnnnn you craaaaazy 💎 Obviously 5/5, nothing to say that hasn't been said
It took more than one listen to get 5 stars, but it's awesome!
Ugh, just pure perfection. David Gilmour’s bends could bring about world peace if they so choose
80 puppies of awesomeness.
Another great album from Pink Floyd. A sad one given the context of Syd Barrett leaving the band due to illness.
Good album. Man, those songs are long. They all sound cinematic though
Pretty dang close to a 5 star. 4 and 3/4.
One of the quintessential albums of the Pink Floyd's catalog.
better than expected
Just Perfection. 10/10
Amazing guitar riffs, really interesting sections through the songs.
This is the first ever Pink Floyd album I've listened to, after hearing about them forever. These guys really earned all of the commendations and praise over the decades. You are greeted by an ethereal setting, which obscures what type of genre you will be met with for those that are unfamiliar. As the album begins to show hints and signs of presenting you with 70s rock, two Sax solos appear out of nowhere within the same track. Soon after your ears are graced with the sounds of Retro-Futuristic synth sounds, which remain present for the rest of the album. This entire collection of songs take you on a complete adventure that doesn't let you down at any moment. Its a non-stop, continuous high of innovation and the essence of musical creativity. This is a 10/10 5 star album that everyone should listen to.
Muy bueno
The technical mastery here is just insane, the music is transfixing and cinematic. Pink Floyd is at their best when they’re getting kind of evil with it, like in Welcome to the Machine. However, I have this problem with them which is that I don’t find the ideas they speak to directly relatable or even all that interesting. There is something so British and Baby Boomer about their engagement with a resentment of conformity and desire for independence so great it nearly defines their body of work. It’s good stuff, but I feel at a distance from it.
Exceptional.
a masterpiece from a unique band
En efecto es un álbum que tienes que escuchar antes de morir
Joya de progresivo. De los mayores exponentes del rock psicodélico virtuoso. Se siente un gran equilibrio entre canciones con forma instrumental y con forma habitual. Gran disco.
Slower and atypical. Okay.
08/02 Absolute classic. Not a bad song on it
One of their best. Favorite song: Shine On pts. 1-5
"Shine On You Crazy Diamond" (the bookends of this album) are an absolute masterpiece. I have fond memories from high school, driving at night with my friends while listening to that long song. The middle songs are excellent as well (including the famous titular song), but the bookends will always be the highlight for me.
Az év amiben születtem, született a Pink Floyd legcsodásabb dala is. Természetesen a Shine On You Crazy Diamond.
No Notes - for me this is an all timer. Having never heard it before, I come out of listening having just really enjoyed everything they put into this album.
Some of the best instrumentals ever. Shine on You Crazy Diamond (1-5) is a great song and likely the best on the album. The pacing just feels a bit off at times and can lose your engagement. Overall 8.5 out of 10, or 4.3 out of 5.
Such a cool atmospheric album with mystifying synths
Deilig pink Floyd!
One of my all time favourites
Rock prog mais pas psyché comparé à d’autres de leur album J’aime bien vibé dessus
Shine on
My first album I was given for this project! I am so excited for this <3. I am not sure how exactly I am going to do these reviews but here I go. I am going to try and do track by track, but maybe some days I will just do album overall review. I have always heard of how legendary Pink Floyd is, but in all honesty I have never listened to a complete one of their albums completely. So here let us see. Post album first listen thoughts- this was an experience for sure. my favorite is Wish You Were Here hands down, but everything was so pleasant and interesting to listen to! I am so excited to go down this rabbit hole heh. albums like this one are an experience for sure, not just one hit wonders. gah Track 1- "Shine On You Crazy Diamond Parts 1-5"- 13 minute song hello! This is very interesting sounding, I do not get the hype though. Wow 8 minutes for any singing to happen. Wow! is that saxophone in the last two minutes?? wowow!! amazing!! Track 2- "Welcome to the Machine"- i lovee the soft strung guitar on this one! but still paired with the really baring what is that strings? really interesting whoo and the space-psychedlics? wowowow so cool. I like this one. does the machine represent real life? reality away from expectations? overall the whole album the sound is so spaced out yet every second has very meaningful placements going on. how cool is that! Car door closing and speeding off transitioned to just this white noise? wow. and now a crowd. what interesting choicess Track 3- "Have a Cigar"- very old pop rock vibes. Wow the guitar bro!! Seems like song is about experience coming down or after from the success of their album. Gosh who is the guitarist on this track?? Track 4- "Wish you Were Here"- ok so no one was going to warn me at how sad this was going to be. That first guitar string reminded me of wild horses :(. But wow this is a sad and soft song. Was not expecting that, but delightfully surprised. Will be adding to playlist! Track 4- "Shine On You Crazy Diamond Parts 6-9"- ok so are these like multi guitar solos? multiple different songs smashed into one? here we go! ok this one is a lot more upbeat i will give it to them. feels like the ending of a movie post-climax when the chaos settles down. holy guitar dude. very interesting. the saxophone that keeps giving at the end! very cool very interesting.
I guess you had to be there (geddit?)... great title track, the rest, god, I don't want to listen to it again... far too much noodle, not enough meat... Begone foul music!
I believe this album was my profile pic on MySpace in 8th grade. I don’t particularly care for it today? I guess it’s a step between like long bloated suites and the pop songs they started doing on The Wall. But it’s kinda caught in the middle. I mostly enjoyed crazy diamond this time around though it’s so much shorter and more structured than I’d remembered. Also really responding to the guitar solos I feel like in the past I basically thought of Pink Floyd as like clock sounds and wooshes but they’re also a rock band. Excited for all their other better albums.
An extremely nostalgic listen: I've listened to random tracks from this album SO MANY times while hanging out with my hipster friends in high school without realizing they all came from this album. Groovy contemplative bluesy synth cyberpunk vibes that's exactly as long as it needs to be.
Fucking banging
This is an album that definitely belongs on this list! No ifs, ands, or buts—even if you’re young. I believe this album has influenced every young musician in some way. The world wouldn't function without it. As if by chance, today we’re visiting the famous Zeiss Planetarium in Jena. It’s the perfect setting for the music—and specifically the song "Shine On You, Crazy Diamond." When the starry sky opens up above you on the dome, you can practically imagine yourself flying through space—even though the song is actually dedicated to Syd Barrett. I imagine any music fan recognizes the song the moment those first quiet bars of "Wish You Were Here" begin. It’s an atmospheric record with a continuous theme—a sort of concept album. I first heard it in the late 70s. For guys living in a land from a bygone era called the GDR, Pink Floyd were like the unattainable kings of music. I still love their music. I think I own all their original records—which cost me a fortune.
An excellent album paying tribute and homage ti original member and founder of the group Syd Barrett. Great guitar work from David Gilmour and poignant lyrics from Waters.
Quand même nice pour vrais
Good, just not my music taste
pink floyd!