Rejoicing In The Hands by Devendra Banhart

Rejoicing In The Hands

Devendra Banhart

2.8
Rating
23526
Votes
1
11%
2
28%
3
37%
4
19%
5
5%
Distribution

Album Summary

Rejoicing in the Hands (full title Rejoicing in the Hands of the Golden Empress) is the third studio album from psychedelic folk musician Devendra Banhart and the second full release for the label Young God. It was recorded during 2003 and was released on April 24, 2004. The song "Insect Eyes" was featured in the teaser trailer for the 2007 horror film The Hills Have Eyes 2. The song "The Body Breaks" was used in the 2007 film Eagle vs. Shark. The song "A Sight to Behold" was also used in a season 2 episode of "Sons of Anarchy". As of September 2005 Rejoicing in the Hands has sold 24,000 copies in United States, also first four albums collectively have sold 56,000 units up to 2005.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Close to a 0/10 vocalist for me. Too gnarly and freaky. Knobbly and bleaty but also very twee and affected in that sickly pretentious way a lot of early 00s American folk and indie is. I can listen to Incredible String Band all day but this is tough. If it’s a singer-songwriter album from 2004 I’d rather it be James Blunt Back To Bedlam.

If a flaccid penis were an album.

This one was hard to get through

What the hell was that?

Yikes. Overwrought and boring is a terrible combo.

A friend of mine had me listen to this when it came out. I haven't spoken to them since.

Boring. The guitar work is really good, but it was a chore to listen to. Sufjan had already put Michigan out the year before. This album sounds kind of dated compared to it. A “stomp clap hey” ancestor. Fav song: The pretentiously named instrumental one

Think Tiny Tim crossed with a six year old song writing. Pluck pluck guitar and this annoying high pitched voice this is truly awful. Let's be honest truly awful is better than just meh. Think there's a woman singing on rejoicing the hands. Unfortunately he decides to sing along with her.

Started off well with great guitar plucking and a folksy vibe. That lasted all of 30 seconds before it dropped off a cliff when he started 'singing'. I'm sire his mum was proud, but unfortunately the music world might have been a better place if someone had been honest with him about whether he could sing or not. I really wanted to like it, and did enjoy the guitar play and also the female vocals on one track were beautiful. A shame he chose to sing too. Sorry 1/5

This is what unseasoned chicken would sound like

Weird lyrics, roomy acoustic guitar. Shades of Cohen's early albums

Oh I loved this! 2000s indie folk that’s kind of odd but every song is fun and just pleasing to listen to. This is the exact kind of shit my hipster ass has a soft spot for

Imagine an Adam Sandler album without the comedy, irony, or musical talent, and you're getting dangerously close to this pretentious disaster. Sixteen tracks of whimsical acoustic noodling accompanied by lyrics so shallow I nearly broke my neck diving into them. "I know my mother's womb was warm because I was born on a hot day." What the actual fuck? That's not profound. That's something a stoned eighth grader writes in a journal and mistakes for philosophy. The occasional attempts at humor were somehow worse. Between the bizarre Vegas stuttering routine and restarting a non-English song while laughing at his own inside joke, I felt like I'd wandered into an open mic night where the performer was also his own biggest fan. "Fall" was marginally less terrible, although by that point I was desperately searching for anything resembling a redeeming quality. I don't mind stripped-down acoustic music, but when the guitar is the star, and that star is f burnex up ball of gas you've got a problem. I refuse to believe this belongs among even the top 10k albums you should hear before you die. Boring, pompous drivel sung with a wink that I'm looking away from. One star and I'd like my 42 minutes back please and thank you.

It was weird that an entire retake of a part was included in the album. I didn’t hate this as much as I normally hate folk music, I think this was a bit more interesting. I think the guitar work kept me interested.

Track By Track This Is the Way - A very tender beginning. Soft and subtle. His eccentric nature is still shining through though in his delivery. A Sight To Behold - This album’s beginning to feel very mythical, mystical and folksy. I’m liking it! There’s a slightly haunting quality to this but flecked with beauty, mainly lent by the strings. The Body Breaks - I believe I have heard this one before. It reminds me of people like Cat Power. Just very simple and tender. Poughkeepsie - This feels as if in the same camp as Sufjan Stevens. Slightly quirky, quite jolly and alternative, funny rhythms and delivery. Dogs They Make Up The Dark - A little medieval moment. Very nice. Will Is My Friend - I am enjoying the loose, demo-like feel of most of these. This sounds quite spontaneous. There’s a quite friendly intimacy coming though here. This Beard Is for Siobhan - This has nice guitar picking. A very kooky delivery again. Builds to a convivial, bar/party stomp which is quite nice. See Saw - Did not like this as much. It’s a little too warbly for me. Still retains the intimacy of the album though and nice plucking work. Tit Smoking in the Temple of Artesan Mimicry - This was some of my favourite guitar work on the whole record. A big fan. I can see from these titles the psychedelic, almost child-like fantasy of the themes on these albums. Again, recalling Sufjan Stevens’ long form projects. Rejoicing in the Hands - I am enjoying these little vignette songs. A sweet little number. Close to a lullaby. Fall - This sounded a little mushy. Did not enjoy as much, struggled to connect with it for that reason. Todo los Dolores - Back to the live, demo feel on this one. Enjoying the Spanish influence. Another tender folk songlet. When the Sun Shone on Vetiver - This was almost like a prayer. Very mesmeric. Hypnotic. One of the more grand scale songs here. There Was the Sun - A little hippie-like ode to his life. Insect Eyes - Intimate imagery. Has the sort of ethereal haunting magic of Nick Drake, but more folksy and medieval witchified. Autumn’s Child - Very mournful and melancholic. It’s a lovely accompaniment to the season. Very apt. Overall Review: I had heard of Devendra before, but never heard a whole album. He has a very eccentric personality but a huge amount of tenderness as well. Or at least that’s what I get from his music. I can also hear that he has an eclectic range of influences yet also a singular sound. Quite recognisable. He sits well nestled in the contemporary canon of folk singer/songwriters. Not all of it was my cup of tea but very sweet and innovative moments. 3.4/5 Favourite Songs: This Is the Way, The Body Breaks, Tit Smoking in the Temple of Artesan Mimicry

Honestly I really do like this kind of simple Folk guitar and vocals or piano and vocals type of recordings. I really found the songs very good in this and I probably would like it better if I liked his voice just a little bit more there's a certain quality which is not my particular favorite but he's got a lot of emotion behind it which really pulls it still in a strong four-star category. I think if his vocals were more to my style this might have even gone up to four and a half (8.5) ★★★★

Devendra Banhart kind of kicked off the 2000s Freak Folk scene, and this was released at what was probably the peak of it. I think it's a cool album in that it's really delicate and pretty at times, but you also get this psychedelic weirdness mixed in. Devendra's voice is really cool and unique. Highlights for me are "A Sight to Behold", "Will is My Friend", "Fall", and "This Beard Is for Siobhán". 4 stars.

Totally unfamiliar going in.

Baffling inclusion #10 This album is from 2004 and so is almost certainly from the extension. That said, who asked for this James blunt ass album?? Who would notice if this was deleted? Is devendra banhart anyone’s favorite artist who would be omitted from our humble project? I’d guess not. ⭐️

It’s okay, nothing that pulled at my heartstrings. At least his style seems consistent.

Marc Bolan with an acoustic guitar.

The voice, a thin, dry tenor with a strange tremor when he sings high notes (attempted vibrato?), is hard to take over the course of 16 songs. Most of this is him and his guitar, which gets repetitive and dull. It does make the few tracks that are more arranged stand out in a positive way. The songs themselves are odd little snippets, which often just seem to peter out and end abruptly, giving the feeling of “Oh. I guess we’re done.” At least it’s only 42 minutes long, an absolute token of mercy in the CD age.

Some weird hippie shit. I like some of the guitar playing in this and the mild indie folk sound, though the vocals aren’t strong (and he seems to be compensating for it with a weird croaky timbre).

This was a peaceful album to listen to and I enjoyed the tracks, but I'm not sure if I'll come back to it.

It was OK. Not horrible, but boring and uninspired.

Started out promising, then got annoying.

Dit ken ik totaal niet. Het begint wel lekker. De zanger heeft een wat typisch geluid, maar typisch hoeft niet altijd verkeerd te zijn. Hij zet met relatief simpele liedjes toch een lekker sfeertje neer. Ik vind niet elk nummer super ('Poughkeepsie' vind ik bijvoorbeeld een irritante), maar over het algemeen vind ik dit wel een leuk album om te leren kennen. Waar ik wel tegenaan loop, is dat deze meneer een hoop te vertellen heeft. Misschien wel iets teveel voor mij. Ik geef het wel 4 sterren want ik vind het leuk om dit zo te ontdekken, maar het is wel een 4 met wat bramen (de scherpe onvolkomenheden, niet het fruit) eraan.

Something different. Some cool guitar work and can see where some modern folk/slow rock might have taken inspiration. Annoying after the first half though and felt like I was listening to the same finger picking over again crossed with the high pitched voice made it a bit jarring. Not his best work

Not for me at all. There is some utter rubbish on this album. Poughkeepsie is a terrible song. There's a difference between being experimental and progressive, and just being bland and boring and hiding it behind intentionally abstract lyricism and discordant singing. Nothing in this album wasn't done a million times over by a thousand other artists. The lyricism barely makes up for it... There are songs in the middle and latter half of the album that are more tolerable, in so far as the songs are composed as soundscapes. Banhart is weaker as a musical force when he is alone with the guitar. That feels almost blasphemous to say considering his clear skill with the acoustic, but it's the truth. Adding other layers really does bring about a better vibe to the music, makes it seem more whole, more Western, more American. Which is ultimately the goal of this music. I wish he would have done that more. Fall is a great example of it done right. Bland, boring Americana tbh. He is not Swans, no matter how much he tries to be. All the ideas are stale, and despite the great production there is little else to shout and scream about with this album. Won't be getting much time on my playlists. A Sight To Behold is a gem though. One of only a couple songs that makes this album a 2 and not a 1.

Ultimately not all that interesting. I didn't find it to be bad, but I wasn't left with any resounding idea or feeling from it aside from it being just okay or kinda eh. rating:4.0/10

Strangely compelling in small doses.

To folksy for me, with very weird lyrics. Not my kind of music.

First reviewed in 2005 No real standout tracks for me, folk/acoustic Its ok 2.5 36%

I do like "A Sight to Behold." Something about his sound there is the version of his voice I like best. Sometimes he's too gentle for my typical mood; he reminds me of Sufjan Stevens in that way — when I'm in the right mood, it's exactly the right thing, but that's not most of the time.

Strum strum, sing sing strum strum If you want to listen to this type of music just listen to Big Thief. Lack luster but not bad. Just less than mid for sure

The vocal reminded me a little of Marc Bolan in places, but that’s about as far as the comparison goes. Everything here feels incredibly basic — the songwriting, the arrangements, even the performances. Most of the tracks seem to follow the same sparse formula, and after a while it starts to feel less like a finished album and more like someone sitting down with a guitar and making it up as they go along. There’s a certain charm to that kind of simplicity, but for me it wore thin very quickly. I couldn’t wait for it to end. 1½

All a bit forcibly twee

471/1102 okay faith-based folk guitar man??? Dogs They Make Up In The Dark was pretty cool but WAYYYY too short wth okay so this one started a bit ??? but by the end i was pretty well in board. it had some really nice moments and i ended up liking the shorter song lengths faves: insect eyes, autumn child, when the sun shone on vetiver, tit smoking…, rejoicing in the hands 73/100

I know I Feel Just Like A Child from one of his later albums and that's a bit more rowdy than this. I was hoping for a bit more energy and some fun. If I want minimalist guitar playing with with quirky lyrics and an outside aesthetic Vic Chesnutt is my go to I went down a Vic rabbit hole straight after finishing this and he is still very missed. It's a light three for Devendra because there's something interesting here it's just not quite hitting the mark.

Overall solid and enjoyed it more than I thought but his voice did get grating at times 3

Enjoyable listen. Feels very of its time -- I listened to the "freak folk" bands at the time, but hadn't listened to this one in full. Not something I'd probably listen to in full. but a few songs definitely stand up.

Weird folk. Don't think it's for me.

ive heard this before. i didnt like it then and i dont like it now, though i will admit i liked it more than i remembered. maybe after 3 or 4 more listens ill find it tolerable. as it stands its like dylan was a better guitarist and somehow an even worse singer.

XPN would always tell us when Devendra Banhart was playing locally. But they never played his music. Probably because people who like his music would want to know he was around and go see him live and everyone else didn’t want to hear his music at all. There’s some singers from this era and of this style that I really like. He’s not one of them.

A lovely little slice of folk rock. 4.5 bumped up to 5.

I’m at a 4. This album feels like finding someone else’s tattered diary in your dreams. It is incredibly abstract, in ways that feel mysterious at times, clear at others, and yet there’s never really anything that feels solved throughout. That said, it’s generally calming, and you can tell Devendra’s got a good, positive head on his shoulders. I’m pretty sure that the first track establishes that he’s the type to look on the bright side even when the world has given him every off ramp to choose the negative side, and it reaffirms that throughout the album. In totality, these tracks feel loosely centered around a zest for the gift of life & being grateful that we can even feel pain to begin with. It doesn’t diminish the impact of that pain, and I’d argue it even leans into nihilism at times. It’s generally looking towards the light, though. Of course, this is all from my interpretations of these tracks. I only think I have a framework for half of them. It’s why I called it a tattered diary; there’s nothing overly concrete here. Take a track like “Will Is My Friend”; I think it’s about getting lost in the past, with very loose connective strands of memories that create a rabbithole. One thing leads to another, and then you’ve got to snap your brain back to the original memory you were trying to express in the first place. Even if that feels right, I can’t say for sure. That applies to most of the album. Some of them are more lighthearted; “Rejoicing in the Hands” struck me as a child waiting for their mother to hold them after a long night. Some are darker, like “Insect Eyes” seemingly being about a relationship where an evil twist is inevitable, even if I can’t tell who corrupted who. The thing that makes this album really work is entirely in the vocal performance adding onto that dreamy vibe; this is recorded in a way that feels localized. The echo in the room, the lack of extra bombast (for the most part), & the homely guitar throughout all accentuate the dynamic approach in his vocals. It makes for an interesting listen, even if you can’t really comprehend what the fuck he means at times. I think this album has a handful of weak spots where it’s just not as interesting & a bit too confusing to really feel captivated. “Poughkeepsie” & “See Saw” are probably the two that bit at me the worst. When the abstract stuff works, it really works; “Fall” & “When the Sun Shone on Vetiver” both felt like highlights to me, even though I can’t really tell you what either are about. The main reason I’m at a 4 is because the album doesn’t make the strongest first impression in its opening tracks, plus it feels a little long & a little same-y throughout. I think a few tracks could’ve tightened up their structures too, as there’s little pitfalls of looping guitar patterns that feel noticeable at times. All of that said, I found myself charmed by the end of it. It’s a tattered diary, yes, but it feels like one you’d find in a dream with the coziest sleep you’ve ever had. Devendra just does something here that mostly makes it a compelling listen, save for a few tracks. Hence, a 4. I think it earns a place on the list, if only to challenge a listener a bit.

I don't know what to do here. I was so confused as to what I was listening to ...Folk? 60's? Alternative? I forced myself to listen twice just to see if I was missing something? Nope.

description sounded cooler than it was.

He's been a good artist over the years. Don't think any albums stand out though.

That first one and the last one are just wildddddd and so, so calming. Next time, I'll get me a cup of chicken noodle imma say "this is the soup that I believe in". well done. not sure it deserves 5 stars but I don't want it to get buried beneath the long list of 4s either so ill give it a 5. Drink: if a bunch of cannolis were blended up, put into a smoothie, and then topped with mint pieces.

Easy guitar music

Some of it was really good and some of it was really weird. Seems like an excellent musician.

A Sight to Behold

sometimes interesting, sometimes annoying. not sure why he sings that way....it's weird. I'm also confused how this album belongs on a list of albums you need to hear before you die.

Chill and aight

This is an overall pretty chill album, surprisingly from this millennium. I enjoyed leaving it in the background while I was doing other things and even the least-listened-to songs were actually pretty enjoyable.

I recognized the name, but can’t seem to find the particular song or reason why. I think you’ve got to be in the right mood for an album like this, it was just okay.

One of those acoustic albums that could have been recorded during Frieren's adventures. I can't get behind the voice and there aren't a lot of catchy melodies to stick to here (2.5).

Tää oli ihana! Varmasti jää kuunteluun. Jotain Nick Drake-vibaa mikä oli tosi miellyttävää. Rauhallista, mukavaa

Beautiful guitar paired with the most annoying singing voice I have heard outside of the 80's

I actually kind of like this. It's very reminiscent of that era of alternative music, and hit right on a Monday morning. Maybe not worthy of the list, but I liked it overall. 4*. As a spanish speaker, I found "todo los dolores" hard to listen to. It was like a preschooler throwing spanish words he knew together into a children's song. Highlights: fall

Brilliant and original. Need to revisit.

This record didn't grab me in anyway. Might as well have been musak, for all I know it is... One

Pleasant

gar nicht schlecht

*Rejoicing...* is dull folk rock that's been done dozens of times before, and better. If Banhart at least had an interesting voice or exceptional guitar skills this album might have had a chance but that isn't the case here.

This makes me feel like a mouse or perhaps a vole.

A little boring

Wow is this man's voice so annoying, one song in I thought I could be into it but 4 songs in and I want to drop him down a well

I fw the lyrics on this album. It's simple but evocative, in a word very folksy v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-v-iva las vegas!

I LOVE dudes with weird voices typically. This however was the exception that proved the rule.

This is amazing. Everything about it is unique. His voice reminds me of James Blunt and also Tim Buckley at times. Will definitely be returning. Also, a well timed album for fall Edit: It’s five stars for me now!

I had a hard time getting past that this guy sounded exactly like Alt-J but wasn't Alt-J, but Devendra came out first so I have to give him credit for the sound. I liked it at first, it was unique and funky, a new spin on an old pschadelic sound. I don't love psychadelic rock but i appreciated turning it into a fresh millenial sound. But after a while the voice just became all I heard and I don't know if it really added anything or just tried to take over.

This was really pretty. He has an avant-garde vibe, but it's in just the right dose for me. Weird enough to be interesting and intriguing, but not so weird that it loses me. It had a cozy comfort factor that drew me in too.

Fine bit hippy dippy

A lovely surprise! Folky and funky; dark but still light. Reminds me of Rhiannon Giddens. Really beautiful. This is a keeper! A 5, on the first listen.

It’s gonna be a no for me, dawg.

Number: 269 Familiarity: Moderate (3) Rating: 4 Before: ======= Hm, I have to admit I'm kind of surprised to see Devendra Banhart on this list. I'm a little familiar with him as I have exactly one song by him in my favorites by years lists, and that is from his 2016 album, Fig in Leather. During: ======= Two songs in now and I am liking what I'm hearing. Like I said, I'm a little familiar with his music and most likely skimmed through this album a few years ago when putting together my favorites by years lists. I apparently didn't find much from him then that I liked that much. However, I have been more interested in Folk/Americana/Alt Country in recent times and this kind falls in that realm... After : ======= Overall it's a decent album, not really 1001 list material though, imo. I did add one song to my 2004 list, "Fall", mainly as a reminder for the next time I evaluate that list, to come back and listen to this album. It seems like something that would get better with repeated listens...My overall rating comes to 3.55, so I guess I'll give it a 4.

Rejoicing In The Hands was an album that i'm not a huge fan of. Honestly, i thought that this album was going to be older than it actually is due to that album art but the production definitely gives the vibe of an album from 2004. That being said, my major issue with this album is Banhart's vocals. They just have that really annoying vibrato and are just not the clearest. The lyrics in some of the songs are kinda weird too. That is a shame though because musically, this album is very solid. It's minimalist while still doing enough to keep me interested. If it weren't for the vocals, i'm sure i would have liked this album but they are the main thing that's dragging it way down. Best Song: Autumn's Child Worst Song: See Saw

Devendra Banhart, unexpected. But cool! Have listened to his Mala album loads of times, which is a 4-5 star one. This, however, was a bit of a disappointment. But then again I've tried getting into other albums than Mala, but failed to, apart from some stellar songs here and there. So I guess it's not too unexpected. The album has Devendra's trademark vibrato and breaking voice. You also have some guitar tunes that take unexpected turns with unorthodox chords, which is common to him. Still, I felt like no song really grabbed hold of me. It's definitely beautiful, but I think I get a bit tired of hearing a whole album with just song and acoustic guitar. It lacks in the percussive department for sure.

Man, I would have loved this when I got into folk in the late 00s. It reminded me a lot of Bright Eyes, but with less teenage angst. There’s something about the lo-fi production that I really enjoy, and it reminded me why I fell in love with the genre in the first place. It felt nostalgic, even though I don’t think I’ve listened to this album before. It feels like it came fairly early in the 00s–10s folk revival. I enjoyed the simple guitar playing, which reminded me a bit of the arrangements on early Leonard Cohen records. The vocals work quite well, but the vibrato gets slightly annoying after a while. 3 stars.

a rainy morning in central japan proves wonderful ambience for this strange, shaggy record. Banhart is at times excruciating - his Jeff Buckley trills on the opening track, the hippie-machismo growl he puts on on See Saw - but so are we all, and like us all he can often be beguiling, scary, earnest. like fewer of us, he's an excellent guitarist, which is a nice way into his music if you find the voice a bit much. i got over it in a few tracks, and was comfortably within Banhart's shagadelic world, ears pricking particularly up for simpler tracks like Will Is My Friend and Todo Los Dolores. i am pretty far from in love with his whole thing, but was also surprised by how agreeable i found it all with a cup of coffee and the temperatures falling, a mood wherein i could feel a little closer to the record's insular world

A very good album. I’d heard of this band on KCRW but this was my first real listen

I started off liking this a little. The first three tracks fit my mood for the day. It starts kinda sparse and sullen, with a pinch of melancholy. But then it just kept going.. and going. This isn't the longest album we've had -- not by a long shot -- but damned if it wasn't a chore. I think this guy's warbling voice gimmick quickly ran it's course with me. I love the movie "Eagle vs. Shark" and recognized the one track from it. That song fits the mood and tone of the movie, at that point IN the movie, perfectly. Congrats. But a whole album of this? Tiresome and tedious. Secondly, is this album 'essential'?? Absolutely and emphatically **NOT**. More filler from Dimery and co. I'm beginning to cement the idea in my mind that music from the mid-00s through the 10s is either a) categorically worse than the music that came before it (have we run out of ideas?) <or> b) I'm a grouchy old man who doesn't have the capacity to like anything newer than late 90s/early 00s stuff.. It's one of those two things. (2/5), but only because I'm trying to give this crap a chance.

I tried. I really, really tried. There is some pretty impressive guitar on this one, and it has a throwback sound that at times belies its 2004 release, reminiscent of Cat Stevens, Jim Croce or Frank Zappa. But the singing and lyricism here is absolute buns, stuffed to the gills with pseudo-intellectual, proto-philosophical hot garbage, and I found myself more and more annoyed with it as it went on. By "There Was Sun," all benefit of doubt was withdrawn, and I was unable to finish each of the remaining tracks. For its instrumentation alone I wanted to give it at least a 2/5, but find it difficult to round up to there.

6. Rejoicing In The Hands - Devendra Banhart (2004) 9.26.26 Variety: 1 Adequacy: 3 Listenability: 2 Uniqueness: 1 Emotionality: 1 = 1.6 rounded up to a 2 "And the breast on her chest is where I take my rest/ Is where I have my fun/ Is where I have my fun/ Mm hmm hmm hmm" To my knowledge I've never heard more than a snippet of this guy's music. I've always gotten strong modern hippie vibes off of him ( I've made my loathing of the whole hippie vibe apparent on previous reviews. Theoretically, given my social and poitical views you would thing I would align quite well with this worldview, but alas, no - I find the culty, shiftless, hedonistic stuff to be gross and offputting in the extreme) which doesn't make for a good starting off spot. Strike number two is that he ( along with Suftjan Stevens, who I have similar issues with) has been a favorite amongst several people I know who I will not describe otherwise except to say they have very untrustworthy taste. Strike number three is that not only do I get hippie vibes off of him, even worse is those vibes are of the crunchy granola, yoga mat, man-bun variety. Going completely out on a limb here, he gives the vibe of someone raised in a weird culty southern California commune/ sect, and probably has failed actor parents who sent him to the school from Billy Jack. (Edit: had to look this up, and based on what little info I could find his mother was a model, and the family did follow some spiritual guru. However he's from Texas originally and only later moved to California. But still - pretty good guesses, right?). All this said, I usually like to go into an album giving the artist the benefit of the doubt. Someone in my group suggest that I likely start at a 4, and would agree with that. These albums made the cut, as subjective as it was, so there are apparently a lot of people who see the artistic merit. Then, depending on how things go they can move up or down that ladder as I listen. Let's see if I can clear my mind of all preconceived notions, remove myself from the earthly plane, focus on my mantra ,and open up my third eye to make myself receptive to some more positive vibes... THE TRACKS "This Is the Way" - Hmmm. Not off to a great start. Despite my slight exaggeration in the intro, I do in fact have some tolerance for hippie shit. If it's good. I love me some Cat Stevens for example. The Grateful Dead I've grown to appreciate more and more. This is exactly the sort of thing I expected to hear. It's cloying and precious, but not in a charming way. A lot of it has to do with Banhart's voice. He sounds like an elderly goblin doing an Al Jolson impersonation. That affected curling of his vowels ( could this be considered cursive singing? and the warbling stutter he adds did nothing to endear me to the brand of folk he's selling. "A Sight to Behold" - Atmosphere on this was good, and leaned towards something a bit epic in nature with the strings and intense acoustic guitar work, but damn that voice... "The Body Breaks" - This one started off very pretty, and felt like it was going in maybe amore whimsical playful direction, but no such luck. It was all schmaltzy romance vibes. Also, ewww... Is this a song about Davendra's sexy times? No thanks. With those vocals I'm picturing David the Gnome and his wife Lisa getting it on. "Poughkeepsie" - The count in on this just made it more annoying somehow, but the guitar work and even the melody was ok on this one. The pronunciation of floor as "flar" rhyming with door pronounced "dar". Jesus, dude. You are not in a 1930s Betty Boop cartoon. I could see someone like Joanna Newsome pulling this off and doing the instrumentation justice maybe. Will have to split the difference on the quality here. "Dogs They Make Up the Dark" - This one felt, well... darker. The guitar melody here slowed down and with some colder production might would not feel completely out of place on an Allogach album, which is impressive. And it's the shortest track on the album, which automatically puts it in running for the best! Which even makes the vocals far less distracting. "Will Is My Friend" - I get it, you really want this to have a homey, live feel. The warm, hissy production is doing all that work for you. We don't need any more countdowns. Oh my god, the affected vocals are even worse on this one. Is this just what he sounds like? Am I being cruel about a grown man's speech impediment? Am I a bully? I'm ok with that. I'm sure this guy is a millionaire many times over ( somehow) and this does not feel like punching down. "This Beard Is for Siobhán" - His voice actually works ok here. He's using the kind of old 1920s jazz phrasing and the guitar is approximating the sort of "every song is a novelty song" feel of the stuff from that period. It borders on charming. Just. I'd so much rather listen to Andrew Bird if I want some old timey nostalgia music. I'll give him his props here though. "See Saw" - So close my man. Just take a bit more English off of those vowels but keep the folkie forest troll vibes and this could actually maybe be kind of haunting and pretty. "Tit Smoking in the Temple of Artesan Mimicry" - What a title. This better be hilarious or super pretentious to live up to expectations. But what's this? A song where I don't have to listen to him sing! This was fine. It's fine. Worth 1:25 of real estate though? "Rejoicing in the Hands" - Oooh. He can sing like a normal person. I'm guessing he toned things down when he found out a legit minor folk legend agreed to sing a duet with him. This kind of makes me hate the other stuff even more knowing it could have been much better. This was pretty, if slight, and benefitted enormously from Vashti Bunyan's participation. Of you listen to any of the recommendations at the bottom, at least listen to this track by her, which blows anything on this album out of the water: "Train Song" by Vashti Bunyan: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hswWRRk4vAo&list=OLAK5uy_nisrHSVgxesojmebWjHnC1_peHtqs0EN8&index=3 "Fall"- More good guitar, and even some percussion. I am so sick of his voice though at this point I'm tolerating the full runtimes of the songs. To skip them would feel like defeat. "Todos los Dolores" - More count offs! Sure , ok. oh, HAHAHAHA how charming, they left in the fuck up! Man, this Davendra guy is so authentic and natural. I'm sure that wasn't rehearsed several times. I'm impressed you can sing in Spanish. Truly. It does make his vocals a bit less awful, but not enough to matter much. Very off putting presentation in that it was trying to give demo vibes. "When the Sun Shone on Vetiver" - Nope. "There Was Sun" - An attempt at some old timey blues is admirable, but the delivery was borderline unbearable. This sounds like a song Jack White would do as a joke in between real songs to amuse the recording engineers. "Insect Eyes" - more blues folk, somewhat less offensive, but I really didn't need to hear Davendra's sexy voice, on the "Mm hmm hmm hmm" part which sounds like Yoda got into Luke's BlueChew stash. "Autumn's Child" - This was awful AND boring. Let Lana Del Rey re-record this and maybe you're on to something. HIGHLIGHTS - "Dogs They Make Up the Dark" - "This Beard Is for Siobhán" - "Rejoicing in the Hands" MIDLIGHTS - "Poughkeepsie" - "See Saw" - "Tit Smoking in the Temple of Artesan Mimicry" LOWLIGHTS - "This Is the Way" - "A Sight to Behold" - "The Body Breaks" - "Will Is My Friend" - "Fall" - "Todos los Dolores" - "When the Sun Shone on Vetiver" - "There Was Sun" - "Insect Eyes" FINAL THOUGHTS This all sort of blended together for me into a very samey stew, with no memorable melodies to speak of and nothing to disabuse me of any of my presupposed notions. On top of that, I grew to hate Barnhart's voice. I have to ask myself who is this music even for? Without getting too mean, I suspect there are legions of crystal collecting, essential oil using, Starbucks moms who love this thing, and more power to them I guess. I'm wracking my brain to try and think of anything positive to say about it. Okay, his guitar playing was quite good throughout, even if I didn't find much of it catchy enough to differentiate from track to track. The production is warm and all around good, and this does indeed feel like a professional attempt at ... something. I don't get the sense that Banhart is trolling or trying to be annoying or offensive or anything. The fact that he committed these boring, unmemorable tracks the record convinces me that he must have thought this was some good shit. That sort of misguided artistic intent at least keeps him out of the 1-star club, reserved for cynical assholes and the bafflingly untalented. Nothing on here makes me want to ever explore the man's discography anu further though, and it fully misses me in any sort of pleasurable way. This is the type of music I would expect to hear playing at an overpriced vegan cafe, so it has it's place in the music ecosystem. But it's just not my thing, and I think even as a representative of its kind, it falls well short. I'm sure there is a version of this sort of thing I could at least respect, if not like, but this is not it. And this is at least 75% or more because of his voice. Bjork can get away with this stuff, but c'mon man, you're from Texas. Possible turn-Offs might include: - grating, affected vocals - very dumb lyrics - strong hippie folk vibes You Might enjoy this if you: - larp as a gnomish alchemist, and need some inspirational music to psyche you up before a session - are not very picky about what you listen to PLAYLIST ALTERATIONS - none of this is for me FURTHER LISTENING Precursors: - Some Things Just Stick in Your Mind – Singles and Demos 1964 to 1967 by Vashti Bunyan - Starsailor by Tim Buckley - Basket of Light by Pentangle Contemporaries: - Andrew Bird & the Mysterious Production of Eggs Andrew Bird - Transfiguration of Vincent by M. Ward - I See a Darkness by Bonnie Prince Billie - The Creek Drank the Cradle by Iron & Wine - by Andrew Bird - The Milk-Eyed Mender by Joanna Newsom - Descendants: - Chemtrails over the Country Club by Lana Del Rey - Thunder Follows the Light by Mutual Benefit - I Need to Start a Garden by Haley Heynderickx - Moon in Gemini by Isik Kural

There is some outstanding guitar picking on this album. I usually will love an acoustic guitar like this. I enjoyed the instrumental track, which tells you about the rest of the album. Yeah, all of the good guitar bits are wasted on the cringiest song writing I’ve yet encountered on this project and we’ve had albums by Morrissey, 10cc, and The Happy Mondays. Also, I recoiled from whatever this dude was trying to do with his voice on most of the tracks. Overall, not a good album experience. 1/5

I quite liked this. Easy to listen to.

hipster w4nk music made for hipster w4nkers!

Was anyone else reminded of José Gonzalez, Bon Iver and Elliott Smith when listening to the first half of the album? It's good, but there are other acoustic folk albums you should listen to before Rejoicing In The Hands. Overall: 4/10

Dime a dozen album. If not for the democratisation of music production in the late 90s/ early 00s we probably don't get albums like this. Would we be worse off? The quivering vocal is painful. 2/5.

Too überhipster. He’d get more traction if he didn’t ham it up.

"Psychedelic Folk". This is interesting and unique, but still not great. Not sure why this is on the list. Pitchfork: 8.5 Rolling Stone: n/a