I’m pretty sure I had this on cassette tape given to me by an Aunt

This should have been on the main list 4.5

I’m pretty sure my mum played the hell out of this when I was a kid, it is so familiar! Prog can either be good or absolutely awful this is good stuff

Just too nice and not interesting

Some occasional annoying vocals bring this down to a 4.5 Unironically great

I’m pretty sure my mum played the hell out of this when I was a kid, it is so familiar! Prog can either be good or absolutely awful this is good stuff

Nice but didn’t grip me

Sorry Bruce I just don’t get you

Just too nice and not interesting

It may have failed on release but this is one of those albums that spread’s influence far and wide. A 10/10 classic

As someone who is an indie music enjoyer the hype on this was massive and I just never got it. It has some interesting hooks and melodies but I never felt it was a good and cohesive as everyone said.

I have never understood why he is lionised as some sort of guitar genius. He’s good but the songs all blend together and nothing grabs me

Never heard of this guy and I live in the town he grew up in! Interesting work I enjoyed it but I don’t feel drawn to listen again

Hadn’t heard this and somehow knew they were Australian. Fun listen

Danish and alternative rock sounds like it doesn’t belong in the same sentence but this was great. So far the people who have added albums have done a much better job than the actual official list!

Obscure and British are 2 things I typically love and there is a lot to love with this!

Reminded me of elvis Costello

I saw this and thought ffs who put a joke album in this list. But how wrong I was, annoyingly great songs, a little over produced but I guess that’s the genre 3.5 as the back half drags a little

I was entranced by her vocals, the music was good and I will delve into this artist’s catalog

It’s ok, nice vibe singer has a good voice but didnt inspire me to check out more of their work or re listen

I have heard of ween but mostly as a joke band but this was great!

I’m pretty sure I had this on cassette tape given to me by an Aunt

Almost triphop like. I was in the mood for an album like this so the timing was impeccable

Being a man in my 40s seeing this made me think I would be listening to some generic pop crap, but I was wrong. I thoroughly enjoyed this

On paper this should appeal to me, I’m a GenXer into rock, punk, post hardcore but this just doesn’t quite land right for me. It has some good parts but the whole feels lacking. I will re listen but my hopes aren’t high

This should have been been on the original list!

This should have been on the main list 4.5

I recognised one of the songs but no idea where from. This was good

Too long would have been a solid 3/5 but jus keeps going

One of the great albums they have produced. The best thing about them is if you don’t like this one wait until the next one as they are ridiculously prolific and not tied to any particular genre

I thought this was a joke addition but it is pretty catchy pop and it’s fun. I will never listen to it again though!!

Feels over produced but some great songs hidden below the production

Indie folk and west end musicals are not my thing so this is not my thing

Some occasional annoying vocals bring this down to a 4.5 Unironically great

I generally don’t like live albums and it turns out I definitely don’t like live albums by phish

I went backpacking around the world in 2005/6 and this album was played everywhere and all the worst people I met were always talking about how this was “real music made by a real musician” I always thought it was shit