New York Dolls by New York Dolls

New York Dolls

New York Dolls

3.12
Rating
24115
Votes
1
5%
2
20%
3
42%
4
25%
5
8%
Distribution

Album Summary

New York Dolls is the debut album by the American hard rock band New York Dolls. It was released on July 27, 1973, by Mercury Records. In the years leading up to the album, the Dolls had developed a local fanbase by playing regularly in lower Manhattan after forming in 1971. However, most music producers and record companies were reluctant to work with them because of their vulgarity and onstage fashion as well as homophobia in New York; the group later appeared in exaggerated drag on the album cover for shock value. After signing a contract with Mercury, the Dolls recorded their first album at The Record Plant in New York City with producer Todd Rundgren, who was known for his sophisticated pop tastes and held a lukewarm opinion of the band. Despite stories of conflicts during the recording sessions, lead singer David Johansen and guitarist Sylvain Sylvain later said Rundgren successfully captured how the band sounded live. The resulting music on the album – a mix of carefree rock and roll, influences from Brill Building pop, and campy sensibilities – explores themes of urban youth, teen alienation, adolescent romance, and authenticity, as rendered in Johansen's colloquial and ambiguous lyrics. New York Dolls was met with widespread critical acclaim but sold poorly and polarized listeners. The band proved difficult to market outside their native New York and developed a reputation for rock-star excesses while touring the United States in support of the album. Despite its commercial failure, New York Dolls was an influential precursor to the 1970s punk rock movement as the group's crude musicianship and youthful attitude on the album challenged the prevailing trend of musical sophistication in popular music, particularly progressive rock. Among the most acclaimed albums in history, it has since been named in various publications as one of the best debut records in rock music and one of the greatest albums of all time.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Solid. I don’t have many comments negative or positive.

NINETEEN SEVENTY THREE?!?! PUNK AND GLAM IN 1973!! This is awesome

Some occasionally odd production/sound choice decisions, but I still dig it

Well, another glam punk rock band from New York. They all sound so similar. They might have been influential back then, but in retrospect, they're just one of many.

I imagine this played much better in 1973, and I probably would have loved it had I been born 20 years earlier. Hard to really get into it for the first time in 2026, but it definitely gets a "thank you for your service" and that's enough to round up. 3.5

Whole lotta people run their god damn mouths about how drag queens are ruining the fabric of America but everyone’s awfully quiet about all the dudes who dressed up as women to “rock out” during the 70s and 80s.

Really captures a certain era of New York

See, the thing is, I can see how influential it was. But it's not that great in the Big 26 we are currently suffering thru.

The first two tracks are classics. The rest is kind of good. 'Frankenstein' sounds like a glam-proto-post--punkish thing, which is nice. ★★★½

Just feels like another rock album. Nothing out of the ordinary.

Vocals are… not great. I see the inspiration for better artists in the sound and look, but the punk sound just isn’t for me 🙁 Favourite tracks: Trash, Frankenstein

i liked it but some songs felt a bit repetitive

The song Trash actually got stuck in my head for a day or so, pretty catchy

lovely planet boy my fav and also subway train. i have to be in a specific mood but i appreciated it i feel like live performance would be insane. i really liked the guitar parts and the last bit of the album was the best 🤌

nah. was expecting something different, something better than this. my expectations were definitely too high tho. some tracks were just okay. the rest was just bad. maybe i was in the wrong mood but i actually struggled to finish the album. it honestly sucked. the lyrics are pretty mid and predictable, and i just couldnt get into it. guitars cool. top3; trash, personality crisis, looking for a kiss

Enjoyed this and was in the right mood to listen which always helps. I like the energy of it, his voice and guitar, but no songs massively stood out and lost interest more towards the end

So torn on this. Really liked some of the songs and I definitely vibed whilst listening to it. But the album just isn’t strong enough and I wouldn’t be going back to the album over and over again

I didn’t mind this, very fun with some good electric guitar riffs. I’m super tired rn so I don’t think I’m in the correct mood to listen to this album. I feel like if I was more energetic this would work better for me and tbh I do think it would make a good gym record, the guys voice has a lot of grit and passion in it. I do think I would listen at least one more time but probably not after that. 3.0223/4

Medio raro, no le puse mucha atención.

I can see where this is going in the musical future and the cover is fucking dope. It just didn't hit all the way for me.

Enjoyed this. A bit of its time but you can still see the influence in so many following bands. Great stuff

70's glam scene snapshot

The first song is the best and the rest is fine. I like the energy. Feels important.

some good ol' rock and roll. not the most adventurous or memorable but keeps up a nice energy. favorite song is Frankenstein. soft 3

This albums sounds so much like the Stones. It's quite fun. Four stars

Cunty as album cover

You might call them glam based on their aesthetics, but damn, this is a hardcore rock album. It’s packed with cool 60s throwback piano hooks and killer guitar solos. This is a badass debut that comes roaring right out of the gate—grimy, raw, and completely in-your-face. You can hear its DNA all over later punk and garage-hardcore bands like The Candy Snatchers, Big Bobby & The Nightcaps, and Nashville Pussy. Utterly youthful and unapologetically rebellious.

Much stronger than I expected, and a lot stronger than some of the "I'm cool because I like this" picks on the list. You can hear how the Sex Pistols just imported their style and sang about British punk things. The guitar playing is really good. Not really my kind of music, but I'm impressed. On the other hand, it feels like they were not that innovative. I mean, other than the glam, isn't this just MC5?

Eh... It's ok proto punk. Songs aren't super memorable. Like a less good version of Kiss or Richard Hell. Guess they came first though so yeah...

It’s iconic for a reason. Kicks of with Personality Crisis and never lets up. At times the songs sound like second rate stones but that rates pretty good to me

This album cover is so 70s ragebait, cause the music sounds like early David Bowie and Iggy Pop. Within the context of prog rock, I like how unserious it is. But I've heard this sound already so it doesn't pack as much of a punch as I wish that album cover must have done in the 70s.

This was disappointing. Based on the genre, era, and album cover, I thought this'd be great. But hardly a standout in the bunch. I did quite enjoy "Lonely Planet Boy" which gave me Kinks vibes. 2.5/2.75

this was fun, the doll fathers of punk!

Good rock energy

Es ist ein herrlich verwilderter Startschuss für alles, was später Punk, Glam und sleaze‑iger Rock’n’Roll werden sollte. Die Band stolpert, stolziert und explodiert durch diese Songs, als gäbe es kein Morgen – roh, schmutzig, aber voller Charme. „Personality Crisis“ ist ein sofortiger Klassiker, „Trash“ ein melodischer Straßenköter mit Herz. Das Album ist nicht makellos, aber genau diese Unfertigkeit macht seinen Reiz aus. Ein frühes, grelles Juwel des Chaos.

I kinda wish I’d like this. But meh mostly.

Glammy pronto-punk that is a glorious, and sometimes hilarious, mess.

Really interesting music. Sounded much more modern than I anticipated. Easy to listen to and easy to enjoy

It’s good. Definitely that punk precursor. Sometimes it fades away more into classic rock and it loses me a bit there. I wish it was sleazier sometimes.

This is not for me. I'm immediately not interested in this style of punk singing that feels like Mick Jagger, all off-key and forced. Aside from that, I keep finding fault in the mixing - it's all just a bit messy. I have certain base-line expectations from an album, and not matter how iconic I might be told it is, sometimes we've just moved on and I can't get much out of it in 2026. Trash is fun but also... mixed like a dog's breakfast.

This band may have been more famous for the way they dressed and their makeup instead of their music

NY Dolls were massive! The forefathers of punk, glam rock, big hair .. gritty sound - all of this happening in 1971 !?

This is "cool" when you are young and before technology took over. It's full of energy, surprises, and a deep sense of belonging to something underground. You didn't know what all was out there but when you found it - wow!

The first band I remember hearing of before actually hearing them. And when I finally heard them - you better believe I was in love L-U-V. Sure it's trashy Stones with a side of Shangri-Las and sloppy helping of Bo Diddley. Don't hate them because they are having a better time than you are. An album that got me out of bed in high school and still sounds awesome - credit to Todd Rundgren for capturing a moment and corralling these boys before they self destructed and splintered across the rock n roll universe. 6 stars.

Not as heavy as I expected but ok to an extent.

Ah, the massively hyped New York Dolls. I guess you had to be there at the time to feel any innovation and shock. I can only trust how much influence they have been credited with.

Highly influential glammy proto punk, all scruffy around the edges. These misfits had lots of energy and must have had fun making this record. Ahead of its time and was to become part of the blueprint for the emerging punk counter-culture of the 70's. Great stuff.

Sure, this album isn’t that good. But without this album the world would never have gotten the incredibly important albums that it led to that forever changed popular music. Namely, 1987’s Buster Poindexter, 1989’s Buster Goes Berserk, 1994’s Buster's Happy Hour and 1997’s Buster's Spanish Rocketship. Without this album, novelty salsa/jump blues songs and the portrayal of the Ghost of Christmas Past in Scrooged would have never been the same.

Didn't feel glamourous enough to be good glam rock. Just not my cup of tea

Very fun. Better than t rex, similarly sleazy energetic blues rock, these boys just do it better.

There's lipstick on the collar of this record and cigarette burns in the carpet. It's gutter glamour, trashy and proud. Spins: 1 Playlist Additions - Personality Crisis - Looking for a Kiss - Trash

Reminds me of The Clash or the Ramones, perhaps a bit more punk? Eh? It’s ok. Didn’t really feel like listening to this today. (3)

Proto-punk, I suppose? Very raw. The music was OK, but the lead singer made my ears tired.

This was such a fun album. I knew them but didn't know them and not sure I have enjoyed something this much in a long while.

The is one is fun.

Ok cool I gotta listen to an album that inspired actually good albums instead of the actually good albums.

It’s good to great rock and roll. Just a bit too campy and tongue in cheek for me.

Curious that New York Dolls are not as famous as Ramones. Maybe it's the lack of good songwriting. Pills is pretty good. Also weird how present Buster Pointdexter was in late 80s pop culture.

Never listened to these guys and I can appreciate this as a precursor to a lot of scuzzy stuff that followed. Added to my library and I'll probably revisit. 3.49 stars.

Back during Napster's freewheeling heyday, I got my first real taste of the New York Dolls by downloading MP3s of "Personality Crisis" (loved it), "Trash" (ditto), and "Looking for a Kiss" (thought it was fine). Then I had my mind blown learning the singer was the Ghost of Christmas Past in Scrooged and was responsible for that terrible/catchy "Feelin' Hot Hot Hot" song. This album is a lot of fun—adding "Subway Train" to my favorites—and these dudes clearly knew how to have a good time. 4.5 stars.

Ok. Would've adored this in 1973, when I was 1

Fun album. Certainly deserves it place on the list as its pre Ramones, The Damned, KISS etc. 3/5.

👠💋💄🌃🚇

This was great!

I like the idea of the dolls more than the practice of the dolls

Это че за куколки такие

Like a messier Rolling Stones.

3,5 Highlights: Personality Crisis, Looking For A Kiss

Great example of why context matters. Had this been a 1983 album, the New York Dolls would just be another average punk-ish act among many others. But as a 1973 album, this is surprisingly modern and ahead of its time. Despite being still mired in the glam / proto-hard rock scene, it's also the blueprint for the punk movement. All the building blocks are here, from the simplistic but efficient instrumentals to the provocative attitude and cheerful silliness. It probably tooks real balls to dress like that on stage in 1973, when most rock bands were all about being über-manly men. It has aged well despite its flaws, and their influence is undeniable. It's not necessarily something I'd come back to, but that's only because I know what came after them. Had I been born in 1960, I would probably be a huge fan. I was going for a 3* at first, but I had so much fun listening that I guess I can bump them up a little bit. 6+1/10

Ha ha ha… I only knew them by name and imagery. Turns out it’s basically just rock ’n’ roll, but fun and genuinely exciting, with a surprisingly punk and masculine voice. The whole thing reeks of not taking itself seriously with vocal and musical dissonance, stupid lyrics, and overall it just made me laugh. There’s something gloriously dumb and chaotic about it. And you can seriously smell punk coming from a mile away.

Not bad. Enjoyable rock sound.

I don't like it. I feel dirty just having listened to it.

Overall: 8/10 Glam rock that borders on punk at times, this is a really fun album. I love the whole drag thing they have going on and these songs rock harder than I ever expected. Gonna be looking out for this one to buy on vinyl. Fav Song: Trash

A foundational album for punk but kind of a rough draft too

Punk rock ish

Glam-drag rock

You know what… this is a fun record, and even if it is kind of a drunken mess, a bunch of drunken cross dressers are supposed to sound like a fun drunken mess. Musically it’s a preview of the Ramones, and spiritually it’s a preview of Motley Cru and the like.

Thought it was going to be a 4 but didn't enjoy it all that much. Still, very influential, clearly!

I like the dolls and totally respect the influence they had on music from this era and afterwards. I've just never been able to really get into the band. Not bad, but just not great either.

Nice and punchy but nothing memorable

Fun, early punk. Didn't have a deep impact but liked it

Cool album. Doesn’t sound groundbreaking to me now, because we are so far removed from the time. Still sounds good though.

If it just came down to composition, there's an argument that New York Dolls are as much a rock band as they are a punk band. But just listen to those performances, look at that aesthetic. In all other ways, New York Dolls *ooze* punk. The songs *are* still great though. The lyrics are snotty and sarcastic, the vocals are surprisingly intense, and the structure is an early form of punk's ultra catchy, deconstructed rock. Also fascinating is how the members of New York Dolls seem to (by their own description) all be straight, but from what I know about them, it seems like they slotted into New York queer culture in an incredibly genuine way that I just have to respect. But yeah, it's sick proto punk, with great songs, great vibes, and oozing style, if you are gonna like this, you probably already know by this point.

I did not like it at all. It sounds like the Rolling Stones if the Rolling Stones were even worse than they already are.

It's wild having never heard this album but having heard many punk rock albums/songs that came after it -- I can only imagine how inspirational and revolutionary this must have sounded at the time. I love the 'fuck you' move of shooting their album cover in drag. I would've thought they were cool as hell if I was a teen when this came out. Not sure how much I'll return but Personality Crisis is pretty sticky

This is what I thought punk was before I started listening to all the punk on this list. This is the music that made me think I liked punk. More of this please.

I'm happy I was forced to listen to this for historical value, I'm happy The Smiths had the New York Dolls. Would I put it on again? probably not.

Fundamental, así de simple. Pioneros y geniales. Un disco esencial en la música, por calidad, por imagen y por todo lo que significó. Personality crisis y Trash deberían estar en cualquier listado de reproducción. Subway Train es otra joya, los Burning la habrán escuchado miles de veces.

Fun enough

This has been a fun album. Frankenstein was good. I thought maybe I had gotten one of these guys albums before but I guess not. I like the punk sound. It's like punk but also kind of like glam rock. I like the album cover they're all in drag lol. Good energy through out. 4 stars. This last track Jet Boy, I thought they were saying Devil Stole my baby lol

Dobar, sjeticu se nekad

Musically, it's kind of standard 70s rock/early punk. It's not really anything overly special or interesting. It is good, but it doesn't really stand out to me. I feel like their counterculture shock value is a big reason why they appear on this list, imo. None of their songs really stand out in a listen-through either. I had to go back through the album to try and find a favorite, and I felt like I *had* to pick one, so I just chose one that I knew was good throughout. I wish I could say that I thought it was more than just kind of mid, though. Favorite Song(s): Looking for a Kiss

behalve die ene trage, vond ik dit album best te pruimen... eigenlijk een 3,5 sterren

Great album, although not perfect, full of great tunes but also a couple of fillers. Still, it deserves five stars because its historical importance as a bridge between proto-punk (Velvet Unerground, Stooges) and Ramones and the rest of the CBGB crew.