Album Summary
The Dictators Go Girl Crazy! is the debut album by American punk rock band The Dictators. It was released on March 1975 and is considered one of the first examples of punk rock.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
This obviously is not needed. We do not need a "this is the first real punk album!" that isn't Ramones. The Stooges, New York Dolls, even The Velvet Underground (though for different reasons) deserve to be on here instead of this (thankfully all of those albums are on here, deservedly). This... is good enough as far as music, but necessary listening? Even for a punk fan I wouldn't say so. As for quality, it’s decently scant on that too. Boring riffs. Sufficient vocals. Early drum tones. Everything good on this album was done way better two years prior on the aforementioned eponymous New York Dolls outing. Everything bad on this album was worked out a year later into the rougher edges of the eponymous Ramones outing. Everything not punk on this album are the likes of things that both bands either brutalized (in the case of Ramones) or sleazified (in the case of New York Dolls), and what is left is something that is decidedly much worse than both of those albums. The distinct characteristics of this album are its hedonism and its lack of seriousness. Both of these are heels. The best punk music is angry, hard, and if it’s silly at all, it’s often combated by being heavy to the point of being near-unlistenable to the mainstream. This is not that. Consequently, I do not like it much at all, and it is of no importance to me. 3.9/10 DOES IT BELONG ON THE LIST: NO REASON: NOT SIGNIFICANT ENOUGH WHAT WOULD I REPLACE IT WITH: IDK THROW HOUSES OF THE HOLY ON THIS BITCH
Nope
Dumb raunchy fun in a fast, obnoxious garage rock package. I’m a sucker for this kind of stuff.
This is fun but not that essential and has aged poorly in many ways
Fun Fun Fun … and Dick is indeed very handsome
The Next Big Thing→8.5/10 I Got You Babe→8/10 Back to Africa→7/10 Master Race Rock→7/10 Teengenerate→7/10 California Sun→6/10 Two Tub Man→6/10 Weekend→8/10 (I Live For) Cars and Girls→7/10 best→The Next Big Thing worst→Two Tub Man overrated→California Sun underrated→Back to Africa overall→59/100 SHOULDN'T HEAR Can we just stop treating album that has nothing else but influence as if the entire human race should listen to! The band's sound isn't all that bad, but the vocals are so terrible you can't ignore them, and many of the lyrics aged awfully like milk.
Man, it’s just like, what’s the point? What is this offering? I felt like I wasted my time listening to this album.
Muito básico!
Better than I was expecting the beginning of punk to be.
they wrote the song that’s on every Santa Cruz beach boardwalk ad . That was very exciting for me to learn
A fun romp that grew on me as I listened.
Not sure what this was trying to be, but it came across as too unstructured and messy for my taste.
A little too punky and shouty of my liking. Tone and tune was often sacrificed for energy and attitude.
Oh man. No.
Oh man, what a load of idiotic crap. This isn't even punk! Seriously, cheesy rock. I'm really not surprised anymore by what ends up on this list. If this doesn't belong in the trash, then I don't know what does. The combination of Dictators, Handsome Dick Manitoba, and Crazy About Girls alone should be punishable by law and then maybe end up on a completely different list.
I’d love it if the songs were better. The songs being bad mean I couldn’t possibly give it 4 stars. A respectful 3 stars for these shit songs.
Ehhh
No es nada especial. Demasiadas versiones.
זה חמוד אבל זה הרגיש מזה לא קשור ליום שלי
Dickheads pretending to be meatheads ironically, playing late '50s/early '60s singalong rock songs with heavy Bronx/Queens accents in wrestling outfits. The song titles had me thinking they would be a little more edgelord than they ended up. "Back to Africa" is a lovesong with a *lightly* anticolonialist message. "Master Race Rock" is mostly just making fun of country boys and jocks. Half of the album is California surf rock from some guys I'm not sure had ever seen the West Coast. ✅️ STILL BANGS Favorite songs: (I Live For) Cars and Girls Next Big Thing I Got You Babe
There’s some good riffs here and there but overall this is not great. Hot take: Just because a band/album was the first to do something doesn’t mean it should make the list.
To tell you the truth, I anticipated very little after reading some reviews but ended up quite enjoying the whole thing. It's sort of like a watered down or less creative The Clash, but gets the benefit of being very short and pretty tight. I don't anticipate it getting major praise or anything but it was a pretty solid time. It honestly kept my attention far more than some of the previous albums that received a lot more praise. Also I note that once again, the bookending songs are my favourites. Best Song(s): The Next Big Thing, (I Live For) Cars and Girls Worst Song(s): N/A Rank compared to everything else so far: 70/94 (above Bizarre Ride 2 The Pharcyde, below Don't Stand Me Down)
This started out cool. The monologue was funny and the first guitar riffs were pretty good. It didn't maintain that level for long. I appreciate a band that doesn't take themselves seriously, but some of the songs were just juvenile, and the music was not as fun as I was hoping based on the opening and the cover, which is awesome. Not terrible though.
This was a fun album. More rock than punk but heading that way.
This music is for someone, but that someone isn’t me
No idea who this group was before today, but I like this record. It's a little all over the place, but the music and vocals are great. Kept my attention throughout and the energy was engaging. Punk, rock, easy vibes throughout. I dig this one.
This is pretty decent. I reckon I would’ve loved it if I was around in ‘75, but alas, I think, for me, it suffers from my having been exposed to so many better versions of this over the years. But I do like it well enough, even if I’ll probably never give it another spin. 7/10
I can hear went they hung out with Blue Oyster Cult and the other punks. Beach Boys and 60s garage punk in there too. Great stuff.
Wrestling? Manitoba? This one seems tailor made for "ya boi" as it combines the sport of kings and the province of well, certainly not kings. Subsistence farmers? Pillaging marauders? Who knows. Manitoba is a drive through if you can't fly over province, but that still puts them ahead of every state! To see them grace the cover of this album where territory accurate wrestlers were referenced does my heart good. This album has great music on it! The problem lies in the lyrics. I THINK this record is ironic in its "cars and girls" stupidity, but I just don't get enough bite from the satire if there is any there to begin with. I'm not very smart. What I CAN tell you is that in the battle between Manitoba wrestling legend Chris Jericho and the horrors of middle age, the horrors are up 2 falls, and this shit is NWA championship rules. 2.5 GENRE: Verne Gagne entrance music
Proto-punk without the sloppiness.
That last song is what raging incels sound like to me
Protoless proto punk. At least to my ears. Sure its still infantile in some ways but its damn near fully formed in other aspects. In most aspects id say. Its pretty fast, it has some yucky vocals, it takes old sounds, its simple, its hard as hell. California sun is probably the song everyone knows without knowing the song. Its amazing as ever. I didnt know it much but ive heard it before. Not sure if the Ramones did something with it but thats what I feel happened. Teengenerate is a good one, even master race rock is funny and sounds good. Tough sell on the name but come on its obviously making fun of those guys. The next big thing is also very good. Those were my saves but everything here is very good. A nice suprise for not knowing shit about this beforehand. Made me happy to listen to this whole project. Kicks ass
Everything I hate in an album. But fun!
70s American punk. Apparently it predates the Ramones. I’d rather listen to the Ramones.
interesting album, will revisit
Never heard of this lot and was expecting generic American punk. Well it was up to a point but it offered a lot more than the usual three chord riffs. More hard rock than punk which is the albums saving grace. Overall it sounded like a group of chaps having a good time in the studio and to a point this transferred itself over the grooves. Enjoyable but no one I’d make a point of making a quick return to. 3/5 28/10/26
Fun!
This gives me hope Manowar will make it on here.
I guess Ross is THE BOSS after all.
The look of this band vs what they sang about is interesting
This album is an Australopithecus, a missing link between the Beach Boys and punk. It was a little to cheesy for me, but I did enjoy it more than I expected to based on the name and album art. The music was enjoyable enough and it was interesting as a significant step in the evolution of a new genre. Favorite track: "Weekend," probably
With a band name as ridiculous as The Dictators and a cover featuring Handsome Dick Manitoba dressed like a professional wrestler, 𝘎𝘰 𝘎𝘪𝘳𝘭 𝘊𝘳𝘢𝘻𝘺! practically dares me to take it seriously. I didn’t, and I suspect that's exactly the point. Musically, it’s a rowdy mixture of garage rock and hard rock, full of simple riffs, deliberately stupid humour, and the bad manners that would soon become part of punk. The band sounds like they’re having a great time, and there's something charming about how little they seem to care about musical sophistication. Unfortunately, the songs themselves don’t always make as much of an impression as the attitude. An entertaining piece of proto-punk history, even if the music doesn’t quite live up to the glorious absurdity of its presentation. I enjoyed the racket, but I suspect I’ll remember the cover long after I’ve forgotten most of the songs.
Surprisingly funny
I find it strange how US and UK Punk differ especially in the early days pre mass media hysteria. This is a great example of the US scene which is a more gentle morph from rock n roll to punk
This is amusing proto-punk. At times it reminds me of the Flo and Eddie era of The Mothers of Invention - irreverent goofiness mixed with competent playing, especially the faux-naive cover of “I Got You Babe.” Some of the lyrics didn’t age well, but I doubt they had a classic for the ages in mind when they wrote them. This isn’t one of those records that I want to listen to over and over, but it definitely is part of the lore, and therefore belongs in the book.
3.75 I do not care what anyone says, this is the first punk album. This came out a year before the Ramones first LP. This is punk. It’s not “proto-punk”. It’s more punk than anything by the Stooges or New York Dolls.
This album has the most amusing cover of "I Got You Babe" that I've ever heard. It's sounds later than 1975, but according to the Wikipedia article, it was a precursor to the era it sounds like to me.
the beach songs at the end were funny/odd
Perhaps this is better than I'm giving it credit for, but it really caught me in the opposite sort of mood. Halfway through the first song, I just REALLY didn't want to listen anymore. So, the rules are the rules.
If you draw a triangle with three corners formed by Dr. Demento, the New York Dolls, and BIG Boys, you find The Dictators. I had a colleague at EPA HQ who loved these guys, and leant me this album back when I was a noob attorney. At the time, I felt like it was too much Dr. Demento, but here, 20 years later, it's so much better than I remembered. These guys were kooks, and some of the references are dated, but it's also just great early punk. So yeah, I liked it.
I read a review of this album at some point saying: if you love the New York Dolls, you'll like the Dictators. Maybe. It's pretty apt. I had never heard them and was happy to try it out. I'll stick with the New York Dolls.
Finally listened to this and was pleasantly surprised. It's a soft 4, but better than average. Enjoyed the riffs and energy and some of the jokes. But I think the parody aspect would get old after a while.
Not for me, thanks. 2
Two Tub Man (I Live For) Cars and Girls
This is actually the first time I’ve properly listened to this, though I’ve known about it for years. Honestly, I’m surprised to see it on the list. The band is mentioned and interviewed, though never fully explored, in Please Kill Me by Legs McNeil and Gillian McCain (one of the BEST books ever written about rock, not just punk!). Yet plenty of other bands from that book and this era aren’t on here. Where are the Dead Boys? Richard Hell and the Voidoids? Johnny Thunders & The Heartbreakers? Why only one Ramones album? And why, for God’s sake, THREE Velvet Underground albums? So what are the Dictators doing here? Probably because they were a true crossover band in every way. To those saying this sounds like Kiss: THAT’S THE POINT! The songs are tongue-in-cheek tributes to, and parodies of, the cock rock of the time. And even though he barely sings on this record (he’s credited only as the band’s “Secret Weapon”), Handsome Dick Manitoba, pictured on the cover, was the perfect mascot for charlatans, losers and loudmouths everywhere. Finally, someone Gene Simmons allegedly called “a fat Fonzie” (when they were on tour together) could get on stage and be a rock star. You didn’t need to be a millionaire, or have huge sets and tons of makeup, to do it. (FYI, in Please Kill Me, Handsome Dick was quoted as saying, "Gene Simmons might be the single biggest asshole I have met in my fifteen years of rock and roll." Make of that what you will.) So, what do we have here? Something fun, dumb and loud, no doubt. I find it funny, the playing is often kickass (especially the guitar solos), and those covers of “I Got You Babe” and “California Sun” make me smile like a total idiot. But it mostly covers ground the New York Dolls had already done better, the Stooges had done with more raw animal power, and the Ramones would do months later with more innocent charm. It’s really more of a blueprint that other bands would later improve on. It’s nice to have, but like Ian Dury, it’s a footnote to the great stuff to come. I suppose Manitoba would disagree, like all egomaniacs. So, whatever. 3.5 stars from me. Glad I finally got to listen, I guess.
Very enjoyable, proper 70s glam, with a solid level throughout
Not bad, not great Angsty alright music, I got you babe cover was crap
Equal parts Punk, Glam, and Novelty. It was better than I expected, but my expectations were pretty low.
This is okay
I love a lot of punk and can definitely see the influence this had on future bands, but this one just wasn't working for me
We quite liked this one. Was decent, but not overly strong feelings. ⭐⭐⭐🟡🟡
meh
I guess this was an album of covers?? I’m not 100% certain about the other songs being covered, but I know I Got You Babe is a Sonny and Cher classic. Not a fan of this group though. The vocals leave a lot to be desired.
Already knew from the album cover this was music for hot aesthetic girls, and was proven right one second into the first track. I'm too shook to play any more.
I’m not wowed by this by any means, especially with the vocals. The instrumentation and back track is slightly keeping me alive and that’s what’s saving this from being a 1
Awesome
sucks mad balls
01) The Next Big Thing - 6,0 02) I Got You Babe - 6,5 03) Back to Africa - 6,5 04) Master Race Rock - 6,0 05) Teengenerate - 6,5 06) California Sun - 6,5 07) Two Tub Man - 5,5 08) Weekend - 6,0 09) (I Live For) Cars and Girls - 5,5 TOTAL: 6,11 (61/100)
Dictators are usually spectacularly unfun, so kudos to The Dictators for bucking the trend and giving us an unspectacularly fun album!
You can hear glimmers of New York Dolls here but more humorous. Kind of eh and forgettable but the second half makes a huge redemption.
??? ----------------------------------------- Damn this is fantastic! Doesn't take itself too seriously (album cover definitely gives that vibe) and lays down some surprisingly technically proficient tunes. The guitar and drum work at times is really compelling. Apparently this is protopunk - I really like what is going on here apart from a couple of sketchy - it was alright in the 70s isms. It's got "we've got Kiss at home" vibes - and you can see how this might have had a big impression on the glam/punk/rock acts that followed. WAIT?? THAT's ROSS THE BOSS??? Ah man, MANOWAR is this vibe turned up to 11 so that fits. 4*
Another one of those punk albums, but wait. It's got something about it, it's fun and catchy, and it doesn't just fall into the formula. Lyrics have dated though so ignore the words!
This is pretty energetic lively and keeps you engaged throughout. Some of these lyric though man, they just suck. I mean, it's a decent enough listen, but it feels a little corny at points and not in the funny kind of way. I think it's it's so short. It doesn't really warrant any sort of strong feelings towards it. I'm not really gonna remember this. To be honest, I mean, like there's nothing particularly wrong with it. It's just not that interesting as a project on its own. Fav Track: Teengenerate
Fun punk
Not really a fan of punk or as some people are calling it Proto Punk. Yes it’s silly and at times fun but overall I just found it a bit bland, juvenile and boring. It may well have paved a path but it’s a road that I don’t particularly enjoy going down.
Not good
teengenerate temazo
I wanted to like this album, but couldn't quite get there
fun album
It's very standard, not bad at all but also nothing that special. I don't think I'll think about it very much in two weeks, but that's not on them cause apparently they were here first. Just yeah, not mind bending or a must listen.
Nascent punk from the time when it was all being created. Interesting but probably wouldn’t listen to it again. 3
Completely surprised by this. Based of the cover and a few descriptions I was expecting a campy Ramones. This is better than every Ramones album I’ve heard. Genius lyricism with lines such as ‘ We don't judge you by your face, First we check to see what you eat, Then we bend down and smell your feet’. Some killer guitar, memorable front man. Even a surprisingly solid cover of I Got You Babe. Just a weird as hell album cover. But that’s part of it I guess
Bajo
Hmmmm for punk I would rather go other places
This sounds like a fun but not especially memorable bar band. I will go up one point for being an early kind of punk, but there is nothing too memorable here for me.
This reminded me of the early Beastie Boys in that it’s a bunch of kids from New York just doing whatever. It’s also not great. I can appreciate that it was a forebearer for punk, but I wouldn’t necessarily want to listen to this again. Their I Got You Babe cover was cool.
One thing that I've learned from this challenge is that I don't wnjoy punk, but some exceptions to the rule have been suggestwd...and this is one of them. I didn't know I knew some of the songs, there is the classic I've got you babe that I knew from Cher and itbis surprisingly in this album. The music is fun and the lyrics did make me laugh at times with the sarcasm and irony. I honestly didn't have any idea of this band but, well, quite fun punk. 3.5/5 3/5 for the project.
I like a band with a sense of humor. This album isn’t amazing but it’s not terrible. I also like that they said goodbye at the end of the album, I thought that was nice.
Quite annoying
American proto-punk from New York. I'm a bit surprised that I've never heard this band before to be honest. It bombed at the time, unsurprisingly, but it's full of raw energy and oblique humour. A bit too much lead guitar for what would later become punk rock.
Top 1000??
as letras disto beiram um pouco a ofensa ou só brainrot ahahah algumas melodias safam-se
I thought this was actually kind of funny. I don’t know who this guy thinks he is, suing Manitoba, singing ironic songs about the master race, etc, but you know, boomers.
Pretty basic and straight down the line, but I’m a basic bitch when it comes down to it so this is right in my wheelhouse. Not certain about the cover, but otherwise this was easy to listen to and did what it set out to do. Obviously influential and better stuff followed it, but it’s half decent in itself.
One of the unsung heroes of punk in America, The Dictators blended the rock and roll sensibilities of KISS with a raucous and rude sense of street humor that proved to be massively influential. Go Girl Crazy beat The Ramones and The Sex Pistols to record store shelves by over a year, but unfortunately there was no music industry infrastructure for punk music. Radio didn't know what to do with their acerbic, fast-talking New York style, their label didn't know how to promote them, and before punk could even reach a crescendo The Dictators were gone. As is the case with most trailblazing bands, their legacy lives on in the music of others (specifically The Ramones who credit The Dictators as a major driving force).
Dumb Fun Listen once, then move on with your right & dont look back
Nope
Enjoyed small bits of this (2.5)
The perfect example of how punk can be both smart and stupid at the same time. Ashamed of myself for not knowing about this gem. I’m not the only one I’m sure. Good to finally see where the Ramones stole their ideas from! Glad to have heard this and now I can finally see why critics claim a straight line from V.U. -> The Stooges -> New York Dolls -> Ramones and how that is how punk rock happened. They all forgot to input this before the Ramones. And it’s all New York art rock really anyway, like rap many years later, a lot of regional scenes erupted. Was NYC ground zero for this shit? Maybe, maybe… I might be starting to come around. This bit from the Wikipedia article says what I think far better than I could write it: “ funny, brilliantly played and hopelessly naïve masterpiece of self-indulgent smartass rock'n'roll".[10] Entertainment Weekly wrote: "Go Girl Crazy's junk-generation culture and smart-aleck sensibility did provide an essential blueprint for '70s punk. With its TV references and homely vocals, this ground-breaking and long-unavailable album continues to inspire underground groups everywhere."[7]”
Rather fun protopunk, but not quite on the same level as MC5. The lyrics are cheeky, the mixing is raw, and the feeling reminded me of DEVO if they weren't so electronic.