Album Summary
A Seat at the Table is the third studio album by American singer-songwriter Solange. It was released on September 30, 2016, by Saint Records and Columbia Records. While recording the album, Solange released an EP, titled True (2012) and launched her own record label named Saint Records. Writing for the album began as early as 2008, while the recording sessions took place from 2013 to June 2016. Solange enlisted a variety of collaborators including rappers Lil Wayne and Q-Tip; singer-songwriters The-Dream, BJ the Chicago Kid, Kelly Rowland and Tweet; and musicians Sampha, Kelela and David Longstreth.A Seat at the Table was widely acclaimed by music critics and became Solange's first number-one album on the Billboard 200 in the United States, debuting with 46,000 copies sold (72,000 with additional album-equivalent units). The album's lead single, "Cranes in the Sky", won the Grammy for Best R&B Performance, becoming Solange's first Grammy nomination and win. In 2020, the album was ranked at 312 on Rolling Stone's 500 Greatest Albums of All Time list.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
This album is almost too relaxed. It feels like one long song that doesn't really go anywhere or do anything different or interesting. Fine maybe as background music, but there's nothing worth actually paying attention to unfortunately. A song on the radio here or there is perfectly fine, but as a whole is album is lackluster. Top tracks: Don't Touch My Hair, Don't Wish Me Well
Like Kelela's album but with more slow grooves and sprinkled with interludes about Black pride. I like how it sticks to a downtempo vibe but the length overstays its welcome. I wish it were more anthemic. (3-3.5)
I listened to this album about 3-4 years ago when i was a sophomore in college and I'm pleased it holds up dramatically. just great R&B/Neo-Soul.
likt!
This was mid R&B. Solange not being a part of any of Destiny's Child when her parents were all over that tells me everything I need to know.
Soft, slow, reflective songs with a pretty but not hugely memorable voice. I can't really distinguish most of the songs from each other, even after a few listens through, and I don't think I could even under mortal duress, but I enjoyed the listen. Don't Wish Me Well is gorgeous and I wish more of the album sounded like it!
Inconsequential lift music with pointless and annoying verbal interludes.
A beautiful and powerful album with echoes of Sade imo. It’s old school soul and Motown and hip hop with a touch of pop! This record is so listenable, Solange has the sort of talent you really don’t see very often. LOVED IT!
I love this record, Solange has such a beautiful voice and for whatever reason the instrumentation she chooses always really clicks with me. I don't really like a lot of this kind of relaxed r&b, which makes this even more special. Also, the tone of the interludes is pitch perfect, not patronising or melodramatic, just telling truths. 'Tina Taught Me' is the rarest of rare things - a 'skit' that you actually want to hear again.
I like this album but don’t know that I’ll ever listen to it again. I was impressed with the political nature of many songs.
A classic, happy to have been prompted to give this a listen again. Captures the 2016 zeitgeist
Loved this, and have since release. hard to believe it is already ten years old. Rare album where I think the interludes actually add to the tracks they intro. Solange ate i fear. Just two years after the elevator fight she was feeling her neo soul oats and it is goood. The features are well used.
Actually much better than anticipated. Still not my cup of tea but quite listenable. 3
Ehhh, it’s fine. 2.5⭐️
It's a decent listen but what is Master P doing there?
Not really my jam
Rap-tekster i soul-format. Hadde sikkert likt dette på konsert.
Not great
4/10
Pleasant enough apart from the unnecessary spoken interludes and Lil Wayne's incongruous inclusion. When I think about the omissions the fact that this 2016 nothing album makes the list makes no sense to me and has me feeling like I'm wasting my time.
Woke blm typa shit, but one song is good "don't touch my hair"
Interesting
I like the concept of the album, the lyrics are meaningful.
I think this is a perfect album. I can't believe it's been 10 years, because it feels like yesterday. Along with a few other albums from 2016, this record had a powerful effect on me during one of the loneliest periods of my life. It sounds even better today than it did then.
Seems okay. Not sure if any of us have to hear it before we die though. Modern R&B(soul music) like this is lacking actual soul IMHO.
I hadn't heard this one before and it was really good. It dragged in places, but as a whole, really enjoyable.
I really enjoy this type of rnb music, and I found this album extremely listenable. I don't rate it higher than 3/5 however because it doesn't offer anything to come back to really, title track was my favourite. 🪑🪑🪑
Modern album filed under Contemporary R&B, so I was fearing the worst. This wasn't all that bad though. I think the beats were really nice and so long as the co-stars would shut up and let Solange sing it was a nice experience. Interludes were nicely woven into the rest of the album as well. The flow of the entire album is just pretty good, there are barely any songs as it's just one big piece stringing along. Can't find much fault with it outside of this just not being my thing.
Entdeckung! Toller R‘n‘B von Beyoncés Schwester.
Ganz ok
Ничего не могу сказать, голос хорлший, музыка качественная, но.. ничего не зацепило, просто 2й трек мимо
I enjoyed it. Not as good as like an FKA Twigs album. For me the male rap parts detract from the female vocals and vibe of this effort.
Fucking R&B. Ugh.
I listened to this when it came out since it was reviewed well. I like it alright, but don't find myself moved enough by the hooks.
Didn't make it all the way through. Bland R&B blandness.
Impressed
Stunning album - already familiar, but always nice to listen back to again.
lovely
I can appreciate the messages of empowerment and racial/gender positivity. But the songs seem inert. They're not interesting enough musically and, though she has a great voice, it's not enough to overcome the inertia. It would probably grow on me with repeat listens.
I should have paid more attention to this when it came out. Reminds me of D'Angelo's music in that there are so many gorgeous, intricate arrangements but they're fairly understated. Maybe could do without so many interludes but still a really enjoyable listen
This album sucks; let me check Wikipedia to see why it's on here.... Ah, she's Beyoncé's sister; pure nepotism
This is a relatively recent album from Beyonce’s little sister, and there are some similarities between their music, although Solange’s is less top 40 than Beyonce’s. It’s a well constructed album, and the singing is fine. The music isn’t my style but it’s decent.
Sister of Beyoncé! If Beyoncé (or Jay-Z) is on the list, there's another relative for the version of me who remembered to track relatives. (Right now I only remember the Buckleys & Shankar/Joneses, but I know there are more. Highly disproportionate!!!) As for Solange, I didn't like her first singles when they came out (this is her 3rd album, so probably that was around 2008), but maybe we both have changed some since then. I think she got more jazzy. I still feel pretty "meh" about this, though. When my favorite parts are by Lil Wayne I know an album is not for me. The lyrics are fine, maybe even good (generally about identity/racism), but the delivery is very slow... chill... yet high-pitched... I like the music, which is kinda funky and bleep-bloopy at times, but I don't like slow high-pitched singing (by any gender)!! Slur count = 9. Highlight: the song title 'Interlude: Dad Was Mad'
Voz potente e batidas interessantes. Pula Unicrom.
I have known about this album for a long time, but never got around to listening to it. I'm glad I did now, because this is exactly my thing. It feels modern and classic at the same time, her voice is amazing and the songwriting is really strong.
A irmã da Beyoncé é melhor que ela
Easy listening. She sounds a bit like Maria Carey but obviously better.
Overall a pretty great album. There’s a couple of songs I don’t care for, but most of them are unique and have a great feel, and I like the way it gets its message across
8 interludes and a closing.........this is why no one knows your name, Beyonce's sister...
I feel like the public has spent years trying to convince ourselves that Solange is also great. I think I’m ready to stop pretending and say “this is okay!”. Listening to this reminds me that Solange and Beyoncé were both nepo babies*, but how only one of their music reminds me of that fact when I’m listening to it. *get that bag, if my parents had connections like that I think it would be fun to record an album too
The *songs* are fine. Why are there so many interludes? Who the hell listens to an album thinking “I can’t wait to hear some random person talking about some dumb shit between the songs.”
Welcome to Interlude city. I think that the album is a celebration of black culture to a certain extent. It's honestly full of platitudes and surface level remarks. I don't think it goes deep enough for me to give it the flowers some might think it deserves. I think this type of music is important, for sure... that this album holds a significant space in the context of black culture is up to debate. It's a mediocre version of something that had already been perfected around this time, in my opinion, and for that reason I don't think it needs to be listened to before you die. I think my rating is a protest rating, and that the album falls somewhere around a 3/5 stars. I think the instrumentation gave Solange's middle of the road vocalizations too much space, to be honest. The bland trap beats and bland synth pads didn't dress her up enough to need warrant eyes on her in a similar vein as eyes are placed on her sister. Idk man. It's tough, but I think I gotta stand with myself on this one. Albums like these are needed, but GOOD albums are needed as well. MEMORABLE songs are needed as well. LESS INTERLUDES are needed. I don't think this was memorable enough to warrant a spot on here.
Dreary.
Initially thought I was going to like this but it's spread too thin.
Not bad, just a bit boring...
Dull
Хороший альбом Так уж совпало что после него сразу cza и на фоне него он уже не такой прикольный. Первое прослушивание было скучно, второе уже вайбово Наверное под какой-то особый случай могу такое переслушать
Pretty mellow, down tempo beats that we alright, she's a great singer for sure but this album didn't do much for me.
Really good voice and there's a weirdness here that's hitting me just right. 4 stars
A beautiful R&B album with a great concept. The second half is unfortunately is not as strong as the first half though. Rating:7/10 Favorite Song: Mad
This is not one that I would ever have listened to had it not been for this list. And I don't think my life would have been any worse for not having heard this record. I mean, yes, she probably has a good voice but the production is just so overdone that it takes anything unique out and just makes it sound like every similar record of the time. I get so tired of this kind of production where it seems the goal is to just make the record sound like 'generic female R&B singer' from a software bundle. I think I picked out a real bass here and there, maybe a real guitar on one song, and horns that could either be real or not. Would she have been able to have this same album released to the same accolades were it not for her sister? I don't know. I would say no. But that might just be me. I do enjoy some of the lyrics and certainly the overall theme of the record. As for a rating, it's not my thing at all and is so generic and overproduced that it could be anyone with a half decent voice. 2.5/5 and will round down because there's now way this is a better record than that.
Lindo album, pero no me voló la cabeza. No diría que tiene algo innovador para el género y fecha en que salió tampoco. Así que poco más para decir. 5/10
Not my usual thing but not bad
Maybe one or two ok but not for me
Solange – A Seat at the Table (2016) ★★★☆☆ — 5/10 This was my first experience listening to Solange, and while I enjoyed parts of the album, it ultimately became a bit of a chore to finish. The album starts out promisingly with some smooth R&B grooves, layered vocals, and tasteful production. "Cranes in the Sky" and "Mad" were the highlights for me, and early on I thought the album might be able to hold my attention if it offered enough musical variety. Unfortunately, that variety never really arrived. As the album progressed, the songs started sounding too similar, and the mellow atmosphere that initially appealed to me became increasingly monotonous. There aren't any truly terrible songs here. In fact, most of them fall somewhere between average and pretty good. But there's also nothing that really blew me away, and by the second half I was struggling to stay engaged. I can appreciate the production, the cohesive atmosphere, and what Solange was trying to accomplish. The spoken-word interludes also contribute to the album's overall concept. But musically, I needed more changes in energy, stronger hooks, or something unexpected to break up the sameness. 5/10 — ★★★☆☆. A respectable album with some enjoyable moments, but not one I see myself returning to very often.
2.5
This is pretty decent RnB album, don’t have much to say but it did sound good and gonna go a 3.5/5 Round down for now but could reach a 4
her best album
7/10 Buen album. Tranquilo y relajo, pero no aburrido
Breathy, stripped back neo soul with electro elements. Listen hard and you can hear a lineage with say TLC in here. Vocals are breathy, but not offensively so like FKA Twigs. Those electro elements in Weary put me in mind of Brian Eno's Golden Hour. Some interludes commenting on race etc. More jazzy in Mad. It's quite good. But listening while sleepy isn't a good idea. Easy to fall asleep to. Best track - Rise, Weary 3 stars - I enjoyed more than I expected.
“Don’t touch my pride, they say the glory’s all mine.” An R&B masterpiece. I heard a lot of hype around this when I came out and completely overlooked it because I thought the genre “wasn’t for me” - I was foolish and this is a great record. Heartfelt, confident, and beautifully sung. Joyful and sincere. I enjoyed the grounded, colorful production. The curation of the features is spot-on as well. Lives up to the decade-old hype.
This sound and style within the R&B/Soul genre are not for me.
High 3.75
Neo soul, funk, R&B.
Not bad but nothing particularly caught my attention. Infinitely better than anything her sister has ever done.
Ik schuif aan
2016 was op muzikaal gebied zo'n overdonderend jaar dat deze plaat destijds niet bij me geland is. Na wat enkele luistersessies bleven eigenlijk alleen de waanzinnige singles Cranes in the Sky en Don't Touch My Hair hangen. Bij nader inzien had ik het toch misschien iets meer een kans moeten geven. Ja, dit album heeft het probleem wat voor overgeproduceerde moderne albums hebben: het klinkt soms wat plasticy en er zijn veeeel te veel interludes en throwaway nummertjes die ze gewoon achterwege hadden moeten laten. MAAR: een aantal nummers (met name Don't Make Me Wait en FUBU) zijn geproduceerd en grotendeels ingespeeld door David Longstreth en die heeft zijn stempel op briljante wijze op dit album weten te drukken. Net als op de betere Dirty Projectors platen krijgen alle instrumenten super veel ruimte en weeft alles op schitterende wijze in elkaar. Echt heel tof. Dus? Ja, dit album heeft z'n problemen. Maar ook ja, het is beter dan 99% van de psychedelische rock-slop op deze lijst, dus 4 sterren.
Beautiful voice. Bravo
Not what I usually listen to - but much more enoyable than I was expecting. Was fearing in your face pop with vocal excess- but was actually pretty chill with some interesting productions/ beats. Her vocals are generally nice and chill.
Very chilled and soulful, nothing shoved in your face nor overly produced. Felt genuine and honest.
Well, is guess she is Beyonce's sister and all.
Beautiful R&B about black identity, reflective of a culture in the midst of the Black Lives Matter movement
She has a fantastic voice and the story telling in the albums is really good.
Enjoyable, and she definitely has an amazing voice, but didn't really do it for me. I tend not to be a fan of albums with a bunch of speaking interludes like this one. Takes me out of the music too much.
Hermanita de Beyonce. Fui saltando las canciones porque todas suenan igual. Una bronca
Good vocals and enjoyed some of the songs
All kind of similar sounds and made me a little tired to be honest
Ruined my morning drive to work. It’s just so boring.
There is real beauty and importance to this record and the seat is grabbed, no resistance from me. I just think it does feel a bit too a like to truly be perfect, I do not need all of it, but the note that it does hit rings true.
Radio pop... supposedly this album is exceptional, but I don't get it. Sounds like pretty typical R&B that would go on in the background nicely. Lil Wayne showing up was a choice... It's not bad by any stretch of the imagination, but I also don't understand what makes this album special. It's slow and kind of dreamy in ways, but I don't find anything standing out.
Extraño, no me gustó...
its ok
Soulful and powerfu
Not as bad as i thought it would be
Solange has a beautiful voice. I like the message she’s delivering here — civil rights, black working-class struggles. But the album needs editing and better stylistic decisions. Adding vocal frills and trills everywhere is not a good strategy— those should be saved for special songs and special moments in those songs, IMO. In particular, the bird like oratorical stylings don’t play well in the collabs with hard rappers like Lil’ Wayne. I appreciate the creative instinct to mix hard with soft, gritty with sweet— but here, it doesn’t work. A 2.
It’s not the best I’ve ever heard. It’s not the worst I’ve ever heard. The register of her voice is a bit high and seems forced to me and all of the interludes of what seem to be voicemails from her father can probably be cut also.
First track was annoying and the entire album was a slog
One of those gems, you find forget about and then go back to.
Although beautiful at some points, it was a boring experience overall. A personal highlight for me was actually the track Junie, mainly the chorus (Andre 3000).
Started off enjoying it and then went off it in the end