A Seat at the Table by Solange

A Seat at the Table

Solange

3
Rating
23738
Votes
1
8%
2
23%
3
36%
4
25%
5
8%
Distribution

Reviews (page 2 of 8)

The overall messaging was good and interesting, but the music itself was just sorta nice, nothing wrong with it but nothing that really stood out.

I do not care for this style of music at all. No saving it for me. Just not good.

rym 3.65 Neo-Soul/Progressive Soul 这位竟然是byonce的妹妹,看来音乐才华确实有基因作用。整体上非常悦耳且不无聊,同时有着一股不屈服与任何人的韧劲。十分擅长用鼓点挑动情绪,再用钢琴或歌声与之应和。 pick: Mad, Where Do We Go, Don't Wish Me Well

I liked the first half a lot but it really faded down the stretch

Ugh. Interludes. I didn't look at the track listing beforehand, but as soon as I heard the monotone skit delivery, I knew Solange had fallen for the same terrible music decision that most of hip-hop falls for. (Seriously – if there's nothing musically interesting in those 17 seconds, why not just cut it out of the final LP? Or better yet, don't record it at all?) 8 of the 21 tracks are interludes (10 if you include the 42-second final track). Most are unnecessary. Lots of decent tracks here, but an unforgivably large volume of wasted time. Immediately, I'm captivated by the vocal harmonies. 21st-century inclusions on this list tend to have "layered but not actually musically convincing" harmonising, so a song like Rise was a nice subversion of expectations. Weary also combines this with some really entertaining synthwork and basswork. The synths in particular are a joy to listen to (whereas the bass mainly repeats two chord arpeggios). A super compelling, soft, almost alien atmosphere that proves very hard to describe but is an easy early-album highlight. After the interlude, we hit Solange's biggest hit – which is very good, except now we regress slightly toward that overharmonised state I was worried about earlier. Particularly at the end, with all those overlapping vocal lines... it just sounds excessive and not musically informed. Hard to explain. Still, the remaining song elements are great. The Dad Was Mad interlude has some pretty entertaining piano, plus it segues nicely into Mad, so I give it a pass. And Mad comes in seamlessly with that slow, bass-heavy beat and that delicate lead vocal. I really enjoy it. In contrast, Don't You Wait is just kind of... uninteresting, I guess. And that almost brutalist synth-percussion doesn't do the song any favours. While I appreciate the sentiment of Tina Taught Me, in the end it's just another musically weak interlude. And I can't help but feel that the critical race theory stuff, for the target audience, will go in through one ear and out the other. The 90s were a more effective time for hip-hop to do, well, hip-hop stuff. I enjoy the "What you say to me?" refrain of Don't Touch My Hair. But the goofy line "You know this hair is my shit" singlehandedly counterbalances it. We hit yet another interlude in This Moment, where the big-band-esque brass easily justifies the conclusion. Just ignore the vocals, kick back, and be entertained by those trumpets. Where Do We Go is really weird. The texture is very thin barring the drums, but the drums are mixed in a way that leaves a solid half-beat of silence for each (half-)beat of percussive noise. So the whole thing feels kind of... disjointed, maybe? I like the piano, though. Reminds me of Bennie And The Jets. After the barren interlude For Us By Us, we at least get a smooth transition into F.U.B.U., an extremely slickly produced tune that does what Where Do We Go tried to go, but slightly better. Really good melody, catchy chorus, and a disorienting rhythm that keeps you on your toes. I enjoy Borderline but it does include that overcompensatory vocal harmony thing that R&B music is so obsessed with. (It doesn't surprise me at all that Beyoncé is Solange's older sister. Both artists commit pretty similar musical sins.) The last seven tracks alternate between interludes (empty, inconsequential) and actual songs. Of the latter, only two are strong: Junie with its infectious positivity, and Scales with a beautiful, emotive vocal delivery. Don't Wish Me Well has an ultra-clean hip-hop-standard beat, and ultimately is just too predictable and repetitive to really get off the ground. 2/5 Key tracks: Weary, Interlude: This Moment, F.U.B.U.

Honestly one of the best pieces of art from the 2010’s

This was nice and liked the spoken word inserts. It felt retro soul but also modern R&B at the same time.

she is really, really, not as talented as her sister -- and she aims to prove it.

I’m certainly not the target demographic for this album, so not that surprising that I didn’t really connect with it. It’s not terrible by any means, but it’s just not something that grabbed me.

Very quiet and not much.

I liked this one. Lots of interesting samples, the black power message was well put without being hamfisted, music was easy to listen to. Commendable

This album shifted in and out of my taste all throughout it's entire runtime, but I just don't think anything really stuck for me overall. One thing I'd like to point off now is that there are too many interludes, I am sorry but if you album "needs" more then 3 interludes then just mesh them into your songs and stop fluffing the tracklist. I felt super disconnected during the middle of this album and it really hindered my listening experience as so many different sounds (and interludes) were flowing through me but barely anything stuck out. Every now and then a song will grab me with it's weird sound or instrument like Junie with it's wavey synths. I am sure Solange is a very talented artist and full of other songs I will enjoy but this project was more of a miss then a hit for me.

This was great. Reminded me of Lauryn Hill!

it's alright background music, quite basic

Nothing special

I'd not heard of Solange, wasn't aware of this album notwithstanding #1 in US. Anyway I have a listen, It was very low impact for me. No standout vocal melodies, backing tracks not gripping for me. I wondered if Cranes in the Sky would be more impactful if I watched the video - opened with a series of snaps showing off many different glamorous costumes?? So there may be some meaningful messages in there somewhere but for me the surface looks like USAvian luxury - not backed up by music that grabs me. For me, it's Not Good, 4/10.

What a boring album, the same beat the whole way through with Solange warbling over it. Another I question why its on the list? Appreciate it may have 'important' lyrics, but I can barely parse them through solange's articulation; she lets the ends of sentences just float off.

Sonically dull and one note. More of a TedTalk than an album. Rating: 1.5

De muziek is geweldig, maar ik hou niet van dat gemurmel tussen de nummers door

nu when i get home nog

2010s soul pop. Floaty and ethereal. Relaxing, pleasant album with some interesting turns.

Good album but I don’t think I’ll listen to it again much

Too deep in the R&B vibe. Smooth and proud. Listenable, but not something I'll come back to.

Important messages contained within the interludes of this album. They were my favourite part, regrettably. The musical elements were not to my taste, unfortunately. This type of R&B does nothing for me other than persuading me to nod off. Actually that’s quite a useful tool. 2/5

La moindre petite idée est transformée en musique unique, ce qui donne un album à la fois diarrhéique et vite ennuyeux. Symptomatique de son genre et son époque.

Vraiment aucun intérêt, même en musique de fond on peut trouver mieux.

Could have been a four, cause the music is really great, but the interludes are tiresome and it's overall a bit too long.

better than anything beyoncé's ever done

It's obvious she only got her recording contract because she's Beyonce's sister. Her voice is good, and the album is recorded and produced well, but the songs are just boring. Not for me, dawg.

Hey those are some beautiful son—DIDACTIC INTERLUDE ALERT! DIDACTIC INTERLUDE !DIDACTIC INTERLUDE ALERT!DIDACTIC DIDACTIC INTERLUDE ALERT! INTERLUDE INTERLUDE INTERLUDE DIDACTIC INTERLUDE ALERT!!!!!

I think this is better than I thought it was when I first listened to it when it came out. But still not great.

I imagine Pitchfork writers sit around listening to this drinking Matcha. All nodding at each other, pretending they’re really enjoying it, but actually Matcha is just a bit shit isn’t it.

This album has such a sameish quality that all the tracks blend into one another. The message gets lost and the music started to take on a turgid quality. I was over this album half way through. I endured to the end. I'm not listening again.

A little on the long side. BUT it wasn't too repetitive where that was a problem. No it was fairly varied to keep me interested enough that I would say I ended up liking it.

Some nice songs. Overall, not exactly my vibe.

Hm. My first impression with this album, and Solange, is that I had no idea why the project editors chose this artist or album. It took me about halfway through the Wikipedia entry to realize that Solange is Beyonce's sister, which at least explained why Solange was included in the collection. But while I know it was a popular album, I must admit I didn't find anything particularly distinctive or compelling on it, and the interplay of interview-style "interludes" and very slow/mellow/soul tracks reminded me of previous albums in this collection, especially Erykah Badu's "Mama's Gun". Fine, and kind of a weird experience of feeling like you're hearing music played underwater, but not really all that interesting to me.

If you like high-pitched whisper singing about Black identity, Black power, Black history, Black hair, Black women, Blackity Black Black Black, have I got the album for you. Located at the intersection of Bjork and Martin Luther King Jr. Blvd, A Seat at the Table has everything...

Very polished result but the content is still rudimentary.

no notes

Probably a top 100 all time for me. A beautiful, introspective, melodic masterpiece.

Cranes in the sky

Solange is an incredible vocalist and is delivering an important message here and is highlighting hypocrisy. Ultimately not to my taste musically and the production is very average for this type of R&B record. 3/5

This is a chameleon that had me wondering is this background or foreground? The whispery swoosh almost lulls, but it’s off-kilter, has some daring fluorishes and its politics relentlessly nibble through the silky production. Maybe the first album on here that has lived up to - for me - the promises of avant garde I’ve heard touted around neo soul. That “Cranes in the Sky” standing out so prominently perhaps suggests too much texture in place of song, but what texture!

This started out quite well, bright and melodious. Dragged on a bit, not helped by the interminably-glib "Interludes", eventually trending to a predictable level of nepo baby multiplayer R&B. Meh, a bit better than her sister.

The many vocal oohs and aahs made my mind wander away from trying to keep parsing meaning in what she was singing. Luckily the interludes are spoken clearly and unsurprisingly, from a person with the same background, the politics are the same. Glitz and glamour if you just work harder than anyone else, just keep grinding, practice that self care so you can keep grinding, outta here with that shit. Boring and disingenuous.

Nepobaby sin talento.

Álbum que no creo q nunca vaya a volver a escuchar. No es mi estilo, para nada. Está bien igual, no duele escucharlo, pero el comentario de q solo está acá porq es la hermana de Beyonce jaja.

Muy buenas letras, linda voz, lindo todo. Se me hizo repetitivo por momentos, no es entretenido. Es para tener de fondo quizás. Me gustó pero no me termina de encantar.

I like this better than most R&B. By which I mean it's fine.

This sounds like the kind of album someone produces who is only in the studio because their sister is a cultural phenomenon (and one of my favorite Altos), the lyrics to this album are also pretty racist

Liked this, gorgeous voice and fairly lofi tunes

I really love how unapologetically Black Feminist this record is.

Woooooow 😳🤯 Excellent. This is what I’m doing this challenge for, to find albums like this. Immediately added to my library and it’s going to get so much replay.

This definitely has too many interludes. It slows down the pace of the album every time it gets going again. The actual songs themselves are alright, but a bit generic for the genre.

Easy to listen and appreciate. Warm and deep. Can go back to it when need something to comfort me.

Because I'm black like that! I love this Album ititss a classic as well as a symbol of black expression and pride. Love Solange

I liked it, pretty chill

Very beautiful

Album #251 Solange: A Seat at the Table I don’t know why, but R&B just bores me to tears. The vocals are emotionless, so to make up for that they cram in gospel-esque harmonies; and if there is one thing I hate, it is a random gospel choir ruining a song (looking at you Leonard Cohen). The instrumentals are always so minimal that I forget that they are even there, which I guess is the point, since the music is meant to be ‘chill’, but personally I like to engage with the music I’m listening to, not just forget it’s even playing. I’m sure this album is good for what it is, and I’m not trying to argue it’s bad, just not for me and not something I would ever return to. Also, minus points for nepotism; I mean I already suffered through two Beyoncé albums. Did her sister really need to make the list as well? Strangely though I did like this album more than her sister’s work. Best Songs: Borderline, Cranes in the Sky, Where Do We Go Worst Song: Junie Score out of 10: 4

A Seat At The Table was a pretty decent R&B album. I never knew who Solange was or about her music but i am definitely well aware of her older sister's music (that older sister being Beyonce) and it is pretty evident that they are sisters since their music is certainly very similar to each other, each having that poppy R&B sound. Overall, i did like the songs on offer, they were nice to listen to and there wasn't one i would consider bad, however, I think that this album doesn't really have any stand out tracks. Every track here just kinda adds to the album's vibe rather than being good to listen to on their own. This album is decent but that's all it is. Best Song: Cranes In The Sky Worst Song: F.U.B.U.

The more talented sister

This went down much better on this listen than it did for me when it first came out. I understand the hype that it received now.

lol at the top review. I get it, music is subjective and everyone has different tastes. But to say that this music is uninspired is a joke. The production is incredible and complimentary to her voice, the features gave some of their best work, and most importantly, the message in the music was potent and necessary. This album inspired the next generation of R&B and is widely heralded as being one of the best albums to come out that year! And 2016 was a heavy-hitting year for music, btw. Anyways, happy ten years to an album that caused a crater when it landed & still holds up to this day!

Apple Music have this curated in their ‘100 Best Albums’ and surely I don’t believe it sorry - it’s good! Don’t get me wrong but 100 best??? Sadly disagree

Pretty good for the most part except for some cringe sprinkled throughout.

Beyonce's sister follows Nietzsche's advice to truly tap into Will to Power by creating one's own form of valuation by creating an R&B album that defies the convention and genre and speaks to powerful themes. I respect it. Unfortunately, the system of values that I abide by think this music is bland as f**k. Which is a shame, since it is supposed to (and does) speak to very visceral and socially potent themes of injustices against blacks. I would respect that more if the music made any sort of attempt to get me to care about the messaging via melody--or anything sonically interesting at all... Instead, I am given the same quasi-experimental boring stuff that I see on my struggling-musician friends' Instagram posts daily. It tracks that this was praised so highly in 2016, and is a shame that it is considered so highly as for it to be a 'must listen' when I know damn well there are fantastic albums of the 2010's worth listening to over this. Regardless, like I said, I have a great degree of respect for Solange for following that Nietzschan prerogative.

Nice voice and competent production, okay. I fail to see how this is any different from the thousands of R&B Albums it there and I don't particularly care for that style.

Message is strong. Music is slow and bare. Vocals are nice but tame

Somehow never knew this was Beyonce's sister. I liked this more than Beyonce's self titled that we did months ago. This wasnt my favorite but I bet it would grow after a few listens. Any album with Sampha on it gets extra love from me - check out his latest album Lahai if you liked his sound here.

bom pra caralho hein puta que pariu já tinha ouvido falar da solange, nunca tinha parado pra escutar, incrível não sei elaborar mas esse álbum tem a sonoridade de 2016 na veia dele. eu nem tinha pesquisado sobre e já sabia que era de 2016 só pelo som. brabo. (vim editar pq percebi que esse me trouxe 100% era flower boy do tyler, fui pesquisar e a dra. solange e o tyler são parças absolutos, o que explica mta coisa)

pedrada máxima concordo com o amigo sobre a sonoridade 2016, hein. às vezes eh bão demais um album que te transporta pruma época. as letras desse aqui também são boas demais! só não dou nota 5 porque, mais pro finalzinho, tiveram umas músicas que não gostei mto. mas ainda assim, é um ótimo álbum, hein!!

Listened before? yes, at least once. it was a while ago tho Rise - 3/5 Weary - 4/5 Interlude: The Glory Is in You - no rating Cranes in the Sky - 5/5 Interlude: Dad Was Mad - no rating Mad - 3/5 Don't You Wait - 4/5 Interlude: Tina Taught Me - no rating Don't Touch My Hair - 5/5 Interlude: This Moment - no rating Where Do We Go - 4/5 Interlude: For Us by Us - no rating F.U.B.U. - 4/5 Borderline (An Ode to Self Care) - 4/5 Interlude: I Got So Much Magic, You Can Have It - no rating Junie - 3/5 Interlude: No Limits - no rating Don't Wish Me Well - 5/5 Interlude: Pedestals - no rating Scales - 3/5 Closing: The Chosen Ones - no rating Average score: 3.9/5 ⭐️⭐️⭐️⭐️ now i know why i couldn't remember much about this album. these tracks are very low-energy, even the good ones solange is undoubtedly a talented vocalist. however, this wasn't the most riveting performance i've ever heard (though many of the better tracks were clearly saved til nearly the end.) not sure if that's due to production or just my lack of enthusiasm for this genre. maybe both? she definitely has a lot of potential as a performer though. the album was just barely within 4-star range for me personally, which is pretty solid. she put out a more recent album in 2019 that i have yet to hear, so hopefully she's only gotten better since

Beyonce je vrlo nemuzikalna, i ova je tu negdje vrlo blizu. Muzički album na kojem nema muzike. Čudno iskustvo veoma.

I like interludes. It's the kinda thing you miss out on when sticking Spotify on shuffle and not listening to albums in full. Enjoyed this, even if it's not my usual kind of music.

I found this one a bit boring. OK in the background, but not for me.

Nice to have something from this century today, but its not my jam.

- I like this album a lot. That said, I definitely prefer poppy Losing You Solange to this, but I still find this a nice listen. I really like the political nature of this album, though I would like to have a version of it without the interludes to listen to repeatedly. - There's a nice easy, smooth vibe to the music that I appreciate and that grows on you the more that you listen to it. - My biggest gripe is that it can be a little too smooth without super memorable melodies. I want a little more grit and evolution to the songs, themselves. The breathy vocals feel tentative, throughout, and I want more strength in them. - Also, the album really feels like it goes on a long time because of the sheer number of tracks & interludes and some of the songs that aren't as good as the others. - I'd say it's a 3.5.

Excellent, conscious and unified. Hadn't heard this and enjoyed it greatly.

Really liked this actually. It’s a little cooler than what her sister does. Very cohesive album

Listened on 2nd April 2024. Favourite songs are Cranes in the Sky and Don't Touch My Hair.

A beautiful, black powered, modern day masterpiece

Smooth lounge pretty voice

Slow R&B with good vocals, not a top 1,000 album

Not really for me, didn't really connect with me. It wasn't terrible but it felt overproduced and polished. 4/10

The cool Knowles sister (no offence to Beyonce, I'm sure she'll wipe away her tears with a $100 note that she's the slightly less cool sister). I was really obsessed with this album when it came out and it does hold up. Expertly crafted and lots of bops - nice one!

Really really good neo soul music, super dynamic but super subtle with so much depth. Pretty hard to find any flaws in tbh. Beyonce could NEVER. This is a modern classic

This was great.

I appreciate her addressing issues that needed(and and still need) to be addressed, but I get the impression she's only on this list because her sister is one of the most likable, and talented billionaires on the planet. I just found myself bored throughout the entire album. I don't know what else to add. It barely seemed like music at times. Favorite Track: "Rise".

Prone to the usual tendency to over sing, coupled with the backing singers also trying to over-sing and out-sing the main act. Despite that and despite the irritating segues, it wasn’t tooooo bad. Floated around me whilst I was busy doing my stuff. Next….

A seat at who's table? I was trying to work out what her influences were. Sade? The interlude between songs hinted at your average US mainstream Rap artist. But unfortunately, this whole mess was plain boring and one dimensional. Pedestrian at best. If it was trying to be soulful, then it was lost one me. The only thing I found of interest was the black persons take in Black History Month, it made me think about things from that point of view. Sadly it had nothing to do with her music at all. What exactly was this seen as a good example of?

# Album Name: A Seat at the Table # Artist: Solange # Rating: 2/5 # Comments: Honestly, absolutely meh. Decent voice but clearly has a famous family member to lean on.....oh wait, whats that? Beyonce. I'd never have guessed it was someone famous. Definitely should not be on any must listen list. Way too long. # Top Tunes: # Would I listen to it again? NO

This list has a few performers (Cobain, MJ, Lauryn Hill) whose charisma is undeniable…..Solange is not one of those performers. Lots to like in this album, the production, the guest stars, even the interlude into song format all works for me but the songs all fall flat because they sound like they’re being sung by Beyoncé’s little sister.

3.0 A nice, understated effort. The more we go through the list the more I think interludes and skits are a waste of time and dont really add anything for me

yummy elegant neo-soul

Interesting album. Like the beats and her lyrics are poignant and delivered well. The skits get to be a little annoying. 3/5 Might listen again

Not my style

This is a perfectly fine album, but it's just not the type of music that really interests me. The production is smooth, the songwriting is thoughtful, and Solange has a pleasant voice, but I never found myself getting pulled into it. My biggest takeaway from this was find out that Beyoncé has a sister. I had no idea before listening to it.

Really lovely album, I do like most of what Solange does, and this doesn’t disappoint

Not for me. Too popish.

One of my favourite albums of all time. Atmospheric and beautiful. Moments of grace and anger. Songs you can hum along to and also listen hard to. I’ve loved her work since but this one is the one for me. Perfect. No notes.

I didn't even know Beyoncé had a sister. Pleasant vocals and would listen again, but not really my thing.

не зашло.

This one didn’t really do much for me. The general message throughout the album was good and necessary, but it doesn’t drive the point home enough for me. 2/5

Nice melodies - sort of reminded of 80s R&B artists. Not really my type of music but pleasant enough to have on in the background. 3/5

Good voice. Not the type of music I listen too. Did not like anti-white message of the song "Interlude: Tina Taught Me". The constitution gives this artist the right to compose and write whatever she feels. That same constitution says I can rebuke her message if I so choose. Instead, I'm not going to continue listening to her racist drivel.

I've been waiting for this one to show up for a long time now, and it didn't disappoint. This reminds me a lot of CTRL, I was surprised that it came out the year before because I thought the interludes were very reminiscent of that, but I don't think that it hits quite the same highs as that one. The interludes, while interesting, I think are too numerous, and they kinda interrupt the album for me. I don't think there's a need to get rid of them, but perhaps a couple could get cut. But that's really my only complaint. Favorites: Mad, Don't Touch My Hair, Junie

Different

The album is way too repetitive but at least it makes sense

The most 2016 album of all time. Kinda incredible - basically a pop album built around a really good backup singer with a bunch of twee white 2010s Brooklyn hipsters doing production and songs which are very broadly political, but the album comes out at a time when political sentiments started expiring extremely fast but before artists realized that they shouldn't build those timely sentiments into their timeless art. Anyway. Cranes in the Sky is so awesome. Album is really bloated.

A lovely record with heartfelt interludes throughout. Carries a strong vibe from start to finish.

sosososo good

pretty nice

Dreamy and vibey pop/soul. I'm still not a fan of interludes on albums and in this case it just contributed to the already slow pace set by the songs. The songs all kind of felt the same to me and I didn't really vibe with any of them.

gibt mir bisschen Friends Who Failed At Love von Chloe Angelides vibes aber weniger touching. 2.71 Sterne

My rating 3.3

Ok, as a thirty-year-old white male in 2016, I'm keenly aware that this record isn't "for me", per se, but that hasn't really stopped me from loving it. Maybe part of that is because I'll always think of a story when I think of this album. Years ago (some context clues suggest it was around 2019), I was at home on a Friday night minding my own business, cooking dinner for myself, and planning to just spend the evening at home. I put this album on while I was cooking, and didn't think anything of it; I was cooking a normal meal for me, and just felt like listening to some chill R&B. It was either R&B or Bossa Nova, and I just felt a little more contemporary this particular evening. I'm a true "I listen to a bit of everything" person, so none of this is strange to anyone who knows me. While I was cooking, a friend of mine (black male, also early thirties) texted me to see what I was up to so I grabbed my phone to tell him exactly what I was doing. Somewhere between typing "Listening to Solange and making chicken and collard greens." and his "Bro wtf" reply, I realized the strange optics of this whole situation and had to laugh. What is my life? I know none of this is very funny to you, a stranger, but that's your loss. Anyway, this album slaps and it's been on my personal "you must hear before you die" list ever since that night.

21 songs The most mid to ever mid. Nothing stands out, just a way too long album for how boring it is.

Had no idea who or what this was, really enjoyed it. A super solid R&B album that I will likely listen to again. Just overall good production, impressive vocals, awesome features

Damn the Wayne song is awesome. This album sounds like if someone heard it and then tried to recreate it from memory, they would end up with a worse version - Mr. Morale and the Big Steppers. Such good producing and mixing. The sounds were so clear and real, there wasn't apparent quantizing or machine-ish loops; It sounds like real music played by real people. Got slightly bored towards the end. Good album though. Would listen again.

lil Wayne has never sounded better

Nicely done solange! I really liked the writing on this album

Lots of the same, fair amount of filler. I'll say 2?

Not something I would revisit but she is talented. Some cool songwriting and features. Non of it was super poppy which is good!

Was not expecting her to be on this list and she was definitely better than I expected.

Weirdly feels like a 90s R&B record, right down to the interludes. Listening to A Seat at the Table, I’m immediately hooked by the minimalist neo-soul vibe and Solange’s airy vocals. It’s a super cohesive, well-crafted project that wears its message of Black empowerment on its sleeve. "Cranes in the Sky" is a total standout, the perfect mix of chill production and deep lyrics, and it’s easy to see why this is considered a modern classic. That said, I get why some people aren't fully sold on it. The tempo is so laid-back that it can occasionally drag, and I found myself wishing for a few more catchy hooks to shake things up. Also, while the spoken-word segments definitely add to the message, they really kill the momentum and get a bit repetitive after a few listens.

Not my type

Aching vocals ambitious production very good

Very feminine album--light touches, smooth and gentle beats, delicate vocals, etc. I liked it! I thought I'd like it more, though. It was pretty long. Unlike the rest of the peanut gallery, I didn't think there were too many interludes and thought they added a lot to the album as a work. High 3, almost 4

This feels like a Dirty Projectors album

This has no fucking place on this list

Nice voice, good production, important message,but kinda one note. If it wasn't for all the spoken interludes it would be hard to tell where one track ended and another began. Not something I'll revisit. 2.5* Rounded to 2*

omg - this is a perfect album. so tied to a magical point in my life and i am so fortunate to have heard much of this album live

The album cover is a perfect encapsulation of what this album is... Solange in front of a big load of beige. She's an unexceptional vocalist singing to unexceptional music.... why is this here?!

Big ooof here, as we realise that for all of Queen Bey's undoubted pop smarts, she probably hasn't released the best album of people in her own family. This is really good from start to finish, smooth but not dull, fun but not frivolous, and varied but not unfocused. I really like it, is what I'm saying. I think that she wears the weight of the songs quite lightly, because there's no doubt that they're dripping in meaning, but the delivery isn't at all over the top. Big fan.

Smashed jay z with handbag, smashed making this record

I liked this more than I thought I would, just not quite my genre

Is something that gets better the more you listen to it just conditioning yourself to like bad music? Not sure. Either way, this got better with the second listen.

An interesting R&B album that I still don't feel I've fully gotten hold of just yet.

I like the instrumentation/production more than the vocals - Solange has kind of an “airy” voice which is pretty but seems less like a soloist voice. The songs feel more like jazzy spoken word. It’s all pleasant but not as catchy.

Very much a cohesive album. No huge singles that warrant a 5 star rating, but likewise very little that slips below a high 3. Sometimes consistency is a good thing, if it rewards the long listen.

Minnie Ripperton-esque vocals, smooth R&B instrumentation, and subtly defiant socially conscious lyrics. I'd written off Solange as a nepo-adjacent beneficiary of Beyonce (it doesn't help that Lemonade came out the same year) but this is a super solid listen that resulted in multiple tracks ending up on playlists. & god, this lyric: Man, this shit is draining But I'm not really allowed to be mad ...is such a solid truth, something I've personally said so many times (especially in a professional context). So props to Solange for speaking truth, making people who look like her feel seen & heard, and doing it in a way that almost makes you let go of being mad for a minute.

A nice voice but this album is just ordinary, boring, and not very good

Really like it

Only found out afterwards that’s she’s Beyoncé’s sister! That’s cool! There a part of me which can hear that in the music, but just as much of me likes how it has huge style difference whilst being in adjacent genres. It really gives indie for some reason??? It did drag in bits, I do feel like these sorta albums work at 40mins a lot more then 55mins

Look, it’s a powerful album that represents being proud of their blackness, which is powerful and it is evident in its how it is produced and the energy it gives off. Other than that, it’s a more modern R&B album that is just a decent pleasant listen. I just learnt that she is Beyoncé’s sister, didn’t expect that.

I was hyped to see a hip hop & soul album with female vocals in this list, but disappointment kicked in soon afterwards... The songs aren't bad, and I always love the idea of an album where songs get connected and introduced as a whole. The interludes made it a nice, more personal appraoch, but the songs themselves just didn't spark at all. Too much repetition and lack of novelty - and in the end, less than mediocre.

A Seat at the Table is slow, minimal, introspective R&B — Solange processing identity and race over sparse beats. Important themes. The music itself is a woman vocalizing over production that never quite arrives. 1/5 — the message is there. The songs aren't.

The coolest things about this: the interesting intro track and the interludes that often use snippets from interviews and connect most tracks seamlessly which I think is really cool. Also, great voice. Unfortunately most of the actual songs are pretty boring to my ears with barely anything happening beat-wise or intrumentation-wise. 2/5 - below average

7/10 - Its really beautiful at points Fav Tracks: Cranes in the Sky, Mad Heard before? ---–- ✅ Saved a Song? ----- ✅ Saved Album? --–-- ❌ Will Listen Again? -- ❌

Concious black tyyppistä hyvää musaa

I liked this!

Not bad for Beyonce's sister

A tremendous R&B album. A very hot take of mine is that this is a better album than any of her sister’s albums (hiding from the Bey-hive!). Cranes In The Sky is an incredible highlight. This isn’t everyday listening for me but it’s as well executed a concept as you’ll find in the R&B space.

I like the minimal arrangements and Solange can sing, but I'm not into this music.

Solange is one of the most underrated people in the music industry, but at least she got her flowers with this album. So well deserved. It’s just perfect: the vocals, lyrics, beats, messaging. This is a hugely important album and puts words to the feelings so many people have. Not to mention it’s just so beautifully produced. Top Songs: Cranes in the Sky, Mad, Where Do We Go, Borderline, Junie, Don’t Wish Me Well, Scales

Quite enjoyed it. Not really sure when you would listen to it in day to day life though.

It was alright I guess

It was fine, nothing more

Monotonous. Wouldn't bother with again.

Indie girl R&B that is very enjoyable

Happy almost 10 years to A Seat at the Table. I get something new from this album each time I hear it, and love it a little more with every listen. Her voice has a delicate power that shimmers in the lush production that's always just right - never over the top, but never understated. The interludes are woven in so seamlessly; I kind of experience them as a guided tour of a fine art exhibition. Knowing the historical context behind the art can broaden the understanding and experience of each piece. Also, an amazing team of artists contributed their musicianship, but I most especially love Sampha's feature. He has such an instantly recognizable voice and presence, and his tone is so heavenly. Overall, a beautiful album about claiming empowerment in a world that wants to see you fail just because of the color of your skin.

I usually reach for the skip button when I hear R&B music, but this album was really lovely listening, with a few minor unlovely moments but overall an incredibly good album.

A great album full of a mix of Solange’s smooth R&B and guest performers adding brilliant collaborations. Really great listen.

A five-star album that just isn't my thing.

This probably deserves better than simply being dismissed as "just pop music," but that's all I could really hear. I'm giving it a second listen but I'm not sure it's going to change my mind. This came and went for me without incident.

I've liked Solange before, but this kind of came and went for me. Weirdly, the interstitials stuck were more memorable than the music. None of it is bad—it just didn't hook me. Imagine being a singer and having a sister who's a generational talent and icon. Kudos to Solange for having the guts to do her own thing.

Wonderful artist. The lyrics are incredibly empowering and meaningful.

It was ok

Appreciate it, but not my speed. Didn't speak to me.

A good album that could be improved by cutting 2/3rds of the interludes. I'd love if we just cut the 47 sec-1min tracks into one song.

Great voice mixed with a rnb sound, reminds me of a more moderrn take on soul as well. Great album. I have a prefrence for female voices unless its gym noise so 5/5

A beautiful laid back RnB record. Little slower than I am used to enjoying, but the sheer quality makes up for it. Perfect to put on during a nice sunday. I adore musicians who (at least partly) produce their own music. You can feel the difference in artistic expression and cohesion in their records and Solange is a great example of this. Solanges music ofcourse draws comparison to Beyonce's records. Where Beyonce's voice is a big bombastic megaphone, Solanges voice is a clear spring filled with cool fresh water. I also rather like her approach in tackling social issues, something her sister can learn something from. People should compare Beyonce to her clearly more talented sister, not the other way around. Difficult to rate. On the one hand I don't see myself quickly putting this record on again as it just isn't music I tend to listen to, but I have to acknowledge the quality of this record. 8.5/10

A great album, powerful and personal. The music isn't big, but it knows how to properly fill in with the lyrics and the story the album tries to tell. Each song is distinct and has its own place in the album, yet they flow effortlessly into one another.

She can stand, for all I care.

Godly music, queen of beating up jay-z

A nice mix of dream pop and R&B. I liked this more than I expected but will probably not revisit much.

As someone who is indifferent to RnB and a certified Beyonce hater, I did not have high hopes for this album, but it is surprisingly a very solid album. This isn't life changing by any means, but it is leagues better than anything I've heard from Beyonce. Low 4.

This was a long 52 minutes. And, this may be an unfair hot take, but in an album supposedly in part about female empowerment, were there a lot of male voices explaining the world?

Without making the obvious comparisons, she has a nice voice but this album just drags on and on.

Was not what I was expecting from the album cover but actually quite enjoyed it. There were some really interesting beats and melodies with a black power theme

People on here claiming this is slow when it’s on such a propulsive and enveloping wavelength. Complaining about the interludes as though they weren’t thoughtfully and seamlessly counterposed against the grooves driving the record forward. Clearly one of the greatest albums of the century so far and if you can’t see it you really need to interrogate your biases, sorry.

Voice 10/10 Music 5/10 Lyrics 3/10 Lots of collaborators. Lots of spoken word bits. The singing is very good her voice soars effortlessly but to me everything else is just meh.

I won't remember any of this, but I quite enjoyed the listen

Wow. This was really great and exceded my expectations. The music is consistent throughout and alternates from more contemporary r&b and heavy snare and stand up bass. Solange's voice is great and so is the theme of black perseverance and excellence. I should have listened to this long ago.

zzzzzzzzzz

A solid album, although, in my opinion, not really too worthy to be on this list... 😀

I absolutely appreciate the message, but I didn't find the music compelling.

Langweiliges Gequietsche! Wirklich furchtbar! Wer hört sich so ein Gejammer an?

Not awful; a decent range of sounds. Def sounds like Beyoncé at times. Could absolutley do without all the “interludes” - just don’t ‘get’ those, on any album.

Nice and chilled and worth a second listen

I am waffling between a 3 and a 4 on this one. The interludes are overdone and detract, but the music is great. I am going to focus on the music.

I'm not really a fan of 10s R'n'B but I found this quite listenable and both lyrically and musically interesting.

I enjoyed it. I like her voice. Obviously nice to have a recording studio and all the tools needed from big sis, but she created her own sound. Lots of black culture education fueling the lyrics. Wish there was a more standout hit.

Oh, September 2016. Two months before “Revenge of the White Supremacy” came out and has been playing in theaters ever since. I think the cheesiness and corporatization of black empowerment in the Obama era played some part in creating the world we live in today. The little internet Nazis that have been running amok since 2016 turned into that because liberalism stopped seeming cool and young people want to be cool. This album isn’t cool. Interludes of dumb people saying dumb things isn’t cool. Boring generic bland hip hop easy listening isn’t cool. I’m not saying Solange is solely responsible for the rise of Trumpism, but she certainly didn’t help matters.

Limite 3

Gefällt mir recht gut

Overall: 8/10 This is such a chill album. I'll admit, I had my doubts about this one due to the fact that I'm not a huge Beyoncé fan, and I was afraid that this album would just be manufactured garbage. There is a bit of a glossy feel to the songs that you get from mainstream pop music, but it's mostly slow burning R&B/soul album. I think this type of music is an effective way to get her messages of black and female empowerment out there. I'm heavily impressed by her voice and style. Fav Song: Don't You Wait

Surprised at how much I enjoyed this one. Not really my thing but would happily give it another listen.

really nice

I really liked the production value on some of these tracks but honestly, this album was just exhausting to get through. So repetitive, incredibly preachy with all the interludes. Maybe it’s just how mainstream everything like this was for a decade but I really struggled to get through this one.

An album that’s easier to admire than love. It has something to say and the production is really interesting, I just wish the melodies were stronger.

Not bad, but forgettable. 2.5/5

Erykah Badu's modern competition. Hard to believe this album's a decade old.

It is not really my kind of music but elements of it were nice and it was very well crafted. It stood out from the usual R&B format

It’s ok. Not sure what about it stands out.

"It's Silk da Shocker's birthday" - Master P when on WCW Television. I didn't realize that when the Master was "making 'em say UNHHH" it was about "his pain." That sampled anecdote possessed the rare two punch combo of being a poignant statement on race as well as gut-bustingly hilarious. This record also hit me as not terrible! I saw the year and the cover and knew that it wasn't for me and as I listened, the singer expressly said that it was "for us" which I don't think includes me. While that all may be true, I couldn't hate this. The samples were varied and interesting, and I found myself actually listening to R & B vocal lines without wincing as if I'm get a tooth removed sans anaesthesia. That in itself deserves a full star upgrade. A true surprise on this dismal early summer Tuesday. 3 HIGHLIGHTS: Stop trying to touch her hair, alright? I've heard a few of those clips are LOADED with poison

6 - great voice, mediocre songs

-first time hearing Solange and i definitely understand the hype among R&B enthusiasts. i usually hate albums with a lot of interludes but i think she did it ok. really good vocals on here too -fell a liiiittle flat for me due to personal taste but i respect it a lot. i miss this type of woke -Favorites: Rise, Cranes In The Sky, Borderline

The extreme positivity around this album was excruciating when it came out but, ya know, even though she'd never again reach the heights of Losing You, this is a dang good record. As expected, crybabies in the reviews crying about Beyoncé. Sort it out fellas.

I thought this album had a fresh, more electronic, R&B sound to it. With some solid vocal work too.

Solid pop album. Cranes in the Sky is the clear stand out for me.

an audibly pretty album. the sound gets around a little, and it's exceptionally vibey overall. solange is a very good singer. Cranes in the Sky brings up a star on its own. soft 4

I almost liked it but it was too sleepy for me. The songs were pleasant but there wasn't enough cohesiveness to it all 5.6/10

Boring album with too many interludes.

This is Solange getting her wings, and girl, fly!! Fantastic vocals, great interludes, and a solid, solid record.

Not my thing.

It’s cool, it’s listenable, and it says something Very good!

The creative force of this, a neo-soul adventure into psychedelia, and the positive, empowering messages it conveys have to be acknowledged. But it's just not a style of music for me, I'm afraid.

No private session used, but I should have. I don't like R&B.

Pretty good R&B. I liked the track with Lil Wayne.

Lovely voice with sleep inducing songs.

Who? Beyonce's sister? Never heard of her or heard her. Really cool cover, what the f...?! Pure pop drivel whispered to me until I dozed off from boredom. "Cranes In The Sky" has 189M listens, why?! Do these people not have ears? She obviously cannot sing upbeat songs with range, it's all done in a super small vocal wheelhouse. At this point, I'm so irritated by this list. I haven't heard a deserving Top 1001 album in weeks -- this is what they do to prisoners when they're torturing them for secrets. 1 star. So utterly boring and downtempo. This wouldn't make anyone's Top 2002.

I listened to this two summers ago during the Apple Music GOAT countdown, before I started this project. I didn’t hate it then, but I wasn’t a huge fan either, so I was curious if 676 days of doing this generator had changed my perspective any. “Weary” kind of reminds me of something Ciara would’ve done in the early 2000s. I also forgot about the spoken word interludes setting up the subject matter for the next song, which is a pretty nice concept. Then Lil Wayne shows up on “Mad,” and that’s a bonus. The album really gets heavier with the “Tina Taught Me” interlude going into “Don’t Touch My Hair.” And that was three years before the first CROWN Act was even passed in the US, so the subject matter definitely had weight to it. This still isn’t really my genre, and would she have gotten the same record deal opportunities without her big sister being Beyoncé? Who knows. But I’ll give it 4 stars for the subject matter and the songwriting.

I connected with this. 4!

A nice album with some good social commentary. But not really my thing.

Really good songs, hate the 9 interludes

I can't relate to the subject matter at all, but the album flowed very well and Solange has a nice voice.

2026.05.18

A great album with one of the best songs of the last 10 years in "Cranes In The Sky".

Solange’s voice is angelic. The production is amazing. Not really “for me” in terms of genre but clearly a great album.

so bland and pretentious

A pleasant surprise. The list should be more like this, rather than "albums you've never heard of because they absolutely suck."

i liked this

Great songs and the production on this is kind of incredible. A lot of prescient songs, but a really timeless vibe.

Some of the song themes are weighty, but some fairly trite, and musically it lacks edge. Solange’s vocals sometimes brought Sade to mind.

A couple of tunes and I was ready to stop.

So boring, perfect for H&M. 3/5

I didn't know Beyoncé even had a sister, let alone one with a musical career. Solange Knowles does have some talent, as shown on tracks like "Cranes in the Sky". After a while, "A Seat at the Table" seems like your average modern RnB album The biggest problem with "A Seat at the Table" is the number of unnecessary interludes. They take up half of the tracklist. 3 stars for "A Seat at the Table".

So dreamy and cool girl coded

5/11/26. After listening again several years later, I'm still amazed at the production and storytelling. Severely underrated album, likely due to her more popular sister and a silly headline in the 2010s. Very proud, personal, and soulful.

Beautiful! Loved it. Im happy that thanks to this generator I finally let myself listen to it.

Good voice, boring music, the attempts at social commentary just don’t land when juxtaposed with such dull music. A double album has to contain phenomenal music to be worth hanging around for, like Songs in the Key of Life or Blonde on Blonde, this just isn’t. Too long, too dreary. 2/5 because if I was out somewhere and this was on in the background I wouldn’t be offended by it, but I’ll never choose to listen to this again.

Her music is fine, just not for me.

Solange, and thanks for all the fish! Spotify says she’s an “expectation-defying artist” which is rich since this was a real one note album. I don’t inherently have a problem with one-note, but I got really dig that note.

I liked this more than most of the soul/r&b on this list but as she said in the album, this isn’t for me

This album has had staying power for a lot of people, but I was soft on it then and softer on it now. Her voice is thin to the point of emptiness and becomes grating the more she layers it to cover for that, the production is slick but lacks the impact and spirit of its influences such as Jai Paul, Erykah Badu, D’Angelo etc. This is propped up at least in part by a parasocial cult or Knowles celebrity, I feel.

Very well produced and pleasant to listen to. But it feels like she hiring all the coolest collaborators and producers of the time to make something very calculated and on brand so it lacks a certain spirit.

musica de niñas, chill, casual, nada de mi estilo, 1/5

She doesn't have as good a voice as her sister, but you can tell that she understands music. Or she had a lot of help. Or both, honestly. Musically, this album is pretty incredible, and pair that with its messaging and celebrating of black culture and music, and I'm a big fan. This is sick. The beats are incredible; the music is really well crafted. There's a lot of great interludes about living as a black person/musician in an inherently racist world. It's a really great album. Her voice does hold it back a bit for me, but it's fairly insignificant, because I do think that her voice works really well in the style. Also, the middle of the album gets... I know it's also a bit outdated, but I can't find a better word... PHAT. There's just no better word I can think of to describe music that's slow tempo but still really beat heavy. Favorite Song(s): Cranes in the Sky, Where Do We Go, F.U.B.U

Decent. ei oikein muuta sanottavaa.

Smooth and easy listening music with no really excellent stand out songs. Some of the more soul like songs were nice and the singers voice is really good. I just weren't hooked by anything.

Great voice with good vibes

Important topics addressed by an able singer in a style that wasn’t for me.

Don't Wish Me Well was the only song that stood out in a formless sea of pretty vocals.

Yowza mama. This fucks heavy. Its like old school R&B charm, flow and production rolled up and delivered on a platinum piece of alien spaceware. I'm very impressed by the song structure, the melody, the instrumentation. The pacing is aces. This album is an instant 5 stars and I'm probably gonna hone in on this.

Not bad. Always hard to rate songs where I'm sure it's just that the genre isn't my thing. I'm sure if I was looking for something in this genre this would fit the bill but overall it is just okay.

Double blind. I was aware of the existence of Solange but was not aware that she had music worthy of inclusion on this list. It’s not my favorite but I understand why it’s on the list. It feels like an obvious homage to “The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill”, between the smooth vocals and the filler tracks. It seems like Solange has done a good job of living up to her own last name, while creating music that feels uniquely her own

I think I'll stick with Beyonce

Weird album for me. I can tell the music is quite good but it’s absolutely not my style… too moany etc High 3*/5

This album is super pretentious. There’s lots of weird interludes, the beats are super boring. The artist has a really amazing voice, but she uses it sparingly, none of the songs are catchy. I really don’t think this is my kind of music.

Solange's life experience is very different from mine, and I respect what she's trying to do, but I'm not sure the music matches the message. Actually, it's low-key enough that I get the self-care and maybe grief, but not anger. Maybe determination and strength. I was unaware that she's Beyonce's sister. Guess that's where the high energy in the Knowles family went, as my kids are very different, too. Cranes in the Sky was really the only memorable tune for me. The interviews with her parents on the interludes were nice, but otherwise, the interludes felt like a forced attempt to create some flow on an album that was often repetitive.

How can you make good vocalist sound this dull. Absolutely nothing going for it.

Ok album with good execution of having a story in it. The music it self didn't really work for me and I felt it tad bit boring but it definitely wasn't bad. 2,5/5 but I'll round to 2 as I feel it wasn't quite worthy of 3.

2.3 2x youtube -- not great

There are a number of concepts in this album - all of which are good but not fully realized. Choose one, make it tighter and it's a great album.

This was decent. You can tell she's Beyonce's sister, their voices sound similar. The interludes were kind of Lauryn Hill-ish.

Important story

I didn’t realise before listening that Solange is Beyoncé’s sister. Going in, I wasn’t sure this would be my kind of album, but I was open to it. Overall, it’s a very pleasant and easy listen. Solange has a great voice, and the production is smooth, polished, and really well put together. There’s also a clear social message running through the album, which adds depth and purpose. That said, nothing really jumped out at me as a standout moment or a track I’d go back to. It all blends together a bit too much. There are some solid collaborations throughout, and while the album is consistently good, it never quite reaches that “wow” level for me. Interestingly, I’d say this is better than any album I’ve heard from Beyoncé, even if it didn’t fully connect with me. Favourite tracks: Nothing really stood out, but everything was a decent listen Least favourite tracks: Same as above, nothing I’d single out either way Album artwork: A standard cover, nothing particularly memorable

Not my thing. Good voice though

No soy muy fan del r&b, pero es un álbum que esta muy bien

Smooth listening and good vibes. Love the collaborations.

Modern version of "The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill".

It was an ok album, I felt parts got a little long but didn’t hate it.

Deep. Helps me understand what some folks have to go through, and we absolutely need constant reminders. Which sucks. Hopefully there will be change someday. Oh, also great music by a excellent singer. Solange delivers her message in a sweet-tasting way, making it easy to listen to - gets your attention, makes it enjoyable while not berating or lecturing. Just brings you to the experience.

smooth 7/10 Will I add this album to my library? maybe

Muzikaal niet onaardig, relaxte R&B, niet al te veel geklets. Wel weer een boel preken. Neem dan op z'n minst de moeite om de preek op muziek te zetten.

Zoveel producers en dan nog zo saai. Dan zit die saaiheid toch intrinsiek in de zangeres zelf...

Een zangeres die alleen haar voornaam gebruikt. Dat is redelijk hip. En ook hier hebben we er daar al veel van gehad. Het gebruik van autotune valt in dit geval gelukkig mee, dus in die zin is het beter te pruimen dan sommige andere over het paard getilde vergelijkbare muziek. Maar ik merk dat ik dit gewoon totaal oninteressant vind en vooral heel erg saai. Misschien dat ik anders zou piepen als het om NL muziek zou gaan. Want ik denk dat het voor ons veel interessanter is om Froukje, S10 en bijv Merol te luisteren, dan deze Amerikaanse equivalenten. Daar kan Solange niks aan doen, die is gewoon uitgekozen door ome Robert en zijn snobberige kornuiten en die hebben zich nooit verdiept in onze nederpop. Gemiste kans zou ik zeggen. Een ietwat saaie en oninteressante 2 sterren. Ik luister het wel uit, maar ik ben blij op het moment dat ik weer iets anders op kan zetten.

This is a really great album, musically interesting and beautiful, deeply personal and broadly social and historical. Usually I dislike interludes between songs, but in this album I really enjoy them, and don't constantly feel the urge to skip to the next track. 4.5/5. probably belongs on the Must Hear list, but I think I'm rounding down.