Reviews (page 3 of 8)
Musically is very very good! Greatly layered with such soothing vocals mixing R&B and pop and a bit hip hop. Not much my taste but i get it.
The production was really nice but overall I was lukewarm about the album.
Message is fine but this reinforces that I don't like this type of music
Yeah listened to this for the first time recently and enjoyed it so much. One of those “woah” moments. 4.8/5.0 Best Song: borderline
Really good stuff, listened to it recently and enjoyed it, enjoyed on this listen to. Really great gear
I think this is quite well regarded. To me this production never really works, feels like a collage of layers more than a track often. Probably I am missing some musical context.
I've never heard of this artist, but enjoyed the album.
Smoooooooooth. Everything from the instrumentals to lyrics to vocals work together beautifully. This is an album arranged so meticulously that there’s no altering the set list- it needs to be exactly the way it is, and that’s not been true very often for the other albums we’ve covered so far. I also really like the interludes because while they don’t necessarily need to be here to get the themes across, their inclusion still really ties the album together while walking the walk. It would have been a crime not to include this album.
An absolutely beautiful work of art. Solange's voice commands attention but never takes attention away from some of the incredible production beneath her. The inclusion of so many interludes adds a sense of clarity to the album's themes and message and makes the album stand out in the world of pop.
What she talks about is really important and good to hear, but overall I didn’t like the album that much. There are some great moments, but also some parts I really didn’t enjoy. 2.5/5
Bedroom pop from the House of Knowles. What I like best about this album is the juxtaposition between its indie, Casiotone moments; its empowered neo-soul moments; and the deep history of the interlude stories. I think there are so many artists of the subsequent decade we wouldn’t have heard without this album creating that template. That she’s Beyoncé’s little sister just adds to the achievement, because she went so quiet and subtle when the family brand is bodacious. I might consider it more of a 4.5 than a 5 because no song quite measures up with “Cranes in the Sky” but I’m bumping it up to a 5 for her artistic vision and influence. Even as a suburban white dude, something about this album made me say, “Yes, she did it, now what can I do?”
R&B, nice voice
There are times when the production and sound of this is fantastic...and there are other times when I'm just bored. R&B tends to go that way for me.
I swear I heard the Bulls championship song in here. Lots of interesting coming up stories. Some OK harmonies. Respect for a release looking at the list of Divas from 2016.
Don't think I've ever heard Solange Knowles sing before but I really enjoyed this album. Nice and eclectic. The interludes I thought added a great deal, broke up the songs and was a nice way to introduce the next number. Lovely voice.
Many albums i’ve listened to were set in different cultures, like most hip-hop and country music, but I still enjoyed the music and understood the message. This album, though culturally different, I did not enjoy. Probably the best thing about this album were the beats. Everything else on this album fell flat. There was no discernible melody and it was so subdued as to be sleepy and boring. However, she’s a vast improvement over her sister.
the messaging is clear, but the listening experience as a whole is just good, not spectacular.
Music was meh but I gave her an extra star for beating up JayZ
It's so annoying to finally listen to an album you've been meaning to check out for 10 years only to realize it kind of super sucks. This would be 2 stars but it does bring a smile to my face to think about Solange beating the shit out of Jay-Z in that elevator, so she gets 3 stars for throwing hands like the true ride or die bitch she is.
2.5
Mycket intressant med ett ganska nytt album. RnB, Beyonces syster. Lugna låtar och beats men blir aldrig riktigt ointressant. Kul med "interluden" med kommentarer. Tydligt tema på svartas situation, rasism osv. Hög nivå på produktionen. Kanske inte lyssnar på hela igen. 3:a
I understand the appeal but it's really not for me.
Deux albums de néo-soul en 3 jours et je pense que je peux conclure sans me tromper que le genre n'est tout simplement pas fait pour moi. Celui-ci était beaucoup plus dépouillé musicalement que celui que j'ai entendu avant-hier, mais il se distingue par une construction un peu différente, avec de nombreux interludes avec des gens qui parlent de racisme (et qui en parlent bien, d'ailleurs). Le reste du temps, j'ai pas fait attention aux paroles, mais des chansons comme "Don't Touch My Hair", me font me dire que c'est l'un des grands thèmes d'A Seat at the Table. Si le côté politiquement chargé me plaît, au niveau strictement musical, ça ne me parle tout simplement pas. 3, parce que je ne pense pas qu'il s'agisse d'un mauvais album, bien au contraire, mais sur ce site, je note avec un peu plus de subjectivité que je le ferais ailleurs.
My new conspiracy theory is that solange's sound completely reinvented Tyler the Creator into making Flower Boy. The timelines don't really line up but I don't care. This is a great instrumental album, the vocals are wonderful, the messaging is fantastic, but nothing here hits me in a way where I feel a need to listen to any of it again. I think this falls squarely into the beautiful tier list that is growing in popularity of "albums I can listen to with my wife in the car and we both enjoy it."
Boring. After five tracks, the album started to get on my nerves. 2/5
1001 Albums Vol. 0037: A Seat At The Table ============================================================ Introduction: Ack! Oh, well it seems that time is...relatively normal again? I mean, car models look relatively...modern even though I don't see any Cyber Trucks. Um...oh wait. I know exactly what year it is now...Markiplier has red hair and I know the lore of Markimoo better than anyone so that means we must be in 2016...specifically after March of 2016. So um...yeah, here we ar-.....Wait...Oh...um...hello? I think I heard something clanking around in this box of text? Um...maybe not. We'll just keep going for now. Anyway, the year is 2016. The Zika Virus is running rampant, South Park airs its weakest season up until that point, Gen Alpha has just begun to grow out of being toddlers so they can wipe their grubbly evolved hands all over their phone screens, and Donald Trump...wait...actually he hadn't won yet because we're in September of that year. But most historically important of all, Solange would release A Seat At The Table that year! And trust me, this changed the trajectory of the entire fucking worl-! What the hell?! I....It-It's the clanking again. This time it was louder and sounded...a lot more echoey? Is there like...something in the walls of the text box or something? Okay...we're going to need to try and get through this intro fast. So um...yeah Solange released A Seat At The Table in 2016. And it apparently even won a Grammy Award too...huh? A rare instance where we're giving musical awards which are actually deserving I see. You know, musical Grammy Awards really should be reinvented or at least a few categories should be added. Like of course Sabrina fucking Carpenter is going to get nominated while artists that are objectively better like...I don't know...Geese are not. And awards like that keep encouraging artists like Sabrina to keep pumping out the same bad music and the cycle just continues and goes on and on and on and on and...yeah...I'll digress for now...just one of the many flawed things about the music industry. So um...anyway...yeah, the album. Like I was saying, it changed the trajectory of the entire world! And while that may be an over exaggeration, it at least attempted to have a huge impact on its listeners and the world around it which is more than I can say about a lot of albums that were made around this era. How? Well, very similarly to To Pimp A Butterfly released the year before, the album covers themes of Black empowerment, history, and experience in the questionaly great U.S.A. And...well...um...I won't even lie, something like this would probably be enough to make me like an album already, especially if its lyrics are well-written. I mean, albums like this are very typically some of the most personable and genuine stuff you can find in the industry which is something that I generally love and respect. There...are some pretty...obvious exceptions to this rule...Nostalgia Critic...oop...I didn't mean to say that. But um...yeah, there's just something about albums like these that hit in a very different sort of way. And, combine this with an actually interesting setup we have going here, and you hav-oh wait? What's the setup? Well, silly reader, clearly you haven't been keeping up with our amazing series of album reviews we have going on here. Why, I'm talking about hearing the evolution of Soul music across the span of 50 years of course. But really, the one Ray Charles album on this site was the last album I generated and now we timeskip 50 years in the future to see how far Soul has come since that album. That's...kinda the setup and the hook that I'm going to create here because I really don't have all that much else otherwise. I think I've used the "apparently this album is pretty good but let's see" hook way too much already and we're only like 30 albums in! So um...yeah, I really don't have much else to say, so let's jus- just...there...there's something in the text box. It just happened again.The clanking. There-.....................There's something in here with me....I'm gonna....go ahead and switch over to my phone now and start the album on Spotify, rate tracks along the way like always and just...just see if anything's happened when I come back for the conclusion. Yeah, let's just....let's just go ahead and...yeah. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Track 1: Rise: 8/10 Track 2: Weary: 8/10 Track 3: Interlude: The Glory Is In You: 6/10 Track 4: Cranes In The Sky: 10/10 Track 5: Interlude: Dad Was Mad: 7/10 Track 6: Mad: 9/10 Track 7: Don't You Wait: 9/10 Track 8: Interlude: Tina Taught Me: 8/10 Track 9: Don't Touch My Hair: 9/10 Track 10: Interlude: This Moment: 7/10 Track 11: Where Do We Go: 8/10 Track 12: Interlude: For Us By Us: 6/10 Track 13: F.U.B.U.: 8/10 Track 14: Borderline (An Ode To Self Care): 8/10 Track 15: Interlude: I Got So Much Magic, You Can Have It: 6/10 Track 16: Junie: 8/10 Track 17: Interlude: No Limits: 6/10 Track 18: Don't Wish Me Well: 9/10 Track 19: Interlude: Pedestals: 8/10 Track 20: Scales: 7/10 Track 21: Closing: The Chosen Ones: 7/10 ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Conclusion: Okay...I...I just re-read the intro after listening to the album and everything seems relatively...normal. I think my wording is about right and nothing...seems to be changed. Alright. I think we're good for now. I'll...try to keep this review more brief than my previous have been because I just want to get out of here. So um...yeah, here we go with the album. And...well...I won't lie, after listening to it, I really don't feel like I'm the most qualified person to really even be reviewing it. And, of course, I don't mean that in a bad way at all. I'll be honest, I'm a cisgender White male, so there's just...plenty of stuff on this album that won't quite resonate as deeply with me as I imagine it would for someone who is part of the Black community. And that's completely okay. There were still plenty of moments across this album that did have a genuine effect on me either simply because I agreed with the message or I could relate it back to my own life in some way. Basically, point is, there are some aspects of this album that I might just...ignore without meaning to or not understand the true meaning of. But regardless, I'm still going to explain to the best of my ability what this album did well for me without overreaching into topics that I can only pretend as if I understand and never likely truly will. Okay? Got it? Alright. Cool. So...um I'm going to go ahead and delve into simpler topics first like the music and production before I get into the more complex subjects so as to kind of warm myself and my voice up. And, well, first things first, I think I quite literally just the voice of an angel for the past forty minutes. And I'm not even really exaggerating. I normally discuss the music first but I just have to praise Solange's voice before anything else because OH MY GOD. This girl...this girl can FUCKING sing. Okay, seriously though, she is undoubtedly THE best singer we have come across on this site so far and may genuinely be the best singer I have heard of all time period. I mean like, I don't really think I have to say anything more than Cranes In The Sky's outro to prove my point but I guess I will because the review calls for it. So, yeah, on top of Cranes In The Sky having the most angelic vocal performance I can recall hearing in recent memory, Solange is also able to perfectly mix her voice in a similarly transient yet fitting way in pretty much every other song heard on this album. I haven't quite touched on it yet and I will soon, but there's a pretty wide variety of Neo-Soul, Pop, R&B you can find on this album. Some melodies are more intimate and quiet while some try to sound more energetic and pretty. Regardless, Solange is perfectly able to retain her more than angelic tone while flawlessly adapting her voice to fit the changes in music as well. I mean, I can't really describe it all that well here and would more than recommend you just hear for yourself, but she's just able to keep that same beautiful tone and quick pitch shifting across the entire album...a-and...and you have s-such clean delivery as well and- I'm not blushing, what? I'm not. Really....um...so-...okay fine, maybe, just maybe I kinda find good singers to be attractive. I mean, I can say without a doubt that singers like Robert Smith move a whole point up for me simply because of how unbelievably good his voice is. But um...yeah...okay...calm down...yeah, regardless, Solange's voice is just great. I would genuinely recommend you listen to this album just for her voice if for nothing else and would at least suggest you to give Cranes In The Sky a chance at bare minimum. There's just something about her voice that I can't quite describe here that elevates it above all other singers I've heard. So, yeah, that's that. And now the glaze ends and we can finally shift focus to the music before we touch on the general themes of this album. So, is the music anywhere near as perfect as our lady of the day's vocals?.......Well, no. I'll just keep it straight. But I mean the bar was as high as the...the cranes in the sky anyway so like that's not an insult at all. In fact, literally just take a glimpse at my ratings and you can tell that I actually find the music here to be quite appealing. As stated above, there's a fair mix of Pop, R&B, and Soul across the album, and all of it works insanely well. You have laid-back and quiet songs such as Weary or Rise, more energetic melodies such as FUBU, and just a good mix of stuff in between as well. Despite this, every track just has this very distinct intimate feel to its music that works really well in unison with the album's themes...of which we will get to in a bit....It just feels like every track was made with the intention of the listener being able to fully catch every detail of the song without too much effort and I just...I really like it. It gives the already artsy melodies across the album an even more experimental and almost Folk-like feel to it in the way that the lyrics are meant to take the foreground and not the melody....Of course, that's not...the exact case here. I mean, I would say the music and lyrics are about equal in terms of the musical intensity but I digress. And...OH MY GOD. Don't even get me started on the production. Okay. I'm going to have to hold myself back here because I have talked and talked and talked about how much I love the style of production this album uses in the pas-...You know what, screw it. I'm going to label this style of production the "Melody A.M." production seeing as that was my first album with this style. What does the Melody A.M. stamp of approval, you ask? Well, basically, think of a cocoon. You are trapped inside, the space is enclosed, and you can probably die from a solid object the size of a golf ball being thrown at you...okay, that last part may be unneeded but still you get the point. Basically, you have a speaker inside of that cocoon with you and...well...this album's playing. Do you get it?...No...maybe...oh...alright. Layman I get it. Alright, so basically what I'm trying to say is that this album just has a very entangling kind of production to it. A kind of style to its sound that can very easily pull you away from anything you are doing and thoroughly engross you in its sound...which kinda sucks in this case because I usually have the album on as background when I write these but in this case it's literally just too distracting. It almost feels as if the sound of the album is like its own fleshed out world that you kinda just want to...find a portal too and delve into...Okay look, I am actually trying my hardest to explain this style of production here but I literally can't think of the words or metaphors to describe it properly or in a layman way. If you really care that much, just listen to Eple off of Melody A.M. and you should hopefully get what I'm saying. Basically, to truly put it into layman's the point I'm trying to make is that the album sounds great. Very good producing and mixing that I find to be genuinely praiseworthy...Um...okay, so that's music and production checked off, double whammy there...oh...okay...now it's time for me to get serious for a bit as we turn our attention to this album's themes and lyrics. Okay...just...switching hats....alright. I have a tophat on now, my serious hat. Alright, so just as a reminder, there are probably going to be things that I glaze over or don't understand fully here but I do hope to give my best analysis possible. And also, I should have said this earlier, but I am in complete support of pretty much all things Civil Rights and equality. "We should be judged on our character and not our physical appearance" is a statement that I firmly agree with and stand by. So, it should come as no surprise that I can resonate with a lot of stuff on this album even if I am not its target audience. Something that I haven't mentioned yet but are a crucial part of the album as a whole are the interludes. As pretty much all interludes do, they serve as a transition between tracks. Yet here, they serve as Spoken Word segments meant to describe themes of racism and Black empowerment with a bit of backing instrumentation. While these interludes are definitely the weakest part of the album in terms of music, they completely make up for it with their very powerful, moving, and fearless messages. Take Tina Taught Me as an example. It boldly pushes back against the entire claim for a "need" for White History Month in a way that you really couldn't argue with even if you wanted to. And the same thing goes for all of the interludes. They all have these very deep and empowering messages that just work perfectly in unison with the album. And, pretty much every musically-focused track has similar messages albeit with a more poetic tone to their lyrics and music. And like I said, I really don't understand some of these songs or their lyrics fully. Hell, I had to look up Junie simply because I didn't get it at all. Ironically, that specific track is meant to be about people who claim to be in the Black empowerment movement but don't truly understand it...which...who knows...maybe that's me but I digress. But regardless, something that I really like about Solange's lyrics is that, while they are aimed towards Black empowerment, they can have a very personal meaning for pretty much anyone no matter who you are. I can relate songs like Cranes In The Sky or Don't Wish Me Well back to my life and my struggles pretty easily. And that's why I think this album is as effective as it is in a lot of ways. It has a target audience in mind, yet it is able to deeply speak beyond that target audience at the same time with minimal effort. And...well...yeah...the lyrics and especially the themes are just amazing as well. Alright...cool...now let me just walk back over to the coat rack...top hat...comes off...and...maybe I should switch it up with a Fred Durst ballcap for my final few sentences...alright...yeah.........there we go. Okay. Yo! What's up everybody! Are we ready to get this party start-.....Oh....god....I forgot about that...the clanking. I.......okay um...I....seriously need to......okay it's non-stop now......why is this......why is-...............I-Listen, Lester, do not be afraid of my text. I-How?-Be still, Lester. Let your heart be quiet for a moment. Do not be ashamed of your dread. But f-I need to go to the next album. Get rid of this now. ============================================================ A Seat At The Table: 8/10 Song Average: 7.7/10
hard not to compare her to her sister, but sounds like she could've used some of the projection lessons her mum had already obviously paid for. She's got a great voice but I wish there was better production at times.
In think this does what it aims to do very well. But what it aims to do is not for me. I added “Cranes at the Table” to my Generator playlist.
3.5 perfectly enjoyable
Really good! Great RnB album with really unique tracks, I listened to this twice through. Easily 80/100
Quite a talented lady
great message... not particularly great music. interesting interludes. 2.5
Number: 96 Date: 04/08/2026 Artist: Solange Album: A Seat at the Table Year: 2016 Genre: Pop Soul Rating: 2 Notes: Before: ======= Solange, never heard of her. Wow, 2016. This is the most recent album I've had so far. This better be good. During: ======= Six songs in now. So far all 3's or 2's. It's OK as background music. In that spirit, let's get some other stuff done whilst I listen to the rest of the album. How's about we check my personal top 10 albums of 2016 against the 1001 list. Admittedly, they are all very "white" with the exception of Xenia Rubinos. Angel Olsen "MY WOMAN" Autolux "PUSSY'S DEAD" Living Hour "Living Hour" Lambchop "FLOTUS" Michael Nau "Mowing" Band of Horses "Why Are You OK" Thee Oh Sees "A Weird Exits" Xenia Rubinos "Black Terry Cat" Kevin Morby "Singing Saw" TOY "Clear Shot" None of these artists are even on the list at all, except for Lambchop, and it's a different album from them, "Nixon". My ratings for this album: 3 Rise 3 Weary 3 Interlude: The Glory Is In You 3 Cranes In The Sky 2 Interlude: Dad Was Mad 3 Mad 3 Don't You Wait 3 Interlude: Tina Taught Me 3 Don't Touch My Hair 3 Interlude: This Moment 4 Where Do We Go 3 Interlude: For Us By Us 3 F.U.B.U. 3 Borderline (An Ode To Self Care) 3 Interlude: I Got So Much Magic, You Can Have It 3 Junie 3 Interlude: No Limits 3 Don't Wish Me Well 3 Interlude: Pedestals 2 Scales 3 Closing: The Chosen Ones ----------------------------------------------------- 3.00 WEIGHTED AVERAGE (accounts for song lengths) After : ======= Oh, so her sister's Beyonce? That's interesting. Overall, I found the music on this album to be nice but nothing really special that would make me want to listen to it again. 3 my personal rating 1 suitability for this list 2 impact ----------------------------------------------- 2 composite rating
When the beat drops, this is a solid album with an important message. However, slow R&B never did it for me, and a lot of this one is exactly that. The comparisons to her (admittedly more talented) sister are inevitable, but at least Solange has carved her own path.
I can see why some people same that Solange's music is better than Beyonce's.
Criticising this as the sole product of being related to Beyoncé seems incredibly reductive. Is it the greatest album ever? No, but it does have some pretty great production and featured performances. It lacks dynamism and everything is maybe overly mellow, but I’d struggle to be upset if anyone popped this on as background music. I can’t even find it in me to be upset by the multiple interlude tracks. I came in thinking I’d be making a snarkier review where I’d shove 8 of my own interludes in. But they barely take up any time, are woven into the tracks, and aren’t filled with content designed to shock like many male artists historically seem to find so amusing. They all offer insight and positivity and I’m not so cynical that I can’t find value in that.
So beautiful
I liked it. Didn't love it.
This is far better than how others have rated this. She's a great voice and the production is great but no real change in tempo and the voice over things get in the way. Done on other albums too. Use a song to connect the story. You don't need to do this
This wasn't bad at all, but no clue why it was included on the list.
I recognise is an album full of meaning but i didn’t find a song that stuck in my head
It's aight, but it's boring
I actually like her music more than other similar artists, like her sister.
Pretty damn bad and thinks it’s special
You aren't allowed a seat, Blancmange Knowles. Fisher price 'my first r&b' ass beats
Oh man. I've always heard this album's great, but I've never been a big R&B fan. But listening to it now. I get it. It's incredibly smooth. A little jazzy at times with songs like Where Do We Go, a lot of soul and R&B. Just a great vibe throughout the whole thing. Definitely an album I'll go back to and pick apart.
So boring and repetitiiiiiiiiiive boriiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiing But yes, I understand she has a good voice,but man, this was so boring, can't remember a thing and... I could easily die without this experience! 2/5 because of the voice, and that's it
Beautiful, well produced and well sung album. It was dreamy and funky and I just floated through it's tracklist in bliss
I don't know why but I was captivated by this album. I chalk it up to be that I just love R&B and the interludes were pretty interesting.
I hadn't ever heard of this album before, and what a pleasant surprise it was! The music is beautiful and the message is strong. I actually really liked the way the interludes fit into this album, they worked pretty well as transitions between tracks. Favorite tracks: "Cranes in the Sky," "Don't Wish Me Well"
This is good…is something that people who like this would say, but unfortunately this isn’t really my thing. In fairness, it had its plus points in production etc but I lost interest after the first few tracks.
listened to this a few days ago and didn't have anything bad to say but already can't really remember anything about it. so that's the review.
What a superb record celebrating heritage with catchy but emotionally charged performances
A great album. Was really refreshing to get something truly modern also. Top notch storytelling, great production and performances, cool historical callbacks and interludes. The real ones know who the best Knowles sister is.
I liked this more than I expected. A lot of lyrics I could relate to, and really just a great, melodic listen.
Well produced with nice vocals. 3.6/5.
Een prettige ervaring. Zou me ook wat moeten verdiepen in de teksten. Thema ‘black’ komt regelmatig naar voren. Bij eerste keer luisteren is het ook wel een beetje kabbelend.
Dit album is op mij gaan groeien. James blake achtige beats. Het genre wat ik leuk vind. Het album heeft mij wel verrast. De derde keer was het leukst. Ik snap alleen niet dat er tegenwoordig zoveel voicememo’s op albums staan. Ik geef het 4,5 sterren. Misschien later de volledige 5 sterren.
Had hier hoge verwachtingen van. Ik heb mijzelf moeten forceren om dit album na de eerste teleurstelling nog twee keer te luisteren. Het is een bijzonder persoonlijk en ook maatschappelijk boeiend album. Ik moet heel erg mijn best doen om dit er uit te halen omdat ik het stemgeluid en stijl bijzonder onaangenaam vind. De r&b vibrato is iets wat ik altijd als heel storend heb ervaren. Icm met het zachte en bijna hijgerige sla ik de meeste nummers het liefst over. Het is wel jammer want ook de productie is best goed met mooie arrangementen. Deze review heeft niks met kwaliteit te maken. Ik bezit simpelweg de capaciteit niet om deze muziek te waarderen en hierdoor mis ik ook een groot gedeelte van de boodschap. Ik kan wel begrijpen dat dit voor veel mensen een bijzonder album is.
Ik vond het tof om eens goed in dit album te duiken. Ik wist natuurlijk dat Solange de zus is van Beyoncé, maar ik had me nooit echt in haar muziek verdiept. Verrassend album. De sound past perfect bij haar stem: warm, dromerig en soms bijna fragiel, maar wel met een duidelijke identiteit. Het geheel voelt heel consistent en verveelt niet. Er zit genoeg afwisseling in om het interessant te houden zonder dat het zijn sfeer verliest. Wat ook blijft hangen zijn de thema’s. De interludes met voice notes voegen echt iets toe. Het voelt niet belerend, maar roept wel iets op van bewustwording zonder dat het geforceerd aanvoelt.
a beautiful tribute to the challenges of black creatives
Fell asleep halfway through so it gets three stars
I don't listen to much R&B but this album is great. Soothing, soulful, comforting.
Ноунейм залупа, которую зачем вообще включили сюда
ok
Good vibes
Powerful themes, angelic singing, and beautiful piano. The transitions on this album were so seamless and perfect. However, the songs were kind of samey and none of them really jump out, making it hard to actually pick a favorite. Favorite Track: Borderline (An Ode to Self Care)
4/10 Best songs: F.U.B.U., Scales As the album very clearly states: "this shit is for us." I, unfortunately, am not part of "us," which makes me conflicted about whether or not I should even be reviewing this album. Anyways! I don't really like the album (it's too downbeat, repetitive, and some parts just bash you over the head because they are oh-so meaningful, which makes me irrationally annoyed), but I do think the production is great and I wouldn't be surprised at all if people find it important and meaningful. I just find it a bit dull and obvious, too lowkey and unemotional, with pointless interludes. Not my favorite.
Bello, ci stavano anche le 4
4 maybe a bit more.
Nice message packed into "Fitting Room Music". Boring beyond boring. Nothing about this is remotely rememberable.
This is a strange one for me. Solange has a nice voice, even if it is relatively unremarkable. She probably is good enough to get a record deal without her famous sister, though she undoubtedly gets elevated company support via that relationship. That’s not her fault, of course, take advantage of it when you can get it. That said, this is far from a great album, certainly not worthy of inclusion on this or any other best album list. This is evidenced by this having exactly a 3 star rating across all users as of the time of this review. I can’t help but think that its inclusion is because people want to seem like they are cool by listing it. When you listen to it, really listen to it, there is nothing here that is different or special vs. what countless others could produce. I could name 100 female singers who are better than her off the top of my head. I think my problem is what she sings about and the lack of real character or pain her voice just doesn’t jive. Add in the interludes which are just dumb. If she was doing them, fine. But other people making the atatements they are, when she is getting as favorable treatment as she possibly could? It just doesn’t track at all. It all adds up to someone trying way too hard to be anything other than ordinary, which is all that she is. Not that this album is horrific. Again, she is a decent singer. I like piano based tracks but all of the playing sounds pretty homogenous and a bit sleepy. Don’t You Wait was probably my favorite on this. 2 stars.
To jest wielowarstwowe
Very good album. It’s not my style, but I enjoyed it. I also thought the concept was very important. 4 stars
Cool
Pretty easy and languid R&B and soul. Solange seems very interested in her albums reaching a very niche audience but one that will understand her. It’s not me.
4.5/5
Slow, low key R&B isn't really my thing. There are some more interesting sounding tracks on the album, but all together I wasn't really into it. The lyrics and messaging are good and will resonate with some. I'm not the target audience here. It's nice pleasant listening overall, but not anything I'd seek out. I generally hate spoken word interludes on albums as they tend to throw off the flow, and that kinda irked me here, but it actually wasn't too bad; the segues between songs were pretty well done. Hate to bring it up but it's the elephant in the room: I wonder if this album would exist without the Knowles name attached. That's all I got, 2/5.
Not for me
10/02/2026 *1. rise - her singing is absolutely lovely, love the drums and bass together. piano is nice as well. 2. weary - bass is nice again. as nice as it is, it sounds like something that would play in the back of a primark... 3. interlude: the glory is in you - spoken word interludes.... ok.... *4. cranes in the sky - drums are nice in this one with the strings.... really liking this one. love her voice in the chorus. 5. interlude: dad was mad - more political now... 6. mad - liking this one but not mad about the rapping sections... her voice is so lovely <3 all of the songs are starting to get a bit samey, which isn't great this early on.... beat and piano is very 24 hour lofi study music 7. don't you wait - liking it, but would maybe like it more if it had louder moments.... her singing is very soft, would maybe stop it being so monotonous? 8. interlude: tina taught me - wonder where these clips are from... will look it up after listening. 9. don't touch my hair - like the horns in this one... not as big a fan of the sound of this one. a bit too inoffensive and mellow and a bit repetitive towards the end. *10. interlude: this moment - love the power of the horns at the start... 11. where do we go - love the piano immediately. very samesy still... 12. interlude: for us by us - 13. f.u.b.u - like the horns again. feels like the one explicit song on the album... lyrics stand out more than some of the other songs though. *14. borderline (an ode to self care) - piano and bass are reaally nice together. beat is nice. bit repetetive again... 15. interlude: i got so much magic, you can have it - 16. junie - like how all the tracks are fading into one another. still a bit boring. 17. interlude: no limits - 18. don't wish me well - low organs(?) at the start are nice. like the kindof ominous vibe. verse just started, ominous vibe has already evaporated. 19. interlude: pedestals - 20. scales - nice, but over this album at this point... 21. closing: the chosen ones - horns are nice again. as much as listening to this was nice, it felt a bit bloated and definitely fizzed out massively towards the end. the constant gentleness in her voice was lovely, but the album then lacked a lot of power, which made it feel a bit monotonous. really liked the interludes and the first and fourth tracks though!
Nicely written and recorded. Not facile pop. Borrows a load from some outstanding contemporaries without being as essential
It's better than I expected, but I'm not sure it's special. HOLY SHIT - they selected this album but there is no Lemonade by Beyonce? No Blonde by Frank Ocean? That is extremely wild. Those albums were released the same year. Blonde is a masterpiece that resonates over culture and music to this day, and Lemonade was an extremely massive hit that moved mountains when it was released. They selected 3 albums from 2016 and while Blackstar absolutely deserves to be here, they easily could have dropped their FIFTH Leonard Cohen album and included Blonde - an album you absolutely need to hear before you die. Even though I'm almost 850 albums in, I'm considering just stopping. This project has lost all legitimacy.
Nepotism. 3. Just kidding. This isn't really my thing, and I'm not sure how qualified I am to critique it. I loved her voice, and liked much of the album. But didn't really love any of it. Can't go as high as four, and don't want to go as low as three. So 3.65
very refined and relaxing R&B here. lots of very graceful tracks with lots of interludes every few songs... i can definitely hear why this album got to the top spot on the billboard, with its production value and large center on identity. this album also has a large number of features from other artists which is cool too!
The supporting cast of special guests helps to keep this one fresh
Gotta admit, I didn't listen to this super closely. I can hear the family resemblance, a little.
I had never listened to her before. She sounds a bit like a next generation Sade. I like the inclusion of spoken word.
She's got a great voice, interesting that it progressed to a lot of black life subjects, learnt a bunch!
Any sleepier and I might have passed out behind the wheel.
Not for me.
Not bad, interludes between pretty much every song create an interesting flow. Seems frontloaded maybe? Almost funny how similar her voice is to Beyonce's Deserves another listen but I know deep down that I won't
didnt really enjoy this on AM top 100 either, maybe the message is just missed on me but i just felt like this dragged a lot. I say this as someone who would actively describe themselves as "woke" but this kinda feels like its here because its "woke" and not because its a good album. i find the songs to be just a bit boring and dont really enjoy her voice that much 1/5
It was fine, but forgettable.
Liked her previous work. A lot of jazzy vibes here but some songs are exceptional
Every ear locates the line where smooth becomes boring at a slightly different place, but any album that is consistent in its pacing and spare in its production is going to open itself up to this criticism. The final determination depends on which way we turn the gem in the light to see what reflects and refracts for us, since it's often the other facets of the record that inform our decision. I appreciate this record's reserve and subtle choices, but I am not floored by it. Listening to this album 10 years after its release, I think there's a version of it that's close to what we have here but that comes in at a tight 42 mins and is sequenced to move us more. This circles back to the line of thinking between smooth/boring — when your songs are this similar, where the differences are small, the sequencing is even more critical. I think this record ultimately lets us down and jeopardizes its longevity by not being leaner and more intentional with its macro editorial decisions.
Notable for its ability to be inoffensive and yet completely unengaging in almost every regard. I get the intent and the narrative but I actually have to be interested in the music to follow along with it, and frankly I'm not.
Listening session: march 1st, while running errands Listened to before: no Thoughts: going into this I kept in mind that Solange has had advantages because of het sister, but this album was actually quite nice to listen to Favourite tracks: Cranes in the Sky, Mad & Borderline (An Ode to Self Care)
Прикольно, но всё-таки за этим столом я лишний
First time hearing her... literally. Girl... what are those harmonies? This is rich as fuck. I love neo-soul, contemporary R&B, it's so full of breath and space to exist. Maybe not innovative for its time, but it's solid, well done and pleasant. One note: usually it's hard to like a rapper in such a fairy/magic vibe, but Lil Wayne? The man got the vibe. This album is a warm room with good lighting. But it's a bit repetitive,I don't know if that's intentional, like a meditative thing, but it made it feel monotonous at points. A little more dynamic range would've taken it further. Extra point for Elevator Queen, luv anyone who punches Jay-Z.
Not for me. Ordinary at best. Nothing new. Pseudo racism wisdom inserts to pad it out.
Soft-spoken alternative R&B built from airy synth pads, minimal percussion, warm bass pulses, and spacious, uncluttered production, paired with hushed, intimate vocals, moves like sitting alone in a quiet room after a long day—calm, deliberate, and emotionally focused, prioritizing mood and reflection over immediacy or dramatic release.
lowkey langweilig, die themen sind aber wichtig
Better than her sis.
Nice times and words but not my style really :) thx
I can appreciate Solange has a great voice and the production on A Seat at the Table is pretty crisp. This album is not for me, I am not a fan of R&B and I don’t believe this is bad but I don’t like listening to this. There is the odd beat that draws interest but as a whole I’m bored by what’s happening, it’s not interesting and I don’t care for it. 2 stars
Great voice, nothing special musically
An understated neo-soul album with a relaxed, chill, almost dreamy vibe; while lyrics and themes are heavily grounded in reality, difficult truths, and empowerment. The vocals are the selling point, with a pretty, wispy tone and backup vocals that add really rich harmonic and melodic textures. The songs are spacious, but my problem was I didn’t consistently feel that groove deeply - the songs didn’t draw me into the pocket. That really made a lot of the songs uninteresting to me, starting to blend together as the album went on. I could see what people enjoy, and didn’t dislike it, but am unlikely to think of it much again.
Not really my favorite style of music, but I enjoyed this.
One that could grow on me with further listening.
Unexpectedly good. I like the interludes a lot, especially from Master P. Love that guy, well used to high school anyway. Sitting at 3.5 solid stars..going to tip it over after another listen on day #2.
Cool sounding album, with some great social commentary. Dig the interludes, and there's obviously musical talent here.
Ahí nomas
I liked the interludes and thought they were more interesting than the rest of the album, which admittedly isn't saying much. "Where Do We Go" was okay and the driving beat was nice. The rest of this was bland and uninspiring. It was more exciting lyrically than musically, but I feel like she could have pushed more with the lyrics also. Her voice is pretty, but nothing spectacular.
This was a very well constructed album, everything flowed together intentionally. Not my style, but I respect that design. 3/5 stars.
This seems like a more chill Beyonce to me. If you described this album to me, I would think it was right up my alley. Nothing here makes me think this is a must listen album. Confused as to why it is in the list. Not groundbreaking and not influential, rather it is influenced by others. I really like the themes discussed on the album, but it still does not make me want to re-listen. Even lil Wayne and Q-Tip doesn’t save it for me.
Pretty generic R&B.
Like all the latter-day Beyoncé albums, this is the dull, navel-gazing bullshit of people privileged by their fame and class trying to make "art" without thinking too hard about what art actually is. Better than Beyoncé's crappy albums, at least.
I'm kind of surprised we don't get any of Beyonce's most ambitious albums on this list? Anyway, A Seat at the Table feels less immediate than the songs I've heard from Beyonce's albums, but I like it! Nothing really stuck out in particular honestly, but I'm just a fan in general of how neo-soul albums sound and Solange has a good voice.
Абсолютно не мое. Еле высидел. Теперь не буду писать "не мой жанр", так как открыл Эрику Баду, ее музыка для меня в миллион раз интереснее.
Жесть, этому альбому уже 10 лет…. Помню как его хайпили во время выхода. Спустя декаду звучит так же приятно, лайфово, актуально и красиво. Хорошее все-таки было десятилетие. Второй ее альбом 2019 года тоже классный. В тысячу раз вайбовее всего творчества систы….
Красивый взрослый альбом, с каждым прослушиванием все больший отклик во мне находит. Намного интереснее всего, что делала ее сестра. Жаль, что Соланж давно ничего нового уже не выпускала. 4 отметеленных Jay-Z в лифте из 5
Лучшая песня: хз Худшая: хз Лучше, чем любой альбом бейонсе, что я слышал, но ничего особенного. Понятно, почему его сюда добавили, но если я слушаю NWA, я им верю, а миллионерше дочке миллиардера-продюсера - не очень
Вайб определенно присутствует, но всё ещё не мой. Хотелось бы поставить альбому больше, но не могу. Забавно как все объединились в шейде бульёнсе.
хорошо, но видимо не совсем мой жанр музыки, поставил бы 3.5 если было можно
Этот альбом удачно вышел в эпоху хайпа вокруг интимного рнб. При повторном прослушивании обнаружила, что активно слушала его в год выхода, но ничего особо о нем не помню. Бейонсе стёрла память людям, чтобы они забыли о куда более талантливой музыке её сестры? Но показалось, что альбома слишком много, к концу уже начала уставать, но в целом на уровне недавнего lp от Эрики Баду для меня. Здорово, что в челендже есть и новые альбомы, я думала, что подборка закончилась на 2015
Красиво, фоново, скучновато. На фоне безликих блюз-рок альбомов из списка - альбом 2016 года в стиле нео-соул выгодно отличается и сначала я даже хотел поставить 4, но увы - по мне не дотягивает. В целом звучит приятно, но очень много скипов для меня. Еще хочу вставить слово в защиту Бетонце. Думаю, если бы она хотела записать такой альбом - она бы с легкостью записала, но она находится на мейнстримной стороне музыки и выбирает хиты. За что ей и спасибо (не считая последнего кантри-альбома).
Sehr geiler Sound, hat mir unglaublich gut gefallen - 5 Sterne
Musik ganz ok, die Interludes fand ich langweilig und selbstgefällig.
Same wie Thomas
Nice voice, ok songs, nothing stood out. Kind of dated. Kind of tired.
Enjoyed, wouldn’t return.
Nice R&D album. Unfortunately I am not a R&D lover.
She has a nice voice, but there is nothing here that suggests it should be anywhere near a list like this.
Yeah but nah no really
Inoffensive but symptomatic of the need to add semi popular shite in later editions of the book to justify a reissue.
- Kunne godt lide det
I enjoyed this more than most of what I’ve heard from Beyonce actually
I get why I never actually paid attention to this before, but it was surprisingly pleasant to focus on.
nepotism at its finest
Started off really strongly with Rise, which immediately caught our attention and had us ready for a high-quality album. Unfortunately, it didn't live up to this initial high and we found the rest of the album slightly mediocre.
This sounds like Christina Aguilera on benzodiazepines. This is the most boring and restrained shit I have heard in my life.
Bey's sister got pipes.
loved this, her voice is so good
Not bad, just not good. A bit of a yawn fest
some really good R&B music in here. really love the melodies and smooth vibes. too many interludes though, it took me out of the flow of the album. love the harmonies and vocals. she can really sing! 7/10
This was ok! Pretty but didn't pull me under or ear worm its way into my memory.
Beyoncé: easy listen Her sister: exciting listen Real Talented family fr fr
I knew this was popular, but hadn’t listened before. Really nice, and Cranes in the Sky was a highlight.
Cool, experimental and interesting. I don't think I'll come back to it, but I enjoyed it.
It's fine, but it seems like the critical claim was mostly for the lyrics. Nothing on this album is as good as 'Losing You', which is a genuinely great song.
The sentiment of this album is really strong, which means that the backing track has to be bland. Solange’s vocals are Beyoncé, but she is a thousand times more impactful.
In this game you cannot be too extreme (Throbbing Gristle, Einstürzende Neubauten, etc) or too subtle. If you listen in there is so much to discover in this album's arrangements never mind the personal and political in the lyrics.
This is ass. Nice voice but she’s just doing stuff with it with no intention or structure
216/1001 Solange - A Seat at the Table Heard before? ❎ Revisit? ❎ This is absolutely fine. Whilst I agree with the sentiment of the lyrics, it's watered down by the somewhat samey style of music that's carrying it (not that I dislike it at all). It's not surprising to me in the least, that the only song from the album I've heard prior to this is Cranes In The Sky, which is really the only standout track.
Better than Coldplay
Listened to half one day and the rest another and really just never got into it. There were a couple of things I liked, mainly with the delayed guitars. Wouldn't relisten, I kept finding myself waiting for it to be over:/
Solid album Unique listening experience with the structure and interludes Celebrates blackness and culture She has a great voice I liked When I Get Home a little more
It’s a vibe
This is fine, I suppose. It's tasteful, but nothing sticks. It bores me.
An unexpected gem. Really enjoyable rnb with elements of soul.
3.5/5. A well produced modern R&B album which deals in themes such as self healing and black empowerment. Was maybe a bit longer than it needed to be IMO but when it hits there is some great songs to be found like “weary” or “FUBU.”
Actually, I liked it more than I thought. Message was strong. Laid back musically. Maybe at times, too laid back but it suited the material better than throbbing synth pop beats. Too many interludes made it bloated but this was an okay album, even though it's not in my wheelhouse.
Great voice but I could care…not much.
Soulful
Loved the style and sound, production was a bit too much at times and I’m not big on the interludes, but still good overall
relaxing and beautiful
I like it. I appreciate the more stripped down arrangements compared to other similar pop albums. I could have used more Q-Tip on that one track.
Was going to give a 3 for the nice music but the commentary on the Black experience and history elevates it.
If she wasn't Beyonce's sister would this album have ever been made? I'll give it to her that she wrote all the lyrics herself. That said, there were a couple of songs I enjoyed on this album, but overall for me this was a flop.
I loved this album. That said, I don’t think I’d ever listen to it again. But I loved the vibe and the production. I couldn’t even pick out a single from the record, but it flowed from front to back extremely well. After sitting on my thoughts overnight, I confirm my stance. This is a really good album.
Has some ok songs. Would be good background music if it wasn’t for the spoken sections.
I liked the activism in this album, but I can’t say the same for the music itself. I don’t know what it was; it could be the slow tempo, the unexciting melody, or how similar all of the songs were, but it just didn’t hit. It was still a good listen, though. I really liked the way they faded the songs together; it was really well “built” as an album. It felt so much shorter than it was since I lost track of how many songs I’d listened to, because I didn’t even know when a song started or ended. It was just that well blended.
FINALLY an album I like from a genre I love! Solange is Solange. The dialogue interludes created an atmosphere that evokes this feeling of the power and history of being black - so beautifully put together! 'Cranes in the Sky' is just so amazing. This might be the first album that I agree everyone should listen to before they die - it's a very important listen - it's what being black is all about.
Really nice with a great mix of funk, neo soul, psychedelic soul and contemporary R&B!
Un bell’album rnb, non sono sicuro rientri tra i 1000 album da sentire prima di morire
Ok, I can give it credit for being an important document for black women and black people in general, but I’m neither of those things and I’m judging this on musical merit. It’s shit. It’s like a LiveLaughLove sticker in musical form. It’s for people that have French bulldogs, or drive poverty spec white Range Rover Evoques on finance, or live in new build greige boxes on soulless estates. And it’s 51 minutes long, and has 18 producers credited on Wikipedia - something something cooks something something broth.
Destiny Childs lite? No thanks.
Did not enjoy this but better than some of the others I have listened to hence the 2 star rating defo would not recommend
Even with 3 breaks, I found this album interminable. Solange's singing style is fine enough but her voice is so thin. She doesn't demonstrate she is capable of anything bigger and more dynamic. This becomes grating especially with a 51 minutes long album. You wonder if this was over praised due to her last name being Knowles. The production is pretty good but seems wasted here.
No Thanks!!
This isn’t my genre, but Solange has a pretty voice and I liked the vibe of this album
The spoken-word passages are powerful and moving. The songs are horribly dull.
Fav song borderline
Solange’s voice is gorgeous. It’s so delicate but also powerful. The Sampha feature is amazing I didn’t know they had a song together but their styles work so well combined. It’s hard to explain what’s so nice about this album but it’s beautifully constructed and it feels very clean. Lil Wayne feature is fun too. Fav songs: weary, cranes in the sky, mad
Fine. Can't believe this is on here but not beyonce yet!
I'm not a massive fan of pop music, and less so of R 'n' B, that said, I have a formula for assessing whether an album of this style has any merit and that is to imagine what would be left to listen to if the vocals are removed... In this case, there's very little substance to the music, in fact it's barely more than a backing bedtrack; a few pops and beats. She can sing, that's not in question, but as an artistic package, this album is weak. Heard before ❌️ Listened this time ✅️ Revisit ❌️ Unremarkable ★★☆☆☆ (3/10) Total reviewed : 206 Already owned : 46 Purchased : 8 To buy list : 6 Nope : 146
Chill r&b
Almost 10 years old, but it still sounds as fresh as the day it dropped. 4.5 bumped up to 5.
I’m at a 5. This is, much like “Untitled (Black Is)”, an album about black positivity, black excellence, and black affirmation. I am a half-Filipino, white-passing male. I once again fully acknowledge that I can’t ever fully relate to this album, or the black experience, but I can continue to listen and do my part to make this world a better place, and that includes lifting up albums like this that so deeply acknowledges what it is to be black, both in the positives & the negatives, and share a better understanding of that experience. It does a pretty good job of expressing that experience – while it doesn’t feel as vividly & as dazzlingly painted as what SAULT did, this takes a much more confidently feminine approach, portraying a sort of softer simmered anger about the day-to-day microaggressions that simply come with being black in this country. It’s not going for the jugular here; it’s just asking to be heard out, and it’s more than worth hearing out, from both a messaging standpoint & a musical standpoint. It’s certainly worth hearing out from a production standpoint; Solange is not her sister and it shows, with this album drawing more from the indie hip-hop scene of the 2010s, with a touch of TPaB’s jazzier influence in there. The synth / bass / percussion work that underlines a lot of these tracks is quintessentially 2016 to my ears, and with the recent trend going around, it does feel kinda nice to go back to this style. The main 12 tracks here are all pretty good; Solange’s vocals shine through like a star, occasionally pretty comparable to her sister in its most tender harmonies. The lyrics are great, and I don’t think there’s ever a dull moment of repetition like that; it’s constantly moving forward, much like she is on “Don’t Wish Me Well”. All of the features here kill it, even if I wish some of them had more to them (Andre 3000 on “Junie” is criminally underutilized & Q-Tip feels barely present on “Borderline”), but the whole album flows really well with Solange as the star. I’d be remiss to not mention the interludes at some point – sure, it’s a little strange for Master P’s life story to take over most of them, but I think it works as a good contrast to show a bonafide success story, & with his own relationship to the family, it fits pretty well in the context of the album. I do think there might be a few too many interludes in a way that messes with the pacing of the album, but it’s never egregious. They certainly don’t ruin the quality of any of the main 12 tracks, with the transitions between them usually flowing well. Ultimately then, I’m at a 5. It’s not a super dazzling cultural phenomenon of a 5 like her sister dropped earlier in 2016 (it is criminal that “Lemonade” isn’t here given some of the hand-in-hand themes at play here), but it’s a tightly written, tightly composed album that still shines uniquely in its own way, & one that I think is worth being on the list. It’s a super strong album without a single miss throughout the 51 minutes here. The floor is a 3 if you just don’t vibe with it musically.
Surprisingly good pop album. This exceeded my expectations and I would listen to it again.
Liked the production and message
My daughter listens to a lot of “pop radio,” and I think Solange is as good as, if not better than, most of the so-called divas I overhear several times a day. In addition to a seat at the table, she definitely deserves more air-time around here.
I agree with the statement, but I didn’t find the music very compelling.
Good singer. Songwriting is uneven. All the interludes detract from the music. 3.5*
Didn’t listen
Women on this list are so rare, so I’m really trying my hardest to like them when an album pops up, but I just can’t. There’s no way. It’s just too boring for me, too samey in places. I’m still trying to understand how this guy picks the albums. I’m not saying this woman isn’t talented just because it’s not my style. Maybe other people dig this. I’m just saying there are so many incredible women who didn’t make the list, and I just don’t get why. Like, no offense to Solange, but I’ve never heard of her (I’m not American). This is the first time I’m finding out she’s Beyoncé’s sister, who, mind you, only has one album on here (one with Destiny’s Child too, I think), while some guys have five to seven albums. Lady Gaga has none. Shakira has none. Whitney Houston has none. Cher has none. Shania Twain has none. RIHANNA HAS NONE, AND SHE IS ARTIST NUMBER SIX IN THE WHOLE FUCKING WORLD ON SPOTIFY. The list can go on for days. You don’t have to like the work of these women to recognize that they are more influential than, no kidding, 40% of this list (maybe even more, but I’m not trying to exaggerate too much). As a woman, I’m just so disappointed in this guy and his list. Barely any representation for women, for other countries, other ethnicities. It’s just British and American crap over and over and over again. I’m so fucking tired. Even the genres aren’t that diverse. The same three seem to be more prevalent on here, and I HATE IT.
such a sweet sound 4.5
Boring AF
I found this to be a bit boring. Otherwise it's alright.
An introspective soul/RnB album with some social commentary. The album is pretty atmospheric, so it would probably create a chill vibe if that’s what you’re looking for.
Nice voice and production, but boring to me. Kinda bland R&B. 2*
I'm almost starting to believe people only made R'n'B in the past 10 years
Honestly cant remember a single song after listening to it
BeYAWNce
Holy interlude. Tons of filler. With a good voice and a sister like Beyoncé I can see why she’s so sad. Couple songs added to the rotation.
This album is very well constructed and meant to take you on a journey of sound, empowerment and grief. And I do think it does that. Her voice is like an angel and the sound was chill and relaxed. However with the way the interludes and tracks drifted in and out of each other there were no stand out songs and it all blended together. It got kind of old after a while and the album is very long.
3/5 Amazing, soothing vocals. The entire album was incredibly chill, and it was made clear the political stance it took. However, nothing jumped out at me and it was as a result, quite boring musically. I was wanting it to end after a certain point.
3.5
superb album. deserves its spot on the list. i loved how you can really see the work that solange poured into this and how interwoven the story she is trying to communicate with her features and collaborators. the interludes (fav was the tina interlude) fit in well with the piece and it really explores the inner workings of the album, the message, and solange herself. top tracks: crane in the sky- love that bassline. funky song that is very melodic. where do we go : these harmonies….. borderline: love the jazzy piano!! fubu: slow, very smooth
This is so disrespectful to other albums. Nowhere being a classic. 3.96
really nice, 3 stars
Her voice is beautiful however every song sounds basically the same. Booooooooooring.
Mmh...I like it...surprise myself
El disco es tan excitante como la portada. Es decir, nada. Un continuo de ritmos lentos y coros repetitivos para dar un sermón insoportable. El recurso de la sección de metales con un tipo recitando la última idea que ha tenido sobre el mundo está ya un poco gastado. Para algo así hecho con gusto me pongo a Gil Scott Heron.
Solange is a new artist for me. I know she has a famous sister, and that some critics liked at least one of her albums. No, this is not for me. I get that others see the value in her voice, the production and the samples, but for me it gets soo boring.
The promise fulfilled by When I Get Home
This was fine. I feel like I appreciate this even though I am white but also because I am white, I felt that I couldn't appreciate it to it's fullest abilities. I like the song "Cranes in the Sky." One of my yoga instructors at Core Power, Jennifer B, alwayasss played this song and it reminds me of her and Chicago and Core Power.
Not my thing
Really unique production, awesome features including Sampha! Definitely was feeling this one
Some really solid songs on here. Gotta admit, however, that the interludes didn't add much to the experience for me.
The subject matter sounds great, but I remain unfamiliar with R&B as a genre so it all sort of washes over me. I did figure out that R&B sounds terrible through tinny phone speakers though - I'll listen to future R&B albums through hewadphones or decent speakers. I enjoyed it much more once there was some decent bass.
So I have never listened to this album before, admittedly because she is Beyonce’s sister, and I just am not a fan of Beyonce. So when I saw this pop up, I acquiesced and said sure, let’s give this album its fair shot. I must say Solange’s voice is so much better to listen to. If I had one issue here, is that I felt the album started off a bit weakly, but it gets stronger as it goes on. Don’t think this will be one I go back to often, but I’m glad I finally listened to it, because it was enjoyable. 3.5 / 5
South London soul type music, good at what it does but not me.
Babymaking music
TPAB if it fucking sucked:
Low 3. Bored
👎🏻
This was really interesting. I expected it to be striving to be a pop album of songs written to be “hits”, but it’s original, different and brilliant for what it is. I would have never been exposed to this had it not featured on this list. A worthy 3.
Just not a fan of this vibe. I can't tell if it is "good" but I don't like it, or if it was a not good, or I just don't get it.
Not my style but a lot of talent here. 1/5 didn’t finish the album 2/5 didn’t keep the album 3/5 kept it and will listen when songs randomly show up on shuffle 4/5 kept it and will listen to it again front to back on my phone 5/5 buying the vinyl
Between 2006-2017 I listened to very little music. In high school I basically listened to only 4 bands and some random scraps of music I picked up from commercials or YouTube videos. In 2009 I stopped listening to music all together and became exclusively a podcast guy. It is funny to me now that one of the rare albums I actually listened to during the dark age was this album. Somehow SOLANGE KNOWLES pushed through the barrier?
I can appreciate this but just not for me.
A wonderful, musical insight into the experience of so many Americans.
Not nearly as bad as I was expecting after I visibly winced when this generated, but I would never willingly listen to this again. Quite generic.
Great voice, strong message, not enough variety in the music. Just an hour of mid-tempo R&B that just faded into the background. The interludes were interesting, and brought more context to the themes of the album, but don't help raise it above a middling album for me.
Very cool and chill, also very funky and groovy. I liked it a lot!
Hadn't heard this one before, really liking a lot of these songs
Went into this with a more negative frame of mind since I really don't care about Beyonce or pop music, but was pleasantly surprised by it. This is probably better than anything I've heard by Beyonce, but it's still not my style of music at all.
I guess according to this list I hate soul music? Which couldn't be further from the truth really. I have heard of her before but only now learned she is Beyonce's sister, if that matters. Music is alright, production is slick as most pop records these days really so I can't increase rating based just on that. Probably 2 stars for this one, dont even care to finish listening to it.
Don't get me wrong, she has a great voice. But it sounds so over produced, I feel like it was created to be nominated for a Grammy. Side note. After reading the album article, it did win a Grammy, so I guess I was right.
It was fine. I liked the sound of it a lot but there wasn’t a lot of variety between each song so it was hard to pick out individual songs that I liked more than others
I recently have had this, and The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill, which at face value may be somewhat similar. However, not so! This is so much more interesting musically, lyrically, production, the whole thing. Some of the guest spots can be a bit annoying, and the interludes and some of the songs drag a bit towards the end of the record, but I really enjoyed this.
This one started off real strong. I felt it lose potency along the way, and by the last few tracks I was hoping it to finish. Maybe I need to let the details seep in a little more, or maybe it'd actually be beneficial to shave off 5 minutes somehow. I find it very strong conceptually, being brought to the adult table, listening in on family and the hows and whys we are often excluded from at a young age. In that sense it's a beautiful piece, very emotionally aware, very open and intimate. 3.8/5
very pleasant listen
A well produced neo-soul / R&B fusion, full of introspection on black culture and identity in America. Ahead of it's time at release in 2016, predating the reckoning of BLM that would come a bit later, for better or worse. The sonic space of the songs is rich yet contained, with indie influence from the likes of Dirty Projectors/Vampire Weekend/Chairlift collaborators. The interludes are very welcome, speaking to Solange's theses and connecting everything together. Nothing aside from Cranes In The Sky jumps out as a sticky melody to me but impressive as a whole.
She has a pleasant enough voice, I liked it more than the last soulless hard sell album on here by her sister. There is nothing here that makes me dislike it, but nothing of interest either, the music is so pedestrian I have no interest in listen if she has anything to say. It’s not my thing and leave it at that. 2 Star
Even without considering that I don’t usually listen to R&B, this album didn’t really appeal to me, and I didn’t find any tracks that left a lasting impression. Sorry!
What a beautiful voice but its very repetitive and nothing ever jumps out at you. The interludes are weird and obviously have a very strong theme but feels like just illustrates the lack of story telling if you feel they are needed to spell out what should be said through the music. Having said that I still enjoyed it.
themes of racial identity and struggle. interesting stuff.
Boring
"If you don't understand my record, you don't understand me, so this is not for you." Fair enough. But since I had to hear this before I died, I'll give it a review anyway. Maybe as an artistic statement this would be OK, but musically speaking, it's not particularly interesting nor enjoyable. I don't think we've had another album whose songs felt THIS samey over and over again. Furthermore, I get that the interludes are adding context to the songs, but if the songs, themselves, were stronger, then there wouldn't be a need to prop them up so blatantly. We've seen this interlude/skit formula a number of times now, and in all cases, it just ends up derailing the flow and detracting from the overall experience. So yeah, I guess I don't understand this; ergo, this was not for me. Here. You can have it back now.
I couldn’t really get out of my mind that these were songs AI created if you asked. It all felt so repetitive, and generic. A superficial approach to topics that should have more weight to it. Disappointed in this one.
It's fine r&b. It was enjoyable but not something that really blew me away. That said, I don't love this genre so maybe it's me?
seriously ??
I only really knew "Cranes in the Sky" going into this, and I did like the album, but it’s just not really my thing. It's refined and subtle, and there's a real calm, crafted feel to the whole thing. But for me it stayed more in the "I respect this" zone than something I'd come back to a lot. "Cranes in the Sky" is still the standout, and hearing it in context does make it hit a bit harder, but the rest didn't fully click with my tastes. Really well made, just not quite my scene.
Not for me.
She has a good voice, but nothing about this music drew me in. Just seemed like standard R&B singing over random noises.
Every song sounded like a chorus and a rap song, like filler. Also, how many interludes does one album need?
3.5
8/10 Favorites: Mad Don’t Wish Me Well
It is the instrumentation that lifts this album as much as anything else. Solange’s vocals are good but i fear against a normal pop/rnb production they would be lost in the numbers of similar artists. However the production on this is great and elevates each song to make them interesting and complement Solange’s vocals perfectly.
Despite being somewhat vaguely aware that Solange Knowles had a singing career of her own, my actual knowledge of her was limited to the fact she is Beyoncé’s sister and, once, whacked Jay-Z in a lift. Needless to say, I wasn’t sure what I thought when this popped up. Whilst it definitely falls into the category of albums which I question their inclusion in this generator, it was a very nice R&B album to have on whilst I pottered. I liked her vocal style, she kept her songs to a reasonable length, and had good artists as featured acts. It didn’t feel like there were 21 tracks to get through, nor did I find I wanted the album to hurry up. As always, I could do without the interludes, even if I did find one by Tina Knowles rather interesting to listen to. There were also way too many of them and I’m not sure that they added anything.
I obviously know who she is, but had never listened to anything by Solange. Somewhat unsurprisingly she has a lovely voice, so it hung on the instrumentation and songwriting for me. Well mostly, given I'm on record as finding interludes incredibly annoying. I still find interludes incredibly annoying. This is alright but not particularly interesting. I listened to it on a long train journey, and coupled with the gentle rocking of the train (something that always makes me a bit tired), this record really made me want a snooze. I only really perked up at one point. I am too white to type out the actual lyric, but at one point I thought she was singing "All my knickers around the world" and I had to check. Nice voice, just not for me. 2/5
Started at a boring 2 star effort, clearly lots of money spent on production but you can't really polish a turd can you. Got progressively worse as guest artists introduced their own mumblings.
mid
I’ve enjoyed some work in the past but stylistically this was just okay to me.
Cranes in the sky one of the best songs of 21st century Lacks a punch a bit overall but still great listen Cant fully relate to the message due to my demography Junie is great
I enjoyed this more than I thought I would. It’s pretty good. All the political stuff was lost on me though.
Laid back smooth RnB. Easy listening, but without any edges. Boring to some extend
Not my favorite genre but this album was really well done. I like the weird instrument in Junie.
Wow. Great! Think Anita Baker, May J Blige, Roberta Flack, etc. Great voice, nice music. A bit racist, as expected……
In the words of a great poet “Now I be kickin’ shit like Solange in the elevator” This album is very smooth. The transitions between songs and interludes have a great flow, the drums and bass compliment her voice well and the featured artists do a good job. Any album that features Sampha is good in my book. Favorite songs were Cranes In The Sky, Mad, Don’t Touch My Hair, and Junie.
J’ai beaucoup aimé!
Good vibes and good beats but a lot of racial content made it hard to penetrate the themes.
Not really my jam/seemed a little repetitive, but enjoyed it. Nice vocals, good lyrics.
Pretty good album. Vocals are airy and lush, the production is clean bouncy and crispy, and the overall sound is very professional. The meaning and message of this album hits deep with topics about the KKK as-well as black culture/ community. Overall really good album 4/5.
I had heard of Solange before, but never listened to her. Glad I did, because this is great
Artiste inconnue. Rien d'original dans cet album terriblement long (21 morceaux !). Sa voix est plutôt agréable mais l'accompagnement ne présente rien de bien intéressant. Je me suis très vite ennuyé, tellement vite que je ne suis pas allé au bout. L'album sera vite oublié. =>1/5
Yes, yes, a thousand times yes! The most impeccable vibes. Solange had one album in her and it was this one.
Suena muy angelical, muy soul, armonioso, quizás no si siente una diferencia profunda entre las canciones, siento que es un álbum hecho para escuchar de principio a fin, porque suena como una sola canción
not for me
Já havia ouvido antes, porém, desta vez a sensação foi diferente. Consegui perceber melhor a voz deliciosa da Solange, em harmonia com a melodia incrível, criando uma atmosfera única. Album coeso e gostoso de ouvir. R&B de altíssima qualidade.
No
Not seeing this as anything special in the least
A good more modern day R&B / pop album. Had some good guest appearances too. I probably won’t ever listen to these songs again, but I didn’t mind listening to this all the way through!
This was pretty good and fresh after boring boring, rock music.
What a beautiful sound. The music is rooted in easygoing grooves with deep, funky bass lines. And Solange floats over all of it, sounding ethereal. The style is a mix of R&B, jazz, funk, and pop. It’s a distinct sound and I love putting it on and just soaking in it. Great album cover. I love how those hair clips look like butterflies.
When I saw this album cover I was immediately brought back to the time period when it came out, as I had a bunch of friends who loved this album and recommended it to me. Unfortunately it was put in the backlog and I never got to it but I'm happy to be listening to it now! Right away I'm pulled in, she's got a great voice, the music is a bit sparse but blooms in a really nice organic manner. I'm going to get picky already on the second track, "Weary". There's this type of drum beat that I like here that is very specific- a subdivided tom groove. It's nice! But when it goes throughout a whole song and never gives me any snare it ultimately feels kind of anticlimactic. This is a personal taste thing, but it's something that's always bothered me a little bit with these types of grooves- when you get teased that there's a snare coming (or some kind of higher pitched percussion sound) but it never comes. I absolutely love in track 3 "Cranes in the Sky", right at 1:33 the drummer loses the tempo slightly and they left it in. I love little human elements like these and I love the idea of leaving it in and not "fixing" it in a period of time where most music is overly quantized. Awesome! Unfortunately the more I listen the more I'm realizing that this album doesn't give me enough compositionally. There's so many good ideas in it, there's so many beautiful parts and layers, but I so often want Solange to just give me a good verse with good lyrics and to keep it in my head after the song is over. Too often by the middle part of the album did I find myself thinking "ah yea here we go another vowel vocal section with a bunch of layers that doesn't do much besides show me her technical prowess". I hate that I'm being a hater with it, but it's too much of a security blanket for her. Not sure what to do with the next part in the song? Just add in another "oooh" "aah" part with a bunch of layers and call it a day. Sometimes I feel bad for docking some points on these reviews when I'm mentioning a facet that might very well be that artists "thing" or "sound", but if I get a whole album where I expect a song to explode or move or change and I get given this same color over and over I really can't help but be let down. By the end I'm a little bit frustrated. Her voice is amazing; it is smooth, subtle when she wants it to be, and in the front of the mix when she wants. The band is very tight, and yet still very human and organic sounding. I just want some more composition, I want some more songs. Still, this album is a 4/5 for me. My critique is hitting an artist that has a great sound and my only frustration is that it could have been even better.
A 2016 period piece
I listened to this album a few times over different days. I feel like I should really like it, but I'm struggling to extract much out of it. Mostly I find it a bit boring, that is, hard to cling on to something and hear what everyone else is. This is one I plan to return to with fresher ears, but right now it's sitting pretty average.
I dig, however I don't understand what makes this significant enough for the list. Going 3, solid average.
It was surprisingly good actually, I was expecting... I don't know what but this was way better than I thought it would be.
Fine. A little non descript
Let's get the one detail out of the way when discussing Solange that is gonna loom over. She is indeed the younger sister of Beyoncé. In fact, she started as a backup dancer for Destiny's Child before signing to their father's record label, and her first solo release was very much in line with the hip-hop-inspired R&B of the era her sister thrived in. But that's where the comparisons largely stop. Solange followed up with a more tasteful retro-throwback record and subsequent EP, and then this record won a ton of critical acclaim. So, what did we get with A Seat at the Table? Well, this is the kind of record that I feel is going to work wonders in terms of the content more than the presentation. With that said, let's start with that content. If there's one aspect that remains true throughout the listen, Solange is direct in her social commentary, sprinkling in both well-spoken connecting interludes and some surprisingly poignant guest verses from Lil' Wayne on "Mad" and the team-up of BJ the Chicago Kid and The-Dream on "F.U.B.U.". That commentary in question being healing and self-empowerment, by black women, for black women, reclaiming an inner peace in spite of a world that would choose to ignore, erase, or marginalize them. Now, I have to admit that I'm not the intended audience - I'm a white guy, plain and simple. But that doesn't mean I can't respect and even appreciate the plight, especially with how straightforward and insightful Solange cuts into. From dealing with the frustration to explain herself to a friend on "Mad", to being done compromising herself to satisfy other people on "Don't You Wait" and "Don't Touch My Hair", to carving out her own path and choosing to leave people behind on "F.U.B.U.", the larger theme is Solange moving on, not caring if a white audience that may have loved her previous work won't get on board with this new direction. On the flip side, with cuts like "Junie" opposite and uncredited André 3000 about cultural appropriation, and her mother's spoken interlude "Tina Taught Me" about how black positivity is not the same as reverse racism, it's clear she's not against white culture enjoying or embracing her music... it's just that they're not going to be the focus anymore in her life. This album is very acute in its uncompromising position, probably the closest I could get to feeling how black audiences feel when culture ignores them entirely. I don't mind being on the outside looking in to try and understand. Also helping matters is how much I like the production throughout this record - the sharper snares that crop up on "Rise" as Solange accepts her own vulnerability, the presence of cello on "Cranes in the Sky" as she searches for her escape, the sandy yet blocky beat on "Mad", the brash piano strokes against the kick beat on "Where Do We Go", the heavy presence of synths and supple bass on "Don't You Wait" that also show up on the funky "Junie" and the sharper electronic tinge of "Don't Wish Me Well". Even if I wasn't much into the wiry synth on "Don't Touch My Hair", it's still got a nice driving beat as Solange shared her cadence with Sampha. But, this is where the presentation comes in, and I wish I could connect more. Solange herself has a very pleasant voice to listen to, yet I didn't feel as gripped by her as much as I'd like to be. It really feels like the content was the focus of this record more than any performance to help elevate or accentuate it. That problem also feeds into the pacing of this album. While it runs under an hour, it feels longer, between Master P's interludes in the second half that come off oddly juxtaposed to the more meditative pace of the surrounding tracks, and the penultimate "Scales" that ends things on an oddly downbeat note, even if I liked the interplay between Solange and Kelela. Then again, it's possible the target audience for this record won't care about pacing or atmosphere, and that's fine. After all, Solange established on this record that she does not care what I or anyone else thinks about her musical direction, which, again, I liked for the most part. A Seat at the Table is the sort of thought-provoking, well-produced experience that can lead into a larger discussion. Even if I feel the album could be trimmed down for a more effective impact, that doesn't stop how poignant and forward-looking Solange has established herself.
Smooth grooving, but it felt like one song repeated with tweaked lyrics
Eh.
Nice RnB sound with solid rap features throughout. Solid throughout with a little bit of repition throughout.
This and the two Untitled Sault albums from 2020 capture the most recent moment of protest and optimism, which has been sadly more than stomped to nothing. But these are also the types of albums that can inspire us to create and keep fighting for a better tomorrow. An absolute gem that brings the best out of Solange and her supporting cast. And the Master P narrative doc interludes was a brilliant touch.
Clever, ambient, R&B. Nice and dark! Favourite tracks: Cranes In The Sky, Mad
It’s not bad