Album Summary
L'eau rouge (French for The Red Water) is the second album by industrial band The Young Gods, released in September 1989 by Play It Again Sam Records. It is usually referred to as their masterpiece and was included in 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die in 2005.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Really interesting first listen. Loved some of it, not so much other parts, needs another listen like first time I heard Mars Volta. I’ll give it an 8/10 as it challenged me.
Had I heard of this group before? No Did I enjoy the experience of hearing them for the first time? Also no. Did I have the slightest idea of what I was listening to? Again, no
Whoa, where did this come from? I’m always on the lookout for cool uses of orchestra and it was really effective here. Added to the intense atmosphere without overwhelming. Also, just a solid early industrial album in its own right.
French Tom Waits being sucked into the pits of hell:
I don’t have the first idea what that dude was screaming about, but I know he meant it. This is not for me…partly because it’s in a language I don’t understand, but also because it scared my goldfish.
French nine inch nails? Actually, they're Swiss.
Some of the decisions from the alt-sphere in the 1001 are surprising. Lot of strange choices in industrial, experimental, and stuff like that. I do however think this is good! Intense vocals, lots of skittering drums. metallic guitars and sounds. Despite all that, I kinda have a natural aversion to cabaret, and carnival ass music. I'm sorry.
Oh! I like this. Started out a bit odd but really grew on me.
Meh
Мрачное индастриал-шапито на непонятном для меня французском. Если воспринимать это не как альбом, а как саундтрек к какой-нибудь авангардной театральной постановке, то становится проще воспринимать. При всём моём положительном отношении к индастриалу, не зашло.
Why is this in the book? Wasn’t as painful as some others but no clue what was going on
This was interesting. I was hopeful when it said it was industrial. I checked out a couple of songs from their next album; I think I would’ve enjoyed that one more.
It’s ok. Some interesting parts, but it doesn’t grab me the way other albums do
first thought that was that French can't save this, then the French stopped being French a French and became Rammstein French. who knew French ever didn't sound French? silly, shouty, not as bad as I thought it would be as in it didn't make me angry as others have but then maybe I didn't listen hard enough. 1 5.
Eh, this is really just a nothing album. The last 2 tracks were fine, but there's really nothing else going for it. This is going to get a 2 from me, almost a 1
Industrial is a pretty hard sell for me, outside of NIN maybe. I'm guessing this would be a pretty rad concert for the visuals and the crowd, but this is never something I'd just throw on the stereo for fun.
I feel like this would be sick to see live
Yeah, nah.
Never heard before. Probably a 5/10. Might be a 3 star if i heard it again but it didn't really grab me on that first listen. I like industrial music a bit so i was interested in the sound but after the first 3-4 tracks i struggled to hear anything that massively stood out.
Interesting start—but it quickly gave way to something you’ve heard 1,000 (1001?) times before. 2.5?
Wow! I’d never heard this one before. It’s strange, since I’ve delved into industrial music and dark cabaret, but perhaps not deeply enough. I’ll admit it: I’m not a huge fan of this, but I admire its candor. It’s a bit of a slog at times, reminding me of many awful opening bands I’ve had to sit through. And yet there’s something mesmerizing about it. They really wanted to evoke something unique to their place. I’ve been to the canton of Fribourg, and it’s traditional and folkloric, but it’s dark, morbid and often bleak. Don’t forget that H.R. Giger opened up a museum in the canton as well. What I find impressive is that the only instruments on this album are a sampler, drums and vocals. Everything else is engineering and sampling, and that’s beyond cool. I literally can’t tell what’s what, but there’s a definite wall of sound and busy drumming that complements Franz Treichler’s gruff, angry vocals. Pretty gutsy of them to include something so niche and furious in this book. From that point of view, I enjoy it for what it is, as I admire angry music, but I don’t particularly love it. I also speak French, and the lyrics aren’t especially imaginative or threatening. Maybe he should have screamed in German (Fribourg's other language) for extra effect, but it’s fine just the same (Francophone music doesn’t have enough angry bands, so I’m pleased to add this one to the roster). 3, maybe 3.5 stars from me. I’m definitely interested in checking out more of their stuff, even though this is considered their biggest classic.
Horrible voice, horrible noise
Horrible, qué es esto.
Well, the last thing I expected to hear today was a metal band from Switzerland... a pleasant surprise, though. 4 stars.
This would've been a banger two days ago during Halloween. Alas. Not my taste but I found myself nodding along to the music quite often. A decent offering.
Very French. And heavy
This was really interesting. There were times when I thought this is worth buying but at the end of the day not being in English and some interludes with French folk music or something (which is quite cool but not sure I want to hear it repeatedly) make me think not. Still a good listen though, and different.
Started getting better towards the end but never got good
i wanted to like it. music was fine. Singing was cringe
possibly the worst thing i’ve heard in my life like what is this 😭
It's something of a surprise that I hadn't heard of The Young Gods until yesterday morning. I'm of an age that I've come to know so many bands without hearing a note be it from other people mentioning them, reading references in music magazine interviews or simply going through the racks in record shops. Clearly I've skipped the XYZ section one time too many over the years. The Young gods are a Francophone Swiss industrial rock trio and strangely more accessible than that sounds. There's more to them than that as 'Charlotte' the side 1 closer proves. This track sounds like Tom Waits meeting a proto Rammstein armed with the wrong Berlitz phrasebook. The 'of their time' drums on 'Crier les chiens' and 'Ville nôtre' on side two ruin the 'atmosphere' slightly . It's not an album I'd listen to again in a hurry but warmed to it more than I expected I would. Two and half stars.
Kommer rett fra disken bak Joe&djuiss med fløyelskjorta og øredobber, ned i kjelleren til kompisen, på med skallebøffen og skinnfrakken og kjetting i øra. Hvordan ender mann opp med sånn musikk? Rock og punk er gøy men dette høres jo ikke bra ut. Mareritt kaizers
Ja d va nisje ja.
Never heard of this artist or album. YT Music calls them French industrial music and says this album is their masterpiece. I don't really agree, overblown and pretentious seems more fitting. The first song is the longest 7.52 minutes ever. It didn't get any better. BTW my wife walked in when I was listening and her reaction was stronger.
Heard the name but never the music. Interesting for sure, always good to hear different stuff on this list. Like Rain Dogs pushed further into Europe. I guess I don't actually know a lot of industrial music. Prefer the heavier songs. 3.5 rounded up Heard before? No Owned: No, 115/460 (25%) Will I get: No
First, I'll say that, as a native French-speaker, the butchered French annoyed me (the singer is German-Swiss). But I don't want to gatekeep singing in French, especially when so many French artists desecrate English (I'm talking about you The Onirist). Just saying it made my ears cringe at times. The low-pitch singing can also be a bit much, and sometimes it doesn't really fit the music. Aside from that, this album is amazing. Very imaginative, atmospheric, varied, fun and full of life. No instrument was deemed unfit for the music the band wanted to make. There's a lot of guitar, bass and drum, of course, but also violin, accordion, industrial-sounding percussions and all kinds of orchestral instruments (through sampling I presume). Some songs are a bit repetitive, but never for very long; they keep moving around, transporting you elsewhere. A very surprising album, full of creativity, and the reviews here are pathetic. Seriously, if you think this sounds like Rammstein or Nine Inch Nails (whom I love btw) you have piss in your brain. Do... Do y'all even listen to the albums, or do you just click randomly on the track listing and listen for 10 seconds? Embarrassing.
It's like Rammstein but in french!!!!!!!!! No
My poor ears! What was that?!
No. Fuck off, list guy.
If it helped inspire NIN then I have to respect it.
Sung in French which I do not understand any French. Yet this album kept me interested and captivated. The music is awesome playing wise as well as their style. Sort of Goth/metal.
Ceci était parfaitement horrible.
Interesting. Hard like some of the German and American hard core stuff at the time but I would argue with better musicality and interest. 3+
Interesting. I've never heard it before; I don't think I've anything by The Young Gods before.
Meh. Didn't think it was bad. But wasn't really feeling it.
Водевиль в стиле индастриал
The Good: Wine anyone? The Bad: Seems the water is mixed with blood... The Ugly: A French version of Rammstein... unless you are into that, of course... It started off well... intriguing, I would say. Then, well, then it was a little less of intrigu and more of annoy... And yet, then the intriguing started showing up again... I am so conflicted on this one... What can't be denied is that I am no fan of the singers voice... Shooting this one down the middle... 3*
I’m not sure if it’s completely my taste but I don’t mind it, it’s kinda like death metal but it’s all in French so I have no clue what they’re singing about, very deep screamy music, which if done right, I quite like.
457/1089 a very spooky opening track, it’s on the verge of clicking for me idk i like the string section that comes in around halfway through okay it just didn’t click, french industrial rock isn’t for me ig 23/100
This was so bad. This vocalist was horrid. I hated this. The music was just not good. Actual Rating... .5 Liked Songs: Not much but "Rue des tempêtes" , "L'Amourir" , and "Pas Mal"
Spooky ass French circus magic
French Nine In Nails... I did not need to know this existed.
Ween if they were french and made an industrial album
I’m getting a swiss-French nine inch tails / Metallica / rammstein tri-brid. A good Halloween album, especially with the song Charlotte. The album cover communicates a lot about the music. 3.5 rounded down.
Blast from the past! I bought this on cassette when it came out and I was blown away. Lots of people copied this style in ensuing years and the Young Gods themselves only improved after this (TV Sky anyone?) but this is still a classic. (4.5/5)
French Tom Waites, but slightly better.
It's hard not to draw comparisons to Laibach and Tom Waites. I really enjoyed the first track and did not expect it to make a switch to industrial noise rock, but that was cool. It's kinda impressive and epic for the first half but I got a little bored once they settled back down. Not sure if it was the French shouting or the instrumentals that got stale. Either way I mostly enjoyed it.
similar sensory experience to hearing du hast for the first time at like 8 years old or whatever. cool and kind of scary and bad but still compelling? opening with the haunted carnival vibe is fascinating, completely draws you in right away. i think it runs out of creative stamina partway through, but the front half compensates for that and generally speaking it's just noisy and cool. La fille de la mort is my favorite. strong 3
Rating: 6/10 I'll be honest the French vocals were throwing me the most. There's something about the guttural French shouting that turns the effect from interesting to slightly obnoxious. The industrial noise stuff is right up my alley, the cabaret sound it takes on ("Charlotte", "Les Enfants") actually works pretty well for the vocals, and gives it an evil Tom Waits vibe, but I wasn't into that aspect as much. Those two tracks are probably my least favorite for that reason. It makes for a pretty funny transition when it goes from cabaret back to electro-industrial, like tracks 4-5. Pretty awesome actually at times. One other problem is that there was barely a track that actually stood out as really noteworthy. My favorites would be tracks 2, 3, and 5. Overall I liked it but didn't love it. Probably super political in some type of way I don't understand lyrically but I didn't dive into it, so maybe not
Super creative and cool!
Get the fuck out of here with this shit (excuse my French).
Napoleon Blownapart
Not entirely sure what I just listened to. Vocals were creepy, didn't understand a word, and happy for that. Most of the songs were a mash of wierd nonsense. I did enjoy the songs with the orchestrations embeddded in them, that was different and cool. Had the feel of a heavy metal symphony.
Groupe connu, cet album fait partie de mes préférés ! J’ai découvert le style ‘Industriel’ avec 2 disques très différents et inégalés à mon avis : Streetcleaner de Godflesh (plus metal) et celui-ci (plus expérimental). ‘L’eau rouge’ commence très bien avec ‘la fille de la mort’ qui enchaîne des ambiances de plus en plus sombres. Les samples sont excellents, la batterie acoustique un vrai plus, le mixage est aussi très bon. Et les morceaux s’enchaînent, plus ou moins dynamiques selon les cas. Leur structure est rarement standard, et les samples de guitare sont vraiment biens choisis. Quelques autres morceaux remarquables : ‘les enfants’, ‘longue route’. L’album mérite la meilleure note sans hésitation ! =>5/5 Et leurs albums suivants sont aussi à découvrir.
This one has always intrigued me. I like the title, I like the band name, and I like the cover. But this has like, NO good reviews. I'm interested. 01. La Fille De La Mort Absolutely batshit insane way to start off an album. A great ballad, with some wicked sampling. I fucked with it. 02. Rue Des Tempêtes I really fucked with this one. Was fun. The guitar is so uniquely not fitting with the song. 03. L'eau Rouge This sampling feels so ahead of its time! I've never heard a song like this, let alone from its time! 04. Charlotte Feels like a Mr. Bungle song (I love Mr. Bungle). 05. Longue Route This made me realize that the lead singer doesn't do on good on harder, more rock like instrumentation. 06. Crier Les Chiens Absolutely crazy chorus, that instrumentation is crazy! Great vocal performance too! 07. Ville Nôtre Feels like a weaker version of Crier Les Chiens in every way. Least favorite so far. 08. Les Enfants It really interesting. Not my favorite, but for time this is super experimental. Perhaps a bit too long. 09. L'amourir A really interesting, synthy one. I really love the latter half. 10. Pas Mal A nice, quick, fast-paced song to cap us off. Nice and enjoyable. Although not my favorite album ever, this is extremely ahead of its time. This crazy, wacky and strange samples and guitars are absolutely nuts, especially for 1989! I know Pretty Hate Machine came out this year too, and I have no idea how that's not here.
Cool that this is on the list! Name checked by a lot of bands/artists I like but never really listened to them
I hate when you can hear how full of themselves they are.
As soon as this album started, I wanted to be at a live show listening to this band sing these songs. I just really felt connected to the music and voice and even some of the words (the little bits I could understand). I was surprised to learn after my listen that this band actually uses a lot of samples (some borrowed, some created), which sort of ruined my image of what a live show would be! Like with some of the other albums on this one-a-day journey, not having lyrics that I could fully connect with pushed me to focus more on the music itself. The heavy rock guitar riffs were energizing and the classical bits were a surprising element that totally worked. The vocal was very unique and intense and full of feeling, so that really hit me, too. My favorite track was “Rue de tempêtes.”
5.4/10. I can't say I understand the purpose of this album, because I don't. Due to the same music throughout every song and the harsh vocals, I couldn't get any emotion other than rage coming from this artist. It was good at first, and I enjoyed the use of metal instruments as well as orchestral ones, it brought a grandness to the album you couldn't get without that many instruments. But 10 songs in a row of it just wasn't the best, they all kind of blended, especially because the album was sung in French. Not my favorite kind of metal, it was too heavy and not catchy in any way, and it just didn't catch me in the same way other artists of the same style do, like Nine Inch Nails.
The main vocalist makes me nauseous.
Lowkey industrialized.
Fucking piss in my ears
It’s got quite a unique sound, as if an industrial baby grew up in the streets of France and learned how to play the accordion. I like that. At the same time, the songs aren’t very good, and I will probably never listen to it again
I don't think this is as repellent or as interesting as a lot of the reviews make it out to be. It's neat.
circus rammstein
L'Eau Rouge by The Young Gods is basically like getting tossed into a chaotic, neon-lit funhouse where European cabaret meets '80s industrial metal. It’s pretty wild, no traditional riffs here, just a wall of sampled guitars and heavy, clattering drums with the singer snarling over the top in French. It sounds like a deranged, horror-movie version of Tom Waits or Jacques Brel backing an early Nine Inch Nails demo. One minute it's a tense accordion waltz, and the next it's just full-on mechanical mayhem that leaves you feeling totally buzzed and weirded out. It’s definitely not for everyone, it’s abrasive and kind of a lot to take in, but the way they pull it off is pretty cool. It's a high-stakes, intense ride that might catch you off guard, but if you can handle the industrial noise and the French vocals, there’s a really unique, dark atmosphere underneath. And true purists know that Eau Rouge is technically part of Raidillon...
interesting/french
Eh… gets redundant after awhile but I really liked the dramatic opening track.
WTF is this
nice enough
It's industrial/noise music with a good amount of orchestra fills (which I like), but also with growly vocals and occasional circus elements (which I don't like).
Imagine Ministry being fronted by Tom Waits and they are going so hard and fast they occasionally fly off the road and crash through a circus tent or orchestra hall. Probably just a 3 but rounding up to counter balance the haters.
I liked when this veered a bit more creepy Moulin Rouge. The minute it went hard rock/metal, it lost me.
Gar nicht mal schlecht, wenn man sich konzentriert und darauf einlässt. Brsuch Zeit und Raum
Really cool. Some sort of French industrial rock, I quite liked this.
I didn’t listen. The symphonic metal wasn’t for me. It wasn’t bad. I just didn’t want to listen to more.
Weird but some good times
Really bad album. Something about the cover does not sit right with me. Did not like the french, tone, backing tracks, or instruments at all. By song 3 I wished that this was over. This isnt just because its in an unfamiliar language either, I genuinely listen to k-pop in my regular rotation and attend concerts reguarly despite not knowing an ounce of korean. If you want to listen to decent french music, listen to the Clair Obsur Expedition 33 soundtrack. Lumiere beats blows this entire album out of the water skyhigh. Best Song: Crier les Cheins Worst Song: Les Enfants.
I don’t speak French, so I can’t fairly evaluate the lyrics. The music was sometimes deep, methodical, cryptic and yet other times it was randomly light. It really never connected.
Je suis ear bleed. This hardcore, often metal, French album is one born from anger. Backing guitar and drums are heavy and loud. The eeriness produced by these sounds is what gives this record its uniqueness, and is quite interesting. The vocals are dark, often devolving into low screams. This is what misses the mark for me, as I disliked the grunting and growling constantly heard throughout every song. I guess I don't want some French guy yelling at me in a language I don't understand — pretty cool guitar though, sometimes.
Nope. Not for me. I had never heard of this group and was hopeful but ultimately disappointed.
Qué acabo de escuchar. 5/10
Too loud...
Sometimes it put me in the mind of a creepy circus
#244 - The other reviews have been pretty spot on so there is not much more I can add. It's far from the best album, but I did hear some early NIN sound, and production in there. I didn't spot the Pink Floyd influence as much. It felt more like French Circus music sprinkled throughout, it was weird. I would listen again at some point I am sure, just not anytime soon, or on purpose, unless someone wanted clarity on said French-NIN style Biggest Hit - L'Amourir Biggest Miss - Les enfants Hidden Gem - Pas Mal
not bad at all but i don't think this will be back in my shuffle...... the 5 star system is so hard!! the 3 star albums are so nuanced and some are better than others!
No aguanto la voz del pavo. Seguramente si supiera francés diría oh la la je suis enamoré pero como no pues se me ha hecho horroroso. Será que no me gusta el industrial.
This album is basically symphonic metal and French, if you're a metal head you might really like this. I however am not I will say that the album IS listenable and enjoyable even for a non-metalhead like me favorite tracks: L'eau rouge, Les enfants 3/5
Absolutely ruddy excellent - SO weird, memorable, odd, great to listen to while working... awesome! :) Godflesh is a similarish band too, both are discoveries this year I can't believe are news to me :) 5*
so many feelings in just the first track. i did not really like the vocals throughout but i did enjoy the music quite a bit. kind of a headscratcher overall, but for the good.