Album Summary
Exile in Guyville is the debut studio album by American singer-songwriter Liz Phair, released on June 22, 1993, by Matador Records. It was recorded at Idful Music Corporation in Chicago between 1991 and 1993 and produced by Phair and Brad Wood. The album received critical acclaim for its ability to combine indie rock and lo-fi music and the concept behind it; in 2020, it was ranked No. 56 by Rolling Stone in its 500 Greatest Albums of All Time list. It was certified gold in 1998 and as of July 2010 it had sold 491,000 copies.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Another act that was on the fringes of a lot of stuff I listened to in the early 90s but never took the time to explore. The immediate vocal comparison to Courtney Love is undeniable, though Liz may have a wider range and be more deliberate in her delivery. The lyrics somehow manage to be poetic, poignant, and trite in turns, with minimalist instrumentation that alludes to the wealth of emotion that's being held back. Overall, I liked this one a good deal more than I expected, and it grew on me during that first listen such that it earned a second later in the day. It's a pretty solid 4/5 that made me look forward to exploring more of her stuff.
Now that was a fucking debut album! This album went hard and didn’t pull any punches. It’s solid all the way through. There is an indie rock attitude trying to say something even if the meanings are not as deep and broad as they’ve been portrayed. Its a female voice stating her gripes and regrets and that can tend to be novel throughout rock history no matter how many times its happened before. The music is quite to my taste and its right in that early ‘90s sweet spot. 5/5
(3/5) Liz Phair is Courtney Love after rehab, on a methadone schedule. Her music is stock standard 90s stuff, and maybe that's a function of my overexposure, but that was my take on it. The music was slightly grungy with a sprinkling of distortion and a touch of atonality. Her singing wasn't good but it was offset by her lyricism and songwriting. Notably, "Fuck and Run", " 6'1" ", & "Stratford-on-Guy", stood out for that reason but nothing really elevated the whole album. Meh. Heard it all before and frankly better. Good enough I guess, and at least its a woman.
Boring, weird and bad vocals. Great combo. Some songs are slightly better but I still don’t like it at all on the whole.
When I saw the assignment I initially thought I could rate it without listening to it; I know it by heart and we saw her last month. But we did end up playing it, and even in a car with questionable speakers, I remembered its real strengths: it is a coherent album (and many of the reviewers here could benefit from some liner notes); as tempting as it is to lump her together with Courtney Love or PJ Harvey or whoever, she really did have a distinct sound that didn't rely on abrasiveness or volume; and she had something very pointed to say. Her career after this was decidedly spotty but this really is outstanding. I'm rounding up from 4.5, but this morning I would have given it a 4.
This was quite shit.
3 out of 5. Some songs here were good others just meh.
That was good.
I first heard this around 25 years ago because my girlfriend at the time would play it now and again. I remember thinking that some of the songs were really catchy and the vibe seemed really laid back. In fairness, given how influential it would become, this album definitely deserves its place on the list. Listening again in 2026, my opinion is largely the same. I am kinda pleased that my judgement was so good, even then. Regarding music that is, not girlfriends.
As foundational to 90s rock as everyone having their first taste of espresso
It's so cool not to care and give no effort.
First music. Not the best and not the worst.
Well, that's it, the 1102nd album! Nailed on 3 as well, It was fine, but nothing particularly noteworthy, which seems fitting. The list has exposed me to a lot of very good albums, which I likely wouldn't have listened to otherwise... Also a whole lot of shite too! Perhaps it's not about those albums, but the Leibachs we heard along the way. Textbook 3. Probably give Dimery a 3 for the list as a whole too. Onto the user submitted albums! Viva list
261. Exile In Guyville - Liz Phair (1993) 11.10.26 Variety: 4 Adequacy: 5 Listenability: 4 Uniqueness: 4 Emotionality: 4 = 4.2 rounded down to a 4 "So don't look at me sideways/ Don't even look me straight on/ And don't look at my hands in my pockets, baby/ I ain't done anything wrong" This is an album that's always intimidated me a little bit. Not so much the feminist aura that surrounds, or even the reputation as being complex. It's more the heaps and heaps of praise that have been dumped on it over the years in combination with the lack of enthusiasm for Phair's career after. I've heard and liked songs she's done since this album, and she never really disappeared or anything, but for such a strongly received debut, I was left thinking it must be a lot of hype if she didn't have the follow through. And I've been reading about peoples' reactions to this album since I was old enough to be interested in checking out Spin magazine, then later on all the online review sites and such. Much more so the reactions and interpretations and criticisms of the messaging on it WAY more than anything about the actual sound of it. And I've dipped my toes in a couple of times. Each time getting no more than several tracks in. I can't say it was because of anything more than the trepidation of "what if I don't like this critically admired gem - what does that say bout my tastes?". Which is something I've felt about a quite a few BIG albums. And it's something I've spent a good chunk of the last 15-20 years trying to correct. I just haven't gotten back around to this one yet. I've got my suspicions about how it'll shake out based on the several tracks I've heard ( catchy indie rock singer songwriter stuff tends to go down well with me), but I've also heard several decades worth of the stuff that was heavily influenced by it, a lot of which I quite like, and with that context I think I can put to bed some of the hesitation I've felt in finally plunging in. It's now a "classic" album and is almost as far back in the mists of time as Elvis's debut was for me this was originally released in '93 and I'm excited to be getting in when I'm a generous mood as well, having just had a run of 5 star albums. Will the streak continue? Will my review be skewed by this? I hope not, but I can't say I'm above the vagaries of mood when it comes to these things. At least so far as the occasional difference in a star is concerned. Let's find out. THE TRACKS "6'1"" - The album opens with some crunchy, by very poppy guitars that remind me a dirtier sounding version of stuff like Nick Lowe or the Softboys were putting out. It's relatively clean and jangle-pop adjacent, and way closer to someone like Matthew Sweet in it's very savvy handle on catchy, 60's influence pop dynamics. If this is an indication of what the rest of the album is going to sound like, it bodes well for its evergreen potential. I've found that so much of that poppier, out of time sounding alt-pop has aged WAY better than most of the grunge stuff from the same era. As much as I like the big four grunge acts, there was SO much similar sounding material being put out at the time, that when I hear something like this that sounds like it has echoes in artists I love that are currently putting out great material ( Courtney Barnett, Snail Mail, Frankie Cosmos to name just a few). Lyrically this seems to be all about confidence and brushing off guys who might be more than a bit narcissistic. I happen to know there was a Rolling Stone thing where Phair did a track by track analysis of this album, and it might be a fun game to compare. I'm not too concerned if I'm too far off the mark, as ultimately I'm a death of the author guy, but I still think it's interesting to see how an artist reads their own material, and what sort of blind spots and interesting takes they might have. It's not like she's writing willfully obscure nonsense lyrics like Beck or Steven Malkmus, so I don't think there's going to be too many ah-ha moments. She seems much more of the auto-bio/ fictional character pov storytelling songwriting mode to me. So I might go back and add some snippets from her piece for comparison if I have the time. --- (Liz Phair: "It’s standing up to the boy; it’s standing up to the guy.") "Help Me, Mary" - Instrumentally, this one is bright with much cleaner sounding guitars that are still very much in Nick Lowe, jangle-pop adjacent territory. It's catchy and briskly paced and I think does not live up to the lo-fi label very much unless you count the basicness of the presentation. The production sounds very clean and warm to me, and as much as I love me some Guided by Voices, I don't see too much in common with this aside from an ear for a great melody. Maybe I'm being too literal here, but lyrically this seems like someone trying to not give in to peer pressure, and maybe more generally how even those you like can get on your nerves and it's good to have some alone time. --- (Liz Phair: The Rolling Stones’ “Rip This Joint” "was all about sort of the attitude of these rock guys that would just kind of roll into town, create trouble, sleep with other people’s girlfriends and leave a big mess behind. I was writing about my own experiences hosting these spontaneous gatherings of rock dudes and how just hidden my real self was in that male scene. There weren’t that many women in the scene and, like, everybody either was like a girlfriend or a den mother.) "Glory" - A downbeat acoustic number, this one adds some variety pretty early in the run, and reminds me of some of the dark, emotionally devastating Elliott Smith tracks. Both Phair and Smith I think must have been more than a little influenced by the Velvet Underground drone. She's been consistently catchy and this one is no exception. Lyrically it seems like a straight up reference to Mick Jagger with his famous tongue, and his in your face stage presence. I can't tell if the chorus is meant to be sarcastic or not, but I know Phair does like the Stones, so I'm willing to take it at face value. --- (Liz Phair: "It’s talking about this sort of intimidating rock dude that everyone knows – someone that’s legendary in the scene. I’m talking about how his tongue snakes out in the club." "Dance of the Seven Veils" - This one was funny right away with it's ever so casually delivered menacing message, made even funnier my how pretty the delivery of the VERY blunt message of the chorus was. This seems like a pretty tonally dissonant number, all threats and barely restrained rage in the lyrics, but all pretty and delicate in the delivery. Great stuff. For anyone playing that game, the Rolling Stones song that takes up the same spot on "Exile On Main St." also uses the same uh... epithet, as well as a reference to a "wounded lover". This one brings to mind the "honeyed tongue, a heart of gall" attitude of someone seething with a hatred that is maybe masked by a smile and a wink. --- (Liz Phair: Johnny "was the roommate who was basically – and rightfully so – convinced that I had bitten off more than I could chew and this was going to be a disaster. It was my sort of Salome lie. “Just you wait ’till the end of the play. Let’s see who comes out on top.” A contentious relationship with a roommate was unexpected, but alright. ) "Never Said" - This is one of the ones I do remember hearing as it had a music video that played on MTV. Can't say I ever heard it on the radio way back when, but it does pop up on satellite radio occasionally. It's very easy to see why it was picked as a single though given how earwormy it is, with it's catchy but simple chorus that reminds me a LOT of "I Want to Destroy You" by the Soft Boys (edit: Linked below is an interview with Phair saying she was familiar with the song, and loves it but doesn't really go into whether or not it was a direct inspiration. Most definitely not a connection I would have made back then as I had never heard of the Soft Boys before maybe 15 years ago or so. ). This one seems to be a very basic "the secret's safe with me, I promise" song where maybe the secret was not so safe. The tone is playful and laid back, kind of making any sort of real betrayal seem unlikely or unimportant. --- (Liz Phair: "...just kind of like about the music scene and how catty it was. People were always getting upset about something that someone had said about their band or whatever the latest gossip was.") --- Interview with Phair about the Soft Boys song: https://kutx.org/features/this-song-liz-phair/ "Soap Star Joe" - A chugging, sharp downtuned and guitar opens this one, and Phair delivers as a lilting and very memorable vocal melody on the verses and up to a spacey echo on the chorus. There's also a prominent harmonica part that screetches and scracthes throughout and adds a bit of folky flavor. This is not unlike some of the stuff Cheryl Crow was doing, with it's kind of funny portrait of a presemably chisel jawed man of action whose maybe a lot more self interested in the glory he might get than the good deeds the glor might get him, and when you see him in just the right light, he probably looks a good 20 years old than he's letting on. You can imagine the sucked in gut, the hair dye that might drip down the side of his forehead if he gets a little overexerted. And it ends sort of a punchline with Phair making the comperison to the U.S. Without making a literal political point it's pretty easy to draw the line between her descroiption and our country's long in the tooth nature, and performative acts of leaderhsip and good will that are 1000% self interested. It's Uncle Sam as portrayed by Bruce Campbell in full on elder-Ash from Evil Dead mode. --- (Liz Phair": "When I was in my twenties, I was always dating older men, and they would always pick me up in cars and take me to dinner. I felt like I was always sitting in the interior of some dude’s car on my way to or from dinner and just how weirdly generic it all felt. Like, every Friday, Saturday night, someone was taking you out somewhere. I just had all these thoughts and feelings that I never shared, and it kind of came out in my songwriting, and “Soap Star Joe” is a perfect example. I’m kind of skewering the guy, but at the same time, I’m also lovingly aware of his plight in a weird way.") "Explain It to Me" - This one has a kind of meloncholy vibe with it's jangly guitar over top of a bass drum ( edit: I read these were bongos) and it's all very pretty and quiet. There's an ambient buzzing drone that closes the song out as it fades into complete bass. As to what it's about, I'm pretty baffled on this except to say that she seems to be getting at some idea of comparing yourself to an older man who's maybe struggling to keep up. --- (Liz Phair: "It’s about a ruined rock hero and seeing one of your greatest figures at their weakest, I guess." - Close enough.) "Canary" - This one reminded me a lot of Ben Folds, with it's sad piano balladry and sparse, underproduced emotionally bare vibe. It feels like the inner monologue of someone with no joy left in their life, and who only lives for someone else. Phair really leans into the deadpan here as it seems the best way to present a robotic, lifeless, trapped person. It's also very pretty, and catchy, but I hope she changes it up soon after too sad ones in a row. --- (Liz phair: "It’s about the loss of innocence and facing the pressures of being a young woman in the world and what men want from you while you’re still kind of on the cusp of your childhood. There’s a period of time where you pretend to still be a little girl, but you’re confronting all this bullshit in the world that is suddenly your new role.") "Mesmerizing" - With its maracas, hand claps, very Kieth Richardsesque guitar riffs and laser-like lead part over top, this feels like the most she has sonically invoked the Rolling Stones. It's got some good hooks and stayed with me after just one listen which is always a good sign. The best I can tell this is about someone who lacks inhibition and how it can seem attractive? There's some fun noise at the end that sounds like a dog growling and had to look it up and confirm that yes, it's someone's dog playing with a chew toy that was caught on the tape. --- (Liz Phair: I could not find much of anything about this one. In the Rolling Stone piece she just tells the story about the dog.) "Fuck and Run" - One of the more notable tracks on the album, and one I remember hearing more than a few times before. The fairly honest content about a person with some strong commitment issues seemed to be overshadowed by the *GASP* language on display. How very quaint. It's one of the crunchier, poppier numbers on the album and would fit right in in that batch of 2010s indie singer songwriters I've referenced many times now. --- (Liz Phair: “There you go. Yep, just sat up in bed. I’m not quite sure who this guy is, but, like, I don’t think I’ll be seeing him again.”) "Girls! Girls! Girls!" - Another great track. I really missed the boat on this one, I guess. That heavy downtuned guitar is back, and it stays sparse and intimate with Phair deeping even deeper and more whispery in what sounds like some sort of mixture of the simple, catchiness of a Buddy Holly solo number as filtered through the drone of Beat Happening, with maybe some aggressive PJ Harvey style menace added in for good measure. This one seems to be about the danger of having a reputation, and what if that reputation happens to be legit. --- (Liz Phair: "Earlier in the record, you can tell it’s hard to be a woman in a man’s world, and then you get to this song, and you see how the knife cuts both ways. You can manipulate the system to your advantage, as well, which women, we do both. We try to live a certain way, but when it gets really hard we sometimes flip the tables. We use it to our advantage, and then we go back to trying to make the world the way it ought to be.") "Divorce Song" - This one has a bright and pleasant sound that's as much like Cheryl Crow as anything I've heard on here yet. It's bouncy anhas an interesting structre with the best hook buried within the second verse, but with a funny little story about a marriage on the rocks and a woman that seems like she's been gaslit the whole time kind of taking it in stride. --- (Liz Phair: "...it’s just two personalities trying to be intimate and bumping up against each other on a road trip and that’s all that happens.") "Shatter" - This is as grungy and rough around the as I've heard yet, with the feedback and crunchy dry guitar sound. The chords are all feel a bit uplifting or at least unsure, and with all the noise underneath it builds a very confused atmosphere and remains an instrumental until about halfway through when Phair comes in to weave a narrative of someone who maybe didn't think they were capable of falling hard for someone doing just that very thing. For a love song it's pretty downbeat in tone, but hopeful in the lyrics. "I don't know" is said a lot though so the doubt is there still, even with the most optimistic take, lingering underneath like that feedback. --- (Liz Phair: She doesn't have much to say about this one other than some technical notes about how her producer pretty much gave her free reign and didn't push for a bass line on a lot of the tracks.) "Flower" - We get some electronic touches on this one as it opens with a pretty falsetto intro bit that repeats under the verses like in a round. We get some of the most directly sexual lyrics on the album with the repeated intro part almost playing like a thought the narrator can't get out of their head. This one is slotted in the same spot as "Let It Loose on Exile On Main Streetm which is a gospely number that's also got a theme of sexual desire. If anything on the album is a blunt statement, this would be it, and it's really just a brutally honest inner monologue that shouldn't seem so shocking, but must have at the time. --- (Liz Phair: "I felt like it was really important to want overtly and to lust and to be able to own my own sexuality. I was scared to do it, but I felt like it was important to take the territory back for myself.") "Johnny Sunshine" - It took a while but we finally made it to a track I'm less than enthused about. On the surface it almost plays like a parody of a country song about someone's woes after terrible breakup, and a partner who took some liberties. It doesn't really pick up until the outro chorus with some more pretty falsetto stuff that seems like maybe a nod to the choral arrangement on "You Can't Always Get What You Want", even though that's not even on Exile On Main St. It was fine. And maybe I'm experiencing a tiny bit of fatigue at this point. --- (Liz Phair: "It’s that feeling of abandonment that you feel when you’re like, “Fine! Go! I don’t care.” Then, of course, you break into the truth of it, which is that she’s devastated.") "Gunshy" - This was another quiet, slow one and Phair gives a dreamy, lazy vocal performance. It was ok, but seemed like a guitar-centric do over of what we already got on "Canary" with the narrator seemingly trapped in a rut, and feeling like a robot just doing the same thing over and over. There are some interesting things going on instrumentally, but it feels more than a little half baked and incomplete. Maybe Phair is feeling the fatigue herself by this point? --- (Liz Phair: "“Gunshy” I connect to “Canary” because it’s more of that true-confession, diary-entry singing. There’s no pretense or bravado. It’s really saying, “I don’t know if I am cut out to do what it seems to be that society wants women to do.” It’s the little things, the little habits that I can’t handle. It’s the fear of being married and the fear of being in that role. It’s a confession as opposed to other songs that are proclaiming loudly." - Well there you go.) "Stratford-on-Guy" - Another one that I vaguely remember from the weird lyrics. Maybe there was a music video? Galaxy 500 gets a call out in this more straight ahead alt rocker that seems to be about a panic attack on a plane where the narrator imagines it's taking forever to land and as time slows down is able to notice all these tiny details that the rest of the anesthetized passengers seem to be taking note of. It's interesting, but doesn't have any memorable melodic hooks and feels a bit like wheel spinning this late in the album. --- (Liz Phair: ...is me waking up as I travel out of there and just getting out of that neighborhood and it all falls off of you. It all just falls away. There is this sense that you’re literally at 30,000 feet above the scene that you are so involved in and this relationship you’re so involved in and it’s just a literal perspective shift above it. A lot of the bullshit just falls away." "Strange Loop?" - This is better, and at least has a catchier chorus, but ultimately it's pretty middle of the road compared to teh vast majority of the album, and is a bit of a let down as a closer. That the songs I least liked on this all come at the very end reinforces the idea that the fatigue has gotten to me, and these might be better with another go around. Too bad it ended with a bit of a whimper, but overall I still really liked it. I'd say this one seems to be a bout not knowing what you want, to keep it relatively simple. --- (Liz Phair: "This is a reconciliation song. It’s about saying, “Yeah, OK, we’ve been through a lot of shit. You’re fucked up, and I’m fucked up.” There’s a sense of having moved past the Sturm und Drang. We’ve gotten some distance from it all and it’s conciliatory in a weird way.") HIGHLIGHTS - "6'1"" - "Help Me, Mary" - "Glory" - "Dance of the Seven Veils" - "Never Said" - "Soap Star Joe" - "Explain It to Me" - "Canary" - "Mesmerizing" - "Fuck and Run" - "Girls! Girls! Girls!" - "Divorce Song" - "Shatter" - "Flower" MIDLIGHTS - "Johnny Sunshine" - "Gunshy" - "Stratford-on-Guy" - "Strange Loop?" LOWLIGHTS - FINAL THOUGHTS What relief. I'm so glad this thing didn't end up being the on the nose, in your face, angst-ridden dark alt rock piece that I thought it was going to be. Instead I was treated to a pretty bright, if acerbic and witty bit of catchy, jangly pop rock that had way more in common with Warren Zevon than it did any of the more cringey 90s confessional stuff that I think has not aged as well ( looking at you Tracy Bonham and Alanis Morrisette). This was pretty delightful all around, and I'm happy to finally be able to mark it off the list. I think the later stuff I heard from her was a bit more polished and shined up for pop consumption, but this sits in a really nice middle ground, and is comparable to work I've liked from a lot of the more witty, and pop conscious acts like the aforementioned Nick Lowe, Elvis Costello, and Robyn Hitchcock. There was plenty of variety, a consistent and professional sounding production, a real ear for melodic hooks, and a depth of emotion on display that I can't even think of giving it less than a 4. It was even pretty unique in that it stands out as being untethered by so much of the dirty, grungy alternative muck of the period, and hearkens back to a very poppy sound that echoes back through the late 80s, late 70s, and mid 60s and probably can ultimately be traced primarily to the Buddy Holly school of pop rock, with its focus on short, catchy, pleasant delivery systems. I think one of the oft-repeated "facts" about this album is that it was meant as a track for track rebuke to Exile on Main St. by the Rolling Stones. I know at least from Phair's Amoeba Records "What's In my Bag?" episode that she's actually a huge fan of that album, and considers the Stones to be a big influence on her work. In a general sense, sure I can see thematically the album could be slotted into a response to the Stones and their very macho and misogynistic vibe, but that's not just those guys. It's a bigger, broader statement than that. The whole 18 track thing, and the titling similarities are at best a template and have the side effect of a quite good gimmick to rest the thing in, besides. But I don't think there's too much meat (though I'm sure a good enough writer, with a sense of self-awareness and some humor could make it fun) in doing such an song by song comparison. This isn't a map. It's more of a guidebook, with some, at times, alternately harrowing and funny commentary. ( Edit: Evidenced by Phair's own song by song analysis, I guess she thought more about that one-to-one mapping than I assumed...) One big criticism I've seen people raise about Phair is that her voice is an emotionless deadpan. I would heartily disagree, at least in part. Yes, there's a disaffectedness in her delivery, but it's anything but emotionless. She falls into that same category for me as Aimee Mann or Courtney Barnett in that she leaves so much of the emphasis on the actual vocal melody, and what people read as deadpan, I read as a steadiness and full throated confidence in the material. Not to get to deep into social, cultural, and political stuff off the bat, but there are a TON of dude's with this same kind of delivery, who have a level set kind of speech-oriented delivery that modulates when called for, but stays even-keeled. Tom Petty, Lou Reed, Mark Knopfler, Beck, Iggy Pop, Julian Casablancas, Steven Malkmus, and Bob Dylan are just a few I can think of. And I love all those guys' Singing styles. It's understated, sure, but I find I like it better than the opposite approach like you get from guys like Morrissey or meat Loaf ( though I do like this sometimes like with Robert Smith or Peter Murphy, so...). But all that said, I'm not sure Phair needs or would appreciate any sort of defense of her style from the likes of me. It's enough that this this was an entertaining listen, and it made me want to keep going with the other albums I never fully investigated due to being hesitant about this one. If I had to lay one big criticism at it's feet it would be that it does feel a bit long. No idea what I would trim as it all went down smooth, but as much as I liked it I'm not immediately looking for more of the same. That said now that the band-aid has been ripped off, I think I can go into those with no expectations other than the person at the helm knows what the fuck they are doing. We've also still got Exile On Main St. to get to, so it will be interesting to compare and contrast. Possible turn-Offs might include: - vocals that might be a bit of an acquired taste for some - some pretty intense subject matter - long-ish album run time You Might enjoy this if you: - enjoy catchy, lo-fi-ish indie pop rock - love strong female voices in rock - would like to follow the chain of influences backwards to one of the flashpoints that inspired the modern wave of women in rock PLAYLIST ALTERATIONS - Those last four might very well be better than I thought, but I'm in no rush to find out FURTHER LISTENING ( I think maybe the whole Rolling Stones thing got me thinking more so than normal about influences, but the album itself reminded me of SO many things I went a bit overboard on this section) Precursors: - Kinda Kinks by the Kinks - The Velvet Underground & Nico by the Velvet Underground - Bridge over Troubled Water by Simon & Garfunkel - Horses by Patti Smith - Pretenders by the Pretenders - Bad Reputation by Joan Jett - Underwater Moonlight by the Softboys - Solitude Standing by Suzanne Vega - Throwing Muses by Throwing Muses - Let It Be by The Replacements - Exile On Main St by the Rolling Stones - #1 Record by Big Star - Jesus of Cool by Nick Lowe - Sister by Sonic Youth - Slanted and Enchanted by Pavement Contemporaries: - Under the Pink Tori Amos - Whatever by Aimee Mann - Rid of Me by PJ Harvey - A Date with The Smithereens by The Smithereens - Tuesday Night Music Club by Cheryl Crow - Saturation by Urge Overkill - American Thighs by Veruca Salt - Roman Candle by Elliott Smith - Purple Tape by Lisa Loeb - Dear Sir by Cat Power - Sleater-Kinney by Sleater-Kinney Descendants: - Tidal by Fiona Apple - Jagged Little Pill by Alanis Morissette - Calling Over Time by Edith Frost - Rabbit Fur Coat by Jenny Lewis - Sometimes I Sit and Think, and Sometimes I Just Sit by Courtney Barnett - Marry Me by St. Vincent - Lush by Snail Mail - Stranger in the Alps by Phoebe Bridgers - Sour by Olivia Rodrigor - No Burden by Lucy Dacus - For Young Hearts by Soccer Mommy - The Death of Speedy Ortiz by Speedy Ortiz
I feel as though I’ve just lived through a novel. Eighteen songs, a little band that frequently sounds as though it has barely finished rehearsing, and an extraordinary accumulation of characters, encounters, desires, resentments, fantasies and disappointments. By the time the record ended, I felt I’d inhabited an entire world. And, rather wonderfully, I wanted to go straight back in. I came to this album with one fairly substantial reservation: its relationship to the Rolling Stones’ Exile on Main St., a record I’ve never particularly enjoyed. I find the Stones’ sprawling looseness more often indulgent than inspired. But Phair seems to have recognised something useful in its architecture, taking an existing framework and filling it with an entirely different musical and imaginative universe. Whatever the extent of the correspondence, this album has a shape and momentum that I find considerably more satisfying. The first revelation is the writing. Within seconds of 6’1”, Phair is producing observations of startling precision. The phrase “shyly brave” stopped me in my tracks. It’s the kind of apparent contradiction that conveys an entire personality in two words. And she continues finding these little miracles of economy across the record. It’s tempting to hear these songs as a confessional autobiography, particularly given the intimacy of the performances and the frankness of the sexual material. But that would undersell Phair’s literary imagination. She invents situations, adopts voices and constructs characters who aren’t necessarily consistent with one another, let alone with their author. Her narrators can be sexually voracious, romantically needy, contemptuous, vulnerable, manipulative, compassionate and spectacularly unreasonable. The contradictions aren’t defects in a personal manifesto. They’re the substance of the writing. This is also what makes the album’s treatment of gender so interesting. Phair enters a musical world in which men have traditionally enjoyed the privilege of defining both the rules and the language, then proceeds to examine, appropriate and sometimes ridicule those conventions. But she doesn’t simply reverse the roles and declare victory. Her characters still want affection, approval, commitment and sexual satisfaction, sometimes simultaneously and incompatibly. Their freedom to be contradictory is part of the point. And then there’s the music, which I absolutely adored. The arrangements are almost comically modest. Scratchy guitars, rudimentary rhythms, little instrumental figures that sometimes sound as though they’ve been discovered by accident. Yet there’s considerable invention within those limitations. Open strings continue ringing while fretted chord shapes move against them, creating lovely, slightly dissonant harmonies. Strummed guitars occasionally push against the underlying beat. Melodies wander across the bar lines, following the contours of speech rather than demanding that the words march obediently into place. Phair’s singing is particularly remarkable for how little it seems to perform. She doesn’t advertise the emotional significance of every line or inflate a small observation into a grand revelation. Often the melody seems to be forming as she speaks, despite the evident care in the writing. There’s something wonderfully intimate about being allowed to hear a thought without having its importance demonstrated to you. The production is equally inventive. A distant, reverberant piano can coexist with an almost uncomfortably close vocal. Faint secondary voices drift around the margins of songs, sometimes barely intelligible, like stray thoughts intruding upon the narrator’s confident declarations. At other moments the band changes direction or the tempo unexpectedly shifts. These aren’t necessarily expensive or elaborate effects, but they continually alter the psychological space occupied by the music. What astonished me was the emotional range available to such tiny arrangements. Divorce Song is a particularly devastating account of the petty details and impossible bargains of a failing relationship. Its bright rhythmic guitar makes the weary resignation of the singing more affecting, not less. Elsewhere, Flower delivers an extravagantly filthy fantasy in a sweet, almost musical-theatre voice, with a comic innocence worthy of Rodgers and Hammerstein. The contrast is hilarious. Then Johnny Sunshine begins with a succession of almost absurd grievances before suddenly opening into a heartbreakingly exposed lament, its overlapping little voices achieving something of the emotional force that Spiritualized would later pursue with enormous gospel arrangements. Phair does it with what sounds like a handful of overdubs and a roomful of ingenuity. That’s the recurring miracle here: small music for grown-up feelings. The sequencing matters enormously. These aren’t simply eighteen good songs assembled in a convenient order. Their contrasts gradually establish the dimensions of Phair’s world. The more expansive, uneasy atmosphere of Shatter feels like something changing in the album’s emotional landscape. Stratford-on-Guy then offers an almost entirely descriptive account of looking down upon Chicago from an aeroplane. It reminded me unexpectedly of Spalding Gray: precise observation made fascinating without the obligation to produce a moral or advance a plot. Finally, Strange Loop brings us to a thought that remains unresolved: wanting someone, being exhausted by conflict, and recognising that desire has exceeded understanding. The familiar chiming, slightly dissonant guitars eventually descend into ragged, Pavement-like disorder. The band almost seems to come apart. And then there’s silence. No grand resolution, no triumphant conclusion, no final explanation of what we’ve just experienced. Certainly no obligatory 1990s hidden-track joke. What makes this such a compelling album is that its roughness never feels like an excuse for artistic laziness. The performances may be loose, but the ideas are disciplined. The songs are brief, but their implications are enormous. I repeatedly found myself pausing because it took longer to think about what I’d heard than it had taken the song to play. This is everything I want from an album: an unmistakable authorial voice, an endlessly resourceful musical imagination, humour, discomfort, emotional credibility and a compelling reason to experience the whole thing rather than merely collect its highlights. I finished it exhilarated. Not because every question had been answered, but because Phair had given me so many interesting questions to take away. And because, after eighteen songs, I still wanted more.
So, so bad. 0.0000
Aggression without abrasion.
I don’t know why it took me this long to listen to Liz Phair she’s awesome
I remember a lot of buzz about this album when I was in high school, but I never was really able to get into it. Listening to it this time I thought it was okay. Her voice sounds like she's trying to deliver everything in deadpan... no real energy or emotion. It just doesn't work for me... and I was hard pressed to find a memorable melody here.
I can’t help but enjoy what Phair is doing here. A record like this that subverts the patriarchy in rock with this clever of a concept is likely to be a winner for me. The one thing I wasn’t sure about, at first, was this Lo-Fi production but it grew on me more and more as the album progressed. I felt it fits what she’s going for well and there some nice nuances and little moments I appreciated, though the narrative and lyricism are still the strength here, for me. 1 listen Favorite Tracks: Fuck and Run, Never Said, Stratford-On-Guy, Divorce Song, 6’1”, Strange Loop
This is very much a 90s album and a style I'm glad we moved past. I did like/recognize Divorce Song. Perhaps that got some radio play back in the day.
Solid, but didn't live up to the hype for me.
Another 1 I haven’t heard since it came out. It’s not as bad as I remember and nowadays I would probably have given it more time. But it still has or doesn’t have something. The songs just aren’t strong enough to carry the limited vocals, the vocals limitations put a strain on the lo-fi arrangement and production. It’s ok, that’s about it 3 Star
Thought I'd have liked this more
I love this album.
debut album by singer and musician liz phair. before recording a full album release, phair recorded original alt rock songs on cassette and circulated them with other likeminded rock and indie fans. her debut is centered around themes of small-town isolation and mentalities. the album got large acclaim and sold . moderately well, which was a surprise to phair; she dismissed the album as "nothing remarkable" and simply focused on the fact that she finished a project. now this is some indie rock i can really vibe with. true classic indie with actual clear mixing, good written song structures and clear vocals that don't sound like someone groaning and mumbling into the mic... it's the total opposite of what a lot of indie tends to be. just a woman who's fed up, her guitar and some drums. you can't really ask for more here. lowkey it sounds like daria singing an indie rock album. it's pretty cool. i'm giving it a 4.
3.3
This one took a few listens but it really grew on me. She's not the strongest singer but in most cases it suits the song and the mood.
This is the kind of album I love but I've never loved Exile in Guyville (or Liz, generally). Even around when it came out and I was desperately seeking anything in this kind of space it didn't click for me. I do like it a little better now, however many years removed, but its lows are real low (6'1" sounds terrible) and it doesn't have any highs to offset them. It's just ok. I really tried. I even listened to Exile on Main St. again to see if the added context improved the album. It just reminded me I did not care for Exile on Main St.
Enjoyable album
Kind of liked it
Why does she sound so bored here?? It’s both unsettling and off putting. The instrumentation is fine enough, pretty good at times even, but the length of the album and singer leave a lot to be desired. Really not a fan of Liz’s uninterested voice and it makes the songs on this album very hard to bear, unfortunately. Never a good start when I don’t like the singers voice, but when you also pair it with an album that lasts for almost an hour, it’s tough not giving this one a single star. Never heard of Liz Phair and unfortunately I don’t think I ever want to again. Graciously, this is her only album on the list, and I’m very thankful for that, because I really just did not like this one in the slightest. Another review mentions this sounds like a worse Alanis Morissette, who they also didn’t enjoy either, and I think that review really spoke to me. I also didn’t like that album, and this one may be worse. I don’t even mean to come off as rude or hostile, I give like 90% of albums at least a 3, but this one in particular is just egregiously bad and I don’t think I want to listen to it more than once. Which also makes picking a favorite difficult, so I guess I’m going to have to dive back in to it, begrudgingly so. Because there’s really not a lot of enjoyment for me here. I just hope she’s not still making music today, this is pretty torturous. And of course the album ends with several seconds of pure silence, making the looping a slight pain as well. Hell, even the album art is stupid and loops derpy. Man. I don’t know what it is about this album today. I’m in a good mood and everything. It’s just really bad. If I had to pick a favorite it would be “Mesmerizing”. That song didn’t immediately aggravate me, and might even save me from having to listen to this album all the way through a second time. The real question is whether or not I give this a 1 or a 2. Since at least the instrumentation is ok, I’m leaning towards a 2, but it’s surprisingly close. Sure, let’s give it a 2 and never speak of this one again. Next album please. I don’t want to spend any more time with this one.
Overall Rating - 3.47/5 (6.94/10). A coworker, when I told him I had this album today, called it slacker-rock. I like that description. And it's a good album. Better than average. Not necessarily fully my taste, but definitely very good. Competent songwriting, clearly early in her career, experimenting to find her voice. Definitely a voice of GenX Slackers, which I can respect.
I've heard good things about this from critics and music nerds. It's not very interesting sonically, just being a light guitar rock album with fairly pleasant vocals and not a whole lot of sonic bite. The lyrics are an attempt to portray an honest portrait of the female experiences with love and relationships. However, though this raw, honest statement may have been revolutionary at the time, it no longer feels so today, and all we're left with is a light, pleasant alt-rock album.
This is one of those albums where I went in having a very vague expectation of what the general vibe was going to be. I was expecting much more of a punk rock, in-your-face, angry vibe. And while there is some of that, most of it is definitely not. Maybe shame on me for having preconceived notions, but I was surprised that a lot of this was almost folk-y sounding, acoustic, and emotional. Now I will say that the lyrical content is fairly deep. “Canary”, in my interpretation, is analogous to being the “good girl” that conforms to societal norms. “Fuck And Run” is about those relationships we have all gone back to, knowing damn well that they are no good for us and will wind up nowhere. And those are just some of the many examples throughout the 18 tracks on this monster. So while being far from shallow, it doesn’t have the sound I’m looking for. At least not all the way through.
This album takes me back to a very specific time in the 90s, and feels like it would be on some kind of quirky soundtrack with a manic pixie dream girl. I didn't mind it, but it won't be something I'll add to any playlists.
I had never heard of this album before but really enjoyed today's :)
The lyrics here are crazy. The songs are clever. The guitar sounds annoy me and I can't get past it
I’ll be phair and say that this wasn’t too bad there were some good songs. but liz be honest it wasn’t great, respect to her though
Вперше чую) Прикольна співачка)
Not bad!
I never really connected with Liz Phair, but was glad to see a female driving force out there. This album feels very long, too long. I guess that means I'm not really enjoying it. Meh.
I gave it an honest try but couldn’t get into it. Not my vibe but can appreciate it so giving it a 2.
j'aime beaucoup sa voix grave, ses textes sont intéressants et la guitare est top. super album
I feel that she has always been a bit underrated.
Definitely some enjoyable songs on this album, but even more just plain mid songs that didn't do anything for me. My biggest gripe is that a lot of the melodies are weak and uncompelling. A bit more refinement and fleshing out of the songs would have gone a long way to elevate things. Way she goes.
This gives me a bit of Fiona Apples vibes... and that didn't sit very well with me. This is much less abrasive and dissonant, but still. My guess is that this album is all about the lyrics and her story telling. Sadly, that didn't resonate with me. And the music itself felt very bare-bones and almost like demo material at times - though slightly better sounding to be fair. But just under-produced, really. In addition, the album wasn't very varying to my ears. Too much of the same. Liz Phair seems like a fun person to grab a beer and talk smack with, but I didn't particularly enjoy her music. Just not my taste.
Soon there will be no more 90s rock albums I’m forced to listen to. Hurray! Didn’t like this one, she always sounds bored. Bland rock with no edge. Just go listen to Alanis Morisette instead.
A bit long for my taste but it wasn’t terrible.
I find the idea of this fascinating. Such a cool project. Kind is hard to listen to, though. Possible that this is just sexism. Thinking about it
Not the best thing I’ve ever listened to, but it’s not like ear bleed level. None of the songs really jumped out at me but they were perfectly listenable. It was fine, not bjork bad.
kinda feels like its trying to be sonic youth and, as someone pointed out, hole. it has its own merits though
If Elliott Smith were a woman, he'd have sounded like this.
I’ve heard Liz Phair’s name throughout my life, but I’m just realizing I’ve never actually heard a single one of her songs. After listening to this album, I wish I could go back to that time in my life. I am not a fan of her singing, but it seems like she can write a song.
So good. I don’t care about concept album dimension - this is just piercing and wonderful.
Get a load of me get a load of you lady. 6"1' Canary and probably Flower
'& all the bridges blown away keep floating up.' Most people don't - can't - do attitude this well & this comfortably, but Liz Phair is a wholesome genius of the pop persuasion, & Exile In Guyville is a miracle of a record. It's very tempting to compare Phair to PJ Harvey, but comparing woman to woman can be not all that nuanced a business, & their styles are actually different enuf for the comp to be empty. More like an amalgam of Lucinda Williams & Malkmus, Phair is wise but not too wise, sensitive but not too sensitive, a punk hero, pop master, rock realist, & a conclusive vocalist. 'Explain It To Me' is simply extraordinary, one of those tracks you hear for the first time & know it'll be one for the books. Yet so much here is extraordinary. I love it.
*1993. *I almost like the sound - it's like a wannabe Hole, but Liz kinda sounds like a poser. *Lyrics are largely really juvenile while trying to be edgy. Maybe it worked better in the early 90s. *I thought I'd like this better than I did, as I'm into the angry 90s woman vibe. But it's not hitting for me. *This is really a strong 2, but bumping to a 3 because it isn't that terrible. RATING - 5.5/10
This is an album I just can’t figure out. I see this on many critics lists of best albums but it just seems to go on forever. I understand some of the themes of women taking back the power in the relationship but maybe since I am a man I just didn’t get it. The voice also seemed like a weaker Courtney Love
Decent enough, but didn’t really have me in awe or anything. Wouldn’t rush back to it.
I found myself liking this album more than anticipated... Unfortunately. Why do I say unfortunately? Because this is the perfect representation of the major criticisms of 90's music: "Talentless unskilled crap with little technical skill." While I suppose saying that implies I think as much about this album (and to a certain extent, I do), I do think there is an important element to the storytelling and nonchalance of this album--and to a greater degree, the grungier albums of the 90's. I don't want to jump the gun and assert that this album is only on here due to Phair's apparent feminist ties (after all, this is a list of albums one MUST listen to, not necessarily the best albums), but it does shock me that this album makes the list. Then again, I liked it.
Favorite Track: Fuck and Run
This is a pleasant surprise as I’d never heard of her! A lo-fi, stripped back, indie/folk little number. She seems quite angry and I suspect on the second listen I may tune into the lyrics and find this a bit more disturbing!
Really good, a little long, but I enjoyed it.
*From* Guyville sounds more like it.
langweiliges Album
Schwer anzuhören
mid
3.75 🤘🤘
Whipsmart is my fav, but Guyville is certainly very good.
Her lyrics are simple n straight forward but being her debut album it will be interesting to see how her songwriting progressed. I'm sure she was popular with the teenage girls when it came out.
This isn't bad but I feel like you have to be in a specific mood for this kind of music to really hit.
never gave her a listen until today. Good stuff, although I do not feel I was missing anything these past 33 years...
Not the best singer but it works really well as a soft lo fi indie rock piece. Likes: Never Said; Fuck and Run; Divorce Song
Aged like a fine wine.
Really not a fan. Like a worse Alanis Morisette (and I didn’t like that album either). Maybe if this didn’t directly follow the greatest album ever made I’d cut some slack, but no. 2 stars
Audacious. If it were merely Liz Phair doing a lo-fi 90s indie rock album, mainly just her and her guitar, singing about relationships and raunch, it would be a winner. But to know that this was a song-for-song reply album to Exile on Main Street by the Stones, this puts it in the classic category.
Generally not a fan of the singing style, but Canary had me captivated.
4/10 - whiny teen rock
fine
Fali nešto. Više života. Više energije. Više bijesa. Ovako ispada veoma bljutavo što definitivno nije željeni utisak. I predugo traje.
one of those great female alternative 90s stuff
One of the formative 90's Indie music albums. Pitchfork: n/a Rolling Stone: Top 500 Albums #56
Fuck and run, man. Fuck and run.
I dont like it
la verdad me sorprendió, al principio no creí que me iba a gustar pero al final terminé muy enganchada
Kind of all over the place but I enjoyed it
Day997 - passion and good lyrics is better than polish
God awful.
The 90s called and this album picked up. It's not my usual fare but there's something compelling about it.
Yeah, great. I get the impression that there is some pretty cool stuff going on lyrically here that I'm not quite in tune with because I tend to miss lyrics. I guess it hear enough to know that she's a woman not afraid to talk about female sexuality which seems admirable (hope I haven't got the wrong end of the stick). The delivery style works great in places and sometimes for me personally it just doesn't chime and kind of seems nothing special.
I avoided Liz and this album when it first came out. It was way better than I gave it credit. Still only a 3 though.
Ok
Many of the songs do really clever things with that makes the songs interesting and makes the album feel cohesive even though the songs differ a lot. I enjoyed it but something was missing, I was waiting for some song that made the singer really go for it but it never came. Her voice is great but it feels like she could have gotten a bit louder, like she could have taken the center stage a bit more. But it kept being subdued instead. Its not music I listen to often and while I might have something like this on in the background its not an album I will be seeking out for that purpose.
I liked this! It is the kind of feeling though that I might have to give it a relisten to fully engage with the songs. I like Liz Phair's voice and vibe a lot though, so I'll look forward to exploring her music more. Fav Tracks: "Never Said", "Divorce Song" and "Johnny Sunshine".
The production on this just doesn't sound all too great but there's some interesting moments here, they're just wayyy too rare. 1.5/5
At the time, such a breakthrough. What a talent.
Liz Phair is so underrated! This is her most famous but not even her best album in my opinion. But this was such an amazing way to kick off her career. So raw and real here - she does not hold back at all or shy away from telling the truth. This is such an important album for indie rock and women singer/songwriters. Lyrics are so good and the sparse guitar works so well. It's long and not every song hits, but when it does, it really does. Top Songs: 6'1", Never Said, F**k and Run, Divorce Song, Strange Loop
Gosh this book makes you realise how much music is actually out there in the world and so little of it actually permeates the veil of our own personal experiences. As someone who is always listening, so much still goes unheard. How many lifetimes would I need to hear it all I wonder. My list would be so extremely different if I ever took the time to curate such. I have never heard of Liz before, first thing I notice is that this album has a whopping 21 tracks! The chord progressions of the first tracks remind me of smashmouth haha nothing incredibly unique there and her voice certainly isn’t anything outstanding but interesting stories are told within the lyrics. Further listening, reminds me of Merideth Brooks/Sheryl Crow, typical of 90’s pop/rock chicks I suppose, same sort of musicality and voice tonality, same sort of honest bluntness in the words. Like many other reviews so far, I struggle to just listen to the album for what it is but wonder what missed out so this could make the list? For the sheer amount of songs she squeezed in? The possible ‘nip slip’ on the cover? Would I buy this record if I saw it in the $5 bargain bin - no
21 songs, but only available 17 on Spotify Fairly monotone voice, but it works for the songs and their lyrical content tbh. Didn't blow me away or anything, but it's not bad.