The first two songs were great - the rest of it was kind of forgettable

Enjoyable! Hated the sex intermission but the rapping was pretty good

LOVE S&G together, solo album just doesn't do it for me sadly

All-time classic

In the words of Jay-Z, "Grand opening, grand closing.... forgettable middle"

Enjoyed this a lot more than I thought I would! Love the blues here.

Thought the 18 min track would save it, did the opposite. Not a huge fan of LSD rock it appears

Fine! Just fine. Won't listen again

So long. Not terrible though, nice to recognize some stuff, liked it more than I thought I would

I love the guitar and the vibes but dislike the whole braggadocios nature of the band, feels like the same song 9 times

I was always a self-titled truther for a long time & hadn't listened to this album in a bit. Rolling it on its' 38th anniversary feels like fate and I finally understand. Listened multiple times yesterday, highly enjoyable. May be music for sad people but dammit if between the bars isn't one of the best songs ever written

Sounded pretty dated unfortunately. Not a huge fan

The first half was great. I've never taken psychadelics, but if I did I think the world would sound like the narrator on the second half of the album. Very interesting.

Long but enjoyable, recognized a couple of hits from here

Enjoyable but not particularly memorable

Most enjoyable acid rock I've heard so far easily

Unmemorable but unoffensive pop, I'm fine with it

Can't recall a single song, especially compared to let it bleed

Solid disco!

Quite enjoyed this! Love some politically charged folk music

I have tried this album a lot in my life, because I feel like it's an album I SHOULD love. Each time I like it a little more, but not enough to give it more than 3 stars. Just feels kinda dated to me, I dunno

Was actually pleasantly surprised by this one. Recognized a couple tunes from soccer chants. Wouldn't listen again but I expected for it to be a lot less I mean holy shit it's the monkey album

Not bad at all! Didn't realize I knew the first track until I got war flashbacks to every commercial I've ever heard

Actually incredible pick. Best new album I've heard so far. Love the songwriting, love the electric guitar.

Enjoyable, but forgettable

Never been a metal guy but I really enjoyed the guitar work on this album, will listen again

Really enjoyed this. Only ever listened to Rumours like most people my age, but there were some good poppy tracks combined with some great songwriting. Probably the best album that I've never heard so far.

Awful. Girls might be the worst song I've ever heard, laughably bad. Yeah, No Sleep Till Brooklyn and Fight for your Right are on here, but they're overplayed and I could not STAND them. Brass Monkey is super corny, too. Nothing else memorable. Glad to never have to listen to this album ever again.

Also not bad. Not great either, but unsure why U2 gets such a bad rap.

I didn't think I was a metal fan, now I KNOW I'm not a metal fan. Guitar is fine, but vocals are horrendous.

Yeah, just not the genre for me... oh well

Wow, really loved this even if I didn't understand a word. Great rhythm, great harmonies, very very groovy

Felt a little long at parts but otherwise pretty good!

This sounds like if you told someone to record a rock album at The Haunted Mansion

People say this album is super influential, and I don't doubt it - and maybe it's because I wasn't around when this came out - but it just doesn't hit too hard for me. I think Heroin is very cool, and I'm not too fond of the experimental bits, but I think it's supremely overrated if anything.

Repetitive certainly

An album I've always wanted to listen to but never had the motivation. Met expectations, I'd say, really enjoyed the atmosphere

I didn't think I was a big Nick Cave fan, mainly because of the voice (reminds me of an older Johnny Cash), but I REALLY enjoyed the instrumentation, especially on the first album.

Not my favorite but I appreciate the increased instrumentation

Definitely inoffensive melodramatic pop!

Like you recorded a rock album at the Haunted Mansion, but this time it was actually good

Nice r&b, however largely repetitive. Think his other albums are better

I enjoyed this but it gets knocked a star for the homophobia. Guess that’s just the 90s

Surprised by this one! Loved the variety and heard inspiration for so many bands.

Heck yeah. I haven't ever given Zeppelin a chance outside of the classics (IV mainly), but man I LOVED this. Bumping it down a star because the end felt a little underwhelming, but this is getting me excited for the rest of the Zeppelin on this list.

As I got further into this album the rating dropped lower and lower. Not because the music is bad - I think it's perfectly tolerable as background music in, say, 1985 - this album just feels like it goes on FOREVER with nothing redeemable. I'm sure you could play me this album again in a year and I wouldn't remember a single thing. It's just well-produced, risk-averse, bland late 70s jazz. Certainly not something I MUST listen to before I die, taking the title of this website literally.

Quite long, but still enjoyable. Classic CSN harmonies, love the instrumentation, but getting knocked for length, rounded down even.

Gifted with one of the best albums ever written today! Superb lyricism, wonderful guitarwork throughout, perfectly fit for one of the greats of our time.

First time willingly listening to Buddy Holly at all, can definitely understand how women from the 50s would go crazy over him. I think it's perfectly fine and representative of the time, and I can definitely hear the influences. I'd put it on this list for sure, it's a classic, however not sure if I'd ever listen to this again.

If I wanted to listen to jazz, I'd listen to jazz. If I wanted to listen to spoken word, I'd listen to spoken word. I would NEVER try to create both at the same time.

Pleasantly surprised! Loved the chamber pop melodies here. Mermaid Smiled is so so beautiful. Will listen again

Reminded me of Elton John, kind of. Liked the guitar work but I think it all blended together

Almost too positive, threw me off.

Surprisingly enjoyed this! Obviously some hard rock and some sex appeal screaming throughout but I thought it'd be a lot more offensive

I’m just confused. What the hell? Am I supposed to be high while listening to this? Am I high right now?

First, fuck Morrissey. Second, I think this album is just fine. I don't know what it is, but I never understood the obsession people have with it. There are some catchy tunes (There Is A Light and Bigfoot in particular) but the immense whining voice and self-loathing is just insufferable at times. Bumped down a half star for Morrissey existing.

Killer front half, forgettable back half. I do like synth-pop and I recognize their impact on modern synth-pop but I'd imagine their other albums are better.

Heck yeah. Great, easy-listening country tunes. Wish I had bought this on vinyl to listen first, feels like it needs some crackling to feel truly authentic

Forgettable. Repeatable. Dull.

I (generally) like jangle and britpop from the late 80s/early 90s, so this was right up my alley. Enjoyed the deeper cuts more than There She Goes, actually. Just wish the sound were a bit more varied.

Was pretty close to falling asleep during most of this, honestly. Not a huge fan

I have never been a big Bowie guy, full disclosure. I liked the first half a bit more than the ambient/electronic second half, but generally enjoyed this more than I have other Bowie records. Hoping there's one in here that ends up making his whole schtick click for me

I think this suffers the same problem as the Crickets album - both very stuck in their time, a time so far removed from pop of the modern day. Though this is more enjoyable than the Crickets album and it should definitely be on this list, not sure I'll listen to this again.

This feels like an evolution of trip-hop that Dummy created, the (at the time, I guess) modern tech really fits with the vocals. That said, I still like Beth Gibbons' solo work more than this.

I'll be honest. As this is my first Billy Joel album to come up on this list, I was ready to come in here and absolutely dog on him for being bland, unoriginal, etc. I gave this record another spin and realized something. This reads like a Greatest Hits album. Now, granted, 6 albums were released as singles, but I've heard, literally, a majority of the songs on this album for my entire life, either through my parents (yeah they had Just The Way You Are as their wedding song, too, so what?) or through the radio. The A side is absolutely loaded, I've never seen anything like it. And it's not like the songs are truly bad either - they're catchy and musically well written! The lyrics aren't gonna stun you with their wisdom, but they're relatable. I'm not going to sit here and decree that RADIO MUSIC = BAD, because who am I to act like I know better than what millions upon millions of other people have decided they really enjoy. The criticisms I mentioned above are valid for Billy's other albums, but not for this one. I cannot give this anything lower than 4.5 stars, but I'm bumping this down to 4 because this isn't my favorite album of all time, but the popularity and impact of this album is undeniable.

Good album, but can't help but wonder what it would have looked like in its' intended form. RIP Brian.

Really enjoyed this one! Incredibly well mixed, and Dusty's voice does wonders to make this feel so warm and rich.

Some nice jazz. Would be nice to put on in the background while I work.

This was a pleasant surprise. A little eclectic at times, but I found this album generally pretty groovy. This might enter the rotation for me.

I really wish I could like this more. Just find it uninteresting, I don't know.

Another phenomenal Neil Young album. 2/2 on this list so far, maybe I never gave him enough credit before this list.

Just not my genre unfortunately. Not as bad as the last album of this style I listened to

I understand the whole other devil persona bit Eminem goes for with Slim Shady, and I knew what I was getting into with this album. Did not make it any more enjoyable, he has better songs/albums than this.

My favorite coldplay album! I know it's really popular to dunk on them for being radiohead clones or what have you, but you can't deny that this is some great arena rock.

The best S&G album, and one of the best albums ever written, bar none. Plenty to love here, from the title track to one of the best storytelling songs penned (The Boxer) to the gorgeous harmonies on The Only Living Boy in New York... what I wouldn't give to listen to this album for the first time again.