Album Summary
California is the third studio album by American indie rock band American Music Club. It was released on November 10, 1988 on Frontier Records. The album was included in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. In the album's article in the book, reviewer Arnar Eggert Thoroddsen, from Iceland's daily newspaper Morgunblaðið, describes the album as the band's "definitive statement."
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Another YouTube listen, fortunately not punctuated by adverts. This was a pleasant diversion; nice songs, well arranged and with good musicianship. If it was easier to access, I would probably listen again.
Not quite up there with ‘Love Songs For Patriots’ in my opinion but still a strong showing. I like Eitzel’s delivery and there is a fair showcase of different approaches to this style which I enjoyed, particularly ‘pale skinny girl’ which really grabbed me. Probably worth a relisten to really appreciate the lyricism.
sweet + mellow, chord progressions very cool
What a crazy transition to and from Bad Liquor. Favourite Track(s): Blue and Grey Shirt Least Favourite Track(s): Lonely
Wasn't available for streaming
okay
Now this was interesting
Least pretentious indie band name. Another album that was a bit difficult to track down. Surely it won't also suck, right? They feel like a band that might actually have something, but are too afraid to explore it fully.
There is a sterility to the production that irks me. Can't put my finger on it, but it's there. Too clean somehow. Jenny, was my favorite track and ironically it sounds nothing like the rest of this album.
Another album that doesn't exist anywhere except YouTube (insert lengthy screed about use of YouTube in 2026), so I couldn't listen to this one. Instead, I listened to these guys' 1991 album, Everclear, which was ... well I was going to say "more sad dad" music, but it wasn't exactly that. Not really even sad uncle music -- more like sad slightly older cousin music. Anyway, quite meh; I sorta liked Crabwalk, which sounded a bit like a lesser Old 97's song, but that was about it.
I had never heard of this before now. I did actually kind of enjoy parts of it. I'm sad about some of the production choices first and foremost. If this had been recorded more dry,raw,live I think it would have definitely had more of an impact. I feel like I say that pretty often on so many recordings from 1985 to 1989. There were some cool guitar parts and some interesting songcraft on here. It will probably motivate me to go through their other stuff.
No conecté con el, pero si hubo momentos donde se sintió un rock un poco diferente a la línea que llevan en este álbum como pasa con Bad Liquor Más allá de eso, nada que destacar
Fun times on Youtube streaming
couldn't get access to it to listen /did not listen
AMC were the soundtrack to my 20s. After the initial resistance I even lured some friends into the Mark Eitzel camp. Teenage angst in an old soul. Restless guitars and poetic proclamations. Like hanging with Chekhov at your local dive bar... And outside this bar there's no one alive Yeah, outside this bar how does anyone survive Together you and me, you know we've gotta destroy this world Come on darling, we've gotta destroy this world What's not to love?
i didn’t listen to this one i listened to another one of theirs tho
annoying, whiny and uninspired.. yuck. i had high hopes after the first song but it went downhill FAST
blegh
A bit too moody and atmospheric for me today
American Music Club is a tough band to understand, apparently. What to know: 1. "Is it "slowcore"? Wikipedia and such say it's slowcore." Fuck no, that's barely a genre anyhow. These early albums like California are more early alt country albums, no slower (or core-r) than the country-folk of CNSY or TVZ, with pedal steel features heavily (and beautifully), with lyrics are definitely booze-soaked stories of losers and tragedies, straight out of country music before that genre become trucks, beer, boots, and jingoism. The production is much more murky reverb-drenched post-punk (which is kinda too bad, honestly, especially on this album), and that's probably where the association with that "slowcore" tag comes from. 2. "Is it mopey?" Fuck yes. None mopier. They probably didn't record a happy song until 1994 or so. You'll just have deal with all the losering. California, having listened to it again for the first time in years, is a pretty great set of songs. The two previous albums has some great songs as well as some clunkers, but Mark Eitzel's tragicomic storytelling is fully developed for the first time here on California. For me, the next two albums, Everclear (probably my favorite) and Mercury surpass California. Listening today made me feel like I had underappreciated California though. It really is a remarkable set of songs, but the production makes all the songs sound to much alike. Everclear is probably slicker but the instruments come through more distinctly (and its best songs are even better, even though the tracks here might be more consistently strong). Mercury is a more diverse set of songs, with the band showing off its capability a little more. I think I'd still list Everclear instead of California, but I'm kinda surprised to remember what a great album California is, too.
lol what is this?
Good album, dragged on a bit, bad liquor was good. It startled the fuck out of me though, why is it even there??
Nothing special.
Very uneven, sad americana, has its moments, but a little over the place to me.
The album wasn’t available on Spotify so I listened to the top 10 tracks instead. No fav song
Had to listen via YouTube again. Not really my thing, not much more to say about it.
29 Oct 2026 · 4/10 ughhh kinda mid as hell. boring too
Fine
The music press loved AMC and I was always keen to try them but it was harder in the 90’s… so now I’ve heard them and I enjoyed it but probably wouldn’t have in the 90’s. Country flecked, but mainly Mark Eitzels emotionally bare lyrics and skeletal guitar. It’s fragile and heart worn and that’s often a sweet spot for me
Not a fan of spiritualized rap. Not surprised I never heard of this band before.
Had to go to YouTube for this one and was surprised at some of the gushing comments. I’d never heard of American Music Club before. This album has a nice production, but musically I found it beige and uninspiring. Good for what it is…
Album was not available
2. Ugh. Seriously. Lyrically annoying.
Wordy, but not exactly literary.
He's trying to say something, but I have no idea what. Kinda sleepy and bland, then at the 20 minute mark, Reverend Horton Heat snuck in a song, because it did NOT fit the rest of the album. I was going to give it a 2, but I love The Rev, so 3 it is.
I was unfamiliar with this band and its creative force, Mark Eitzel. I found this to be a good listen. I probably won't return to it, but fans of this style will enjoy this album. This is between a 3 and 4 for me. I'll go with 3, simply because nothing really grabbed my attention and held on.
4.5/10 Late 80s indie rock by a band I've never heard of before. This album is ragingly mediocre - there is nothing of interest here in the slightest. At times it sounds like Wilco, or Sufjan Stevens, in that country rock and acoustic singer-songwriter kind of way, but it just isn't good enough for me to want to engage with in more depth. The death-knell of this album comes in the penultimate track, Highway Five: when singing about Los Angeles they say "highway five" rather than "the 5". I can't. While I can see a world where this would be 3 stars, I'm too bored to give it more than 2.
1988 no depression Firefly Blue and grey shirt
Could not listen
I enjoyed the first 2 songs and bad liquor, but after that it seems like they tried to go a whole different direction. It does not work imo
pissed off and sad that this isn’t on streaming. Loved firefly, Jenny, and last harbor
it was ok. i think aucklynn said the first song was really good and i agree. it raised my expectations a little too much for the album.
shoutout to whoever put the full album ad free on youtube. This album was whiplash to say the least. I loved the first song a lot and was like wow! I think im going to love this. what followed after that was... disappointing to say the least. They felt like recent taylor swift trying to fit as much whole lotta nothing burger 'deep' lyrics in as much as possible. I was prepared to give this a 1 when bad liquor played and I thought "oh one good song in a whole lotta bad album" and then jenny played and was like holy shit this is great I wish this was on spotify so I could listen to it more. And everything after that I was like this is kinda my shit. Feeling conflicted and confused as to how I feel about what I just listened to I give this a 2 because that feels the most right, maybe.
Relaxing and pretty diverse for what it's worth. I liked it, but I can see rating it lower
Had to work unusually hard to find a way to listen to this because it's not on Spotify and truthfully I'm not sure it was worth all that work. It's fine, he's kinda doing a Bruce Springsteen lite thing with his voice sometimes which I don't think totally worked for me. I do like the sound but it didn't strike me as extremely compelling or interesting. Overall I enjoyed listening to it just fine but it didn't blow me away. 3.5ish stars! Second act montage needle drop in my biopic: "Jenny"
I liked the first song! and then nothing from the rest of the album really caught my attention but it wasn't bad to listen to for the most part. Didn't dislike it and it set a pretty alright vibe. Im saying that I would listen to it again because it seems like an interesting album that I would want to further appreciate but in truth idk when I am going to return to this. still, a 3 Likelihood that the members of this band lezzed out IMO: 4/5, theyre from san francisco and they have a bunch of pictures in cute little outfits. I think it happened.
ok so i had never heard of these guys before and on paper this is something that should really hit for me but it didn't for a reason that i really can't identify... i almost turned it off after the first track, godawful this project is making me see that vocal performances do actually impact how much i enjoy a piece of music, for the most part the instrumentals on this are good but not amazing but the singer and a lot of the lyrics being dumb really kind of kills it for me i do see how they influenced later bands and that like indie Americana sound but I'm not really a huge REM guy either, i prefer the more slowcore songs to the rest of it 2.5/light 3
Sympa
Not available on Spotify and I've never heard of them before. I'm having a hard time getting past the singer's voice. I just don't like it... "Blue and Grey Shirt" was the first song where I thought the vocal matched the music. Before that, it even sounded out of tune. I kept going, I kept not liking the singer. No fault to the music itself but I wouldn’t listen to this again bc of the vocals.
Really good album it kinda sounds like a indie album from late 90s early 2000s, I'd never heard of the band and never heard the album before it was a pleasant surprise I'll be listening to this one more
Perfection.
Felt meandery. Vocals were good but the music didn’t feel cohesive
Fine, but not particularly inspiring.
I wasn't expecting to like this one as much as I did based on the ratings, but I am pleasantly surprised! This is a low 4
Uplifting, relaxing country roadtrip. Fusion of multiple genres. Favorite track - Bad Liquor
This was pretty dull. Lyrics are corny. Music was blah. Nothing to get excited about.
Never heard of them before, but really liked this. Easy listening.
Not come across this before and can here how in some parts how it has influenced REM, Elbow etc...
This album sounds really good, as in it sounds like it could've been produced and released today. Sadly, much like the band's name, it's a largely forgettable and fairly average album with a few key moments that are pleasant enough.
Album No. 0212 on my list. To be perfectly honest, I had never ever heard of American Music Club to be honest, so "California" was something completely new to me. I'm not quite sure what to make of this album. It feels oddly connected to some of my favorite albums (there's some "Darkness on the Edge of Town" by Bruce Springsteen in there, as well as Radiohead's "The Bends"). In addition, there are some country influences, some folk stuff, some rock stuff, something that may generally be interesting and appeal to me very much. The songs themselves however don't stick all too much, I'm not the biggest fan of the singer's voice, and I don't really like the production/sound on this one. It's a solid album and I'm actually curious why it has not been a bigger hit overall, but I'm personally not super much into it. It's a shame this album is not on Spotify (found it interesting how much this impacted people's rating of "California"), so I can't add any songs to my playlist. If it were possible though, it would be "Firefly", "Lonely", and "Pale Skinny Girl". 3/5 stars.
Alt rock meets alt country. Sounds like a bunch of different records, so I guess it’s influential even if it’s not essential. Not even the best alt country album released that year.
This is kind of just a whole lotta nothing. Another filler album with nothing really terrible, but also nothing standout either. 5/10
day 13 of not rolling Aja by Steely Dan Has to track this one down on YT, but it was kinda fun. Nice thing to listen to while I cooked dinner. Doubt I’ll seek it out again but compared to how much I hated The Cure yesterday this sounded excellent
Couple of weird spots that I wasn’t super into (bad liquor) but good vibes overall. 3.5
Some interesting songs here and there, but I mostly tuned it out. "Bad Liquor" was a huge jolt when I was enjoying the sleepier vibes.
I’ve heard cover albums with more original ideas than this but, honestly, I found it pretty enjoyable. I will say, it's one of the only times that I've been fully confused by an album because there's nothing unique about it as a rock album and it doesn't even have the novelty excuse that some later albums have.
Really a "meh" experience overall. As soon as the album started getting some steam, they threw in this weird punk-type song, "Bad Liquor" - genuinely might be one of the worst things I've heard in recent memory.
A 3.5 not quite good enough to round up.
#283 Heard Before? Other AMC, but not this album. Notes: - while it runs the gamut from Uncle Tupelo sounding country rock to Elliot Smith sounding songwriter fare, it never latches on to anything outstanding. it feels like music in the shadow of other music. Verdict: Fits nicely in the 90s alt-country scene, but not particularly special. Listen Again? Not feeling it, but you never know. I sometimes give pleasant things another chance.
Really enjoyed this one.
Relaxing background noise.
Soothing in a way
Good
The experience of listening to this album was really funny. I started out rather liking the instrumentals of the first few songs ("Firefly" in particular started out very promising), but the singer's voice (accent? enunciation?) was not doing it for me. Still, an overall 3-star. Then in the more high-energy / rock-like songs like "Lonely" where he tries to throw his voice, it just sounded strained in an uncharming way ... so okay, a 2-star .... and then finally the SLOG starting with "Bad Liquor" and *especially* "Jenny." :/
Honestly underrated here. Disappointing I can’t easily add some of these tracks to my daily rotation
The album not being on spotify led me to a youtube video of the entire album. I have no idea if it was the right album, as I have no way to verify, but I assume it was. This was perfectly boring background music. You forgot it was there until you suddenly remebered it and thought: Wow, this is pretty bland.
This is, well ok. I was listening to a lot of US indie at the time and thing is this album doesn’t stand out in my memory. Shit the band name is only a vague memory. And that’s the point here it’s completely not worthy of a spot on this list. It’s ok for its genre, part indie pop rock, acoustic introspection, hints of past agitation post punk and Americana- ticks all the boxes. But this is just that an ok example, yes as per the list is subjective, but this just seems to me critic suggestion of the slightly obscure to be cool. There are better, and/or more successful from the time to represent. Ok but not worthy of the list 3 Star
Really good alternative, almost tinged with Springsteen; like The National but obviously far ahead of that time. Stripped down in just the right way, not too much. I couldn't stop listening.
got a lot more out of this than i expected after the first couple songs. the more stripped back songs are generally much more appealing than the camp country rock stuff that makes up like half the tracklist tho (except for bad liquor, that doesn't really fit into either camp but i liked it anyway lol) favorite songs: pale skinny girl, highway 5, bad liquor least favourite song: somewhere
Fav: Western Sky L: Jenny, Bad Liquor 3 It took me a second to get used to the singing, but besides that I think the songs were pretty solid. On the Youtube video I watched with the whole album it freaks out at 26:14. Cover: 3 Name: 2 Can't stop thinking about RHCP with a title like that Minecraft Parody: Green Tater (Bad Liquor)
Not much to chew on with this one. 2/5
Fuck all of y'all, this thing is beautiful. Solid 4.
Fun stuff
Unremarkable but pleasant enough. This is much more pure indie to me than country but I suppose there are tiny little Dave Matthews tinges in there. Sounds more talkings headsy than that though
Liked the country crossed with post punk. If I walked by a bar these guys were playing I'd go in and have 3.5 beers
2 pictures: AMC or an old high school acquaintances that formed an Americana rock band that plays a couple shows at the small town fests and bars. What's that? They're the same picture? What a waste of a spot on this list (1.5)
Pleasant and unchallenging, but hardly essential.
average
A cool mix of post-punk and alt country. I can hear their influence on a lot of the 90's bands I listened to a lot. Depressing or sadcore is not really my thing, it really has to be the right moment to land correctly. This isn't something you put on just to have some background music going. There is some really good songwriting going on and it deserves a more active listen but I can't rate it highly, to sad sack for my liking.
IMHO a bit boring. But solid. (Listened to it on YouTube)
Not on Apple Music. Rating based on other album.
Only on YT. To listen again. Really good.
Indy Rock as 'definite statement'.
Not for me. 1/5
surprisingly so good
Il y a une imposture assez tenace dans les chapelles du rock indépendant qui consiste à confondre la neurasthénie polie avec le génie poétique. Dès qu’un type s’empare d’une guitare acoustique avec l’air d’avoir passé sa nuit à sangloter sur l’évier de sa cuisine, la critique s’emballe, sort les mouchoirs brodés et nous vend le nouveau messie de la douleur américaine. Avant tout soyons clair deux secondes, j’adore l’Americana, j’aime cette musique mais avec Mark Eitzel et sa clique d’American Music Club, j’ai toujours eu ce réflexe instinctif de recul, un scepticisme tenace qui refuse de céder sous les louanges convenues. Et pourtant, Dieu sait si l’on m’a rebattu les oreilles avec ce fameux California, sorti en 1988, estampillé par tous les gardiens du bon goût comme l’apogée indépassable du groupe, le chef-d’œuvre absolu du slowcore balbutiant et de la country alternative en trench-coat. Autant crever l’abcès tout de suite, ma réécoute attentive n’a absolument rien changé à l’affaire et pire, elle m’a conforté dans mon diagnostic initial. On nous vend un monument d’amertume crépusculaire, et je me retrouve face à un disque qui ronronne tranquillement dans son coin, confortablement emmitouflé dans son désespoir de salon. Attention, ce n’est pas une catastrophe intégrale, loin de là, et l’album mérite son 3 sur 5 parce qu’il aligne deux ou trois éclairs de grâce indéniables, des instants suspendus où le talent d’écriture émerge véritablement des limbes. Mais pour le reste, nous sommes face à un océan de torpeur, une mare sans la moindre ondulation. Le problème central d’American Music Club sur ce disque tient dans cette manie exaspérante de désamorcer toute prise de risque. L’Americana, pour fonctionner, a besoin de friction, et ici, la production préfère polir les angles jusqu’à l’usure. Dès que la batterie menace d’avoir un peu de frappe ou que la pedal steel pourrait déchirer l’espace d’une plainte poignante, le mixage étouffe la velléité sous une nappe de velours tiède. C’est tout simplement inoffensif. Parlons deux secondes de Mark Eitzel, le milieu indé a érigé ce chanteur en poète maudit définitif, l’archétype du loser magnifique qui contemple sa propre déchéance avec une lucidité chirurgicale. Sur le papier, le programme a de quoi séduire, mais à l’oreille, son registre vocal hésite constamment entre le murmure affecté et le vibrato chevrotant, comme s’il cherchait à nous convaincre de sa détresse par des effets de manche un peu trop voyants. Là où un Townes Van Zandt vous brise le cœur en deux accords et trois syllabes sans jamais forcer le trait, Eitzel semble constamment vous taper sur l’épaule pour vous rappeler à quel point il souffre. C’est du pathos bien emballé, parfois brillant dans les textes, mais qui manque cruellement de cette sécheresse tragique propre aux véritables géants de la musique de terroir américain. On a l’impression d’assister à une thérapie de groupe un peu chic où chacun s’écoute parler avec une complaisance infinie. Heureusement, au milieu de cette traversée en eaux calmes, le navire évite le naufrage grâce à quelques fulgurances que je ne peux décemment pas balayer d’un revers de main. Quand le groupe lâche enfin la bride à une mélancolie plus directe et moins boursouflée, la magie opère. Il y a sur cet album deux ou trois titres magnifiques qui justifient qu’on ne jette pas le disque par la fenêtre. Des moments où l’écriture folk trouve une résonance authentique, où les arpèges de guitare et les arrangements de cordes discrètes esquissent une Amérique fantomatique, rongée par ses propres chimères. Sur ces quelques perles, Eitzel touche du doigt ce qu’il prétend faire sur toute la longueur : capter l’essence d’un désenchantement sans fard, une solitude nocturne où l’ironie mordante se mêle à une tendresse désespérée. Dans ces parenthèses inspirées, la voix ne cabotine plus, elle se pose, les arrangements respirent enfin et l’on entrevoit ce qu’aurait pu être cet enregistrement s’il avait été tenu par une véritable vision incisive plutôt que par une mollesse érigée en système esthétique. Mais l’illusion ne fait pas long feu, et dès que ces réussites s’achèvent, le disque replonge la tête la première dans son marasme capitonné. Les morceaux s’enchaînent avec une régularité de métronome engourdi, se diluant les uns dans les autres jusqu’à former une purée d’accords mineurs où rien ne dépasse. C’est tout le paradoxe de ce cru 1988 : on nous parle d’un chef-d’œuvre incandescent, mais en vérité, c’est une œuvre qui ne prend jamais le moindre risque de se brûler. La formule reste désespérément la même d’un bout à l’autre, reposant sur un tempo ralenti à l’extrême et des arpèges qui finissent par tourner à vide. On comprend bien l’influence que ce disque a pu exercer par la suite sur une ribambelle de formations dépressives des années 1990. On y trouve déjà les fondations de ce que deviendront le mouvement sadcore et les lamentations en chambre d’écho de toute une génération de hipsters languissants. Mais avoir été une étape historique ne suffit pas à faire un chef-d’œuvre intemporel. En refermant l’album, je me retrouve exactement à l’endroit où je l’avais commencé : dubitatif. Ni complètement conquis, ni tout à fait déçu, simplement conforté dans mon impression que la réputation de cet enregistrement relève davantage du malentendu critique que du triomphe artistique. Les amateurs transis de Mark Eitzel continueront de crier au génie incompris et de vénérer chaque sanglot enregistré sur bande magnétique ; grand bien leur fasse. Pour ma part, je garde précieusement les deux ou trois pépites éparpillées sur cette rondelle, des titres qui méritent sans doute de figurer sur une anthologie sélective du genre, et je laisse le reste dériver au large, dans cette mer sans vagues et sans frissons. Trois étoiles sur cinq, c’est la note de la stricte équité, celle qui salue le savoir-faire mélodique indéniable de quelques morceaux choisis, tout en refusant d’applaudir une traversée en eaux si calmes qu’elle frise l’encéphalogramme plat.
I don't know why but I expected much worse, pleasantly surprised, although it didn't blow my mind or anything.
サブスクには無いです。
Had to listen on YouTube since it wasn't on Spotify at the time the album came up in the queue. Some catchy pop/rock songs that have a distinct late 80s sound. Really liked the songs "Somewhere" and "Lonely" among others. Think it'd be a fun album to come back to.
Nothing really grabbed me here, it wasn't bad though.