Penance Soiree by The Icarus Line

Penance Soiree

The Icarus Line

2.5
Rating
22884
Votes
1
17%
2
34%
3
33%
4
13%
5
3%
Distribution

Album Summary

Penance Soiree is the second full-length album released by Los Angeles band The Icarus Line. It was one of 2004's most critically acclaimed releases, and its reputation has subsequently earned praise in various publications, including the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die.Due to infighting with the band's U.S. division of their record label at the time, V2 Records, the album, which was recorded in early 2003, was not released until May 2, 2004. Disagreements and aggravations on the band's end stemmed from the label's general lack of interest and support, a nearly non-existent promotional campaign for the album, and the group's control over its artwork. The U.S. division of the record label did not invest in even one advertisement for the release, and also made the band pay for the production of their music videos out of their own pocket. The album was produced by Michael Musmanno, and then mixed by Alan Moulder. Moulder also contributed some last minute recording and engineering to the album, while mixing it in London with Aaron North and Joe Cardamone at Eden Studios in west London. The song "On the Lash" was also re-mixed for the album's inclusion by Ken Andrews, due to the band being unhappy with the original mix after returning home. The album was mastered by Howie Weinberg in New York City. This was the last album by The Icarus Line that featured guitarist Aaron North.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

I looked at the year, looked at the album cover and knew exactly what this would sound like.

4/10 Just not very interesting? I assume that there was some kind of familial relation that resulted in them being included?? Although 1,475 Spotify listeners can't be wrong. It's a bit too much at the heavy end of Indie guitar for me, but I quite liked the last track. I just don't see anything special.

I think this albums worst crime is being mixed poorly. The highs were so piercing. Otherwise this is a pretty straightforward alt rock album from the mid 2000s.

Didn't quite gel

This is just a sonic mess.

It was a good listen. Not sure I would go back to it though

Hell yeah

This was one of the most acclaimed albums of 2004, what else was out then to make this seem good in comparison? Garage rock can be hit or miss but this didn’t touch the sides of my head, just one big blur.

No me gustó. Un rock medio grunge/sucio. Con sucio me refiero al sonido medio constante de interferencia.

Fun garage rock party that doesn’t feel quite as unique as it probably did in 2004.

This is fucking insane; I can't believe the reception for this is so negative. Sure, it veers a little close to Jon Spencer at times and the mix is brickwalled to hell and back, but this is ferocious noise rock. Quite an enjoyable record, a pleasant hidden gem.

Overall Rating - 2.38/5 (4.77/10). Vaguely unpleasant, early 00s indecipherable rock.

Typical mid 2000’s rock, nothing notable here.

This is okay!

++: Up Against the Wall Motherfuckers, On the Lash, Kiss Like Lizards, Getting Bright at Night, Big Sleep, White Devil +: Caviar, Spike Island, Virgin Velcro, Sea Sick, Party the Baby Off +-: Spit on It, Meatmaker 7,3/10

You, yes you who listened to this full album; congrats on being ~1% of this bands entire MONTHLY listening on Spotify It’s high energy, and at the very least there’s a couple of songs that are just ok. The way Getting Bright At Night plays out and builds is kinda cool I think I’m realizing noise rock is just not a good genre at all; the vocals range from mediocre to downright awful; that retching, out of time style genuinely hurts to listen to. This is clearly not a very well produced album, with sound mixing being very poor and that does not help in any way. Variety is bad, there are some really stupid lyrics, and it just feels like the band is squandering what little talent they have This is genuinely the most baffling inclusion in the list so far; why did they actually think this was a must listen? And even more baffling, somehow this was in the original 2005 list and fellow 2004 album American Idiot didnt make it on at all. Just a complete miss in every way, and I’m just confused more than anything else. The band should thank Dimery for putting this one on there since I genuinely think that’s the only thing paying the bills

It's just noise. Ambient noise to go in the background. Basically just worse white noise. 2 stars because it's not actively painful, it's just nothing.

It’s fine, but in what world is this album essential? Despite having a sound that *should* be something I enjoy, The Icarus Line manages to avoid anything of substance.

The loud, prominent bass on the first track hints at a noise rock album with abrasive and left-field choices. After that though the albums veers in a much more classic rock direction, turning into a garage rock album more suited for partying than headbanging. This reaches its peak on "White Devil," which is basically a straight-up blues rock song, and the party-ready final track. There are some moments where the loudness really hits, like the extended "Getting Bright at Night." But too often this sounds right out of the 2000s rock scene yet without any of the hooks or interesting choices that made the best bands from the scene shine.

Never heard of this group. Kind of nonsense noisy music. Might have been something I would have liked when I was 16 but I am way beyond this now. It's not something I would seek out or listen to again.

This should have but it didn’t work for me. Probably just the day. It sounds very similar to someone else and that was distracting me the whole time. There good here don’t get me wrong but it didn’t hit for me like I hoped it would.

Great sound and interesting songwriting. Enjoyed most of this from start to finish.

Enjoyed the later half of the album.

This isn't horrible, but it isn't great either.

5 Takte, bin raus! So ein Mist!

This has just been done so much better by SO many other artists before and after.

Started out somewhat promising with a nice tinge of noise, but ultimately didn't do much with it, and started sounded fairly generic. 2.5

Firm balls

It was ok, I was a little bored, the instruments were good I like the start of up against the wall motherfucker

This was a great album, just after a while I got tired of listening to it.

Devon 5 incoming Yeah that was fucking awesome

This just hurts to listen to. The singer's voice is pretty good though.

So I actually thought some of this was okay. Gave me White Stripes vibes at times. Lead singer sounds like Bono a little. Definitely some talent here. But this is the first time I was legit confused about an album on this list, and I’ve given some albums 1 star. This felt like the potential start of a breakthrough for this band who then fizzled out and there’s not much out there on them. So this truly feels like an unnecessary album on this list. Again, the album itself was okay. But it just truly didn’t feel like it should be on the same list with…everything else

Was a solid 2/3 at first but I'm knocking it down for how long and repetitive the whole thing was it really annoyed me. Further knock down for being completely irrelevant how do we have this and no Deftones

Nie zlé, ale chýba tomu niečo, čo by ich robilo výnimočnými. Počúval som to niekoľkokrát, ale to asi stačilo.

What the hell is this even supposed to be?

This surprised me. It was a more raucous than I expected. It started really well then dwindled a little into more bland indie rock territory, which was a shame. Not sure it really belongs on the list, but I’ve had worse albums on here.

Can't quite recall. Ordinary punk rock? 2-3 rats?

Surprisingly good. Why haven't I heard of these guys before?

had this on at work... literally just sounded like noise

It was fine.

Never heard of these guys, which is an absolute shame! This is exactly the sort of thing I was listening to in the early aughts. Blistering guitars and unrelenting energy, a great mix of alternative, noise rock, punk and hard rock. An instant save for me!

Cliché obnoxiously loud music. Dreadful to sit through this noise for an hour.

2000s rock can't ever go wrong

Not unbearable

Didn’t know anything coming into this. And it seems to be where a standard heavyish indie rock album was at it seems by 2004. That continuation from garage bands in the late 60s and 70s, through 80s US rock that got swamped with the noise factor from US indie noise rock into the 90s. Little bits of melody with mild dissonance mixed. All while being the required Quiet shouty. Someone one once said to me every generation has their shouty boys with guitars, very much that youth energy thing. These weren’t mine so where I have nostalgia for say mudhoney these are just yeah so what. It’s ok at what it is but I personally see no relevance into the 21 century for this what so ever, but I wasn’t 17 when I heard this. 2 Star

I can think of a great many bands contemporary to The Icarus Line that deserve this spot more. The Kills, At The Drive-In, ...And You Will Know Us by the Trail of Dead, The Blood Brothers, The Jesus Lizard, and Death From Above 1979 all made albums around that time and style that could be considered more essential than this one. This just reminds me that Jet was a pretty big deal around then. You wouldn't put Jet on this list, would you?

This album cover is kinda creeping me out. Idk why. Ive never heard somethint this abbrasive being this boring since saint anger. Ok, its not has bad has saint anger. Honestly, I dindt hate any songs here, and because some had some redeamable quality (1 good riff), im giving this a positive score. Congrats The Icarus Line.

This is basically just noise.

Didn't enjoy their Peel Sessions back in the day. Not liking them now. 1.462 monthly listeners on Spotify. 22.484 votes here 1000 bands do *this* but Good™ Give McLusky/Future of the Left a spin!

Lamentablemente no está ni en Youtube music ni en Spotify.....

Perfectly ok alt-rock, almost noise rock album. Better than the rating, and one of the better 21st century albums in the list. Not bad.

Pleasant surprise, not English and not edm.

Listened before?: nope. i haven't seen a whole lot of praise for this album so i'm bracing myself for a potentially bad listening experience Up Against the Wall, Motherfuckers - 3/5 Spit on It - 1/5 On the Lash - 3/5 Caviar - 1/5 Spike Island - 3/5 Kiss Like Lizards - 2/5 Getting Bright at Night - 2/5 Big Sleep - 2/5 White Devil - 2/5 Meatmaker - 1/5 Virgin Velcro - 1/5 Seasick - 1/5 Party the Baby Off - 2/5 Average score: 1.8/5 ⭐️⭐️ this is just so fucking noisy in my opinion. i hate to say it since it feels like a lazy critique to make about an album, but i don't really know how else to describe this sound. i don't know if it's the mixing or what, i just didn't like this very much. the tracks weren't all that interesting to me either. it's just not very enjoyable considering the fact that my ears weren't in terrible pain listening to this, i suppose i'll spare this album of receiving 1 star (i'd give it between 1.5 and 2 stars elsewhere)

fine album. it’s not on spotify anymore and nothing to write home about. You can hear the influence of the stooges and the ramones and i’d rather listen to them.

Never heard of this, though it seems to take a lot of shit in the reviews. It doesn't actually deserve most of the flak it gets, as it's just a fun, loud 2000s rock album. It's not afraid to experiment with noise or get in your face, but for the most part it's pretty simple garage rock. It's not nearly as extreme as some reviews would leave you to believe, but it's not always a clean, neat rock album. It's not the best thing I've ever heard, but it's not as bad as many people seem to think it is.

Not bad pretty fun

This was an OK album, but I don't think it belongs on the list. It had zero influence and barely garners any listens these days.

like the white stripes decided to make a boring noise rock album

Loud and in your face but that’s about it

US noise merchants eh? Didn’t mind On the Lash / Caviar / Seasick. Preferred Pulp’s Spike Island. It’s mostly not terrible and more than ok in places ( the ones where they sound like JAMC) Not enough for a 4.

Penance Soiree by The Icarus Line...never heard of them, could the title be more pretentious? The music feels like it could turn into something good at points but is mostly ruined by screeching 'rock' vocals or guitar wanking. I'm sure the various members are now happily working for Amazon or serving in a coffee shop......and rightly so

The 9-minuter, particularly the transition into it, won me over a bit and I was somewhat into it from there on.

I don’t quite know what a wheel house is, but this genre of US noise rock is a long way from being in mine. Spike Island the best of a bad bunch but not a patch patch on Pulp’s song.

Not for me. Honestly, it's surprising this album is on this list -- it sounds like every dive bar college band I ever heard

Irreedeemable dreck from a bunch of no-names that you will never hear from again.

Неочікувано сильно сподобався альбом. Прямолійнійний гаражний рок, який мені здається могла б грати гурт з будь-якої країни і збирати на концерт 200 людей. Але щось для мене є в цих піснях. Подобається, як бас вивели наперед, непогані гітарні партії, вокал такий мені подобається. Залетів альбом.

Дуже нудний гітарний альбом, який мені нагадав місцями гіршу версію Джека Вайта і навіть простігосподі гурт ДЖЕТ. Нецікаві гітарні партії, вокаліст який старається, але виходить все якось дуже посередньо. Здивувало в тегах десь побачити пост-хардкор і нойз, бо я тут почув просто радіоформатний рок. Є певні цікаві моменти, але їх ДУЖЕ мало.

No need to yell it a little samey and screamy ya know i like the vibe but I didnt hear anything special

This is just average early 2000s rock. 2.5

Glad I tracked this one down. Really enjoyed this album. All tracks were solid and enjoyable.

Неожиданно классный альбом 8/10

Mudhoney light. Not that there is anything wrong with it just didn’t hit as hard

Not anywhere near my favorite, but it's not that bad. The music sounds reminiscent of a lot of the British punk/rock bands I've been getting from the list, and the vocals sound distinctly American. This album isn't my preferred sound of grunge rock, so it's not high on the replay list, but it was decent. If I could give half stars, this would land at 2 1/2. But since I can't, I'll round up.

Very noisy. It was enjoyable enough without truly sticking

Shouty fun when you listen to it. Forgettable after

Sounds like one of those bands you saw as a support act once then instantly forgot about.

3.5 love the energy here

Boring and made my ears bleed at the same time. Quite a feat

blends into the white stripes side of indie

expectations too high because of the sick ass album cover

It’s not all bad but it’s nothing special to me.

Great record, though not a genre I’m super familiar with. Especially enjoyed the noisy experimentation, and great riffs. Fav track probably “Sea Sick” 8/10

Too much going on. It feels like everything is competing tp be heard. This could have been ok with a few better mixing choices.

didn't care for it, kinda screechy

Good but I stopped after the third track

Never listened. Expectations: None - Verdict: Good - The opening couple of tracks are decent and give me a bit of an idea of the sort of album this is. On The Lash is very rocking and I like it a lot. Caviar has a cool sound although I'm not blown away by the vocals. Spike Island doesn't do much for me. Kiss Like Lizards has a very cool and creative main riff and I enjoy the more expansive approach on Getting Bright At Night. Big Sleep is ok but the next few tracks can't reach the level of the earlier ones. Sea Sick is a late highlight but overall this album was enjoyable but not amazing.

awesome album cover but otherwise mid

Favourite Songs: Spike Island Getting Bright At Night

I know I'm probably going to be in the minority but I really liked this. It's right in my wheelhouse. Probably not as "good" but give me a Mid 00's garage-y rock album and I'll eat it up every time. 9/10, expect this to be one where for once I'm a lot higher than the average rating.

some good sounds from a band I knew not of. For heavy rockers only

Day1002 - this band had no chance. stupid band name and nothing original about their songs

Not at all pleasant to me.

Nope I didn’t like this. A bit too obnoxious and heavy for my liking. Next.

Some interesting stuff but on the more generic and boring side of garage/noise/post-hardcore

production was good but the songs weren't there. low 2 or a high 1