Incredible album. Makes you dance, makes you feel, makes you cry. This could be a list of the top 25 albums of all time and you could still make a strong case for Rumours.

War pigs is such a banger start to an album. The rest keeps up the energy

21st century schizoid man is holding this album up by itself. Influence cannot be d denied, though it gets a bit slow in the middle.

A couple are pretty corny, but honestly holds up better than I expected.

Very nice 👍

Life’s a bitch and then you die. Probably have been underrating this one. Not at the very top of my personal rap list but still really good and understandably a classic.

Makes me feel like I’m on an elevator in a good way. Easy listening, love me some Stan Getz.

Admittedly I’ve never really been an R.E.M. fan but I don’t really find much to latch onto. It’s not bad but I’m unlikely to be listening again anytime soon.

I wrote a long review but it didn’t save. Love this album, lyrically tight although goofy. The storytelling really shines through and the group bounces well off each other. Production is fun, can definitely hear how/why it influenced future artists. Sounds a little dated beats wise but they more than hold up and provide a good backing for the rap. West coast = best coast

Possibly my favorite Zeppelin album, it simply rocks.

Who doesn’t love a good organ? Good sunday morning album, but fades into the background a bit for me. Would give a 7/10 if if was an option.

Did not enjoy this. A couple songs were okay I guess but more than a couple were just straight bad. Production was… creative, but often not enjoyable. I really don’t that this was an album that I needed to hear before I die.

I have a sudden urge to head south

Too artsy fartsy for me. There were some interested elements mixed in but overall I was kind of bored. I probably just don’t get it.

Has lost a little bit of its luster over the years for me but still a top tier album. -1 because I don’t trust Mormons

Everybody wants to rule the world is an all-timer. The rest of the album doesn’t really do it for me

A 78 minute Christina Aguilera album? Really Robert? Undeniably great voice, but her singing style doesn’t really do it for me. Trying a little too hard imo. Production is good, content is not very interesting. Pretty forgettable overall.

Spent longer than I’d care to admit last night unsuccessfully trying to moonwalk

Had some highs and some lows. Pretty weird listen overall. Probably would have liked it better if it was an hour shorter.

Good fall album. Don’t think I’ve ever sat down and listened to it all the way through and I enjoyed it more than I expected.

Had a very good time listening to this one. Forgot how much I love some Elton. Funeral for a Friend is awesome and really enjoyed some of the deeper cuts like Roy Rogers. Of course the hits rock. Really close to a 5 for me but just a few too many that I wanted to skip, and Jamaica Jerk Off is weird af

I liked the more psychedelic stuff but overall it was a bit boring

Supreme storytelling. Simple but effective instrumentation. John Prine is simply that dude. I bet Wes Anderson loves this album.

Weird, self-indulgent, murder porn. This guy sounds like Lin-Manuel Miranda’s cringier older brother. Way too theater-y for me. I get the impression the lead singer was jerking himself off the entire time he was writing this.

Like most of the new wave bands (in my opinion), Violator’s high are through the roof, but it also has some pretty forgettable lows. Dan Gahan also doesn’t have my favorite singing voice if I’m being honest. It’s an enjoyable enough listen through and through, but not an album that I’m likely to listen to end-to-end again.

Damn near perfect

We’re getting spoiled this week.

Pros: really fun, Paul Weller reminds me of Morrissey, not a bad song on the album Cons: sent me down a ska rabbit hole

Dennis needed to pick a lane. It was enjoyable enough, but a pretty disjointed listening experience.

Tough one for me to rate. Objectively, this might deserve a 5, but I guess the point of the exercise is to give our opinions. While the vocal harmonizing is nice on some songs but overdone on the album in my opinion. Kind of makes the whole thing sound dated to me. I wish they had given more songs to individual singers. Otherwise, it’s a very enjoyable listen and the talent of these guys really shines through.

A great artist and a great piece of history. The track list is pretty strong, but honestly I just don’t really like live albums.

James Bond nightfire soundtrack meets house meets hip hop? Very 90s. Not my style. Fuck Donald Trump

Dancing queen is lightning in a bottle. The rest of the album pales in comparison

Fun early hip hop album. Definitely can hear the influence it had on east coast rap. I like the writing style of this era, with a focus on goofy stories/situations instead of the swag rap we hear so much of today. Good punchy beats that remind me of ssx tricky, which is always a plus. Feeling a 7/10 but gonna round down on account of Afrika being a diddler.

Classic album. It’s crazy how much talent came out of Wu Tang.

Wasn’t expecting such revolutionary messaging in the first several songs, but my god what a snooze fest.

Kiwanuka’s got a great voice. A little slow in parts but very beautiful.

This was bad. Like really bad. What was the formula here? Madonna does madlibs over generic Dance Dance Revolution-type beats? Lyrically, this is one of the worst albums I’ve ever heard. The production ranged from bland to jumbled, at some points sounding like they were just randomly hitting a keyboard to see what stuck. I am left with more questions than answers: why was this included on the list? How did Madonna get so big making music like this? What was going on in the 80s? I’d rather grab a beer with Stagger Lee than listen to this pile of garbage again.

Really enjoyed the first half of the album, in particular the title track. The Van Morrison cover was also a very nice inclusion. The second half didn’t hold my attention as well. 3.5/5

Not bad, not great.

Production was definitely the highlight for me. Punchy beats throughout that were easy to bop my head to. Lyrically, I thought it was kind of corny. Flows were strong and they worked off each other well, but it was just missing something to make it interesting. I also can’t get over how wacky the deep voice dude sounds. Had a few songs that I’ll return to, but mostly just felt like a dollar store De La Soul.

This one had some interesting tracks. Was pretty hit or miss for me, admittedly 90s electronic isn’t exactly my cup of tea.

Some good clean 80s fun

Good enough. Not that interesting to me though

Enjoyed this quite a bit. Got some real Bowie going on

Gary admitting to eating eggs at the end of Ham n’ Eggs is one of the greatest twists in modern music. Really good album, I mean it has Can I Kick It. Probably a couple songs I could do without, and I do think they have a couple better albums, so I’m gonna go with a 9/10

I mean, I like Bowie as much as the next guy. But it’s a bit much, innit?

A psychedelic standard. Has some good jams, a few great even. A lot of it is pretty forgettable to me though.

Incredible album. Makes you dance, makes you feel, makes you cry. This could be a list of the top 25 albums of all time and you could still make a strong case for Rumours.

Good tweener for the Beatles. Still fairly poppy with plenty of replay value, but they were also starting to experiment with new and more interesting sounds. Enjoyable listen, although in my opinion their best was yet to come.

The cream rises to the top. Oh yeah

Enjoyed more than I expected. Good rock album with some jazz elements that I wasn’t really expecting. Got a little theatrical at times which I didn’t love, but overall I liked the album a lot.

XTC should stick to making plans for Nigel

Provocative

Stevie is a talented dude. I probably should have listened more before reviewing, but it’s not his most memorable week after one listen.

Raw, for better or worse. Some of my favorite white stripes tracks come from this album; see: Blue Orchid, The Denial Twist, Take Take Take. The pure creativity and ability of Jack White really shines through. On the other hand, some of the other tracks probably could have used a bit more time in the oven. But that’s always been White’s style, and that’s why we love him.

I liked the Van Morrison cover, but I’m not really a fan of Patti’s singing style.

Gorgeous album and perfect time of year for it. This is one that I used to listen to a lot so there’s some nostalgia around it, but it more than holds up. Might only be a 4 in the summertime, so good job 1001albumsgenerator.com on the timing.

I wish that I had not spent 49 minutes listening to this.

Based on t-shirt sales, the #1 band since 1998. More than enough has been said about the music, but why aren’t more people talking about the wiener?

Perfect 2.5 for me. Not unpleasant but also not very memorable. Unlikely to listen again but wouldn’t complain if someone else put it on

Much has been said about The Dandy Warhols (by me), but I honestly enjoyed this album more than I expected. Moody and psychedelic at times, upbeat and jammy at others, they displayed more range than I would have given them credit for. Whipping Tree was downright Floyd-esque! That said, it wasn’t particularly innovative. I’m feeling a 3.5/5 but going to round down because it was too long imo

Good music for us fellas that bleed the red, white, and blue

🎶 cool in the pool 🎶

Brutally honest and hauntingly beautiful portrayal of a legends final days. Really remarkable work of art. While not every cover was my favorite, it is very interesting to consider why Cash selected each of them. Hurt is such a deeply moving song, the kind that I will always slow down to listen to closely. The deepest theme is clearly death here, but not necessarily despair. I think the album ultimately portrays a man who knows that he is not long for the world, and while he may have some regrets, is at peace with his fate. Given the context and just how beautiful much of the album is, this is a pretty easy 5 for me.

Imagine (song) is deservedly an all-timer. The rest of the album was fine but not that interesting to me.

Did not bring me joy

Classic versions of classic songs. Not gonna punish it for my being late to review. Could’ve done without silent night at the end.

Dollar store Lou Reed. Inoffensive, but ultimately uninspiring.

One of the best hip hop albums to ever grace my ears. But is it Kendrick’s best? I’m not so sure.

Good stuff

3.5 Happy to see a non-English album on here. Really enjoyed the music, love some African guitar. Rounding up because I like the variety.

Kinda chill. Kinda sleepy. I liked small hours.

Classic rock album. Good music for fixing cars.

Another classic rock album. Made me want to play guitar hero.

Never was the biggest black keys guy but this is a solid offering from then with some strong tracks

Robert Smith on lithium. I almost really like it but there’s just something off that I can’t quite place my finger on

I’m glad smellphones don’t exist yet because this album stinks!

Very black keys-esque. Thought it was a bit more interesting though so I’d bump it to a 3.5. Enjoyed well enough but don’t really understand why it’s on the list.

Mods rise up

The highs are about as good as it gets. The lows are not bad by any means, but there are a couple songs that I could live without. I’ve been really waffling between a 4 and 5. Might be harsh, but just doesn’t quite get there for me. 9/10

One of the albums of all time

Pretty good! Wishing this list was less Brit-centric tho

Lovely. Made me feel good inside.

The early Beatles stuff just doesn’t really do it for me. Definitely some classics on here tho

How can you tell Green Day from other popular artists? Other artists play in major or minor key, but Green Day plays in Dookie.

Really good Bowie album.

The message (song) is a classic. The rest was kind of whatever to me

Did not have a Cheap Trick live album on my bingo card. Would’ve been a fun show to be at! 7/10

Some truly remarkable guitar, but overall not my cup of tea

I know I’m in the minority on this one but man I’m not a fan of this band. The instrumentation is fine, even great at times, but I just can’t stand Anthony Kiedis

Really enjoyed. Those aussies never miss! More of this please 1001albumsgenerator.com

Undeniably god music. Talented group even if they’re not my go-to

Love can. Really enjoyed 1/2 of this album. But like most can albums, there was a couple songs that I could barely get through. Usually I can look past this, but 30 minutes of haunted house sounds is capping this one at a 3 for me.

2 U2 albums in a week is too much. I liked the first one better

Neil Young seems like a real douchebag. Nice album tho.

Enjoyable but not something unlikely to return to

Ahead of its time. Jammy, psychedelic, shadowy. I’m sure this was a trip to hear when it first came out. 2 great minds come together and while the album may not have the most replay value, I really enjoyed listening to it.

Secret pixies album! Really loved it all the way through and never knew it existed until today. This is why we slog through the 2s and 3s folks

In a past life I probably would have regarded this more highly

Short and sweet. Dusty has a great voice

Thought we might be in for a treat after the first song but was pretty let down for the remainder. Sort of flaming lips-esque but lacking character. Idk not for me

She’s got a great voice and I do really love some Billie from time to time but it just didn’t do it for me yesterday

Never really understood why xrt seems to prefer this version of Mrs. Robinson

Sam Cooke is incredible. I do not think this was a necessary recording to hear of his.

The Doors are great man. Riders on the storm is an all time favorite. Really no skips in this album, maybe 1 or 2 that are just fine but very solid from top to bottom. 9/10

A couple of the songs were decent but overall not really my style

Nothing says badass like writing an album about all the crimes you intend to commit

It’s alright

Pretty fun. Probably not something I’ll put on super regularly but I’m glad I gave it a listen 7.5/10

Writing music with your brother so you can explore the hard questions in life. Like, “how does it feel when you’re inside of me?”

Pretty fun, nothing super special

Honestly The Beach Boys aren’t my favorite. It’s sunny and fun, definitely good music, just not my exact cup of tea.

If you don’t like this, you can go funk yourself

Next time I’m whipping up biscuits, I know who I want on the butter knife. Incredible album, definitely one of my favorites we’ve had so far. So groovy and cool, Walk On By is a masterclass. Maybe could have cut down on the spoken word portion of By The Time I Get To Phoenix, but honestly I don’t mind it. Easy easy 5

One of the GOATs for a reason. Really good album, some great tracks, could’ve done without the sex recording though

War pigs is such a banger start to an album. The rest keeps up the energy

Never been the biggest Clapton fan but the talent is undeniable. This isn’t his most engaging album imo, doesn’t help that he’s a huge jerk. But not bad.

Love the pixies, haven’t listened to this one as much but it rocks

Of the great rock groups, I’ve always found the who to be a bit underwhelming. This album helped dispel that notion in some ways but backed it in others. The music was good, especially toward the end of the show, though it started slow imo (I also agree with Peter that the recording quality was kind of bad at the beginning). I did find the crowd interaction to be a bit uninspiring. I’m not sure if this is a recording issue (definitely at some points) or if they just didn’t have it that night. Overall, a solid listen but still not one that is making me rush back for more who. 7/10

Loved it. Stay is incredible.

Definitely an album everyone should listen to before they die. Fun. Provocative. And… dated. I’m sure this blew a lot of minds when it came out, its importance to the genre really can’t be overstated. But it’s a little earlier than the hip hop that I usually go for. Maybe that’s just because I don’t own a boombox. 6.5 for enjoyability + 2 for significance.

It’s pretty insane that this came out in 1966. Definitely way ahead of its time, and easy to hear how this could have been massively influential. Sort of a Marty McFly in Back to the Future moment. That said, it was be a case of “just because we can, should we?” Honestly it’s pretty hard to listen to at points, so it’s one I’m okay with leaving in the past.

What’s with all the negative reviews? I liked this a lot, Mark Smith has a unique singing style that I really dig. The 80s/90s punk scene was very fun and this slots right in. I can definitely see a lot of my favorite 2000s artists having been influenced by The Fall.

She sure is a smooth operator. I hope we get love deluxe too. 9/10

It’s a landmark album for a reason. Dr. Dre is an undeniable production beast. I have a hard time not thinking that snoop is a bit corny though.

More like Smelliott Ith

Tough one to rate. On the one hand, I really do enjoy the music, especially the first half. On the other, the “storybook” portion of the album felt very half-baked. Conceptually, I like the storybook concept a lot. However, I was pretty confused when the story portion started as it seemingly came out of nowhere. However, having looked into the original track listing, I see that it was side B of the record, so I guess it’s more of a modern issue of streaming. That said, I still think that to properly accomplish what they were going for, the Happiness Stan story should have been it’s own (probably more fleshed out) project. To that point, the story itself doesn’t really make any sense. There isn’t much impetus, the action doesn’t ever really rise, and the resolution is hardly satisfying. This is all compounded by the fact that the narrator is hardly intelligible, even when reading the lyrics. I realize this isn’t an English assignment, but it would be nice to be given a reason to care about the story. The music throughout is definitely the star of the show. I thoroughly enjoyed the first half and we were well on our way to 4land, or day I say even 5ville, before the break. Some fun early psych rock mixed with that classic 60s British sound almost in the vein of Sgt Pepper himself. The music on its own I think would have made for a great album although I guess some of it wouldn’t have made much sense without the narration. Overall, I think I would give this a 2.5. Strangely enough, if the two sides had been split, I might just rate both of them more highly than the sum. For sure the first half. I just don’t think it comes across as a cohesive album. This is definitely the most I’ve thought about one of these albums in awhile so I suppose it does belong on the list.

I must be a paleontologist the way I love T. Rex

What an insanely good album

I like the band, but this was kind of a snooze fest. Not unpleasant but Waltz for Debby is far superior imo

This is what- Radiohead’s fifth or sixth best album? Insanely consistent discography. There are some real highs on this one, “Pyramid Song,” “You and Whose Army,” and “Knives Out” are real standouts to me. I also think that there are some (relative) low points on this album and it doesn’t play as well all the way through as some of their more acclaimed releases. The fact that this is still flirting with a 5 speaks to the talent of the group, and maybe on a different day I would rate it as such. 9/10

We all know that I Believe in a Thing Called Love is living in rare air. But I have t confess that I wasn’t expecting to like this album as much as I did. Some really enjoyable glam rock that sounds like it fell right out of the 80s. I’ve always thought of these guys as one hit wonders, and I’m glad to discover they’ve got plenty more in the tank.

Liked the first few quite a bit, the more folky stuff I could take or leave. In that sense it was very much like a CSNY album to me. Would listen to again. 7/10

Really good album and band. I’ve been listening to the flaming lips a lot lately, trying to decide what my favorite album of theirs is. This is a strong contender, with in my opinion some of their best songs. Yoshimi pts 1+2 and do you realize are really standout tracks. It’s an album I’ll never get tired of, although I do think it is maybe just slightly overhyped, at least to the extent that it seems to overshadow the rest of their discography. Not a pure 5, but probably like a 9.5/10

Very fun album and project, although it never was completed. I’m definitely biased toward this one as a Chicagoan, but it really is a beautiful and whimsical listen that I always enjoy. With moments of grave, sadness, innocence, and even humor, this album really has it all. I do agree with Kyle that the second half probably could have been pruned down some, but at no point I find myself not enjoying the music. Definitely an album everyone ought to listen to before they die.

Pretty much review 100% with Kyle. It’s not bad, but there are other bands doing the same thing better

Only 868 albums to go until Robert Dimery grants me permission to die

Pretty fun punk album

Really great album. My favorite of Al Green’s. Anyone wanna see him at Ravinia this summer?

Art Garfunkel might just be the Yoko Ono to Paul Simon’s John Lennon. It’s not bad but doesn’t do that much for me, although Mrs. Robinson was one of my favorite songs when I was a wee lad

Pleasantly surprised by this one. A little Jerry Garcia, a little Neil Young, a lot of fun. Love the choir backing. Probably one of my favorites of albums I hadn’t heard before so far.

90s club trash. Sounds like title screen music for gran turismo.

Honestly I liked it more than I thought, but my god was it long. Doesn’t help that a lot of the songs sounded very similar

Whatever you do, don’t google this album and then spend an hour and a half looking at the search results!

Excellent

Pretty fun, not groundbreaking

There’s a couple tracks I liked, but isn’t really the kind of country music I usually go for. 5/10

Another nice surprise. I really like the singers voice, she reminds me of Joanna Wang. Nothing too over the top here but it just sounds nice in my ears.

Interesting case of an album that was groundbreaking and unique at its time of release, but just has not aged well. It sounds old and simple. Electronic music has come a long way since this came out. There are still a couple bangers on here, but even those are pretty nostalgia driven.

It’s annoying that Spotify doesn’t have the bonus tracks differentiated in any way, how hard is it to put -Bonus Track? Anyway, excellent album. Aretha is one is the greats.

I’ve never been the biggest Missy fan. She’s definitely talented, and there were a few tracks on here that were petty good, but I mostly thought it was just okay

Well this one really came out of nowhere. This album was huge back in the day. The hits are iconic and the less well known tracks are still good, some even great. It’s funny to me given the contents of the rest of this list that Robert chose to include this one, but I certainly think it was a valid choice.

It’s Graceland. Nuff said

I get the love, I just have never been able to get past his singing voice.

Doesn’t get much cooler than Iggy Pop

Honestly I don’t fully understand the hype on this one. Not bad I guess but not extraordinary either. I guess it doesn’t help that I don’t much like her voice

Robert man what are we doing here?

I liked it. Kind of slow and one note but I got it on a rainy day so I didn’t mind. I enjoyed the variety of instruments, but kind of found myself losing focus at parts.

Fela is one of the greats. This was a lot of fun, although there are multiple Fela recordings that I prefer to this one. The drum solo just went on a bit too long for me (sorry Kyle). I love some drums, but I don’t think the live experience quite translates over wax. 7.5

Easy going album for a Tuesday morning. An evocative story told over well constructed music. Glad I got to hear this one.