Album Summary
Tidal is the debut studio album by American singer-songwriter Fiona Apple, released on July 23, 1996 by The WORK Group. Tidal produced six singles: "Shadowboxer", "Slow Like Honey", "Sleep to Dream", "The First Taste", "Criminal" and "Never Is a Promise". "Criminal", the album's most popular single, won a Grammy Award for Best Female Rock Vocal Performance in 1998. In 2017, Tidal got its first vinyl run as a Vinyl Me, Please exclusive "Record of the Month".
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Nostalgic for me! She wrote every song on this album, music and lyrics, and at such a young age. Minor key angst and longing. Jazzy riffs. Odd vocal flatness amidst otherwise strong vocal tones, perhaps by design? Great album production too.
This is such a lushly produced album, and it holds together perfectly. The vocals & arrangements are deceptively soothing & lovely in light of the ferocity of her lyrics. She got more adventurous in her later albums, but this might be the best one to just put on and let the songs envelop.
Not my favourite Fiona but still a great album
Meh
This ones really good. Dont even have to go to the doctor today because of the artist. This ones above a 4 tho
begon redelijk maar verzandde in introvert geneuzel
This was big in one of the iterations of sad girl pop. Looking back it's not her best work, but is solid with some flashes of brilliance that foreshadow her later work
#142 It's seriously impressive that she wrote and released this at 19. Her voice is great, and so is the production. A few of the slower songs are forgettable, but overall it's really good. Highlights: The First Taste, Criminal, Shadowboxer, Carrion
I enjoyed this album less than it probably deserved. I think it was done with heart and skill, but I can't deny that my instinct was to reach for the skip button more than once. Shadowboxer is good, but it's better lyrically than musically, and I need to enjoy a track musically first. Slow Like Honey (and some other tracks) is kind of cool, jazz club / noirish, but it feels a bit shallow. Some other reviewers call out her singing style as less enjoyable, and at times it does sound like she has a mouthful of marbles, but honestly I wouldn't have said she's a bad singer. (Relative to others on this list - compared to the average person she is clearly incredible.)
2/5. Fine
Gave it an extra star for only being 15 minutes long.
I didn’t listen to this very much when it came out. I’m not sure why since I loved angsty female like Courtney love and Liz Phair. But this was better than I’d remembered. And there were far too few women artists during the grunge era
Virtuosic.
This album is not for me, I took little enjoyment from listening to it. I found it dull and boring, I didn't like the arrangements, I felt nothing
I had this on repeat in 1996. Something a bit softer than my fave nu metal bands. I still love this album. It’s not my favourite Fiona Apple album, but I spent so much time learning all of the lyrics from the CD booklet. Watching the music videos. Pouring over her interviews (I’ve referenced her Rolling Stone interview in my Wu Tang review). A few tracks that drag. 4/5
Have tried to listen to this album before because I kept hearing great things about it. But it didn’t really connect with me. But I was pleasantly surprised to find it a lot better on this listen. She is a very talented vocalist and the instrumentals throughout the album are great. Although I didn’t identify with the lyrics much, and they keep going over the same themes. But it makes sense considering how young she was when this released. I watched the music video for Criminal and it was quite shocking that was released when she was barely over 18.
Sleep to Dream sounds like the intro to a war movie.
How can anyone not love Apple's voice?
***an ok, easy listening album
Actually pretty good! Could be nostalgia, but I like the sound.
7/10
I liked sleep to dream, criminal, and the first taste. Great voice but the rest of the album drags for me.
Better than expected from what I remember in the 90s.
soft
Love her
Golden apple
For whatever reason, early Fiona Apple has never done it for me, even though I love Idler Wheel and Bolt Cutters. This one's better than When the Pawn, but still not really something that sticks with me.
Très bon album. Certaines chansons où j'ai vraiment accroché mais moins fan des ballades.
Definitely recognize several of the hits from this album and found it to be an enjoyable listen.
High marks for writing interesting, provocative songs, and for some creative musical arrangements blending jazz and pop in original ways. This album merits multiple listens. But her singing grinds on me a bit.
From the album cover I thought this was going to be an album about rainbows, ponies, and fairies with girl power sprinkled in. This is a badass album. I can see myself coming back to this album, the album looped as I had already finished it and I just let it play. 4/5
Love the piano and vocals. Bonus points for being written by a teenager--very impressive. Calming album to listen to, will definitely revisit. 4.5/5 but rounded down
Easily a favorite of mine.
Fiona.... angry women with real, raw feelings were allllll the "rage" in the 90s and she still stands at the top of the back.
Pretty nice album. I'd say the singles and the first half of the album are a little better than the second half, but overall this is quite good.
This is another album where I want to hear more -- the demos, the alternate takes, everything. Love it.
I kind want to call it a generic pop album, but listening to those vocals was quite relaxing.
Pretty surprisingly good. Congrats Fiona apple
I wasn’t expecting to like this very much, but it’s good! I can see why people love her stuff so much.
Parece que este disco ha envejecido demasiado bien.
Ой, опять вот эта хуйня в стиле какой-нибудь Tori Amos, Rid of Me от PJ Harvey и прочего подобного кала, где девка с вот этой уебской манерой strong independent woman исполняет какие-то поп-песни с претензией на глубину, типа ЭкСпЭрЭмеНтАлЬнОсТьЮ и типа музыкальной ГлУбИнОй и вот этой вот всей "исповедальной" и типа такой эмоциональной подачей, та хуйня какая-то, сори. Дайте мне Патти Смит, дайте мне Эллу Фицджеральд, дайте Билли Холидэй, Шиину Ринго, Мадонну, Джулиану Хэтфилд, дайте ещё один альбомчик Бьорк или Sade, этих женщин я послушаю с привеликими удовольствием, а от этих воннаби-глубоких поп-певичек из девяностых, которых тогда расплодилось как в грибнице после дождя - меня уже тошнит. Жена Шрека Фиона - круто. Фиона Эппл - нет.
Funny timing on this, I just listened to When the Pawn... for the first time a few days ago, and now the generator gives us this one! Once again, another slam dunk of an album from Fiona, proving she had the sauce right from the start. Definitely not as out-there and experimental as Fetch the Bolt Cutters, but also between her vulnerable and surprisingly complex singing style and the jazzy arrangements, it's clearly not a million miles distant either. Really just a hell of a songwriter.
Much more listenable than Fetch the Boltcutters at least!
This album is like a sign of great things to come but I don't think it's great by itself. Her voice is gorgeous, the production is beautiful, but i can't countenance When the Pawn not being on here instead.
A fantastic mix of Sheryl Crow and Lorde. Really awesome vocal performance, production, sound ambience. I mean, just hit the ball out of the park on this one.
Gorgeous album. Her voice is incredible and the arrangements are immensely creative and artful. Will definitely come back to this one.
načelno mi se dopalo. solidno, lijepo. divan vokal. al nije me oborilo s nogu. malo ko previše generični pop na trenutke, al ne skroz dakako. možda mi je bio trunku bolji prethodno odslušan a dosta kasnije objavljen »fetch the bolt cutters«, upravo zato što je siroviji, eksperimentalniji i alternativniji. ali ni ovo nipošto nije loše [odslušao i napisao 4/11/26]
Repeat listen
This was a good album. Enjoyable, and Fiona has a unique, haunting vocal quality. Songs were fairly strong.
This has been the best week I’ve had since I started this damn project.
Dont know a thing about this album, besides her age and that it is her debut album, and it is pretty encouraging debut i reckon . Her voice is strong and expressive and lyrically shes more interesting than the clones of tori amos. I don't knownhow to put it, but theres a healthy sense of self awareness about herself, as a woman in her songs, she doesnt take the shortcuts out in expressing complex emotions. The only problem is that the record is a bit one dimensional, it falls back onto moody, jazzy piano balladry that becomes less interesting as the 2nd half proceeds. Vocal runs are cool only when they're unnecessarily necessary, not when they're every other melodic string. I’ll admit that the moments that grab me most though are the slight glimpses of freak out jazz pop. But when she really connects there's a vulnerability and raw sexuality amongst the self analysis. Jon brion's musical chops certainly seem to have been a big help .
This is a very impressive debut album, although I think it misses the mark on a few tracks. It's a little too long, and it really started to all sound the same about halfway through. A decent album, but not one I am likely to return to. It just needs a bit more polish. Favorite track: "Shadowboxer"
A bit boring and nondescript.
I wish I would have listened to more of her sooner, this album is insanely good!
Oh dear-there are so many better S/S during this time. Rather bland I’m afraid.
New to me. Thank you 1001. Great accompaniment to a long run.
Crikey. First time listening to a Fiona Apple album and what an exceptional debut. Sophisticated jazz-tinged arrangements and an unbelievable voice. Very hard to get 4* on a first spin but I think she might just have done it. 4*
Another day, another very good debut album. Also, like Aimee Mann's debut, this one features great contributions from guitarist/multi-instrumentalist Jon Brion. Apple's talents are off the charts and this features some of her best songs: "Sleep to Dream," "Shadowboxer," "Never is a Promise," and, especially, "Criminal." Some of the torchy-er songs get a little redundant and her whole tortured artist thing keeps this from 5 stars. I would put either of her next two albums on the list instead of this one.
Hard to think of another artist who debuted so fully formed. Bob Dylan maybe, but even his first album was mostly covers. Apple is a fantastic pianist with lots of jazz flourishes and the production and arrangements here are gorgeous. Crazy lyrical depth too for a 19 year old
Marvelous album. "Sleep to Dream" and "Shadowboxer" were my favorites.
YEAHHH
Liked it; quite buckleyish
sehr schöne stimme gänsehaut
51 minutes of my life I'll never get back
peak
A very solid singer/songwriter album.
Beautiful album. Sullen Girl is so good. Shadowboxer has always been one of my favorites by her. The 45 RPM vinyl I listened to it on was wonderful, which probably helped my rating.
i absolutely loved this album. not sure if i've ever heard of her before but love both her voice and her lyrics. she gave me Florence vibes at first but a more pop/rock vibe with it. i love how she can hop through genres and not lose her raunchy vibes.
Faster songs like Criminal are interesting. Slower ones like Slow Like Honey seem to drag on.
Love the jazzy tone, but personally can not handle the melancholic nature.
Skipping to 1996, I always remember what music was looking for. Music by women could be aggressive, but only in so far that they could still be sexually analyzed within discussion of their talent. Fiona Apple is one of those that fought against these standards. So she gets my respect for that. Music wise? Yeah, that worked as well.
This was okay. Just a bit quiet and bland
Fiona Apple is for me an auto 5/5.
Inoffensive
beautiful. mesmerizing. ethereal. there's probably some more adjectives i could toss in here but i think those are good enough. 9/10 FAVOURITE SONGS: SLEEP TO DREAM, SHADOWBOXER, SLOW LIKE HONEY, CARRION
agradable al ído. pero meh total. 5,5/10
Good vocals but doubt I’d listen again
I had to listen a few times, but it won me over
Criminal still rules. The rest of this album is not getting any re-listens, despite being perfectly good.
miło sie sluchalo
sounds incredible. Beautifully written and engineered
This was miles better than her other album on this list. It started well bit it did seem to tail off in quality towards the end. It was still generally enjoyable though, without ever catching my attention fully. It's probably a 2.5 star album, but it's Friday and I'm in a slightly positive mood so I will round up.
Good mems
This was my first Fiona Apple album. I enjoyed it and was very surprised with the sound.
Fav song: Never is a Promise
I'm probably a bit high on it, especially since I think it's me least favorite of all her records. It is good and solid and has a lot of the seeds of what makes her an important voice, but I do think the piano ballad are one too many for my linking, and not all of the offerings here are absolutely essential. That being said, the highs are so high, that I do enjoy it a lot, and there's a good 2/3 of the album that I could listen to and never get bored.
Fantastic album. Sullen and moody, which *does* get to be a little much by the end of the album.
very very strong debut, really experimental and executed really well
I knew her by name but had never listened. Better than expected. Her sound is a bit like Tori Amos with vocals by Alanis Morrissette. Now I like both these artists so this is a no brainier. Slightly jazzy in places. My only issue is that it tailed off a little near the end. Pleasantly surprised.
For a debut from such a young artist, this is such a mature effort. She made this when she was 18! Even the vocals are so mature and feel imbued with lived experience. She has that kind of drawling, husky energy that hits. The production is super cool, with great use of instrumentation to create layered soundscapes. It's a real mood piece throughout. I genuinely thought Jon Brion produced this album as it has many of his hallmarks, but apparently not - but actually looking now I see he did actually play a bunch of instruments across it, which makes sense. I love that vibraphone sound in particular, and the use of violins and bells. I don't know why I seem to gravitate towards 'sad female singer' artists, but I really do. Who knows what that says about me! Anyway, there's plenty of sadness in here. Never is a Promise is heart-breaking, but really effective. There's a real vulnerability, but also quiet resolve. Criminal is the most talked about track, and it really is a standout. There's a danger and sexiness to it. I've listened to this album a bunch over the years, but I'm actually appreciating some of my lesser-listened tracks this time around. Particularly 'The First Taste' which has a real depth to the production. This is a superb debut, bravo! 4.5 rounded up.
Grande Fiona!
Decent
2.5/5, prob bi dao onako 2 da ne racunam da ce doci neki ono actual garbage koji necu moc slusat, ovo je bilo listenable just very forgettable and unexciting. actually dajem dva ipak
Girl wonder, Fiona Apple was a bad ass woman from the day this album came out. Super soulful beyond her years. Wouldn't you love to the the record exec that discovered her.
Maybe I was just in a good mood when I heard this, but what an awesome voice belting out awesome songs. Loved it right from the start. It's so odd how I'd never heard of her before?! This is why I'm listening to all these albums
enjoyed that a lot
Starts ok then moves swiftly into soulless tedium.
it was pretty good, not very memorable
Just a lovely, lovely album and one I shall be returning to. What a delightful voice and great songwriting.
This one goes on the growing pile of albums I admire but don't love.