Tidal by Fiona Apple

Tidal

Fiona Apple

3.47
Rating
30095
Votes
1
4%
2
13%
3
33%
4
34%
5
17%
Distribution

Reviews (page 3 of 15)

Moody, melodic, familiar yet fierce. I slept on Fiona Apple when she came out, but I’m glad I listened through this album. Has a lot of reasons to go back again and again.

I mean it was... fine? Nothing special, especially for the popularity of some (at least one) of these songs. Nothing I'd listen to again, and didn't particularly enjoy it, but it wasn't bad either?

Sexy and grungy and weird.

Bit depressing for a Monday morning

Bit samey

This was crap. I hate the voice

257 / 1089. "Criminal," with its suggestive music video, received a fair amount of attention in 1997. It is still one of the best 1990s singles from a debut album, which has aged like a fine wine. 8/10.

She’s so good, but I am not a lover :(

Good album and she definitely very talented did enjoy but doubt ill return to it anytime soon

Heard good things, Expected more. Rather than cool/moody which i tend to like, this strayed more into whingy/moany/boring territory I Liked 'The First Time' as it was a nice upbeat change Carrion decent. Generous 3

I have some friends who are really into Fiona Apple. I’ve listened to her a few times over the years but, whilst I have enjoyed her, she’s never stuck around my playlists for some reason. Enjoyable enough and glad to throw this album on again. But not sure when she’ll next be taking up residence in my ears.

Never listened to anything by her before. Really good - will have to check out her other stuff.

Never heard of her before - really enjoyed the album

Pretty boring

Really enjoyable, jazzy pop music with some nice instrumentation. Thought the vocals would grate on me after a while but they never did. Pretty good, will listen to more.

How have I not been listening to this ballsy ball of talent all my life?

Kinda lacks some of the fun from her earlier album, maybe she sold out eh

This is a 90s female empowerment pop album. From the era of "Girl Power", there were a few strong female vocalists like Fiona Apple that put out some really good music. This album has a really interesting mix of almost TripHop with Tori Amos piano undercurrent. Fiona Apple's vocals feel a bit like Sarah Mclachlen. In that it feels both powerful and melancholy at the same time. I love a trip down 90s memory lane. Especially when it is an under represented artist like this. (3.000)

I know this album is some people’s bible and although I’m religiously tolerant it’s not mine

eh it was fine, I don't think ill listen to it again.

Fiona Apple is a hit-or-miss artist for me. This is a good album with powerful tunes and interesting musical concepts. I would listen to it again, but don't have it on heavy rotation.

Dull, corny, vacuous beyond words and nothing redeeming about this album. What is this list about? The most annoying albums to kill you or something?

My favorite album from a female artist yet, makes me feel like crap that an album of this quality was made BY AN 18 YEAR OLD

Favorite song: Shadowboxer

The second album from Fiona Apple from my first 73 albums on this project, and I much preferred the previous one (Fetch the Bolt Cutters). I found this a bit boring. One of the compilers of the book must be a big fan to include two albums from her.

Really cool album, some very interesting songs and the blend of that kind of typical 90s female alternative with a more jazz based piano sound is just very unique and well done.

beautiful vocals and instrumentals. nodded my head to almost every song

Gosh, more Fiona Apple in my life please. They really don't make them like this anymore.

4/5 Favorite Song: Sleep To Dream

Really good. I was pretty unfamiliar. There's some really interesting songwriting here. Some fantastic phrasing. There's a little bit of 90s inflection, kind of Jeff Buckleyish in parts. Doesn't feel dated or suffer from it especially though

Sleep to dream 5/5 Sullen girl 5/5 Shadowboxer 5/5 Criminal 5/5 Slow like honey 4/5 The first taste 4.5/5 Never is a promise 5/5 The child is gone 4/5 Pale september 5/5 Carrion 5/5

I was not aware of Fiona Apple. This is not an album I would turn to frequently, and though there a lot of it is sultry jazz, this is not smooth listening. Nevertheless, Apple took me on an emotional rollercoaster. I really enjoyed some of the instrumentals, which ranged from simple piano, heavy trodding bass/drums, to the sliding strings. Tracks I enjoyed were Slow Like Honey, The Child Is Gone, Carrion

I feel fully vindicated by my 1 star rating last week. Here is a 19 yo wise beyond her years, and Fiona's optimism in the face of being hardened by past experiences is even more powerful knowing that she will continue to find herself in abusive relationships and continue to express positivity and optimism, with a healthy dose of female rage as well

Fiona Apple is one of those artists that has one sound and then just makes a bunch of slight variations of off that one sound. Don't get me wrong, it's a good sound - and she definitely deserves her laurels. But she has yet to perfect it in this album. So 4.5 stars, rounded down.

The type of album the critics love and you see the appeal, but can't get any emotional attachment to.

Pretty fun and jammy

10/1001 Imagina lançar sua obra-prima com 19 anos????? Sleep to Dream - 85 Sullen Girl - 80 Shadowboxer - 90 Criminal - 90 Slow Like Honey - 80 The First Taste - 85 Never Is a Promise - 75 The Child Is Gone - 80 Pale September - 80 Carrion - 80 Media: 82.5

Wonderful album look forward to Listening again. Love how it builds each song adding to a full musical statement.

What a debut. She just doesn't miss.

i feel as though this album is what the genre alternative was created for. apple took her classically trained roots and created a jazz record with whiny angsty 90s girl boss lyrics over top of it. it’s literally an alternate version of a jazz record. in a world where we’re so used to alternative meaning some vague rock indie poser mashup, i found this refreshing and interesting. while this album does feel juvenile in parts, i’m shocked at how it has a very clear sense of self. she was a true prodigy, who makes this kinda stuff as a teenage girl????? (ok michael also olivia i know) overall this is a very cool and interesting record and I understand why it was so influential and continues to be. also i think she was pretty bad ass for standing up to a guy like Howard Stern when she was only 19

I didn't dislike this, but wouldn't be in a rush to listen to it again.

This takes me back. Bought this album and listened to it regularly for a few years. Great debut.

The bass is killer on the first track. I also love the instrumentation like that trippy noise that periodically appears. Catchy tune all around. Sullen Girl is more low key but still pretty musically. Shadowboxer’s chorus is great and her vocals standout the most here. She’s so commanding with how she sings. Criminal is the perfect example of this. What a banger. I dare you not to sing along to that chorus. Slow Like Honey is a fitting title because this does drag a bit. I still didn’t mind it though lyrically. The hand drums and what sounds like xylophone are a nice change of pace on The First Taste. Even get a little electric guitar too. Very soft but powerful vocals on Never Is a Promise but the instrumental didn’t grab me as much. There’s a part in The Child Is Gone that sounds like an angel singing and I love it. Pale just washed over me. I didn’t get much out of it. The last track has got this instrumental that sounds like a spy movie at first, then it switches gears for a little before going back. And then we get a cool guitar solo with chimes that is fun.

Like a jazzy alt rock Alanis Morissette, this album had me hooked. I will definitely be exploring her discography further.

Very surprisingly pleasant listen. Even added one song to my favorites list.

Some nice tunes and I enjoyed Fiona’s voice. Would revisit in the right mood.

сильний і водночас ніжний голос я певно нігде так за текстом не дивилась оо крімінал моя темна ванесса you'll be remembered година минула як 5 хвилин

i think no longer being in an abusive relationship takes the wind out of my sails a little bit... still reminds me of him tho! 😝

Singer-Songwriter/Piano Rock Favorite Songs: Technically all of them, but I especially like Sleep to Dream, Shadowboxer, Criminal, The First Taste, Pale September, and Carrion Least Favorite Track: If I have to guess, it’ll probably be The child is Gone? I’m honestly really shocked about some of the reviews on the site here, and some of them, I can see but will just respectfully disagree. The one criticism about her voice, while I would be a hypocrite if I would say that you guys should’ve been a lot nicer about her voice…when I wasn’t a fan of Tom Waits voice, I think it’s really more so about personal tastes, and I honestly find her voice to be really great. However, some of the other reviews aren’t really all that great. For starters, here’s a quote from one of the reviews: “Singer has the feel of "oh I'm so hot, I get all the boys and I know it and I'm so bad" shut the fuck up honestly.” Okay, first of all, I cringed when this person said to ‘shut the fuck up honestly’, I really hope that they don’t actually say that to another person like that. It’s rude. Secondly, and most importantly, this is not about how she has all of the hot guys around, but rather a journey through a breakup. While she has this voice where she’s sounds sexy, I could also get the hint of either sadness, angst, or angry about her experience and how the guy in the song was feeling, too. Then there’s the whole thing about it feeling samey, to which I highly disagree. While the entire time, it’s piano rock, there’s also hints of jazz elements in the album as well as various tempo changes. There’s plenty of variety of each of the songs on here. Then I saw another review about someone giving out too much ‘[redacted]’ like if they’re too scared to even fucking swear and say that no one should’ve been eating this other than one star. Um…if this is how you’re going to react when someone else if giving out a personal opinion like this, then I don’t see how I would even want to talk to that person. Frankly, part of me felt like some of this might be due to sexism, and after seeing one review stating that ‘I’m not a fan of female vocalists’, at least one of you would admit to it. Overall, while I wouldn’t say that this album is near perfect, it’s an excellent album, and the reviews on this site does not do it any justice. There’s some albums that I can get why it has a score like that, but this isn’t one of them (unless if it’s the issue with the voice…to which I can somewhat understand but still disagree). 9/10, but I’m rating this as 5 stars because some of you are really harsh about this album. :/

Fiona Apple would produce some outstanding artistic statements later in her career - “Fetch The Bold Cutters” is a terrific example. This early debut shows her promise, but on the whole it’s rather pedestrian, down the fairway, soulful piano jazz/pop. The potential os obvious, but its not realized here.

An enjoyable listen. Probably should have paid more attention.

This album perfect af

Nice album. Beautiful voice and great arrangements. High 3’s low 4’s

A vibe…but not my vibe.

6.5/10 - Feels like what Adele could have been if her voice was a bit worse. Hard to explain how I mean that as a compliment but I do.

I really wished I liked Fiona Apple the way that everyone else does. It seems like there is something that just isn't clicking for me. Nothing is bad but it also isn't something that I'll go back to. It sounds like the musical equivalent of a cool girl wearing a fedora. 5/10

I like sleep to dream Criminal is not bad either. Grew on me. Its okay but nothing I would listen to again.

Gorgeous album. 'Criminal' that in my nearly thirty years (as long as the album has been out) this hasn't come up. About time!

Honestly a pretty solid listen. Great vocals and just enough variation in the instrumentals to keep it interesting. Also produced in a way that just feels warm/calming to listen to. The middle of the album is definitely the best but overall nothing on here that's bad. All decent to good.

a little one-note, but damn that does it sound abs gorgeous and soo infectious! L8.

Tres bon!

I don't think Fiona Apple has a great voice.

First half was better than the second, found myself enjoying the instruments more than the singing

What I think is the best album from 1996.

343/1089 okayyyy slay. i did listen to this one after the generator gave me bolt cutters, so this isn’t a first listen but it *is* a second fetch the bolt cutters set my expectations a bit high when i first listened to it, i still liked it a lot but was more unsure, on second listen i enjoyed and appreciated it more. it’s a really solid album and a good debut faves: The First Taste, Carrion, Criminal 83/100

Fiona Apple's music has never really clicked with me and this is no different

I fluctuated between 3 and 4. I’m going to go with 4.

Жаль что на фит не позвали Шрека, осла и кота в сапогах - видимо поэтому песни звучат меланхолично Надеюсь Стив Джобс заплатил за рекламу

не моя исполнительница, уже не в первый раз убеждаюсь

Богиня королева лучшая

заслушал fetch the bolt cutters до дыр, к остальному творчеству такой любви не испытываю, но все равно приятно - 4

what a debut

Well OK, I guess, but nothing amazing. I'm surprised she has 2.4M monthly Spotify streams. Not sure who would like her and why. I don't really think she's contributing to the world's musical richness.

I have to give this a proper re-listen, but I do love how elusive and unconventional the song structures here are, even when she's in a far more traditional pop mode. What initially sounds like a standard 90s tune breaks down once you listen closely. And the fact that she was NINETEEN when this came out just elevates it even further.

Fiona Apple obvs iconic n gr8 but not my fave record

There's never a time where I choose Fiona apple over Alanis..

What a ride. I started the listen thinking “oh her voice is not for me” and then wondered “what’s she so upset about, she’s only 19?” And then it sort of clicked just after ‘Criminal’. If she felt mad, I said yes she’s right to feel that, and I’m mad too. If she felt scorned and misunderstood, I thought “that’s right, let them know!” A truly strange listening experience, fighthing what I thought I knew about her as an artist and clearly knowing nothing. This was about the young adult experience where as huge as the feelings feel in the moment, they’re real and they’re valid and have weight. I can’t wait to return to this for another spin.

This is a perfect 90's album. I did not follow her closely but was a fan of the singles from this album. The first half is near flawless. The second half i pretty good, not my favorite. Biggest Hit - Criminal Biggest Miss (if I had to choose) - Pale September Hidden Gem - Sleep To Dream

perhaps i am biased as i am few weeks out of a break up and a few days out of rekindling contact with them (do not ask me how i feel about The First Taste rn...), and i still have 2 songs to go as i write this, but what a fucking magical album. what an insanely talented woman. this has really made her click for me. just fantastic

Solid alt-pop listen

"Tidal" is a fine album, and Fiona Apple is an artist whose work I admire immensely. Whilst I often think of her as eccentric, that label does not quite do her justice. What I really mean is that her music is defined by unconventional song structures, highly literate, intricate lyrics, and an unpredictable vocal phrasing that can jump from a delicate whisper to a guttural growl within seconds. Musically, she often rejects standard pop formulas in favour of strange rhythms, percussive experiments, and unusual instruments. "Tidal" is Apple's debut, and within her broader body of work, it is easily her most straightforward album - yet the seeds of all those distinct characteristics are already fully present here. It is music like this that often makes me think I will enjoy jazz; in my mind, this is exactly what the genre sounds like. However, working through the 1001 Albums list has largely taught me that jazz as a whole is not for me. Instead, what I actually respond to is vocal jazz and traditional pop tunes from the 1940s and 50s. Fiona Apple sits firmly within that lineage, drawing beautifully on that specific atmosphere. Four stars. 1 "Sleep to Dream" (4/5) 2 "Sullen Girl" (4/5) 3 "Shadowboxer" (5/5) 4 "Criminal" (5/5) 5 "Slow Like Honey" (4/5) 6 "The First Taste" (4/5) 7 "Never Is a Promise" (4/5) 8 "The Child Is Gone" (4/5) 9 "Pale September" (4/5) 10 "Carrion" (4/5) Total - 42 Average - 4.2 359/1001 191/359 albums reviewed were new to me.

probably one of the best things ive ver listened to. the first taste is now one of my favorite songs. perfect for walking around the moma. gorgeous

If you are Gen X then you remember exactly where you were when you first heard/saw Fiona Apple

eh...even as background music not great

Not as legendary as When The Pawn… in my opinion, but still a very decent record and worth a listen.

I like this LP, not great but not bad either.

Very chill, my ex needs to sing Criminal to me.

Schwer zwischen 3 und 4. Da ich es gerne nochmal hören würde 4/5

Much more loungey than expected, very nice vocals. Highlights: "Sleep to Dream", "Slow Like Honey", "Carrion"

SHE WROTE A DYLAN-ESQUE RECORD AT 16. but also, i kinda knew about fiona way before i listened to this album. can't believe she sounds like that in her debut album, a masterpiece.

I love fiona apple but this is slower than bolt cutters, so its a four

4.5, just left wanting a little on vocals

Hoped to give this more but nothing really gripped me until it auto-played a Jeff Buckley song after it ended. : (

A true artist.

One of the most influential albums of my teenage years! Still holds up!

Ya lo escuché. Y encima lo escuché hoy sin saber que tocaba acá. Un debut que impresiona. Como podes hacer un primer disco tan bueno? Lo de Fiona es de otro nivel. Genia.

I actually really enjoyed this album. Having not been too excited about a previous Fiona Apple album that I had listened to, 'Fetch The Bolt Cutters', I was really surprised to see how instantly I started to love this. Track one pulled me in straight away, with the peculiar beat, followed by really naturally lovely vocals. One issue I had with that album was that I found the vocals really strange, and even annoying, at times. But this album felt completely different to me. There was a real beauty behind most of the songs, and I would happily listen to this album again. Some of the songs were quite long, which I disliked slightly last time, but these songs have slightly more to offer me, so I wasn't too bothered by this. I actually think I would have been happy with a longer album, which surprises me, as I am not usually a fan of albums that are too long, unless they have something to offer. Favourites: Sleep to Dream Shadowboxer Slow Like Honey Never Is a Promise

Really didn't rate this album as very much on a first listen, but Fiona Apple's voice is gorgeous and she shows it all over this one Favorite Songs: Slow Like Honey, Shadowboxer

A boring kind of average.

Je n’ai pas beaucoup accroché avec cet album. Cependant, la voix et la diversité de son expression et de ses gammes est spectaculaire. Bonne musique d’ambiance, presque Jazz sur certains titres (Pale September) Musique lente, inclassable, parfois sonorité rock avant de revenir sur quelque chose de beaucoup plus calme. On a l’impression que la partie instrumentale n’est là que pour valoriser la voix Pref : Carrion et Pale September

Never is a Promise is a perfect song.

Good album.

Great for what it is, but feels very singer songwriter, which isn't my thing.

Not my cup of tea.

Really turned the tides around in my life

That was altogether more rich, varied and enjoyable than I thought it was going to be. When I saw it came out in 1996 I braced myself for something akin to the grumpy yelpings of Alanis Morrisette, but what heard instead really took me by surprise. In fact, I have to keep checking that date. 1996? Really?? It could have come out last week. I've never knowingly heard anything by Fiona Apple, but I'm really impressed with this. Nice find - I will investigate further.

Have to confess to not listening to the while album (I usually persist) but this was just , dull. No reason I can see it should be on this list at all.

Tinha ouvido outro álbum dela e não tinha gostado. Mas gostei bastante deste. Destaque shadowboxer e never is a promise

Este álbum es bastante catártico, vulnerable, enigmático y sensual al mismo tiempo, la voz de la artista es impresionante y por momentos sorprende los ritmos y atmósfera que crea, a pesar que no vaya con el compás termina de encajar por completo

Favorites: Criminal, Shadowboxer, Sleep to Dream

This is not my first time listening to Fiona Apple, have to thank Family Guy for that. I'm a little mixed on this album; the reason for this is down to my personal taste in jazz or jazz pop. This album is a bit too melancholic and **slow for me and I don't think a fat chud is the target audience for this album. Fuck me and my chud life. Despite my personal tastes, Apple's performance is excellent. No doubt. The percussion instruments in particular is stellar especially in the song Carrion. Apple's vocals is so smooth and that's evident from the opening track Sleep to Dream. Criminal is really good and it's sad that my introduction of it came from Joe Swanson. Nothing against Patrick Warburton. He'd slay doing a cover of Criminal for sure. Album has super broke-up with a boy energy. Let me get a boyfriend, break up, and return to this piece; tackle it with a new perspective. Maybe I'll turn around on it after bouncing on it. Highlight of the Album, Criminal is really good. Everything flows so nice and the chorus is addicting. So much going on with this song, instrumental-wise, that I'm too ignorant for articulating it. The drums make me happy (I like drums) and that violin sound (probably a violin) sneaking it's way in is ver gud. Also, The First Taste feels magical. Overall, thank you Family Guy. T3: Criminal, Carrion, Sleep to Dream

twas okayish

Lahe ja iseloomu täis album. See pole päris 100% minu maitse, aga siin on korralikult krutskeid ja lüürikat, et mitu korda kuulata. Vokaal on ka lahe ja ma olen üllatunud, et ma pole ei sellest artistist ega plaadist kuulnud. 3.6/5

Holy shit this album is so great! It came out in 1996, when Fiona Apple was still a teenager, and that’s part of why it made the list. Not just because she was young, but because the album has this unusually mature emotional vocabulary: desire, shame, anger, manipulation, insecurity, self-possession, and romantic damage. It does not sound like a manufactured 90s pop debut. It sounds like someone already building her own private emotional language. Fucking love it. 5 big stars.

I'd never really listened to Fiona Apple - she has a hell of a voice. Love the use of piano in the recordings. I really like Slow Like Honey.

Pretty cool album. Had a short of Blues sound to it. Better than I expected.

8.5/10 like it more then i expected nice voice. started hard and ended on a more calm sad note. very good piano. liked: sleep to dream never is a promise- shadowboxer criminal slow like honey

could possibly get to 5 stars with more listens, i’ve GOT to listen to more fiona apple

Pleasant music, much better than Morissette and Winehouse

The best albums of fiona apple is so amenoo

Before this, I'd only listened to Fiona Apple's latest album, which I didn't particularly like — it was rather overwrought art-pop, plus her voice is an acquired taste. So, I wasn't expecting much from her debut. But it turned out to be a decent jazz-pop album, perfect for starting the morning. The piano arrangements are slightly complex, yet pleasantly listenable, and the vocals are emotional, sometimes reminiscent of those of her 90s female alternative counterparts, like Courtney Love or PJ Harvey. And considering Fiona was only eighteen when the album was released, the record scores even more points. I'm unlikely to re-listen to Tidal, but if you need a beautiful audio background for breakfast or work, this is a wonderful option.

I’m not sure I would give this album a 5 if I heard it for the first time today. But it was one of the my first 20 CDs… came into my life so early that I’m not sure I picked it myself or if my mom bought it for the household. Her voice was as sure a part of “alternative” for me as Kurt Cobain’s. And even more than that I feel like this album taught middle school me how to FEEL. I had never experienced any of the things she was singing about but I aspired to have those experiences and feelings. I wondered what it would be like to have a “Shadowboxer” love or a “Criminal” love. I don’t know that these songs describe my emotional life today all that well, but I’m attached to rhe memory of each of them so much.

A striking debut—intimate, smoky, and emotionally raw. Reminiscent of Alanis Morissette in places, though not as outwardly explosive, but deeper and more controlled. “Criminal” hooks you in, but the quiet moments are what keep it lingering.

Liked the hit song.

Some good stuff, but patchy.

Ok I’m not sure who I thought Fiona Apple was, but I was wrong. I expected out and out pop. Instead I got some Tori Amos like vocals and some well written tunes

Another pouty singer who claims to shun everything that she so willingly embraced for fame and fortune. Poor girl must have really struggled to cash every paycheck and sit down for every interview that would keep the money and fame rolling in. All that aside, there wasn't anything about these songs, the production, or her singing that was worth listening to any of her songs all the way through. Yawn.....

(Light 8/10) At only 18 years old, Fiona Apple creates not only a wonderfully produced album, but also an incredibly mature and wise-beyond-her-years collection of songs. "Criminal" is indeed a classic, but also "Sleep To Dream" and "The First Taste" are other examples of just how powerful of an artist she was at such a young age. A very good record, I feel like the more I listen and dig into the lyrics my score will go up, for now though I am very pleased with my first listen-through (not my first Fiona album though) and will look forward to playing this one again.

She made this at 19?? I could never make an album this good.

I really liked this, don't know why I didn't listen to it when it first came out.

Enjoyed it but not enough to be a 4

light 4.5.

I never really got the hype around Fiona Apple, and now I don't think I ever will. I enjoyed her unique and poetic storytelling style of writing. I liked the piano and instrumentation, and I really believe she has a great voice. However, altogether, it's just not for me. I think I liked "Carrion" the best.

Brother attituuuuuuude The voice is absolutly spendide The lyrics seem to be boiling with anger in the first song. There seems to be a controlled outburst of energy. Like if anything were to happen you d get the full explosion of emotion she is going through with it very exciting the intonatino and the voice is really really what captures my attention; The lyrics aren't bland either which is fun, i m really enjoying this album so far. The instrumental is very simple sometimes to a fault but, i wouldnt want it to get in the way of the voice so i'll forgive. ---- I dont think i was able to finish the album, i thought over all it was good ? I really like when she does more intense songs. These slow soft one seem a little boring to me. She has an incredible voice but it's a shame that the songs are a little boring :/

This album is way better than I remember, and I own this one. But she’s not blazing any trails here. I’m not sure how this very good album got a spot on this list, but I’m happy to see that it did.

Fiona is THAT girl. Flawless tone and endless talent.

Без поняття хто це. Виглядало так, що це шось типу Kate Bush, але вже з перших пісень звучить більш комерційно, більш “polished”. На останній хвилині Criminal класна кінгізардна музичка. Взагалі музика доволі цікава, а вокал місцями дратує. Коротше поки найгірша рекомендація. Не скажу що жахливо, але трохи було бажання щоб альбом якнайшвидше закінчився.

Not in the mood for this because its sunshines and rainbows

Pretty cool. Powerful vocals and lots of unique sounds. Pretty different each song. Felt like a movie soundtrack Review: 7/10 Fave songs: Sleep to Dream, Shadowboxer, The First Taste

I'm glad I heard her great Boltcutters album first so I know how good she is. This is a good album too, but I kind of bounced off it for some reason. I'll give it more of a chance some other time, but for now it's only a three-star album. I recognize that that's more of a me problem, though.

4.5 maybe a 5, fantastic songwriting, amazing vocals, production is nice!

lindo album, canciones buenas si te gusta este estilo

Best Track - "Shadowboxer"

Quite crap

6/10 Starts off quite well and calmed my fear of a Fiona Apple album (only heard her massively hyped recent releases). After a while it starts to drag as the musical ideas dry up - you can hear her youth, I think.

Ordentliches Songwriting. Gute Stimme. Zu poppig, um Besonders zu sein. 3,4

I need to spend more time with this album to really appreciate it for what it is, but even so this is an easy 5

I don’t know if I’ve ever really got Fiona Apple. I’m well aware of her reputation but when I’ve tried to listen in the past nothing has really clicked, and I felt similarly when I started this album. but there are some great songs. my fave was Never Is A Promise, but I don’t envision listening often

I think that Fiona Apple’s song construction improves after this album and she explores more interesting sounds but there is something so compelling and beautiful here. I love her.

Canta bem, mas são 50 minutos de boring music total. Sessão de tortura musical.

Good concept, not expanded upon enough.

She has a very pretty voice

an impressive debut.

typical Fiona apple album (at least to me), breathy, angry songs. It's ok, I will listen to it again but won't put it on myself. A solid 2

hoy casi tengo dos accidentes de coche escuchando este disco. No repetiría.

Oh Fiona. Well let’s see how I feel… Wow, this was so much better than I expected. Don’t know why my expectations were low. Maybe fan base? Don’t know, but I wasn’t psyched going in. This might have gotten a 5 on a different day. I mean damn the girl has talent. But too slow today. Though, I can’t say there’s a particularly rough spot on the album, it just doesn’t pull me through. I was dragging at the end. But it’s a solid 4. Boolean: definitely Yes. Surprised I never heard this album before

Wouldn't have her on my radar otherwise.

Ganz okay, nach Rock wirds dann klassisch mit Streichern usw?

I’m not great at maths but I know for a fact that Fiona Apple + a piano = masterpiece

Could definitely feel the emotion as she sings.

This album shocked me when it came out. By the marketing I had expected the worst, some 19yo pop singer emo schlock that was corporate produced and polished to death. I couldn't have been more wrong. Yes, emo schlock, yes, 19yo, yes corporate polish, but the result is completely engaging, raw, fun, cohesive. The more you play it the more comes out of it. 30 years later it still holds up.

So good.

Okay. Not my style of music - too soporific. I quite like the closing song Carrion, and it was a bit more musically interesting. After listening to this album, Spotify moved onto another of her songs, Paper Bag, which I preferred to the whole of this album.

Why is this so boring? The First Taste is the only good song for me here, anything else sounds the same, Carrion is interesting but the chorus feels like a slap in my face.

I'd only ever heard Criminal going into this. I loved this album, Shadowboxer is my favorite, but the album as a whole is just excellent. I'll definitely be looking at Apple's other albums.

At first I thought this was just fine and unremarkable, but by the second half the bluesy groove of it grew on me a bit.

Formative. All time great lyricist. Reading other reviews makes me think some people should be grateful they do not “get” and resonate with the seething rage and expressed through this album.

Already a favorite. Have on cd and vinyl

Smokey backroom, two drink minimum, whisky and cigar type vibe.

literally cheered when her face popped up on my screen. thank god i get some good fucking food after yesterday's slopfest. don't LOVE all the tracks on this one but overall a pretty good time. i prefer when the pawn personally favorite tracks: shadowboxer, criminal, carrion, the first taste

Sultry voice ,good songs

She is so sad - Stand Out Tracks: Shadowboxer, Criminal, The First Taste, Carrion

My only complaint is that I'll never be able to experience this album for the first time again.

I liked her ethereal vocals, but couldn't listen to this all the time.

Fiona Apple is a beautiful haunting presence.

Muy tranquilo y melodico,me gusta

Mid-90s rock. Her debut. Incredibly strong female voice. Jazzy, smooth, very cool.

01) Sleep to Dream - 8,0 02) Sullen Girl - 7,0 03) Shadowboxer - 7,5 04) Criminal - 8,0 05) Slow Like Honey - 7,0 06) The First Taste - 7,0 07) Never Is a Promise - 6,5 08) The Child Is Gone - 6,5 09) Pale September - 6,5 10) Carrion - 6,5 TOTAL: 7,05 (71/100) Current ranking: 501/925

A perfect example of a voice matching an emotion matching the atmosphere

Very good, downloaded, and worth a relisten. Solid writing

What a great intro to an artist. The incredible pole dance of J. Lo. in Hustlers to Criminal

Liked this significantly more than fetch the bolt cutters

Art pop is something I haven’t really touched yet. This was a pretty solid introduction to Fiona Apple. 6/10

Her voice is good, but the melodies are very similar and little is happening.

I like Fiona and she should just tell that Howard Stern fella to fuck off!

Pretty good

🌕🌕🌕🌗🌑 (rounded down based on average of every song) I all-caps LOVE "Criminal" and "Shadowboxer"—o such drama! extended jams! et cetera!—so I was really excited to dive into this album, but unfortunately, it seems I heard the best tracks first (many such cases). Fiona Apple has an incredible persona, her lyrics are raw, and this singer-songwriter piano style was the perfect place to wring that rawness out of. I really think that energy could've carried this album all the way through, but (even with great lyrics) I think the momentum died down by the end. This rating may bump significantly if I let it sink in, though, because "Sleep to Dream," "Pale September," and "Carrion" were all musically interesting enough that I'd revisit them, and "Sullen Girl" and "The Child is Gone" felt very emotionally compelling enough that I might as well listen to them again, too, and that's the whole album, I guess. 1: Bad | 2: Okay, No Desire to Revisit | 3: Good, Conditionally (OR Inconsistent Mix of Qualities) | 4: Great (OR Technically amazing but missing the sauce emotionally) | 5: Amazing

Oh Fiona, the world did you dirty…

This caught me by surprise. I’ve always heard that she rules but finally experiencing it was wonderful. Phenomenal vocalist and these songs are all incredible. No notes.

I liked. GJ OG edgy girl

Favs: criminal, first taste, sleep to dream

Criminal stood out, but I believe I've heard it before since it's her biggest hit. Liked the vibe and her vocals. 3.5/5

Good music, great vocalist, good writing with variety and nuance - I enjoyed this quite a lot.

Default music

The first song almost turned me off from the whole album. It seems to have a weird low production value. I dont exactly like her bland voice. However, the other songs are very good and diverse. Love her voice and the different rythms. Crazy learning that she wrote it all herself as a teenager, that just makes the listening different. My favorite song was the first taste, very underrated. Did not really enjoy the most famous songs, sleep to dream and criminal.

어우 듣기좋아

Better than most modern stuff, but not by much.

I’d tell you what I think of this album but you don’t care

90’s Adele

moody, slow, honest, very good.

In the ‘90s I didn’t pay a lot of attention to Fiona because she blended into the barrage of feminist rock. Later, I heard her live with a lot of falsetto and legato vocals, which disinterested me. My former boss at the music store once referred to her piano tab book (her breastfeeding a pig) as “filth”. I rolled my eyes starting it. That changed. This album surprised me! I don’t know if I’m full fledged fan but I understand the attraction to her. Where Alanis had her raw vocals, and Lisa had her guitar, Fiona had the piano and a lower register vocal style, which she rocked at both. The album felt more in the vain of Elton than Carly. Sleep to Dream was a great opener, and Pale September a passionate ballad with a retro-jazz-but-in-minor-cords feel. I have to say that Criminal was still my favorite, with a little dirtiness in lyrics and musicality. I think removing this from the period helped me appreciate it more. I wonder how many albums are like that? Where is my Chumbawamba album? 🤔 Even though her hair is red, Fiona is a grannty smith Apple: sweet with a tart bite.

Random thoughts: * I thought I only knew “Criminal” from this album. Then I heard the opening track “Sleep to Dream” and realized not only did I know more than one song, but I’m pretty sure this is the best track on the album! * I’ve never been a big Fiona Apple fan but I do appreciate her style. * Her voice is incredible on this album! Really carries a lot when the songs aren’t so great. * there were some definitely more downer songs. And the mood is overall dark so it is not exactly everyday listening music. * I’m glad to check this out but I’m still not really a big Fiona fan but I do have a better appreciation.

Didn't really evoke a whole lot out of me, but it was still pretty good. High 3

I was seventeen when Tidal was released - prime for Apple's mix of anger and Broadway inspired piano lines but this album passed me by, unlike Alanis' Jagged Little Pill, which was released the year before which remains a big part of my teenage listening oeuvre. To sit with this album today has been just wonderful. The lyrics combined with Apple's voice and musical intensity have made this a new staple in my listening 'pile'. As I get older I am drawn more and more to female artists and whilst always familiar Fiona Apple, the connection was peripheral - I'm glad to have had this land on my listening mat today!

I love love love "Sleep to Dream" and "Criminal"; I like the other tracks to varying degrees, but in my opinion, they've always paled in comparison a bit to these two tracks. Across the board, though, her songwriting is out of this world for a 19-year-old, and even though I think she goes on to do much better, this is an unbelievably impressive debut all things considered. 3.5/5

Good album

There are a few good ones on here.

I knew quite a few bits of Fiona Apple - and always liked what I heard - but didn’t have much sense for her backstory or musical progression until reading about this album. I think she’s great. This album isn’t as interesting as some of the later stuff, perhaps, but includes some really strong songs. Shadowboxer, for example is a brilliant bit of songwriting.

Front heavy but solid album overall, especially the closer Carrion. She has a (unintuitively) similar voice to Michael McDonald, in that it's somehow high and low at the same time, in sure there's a more intelligent way to say that. Feels like 3.5 rounded down because the b side was relatively forgettable.

Beautiful keys hit across the album and quite retrospective

Forgot how much I love this woman's music. Moody, beautiful, and deep

This still brings out the emotions, excellent!

I didn't really care for this album - I guess it's just not a good fit to my taste.

love me a bit of the Apple

Kinda catJAM; pretty good and chill.

7/10 Having heard Fiona Apple’s name a lot over the years, she was someone whose work I’d never found the time to explore before, and I wasn’t really sure what to expect. Straight off the bat it’s clear that, despite being only 18 at the time of recording this record, she has an incredibly mature and controlled talent for performance, both vocally and at the piano. She has a lovely contralto vocal range that feels both jazzy and soulful and she has the chops to throw in lovely flourishes as required, while also showing the self control to use those chops sparingly to maximise their potency and effect. I was interested to hear a sprinkling of trip-hop production influence across the record which, while very much pinning the album at a certain time period, added an interesting quality to her more jazzy vocal and piano techniques. There’s also a touch of the singer-songwriter about this too, and the general blend of styles and vibes were one area in which the album felt like it lacked a little coherence and focus. It is a little bit of an uneven record in other ways too, with some of the songwriting feeling a little flat and failing to significantly capture enough standout moments in some of the tracks to help them become more than pleasant to listen to. That’s not to say that any of it was bad, particularly, because most of this was pretty enjoyable. For the weaker songs, the performances typically elevated much of the more vibey feel to a level slightly above that. When she got it right, though there were some really excellent moments. Shadowboxer really got me by the time I’d spun the album a few times, and the run from that to Slow Like Honey was brilliant. With many debuts, the real trick is to pick out the talents and use those as a launch pad to further develop an artists voice, and on this album, that launch pad feels very robust indeed. It’s a solid album without tipping over into brilliance, but certainly suggests that her subsequent work will be worth a thorough listen. Sleep To Dream - Quite a cool beat and vibe to kick us off. I like the swagger and rhythm of her vocal delivery and while things float a bit melodically during the verses, the chorus gathers up that roaming nature and delivers something more centred, which is a really nice juxtaposition. It’s quite a trip-hop feel, with the soulful vocal, jazzy piano and stuttering hip-hop beats. This is a pretty promising start. Sullen Girl - This is far more singer-songwriter stuff to begin with, but there are still echoes of that trip-hop sound in the production. This song kind of feels like it doesn’t know what it wants to be in that it changes vibe a reasonable amount from the stripped back bits to the fuller sections. It’s a bit rambly for me and doesn’t really manage to find a particularly engaging musical motif at any point that I can grab on to. It’s just a bit bland and aimless. Shadowboxer - There’s a nice downtempo swing to this and it feels like it has a bit more purpose and direction than the last track. Her voice and delivery are really good, and the vocal hook through the chorus is soulful with a touch of grit, which I really like. The depth and feel of the instrumentation and production here provides a rewarding listening experience, topped off with solid chops both on the piano and vocally. It’s not the most complex composition, but it does everything it does well and those key elements just elevate it. Criminal - The feel of the groove to this is really nice. The change in feel and tone between verse and chorus is cool too and again, Fiona’s vocal delivery is excellent. There’s something quite compelling about the layered rhythms from across the instrumentation and I found myself bobbing along to this one with gusto. I’m not completely keen on the string samples used, but that’s a bit minor and the rest of the track is solid work. This is a little on the rockier side of the road, but there’s still a bit of that electronica/trip-hop side to the production, and it’s a decent blend. Slow Like Honey - Fiona’s piano playing is really lovely here. It’s a bit of a meandering number, but I quite like the roaming, almost jazzy focus of this. I particularly enjoy some of the choices of musical modulation when she jumps out of minor modalities with little flickers into a more major tone giving hints of optimism within a track that’s quite dark and dreary overall. It’s a subtle song, but I can picture this being completely captivating in a smoky jazz bar. It’s really lovely stuff. The First Taste - I wasn’t expecting the beat that kicked in for this, feeling like it was going to carry on the smoky jazz vibe of the last track. Her vocal performance is excellent again, but the mix of sounds in this is a little bit confusing, with some of the instrumental choices sounding a little oddly paired. I like the general thrust of the groove though and, while it’s a bit melodically rambling, the overall vibe does feel decent, even if it feels a bit rhythmically cluttered. Never Is A Promise - This is quite pretty and stark, but again, it doesn’t feel entirely melodically focused and while the performances are very good, the combination of sparseness and slightly wafty melodic centre, it doesn’t quite manage to fully connect and maintain attention in a way the better tracks have done. It’s still very pretty in its own way though. The Child Is Gone - Oof, some of the little bits of vocal flourish she chucks in here and there are really lovely. The vocal performance is so mature and tasty and conjures up a bit more of that jazzy vibe, despite the fact that the rest of the track doesn’t have that kind of vibe. In fact, the rest of the track does jar a touch against that. It feels like there’s a really decent song in here somewhere, but the arrangement and orchestration don’t feel like they really do it the justice it deserves and it feels a touch muddled and unfocused because of that, which is a shame. Pale September - Another pretty but musically wandering piece. There are moments of quality in here, but it’s a bit too repetitive in the piano part and just feels like it’s drifting along not really offering any particular intent or direction. As a result, this one ends up just being a little bit dull and uninspiring as even the vibe is just a touch on the bland side. It’s also too long. Carrion - This immediately has a bit more to it. The blend of rhythms from the instruments gives it a nice shuffling groove and there’s a bit more going on melodically. The sudden change to the chorus about a minute and a half in is SUPER jarring though. It almost feels like they’ve just dropped a completely different song in at that point, with the sudden thickening of the orchestration and complete shift of the rhthm. We do find our way back to the verse and the work on there is really good. What a strange production and songwriting choice that is and it doesn’t work for me at all. Looked at alone, the verses and choruses here are both actually good, but I just don’t feel like they work together.

I thought this was interesting. I have never listened to Fiona Apple before properly and I am surprised I hadn’t. I liked the way it sounded and what it was saying but it lacked someone for me and I’m unsure what. I just cannot believe this girl went out with Tarantino, how did she have time to think of write anything while he was yabering on

I think Apple has something interesting to say here but this just doesn’t work for me musically. The quantity of laid back lounge music just isn’t my thing, and I didn’t enjoy this as much as I should when I listen to the lyrics and focus on her voice.

A fantastic album, especially given that it is a debut from a very young artist. The instrumentals are lush and elegant. Fiona is an incredible singer. She has done better and I still think she is coming into her own as an artist a bit here, but this is still a very good record

it's pretty good so far, halfway through. it gets a 3

Fiona has such a good voice. Really bluesy. Listened to this album many times over the years and it gets better with each listen.

Incredible!! Absolutely loved it. Every song.

Fiona Apple es una artista con excelente reputación entre la crítica. Digamos que es el reverso femenino de Sufjan Stevens. Con una personalidad diferente e inusual, un talento fuera de toda duda y con el tiempo un sentido del humor que le ha sido terapéutico. Tiene alguna versión y colaboración por las que cualquier artista se daría por satisfecho si solo hubiera hecho eso en toda su carrera. Con Elvis Costello, con Cash en Bridge Over Troubled Water o el Across the Universe de los Beatles. No es PJ Harvey, ni Kate Bush, eso vaya por delante. Tiene un estilo más similar a Alanis y una voz a Bonnie Raitt (o Sheryl Crow), pero su estilo podría ser la PJ más contenida, sirvan Never is a promise o Sullen girl como ejemplos, si bien aquí recuerda a otras ilustres como Weyes Blood, Angel Olsen, e incluso a Florence, todas ellas influidas de manera evidente por Fiona. Este debut, es un buen disco, grande, suen bien, buena producción y tiene buenas canciones. Desde la inicial Sleep to dream o Shadowboxer (primer sencillo, que sintetizan perfectamente el tono del disco. The child is gone es de mis favoritas. Obviamente hay que cotar Criminal, su tema más conocido (el otro es Paper bag de su siguiente disco) y compuesto en apenas media hora como respuesta a su discográfica para tener algo que poder vender. El único pero que se le puede poner es su homogeneidad, le falta algo un poco más de chispa a veces para evitar que se vuelva monótono. Lo que se intuye en Sleep to Dream. Algo que lograría con sus siguientes discos: When the pawn... (con record al título más largo de un disco, al menos unos años) The Idler Wheel... y Fetch The Belt Cutters" Un excelente debut de una artista con 18 años (en eso recuerda a K. Bush).

This one's a meditative bedroom listen I'd reach for one searching for some amount of catharsis. Fiona's vocals hit hard and fast from the start of the album and don't really give up for the rest of the hour. Any album that starts heavy and swings into melancholy will always have my heart in some sense. Carrion is a very close second for my favorite on this album just for how emotionally explosive it is. Favorite Song: Never is a Promise

I have ADHD. A shocking revelation, I know. But it makes actively listening to music hard. I bring this up because Tidal is half of a good album (for me) and half a bad album (for me). If I tell you the songs I liked were Sleep to Dream, Shadowboxer, and Criminal, you'll probably roll your eyes and call me pedestrian. The thing is, songs like Sullen Girl, The Child is Gone, and Pale September have this sort of rolling, lulling quality to them that make them (to me) feel like plinking at a piano aimlessly while singing. I will not remember these songs after I have listened to them. Their sound waves will undulate through one ear and out the other and I will barely remember having ever listened to them. Give me a few years and I'll swear to you I've never listened to this album at all. While I was listening, I tried to keep a running log of my thoughts of all the songs. Just little sentences, so I would remember what I thought while listening to that specific song (the album is nearly an hour long, yo). What I wrote for Sullen Girl was "shallow musicality" and I don't mean "shallow" in some sense of lacking artistic depth, I mean literally the range of notes and how they are arranged are not very deep. It's like listening to 1-2-3, 1-2-3 over and over again. Half of this album is that way, to me. The other half of the album pushes Apple's voice to the front more, and those I tend to like much better than the ones where the piano has a more central focus. One callout I'll do though is that the *lyrics themselves* fuck in every song. I also don't want to be That Way about it but during The Child is Gone I thought to myself, wow, in the 90s people probably dismissed the fuck out of this as a "woman album" because it's very much a kind of expression of the frustrations of being born a woman in this world. (And at least one reviewer (not us, I mean like, A Critic) did, it looks like, haha ha... ha...) Favorite Song: Slow Like Honey (for whatever reason it defied the trend of shallow-ness without being a song like Criminal, if you get me.)

"never is a promise / and you can't afford to lie" i can't imagine being 17 and having already experienced so much pain that you could write and record an album like this. no wonder she's such a fan of Maya Angelou — talk about kindred spirits. this isn't a trip-hop album but it's also not NOT one. The First Taste in particular has a real sinuous-but-skittering groove to it that i can very easily imagine the Massive Attack boys laying down raspy verses over. her voice is, of course, just perfect for these songs. she has such mastery over that weary contralto; you don't have to tax your imagination at all to envision her on stage, behind a piano, in some cigarette-choked nightclub seizing the attention of everyone present and refusing to release it, refusing to let anyone breathe.

I've heard Fiona Apple's name more times than I can count, but still I had no idea what to expect from this. I suppose I don't tend to listen to "singer-songwriter" music much... Her voice is very impressive, though. If nothing else, I'll remember that. And the lyrics are fun, with all their 'scorned-lover' sass. Also, the bass on Criminal is very good. Actually, I like a lot of the bass lines here. But I've never heard of any of the credited bassists... I've noticed previously that my ears have an incredibly difficult time latching on to songs consisting of only a lead instrument and vocals. Some of the tracks on this album, like Never Is A Promise, make that effect very obvious. Certainly they're awfully pretty in the moment, but then the song closes and I've already forgotten every second of it. Give me a rhythm section, please. (...Yes, I recognize that this is a personal failing of mine.) Ah, and Carrion has this very cool jazzy, or perhaps bossa-nova vibe... I think if there'd been more of that prior, this album might have truly struck a chord. Great closer, still. Not a taste-changer, but I did have a good time with it. Favorite tracks: Sleep To Dream, Criminal, Carrion.

great songwriting, great voice, great work by the band. hard to say too much more really, it's just really good.

uten tvil en dyktig artist i sin tid, litt kjedelig album. Litt anonym 90talls smølje til tider.. fint, men sitter ikke helt

I liked her voice and the way she sings, but it didn’t hit me as much as I expected. The emotional intensity started to feel a bit heavy by the second half. Personally, I prefer a rawer, more rock-oriented sound.

I like the up-tempo numbers on here tremendously. Everything else is just alright.

Todella lahjakas laulaja, vähän amy winehouse-tyylinen ääni mutta pehmeämpi. Menee jatkoon

albumi alkaa aika kovalla bängerillä. Shadowboxer also aivan jäätävä bänger. Followed by criminal aivan sairasta. Tää laulaja on myös todella todella lahjakas. Todella moni kappale meni omalle soittolistalle. 6/5 hyvää kamaa

She is sincere in her lyrics, because it’s clear that her voice hasn’t been stifled—not by an old love, a disappointment, or the inexplicable feeling of being lost in this world. It’s not exactly a journey, but rather an invitation to see what goes on inside her mind and body when she feels disappointment, pride, and the drive to overcome. She describes what it’s like to feel separated from who she once was and now has to learn to rediscover herself—not to become the woman she was, because that would mean all her experience was in vain; it would mean she’d be ignoring it. What she does is unlearn in order to rebuild herself. It’s a very good album.

nice and relaxing

No. 188 Believe it or not, it's my first time listening to Fiona Apple, and what an artist is she to listen to for the first time. It's a wonderful, powerful record. I absolutely love it.

NO NOTED TURBO BANGER CONVINCED I GOT MY FIRST BIG BIG JOB FROM THIS ALBUMS SECRET POWERS DONT ASK

One of my favourite albums everything from the vocals, to the groove this album is such a vibe i love it… even the slower songs are amazing 10/10

I had heard a lot about Fiona Apple but never listened to her. But wow, she wrote these songs as a teenager and recorded the album at 18, respect.

This slaps and I believe she was extremely young when she made this????? Mind boggling.

Challenging - clear songcraft, but not really "tuneful" or trying to be in any way. More "personal singer-songwriter who doesn't care what you think"

Just a really good album by a really good artist.

Don’t like her voice or the production. I think at all

Horrible

What struck me most about this record is that it doesn’t feel like a precocious debut. It feels like a completed internal system. Most nineteen-year-old artists still show the seams - influence, overreach, uncertainty, flashes of brilliance amid attempts to prove seriousness. This arrives with an already coherent emotional and musical logic. Not “promising”, but authored. The obvious headline is the voice, but the deeper achievement is judgement. Fiona Apple already understands arrangement as psychology. The grooves drag rather than propel. The rhythm section sustains atmosphere instead of chasing impact. Songs are allowed to simmer, with tension carried in timing, phrasing and harmonic colour rather than overstatement. There’s jazz all over the record without it ever becoming “jazz-pop”. More accurately, it has jazz intelligence - blue-note pressure, delayed resolution, conversational elasticity, the understanding that restraint can create more emotional force than release. Again and again I found myself thinking about Nina Simone. Not stylistically, exactly, but in the way Apple leans on notes until they become emotionally argumentative. Certain phrases arrive almost declaratively rather than melodically, with straight-tone attacks that refuse easy warmth. A line like “then you let your love abound” lands not because she decorates it, but because she slightly bruises the note on arrival. The emotional uncertainty is embedded directly into the pitch. The sequencing is remarkably sophisticated too. This is not a collection of strong songs occupying the same CD. It behaves as an album - recurring emotional climates, controlled shifts in pressure, strategic releases of tension. Even the weaker moments are revealing. One mid-album groove piece drifts a little too close to “interesting nocturnal jam” territory and briefly obscures Apple herself behind the arrangement, which only highlights how completely the stronger tracks maintain authorial gravity. Most of the time the music bends around her consciousness rather than the other way around. What fascinated me most was the album’s relationship with control. The songs are emotionally intense, but very rarely uncontrolled. Even the confessional moments contain a hovering intelligence evaluating the scene in real time. “Criminal” in particular works because it never fully settles into either guilt or seduction. There’s an arched eyebrow throughout the performance, as though Apple is simultaneously inhabiting and quietly interrogating the role she’s been assigned. The songs repeatedly resist simplification. Shame, power, desire, performance and self-awareness coexist in unstable combinations. “Never Is a Promise” feels like the emotional centre of the record. Not because it offers catharsis, but because it understands instability without collapsing into nihilism. The title itself is devastatingly perceptive - absolutes are promises people make while standing inside temporary emotional weather. The arrangement trusts space and melodic contour rather than grandstanding, and the vocal performance is astonishingly measured. Elsewhere, tracks like “Pale September” show another side of the record entirely. Apple stops projecting over the arrangement and instead sits inside it, becoming part of the atmosphere rather than dominating it. It reminded me less of singer-songwriter confessionals and more of the suspended emotional climates of old torch songs - not melodrama, but weather. The final stretch is particularly impressive because the album refuses obvious closing-track behaviour. Instead of building toward some grand prestige-ballad summation, it initially appears to drift sideways into ambiguity before suddenly escalating in emotional pressure. The shift arrives so abruptly that it feels meteorological rather than conventionally “developed”. You realise retrospectively that the calm was compression. What lingers afterwards is not simply the quality of the songwriting, but the unnerving completeness of the artistic identity. This does not sound like someone entering an existing lane. It sounds like somebody already in possession of a private aesthetic law and expecting the listener to adapt accordingly. The truly absurd part is that she was nineteen when she made it.

It was okay, couldn’t really get into it outside of criminal

surprisingly liked it yay!

Well, I guess we're keeping the doctor away today, am I right? Get it? Cause, like, an apple a day keeps the doctor away? Hey, it's not every day that I get to talk about an artist named Apple, okay? I'm trying here! Whatever. Let's talk about Fiona Apple! I've heard the name Fiona Apple floating around the music discourse world and I've heard great things said about this artist. As such, I was quite excited to dive into her 1996 debut album, Tidal, as my first album of hers. How do I like them Apples? A lot, actually! This is pretty great! Right off the bat, I understand the appeal of Fiona Apple as an artist. Fiona's voice is great. It's very earnest and fits the lyrics very well. Speaking of which, the lyrics! I've gotta say, I'm very impressed by Fiona Apple's lyricism. There's a great blend of raw emotion and occasional wordplay and it's quite wonderful. This album is distinctly feminine, but not in a way that feels forced or dumbed-down. It's quite empowering and I have a ton of respect for everything here. The music of the album is also right up my alley. What can I say? I like piano rock. Of course, you've got some iconic singles here like "Shadowboxer" and "Criminal," both of which are stellar, but the deep cuts are great too. The fact that a song as good as "Pale September" is the least streamed song on this album is insane. Admittedly, this album isn't perfect, and I'm sure Fiona's made better albums than this. I've especially heard great things about this album's followup, When the Pawn..., but that album's not on the list, so unfortunately I won't get to talk about it for the main album project. Oh well. At least I got to talk about this impressive debut album of hers. Great stuff! High 4/5.

might be the best vocals from a modern female artist i have ever heard. AMAZING. 4.5/5

not for me

Sleep To Dream, Criminal and Shadowboxer are such great songs. This is a really good album. I’m surprised Fiona didn’t have wider success.

la verdad que me sorprendió gratamente, buen álbum, totalmente equilibrado

Catchy, and warm vocals, just a solid easy listen album with some great songs borderline 4

The opening was bad but it picked up and became much more chill and good by the end

Unerwartet gut.

Anything Fiona Apple is wonderful

Listening to this you will get the feeling that you are sitting in a smoky jazz club basement listening to 20s era soothing and scintillating music. A very good album and worthy of inclusion on this list. Fiona has a terrific alto voice.

Soft rock dreamscape.

Favorite track(s): Sleep to Dream, Shadowboxer, Criminal, Slow Like Honey, The First Taste, Carrion

My sister loves this artist. I feel like she made me buy this for her years ago for a birthday present (being 8 years younger, I always made her explicitly tell me what she wanted). It was alright. I recognized a few songs. There was a little angst and attitude between the soft singing and melodies. Made a good backdrop for the schoolwork I was doing. 3 stars.

This album is like a woman going out to the nightclubs as a single woman for the first time in a long time. Her ex-boyfriend Chet was a deadbeat. He lounged around the house which she paid the mortgage for. Dude didn't offer to wash the dishes at any stage in their relationship. He said he needed Netflix, Prime and AppleTV, but didn't have the money to pay for them, so she would have to. But that is in the past. Here she is, ready to have a good night with her girlfriends. In the first hour or so, couple of guys try and talk to her, and offer to buy her drinks. But she knows a scrub when she sees one. She swiftly puts these no hopers in their place. Just as she is contemplating heading home for a peppermint tea, she sees a guy so gorgeous, he makes all other men before him seem like neanderthals. He makes eye contact and smiles, but doesn't rush to speak to her. He heads to the bar to buy a low carb beer, and this is her time to move. She rushes to the bar, stands near him, and orders a vodka and soda with lime but only if it is fresh lime because she doesn't mess with cordials. He commends her for shunning the sugar loaded cordial option, and offers to pay for her drink. He reassures her that he would like to talk to her, but is aware she is out with her friends and if she isn't interested in talking to men that is totally fine. She goes weak at the knees. After a long conversation about puppies and nature walks, he asks for her number and nothing else. Ohhh God she hopes he calls her soon.

Was alright. Ot really my thing but good music

felt that 7.4/10

Before listening: Okay, I know nothing about Fiona Apple other than the reviews I've read on here and there are RED FLAGS! "Grammy award-winning", "jazzy vibes", MARIMBAS FFS! Is she going to be an American Adele and ruin my bank holiday?! Or is she going to be more like Angel Olsen or Cat Power (this would be fine as I like both). After listening: Strong Chrissie Hynde vibes if she'd been a 2000s solo artist instead of in a new wave band circa 1979. I do like a lot of modern female solo artists...the aforementioned Angel and Cat, Jesca Hoop, Nina Nastasia, Kathryn Joseph, Laura Marling...all slightly different from one another, but what they do have in common is an "otherness" that sets them apart. I didn't hear that from Fiona. She sounded "popular", playing "normie music". I can see why she had a Grammy nomination and Jesca never will. Even so, at least she's not Adele, so not all bad.

This is immediately very much my jam. Great melancholy-sounding folksy alternative stuff. It was to no great surprise that when looking up more detail on the album I discovered Jon Brion played a bunch of guitar and other instruments on here... I can hear it, ahh! Wonderful stuff. Love Jon Brion. Have never listened to Fiona Apple. As it turns out, I guess I like Fiona Apple as a musician. Another "W" for this website.

Shadowboxer>>>>>>>>>>>>

Actual Rating: 4.5/5

would not have expected this singing voice from a 19-year-old. gets very trip-hop at times 💥sleep to dream 💥criminal

I didn't hate it. It was exactly what I expected, except for the absolute saturation of vibraphone. So Much Vibraphone. Now, I like the vibraphone, and it works here, but man, it's all over this record. Still. I could be talked into a 4, but I'm giving it a 3.

This album is great. The vibes are great and very consistent throughout. Ar Fiona has a lovely voice and the songs are dreamy rather.

Not really my vibe, but it’s not too bad. I could never really get into Fiona Apple, except for her famous songs. Fav song is ‘Criminal’.

really incredible coincidence to get this album in the same week that i'm reading My Dark Vanessa, which frequently references and maybe owes a huge debt to Fiona Apple... so this was the perfect soundtrack for reading. (side note, i know this isn't Goodreads but MDV is AMAZING. such a disturbing relentless mind-blowing read. and the way it weaves in all these other works of art, Lolita, Pale Fire, Robert Frost, Titus Andronicus, Fiona Apple... just. i don't have the words. it's incredible.) all that being said.... i've tried to get into Fiona Apple before and there is just something about her that doesn't fully click with me and it's actually frustrating! i love the idea of her music, of her as an artist, but then i put on one of her albums and i'm just like. ok. this is fine. maybe i'll get it one day. but i've listened to this album twice today, and today is not the day.

I can see the Fiona appeal.

1.5/5 She has a great voice and I can see what people love about her music but it's just not my style.

No me gustó

Ohhhhh yeah this is exactly the type of music I expected and hoped to discover when I started this challenge!!!!!!!! I've heard of Fiona Apple before but had never heard any of her music but here I am now and I couldn't be more excited to go through each of her albums and listen to her voluntarily after discovering this. I love her voice and how she sings the words she's written oh it’s just flawless I can't stop listening to Tidal; especially Sleep To Dream, Slow Like Honey, The First Taste and Shadowboxer! Fiona Apple I am now obsessed with you

8/10 Best songs: Sleep to Dream, Criminal, The First Taste, Never Is A Promise, Carrion There was something in the water in the 90s that led to a huge number of astonishingly talented women singer-songwriters getting big (often at a young age), and Fiona Apple is undeniably a standout. As far as I'm concerned, she deserves the Nobel Prize just as much as Bob Dylan did - her lyrics (poetry) are some of the best in the business. That being said, I often find the instrumentals/music to not be to my liking; they can be a bit too low-key. Generally I think that when she sings in a more forceful tone, with slightly more intense music, her music is in "best song of (year)" territory.

The dross is strong in this one.

It's much better than most music produced in the same era. Singer/songwriter seems like a thing of the past in the mainstream.