Album Summary
A Night at the Opera is the fourth studio album by the British rock band Queen, released on 21 November 1975 by EMI Records in the United Kingdom and by Elektra Records in the United States. Produced by Roy Thomas Baker and Queen, it was reportedly the most expensive album ever recorded at the time of its release.Named after the Marx Brothers' film of the same name, A Night at the Opera was recorded at various studios across a four-month period in 1975. Due to management issues, Queen had received almost none of the money they earned for their previous albums. Subsequently, they ended their contract with Trident Studios and did not use their studios for the album (the sole exception being "God Save the Queen", which had been recorded the previous year). They employed a complex production that extensively used multitrack recording, and the songs incorporated a wide range of styles, such as ballads, music hall, dixieland, hard rock and progressive rock influences. Aside from their usual equipment, Queen also utilised a diverse range of instruments such as a double bass, harp, ukulele and more. Upon release, A Night at the Opera topped the UK Albums Chart for four non-consecutive weeks. It peaked at number four on the US Billboard Top LPs & Tape chart and became the band's first platinum-certified album in the US. It also produced the band's most successful single in the UK, "Bohemian Rhapsody", which became their first UK number one. Despite being twice as long as the average length of singles during the 1970s, the song became immensely popular worldwide. Contemporary reviews for A Night at the Opera were mixed, with praise for its production and the diverse musical themes, and recognition as the album that established Queen as worldwide superstars. At the 19th Grammy Awards, it received Grammy Award nominations for Best Pop Vocal Performance by a Duo, Group or Chorus and Best Arrangement for Voices. It has been hailed as Queen's best album, and one of the greatest albums in music history. In 2020, Rolling Stone ranked it at number 128 on its list of the 500 Greatest Albums of All Time. In 2018, it was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
I either love Queen or can't stand them, sometimes at the same time. This is both a 2 star and a 4 star simultaneously. Schrodinger's box but with a review, if you will.
God save the queen love this album
A clear masterpiece, what more can be said? Honestly even without a Rhapsody it's a clear masterpiece to me. Never been easier to 5 stars.
4.5/5
I've said it before, and I'll say it again: the best Queen album is Live at Wembley Stadium. That or one of their best of albums. Queen is not a band I listen to in albums. Singles, collections, and playlists? Absolutely. But none of their albums are consistent enough to keep me engaged the whole time. There are always a couple of songs that just do not work (though I will give Seaside Rendezvous credit: it wasn't good but it was funny) and many times where the band's pop sensibilites get in the way of a song that could have been great (The Prophet Song, Lazing on a Sunday Afternoon). There are times where the album works, and it is always when Queen go totally into their most insane instincts, or go fully ridiculous. The opening track and You're my Best Friend are two examples of this. But this album is just not that good. The only thing that saves this album from being a bad album is Bohemian Rhapsody, a song where all of Queen's worst impulses come together to create something phenomenal and unforgettable. There are aspects of the song throughout the album, and they rarely work, but for some reason in this one instance, Queen's operatic ambitions, prog rock ability, and arena rock stupidity come together to make something that still feels new. It's over played, and still amazing. But other than Bohemian Rhapsody, I don't know what else this album offers. It just doesn't work for me. And there albums have yet to. With the exception of their compilation albums, of course. Those are still great.
The album that cemented Queen as the certified legends that they are. Solid 5 Stars.
Party on, Garth But, gawd I’m so tired of Bohemian Rhapsody
blueprint for everything which followed
I’ve always felt that if an alien race ever came down to Earth and asked me to play them one—yes, just one—rock and roll song that perfectly embodies the genre, I’d tell them to sit down, put on these headphones (assuming that’s where their ears are), and listen to Queen’s “Bohemian Rhapsody.” The song encapsulates everything you could possibly want in a rock song, and then some. It’s a grandiose progressive rock masterpiece filled with sweeping vocal harmonies and an astonishing variety of styles packed into just six minutes. From the opening piano and ballad-like verses to the operatic excess, the headbanging hard-rock section, and finally its reflective conclusion, it’s practically an entire musical journey in one song. I’d never listened to Queen’s A Night at the Opera in its entirety until today, and what an introduction it turned out to be. There are moments when I hear elements of Rush, only with a considerably broader vocal range. Queen’s musical ambition and sheer talent are almost too much for a single album to contain. While the first half is relatively restrained, the second half really lets loose, delivering some wonderfully over-the-top operatic theatrics, particularly with “The Prophet’s Song” and “Love of My Life.” Then “Good Company” shifts gears once again, leaving you wondering where the hell this album is going next. And just when you think you’ve got a handle on things, the album drops into fifth gear, and “Bohemian Rhapsody” begins to emerge from the speakers. By this point, you’ve come to expect the unexpected, so you might as well sit back, sink into your seat, and enjoy the ride. This was an incredible, unexpectedly joyous ride from beginning to end. If this is what I’ve been missing by never giving the entire album a proper listen, I have some catching up to do.
“I’m In Love With My Car” is the best song with the word “love” in its title on this album.
Funky start but really liked the back half of this album
Bohemain Rhapsody is a classic, but I was largely unmoved by the rest of the album.
I really despise Bohemian Rhapsody and You’re My Best Friends is also drivel. The rest of the album can also get lost--Lazing On A Sunday Afternoon is faux Victorian drivel hidden under seventies muzak. In Love with My Car is over the top "hard rock". '39 is slightly better, but eh. And so on and so on. I can't take this album.
Queen A night at the opera 3* Queen is a talented band but they never put together a singular great album. There's a reason that both Greatest Hits albums sell so well and that is that every album has a few absolute classics and a lot of filler of varying quality. A Night at the Opera has fewer bad filler songs than their other albums but these guys were not a deep cuts band
Obviously it's difficult to rate Bohemian Rhapsody, a completely ridiculous piece of musical theatre which has achieved permanent classic status, thanks to Wayne's World, although I prefer The Muppets version. And "You're My Best Friend" is pleasant too. I'd agree with the idea that they're a singles band. Because I found the rest of this album pretty hard to stomach, and there wasn't even any of the promised opera to cleanse the pallette. The whimsy is done with no wit, the ROCK is bombastic, and the vocals are pneumatic. The close-mic-ed vocal harmonies - which, on paper, could be similar to the Beach Boys, which could be my favourite band - are committed, undoutedly impressive, but emetic: the vocal breakdown on "The Prophet's Song" is like a toddler proudly showing you an accomplished drawing daubed on your own walls, in faeces. And the grand finale? Arguably the dreariest piece of music ever written - the national anthem - done straight, full pompous, with no irreverence, wit, or irony. It's even got drumrolls in. Sorry lads. Not for me.
Silly album, some ok rocky bits but mostly just mid 70s weirdness, thank goodness punk happened 3/10
Can I get more stars please?
Treads a fine line in places between being fun, and irritating. Like being repeatedly beaten over the head with a bunch of colourful balloons. Musically, it stands unique and not a single note in need ofbfurther tightening. The whole concept stands impressive. But I suspect it’s an occasional visit only.
Way more varied than I expected, in a good way. The whole thing is so destinctively Queen.
Vrolijk, afwisselend, feestje
One of my favorite albums of all time. You couldn't go wrong with Queen.
Spodziewałem głupkowatego plastiku, dostałem świetną płytę
En stark 4! Jag trodde inte att jag skulle gilla det så mycket, det var roligt att lyssna på!
It would be not only ignorant but stupid of me to say this isn't a good record. There are at least three tracks on it that the entire planet can recognise - for good reason. But if I'm being honest, where Queen shine in melody, they lack in substance. Most songs are superficial to a point where they border on comedy. I dislike that a lot.
Despite there being a couple of tracks that don't work for me, this album is an awesome theatrical journey. And it includes one of the best songs ever in Bohemian Rhapsody. A really fun listen. Favourites: You're My Best Friend Good Company Bohemian Rhapsody
I'm firmly in the camp of "Queen are a better singles band than albums band" so I was interested in whether their masterpiece LP would change my mind. It didn't really. It's good but some of these tracks are a bit forgettable (Sweet Lady, Prophets Song, Good Company) or kinda twee/silly (I'm In Love With My Car, Seaside Rendezvous). I prefer Sheer Heart Attack I think
Genuinamemte uno de los mejores álbumes que escuche. No hay un solo tema malo y es tan dificil elegir cual me gusto más, pero creo que me volvi adicta a I'm In Love With My Car o a '39 y a Sweet Lady (ademas de Bohemian Rhapsody pero eso es mas que obvio)
Me duele mucho ponerle menos de 5 estrellas a un disco que tiene Love Of My Life y, me pongo de pie, la mejor canción de la historia, BOHEMIAN RHAPSODY. Pero la verdad es que el disco en sí, completo, no me encanta. Obvio que lo disfruto, pero tiene varias que no me gustan tanto. Le pondría 4,5 si pudiera.
I enjoyed this album but it wasnt their best by a long way. Brian Mays tinny picky guitar was too present. Granted hes a great guitarist but hes a bit over rated in my opinion. The follow up tracks of Stairway to Heaven and Freebird are guitar greats. Listen and learn Brian. Album was fair to middling whereas the other 2 Ive had on this list were superb.
This is not as good as the other two which I've had in the past month. I feel like I got them in the wrong order because this was my least favourite. Nothing really grabbed me, but it's clear this is what took Queen to legend status. Of course, it wasn't bad. That would be objectively wrong. Bohemian Rhapsody is a masterpiece, I enjoyed the concept, and finishing with God Save the Queen was a great little touch. What I've liked about this Queen discovery is that I got all 3 pretty close together and none of them sounded alike, yet distinctly Queen. They are incredible artists even if it became progressively less to my tastes. Did I enjoy this? Yes Did I love it? Sadly not.
Бохіміан Репсоді це звичайно олл тайм пісня, яка проскочила через покоління і навряд зупиниться. Якщо шукати якийсь більш сучасний відповідник, то мені здається це Welcome to the Black Parade. Якщо відійти від цього обговорення, то я все-таки не поціновувач творчості Квін. Розумію їх шарм, вокали Меркюрі, але музично не мій гурт.
Важко якось обʼєктивно оцінити цей альбом через наявність рапсодії, але навіть якщо не брати до уваги її, то тут багато хайлайтів - death on two legs, рок-бойовичок I'm in love with my car, мій персональний фаворит - 39, прогова prophet's song ітд. Не всі пісні мені прям подобаються, як мінімум парочку я б прибрав (наприклад sweet lady), але загалом це найкращий приклад квін у всій їхній помпезності.
não lembro disso mas boto fé demais!! é o tipo de coisa que a gente faria mas é, tem bohemian rhapsody, que é um clássico absoluto o resto não me pega nem um pouco, tendo a achar que esse é um dos álbuns mais chatinhos da banda da rainha inclusive
po mais megalomaníaco e orquestral que o outro. bem complexo. a produção tbm é bem legal! bohemian rhapsody me lembra qdo a gente foi lá perto do boulevard (ou no boulevard nn lembro) e ficou na praça floriano peixoto esperando o onibus, tirando foto. na ida, lembro que a monalisa deu carona pra gente e todo os presentes (acho que eu, o amigo do site, o alden e o recém encarcerado) ESGUELAMOS a música toda. enfim. guardo com carinho porque foi divertido! dito isso, sobe um na nota. bons momentos. PJL pro meu mano.
This album had some good variety and some great songs on it. The instrumental play was solid.
I am not a Queen fan but quite enjoyed this. Pleasantly surprised. Great variety of sounds, harmonies & vocals were solid
This is wonderful and impressive. But it's intense - I couldn't just through this on and relax but enjoyed and appreciated it.
First album. Did not care for it. none of this will stick in my head and the sounds are just not distinct enough. i liked a few song but bohimum rhapsody is the only one i think id come back for i just expected it to be more powerful for a first time full proper listen. few songs i kinda liked but album as a whole is bleh to me. i love the album art tho
It’s ok. It’s not particularly important
The only monarchy I can get behind Top bops: ‘39 You’re my best friend Love of my life Bohemian rhapsody
JL : 2, Bohemian Rhapsody
👑
I thought this was a 5 album. I had a memory of it being so. But it just… isn’t. Still love it. 4 Boolean: True
Not a major queen fan, fully respect what they stood for and what they done for music but it's giving aggressively english in a garden
Say no to operatic rock.
Given it's reputation a little disappointing
zo queen, zo goed
I love it, it felt like a musical
Good amount of songs that I don’t remember listening to. Like that there is a theme.
Very good, but a little all over the place 79/100
Begin by saying that it doesn't matter what I say. So many people adore this album and it was such a huge hit that it's bullet proof. I was 18 when it appeared and I remember the Radio DJ playing Bohemian Rhapsody for the first time and cutting it off half way through with the comment "Too long, too weird, won't be a hit." It's wildly uneven. An album that contains both Death on Two Legs and The Prophet Song is a hardly showing a consistent vision. Death on Two Legs is a great curdled rocker. Lazing on a Sunday Afternoon is slight and the sort of thing Lennon objected to when McCartney tried to sneak stuff like it onto a Beatles album. I'm in Love with My Car is fine, we've got Deep Purple doing Highway Star and Led Zeppelin doing Trampled Under Foot and they are both better examples. But where they use the car as metaphor, Queen seem to be singing about someone who actually Is in love with his car. Which does leave you wondering if a bit of subtlety and nuance isn't beyond them. You're My Best Friend is quite sweet and charming. 39 is ... um ... eccentric at best. Sweet Lady is fine, has a one really good riff and some generic stuff as well. Seaside Rendezvous and we're back to McCartney. Camp music hall gear. George Formby could do a fine cover of it. The Prophet Song sees Queen at their most prog rock and to be honest, they're no Yes or King Crimson. The whole "Now I know" vocal section gets pretty annoying after a while. Love of my Life is another sweet one. Good Company is all well and good, but didn't McCartney already do Honey Pie on the White Album? And then we have the Magnum Opus: Bohemian Rhapsody. Of course it's ridiculous and over the top and "too long and too weird" but damn it, it's good. We finish with God Save The Queen, a but of a joke track really. So it's wildly uneven, doesn't know when to say "enough" and has a vast number of ideas, some good, some bad. But what does it matter what I say? There are plenty of people convinced that this is the greatest album ever to hit vinyl. So maybe it is.
I've mostly experienced Queen through its greatest hits collections and cultural osmosis. I heard The Kleptones' A Night at the Hip-Hopera before hearing this record in full (which, truth be told, hasn't happened quite yet though give me 37 more minutes and I'll have wrapped it up). Three songs deep and on the fourth we get the first that's familiar to me: You're My Best Friend. Seems like the best time to say that collections of their hits erase some of the more distinctly British traits of their music and this album has them on full display. We've got the Victorian music hall and Vaudeville revival, the sarcastic humor dipping into camp, reveling in eccentric English obsessions, alongside polite Edwardian pop and pastoral folk. All sounds like bad circus music to me. I can't help it if that search-fueled list of traits is also a list of qualities that I am usually counting as strikes against a band when they're too present. The Queen that I "know" is just an illusion crafted over time and sold to an international audience (perhaps a metaphor for the Royal Family itself?). I'm just looking to get through to the next familiar banger or to uncover a surprising bop. Oh help me, here we are at Seaside Rendezvous and the theatre kids have taken over again. Is this a night at the opera or is it a night at the high school talent show? Just a touch of sarcasm, sorry, we all know that guitar madman Brian May and vocal genius Freddie Mercury (and those other two, poor Roger Taylor and John Deacon) were immensely talented. They would've wiped the gym floor with their competition. I'm inclined towards repetition as theme, rhythmic density, dissonance, extreme distortion, sonic consistency exploring variation at the micro scale, and buried vocals. Just to make plain my biases: this record is too all over the place, too vocal forward, too ready to pull from existing traditions in one song only to abandon them in the next. While I can appreciate many individual songs the total experience of this record is not for me. Do I want to go back to my greatest hits understanding of Queen? I think not. For instance, while this album isn't my jam hearing The Prophet's Song for the first time and understanding the album's twinning that will unfold with Bohemian Rhapsody later provides surprising context to the band that enriches both. I don't need all the zigs and zags on the regular, but I'd rather hear the explorations, imperfections, and misdirections. And all these distinctly British takes help me understand the band's place in that music history.
Ehdottomasti parempi kuin listalla aiemmin ollut Sheer heart attack. Kuitenkin sanat taudit vaivaavat: jo ekoista sekunneista tämän tunnistaa Wueen-albumiksi ja se ei ole Ohan ongelmaton asia. Älytön määrä stemmoja ja kuorolaulua rockmusiikissa alkaa pitkän päälle jopa ärsyttämään. Kuitenkin, loppupuolen Love of my life ja toki Bohemian rhapsody ovat aivan mielettömiä biisejä. Ja onhan Freddie Mercury tolkuttoman kova laulaja, en toki sitä kiistä. Ristiriitaisissa tunnelmissa vahva 3/5, on tunne, että biisit olisivat ansainneet enemmän mutta kokonaisuutena tässä on vähän liikaa kaikkea minun makuuni. 3/5
I'm comfortable saying this one is Queen's best album. (A band I used to love as a young teenager and grew apart from it significantly). The other one that comes close for me today is Queen II. The sweet spot of this one comes from the progression of the second half of Queen ii that is still present here, combined with strait rock that keeps it together. Songs are well crafted and preformed. I think Freddie as a vocalist is at his best here. And he is, and will always be, a fantastic singer. But Queen as a band Lost it magic to me. I don't feel it anymore. Something about the smoothness of the outcome of those all talented musicians is putting me off. Still. The bangers on here remain. And the little boy inside me is very happy to give it a high 3. It might deserve more.
Queen seem like a greatest hits name. This was fine but I didn't love it
Epic
it's queen. if you don't give it 5 stars are you even human?
I know this is the classic, but to me this kind of feels like the start of the decline of Queen. I like Sheer Heart Attack much better then this. On here a lot of the songs feel like they choose being theatrical over being good. That's fine, but it's not for me.
Some was ok, some I didn't like
Freddie you had so much talent in that weird little brain of yours! It made some really beautiful magical music that makes me smile and enter this fantastical world in your mind. Bohemian is obviously the most well known (and the record company thought it would never work) but I think '39 is my favorite. It just feels so different for them and yet its so beautiful. Queen is a band I wish I had the pleasure to see, the energy and love they bring to everything is just amazing.
It’s hard to give an album anything other than a 5 when it contains one of the best songs to ever grace humanity with its existence. And besides the crown jewel of music that is Bohemian Rhapsody, A Night At The Opera offers a whole range of charming tunes. Old timey ditties, love songs, boppy pop hits, epic ballads…it’s got a little of everything. ‘39 and Seaside Rendezvous are favorites too. This is a Queen album for the ages.
Wouldn’t listen to it again some of the songs were a bit juvenile and went on for too long.
This was a trip, to the opera, with Queen.
Few bangers, but most of the album felt like B-Sides. One song in particular was a bit annoying as they repeated the same line over and over in rapid succession for far too long. Closes out strong, but even that song wasnt very popular until Waynes World made it so. Solid album to put on the turntable on a rainy day though.
Well look what we have here, a British album that belongs on the list. Some really fantastic musical arrangements. One of the greatest pop culture songs in any movie with Bohemian Rhapsody.
I'm a huge Queen fan, so I'm pretty biased. A Night at the Opera is Queen's masterpiece. Of course there's nothing quite like Bohemian Rhapsody. I love Freddie's creativity and the choir sound. Honestly though, while BoRhap is a highlight of the album it's not in my top 10 of songs in their discography. I think it's amazing and still listen to it occasionally, but I think it's overplayed in general and Queen has a lot of great deep cuts. Some of my favorites on ANATO are Death on Two Legs, '39, and Good Company. I've always been fascinated with the way Brian recorded Good Company, making his guitars sound like a jazz band. There's a documentary showing how he made it that's cool. I also love the camp of Seaside Rendezvous. I find the album to be really cohesive and like the transitions between songs. There are some songs I like better live, like Love of My Life and I'm In Love With My Car. I like the live versions of '39 where Freddie sings, but I prefer the album cut with Brian. Overall I just really enjoy it all and it was fun to listen again.
Better than you’d think for a full queen album if you know what I mean. They’re a total singles band with hit after hit, probably only comparable to abba from the same era in terms of pure volume of classics, but you don't hear much about their albums (aside from this one). This does feel like a nice variety, jumping between ballads devoted to cars, typical guitar wanky stuff, almost showtunes, obviously Bohemian Rhapsody, and You're My Best Friend, which I never knew was on this too. The foray into prog was a bit overlong on prophets song, but that said l had no idea they had it in them so did appreciate it, even with the overlong a capella interlude I could talk about Bohemian Rhapsody but what's even the point, what more can I say. I guess all I can say is that I just realised listening to it again for surely the 100th+ time and really reflecting on the way the song shifts between movements is a lot like Radiohead's Paranoid Android, but I never connected the dots til now. Love of my life feels like an alternate cut of “act 1” of bohemian rhapsody, if just for the "to meeeee" that appear in both
Id heard that queen are very much a greatest hits band and that most of their albums are a bit crap outside of the highlights so I went into this with pretty low expectations, but there were a lot less duds than I was expecting Or maybe the sheer aura and anticipation of bohemian rhapsody just elevates the rest of the album 3.5
A Night At The Opera is the definitive Queen album, though whether or not if it's the best Queen album is not even something I could answer. I really like their final album (with Freddy Mercury) Innuendo, but there are only three queen albums on the list. So yeah this one is an obvious banger. Honorary mention: '39 and The Prophet's Song.
I’ve never understood the massive love for Queen. They’re really over the top
A night at the jukebox
Bohemian Rhapsody is of course a classic. the rest is so so
I know people aren’t gonna like this but I’m docking points bc of bohemian rhapsody. The first half Really sounds like a High school play in the worst way possible. Second part is great but good lord
A écouter entièrement,
This one deserves a good, quiet, headphones listen. What an amazing album (except maybe one or two tracks that seem more like an experiment).
Right. Someone said that Queen are a brillant singles band not so good albums. I somewhat agree there are the great singles mixed with some rock opera that dosent work and some Good old days seaside rompty pomp.
One of the 70's records of Queen, my favourite period of the band. Although the quality after Queen I and II was not entirely consistent. A Night At The Opera is of course a classic with Bohemian Rhapsody, but is my least favourite album from the 70's. from them Some songs are annoying like Lazing On A Sunday Afternoon, Seaside Rendezvous and Good Company, but The Prophet's Song makes up for all of that. 4/5
Stellar moments that are too few and far between. A solid arena rock album but not nearly their best set of songs (for my money I'll take Queen II or Sheer Heart Attack).
Brilliant pop-rock. The range of arrangements is phenomenal.
Love the music, complexity, as well as the vocals and variety
Masterpiece. This album features perhaps their most famous song, “Bohemian Rhapsody”, and “You’re My Best Friend,” both of which appeared on their greatest hits, a cassette tape that I wore out as an 8-10 year old, to the point of having to use a pencil to wind the magnetic tape back up into the cassette several times before it finally snapped. It also contains a brutal diss track (I believe at their previous manager), “Death on Two Legs” as well as one of my favorites, “Love of My Life “. The live version of this song on “Live Killers” really captures what they must’ve been like live in their heyday
I’d never heard this album in its entirety. Reminds me of Pink Floyd. Undeniably genius.
cool grand music. especially the sections of the albums where they do choruses and layers of the vocals, with the obvious highlight being Bohemian Rhapsody.
Slightlytoo daft to qualify for 5 stars. It's got BoRap, and you're my best friend. But the it's got I'm in love with my car and a load of old vaudeville nonsense. It's too schizophrenic to be a concept album, it's a bit of an oddity. The performances are exquisite, but some of the songs could be better.
Classic
A classic. There are some absolute bangers on this one. And some weird ones like "I'm in love with my car." Prophet's song and death on two legs are newfound pieces I like.
Ganske så ikonisk, men jeg er ikke verdens største queens fan. legger meg på middelmådig 3 av 5
Had its ups and downs, but the ups were great starting out with Death On Two Legs. I’m In Love With My Car, You’re My Best Friend, and Bohemian Rhapsody are obviously all classics. Bohemian Rhapsody made me realize when I was young that I was a huge fan of rock opera. That song by itself has probably influenced a large portion of my music taste and love for incredibly long songs with many parts.
Great album, not the best but still great. Takes me back to happy days
Melodic, lush, crisp, draws you into Queen's world. Feels like a whimsical "art experience" almost, like Team Lab or Meow Wolf or one of those – in the best way. Makes the rest of their œuvre sound like showtunes.
Didn't bother kinda shit
Álbum de bohemian rapsody. Estuvo bueno.
....
The rock opera thing is a bit too much for me, as a whole album.
Other than Bohemian Rhapsody, the songs are mostly unremarkable. I'm disappointed with this being my first Queen album. As a fan of prog I thought I'd like this more but it didn't click with me.
Meh
The whole album feels like the threads that would come together in Bohemian Rhapsody, which makes it feel like an entire album of recording sessions to the album closer, rather than each having its own merit on its own right. None of these songs are as ridiculous, stupid, catchy, or straightedged enough to be exceptional, bar the perfect Bohem Rhapsody (how can such an overplayed song still hold its own!!)
I’m at a 10. I’ll start by being a little mean to it; I actually don’t think it’s as good as “Sheer Heart Attack” was. It might just be because “Bohemian Rhapsody” has been diluted for me after first hearing it on YouTube in like, 2009, along with “You’re My Best Friend” being in rotation for years, but this didn’t leave me as blown away. Honestly, it might not even be as good as “Queen II” was, but I’d have to really relisten to that one. All of that said, it just means Queen makes fantastic albums, even if they’re still more of a singles band to my mind. We don’t need to harp much on the band; Brian’s guitar is great, Freddie’s vocals are heavenly (if a little held back on this album, honestly), Roger’s drums have a great kick that helps explode each track from section to section, and John Deacon fills out the rest nicely. They’re all on point, as usual. I admire the hell out of the experimental / high concept stuff here; it makes for a bit less consistency than I’m used to from Queen, but when it hits, it really fucking hits. My sci-fi brain loved “‘39” & “The Prophet’s Song”, with the former winning me over on the Planet of the Apes-esque time dilation stuff & the latter winning me over as a prog rock take on the biblical flood. The acapella section in that track is mesmerizing, by the way. The quirkier stuff feels fun too; “Lazing on a Sunday Afternoon”, “Seaside Rendezvous” & “Good Company” are the key examples, with “Seaside Rendezvous” as my favorite of the 3 due to the ragtime feel & Freddie’s charisma just making it work far more than it should. If I have any minor complaints, it’s that “Sweet Lady” is probably the weakest track among any of the 3 Queen albums on the list. It’s not bad at all, and I did like it, but there’s something a bit too plain about it, even against something kinda silly like “I’m in Love with My Car” or ending in a guitar rendition of “God Save The Queen”. I also think it could’ve had at least one cleaner transition, as the album just feels a bit more like a collection of tracks this time around as opposed to a more solidified project. That said, it’s an undeniably strong set of tracks, and while it’s not going to hit for everyone (I can genuinely see the case for a 4 if enough little annoyances pile up), I think it’s too damn good to give it anything but a 10, at least for me. I’m sad this is the last Queen album on the list, but it’s a good one to go out on.
Un album où j'ai à la fois beaucoup aimé pas mal de chansons (Bohemian Rhapsody bien évidemment, You're My Best Friend, Death On Two Legs...) et moins aimé certaines, mais dans sa globalité ça reste un très bon album, fun à écouter ! 4.5/5
Finally, some good ******* music. What a great Friday listen when I was going to give up on this project again. I frickin love Queen. I don't think I've listened to this album through, but I'm glad to do it today!!!!!!! I already knew 2 songs off this, and they're obvious, so I'm not even going to say which 2. But anyway, this listen is flying by. Not even going to lie, this might be the best listen of the project so far. dude not a SINGLE song I'm not enjoying, and I've got fewer than 5 songs left. Bohemian Rhapsody, let's goooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo