Lady In Satin by Billie Holiday

Lady In Satin

Billie Holiday

3.23
Rating
23971
Votes
1
5%
2
19%
3
38%
4
26%
5
12%
Distribution

Album Summary

Lady in Satin is an album by the jazz singer Billie Holiday released in 1958 on Columbia Records, catalogue CL 1157 in mono and CS 8048 in stereo. It is the penultimate album completed by the singer and last released in her lifetime (her final album, Last Recording, being recorded in March 1959 and released just after her death). The original album was produced by Irving Townsend and engineered by Fred Plaut.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Billie Holiday has a singular voice, there is no doubt. However, this album choice represents some arbitrary limit set by the curators. This saccharine, string-heavy recording is hardly an appropriate setting for that mix of croak and warble. The vocal entrance on I Get Alone Without You Very Well, for example, is all wrong - her slightly chaotic quavering is smothered by a gentile, chintzy arrangement. There is a stellar live recording of Strange Fruit from exactly the year after this recording (the year she died, no less), as powerful as her original recording, if proof were needed that it is neither her fault nor time's, but fashions. 1.5 I suppose there was something to be said for the conceit of pairing Billie Holiday’s voice, distinctively wild and brittle, with the unthreatening shopping mall waddle of the orchestra here. But whatever interest that juxtaposition is worth, it isn’t worth 40 minutes of anyone’s time by itself. And it is by itself, to be sure, because God knows the songs themselves are not worth hearing, notwithstanding the fact that they were heard many times before. The ‘Great American Songbook’ is 90% procedural slush and almost everything here is part of that 90%. The opener ‘I’m a Fool to Want You’ is the exception. I was the fool for sticking around for another 40 minutes after it was done. Shite. Great American Shite. 1.5/5

Great album for a moody morning in fall

I love the sound, but not enough variation

Can’t deny it

What a troubling life she had in the final years of her life. This album certainly represents the struggles and the sadness.

Arguably the biggest tragedy in popular music. You can feel it with every note and every syllable.

All-time great voice. Four songs in, and I had little interest. After pausing, I returned later to hear the rest. It wasn't enjoyed any differently.

I really liked this. It felt kinda Christmassy to me but I think that's because my grandparents may have a Christmas album with her on it

Fand ich gar nicht so schlecht. Die Stimme fand ich sehr Interessant

A legend in her own right with an iconic voice. Listening to Billie Holiday reminds me of my Grandpa and I find it sentimental for that reason. It’s also very slow and sultry, and best listened to in the right mood.

Lady in Satin by Billie Holiday is an OK album, but I can't say it did a great deal for me. I've heard much better records from this era and genre throughout the challenge, and while there's some good music here, it's not something I can see myself coming back to. The whole album sounds like a cross between a James Bond soundtrack and a classic Disney film. There's something very grand and theatrical about the orchestral arrangements, and while I can appreciate the musicianship, it all feels a little dated and, at times, rather naff. One thing I will say is that Billie Holiday has a lovely, distinctive voice. She's clearly a talented singer, and there are moments when her vocals really shine. Unfortunately, the music surrounding her doesn't always do much for me. I found a lot of the songs quite similar, and there wasn't enough variety to keep me interested. There are a couple of lovely tracks, though. "I'm a Fool to Want You" is a beautiful song, while "You Don't Know What Love Is" sounds like it was written for a James Bond film. It really should have been a Bond theme! Overall, *Lady in Satin* is a perfectly pleasant listen, and I can appreciate why Billie Holiday is so highly regarded. However, this style of heavily orchestrated jazz isn't really my thing. There are some nice moments, but ultimately, I found the album a little old-fashioned and forgettable. Favourite tracks: "I'm a Fool to Want You" and "You Don't Know What Love Is". The latter really does sound like a Bond theme. Least favourite track: Nothing particularly awful, but a lot of the songs feel dated and a bit naff. Too many of them blend into one another. Album artwork: A fairly standard album cover. Nothing particularly memorable.

A beautiful and iconic voice but lots of the songs don't really go anywhere.

It's ok. I think there's better options in this age and genre, but still good enough.

It gets to be a little boring but she’s so good and can we please go back to mono terrible recording techniques it sounds so good and so warm I love it so much why can’t we do this anymore why is this a skill that doesn’t exist. I love Billie Holiday, you definitely have to be in the mood for it or playing fallout. I sat with it a little longer and this is too boring to give the 4, it’s beautiful but it’s just too much.

I wasn’t in the mood for this low tempo, sultry music. I like Billie Holiday alright, there were a couple lovely songs, the tones and instrumentation were too similar throughout.

Again, I can recognize the quality and craftsmanship. But overall it’s just kind of boring to me.

Beautiful voice but relatively dull/uninspired when compared to others I've heard from this era.

Solo asegúrate de escuchar esto en sábado por la tarde

The opposite to Pantera. So that's nice. I think this might be the only Billie Holiday on this list, which seems like an actual crime.

I like this Billie better than the Piper and Eilish variety.

Her voice is divine! The album tho, feels like one long song.

Great voice but I have to admit to being bored

It is alright, just drags a bit. I'm a fool to love you saved this from a 2.

Lady in Satin review (Wired keyboard take 2 - Post lunch version): OK

Jazz, very chill and nice. good for studying???

Such a timeless album!

God this was a slog. Good singer but damn did this make me want to fall asleep.

lovely! super easy listen for my sunday

old disney princesses vibes (nice)

lady crooner. definitely not up my street.

A great voice but it's not my cup of tea

A signature voice in the history of music.

this album sounds like an old cosy disney film

nice voice not too exciting tho

just wow. truly glorious. it is autumn here and this one fits the gloomy vibe so good. thank you miss holiday

Wat een interessante stem heeft ze. Het doet me een beetje denken aan gisteren toen ik Frank Sinatra luisterde. Alleen dat begon op een gegeven moment te vervelen. Bij Billie Holiday is dit niet zo.

Billie Holiday has such a unique and beautiful voice. It sounds a bit strained on her last album here, but she still makes it sound good. When you’re in the right mood, this is a perfect laid back jazzy/bluesy album

It’s good, but a lot of the songs sound the same: Billie singing over strings holding half notes and whole notes at a slow tempo. Take away the vocals and some would call it elevator music. Billie’s voice adds a lot, but it can’t overcome how mundane and repetitive the backing is.

Clearly an interesting voice and legend, but it's just too repetitive and the relaxed tone makes it hard to pay attention to. The broken hearted themes also get a bit sickly.

Nice one to snooze to

Very nice. Dreamlike. Didn’t know the BH story. Sad stuff!

tiene algo q no se explica, pensás que no te va a gustar y después no podés parar

That was pretty chill.

Overall: 6/10 Billie Holiday had such an interesting and unique voice that makes me want to love this, but the songs get so boring and repetitive that it just becomes uninteresting. Still good, but a change up in style would have been nice. Fav Song: You've Changed

I get why it’s an important album, and given the right headspace I can see enjoying listening to it, but overall just too dated and too mellow for me

Day1014 - it’s just good that seventy years later we can still appreciate good music. listen up kids and don’t lose the treasures

Really nice

Good but I dont think it's very memorable (for me)

Great voice, but not for my romantic moments

A pleasant enough listen before going to work, but they're very same-y and the accompanying orchestra is a bit too saccharine for me.

Voice so smooth it could only be satin!!

This was unpleasant. I remember giving a decent score to Fitzgerald sings the Gershwin songbook (referenced in the wiki for this album as having been potentially sung by Holiday), so I went back and compared it to this album, and the former had two things going for it that were painfully missing here: Fitzgerald and Gershwin. Holiday's voice is so weak, and these arrangements are so empty in comparison. I shudder to imagine Holiday trying to get through the 3-and-a-half-hour slog that was that Gershwin songbook (and I REALLY shudder to imagine me then trying to get through it, myself).

Ok, Im sure this was really good at the time. Probably still is. But this was hard to get through. It sounded all the same, and it neatly put me to sleep several times. I won’t be a hater and I will refrain from my natural tendency to just give this a one.

Man, I am an absolute sucker for this stuff.

Incredible

Review - I was listening thinking "wow her voice is a lot rawer than I'd expected for a jazz singer of the era", then looked it up and saw it was from when she was old (in her 40s) and over the hill. Her penultimate album I think. This was really good. The orchestration was so lush. Love that vibe but never knew any artists/albums with this sort of style. Will almost certainly be listening again in future. Score - 7.5/10 Need to listen? YES

Loved this. Musically, these songs surely inspired all the Bond themes! It felt raw and authentic, and heartfelt. I know this is an older, damaged Billie Holiday, but her voice conveyed every emotion so beautifully.

I can hear the cracks in her voice which makes me wonder what it once was. Given she was not old (especially by modern standards) shows how her illnesses did show. And she died within a few years after recording this. To me this does make me want to listen to an earlier recording if any exist to see what it was like originally. I did listen to some of her more popular tracks on Spotify and certainly a more pure voice on these. Over all I think an album put her due to her overall influence, not as this was an overly significant album in it's own right. Not my cup of tea but I wasn't listening to music when this was released due to a lack of being born yet, so I think I'm excused.

While I'm sure I've heard a couple of these songs during my life, I couldn't tell you which ones as I never have listened to an album of hers. It's clear her voice has aged and is quite mature. She has some unique vocal qualities, particularly in her vibrato. Gotta say I'm not a huge fan of this style of music. Additionally, the songs have a sameiness to them that makes the album get stale very quickly. All-in-all this is not an album that I believe is either her best or one I will ever listen to again, and is probably best served as a historical document of her final years than anything.

Magnificent melancholy.

A very interesting case with this album. First, it made me want to go and explore more of that vocal jazz world of mid-20th century. Its masterpiece-tier contents are in the first few tracks, namely I'm a Fool to Want You, For Heaven's Sake, You Don't Know What Love Is, and For All We Know. I won't have enough words to complement this part enough; it was outstandingly evocative, combined exquisite relaxing music in the background and that voice. Holiday's got a highly peculiar one - on the one hand, it's just a bit harsh and tragic and in this regard very potent to deliver dramatic experiences. Perhaps she did smoke a little too much, similarly to the lyrics of The End of a Love Affair. On the other hand, it is gentle, and she's totally able to bring in all the tenderness required by the subject matter involved, mainly love of course. So with those few tracks, I could barely believe my ears and they drew my tears with their beauty. It was not the case with the later parts of the album. Suddenly, it turned to that level of music which you can fully accept as good and at times pleasing, but you just don't feel much because of it, it sort of flows its own ways while you tend to think your thoughts with it in the background rather than find anything particularly stunning about it. In other words, it increasingly felt like those jazz records which are okay just you cannot comprehend why all those people are so crazy 'bout it. I'm not trying to say that the rest was mediorcre. I think it's just that this material could not compete with the masterpieces in the beginning. And here's the question: should we consinder tha album as a whole a masterpiece in such a chase? I doubt a single right answer exists, but it this case I feel like what I described about Lady In Satin is a little tragedy of its own. But Beautiful and Glad to Be Unhappy, for instance, did make their way to my playlists but I'd lie if I said they were as good as that great early tracks on the album. So let's leave it like that. Lady In Satin deserves four stars, perhaps 4.5 to be precise. I was really impressed about the instrumental part. Ellis's orchestra did a wonderful job with the wavy gentle melodies, I really loved many little moments in the music, especially in those highlighted tracks in the beginning. To me, this album is and offering to explore more, maybe also to relisten it later. While it did not manage to keep to the highest standard set by itself, it was a bright listening experience, and please find a lossless variant for this one, MP3s won't work well, I did compare.

Notable Textzeile: You've changed That sparkle in your eyes is gone Your smile is just a careless yawn You're breaking my heart, you've changed Die Stimme ist so ausdrucksstark, intensiv, nah. Die Arragements sind so überbordend, repetitiv, kühl. Zusammen ergibt das eine wundervolle Mischung. Die Auswahl der Songs und deren Lyrics zeichnen ein Bild einer selbstbewussten Frau. Das alles zusammen ist beeindruckend. Trotzdem fehlt mir etwas die Variation. 3,5 wird zu

Was für eine schöne Stimme, Stimmung, Groove, Songauswahl. Hätte etwas mehr Abwechslung geschadet? Nein. Trotzdem schön

Geht runter wie Öl - aber Öl ist halt auch in großen Mengen gar nicht so geil. Lot of the same und mir fehlt ein wenig Abwechslung. Meckern auf hohem Niveau.

Those sweeping strings certainly give away the album’s age. Then Billie Holiday starts singing, and suddenly that seems beside the point. Her voice is rough and fragile, but I love how much expression she finds in a single line. Sometimes it’s a word she holds onto; sometimes it’s the way she lets a phrase trail away. I find myself hanging on those little details. The orchestra gives everything a grand, romantic setting, while Billie makes it feel painfully personal. Her voice doesn’t blend neatly into the arrangements, and that contrast is what gets me. I might find all those strings rather sentimental with another singer, but she gives them something much harder to dismiss. Old-fashioned, certainly — but it still gets under my skin.

I liked it

I wish they would have used one of her earlier albums, it's so sad to hear her deteriorating voice. Very relaxing and beautiful nonetheless.

She sounds beautiful but boy is this album a slog.

Listening to Lady in Satin feels like watching a legend fade out, and honestly, it’s a tough sit. You can really hear how worn down her voice was by this point, that classic range is gone, replaced by a gravelly, fragile tone that’s pretty hard to ignore. While you can still hear those signature emotional phrasings she’s famous for, the syrupy, over-the-top backing music just doesn’t fit; it feels way too schmaltzy and keeps clashing with her vocals instead of lifting them up. Beyond the tragic backstory, it's not her best work... I would have put "Lady Sings The Blues" on this list instead, and the whole record is just kind of a slog. Everything blurs into one long, forty-minute sigh where the tempo and the mood never really change. It’s definitely heavy to hear an icon pouring her heart out like this, but musically, it’s just too monotonous and drags on forever. It’s a pretty disappointing way to remember someone as legendary as Billie Holiday.

I don't think I'd feel right giving this a 1, but it's absolutely not for me. I just don't really like Billie's voice here. Beyond that, it's just fairly nondescript 50s jazz. Every song sounds basically the same and it's that voice with the same antiquated orchestral backing like I've heard a million times. If this is your bag, more power to you. I'm sure it's a classic album. It just isn't for me.

Looking back over the albums so far on the list, we’ve heard from the big 1950s crooners: Frank Sinatra, Ella Fitzgerald, Sarah Vaughn, and now Billie Holiday. We’ve also covered some of the big band leaders (Duke Ellington, Count Basie), and the early rock and roll era singers (Elvis, Fats Domino, Little Richard, Ray Charles, Marty Robbins). We also heard from Muddy Waters - not really a crooner, more of an old time blues singer. Today’s record was the second last album from Billie Holiday, and by this time her voice was losing strength and was somewhat raspy. But the style was still there and the arrangements were good. Easy listening music and good for three stars.

More oldies! Vocal jazz though - she wanted it to feel similar to Ella's songbook, and I think it does (although blessedly, much shorter). I don't really know any of the songs, but I like the backing music :D? Not that I dislike the singing, but as is the case with jazz, there's no hooks!! So it's kinda boring to listen to as an album. Delaware: Cab Calloway also sang 'I'll Be Around', and he's the namesake of the school I consider the Torrey Pines of Delaware. Magnetic Fields: 'My Only Friend' features the lyric, "Hey, Lady Day, can you save my life this time?" Highlights: The full title of 'I Get Along Without You Very Well' is apparently 'I Get Along Without You Very Well (Except Sometimes)', which is a funny title, but better yet, it was written by Hoagland "Hoagy" Carmichael. Now that's a name. Meet my sons, Blimpie, Hoagy, and Grinder.

The Good: We know what the Lady is wearing... The Bad: When we remove the satin, we find the lady is wearing something else... The Ugly: Lady is a tramp... So, the aficionado crowd will love this... I don't Why? Well, sometimes the missus and I are walking through the city, and we will start pinching one and other when another "forever young" comes walking by... Though I know mrs Holiday had a very strong voice and persona, to me, this album is like watching DLR currently touring, or any of the '80s rockers who should have hung up their spurs a while back. I don't care that this is considered gold... it is unpolished silver that looks like it should be placed back in the musky backroom where it was found. 2 1/2* which i am still uncertain if I should bump it up or not?

How nice was that? Old school at its best. ‘You Don’t Know What Love Is’ hit me hard with the sadness. And, yeah, the sadness I know, which mirrored Billie’s, was a decade old and was inflicted by me. Sometimes, it’s unbearable to face the results of your difficult choices, but ultimately, recalling that feeling of extreme loss may be beneficial for helping you get over yourself. If anything, it reminds you of who you are and what you’ve left behind. We are the amalgamation of our actions, after all. -She was a deep diver, this Lady Day.

Good stuff

C'est doux, c'est chaud, ça sent le feu de cheminée et l'hiver, c'est toujours un peu pareil mais on aime ça.

J'aime bien le blues mais là on dirait vraiment que c'est la même chanson à chaque fois avec des paroles différentes.

Very dated. Musically ok but I just didn’t enjoy the sound of her voice I’m afraid. I’m sure back in the 50s it sounded new age but sorry just wasn’t for me. Best track- ‘you don’t know what love is’ Worst track- ‘violets for your furs’ Although arguments for all for both roles as most of the songs sounded the same! Taking into account its age and the fact it sounded ok musically I’ll give it a 3/10

Billie Holiday - Lady in Satin It feels macabrely voyeuristic listening to this. I knew pretty much nothing about BH but after my first listen was compelled to do a bit of reading as to why this strange mix of sugary sweet arrangements and gritty jazz blues vocals was on this list. And what I learned was truly frightening in its brutality. A woman born in poverty, abandoned by her father, in court at 9, forced by nuns to sleep with a corpse as a punishment, raped at 11 and working in a brothel at 12. And even upon success she is ripped off by her record companies, forced to sneak into venues via the 'coloureds' entrance, chronic herion addict and cirrhosis that finally killed her in her early 40s. And you can hear this in every note. The purity and range of Billie's voice is long gone and the painful cracks are plainly showing, but the phrasing and timing is still there with enduring grace and dignity. There's some bravery on show here. A real trailblazer burning out in the glare of the public eye. Life can be ugly/beautiful all at the same time. 10/10 Best Track - You Don't Know What Love Is Worst Track - It's Easy to Remember

Toooop, muy buena voz

Not my thing.

This is beautiful!

I have never heard a Billie Holiday album before. When I listen to this older music, it makes me feel like an idiot who doesn't know how to appreciate great music. The songs were pretty and Billie Holiday is a legend in the music industry, but the songs were also very depressing. I happened to hear this one on a very rainy day, so maybe there was just too much of a sad feeling for me to enjoy. Billie Holiday has a great voice, of course. The music didn't vibe with me, unfortunately.

1072 - "Here's your juice box and orange slice. Thanks for coming."

This is such a tender heartfelt album. I’m a big Billy fan. This is her second best. My favorite is the one before which characters are similar tone in flavor, but has more standard jazz instrumentation Songs for Distingué Love

A good jazz album, just not really my thing

Good background noise #2

Her voice is much better than Nina Simone's, at least, but not the background instrumentation.

Beautiful, I really enjoyed it <3

what an incredible voice! i don't think i've ever listened to any of her albums in full, but what a joy it was to finally listen to one.

Lovely voice. A bit samey, but no complaints when it actually sounds good.

I don't get much out of this. I can't say it's bad, but I have no attachment toward it. She admittedly has a lovely voice, though.

Listened. Beautiful.

Liked it, but 1950s era music doesn’t really hook me I’m realizing.

I love Billie and listening to her is like being in a dream state. However, this isn't my favorite album of hers - she gets a 4 bc she is her

Her voice is like déjà vu. A fleeting memory from another era that feels so real. It's crips for a beat, then the edges soften and it fades.

Music is able articulate the knowable alongside the inscrutable. There are truths on this album far beyond the words on the page or notes on a chart. A whispered conversation between the foreground and backdrop. The weariness of a life lived taking one more magical ride. This album feels closer to the universe of Scott Walker in the late 60s than the speakeasies and jazz clubs of the 30s where Billies journey began. You can feel the distance. And so can she.