Safe As Milk by Captain Beefheart & His Magic Band

Safe As Milk

Captain Beefheart & His Magic Band

3.01
Rating
23111
Votes
1
7%
2
23%
3
40%
4
23%
5
7%
Distribution

Album Summary

Safe as Milk is the debut studio album by American music group Captain Beefheart and his Magic Band, released in June 1967 by Buddah Records. A heavily blues-influenced work, the album features a 20-year-old Ry Cooder, who played guitar and wrote some of the arrangements. Before recording Safe as Milk, the band had released a couple of singles through A&M Records, and it was to this company that the group first proposed their début album in 1966. They presented the label with a set of R&B-influenced demos, which the label felt were too unconventional and decided to drop the band. Beefheart later said the label dropped them after hearing the song "Electricity" and declaring it "too negative". A&M's Jerry Moss thought the content too risqué for his daughter's ears. This, plus Leonard Grant's severance as manager, added to the discontent. The band instead turned to Bob Krasnow, who was then working for Kama Sutra Records; he recruited them to record for the company's new subsidiary label, Buddah. Meanwhile, Beefheart had been secretly planning changes to the Magic Band's line-up—a practice common throughout the group's existence. The group that recorded the two A&M singles had consisted of Doug Moon and Richard Hepner on guitars, Jerry Handley on bass, and Alex St. Clair on drums. Hepner had already left, and Beefheart was keen to replace Moon with Ry Cooder, who was then playing with Gary Marker and Taj Mahal in the Rising Sons. These and other changes resulted in a Magic Band with Handley on bass, St. Clair on guitar, and John French on drums, with Cooder providing additional guitar parts. Cooder's arrival had been swayed by Marker, who had spent time with Beefheart and had been given to believe he would produce the album; in fact, Marker was only engaged in demo recording. Don Van Vliet has said that the title "Safe as Milk" is a sarcastic reference either to the contamination in women's breast milk, either with the pesticide DDT or radioactive strontium-90 in different published interviews.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

wonderful blend of blues, soul, a little doo-wop, rock, and some psychedelia fuming in and out. Does go on a bit too long but a lot of fun.

Whoa. I hate I'm just now discovering Captain Beefheart - I can imagine a teenage version of myself getting his weed-addled mind blown by this record. A phenomenal listen. The weaving in and out of musical lanes, the absurdity, the organized chaos of it all...it's an album that's greater than the sum of its parts.

I adore this record. Like most Beefheart fans, I started with some of his most radical records and branched out from there. And don't get me wrong -- I love Trout Mask and Lick My Decals. But Safe As Milk might be my favorite of his. It's still extremely weird, but it choogles in a way his other records never really do (other than, maybe, the records that emerged from the Brown Paper sessions). I live for the blues and sometimes "blues rock" can be quite repellent, but Beefheart does it better than pretty much anyone.

4.1 - fucking loved it - van Morrison meets Jim Morrison meets frank zapa?

Surprisingly this album wasn't that bad. I tried listening to his later LPs and could never maintain my focus on them. Electricity stands out.

utterly brilliant debut album. I don't have much Beefheart in my collection, but I play this one often.

Years ago a random hippy once told me he liked his music "acid laced and r&b based" - that is the best description of what we are hearing here that I can come up with. 1967 was a wild year culturally and musically in America and this album was overlooked at the time. But it stands up better than most as legitimately interesting and well rounded in terms of good songs well executed. Recording budget low enough to give this a raw underground garage band sound that engineers spend tons to reproduce now. But young Ry Cooder's guitar gives this a depth that most garage bands lack. I put Beefheart on the back burner of my teenage musical exploration because I was introduced through the advanced/challenging Trout Mask Replica. Like being dropped onto the summit - you need the climb to fully appreciate the view. Then over the years I was confronted by his music through other weirdo musicians like Pere Ubu, Snakefinger and Zappa, and I liked what I heard very much and began circling back. I heard someone once asked him why Beefheart and he said "because I've got a beef in my heart." The world is short on uncompromising artists like the Captain and they should be celebrated and encouraged at every occasion. Now inhale the inspiration and go commit wondrous deeds.

This guy n his band were really out there trying to make some form of psyche-blues rock. Lot of critics liked them but the public said no.

nothing phenomenal here. decent blues but uninspired lyrics.

Review - more conventional than expected. The good bits are really quite good. The lyrics are funny at times. Don't think it'll make me look more into Captain Beefheart but I'm at least not dreading any future appearances. Score - 6/10 Need to listen? YES

This is simply a superb blues album! Was already well awaire of cap beefheart and the album as well, however never really sat down and listened to this - what a treat! Easy at least 4 stars, and the one definitely to REVISIT in the future!

Seeing Captain Beefheart I expected a total chaos, but it wasn't that. Still not exactly my cup of tea, a little too long.

Decent tunes on this one. Far less annoying than Trout guy. Still quite tryhard

Not a fan of Beefheart

Could take it or leave it

Strange music from a long time ago.

Meh. I am sure I was in the right mood when I listened to this but I was pretty bored. It has this echo-ey 1960's kinda sound that I think I am just too young to appreciate being born in the 1980s. I'm not a musician so I also probably don't appreciate the technical abilities being showcased. Sorry but... 2 stars.

It's funny to compare this and Trout Mask. And I feel like you kind of have to, at least in the context of this list. This record is more 'we have some great ideas for songs and really competent musicians, let's make a record' whereas Trout Mask is 'let's do a lot of drugs. Like, a looot of drugs. And then record ourselves doing weird shit.' Maybe the two most different albums from one band on this list. Don't get me wrong, there were probably a lot of drugs involved in the recording of this record too but it's not the same. This one has it's weird moments for sure, but overall is just a much better piece of music, less a piece of performance art. The extended version of this which is the only one on Spotify goes a little more in to the Trout Mask direction with the additional tracks but is still much more listenable. I'm not sure I would listen to this whole album again, but I enjoyed it enough for one play today. The 1+ hour version on Spotify gets a little long but the original 12 song version is just about the right length. 3.25/5

Fantastic! With the exception of the last song, every track was a banger!

I didn't know a lot of Captain Beefheart and I'm not sure I still do. Maybe I'll give it another shot down the line.

Reminds me of Jim Morrison, overall it’s good, goes on for too long towards the end. 3/5

Blues and psychadelic rock that sounds ok, but nothing special. Some of the "experimental" parts work, some don't.

I've heard enough about Trout mask and Zappa projects to not want to have this on my daily pop up but it's good blues rock with that lovely compressed 60's production and some genre hopping.

This is a very bluesy album, doing some absolutely mad shit at some points. A lot more accessible than trout mask replica. His singing is very unique

Interestingly weird

Pretty psychedelic and not as far out as his other album. A couple of good ones, a couple of weird ones and some decent tunes to fill in

Really good blues rock. Sometimes gets too wacky for its own good though.

I'm glad I stuck through the whole album. At the beginning I didn't really like it, I was thrown off by the vocal mixing and it seemed so loud in my left ear. I was gonna write this one off during the first few songs but the further into the album I got, the more I loved it. By the title track Safe as Milk I was fully converted and absorbed. It sounds like they use a theramin in a couple songs, that was cool. The songs got really experimental in the later half of the album and that's what I loved about it. There was push and pull with the rhythm, interesting dynamic choices, and just overall playful and creative musicality. I hear so many cool influences.

Long album my god. But pretty cool sound. Enjoyed the listen. 3.5

I’m not a fan of the hard panned vocals. The overall record is creative but in my opinion not in a good way. Latter half of the record kinda falls apart, I’m wondering if I’m listening to a deluxe version as there’s a bunch of instrumentals and what seems like demo takes. I enjoy the freedom and expression through the record but doesn’t land for me overall. 2

This was great but it does get a little too weird for me at times.

Not a big fan of this group. Nor this album

I was pleasantly surprised since i was expecting trout mask replica again, but the first half was not too bad with a nice variation of different styles of rock. Still predominantly classic 70s rock though, but listenable. there were a couple of odd experimental songs in the second half, but not enough to disrupt the flow of the album too much. I'm Glad was my standout song. Run of the mill 3 stars

This was far too safe - when I hear Beefheart I think of experimentation. This was just fine 60s rock to rake leaves to. 3/5

Were they trying to be weird or were they aiming for the mainstream and it just came out a bit off-kilter? Either way, this was an intriguing listen.

Some good blues riffs with some okay singing and some not so good singing and some too weird for me stuff. 2.49 rounded down

Meh, just meh 60s stuff. At least Trout Mask Replica was innovative and experimental. This is pretty standard and I can see why more casual listeners would enjoy this. I'm glad it wasn't very long.

Not a big fan of the band, but a pretty good debut album. Really enjoyed the R&B parts

So much to like here but too long for me. Selective relisten. RYM: N Saved a song: N

Quite good fun but not enough to hold me attention for long. Not my kind of thing really, and its slide into strangeness throughout the album didn’t fit into what I enjoy in an album. Not one that I’ll go back to but can respect the instrumentation.

Rock blues un peu chill avec des morceaux full instru

Pas mon truc non plus... Faut arrêter avec le rock n roll!

I gotta tell you - I thought this was going to be dog shit, and it really wasn't. Their OTHER album? Dogshit. This one was actually listenable.

6/10 No es malo, pero no me atrapó. Tiene sus cositas, pero tmb algunas partes medio country que no me copo mucho

Really inventive but also frequently great

not sure i had to have heard this before dying but it's not bad.

ik was geheel niet bekend met deze man/band maar mijn god wat goed + interessant

Not nearly the most infamous Captain Beefheart, but Captain Beefheart nonetheless. Honestly, when he has relatively accessible albums like this, I don't think Trout Mask Replica tells the full story (although he was definitely still a dangerous lunatic, at least at times). Anyways, Safe As Milk sits in a funny place where it's much weirder than most of what was coming out at the time, but not *nearly* as weird as most everything that would soon follow for The Captain. But the core of Safe As Milk is really the songs, so it manages to be extremely enjoyable regardless (probably much more *enjoyable* than most of his other albums for the average person). But the lo-fi elements, arrangement quirks, and relatively unhinged vocals make it unmistakable: this *is* a Captain Beefheart album. It's kind of like Trout Mask, but it's like you can tangibly see that the throttles aren't jammed nearly as far as they are on that album, in most every way. There are honestly some really conventionally pretty songs here, and some really groovin' blues riffs. Even if it kind of feels like a stepping stone, Safe As Milk may be a masterpiece in it's own right, of it's own sort. If you like this, but don't like Trout Mask, I also recommend you check out Shiny Beast [Bat Chain Puller]. It's a little more off the wall than this, but not nearly as challenging as Trout Mask, and I think it should be discussed more. Anyways, for the meantime, Safe As Milk is a delight of it's own sort.

More 60s rock. Ok. Not great. Not awful. 2.85

Definitely more digestible than Trout Mask Replica, which I did not enjoy. I appreciate it for what it is, but I can die happy without revisiting that one. This is bluesier and has more structure which is nice. I’m Glad is the highlight here. Overall, I can safely say this one is in my wife’s rotation, but maybe only rarely in mine.

weird! very into it

I can’t believe it’s taken me this long to listen to one of the foundational pillars of alt and indie rock. Way more accessible than I’d imagined. Blues, garage, surf, psych and so much more all woven together with incredible hooks.

Better than expected

I thought it was going to be weirder than it was, given the reputation of Trout Mask Replica--which I know I will be getting at some point. But here is isn't totally out of his mind. It felt like he's got one foot in traditional 60's music--white guys playing the blues, psychedelia, americana -- and one foot in whatever atonal music he would make later. I liked the first couple songs the best.

The first three songs are enjoyable examples of delta blues, but things quickly go off the rails and into the ravine below (both metaphorically and aurally). The more avant-garde/experimental tracks are mostly lyrically incoherent and hard to listen to.

You’ve heard of good cop/bad cop, but have you heard of good trip/bad trip? This album works that angle pretty hard. Some songs are bangers, others bang ears. What a ride to be put on edge by one song and then consoled by the next. I’d listen again… maybe in a less sober state as the band intended I’m sure.

Top album, blues with an attitude

1. 4.5 2. 5 3. 3.5 4. 3.5 5. 4.5 6. 4 1. 4 2. 4.5 3. 3.5 4. 4.5 5. 4 6. 4

This was ok for the first few songs. An hour and 10 minutes later, it don’t hold the same opinion.

#259 This is like a better version of The Mothers Of Invention. "Out there" in a Frank Zappa kind of way, but reeled in by blues influences. There a few songs I like, but a lot that really turned me off. Biggest Hit - I'm Glad Biggest Miss - Autumns Child Hidden Gem - Grown So Ugly

Wonders around aimlessly but goes nowhere.

Why is it that this white-dudes-in-the-sixties-play-skuzzy-blues-rock so infinitely cooler than all other white-dudes-in-the-sixties-play-skuzzy-blues-rock on this list? I think maybe you just have to be a bit insane to make something truly special.

How is it that at album #1006, this is the first of two Captain Beefheart albums I've gotten in my queue? Perhaps more importantly, *why* are there two of the erstwhile captain's albums here? From all accounts, this album didn't really chart all that well, even in the UK (and even with John Peel promoting it), and both the Wikipedia and "1001 Albums" entries suggest that the other album in the collection, "Trout Mask Replica", is the real winner here, at least for those who enjoy Captain Beefheart and his ever-changing Magic Band's stylings. So sight unseen, I'm banking on their other album redeeming their place in this project, because this was a quite underwhelming Frank Zappa impersonation experience (except for the classic "Electricity", which single-handedly rescued this from one-star territory).

I enjoyed this. Irreverent, bluesy weirdness. Sure, why not?

Bluesy, sort of psychedelic, but it manages to sound like its own thing among the styles, decent fun

Favorite Song: Yellow Brick Road Least Favorite: Dropout Boogie

Not really for me

So, I listen to the the "History of Rock Music in 500 Songs" podcast, and he just covered "Frownland" by Captain Beefheart and "Peaches en Regalia" by Frank Zappa. A lot of the discussion was about how the worked together and played with each other. A lot of the music was really weird, so that is what I expected of this, but it wasn't. It was just weird. Some was ok.

Dziwna płyta. Bardzo dużo się tu dzieje i długo się dzieje. Nie wiem jak ocenić, trochę tu rocka, trochę bluesa, nie wiem.

I really like the song “im glad” the rest is fine… but I won’t ever re listen

While I had heard of the name Captain Beefheart, I had no idea who it was or what type of music. From what I read, he collaborated with Frank Zappa and that makes perfect sense after listening to this album. Experimental? but not something I'm very interested in.

A couple of stars for variety, and the one song on the album I liked, but the rest was too much ugly sing for me.

Weird in all the right ways

Just so weird, and I don’t mean in an endearing way.

Nooit eerder van gehoord, maar ben positief verrast. Vond het erg leuk om naar te luisteren

That was a wild and unpredictable ride. Overall I really liked it. One of the better ones, so far.

Fun, but not my favorite

I did bop my head a few times but for the most part felt it was unpleasant.

*1967. *So much better than the other album by these guys. *Starts out great - sort of an Allman Brothers vibe, bluesy and folky rock. *70 minutes is apparently too long to stay on track, so it gets to be a bit all over the place, but you can tell these guys are talents, even if their music isn't always the most satisfying. RATING - 6.5/10

Started out decent.. then got worse..

🥛🥛🥛

Well that was interesting.

Some grooves then like what happened near the end there? Experimental stuff can stay on the living room Captain, doesn’t really add anything to the kupspa

2.5 / 5 stars for Captain Beefheart. Sounds like Captain Caveman singing with Dr. Teeth and the Electric Mayhem, but the guitar work is good. At times it sounds like Wolfman Jack stopped being a DJ and picked up the mic to sing with a random blues band. I actually like the music a lot on this album, but I can’t get over Mr. Beefheart’s (I assume?) singing. Completely unrelated, or maybe related, I really liked Abba Zabba’s (the candy bar) back in the day. The song? Not so much.

Fun. Beefheart was kinda listenable for a minute there I guess. Fave Tracks: Zig Zag Wanderer, I'm Glad, Electricity 3.9/5

Favorite Track: I'm Glad

This was bad. Just terrible.

Spännande att lyssna på Captain Beefheart när man har hört så mycket om honom

The guitar was great, but the vocals were rough.

favs: zig zag wanderer i’m glad grown so ugly rating 1.3/5

скукатища на час и более в ситигриле бы зашло, отдельно от атмосферы америки с ее бургерами вообще не слушается 2.0

Maybe the most accessible Beefheart album.

I really liked "Trout Mask Replica" in all its weirdness, but this is even better. Experimental, yet straight rocking and bluesy. Gets better with every run. One of my favorite discoveries in this project so far.