Reviews (page 3 of 8)
I've been meaning to revisit Captain Beefheart's work lately and Safe as Milk seems like a good entry point (well no shit, Jim, it's the debut album!). It's still accessible, especially compared to some of his later work, but it's got that streak of weird, avant garde eccentrism that kinda defines Beefheart. The music itself is pretty down to earth; some of those blues licks are sick as hell (that's a 20 y/o Ry Cooder you're hearing) but some of the lyrics and vocal phrasings are out of this world. John Lennon was said to be a pretty big fan of the album and I can see it. I guess I am, too
He gets weirder and meaner but this is pretty damn good. Beefheart wants so badly to go off track but hasn't quite figured out how to do that which means that this album is particularly punchy in spots where other bands would want to make something pleasant. Not totally revolutionary or uber strange but definitely tilting in that direction.
Weird lil
The parts of this that work for me work really well and the parts that don't are easy enough to ignore. I'd probably rate this lower on a different day but after a few listens it really grew on me.
not nearly as bad as I was expecting / hoping, pretty decent actually
Mediocre
I was nervous about this, having read about the reputation of Trout Mask Replica. This is actually not bad, in fact it is rather accessible, despite the muddy vocals. But I don’t think I’ll ever come back to it. Electricity is weird, but it’s still music, albeit experimental. Let’s say 3 stars.
Y'know when you kind of recognize an album, but not really? This is one of those. Anyway, holy shit how strong it starts! With the boogieing and the musicality and the experimentation in the first two thirds of the album I thought I was listening to an easy 5/5 if it could be kept up. That being said, it devolves into a bit fine but generic blues by the end. Still, I imagine will definitely be replaying the first seven or eight tracks from the album.
schwach
This album started out in the hole because I hate Trout Mask Replica so much. The guy’s stupid Wolfman Jack voice also didn’t do it any favors. Wikipedia says he sings in five octaves or whatever but I don’t know what an octave is and I think his voice sucks. All that being said, this was pretty inoffensive blues rock, so I didn’t hate it too much. But still, fuck Captain Beefheart.
this was FUNN abba zabba has to be my favourite, i believe. Its so ominous and silly at the same time
This was weird.
First listen 2 second listen 3. Gravelly ass
I just loved this. It's a sound in rock that I always look for, not so many have it, and feeling that they might be one of the pioneers was moving, shaking, rocking.
Kinda cool, quite forgettable.
Começou, olhei pra caixa de som esquerda e pensei "que isso, cara?". Nunca ouvi essa banda na vida, mas achei muito massa o som deles. Animado, voz estranha diferenciada uhauhuhaa. Começou bem, depois começou a ficar chato, repetitivo, podia ter acabado o álbum antes e ser melhor.
Num curti não, achei cansativo, barulhento. Na primeira música eu até achei que tinha potencial, eu até que curto o estilo, mas aí as músicas foram ficando mais bagunçadas, barulhentas mesmo. Achei paia. PS: Exageraram pra cacete no stereo também, de modo que chegou a me incomodar, tipo tacavam 100% do vocal pra um lado só, por exemplo. Apesar de obviamente esse esquema stereo ser comum, e geralmente deixar a música muito mais rica, acho que normalmente as músicas não jogam tanto assim pra um lado só, porque me gerou uma sensação mó esquisita, de desequilibrio.
Bro, this album aged like milk Definitely not my style. I did like one song, but it felt like a chore to get through
weird is all I can say. I won't listen again, I won't buy it, I will take if off the turntable if someone puts it on
Love Captain Beefheart
this album was super good!!
This is unabashedly odd, and something I really wish I liked. That being said, I was not into it 4 months ago, and I don't think I've come around on it since then. It is cool though, respect to Captain Beefheart and also his magic band. If you're looking for a litmus test from the album, throw on Electricty.
An odd one. Something about it made me not hate it
1967, l'année où le rock a décidé de se coller des paillettes sur le fion et de chanter la paix universelle en bouffant des buvards. Tout le monde plane à San Francisco, les Beatles jouent de la trompette en costume de carnaval, et les Doors se prennent pour des poètes maudits dans des pantalons en cuir trop serrés. Et puis, au milieu de ce grand déballage de bons sentiments sous perfusion de LSD, débarque un type qui ressemble à un vendeur de voitures d'occasion ayant fait une mauvaise chute dans le désert de Mojave. Don Van Vliet, alias Captain Beefheart, un nom qui sonne comme une marque de pâtée pour chien ou un super-héros raté. Pourtant, ce qui sort de ce premier album, *Safe As Milk*, c’est tout sauf de la came pour les gentils hippies qui veulent sauver les baleines. Dès les premières secondes, on comprend que le Capitaine ne vient pas pour nous faire des câlins. On parle d’un disque qui se veut "sûr comme du lait", mais c’est du lait caillé, oublié sur un radiateur en plein mois d’août. C’est un disque qui pue la poussière, la sueur et le blues poisseux du Delta, mais passé à la moulinette d’un cerveau qui fonctionne avec des circuits électriques complètement cramés. Ce qui saute aux oreilles, avant même les instruments, c’est cette voix car Van Vliet possède quatre octaves et demi de pure menace. On dirait un croisement entre Howlin' Wolf et un orage qui aurait décidé de prendre des cours de diction. Il grogne, il éructe, il vocifère des paroles qui oscillent entre le surréalisme de bazar et le génie pur. Le mec nous parle d'électricité, de routes en briques jaunes et de vagabonds en zigzag avec une conviction qui frise la démence. Rien que pour cette performance vocale, le disque mérite qu'on s'y arrête, même si on a envie de se boucher les oreilles de temps en temps. Mais le Capitaine n'est pas seul dans son délire car il a son "Magic Band". Et en 1967, le groupe est une machine de guerre, bien plus disciplinée qu’elle ne le sera plus tard quand Don décidera de devenir un dictateur domestique enfermant ses musiciens dans une baraque pour les forcer à manger du soja. Ici, on a encore de la structure et surtout, on a Ry Cooder. Le gamin n’a pas vingt ans, mais il joue de la slide guitar comme s'il avait vendu son âme à un carrefour en 1930. Sa guitare glisse, elle grince, elle apporte une ossature bluesy indispensable au chaos ambiant. C’est Cooder qui rend ce disque écoutable pour le commun des mortels et sans lui, le navire aurait probablement coulé avant de quitter le port de Los Angeles. L’album est un mélange foutraque. C’est du blues, mais déformé dans un miroir de fête foraine. C’est du rock garage, mais joué par des mecs qui ont oublié comment on fait un accord de sol majeur. C’est psychédélique, mais sans les fioritures chiantes et les solos de sitar qui durent quinze minutes. C’est court, c’est sec, et ça va droit au but. On est loin de la fluidité des groupes de l'époque. Ici, ça saccade, ça s'arrête brusquement, ça repart comme une vieille bagnole qui a des ratés. Et c’est précisément ce qui fait le charme de l’objet. Pourtant, malgré tout ce génie latent, je ne peux pas monter au-dessus de 3 sur 5. Pourquoi ? Parce que le titre n’est pas qu’une blague : c’est une réalité. L’album est encore trop "safe". On sent que Beefheart et son producteur de l'époque, Richard Perry, ont essayé de faire un disque qui pourrait passer à la radio entre deux tubes de Motown. Il y a des moments de pure pop, ou presque. "I'm Glad", par exemple. C’est une ballade soul. C’est joli, d’accord. Van Vliet montre qu’il sait chanter "normalement". Mais honnêtement, on s’en fout. On n’écoute pas Beefheart pour l’entendre jouer les crooners de kermesse. On l’écoute pour qu’il nous malmène le cerveau. Ce côté "cul entre deux chaises" est ce qui m'agace un peu sur la longueur. On passe d’un truc monstrueux comme "Electricity" – qui est un sommet absolu de rock abrasif avec son Theremin strident – à des morceaux beaucoup plus conventionnels, presque banals pour l'époque. On sent que le Capitaine n’a pas encore osé couper totalement le cordon avec le format chanson. Il essaie de plaire, il essaie de rentrer dans le moule, même s'il le fait exploser de l'intérieur par moments. C’est un disque de compromis, et dans mon monde, le compromis, c’est souvent le début de l’ennui. Alors oui, "Dropout Boogie" a un riff qui pourrait faire passer Mick Jagger pour un enfant de chœur et "Abba Zaba" joue avec des rythmes africains et des lignes de basse qui vous retournent l’estomac. Tout ça est techniquement brillant et historiquement majeur et on voit bien que sans ce disque, toute la scène post-punk des années 80 n’aurait jamais existé. Pas de Beefheart, pas de Pere Ubu, pas de Devo, pas de Public Image Ltd. C’est la pierre angulaire de tout ce qui est "bizarre" dans le rock. Mais être une influence ne suffit pas à faire un chef-d'œuvre absolu. Le son de l’album est aussi un peu daté et la production manque de couilles. C’est un peu plat, un peu étriqué et on aurait aimé que ça sature plus, que ce soit plus sale, plus organique. On sent la patte des studios de Los Angeles qui essaient de polir un diamant brut pour qu'il brille dans les vitrines. Mais Beefheart n'est pas un diamant, c'est un morceau de charbon radioactif. Plus on essaie de le nettoyer, plus on perd ce qui fait sa force. Au final, *Safe As Milk* reste une curiosité fascinante. C’est l’album où l’on découvre le potentiel destructeur de Don Van Vliet sans pour autant se prendre la déflagration totale en pleine gueule (ça, ça viendra plus tard, et ce sera beaucoup plus douloureux). C’est un disque qui se laisse écouter sans trop d’effort, ce qui est à la fois sa plus grande qualité et son plus grand défaut. C’est du blues-rock de haut vol, avec une pincée de folie, mais ça reste du rock. On n'est pas encore dans l'abstraction totale, dans la déconstruction systématique du rythme et de la mélodie. C’est le disque parfait pour frimer en soirée sans pour autant faire fuir tous vos invités après trois morceaux. C’est l’entrée de gamme du génie. Un apéritif corsé avant un plat de résistance qui s’avérera immangeable pour la plupart. J’aime ce disque pour ses éclairs, pour la guitare de Cooder, pour les grognements de Van Vliet, mais je ne peux pas m’empêcher de penser qu’ils auraient pu aller beaucoup plus loin s’ils n’avaient pas eu cette envie de décrocher un hit. C’est un 3/5, ferme et définitif. Un "bon" album, nécessaire pour comprendre la suite, mais qui manque de cette étincelle suicidaire qui fait les grands disques. On est dans la suggestion de la folie, pas encore dans l'immersion. Le Capitaine nous montre la porte de l'asile, mais il n'a pas encore jeté les clés par la fenêtre. On apprécie la visite guidée, on admire les murs capitonnés, mais on ressort de là en se disant que c'était presque trop poli. Un peu plus de fiel et un peu moins de lait, et on tenait le Graal. En l'état, c'est juste un excellent brouillon d'apocalypse.
No. 162 I don't understand what it means to be safe as milk. I don't understand a lot of things about this album.
Interesting rock music, very vintage, somehow I enjoyed the sound of the instrumental ones
Not my style
Is it typical 60s rock band? Is it a folk album? Is it a blues / soul album? Is it country? I'm not too sure. this album is all over the place in its consistency. it's not fun to listen to. The individual songs are decent, but it just feels like 19 songs randomly picked to be put onto an LP.
pretty good for an old song
I think I probably had the same experience as a lot of people - told that Trout Mask Replica will change your life, you listen, nothing has changed apart from never revisiting the album and live your life safe in the knowledge that Captain Beefheart made art you just didn't enjoy. Well, I enjoyed this one. It made *sense*. I got it. It clicked. There's some songs on here which are undoubtedly brilliant. A lot of them are interesting at best, but now I'm safe knowing I CAN explore if I wanted to. Thanks Captain.
I don’t know how to describe it but I liked it!
Not keen on this. Did not enjoy.
An album I didn’t like when I first listened to it. But after a couple more listens upon receiving it here, I am now giving it 5 stars. It’s weird and unique in such a good way This album has a strange yet satisfying way of being both accessible and inaccessible at the same time! Favorite track: Autumn’s Child
Captain Bee Fart the weirdo you are x
Surprisingly good until it's surprisingly long
Bluesy goodness
I genuinely don’t know where to start with this album. It’s kind of a hodge podge of genres and styles; some better, some worse. Clearly talented, but I’d say I enjoyed maybe half the songs and didn’t really engage with the other half.
This was alright
Maso
Prefer trout mask
An old favourite of mine. It’s a bit of a mixed bag but there’s some real bangers on here.
Unique.
No. 393/1001 Sure 'Nuff'n'Yes, I Do 3/5 Zig Zag Wanderer 4/5 Call On Me 3/5 Dropout Boogie 2/5 I'm Glad 4/5 Electricity 2/5 Yellow Brick Road 3/5 Abba Zaba 3/5 Plastic Factory 2/5 Where There's Woman 3/5 Grown So Ugly 3/5 Autumn's Cild 3/5 Average: 2,92 Hard to pin this record. Some songs I enjoyed quite a bit. Others were really grating.
I can't trust these guys or milk. Like, at all.
utter slop
it would seem than an avant-garde bluesy rock album should sound interesting but damn it's just boring.
Estuvo guay
Pretty unhinged but I think I like it
I…. Like this a lot. Somewhat familiar with a few tunes before. More penetrable than Trout Mask and I still think I’ll learn more as I listen more. 4 stars now and maybe a 4 1/2 with a little more time.
Very gravely, mix between twangy and metal - odd. I didn't hate it but it wasn't great.
Eh
I gotta admit, normal Beefheart goes harder than I expected. this is a real interesting album with some slappers. Thoroughly enjoyed.
A unique twist to 60’s groove rock. This pushes the envelope on the genre, while still staying within bounds.
this was great at the beginning but by the middle I was ready for it to be over
Strong start then lost interest
Listened while in the car, so I was not givingthe music my full attention. What I heard was variable, a strong start which petered out. John Peel was a huge fan while at his most influential. But not really for me.
I found this album so mixed. I found myself drifting away in Blues only to be suddenly woken by some harsh lyrics. Not sure I can cope with the inconsistency.
I'm going full school report on this one. 4* for effort in pushing the boundaries of rock. But 1* for attainment on the basis that I really can't listen to the last few tracks again before I die. And in the final analysis, that's all that matters. 1*
This was a cool album. It is really all over the place as far as genres.
There were some quite annoying sequences that got repeated over and over for a long period of time. That definitely sullied my opinion some. This isn't my style. When the instrumentals got interesting, the vocals were annoying. So it just kinda missed for me.
Not sure I could think of a worse name for a band
Not as abrasive as Trout Mask Replica (still to come in the 1,001) and better than expected. Not sure if I’ve ever heard this before.
Not super impressed with this one, I started at three stars but became less interested the more I listened to it. It’s fine I guess, 2 stars (barely)
Good album - a little dated, but far more accessible than later albums (still don’t get Trout Mask Replica). Well worth a second listen for sure.
To be honest I hadn’t really listened to much, if any, Captain Beefheart before this. There were some good songs on here intermixed with a few real clunkers. I am not a fan of 60-70s experimental music in the style of psychedelic or “acid” anything really adjacent to that and some the songs on this album I could categorize as “that”. But there really were some nice blues or soul inspired songs that really resonated with me.
Weird 70s
Weird 70’s vibe
Interesting album.
Pretty fun
I mean I don’t know if this is good music or not but it sounds cool as hell even if it also sounds abrasive and terrible. Not as epic or insane as trout mask replica but an awesome debut.
3.5
I liked This album a lot! The only other thing I had heard by Captain Beefheart was Trout mask replica, which I think is ass. This album was really good though! It kinda reminded me of The Stones in some areas, way more experimental though.
1.5
Can’t lie, shit rips
Encore du rock des années 70 un peu granuleux un peu unky... "I'm Glad" est sympathique mais le reste on s'ENNUIE.
Never heard him before! I'm sort of familiar with Frank Zappa so I've heard Beefheart's name but never listened to this, quite unique! Some of the later tracks dragged on a bit but overall a pretty good and weird 60s rock, I'm going with 4 stars
This took a few listens to get into. Honestly, if it wasn't for Captain Beefheart being such a critics' darling then I probably wouldn't have bothered. The more I listened however, the more it started to click. Perhaps it's a sign that to do this properly, you need to do an album every few days rather than daily. I can't imagine that Limp Bizkit improves with each listen though!
I have nothing to say. I listened. It was unremarkable.
It was pretty decent.
Experimenting a lot and having fun, way back.
Wow this is… not good. Weird =/= good
Idk man it reeeeeally dragged on and it is so all over the place. The songs are short so sometimes by the time I registered that it’s a new song and got the hang of it, the song ends and another song plays.
Love the names, but too long and didn’t care much for the end
This was funky, ranging from unpleasant listening to interesting and cool. Given that it came out in 1967, I can see how it would have been revolutionary and led the way towards how modern music sounds. However, I wouldn’t choose to listen again.
Wonderfully deranged. I did not know they groove this hard. Now I can see why so many of my faves love this.
Hmm. Not sure at all
Really quite enjoyed this one. Nice to have something a bit different and something I probably wouldn’t have seemed out outside of this list. Some interesting songs in here and the variety helped keep the attention.
A fun listen with plenty of eccentric and weird music going on.
And there was me thinking I didn’t much care for Beefheart. Haven’t listened in years and suspect I was thinking of Trout Mask (albeit I know I’ve listened to this). Anyway’s this is great, the Magic Band on top form with totally the type of psyched up blues that’s up my street. The Cap’n can be a bit hit or miss, but it’s more hit on this one. Some absolutely banging tunes in the middle section. Electricity to Plastic Factory, are the dogs. Babette Baboon indeed.
Captain Beefheart's second album in this project. I was very skeptical, since I found *Trout Mask Replica* pretty confusing. In contrast, I was able to listen to this album. However, I won't be listening to it again anytime soon. I don't understand this music, and I don't like it. 3/5
TBC
nah
Eccentric and quirky, but not really my thing
Weird and strange but also fun at points. Won’t be returning to listen again likely but I’m not so off put by this.
All time favourite
Not for me. Bit too experimental for my taste. Dropout Boogie lived up to its name and did like another couple of songs but I can’t see myself returning to this one
The Grateful Dead’s worst album, which is not on this list, is better than this slop. MI6, you win again.
This was a truly wild experience, and I honestly wasn't prepared for how delightfully weird it turned out to be. I'd heard all the stories about Captain Beefheart's weird stuff later on, but Safe As Milk is actually pretty easy to get into, even though it's super off the wall. It's a wild, crazy ride that's like a fever dream, a mix of a nightmare and a playground, but it never goes totally crazy. It's got that gritty blues and soulful R&B at its core, but then it gets all warped with psychedelic stuff and Ry Cooder's amazing guitar playing. The best parts are the songs that shouldn't go together but somehow work, like the smooth "I'm Glad" next to the creepy "Electricity". Beefheart's voice is insane, this intense, rumbling thing, like a stoned Wolfman Jack leading a band that's super tight despite all the weird time signatures. It's this unique blend of blues that feels like the link between old roots music and when punk started. Whether it's the catchy "Abba Zaba" or the rocking "Dropout Boogie", this album is a masterpiece of experimental 60s rock that left me totally confused and hooked.
8/10… proto punk / blues rock / *1967 👂
Pretty good blues record. I enjoyed the distorted guitars. Favourite Track(s): Electricity Least Favourite Track(s): Autumn's Child
Showing the dullards how to be a suburban white kid playing the blues.
I was kinda wary of this one since I heard such bad things about Trout Mask Replica, but this kinda blew me away with how good it was! It’s funky, it’s blusey, the guitars go hard, and his voice was a bit gravelly but good for the style of music. It’s surprisingly approachable, with enough experimental stuff sprinkled in to satisfy the snobs. It’s not perfect, but it’s a fun, quick (31 mins) listen that I really enjoyed. Really solid 4/5
I knew who Ry Cooder was but never put it together that he was in this band! Love the late 60’s vibe they put out!
Reminds me of some Fripp league of gentlemen guitar stuff from the 80s. Interesting. Oddly spiritual. When you walk while listening to it around the city you notice things you may not have before.
60’s Rock ⭐️Electricity
Hate the name, music was okay
6.9
expected this to be older, but this is their debut. never assume anything when it comes to CB&HMB is the lesson here I guess.
I’m glad I’m doing this project, because it has allowed me to be more studied about what I like versus what I respect. This album is Louisiana blues, 50s soul & R&B, 60s rock and just about everything else they could throw in works. There’s even a track that sounds like the roots of what will become punk. I respect it, but I don’t really like it. 3⭐️
Interesting album. Odd sound, but very enjoyable. One of the reasons I joined this group to find new music. This album is as old as I am, and it’s new … to me. Lots of great tracks led by Yellow Brick Road. 4/5
I like the raspy voice and old timey instrumentals start of album is incredible
milk isnt safe for lactose-intolerant people but im not one of them so i like this album!
Safe As Milk is a pretty weird and wacky album but it actually handles that pretty well. I can definitely admit that this is an album that absolutely belongs on this list as it seems to have influenced quite a bit of other artists with one notable one being Tom Waits who sited Captain Beefheart as a major influence. The album itself has this large psych-rock style on it much like a lot of it's other contemporaries with this one definitely being as weird as a lot of the others but not doing anything too differently from them. I guess one unique thing i will say about it is that little sample from the beginning of Yellow Brick Road which i thought was an ad at first. Definitely a good album but i can't justify giving it higher than 3 stars. Best Song: Sure Nuff 'N Yes I Do Worst Song: Zig Zag Wanderer
I have not listened to this in a long time. A mix of different rock types of the time, interesting on wilder songs but plenty standard. 3 Heard before? Yes Owned: Yes 52/222 (23%) Will I get: Already have
Surprisingly good, considering how much I despised the other Captain Beefheart album. And they said I'd like that other album the more I heard it, and honestly, it was pretty true. Maybe that prepped me more for his music but this genuinely is a blast. It's bluesier than I expected. It also has some inspired moments in it, like the driving bass and drum riff in Electricity which is flat out awesome. Even his flat out bad singing is far less distracting this time, even borderline essential to the vibe. The aforementioned Electricity, Yellow Brick Road, Abba Zaba, and Sure 'Nuff 'n' Yes, I Do are my favorites. Shocked I'm about to rate this so well after our first encounter, but this album was awesome.
古灵精怪的,不错
😍😍😍😍😍😍
Enjoyed it! not something I'll be putting on anytime soon, but glad to have experienced the album.
Just the right amount of weird. A truly fascinating record.
1960s acid/blues rock, kinda. I don't know much about Captain Beefheart or the Magic Band, but the Captain and Frank Zappa were friends and frequent collaborators. Some of this album is pretty good, but overall, it was just OK. I can only imagine how different this must have sounded in 1967. Albums like this are why I do this list. I probably would have never listened to this otherwise.
Parts of this are fun and parts of this are tracks that I skipped after listening to 15 seconds. And it sounded how normal this sounds compared to what I remember off of trout mask replica, like this sounds like it could be the box tops or something
I thought Zig Zag Wanderer and Yellow Brick Road were fun, although not sure they were actually good. Instrumentals at the back-end we're awful.
only counting the first 12 tracks
Too much beef, not enough heart.
Love me a little Beefheart. It's hard to express how out there this album was when it was recorded in 1967. Brilliant debut.
Delta blues prison boyfriend vibes. Similar to other rock faves; doors, stones, dire straights… but weird and unhinged
Brilliant
Different
Some of the vocals really pissed me off
Weird, wacky, but doesn’t quite click with me. Possibly the best band name of all time though
I'm going to have to take back some mean things I said about Captain Beefheart. Sure 'Nuff 'n' Yes, I Do is a decent kick off to their debut album. This is pretty straight forward 60s psychedelic blues rock. I like this better than I thought I would so far. Spoke too soon. Meyer Hawthorne heard I'm Glad and knew what he wanted to do with his life. There's no internal consistency to the songs on this album. Acid rock, blues rock, blue-eyed soul...and I'm five songs into a 19 song album. I'm Glad is a good song though, I'd listen to an album of songs like it. Electricity sounds like a Dr. John song. These guys are all over the place. Definitely very similar to Dr. John. It's hard to know if they just made every kind of popular music at the time or if they were the influence on so many bands because Where There's Woman could be a Santana or War song.
I don’t really know what to say… Sounds like typical 60-s band. Good songs… Unfortunately, I never listen to lyrics and I don’t recognize most of it.
Delta Blues reinterpreted as part of the late 60s California psychedelic scene. There's a healthy amount of Dadaist absurdity and the excellent guitar playing of a young Ry Cooder. If that doesn't excite you, there are a good number of earworm hits mixed in. "Yellow Brick Road", "Abba Zaba", and "Electricity" are all standout tracks. If you continue on with the bonus tracks, the title track is also excellent but it does get a bit cluttered and unfocused by the end. All in all, a fantastic debut that was ahead of its time.
I kinda liked this, which I didn’t really expect. I didn’t need an hour and ten minutes of it, but it was pretty decent. And I have to imagine that it was pretty weird at its release; for 1967 or whenever this came out, I have to imagine that it was considered pretty out there. The singer sounds pretty gruff, and the music was a little all over the place. By today’s standards, this is pretty tame and listenable. For the 60s, this was probably a little shocking. So, overlong, a little weird, pretty listenable…a high 3 stars for me. 7/10
This was surprisingly very average. I was expecting a little more.
ok i was kind of vibing
Low grade 60s British album. Not worth listening to really
It hasn’t even been three entire weeks since I had to contend with fucking Trout Mask Replica but okay here we go again I guess 😭 -> oh actually that was like... basically normal. Maybe kind of boring, even
que puto raro que guauy
Heard worse but it does not really stick and his vocie get pretty annoying at times. "i'm glad" was pretty decent so it's a good addition to "1001 decent albums that you might want to listen to before you die".
Like a fever dream. Favourite track: I'm Glad
It's alright. It's pretty standard 60's psychedelicish music to me. Maybe there is some history I'm missing. I'd never even heard of them until I got to the list. So I'm betting they are someone's favorite band. It's alright. Nothing that made me want to listen to more of them.
This actually wasn't as weird as I was expecting it to be. It's kind of a blend of all sorts of old rock/blues/soul. It hops from one genre to the next. I much preferred the tracks where the weird stage persona/voice doesn't make an appearance. Its always kinda there, and I get that that's his whole thing. Eh, at least it's unique. The range of vocals over the whole album is pretty wide. It's over the top but at least he sells it, and the band is good. This one's a tough rate - I appreciate what's laid down here, but is it something I'd listen to a lot? It's eccentric and catchy in a lot of places, but doesn't 100% gel with me all the time. 3/5
Not my cup of tea
Ok. Pluss for theremin
Okay man. Sure. That can be an album.
I would have said mercifully short if it didn't feel like 3 hours long instead of 33 minutes. Music not bad, but come on. Probably an acquired taste.
This was pretty original and I’m sure “alternative” of the time. Probably at least +/- 1 after a couple relistens.
Honestly way more normal than I was expecting. Pretty much a standard 60s blues rock album. Nothing like what little I’ve heard from Trout Mask Replica
I still haven't listened to THAT Caption Beefheart album(you know which one), and this just happens to be my first album from this glorious, magical band. The quality, and production is terrible(yes, even for the 1960s). There are only two standout songs, and the rest come off as classic Blues Rock. Nothing too special here, but nothing terrible either. Favorite Track: "Yellow Brick Road".
get me out of here
Weird and fun, but also slightly unsettling at times.
Lite långt men många härligt bråkiga detaljer. En svag fyra kan det nog nå upp till.
Faller mig helt i smak! Är ju en sucker för sent 60tal, förvånas över att jag inte lyssnat mer på detta. Tycker det är bra variation stämningsmässigt men de experimentella låtarna är liiite för goofy. Svag 4a
Trodde av någon anledning att det här skulle vara väldigt töntigt, men det är det ju inte! Snarare lide ball. Tyckte det kändes väl långdraget och märkligt vid första lyssningen men insåg att det bara var en omärkt deluxeutgåva som slunkit igenom i smyg. Vid andra varvet, av bara själva originalskivan, är det tajt! Kul!
Rått flum och skitig soul som tilltalar mig. Man hör att de polat med Zappa och att Tom waits inte hatar det här. 3a? 4a?
Helt missat den här nissen! Visste därmed inte vad som väntade när man satte på. Kanske det album från 60taletdipåg som jag gillat minst hittills, men det är inte dåligt för det! Ganska intressant, men inget som jag kände direkt "WOW" för.
ok! upp och ner!
Håller sig för det mesta på rätt sida dadatrams, vilket inte alltid är fallet med C. B och polaren Zappa. Blaha första lyssningen men andra lyssningen blommar den ut. Vad gör egentligen "I'm Glad" här? Smäktande och bra. Ja, ert är väl bara att skatta och vara glad, skratta sig lycklig, inte dra alla över samma kant och dela ut en klassisk STARK TREA™
A nice listen, it has some good lyrics and imagery being created with them. Very 60s audio styles which is to be expected
Well, a step up from Trout Mask Replica, actually can listen to it
204/1089 Having heard about the reputation of Trout Mask Replica, I was a bit disappointed that this album was so normal. It’s a fine 60s boyband pop album but doesn’t particularly interest or excite memaybe i need to return to this in the future knowing what to expect 24/100
Weird. Very 60’s. Didn’t like the singer’s voice.
More straightforward than I was expecting, athough still experimental. Must have been a crazy listen in 1966!
None of the albums on the list so far made me go "I must listen to that again" but this one did. Picking up the 50th anniversary release on my way home from work for the third listen.
Fun listen! The songs and the vocals are stylistically varied and often kind of weird, so you don't know what's coming next. The lead guitar work is great throughout, and I enjoyed focusing on that.
This was so dumb that I was convinced I must be listening to the wrong album. Unsure why it was made.
I respect the weirdness of this, but I just... didn't like the sound. Bluesy rock doesn't click for me. So this is a 2 for my taste, but they do seem like an interesting band.
Yet to reach its fullest potential
I appreciate this crooked blues.
This was a rollercoaster. My feelings ranged from weirded out and delighted to bored almost from song to song.
Ok. Wierd one but I did like it most of the time. I felt that the second half of the album could've been left out as it just turned the wierdness to 11 and that didn't work for me. I did dig the grooves and the first half of the album so I give this a 2,5/5 (rounding up to 3).
This is a fairly normal album by Beefheart standards. And a good way into his / their sound. I miss the weirdness at times, especially with tracks such as I'm Glad, but it's a solid, coherent album without any jump scares, so good for working to.
This is a far more acceptable introduction to the Good Captain. I've always struggled with Trout Mask, going back decades now. I should really just give up on it. Safe As Milk is... safe. It's also very bluesy without all the out of tune wanderings. The bass is a bloody beast throughout. It feels as though it's anchored to the ground. I've still no idea what it's all about. I like some mystique in my music, just not the Trout Mask level of madness.
Sometimes okay to listen to, sometimes a little irritating.
I'm ill, so I've not been able to finish this one. I've heard about Trout Mask Replica (haven't listened to it yet) and how out there it is, so I was expecting something experimental or something like that. This was more conventional Blues/Garage Rock that was pretty good and fun to listen to. I didn't think it was anything groundbreaking, and the length is a bit of an issue. A high 3
Really enjoyed it. Great energy, great musicianship, and I kinda dig his vocals.
"Zig Zag Wanderer" is an absolute jam, and so is "I'm Glad". I thoroughly enjoyed this album and can see the influences and sounds from this era~
A good band that hired the local beggar of the neighborhood to do the vocals.
Çoğu şarkılarını sevdim ya aslında diğerlerine benziyor gibi ama bir şey farklı??
Trotz einiger interessanter Momente – etwa der eigenwilligen Stimme von Beefheart und der rohen Energie der Band – wirkt das Album insgesamt unausgereift. Die Produktion ist dünn, die Songs schwanken zwischen ambitioniert und unausgegoren, und die Mischung aus Blues-Riffs und psychedelischen Ideen bleibt oft holprig.
Who knew Captain Beefheart had it in him to make a somewhat normal album? Yes, the man responsible for one of the most legendary avant-garde albums in music history had relatively humble beginnings... relatively. Quite frankly, this album is still a little weird, but in a way that I'm sure is much more palatable for most listeners. Whereas Trout Mask Replica is utter insanity with a hint of bluesiness, Safe as Milk is more like blues rock with a hint of mild insanity. Does that make it better than Trout Mask Replica? Kinda, I think? Admittedly, Safe as Milk isn't nearly as interesting of an album, but interesting doesn't always mean good. I think Safe as Milk is probably a better album, but Trout Mask Replica is a better artistic statement, I guess. It's something like that. It helps that Safe as Milk is only about half as long as Trout Mask Replica, so it's not nearly as daunting of a listen. I need to stop comparing this thing to the other album and assess it on its own. Safe as Milk is a pretty decent blues rock album. It's got some solid musical moments, though it's not the flashiest album on the planet. Captain Beefheart's vocals are where the quirkiness of the album are most apparent. The writing is fairly abstract, I think. Everything is done fairly well, though I don't think anything is done spectacularly. It's good, but I think you can do better with other blues rock albums and even other experimental rock albums. Still, I do feel positively about it, even if I'm unsure of its must-listen status. 3/5.
Pretty good, fairly quirky. I think this is before he got really out there. Interesting bio.
the back half dragged on a bit too much for me. love the band name
it's a bit grating sometimes but im a fan
Genius, a singular stomp, Dali blues, a wonderful album
Brilliant album!
This is at its core a really solid R&B/garage rock album, albeit with some pretty wacky lyrics and avant-garde influences, most notably on ‘Electricity’ and ‘Autumn’s Child’. However, most of its twelve songs are short, punchy, high-energy and riff-driven (and catchy!), especially the opening three tracks, ‘Yellow Brick Road’, and ‘Plastic Factory’. The notable exception, ‘I’m Glad’, is a genuinely beautiful, soulful ballad, and probably my pick of the bunch. Captain Beefheart’s voice was remarkable, and his gritty, bluesy vocals sound great throughout. I like this more with each listen. FYI, go for the mono mix over stereo.
Weird. But I listened to the whole thing. I was never into Captain Beefheart - thought he was a Frank Zappa wanna be, and never came close. This did get better near the end of the album, but I'm not going to go back and try to find 'the good stuff'.
Beefy
Cooler und fetziger Sound :) Hat mir gefallen
ganz ok
This was not my cup of tea. Kind of hard to describe. I didn't really like the old tiney shouty bluesness of it all
My desk is set up very close to the old stereo equipment in my room. I end up being about 1 meter away from the nearest speaker so when I listen to something while I work, I really listen. This sounded great despite the damage I did to my ear. 3.5
Fun and interesting. Reminds me of a cross between The Monkees and Cat Stevens.
na
Didn’t know what to expect - eclectic mix.
I really liked the beginning, but the ending songs are a bit too experimental for me
I can see this influencing Tom Waits.
The accessible face of Beefheart. Not going to lie - I struggle with so much else - but here I can get on board.
Just okay not really for me. 4.1/10
Ja det var väl bra. Lite långt men nice bakgrundsmusik. När Kent började spela jag bar ”oj vad bra låt” i början och sen oooops…. Mjölkpropaganda?
Hørt om dette bandet, men aldri gitt det et forsøk. Rock, typ blues. Fremstår rimelig eksperimentelt til å være fra 60-tallet. Hoppende rytmer med intense vokaler. Har litt vansker med å få ordentlig tak på dette albumet, til tross for totalt fire lytt. Ikke alle sangene som er superbra, men det generelle nivået holder til en solid treer. Det er utvilsomt et kult album. Top 3: Abba Zaba, Zig Zag Wanderer, Autumn’s Child
Rockin'
Don't get it.
I liked this. Not nearly as insane as Trout Mask. This was just cool, heavier, fringe kind of rock.
Já tinha ouvido falar do captain Beefheart por conta de Frank zappa. O álbum é diferente, bem experimental.
This feels simultaneously a lot more accessible than Beefheart's later work and much more experimental and boundary-pushing than other contemporary music (of 1967!!!). The psychadelica of the late 60s and early 70s got pretty dreary pretty quickly but this is authentically bonkers at times. I don't really like it that much, but I appreciate it. The stuff that sounds more conventional also sounds heavily sarcastic and mocking to me, which is fine, Beefheart is obviously not a big fan of the mainstream and neither am I. But this was a pleasant surprise after how much I hated Trout Mask Replica, although the more aggressively weird instumental tracks from Safe As Milk onward began to wear thin for me.
Some cool stuff, a bit too goofy for a 4. But close
I really enjoyed half the album; rated lower than the previous one.
Ratings: 5: I will happily play this album anytime 4: I may occasionally play this album of my own free will 3: I will happily listen to this if someone plays it in the background 2: I will tolerate this if it is playing in the background 1: I will leave the room if someone plays this in the background My only previous exposure to Captain Beefheart was the infamous Trout Mask Replica....so I wasn't expecting to enjoy this....but I did! A twisted take on the blues that drags in some spots (I did not enjoy some of the slower numbers) but was otherwise a delight.
I mean, it sounds like all the other random mid sixties rock albums.
What is this
Pleasant and goofy at its best - some funny vocal deliveries are probably the highlight. For as large as the Trout Mask Replica legend looms large (still haven’t had that one yet), this is pretty normative. I don’t know, I think there are better, more impactful listening experiences if you really want a late 60’s psych rock record. Of which there are aplenty on this list
Good southern, western feel. Reminds me of the 60s. Dropout Boogie got a smoker voice to it. Soulful songs there. First few songs were really good, ladder songs were not as good and just instrumental for the most part.
Fantastic set of songs that are much more accessible compared to Trout Mask Replica. There is still great musicianship and weirdness to be found here. Beefheart’s growl really works with the bluesy style.
This was a weird listen. Interesting but disjointed. Not for me
Liked this much more than I was expecting. Ry Cooder's great.
Hippie nonsense
Blues rock that doesn't take itself seriously, like Zappa and the Mothers of Invention (3.5)
Some shit Drew would like
Album Review 047 Safe As Milk by Captain Beefheart And His Magic Band (1967) Rating 4.5/5 Safe As Milk is Captain Beefheart’s debut and, whilst being fairly unconventional in rhythms, instrumentation and lyrics/vocals, it is his most accessible album. It’s also one of the best Psych/Garage albums ever recorded is a must-have for any fan of the genre.
This was a strange album. I might have to come back to it cuz I really didn’t know what I was expecting.
A strange mix of country and hard rock. But I kind of liked it.
Favorite songs: I'm Glad, Abba Zaba
As I have yet to listen to Trout Mask Replica, I can't speak too much on my opinion of Captain Beefheart, except that I am extremely wary. This album was a pleasant surprise. Heavily bluesy and reflective of influence from mid-to-late-60s psychedelic rock. Interestingly, it kind of lacks uniqueness in that regard. So many of Beefheart's contemporaries sound a lot like this, ranging from CCR to The Doors to The Who to everyone in between. Whatever the case, it's fun, it's lighthearted, and I kind of dig it. The album's Wikipedia article says that "Beefheart later said the label dropped them after hearing the song 'Electricity' and declaring it 'too negative'." Which is an extremely strange remark. Electricity is one of the jauntiest tunes on the record, and the lyrics are pretty much nonsense. (Record labels are delusional.) In fact, a lot of lyrics on the record are nonsense, as demonstrated by the questionable Abba Zaba: "Babbette baboon abba zaba zoom / Two shadows at noon abba zaba zoom / Gonna zaba her soon / Babbette baboon abba zaba zoom". Call On Me is a standout, owing to its catchy melody, excellent basswork, and subtle use of horns that fades in and out as the music calls for it. Dropout Boogie sounds a little too much like You Really Got Me, and Mr Beefy won't distract me with the schmancy time signature changes. This song already existed in 1966 in a better form. But Autumn's Child is probably the worst track here, because it combines nonsensicla lyrics with similarly nonsensical musicianship. That weird buzzy/theremin instrument is just not necessary, and the lack of percussion for most of the song means there's nowhere to anchor yourself onto. 3/5 Key tracks: Sure 'Nuff 'n' Yes I Do, Call On Me, Yellow Brick Road
2.5
Delta blues and late 60's rock. Not bad but there are better examples of both on this list.
A definite classic. Don the band at the height of their powers - both accessible and weird
You see beef, you know it’s going to be weird
Another questionable inclusion. Fave track: Call On Me
Delightfully weird. 3.5/5
Más accesible que Trout Mask Replica, de hecho es el que más escucho. Aquí está todo y suena igual de marciano y peligroso.
Somebody get me a horse and a real cowboy.
Enjoyed the first half of the album - got a bit bored re instrumental stuff towards the end
Really not my thing
Very odd. Some of it was really fun and enjoyable to listen to. Others were okay & dragged on a bit.
Surprisingly enjoyable
I like it!! Solid 3.5/5 !
10/10 Best songs: Sure 'Nuff 'n' Yes, I Do, Zig Zag Wanderer, I'm Glad, Abba Zaba What a fascinating album. It's somewhere between rock, blues, and avant-garde/psychedelica, pushing the boundaries between music and sound at some points (Dropout Boogie, Electricity). Every song is radically different, showing a real grasp of music and an interest in experimentation. This really can't be considered an "easy" album, but in terms of art, it's really, really good. Based on the surprisingly low rating on this site, I'd guess that most listeners aren't very interested in experimental or "weird" music. If you have an open mind, then this album is definitely for you. Personally? I love it.
pior que achei bacana d+
blues r&b mei experimental né. achei o trout mask replica bem mais legal e interessante, mas esse aqui não eh ruim não. i'm glad e electricity são BEM boas hein
I like this so much than later Captain Beefheart, but I can't say that I'm excited about playing this album again.
Some good, some bad, and definitely some ugly
Interesting music from the 60's. Some cool riffs. Can see how it was influential. A bit too manic for my taste.
Overall: 8/10 I had a friend in high school who was obsessed with any music that came out in the 60s, and I specifically remember him being fond of Captain Beefheart. I heard all the horror stories from him about how insane this band was, and he made me never want to listen to them at all. I've since heard even more horror stories about how crazy Trout Mask Replica is, and seeing that it was in this list scared me a bit. This album, however, is nothing to be scared of. This is just folk rock, but a little bit silly. If anything, I could easily see this as a precursor to bands like Ween and Butthole Surfers. There's nothing especially strange on this album that would be enough to turn anybody off from it. In fact, if you can enjoy Beefheart's vocals then you're likely gonna have a great time, just as I did. His band truly sounds magical at times. His vocals actually remind me of Tom Waits at times. I'm still a little worried about Trout Mask Replica, but at least I got to hear what they sounded like before that monster was released. Fav Song: Plastic Factory
Solid blues rock that retains the weird Beefheart edge. Proves he could make listenable music when he wanted to.
Maan i loved this so much. I miss iconic shit like fast n bulbous, but this one is one of the best records from 67 that's for sure.
Blues to start. I’m not the biggest fan of this right off the bat. Listening to the mono version just because the panning is obnoxious. The rest of the album feels like this too. Very stones-like and the stones aren’t fantastic. They’re passable with a few good songs.
Generic 60’s experimental bullshit mixed with just generic 60’s okay shit.
This was great. I didn't expect this to be so much more accessible than Trout Mask Replica. That's not to say I didn't love Trout Mask Replica. Because I did. But this was good too .
I don’t really like country but this is very upbeat and makes me wanna dance!
Gear: ZMF Bokeh Closed Artwork: 🐟👁️📸 Production (Mono/Stereo Mix): 🔊🔇👎/🔊🔊🆗 Music: 🌀🌊💆 Rating: 🥛🥛🥛(🥛)/5
I enjoyed this record. Much more approachable thank some of their other work.
A classic, much better than Trout Mask Replica
Solid album. Really enjoyed the bluesy stuff. Lending credence to my thought 1967 may be the best year of recorded music. More accessible and enjoyable than their other album on the list. I'm a little surprised that neither Ry Cooder or Taj Mahal has a record here.
This only gets a 2 because the instrumental tracks weren't bad. The songs with vocals were just obnoxious.
ass.
I liked it enough!
As a whole I think this is a good album. At first I just liked the bluesy feel but then it got more experimental and that was also pretty good. Not a new favorite or anything but I like what they did.
Another triple blind! I honestly liked this album more than I expected. Its influences on bands like The Beatles, Led Zeppelin and The Rolling Stones felt palpable. Songs were also fairly fun. Great inclusion
I went into this prepared for something terrible, because I really dont like trout mask replica by beef heart, but this was actually some nice pleasant music! they can do it!
this got less and less charming as the album went on
👺
This was real good, and I was surprised to hear a lot of what sounded like Primus in both zany composition but also in guitar and bass tone and playing style. 4/5
Great album. I really like it a lot, and hadn't heard it previously. I've only really listened to Trout Mask Replica, and I do enjoy that album, but this one is the right kind of weird for me to revisit over and over. I like it a lot. 4.5/5
Pretty off-kilter stuff that feels like it led to butthole surfers later. I liked it fine.
Very odd
iconic genius
Certifiably strange, but also kind of … intriguing?
Weird, fun
yeah
Up until this album I always thought Captain Beefheart was a Frank Zappa alter ego. Apparently they did play together at times. Anyway, this album is great. Beefheart's unique vocal delivery makes every song interesting. I can't wait for Trout Mask Replica...
для любителей блюза.
You're kidding yourself if you think this is worth listening to.
i spose i can see why this was crazy to listen to 60 years ago, but it doesn't do anything for me
Beefy
its safer than trout mask replica and more listenable, hence the title. 3/5
A wonderfully weird take on delta blues, plus some other stuff intermixed because, why not? The transition between “Dropout Boogie” and “I’m Glad” caused me to check to see if Tidal had glitched (again) and sent me to another record. The instrumentation is fantastic throughout the record. Beefheart (Vliet) was high school friends with Zappa and you can certainly hear some similarities on tracks. Hare to tell who was influencing whom, probably reciprocal. Not nearly as far out as later releases, the album is an easier listen, yet you can still see the early gestation of the notoriously experimental releases that will follow. I had a great time with this one. Note to others: The mono version is 33 minutes long because it does not include the bonus tracks. I suggest sticking to that one, at least for the first couple of listens.
Never heard of this or any of these songs but I enjoyed it. Nothing life changing but it didn't need to be. Favorite Songs: I'm Glad, Autumn's Child
An absurd and intriguing album. For the time period, it’s certainly better than a lot of the psychedelic stuff that’s so boring it puts you to sleep. I think my biggest gripe is that the album is just a bit too long overall. It’s fun for a while to have songs of varying styles and intensities, but eventual it wore thin for me and I was ready for it to be over. Still, it was nice to hear something different and experience something new.
No thanks
Enjoyed the stranger parts of it, hated the faux Chicago blues.
Cool
Gross
Good, but not my thing.
I don't understand what it means to be safe as milk. I don't understand a lot of things about this album. But I did enjoy it. Favorite track: "Electricity"
"Trout Mask Replica" traumatized my group but it's still on my 'to listen' list, so I approached this with extreme skepticism, but it was not bad at all.
went into this with a scowl on my face after troutmask and was pleasantly surprised to discover some actual songs on here instead of noisy dicking around. it's still mostly the kind of 60s rock that drives me up the wall, but it is at least a listenable album.
accidentally waded into the bonus tracks on this one (mistake) but fine-to-pleasant overall
Second star is for not being Trout Mask Replica
A good album, I liked Dropout Boogie and Abba Zabba the most.
I know this album pretty well and I’ve played it plenty of times over the years. I got into the album after reading that PJ Harvey (who I love) is a massive fan of Captain Beefheart and of this album in particular. I really like it. It’s such an eclectic mix of styles but particularly based on Delta blues which I always enjoy. The rhythms and percussion is really mixed though and bits far from being ’just’ a blues album. The lyrics are very “other” and often amusing in a weird way. Beefheart’s voice is expressive and sometimes comical. It’s very much a product (and a contributor to the feel) of the mid to late 1960s but it was surely an oddity even for its time. Listening now, it’s clear how the album (Beefheart’s debut) influenced concurrent and later musicians, and in my mind the album and the band form part of an eccentric grouping including the likes of Dr John, Frank Zappa, the Velvet Underground, the Modern Lovers and a good chunk of what later became punk rock. The best tracks for me are the more blues-oriented ones, particularly Korn Ring Finger.
I've heard of Captain Beefheart over the years but never heard any of their music. It's difficult to pin a style on this. Best I could come up with is Blues mixed with some Rolling Stones and The Kinks, but even that's not close. Musically it's not a bad album but I just found lots of the vocals, e.g. Electricity, and lyrics, e.g. Abba Zaba, a bit too weird. There was a lot of weird music in the 60's so perhaps this shouldn't be surprising.
Very unique but has some great highlights 3.5*
Liked this one more than I expected to. Only knew the opening track from its multiple covers on the Lawless soundtrack (thanks Nick Cave). Solid album all the way through.
Okay ... so this is either an acquired taste, or something where you had to have been there to get it. I love lots of 60s experimental music, but this I just don't get!
I’m Glad I listened to this.
PK, bbut it doessn't hold up
Better than the other Beefheart album as a "one listen and done" thing, but too much to take in all at once.