Album Summary
Talking with the Taxman About Poetry is the third album by Billy Bragg, released in September 1986. With production by John Porter and Kenny Jones, Talking with the Taxman About Poetry featured more musicians than Bragg's previous works, which were generally little more than Bragg himself and a guitar. There were two singles released from the album. While "Levi Stubbs' Tears" peaked at No. 29 in the UK, the follow-up "Greetings to the New Brunette" fell short, only managing No. 58 a few months later.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Talking with the Taxman about Poetry It’s hard not to think of Bill Bailey’s Unisex Chip Shop when you listen to Billy Bragg, but as it was clearly a loving pastiche it doesn’t diminish what a good album this is. I had a period in my second stint in Japan when I was missing home and I read his Progressive Patriot book and I got quite into this album and Life’s a Riot, not least as I loved the cover art. Obviously his voice and vocal style can be quite divisive, but I think it’s great; sincerely unique and expressive, although it can on occasion disguise some great melodies. I really like his guitar playing too, his wiry, scratchy post punk tone playing folkily is a great combination, and works brilliantly with his voice, and of course Marr embellishes a couple of tracks. There’s a few more musical embellishments than his previous more starkly arranged albums, like the horns on The Marriage, his detour into barroom piano on Honey I’m a Big Boy Now, the echoey percussion on Help Save the Youth of America, the fiddle and bluegrass on Wishing the Days Away, the hints at a full band on The Warmest Room and the George Martin-esque horn arrangement on The Home Front. Alongside the broader instrumentation and arrangements there are excellent songs, both personal and romantic, the excellent The New Brunette, The Marriage and The Passion, and overtly (and occasionally obviously) political. Ideology may veer towards that obviousness and while Help Save the Youth of America does too, it’s sharply drawn lyrics remain very apposite, and There is Power in a Union is truly heartfelt and sincere, with excellently spiky guitar. I really like how the lyrics about Soviet Shipyards and Hammersmith Hotels sit with that Americana sound on Wishing the Days Away (pointing ahead to the Mermaid Avenue albums). But my favourite is Levi Stubb’s Tears, perhaps his best known song alongside A New England, a superb, forlorn journey through someone’s life, with the only comfort being the Four Tops. It’s between a 4 and 5, but I’ll stick with a high 4 as it’s probably not my favourite album of his. 💧💧💧💧 Playlist submission: Levi Stubbs Tears
What to say about Talking With the Taxman? Not a bad album, not a great album. A couple decent English folk rock songs. Nothing overly special but also worked for some background listening. The accent does some of the heavy lifting as I think otherwise it would be pretty forgettable. I've heard the name Billy Bragg in the past but didn't know anything about him as an artist. Seems like he flirted on the fringes of the punk rock protest scene and had a decent career so props to him I guess. Decent album but nothing to revisit down the line. I wouldn't turn off a Billy Bragg song if I ran into him again in the wild. 2.65 stars
I recognize the first song but don’t remember it completely. I like the opener. On the third track. This sounds like every British alternative band from the 80s. Elements of the Smiths and the Cure. I don’t think I could tell these bands apart if you played the non-hits back to back. “There is power in a union” is phenomenal. These songs are sparse and massive at the same time. I really like “ideology”. This is a great song. Track five is great too. I’m really digging this now. I love the piano on track 6. I’m a fan now. I’m really enjoying this record.
I actually enjoyed this album much more than I thought I would. It’s a hard sell on a less than stellar mix of a single vocalist with a guitar, but I found myself engaging with the content of the lyrics more than anything else. I will happily listen to someone perform songs about the importance of unionizing. Make them catchy enough and the idea might just catch on.
Billy Bragg is a bloke that writes some no bollocks tunes. Talking with the Taxman is poetic at times, no bangers but an engaging listen. Its got some bluesiness and folkiness. String heavy with very little percussion. Good use of violin on "Train Train" and horns on "The Marriage" (top track, tend to agree but I'm scorned). Bragg is like a way better Morrisey. Also reminds me of a British Tim Kasher. Interesting one from the list that gets better the more you listen. I'm not completely taken by Billy but will keep this album in my cue for a revisit. 2.9 stars for peaking and keeping my interest.
I was putting off listening to this because I thought I didn't like Billy Bragg, but it was very good
I feel like this would be my favorite album if I was a young British boy in the 80s. However, I am not that. Jokes aside, I really liked this album! Love his vocal delivery and instrumentation. The songwriting left a little to be desired but the back half was much better than the front. Fun experience.
I'm not sure I get it but I don't think I'm supposed to.
Ok
6/10
It is really good thats all i can say...
I enjoyed the album. A couple of songs I listened to more than once: "Greetings To The New Brunette", "Help Save The Youth Of America" and "Home Front". While at times the music doesn't fit the lyrics, I figured that that's Billy Bragg's brand of irony. "Ideology", for example, has a happy guitar part (in E-major) backing up lyrics that expose the political elite's deception and domination of ordinary working people, who blithely vote incumbents back into office expecting something better over the next term. Sound familiar? Overall, most songs are thoughtful and passionate, while others are perhaps too wry for their own good.
I thought I would like this more, prefer the album he did with Wilco. 2.8
I enjoyed this, but I suspect I’ll enjoy it more on repeat listens. I’m not the type of guy that wants drums in every song, but some of the instrumentation here left me feeling their absence. Everything else about this was very good, though!
Fist time listening to a whole Billy Bragg album, apart from Mermaid Avenue. Not bad
nice
p550. 1986. 3 stars. Decent collection of songs, let down by his estuary accent and strong left wing opinions. Not sure it needs to be on the list.
Dit doet me gelijk heel erg denken aan Frank Turner: eigenlijk een (skate/punk)rocker, die liedjes akoestisch gaat brengen. Maar wel lekker uptempo, waardoor het niet gezapig wordt. Want daar hadden ze in de jaren 80 en 90 ook wel een handje van, dat alles tergend traag gemaakt werd. Eva Cassidy noem ik maar weer eens. Niet alle liedjes zijn even interessant, soms is het geluid iets te kaal. Sowieso moet zijn stem veel van de muziek dragen, maar dat vind ik in dit geval niet zo'n probleem, want ik vind het wel tof. Ik mis toch een klein drumstel af en toe denk ik. Er hoeft geen 80s reverb op te zitten, maar gewoon ter ondersteuning en begeleiding had al genoeg geweest. Ik gaf Billy Bragg eerder al eens een 4, al kan ik me niks meer van die muziek herinneren, dus dat was wel een vrij positieve 4. Ik neig eigenlijk weer daarheen, al zal ik hier over een jaar waarschijnlijk ook weinig herinneringen aan hebben. En aangezien ik de vorige keer al een bonuspunt heb uitgedeeld, hou ik het deze keer op 3 sterretjes.
Great album
I knew nothing about Billy Bragg going in. It was a pleasant surprise. I even enjoyed disc two despite containing alternate or instrumental versions of the first album.
Раздражающая музыка
I quite liked it. More than the other Billy Bragg album on this list.
this has so many things that I usually hate but I actually don't.
I hadn't heard of this guy before, and thought he was some punker doing a solo album with his electric guitar. Looking him up, I was pleased to learn the history of his music having some real weight to it when he wrote a bunch of protest songs for the UK miner's strikes in the 80s. Dude put his money where his mouth was.
Cool guy, okay album, hour too long, often a snore, even if lyrically interesting. Curious why some UK singers sound so British and then some you couldn’t even tell…which one is trying harder?
Turns out not all singer/songwriters are bad!
meh
Um country gostosinho enquanto se toma uma cervejinha.
Completely in line with my broadly lukewarm feelings about Billy Bragg
I was so excited to get this album. Love, love, love Billy Bragg. Love this album.
As always, Billy has put forth a rich tapestry of alternative Americana.
Great album! Good writing and some solid protest songs.
Almost offensively British Best Song: There is Power in a Union Rating: 7/10 Stars: 4
4 out of 5. This album is a fun listen. I knew he was inspired by The Clash and I can hear it.
"Unremarkable" was the only word I could think of after listening. However, after reading some of the other reviews, I guess you had to be there.
No no
Billy Billy Billy
Somewhat better than I expected.
Not really my cup of tea, even if I appreciate his political stance
One of the main joys of this project is being forced to focus on entire albums in one sitting. I have no good reason for not connecting with this one earlier. I've heard some of these songs before, liked them, generally liked Billy Bragg and loved Mermaid Avenue. So again, no excuse. The album is fantastic, with standouts like Greetings to the New Brunette, Levi Stubbs' Tears, There is Power in a Union, and others--a wonderful listen from start to finish. In fact, the final stretch of the Warmest Room and the Home Front is one of the best.
I'm not a fan at all, sorry to say. I like the idea of this activist poet telling it like it is, but I find it so fucking boring he's not exactly winning me over. The guitar parts are just the same tinny gentle strum throughout. There's a bit of additional instrumentation but it's not exactly popping. I don't like his singing style at all. The whole thing is just painful.
Never heard of Billy Bragg, but I can see him buskin’ his style of Brit folk on some street corner in London because that sounds exactly like what he’s doing. There’s no doubt he can strum a guitar, but it’s song topics that get him on The 1001 Must Hear List; Ideology, There Is Power in a Union, Help Save the Youth of America, The Home Front, and Deportes for example. (2.86*s) I’m betting his long term ex was a brunette named Shirley that worked as a nurse.
Música de protesta en inglés, no me identifico.
I need to listen to more Billy Bragg as I loved this. I think I only really know his debut album. Some great tracks on this album - I love his delivery and the emotion he can convey and depth of the lyrics.
2.5 Like if Wallace from Wallace and Gromit was a singer and also your perpetually drunk pub regular uncle
An amazing social activist album in the vane of Woody Guthrie, but with stylings adjacent to Elvis Costello. Full throated and proud, this album also has some fun music. I knew I liked Billy Bragg, now I like him more.
Tedious 1980s English folk songs that condescends. Not a fan of the lyrics or the vocal recording and mixing. The voice itself is not bad, but the recording and mixing makes it feel like I am listening to him through a NyQuil fueled haze. I don't enjoy many of Bragg's musical influences, so it is no surprise that I was not enamored with this effort. He picked up all the worst recording and performance traits of Costello. Feels like typical British overrating of one their own artists and that it really doesn't belong on the list. If I am I going to pick a great English folk artist from the 70s-80s period that is not on the list it would be Roger Whittaker. Personally I would choose his 1975 album THE LAST FAREWELL over this Billy Bragg trite. It is clear that Dimery and fellow editors are trying to engage in a bit of musical historical retcon that is dishonest. This list should be a list of essential albums that helps a new listener understand the musically evolved in each decade and led to later decades. Not a wishlist of what music journalists wish were important albums but never really were. Better quality essential albums (and just happen to be popular at the same time) in no particular order from 1986 that are not on the list: Ozzy Osbourne - THE ULTIMATE SIN Steve Winwood - BACK IN THE LIFE Queen - A KIND OF MAGIC Genesis - INVISIBLE TOUCH Madonna - TRUE BLUE Van Halen - 5150 Bon Jovi - SLIPPERY WHEN WET Janet Jackson - CONTROL
This was woeful, as I expected it to be.
I just can't. He's probably a folk hero from a grim time in British society, but I don't have the stomach for this.
The vocals on this album immediately remind me of Morrissey—not simply because he’s British, but because they share that same dull, bland, and vocal delivery. From a pure songwriting standpoint, I really respect what Billy Bragg is doing here. His lyricism and themes are sharp, grounded, and refreshing, completely avoiding the cliché love song tropes you hear everywhere else in pop and rock. However, the execution falls short vocal-wise. The flat vocal delivery fails to bring those strong lyrics to their full potential, which makes the album feel a bit disappointing. Because the core writing and thematic depth are genuinely good despite the dry vocal performance, I feel it deserves the exact same score I gave Morrissey's Viva Hate. There are certainly good individual tracks scattered throughout, but the lack of dynamic vocal expression keeps it from being a record I'll feel the urge to throw on repeat. Will I listen to this album again? No. Nice job on the themes and the lyrics, but it lacks the replay pull. Will I recommend this album? Yes. There are good songs here and the songwriting is worth hearing; it's just not an album I'll listen to again personally. Will I recommend this album? Yes. I mean there are good songs here. It's just not the album I'll listen to again.
top man
Heel apart - het is de typische jarentachtigbandjesmuziek, maar dan van één gast solo. Met minimale bezetting, meestal alleen hijzelf, of met één instrument op de achtergrond. Je zou zeggen, strikt genomen is het een singer-songwriter, maar dan niet van het bedachtzame soort dat we gewend zijn. Het is bandjesmuziek, maar dan opgenomen op die ene dag dat de rest van de band in de kroeg zat. En daardoor klinkt het best uniek, en fris bovendien. Folky ook, bij vlagen. 'The difficult third album', vermeldt de hilarische. Moeilijk om naar te luisteren in ieder geval niet.
Folk punk noemt wiki dit. Dan denk ik aan bands als Flogging Molly. Maar, al hebben nummers als 'There is power in the union' daar heus wel wat van, dat is niet de kern van wat we voorgeschoteld krijgen. Want, al is het door het volle geluid soms nauwelijks voor te stellen, dit is slechts één man met zijn gitaar. Blijkbaar kunnen de producers toveren met geluid. Ondanks het volle geluid zijn dit vaak echte folk-liedjes, waarin de man met zijn gitaar zijn verhaal vertelt, zijn emotie overbrengt of een boodschap brengt. Als je dit album luistert, wordt het andere album met de band Wilco helemaal overbodig. Nee, ik ga dit niet nog eens aanzetten. Dit is mijn genre niet. Maar ik laat dit voorbeeld voor al die saaie folkartiesten ook niet zitten met een vergeetbare 3.
Love BB, and prefer his love songs, absolute poetry
I didn't buy this when it came out but I did hoover up all Billy's early stuff shortly after graduating. I loved it then and I love it still. The reviews here from certain, obvious Americans are only worthy of contempt.
I don't mind his voice. The lyrics are solid. But honestly it sounds like he's singing from a different room to the band. This should be lyrics/vocals forward, but instead the band are drowning him out with heavily chorused jangle. I expected to like this more but I'm dropping a star because the production is not just dated, it's damaging. I expect I'd like some of his "a voice and a guitar" stuff more than I did this, but I didn't like this.
A very good album with some great tunes and an even better name.
Nopedy nope nope. So bored of his voice. Nothing inspiring at all.
4.4 The more things change, Billy, the more things stay the same....
Took me a while to get used to his voice (it's a bit more obvious in this record than Mermaid Avenue), but this is pretty good stuff. Favourite tracks: The Marriage, Levi Stubbs' Tears, The Passion.
No es de mi gusto, muy country yankee. Sonaba bien pero no creo que lo vuelva a escuchar.
Some good parts. Some entirely too long parts. Feel like I don’t know enough about 1980s British politics.
Liked this more than I expected! The lyrics are just incredible. I loved how the romantic songs were still political, and the political songs were still romantic. The two themes of the album forever intertwined.
...sure? I don't know what to think of this one.
Talking with the Wilco Man about Anger
This guy might as well have been a British version of Elvis Costello. Just sounded so forced and unenjoyable.
Kind of a fun album. Upper 3s but didn't get itself higher. I loved "Looking For Another Girl" and especially the Kirsty McCall cover of it, so I had high hopes and expectations. It was good but didn't rise to what I hoped it could be. I'm not angry, I'm just disappointed, Billy.
Still a Marxist.
BB is better with a small band IMO.
More like it
Alright, he sings wiv a British accent. What else can I say? Not really my cup of tea.
"Greetings to the New Brunette" is a soaring jangle pop opener (written by Johnny Marr [because of course!]) that should have been a bigger hit and probably would have been without Bragg's exaggerated accent. The rest of the album waxes a bit too political for me, what with the neoliberalness of songs like the Dylan cover "Ideology," but he has a powerful voice, and his stripped-back drumless approach makes for a "live" feeling to the album despite it being a studio release.
Boring music and super preachy? Sign me up I’ll say the music itself is far from offensive for the most part and doesn’t really bother me. I like how it doesn’t fully commit to folk sound but rather uses a combination of genres to make it work. Variety isn’t awful As always with that really annoying overly British singing style, it’d be better if sung by someone else. Frustrating because there are absolutely songs on here where he sings normally and it’s just straight up better. I get what the guys going for message wise but I think the way he conveys them is really unappealing and uncreative A lot of 90s rap has strong political messaging, but it does it through the lens of personal experience and just conveys those feelings they’re feeling a lot better. I just got none of that from Bragg and it results in an uninspired snoozer of an album
Appalling. This is the kind of 'political' protest that only exists to virtue-signal rather than change anything. It's the kind of music you can listen to to get mad at a hateful image of a group of people in your mind instead of doing anything meaningful. Fucking garbage. And the music is milquetoast ass, too.
Punk?
Not bad for a folksy album. 2.5⭐️
Some good songs, nice listen, bit long
This is a real head scratcher. I don't dislike this album. Bragg's voice and accent don't do much for me at all and queuing up the first track I was instantly afraid I was going to have to endure 1 hour of it, and those fears were mostly warranted. I was surprised to find this is from 2006 as it feels like the sort of folksy message heavy music of the 60s and 70s. Feels a lot like someone trying to have something to say, but not being adroit enough to package it in verse that does anything other than cudgel the listener with his bullet pointed list. The amount of plays logged on this 20 year old album is somewhat indicative of its significance. How did this make the cut? Further indication of the list makers penchant for anything British to the exclusion of good taste, or validity. Two stars for putting it among a list of essentials. Three stars had I encountered it organically in the wild.
I liked this more than I expected to. It sounds like The Clash and The Smiths got together with some old-fashioned music hall veterans, with some very clever (and Right Bri'ish) lyrics on top.
Actually a bit enjoyable. But nothing special. 5/10
I appreciate his vocal approach. Very unique. Unfortunately, not much else grabbed me about this except for the political commentary. The songs themselves are rather messy, not structured super well, meandering. The record gets tiring fairly quickly, despite not even being that long. What is unique singing with a charming accent quickly turns into irritating whining.
Solidarity brother, truly an irritating voice though.
Targeting Omaha for no reason
I listened to Mermaid Avenue a couple of years ago and I instantly became a Wilco fan, but I wasn't particularly impressed with Billy Bragg's performance, so this is the first time I'm listening to one of his albums. I'm still not the biggest fan, but this is decent. A couple of really great songs bogged down by a bunch of mediocre ones. Not much more to say. Favourite track: Levi Stubbs' Tears
Työläis lauluja ja kansallis
I can get down with a bit of punk, I can get down with a bit of folk. The combination is not quite the marrige one might imagine, but I am still enjoying it well enough. It takes a bit of active listening,
BB. The British Boss. Or BB for short.
This dude is so aggressively British it makes it hard to pay attention to what he’s saying. Like surely he has to be putting this on thick right? Idk not a fan
Another album ruined by the vocals!
Welp I guessed this guy was Irish due to the semi-political nature of his songs but he’s British. While there is nothing wrong with his music, it is boring and repetitive and not for me.
I liked this. He has a good sense of melody and a cool folk/punk sound. Frank Turner surely took a lot of influence from this sound and I also like him.
I enjoyed a lot of the instrumentation on this album, but man, that guys singing voice really got to me after a while. This may have been better if he had asked someone else to sing.
1986 folk punk Greetings to the new brunette Ideology Honey i'm a big boy now Help save the youth of america
I thought it would be worse, it's actually not bad.
I think I had higher hopes for this
Not a bad singer/songwriter album by Billy Bragg. I didn't find his voice grating unlike many other reviewers on here, and I appreciated the working-class spirit, even if the political lyrics were a bit basic and unsubtle. Not sure it's an album you MUST HEAR BEFORE YOU DIE but I generally enjoyed it, and definitely found it more interesting than the album he did with Wilco.
One of Britain’s best songwriters who doesn’t get the kudos he deserves, probably because he’s overtly political. Levi Stubbs’ tears is one of my top songs of all time.
Not really a fan - a lot of the album feels like he forgot to write actual music for the album and his voice grates heavily. Quite a few nice folky moments
Divided. Didn’t love it but also didn’t hate it. Probably wouldn’t come back but a few solid songs.
Un disco muy original. Interesante y diferente