Out of Step by Minor Threat

Out of Step

Minor Threat

2.95
Rating
23576
Votes
1
12%
2
24%
3
32%
4
23%
5
10%
Distribution

Album Summary

Out of Step is the sole studio album by American hardcore punk band Minor Threat. It was released on 45 RPM vinyl in April 1983 through Dischord Records. Although Out of Step has only been released on CD in limited quantities, it has been repressed on vinyl as recently as 2010, and all tracks from the album are available on Minor Threat's 1989 compilation album Complete Discography. It is considered as an elementary piece of the punk rock (specifically hardcore punk) genre and has been cited by many critics and magazines as one of the best progressions for the history of rock music, which specifically helped shape the path of many genres of underground musical currents (alternative music). Its influence is notorious in future bands that would boost the youth crew movement, also in other genres such as grunge, post-hardcore, 90's skate punk and thrash metal, as well in the development of the New York hardcore music scene and aesthetics style. This album’s increased complexity in songs, with more elaborate riffs and arrangements, is its main distinguishing factor compared to the band’s previous recordings. The bass octaves retain the dynamics of the guitar line. For this album Brian Baker became second guitarist and Steven Hansgen joined the bass. The lyrics of the majority of the songs reflect self-reflection, youth frustration, personal problems and difficulties with friendships, in contrast to that of Minor Threat's first recordings (which contained a politically critical message and as opposed to drug use).

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

Bit underwhelmed. I think one of the things that makes me less fond of most hardcore, compared to punk, is the loss of melody, or anything that fills the role of melody. The tracks are hard and tight, and I know how influential they were, but it's a howling into nothing. Gotta be in the right mood for that, and I'm not there today.

Angry but not threatening punk. That is what this is. Stay away if you don’t like OG punk. Stay away if you don’t like voices that sort of talk sing. Don’t come near if you don’t like quick playing guitars drums or bass There, I’ve laid out the plan now it’s up to you to follow it. Choice cut: Look Back and Laugh

I got so fucking excited seeing this. I LOVE MINOR THREAT! YAAAAAY! YAAAAYYYYYY!!!!! This and first two seven inches are great. Fuuuck yes I love ian mackaye and everything he does

Out and out hardcore punk. Fast and energetic. Production-wise just not enough for me to come back to when having listened to more current punk records.

I think the makers of this must are confused about how much punk I need to hear before I die. This is unremarkable.

Short but not sweet

More short, sharp hard-core punk. Every now and again I was reminded of The Ramones, but I think the reason Minor Threat did not break through in the same way in the UK is that they're not as engaging.

Short noise

Gotta love 1001. After the variety served up by Beck's Odelay we have what appears, on first listen, to be one song which has been rearranged and repeated 9 times. All with the same dull drum rhythm and grating vocals. Gets a two on the energy it delivers, and the occasionally intriguing snippet of lyrics that gets through the overly dense mix. 2*

Too much punk on this list. This isn't the worst of it though.

This reminds me *so much* of Hormoaning-era Nirvana.

Crammed a lot of lyrics into that shouting at me lyrics. Rather liked the album though. Still glad it was under 1/2 hour. My eats can’t maintain that amount of energy coming at them.

This one is tough. Highly influential album. I just don’t love it. I feel like a 3 is too low and a 4 is too high. 3.5 rounded up.

Even though it's only 22 minutes, I don't have time for it

Not a fan of punk, but at least the albums are short

just hootin and hollerin and labelling it as punk

This album was released in 1983 and is classified as hardcore punk. These guys are all good musicians. They're tight and their sound is clean. But this isn't a genre I like. The tempo is just too fast for anything to develop so the songs sound the same (jump to middle of any of them and you'll see). The exception and the best song for me is the last one, Cashing In. It's a bit slower, more musical and the singer can sing/talk vs. just scream. It's actually funny.

Fast drums and loud guitar. Every song. That will work.

One of those bands I’ve heard of but never listened to. Pretty good!

Say what you will about Punk music, but at least it has the grace to know when to end. I’ve listened to so many albums where I was just miserable the whole way through, only to discover they were over an hour long and I still had a good 40 plus minutes to go. I’m looking at you, every Jazz album so far. Hot take I know. Jazz just doesn’t do it for me. I’ve mentioned it to death at this point. You’re telling me this album is only 21 minutes long AND we get 9 songs that all know when they’ve gone on too long?? That’s pretty awesome. Also the album art is amazing. I love the concept of a black sheep in general, and this album art is surprisingly cute for a band called Minor Threat, being a Punk band and all. I seriously love the design of that little guy in the lower left corner. Ok, that’s all well and good, but what does the actual music sound like?? Well, it’s complicated. Punk music all sounds the same, with very few notable exceptions that get bestowed with an earned higher rating. They’re usually surprisingly formulaic, which is tremendously ironic for a genre all about breaking rules and disrespecting authority. Anything else that actually sounds different but still manages to be Punk in nature is probably going to be rated higher for bringing a unique twist to the table. And yeah, this album sounds like every single other Punk album I’ve heard so far on the site. In other words, it’s exactly what I’m expecting of the genre at this point. I’ve become very familiar with this kind of sound since I started this project, and God knows I’ve got several more of these to go. This one is just one of thousands that sound just like it. It’s not bad, but it’s also really not that good either. Not one single, solitary thing stands out here. In fact, you could replace one of these songs with a different Punk artist entirely and I wouldn’t notice. That’s how generic it is. It’s still a 3, because luckily I can stand to listen to Punk music, but it’s really nothing special. That does also unfortunately make picking a favorite song difficult here though, but with how short the album is, it becomes less of an issue picking a favorite. I really do appreciate how short and tight all of these Punk albums are. Makes picking a favorite song much, much easier. Speaking of, my favorite song here is the intro, “Betray”. It sets a nice tone, and never lets off the gas until the very end of the album. Overall, this album is simply just ok. Been getting a whole lot of ok albums this week, and including this one, I probably won’t remember a single one of them. Out of Step by Minor Threat comes in at a reasonable 3 out of 5.

Influential, I gather. Didn’t change my life. Competent.

Not bad, definitely mood music. 3/5

панк как панк

Screaming caused some ear damage but it is a minor threat

A fun 21 minutes of pure energy

I started out thinking this was just some generic punk/hardcore I'd heard a bunch of times before, but a few tracks in I started to get this was a little more than that. On second listen (which is easy when it's so short) I started to hear the influence this album has had on multiple 90s alternative bands, most clearly (to my ear) Green Day. Not a love, but I get it's inclusion and I'm glad to have heard it.

Def a milestone

High-energy punk and I'm here for it. The album as a whole is a vibe and is only 21 minutes long so it was less about individual songs for me. But really enjoyed it.

calling this an album feels like a stretch given its barely over 20 minutes long, but that's punk i guess. u don't always need the full 40 mins to get the point across. i definitely feel like i get the idea well enough already. given how short the tracks are idk if i could really pick out individual tracks as favourites? imo this albums more about the sound as a whole. and i fuck w/ this sound. i really enjoy the energy of the whole thing, the frantic shredding, the blistering fast drums and the rough vocals. its fuckin good. when it comes to punk, that's the shit im here for. hell yea.. probably this would be a 5 if there was more of it, but there's not.... so its a 4. and why do i suddenly wanna play thps again??

Painfully average

Punkslop

Not the greatest album to listen to when you're hungover, but even objectively i think there are much more interesting Hardcore albums in the list.

So it's a Minor Threat EP, but instead of the stuff about drugs and politics that they normally do, it's about breakups and stuff. As per usual, I'd kill to know who the "you" is in an album/EP like this, and it drags it down that they just keep gesturing at some person that could damn-well be imaginary. That being said, I prefer their self-titled EP over this one. The music on that one just feels much stronger compared to this one. This EP feels like a band-ending argument, and that's exactly what happened a little after its release. I still really strongly agree with their message about not doing drugs.

Sweet and simple

Straight forward and raw

Punk just really isn't where it is at

Flat 3. It was nice and short

The seminal hardcore album. Absolute masterpiece.

Over very quickly but you can hear the influence on the music that came after this.

Used to listen to this a lot in my late teens/early 20's. I think their first EP is better (Self Titled), but this is pretty close behind it I suppose.

Cool. Super fun listen. Brings me back to my youth. I sometimes forget how immediate and vital this sounded to me back then. Good memories.

I like hardcore in doses and this brisk album hit just right.

For the most part, I like the energy of punk music. But it gets repetitive quickly. So this album is just the right amount of time to spend with Punk.

As expected, gas

I enjoyed that. A bit trebley. I've somehow avoided Minor Threat until today and I look forward to delving deeper.

High octane early punk. 2.5/5.0

Как же хорошо, что это длится всего 21 минуту

sex pistols but if they were worse and not influential

As far as hardcore punk goes. This is pretty alright.

Madi made me turn this off at 9;20 when we were in the office. Admittedly, this punk album isn't my least favorite album on this list, but it's certainly difficult to listen to during the work day. I wouldn't seek it out but I guess it could hit in a mosh pit?

not the world's biggest punk fan, but this was a really good listen. 4/5.

Good album for punk music

So a little over a year ago, I talked about frontman Ian MacKaye in the context of his time with Fugazi. Now I get to talk about him again, this time with his other notable band, Minor Threat. They were a short-lived hardcore punk band that wound up being fundamental in the beginnings of straight edge, an abstinence movement started to avoid alcohol and drugs, though later expanded to other perceived vices like meat and sex. They put out a handful of EPs, including the one we're gonna talk about today, though other sources will argue it's a full-length record; I digress. Without further ado, let's get Out of Step. Right out of the gate, I'm gonna say this right now - I very much adore this record. It's incredibly lean, tight, and well-played, with a level of refinement and nuance in the content that I can respect, even if the straight edge movement only comes into focus on the penultimate title track. I think what works in favor of this record is its universality. It's not linked to the specific politics of the day, instead infusing populism and relatability, balanced by brutal pragmatism and maturity. Take, for example, the opening song "Betray", where it seemed like Ian expected the double-cross, but instead of playing into the blame game, he confronts the issue and ends things. When that thread is continued with "It Follows," highlighting the drama that has stuck around within the scene, his raw exasperation becomes palpable. Hell, check out the closing track "Cashing In", where Ian focused his rage on those who thought Minor Threat in 1982 to "sell out", when in reality A) a lot of these complaints seemed rooted in local jealousy that really made little sense at the time, B) hardcore punk wasn't selling huge numbers in the 1980s anyway, and C) those complaining were still going to the shows anyway. But what really helps is that Ian is fully aware that some of this may be his own fault. He knows something changed with those friends left behind on "Look Back and Laugh", and he hoped they could resolve things, but he's willing to own it if it's him. Later on "No Reason", he may hold that stubborn pride in the indecipherable conflict, but he does realize how immature and stupid it all seems. Then, when you pair that sentiment with how hardcore punk was looked down on for having "all been done before" on "Think Again", Ian may accept some of the blame, but he was sure as hell not going to take those who dump on the scene and give them an air of credibility. Now it does lead into the one slightly weaker track with "Sob Story", basically calling out someone whining about never getting that lucky break and telling them to pull their shit together, but it makes sense given how ruthlessly pragmatic this record feels, even if that can be an isolating feeling as noted on "Little Friend" and the title track. Speaking of which, boy, that title track hits particularly well in the context of straight edge, even if it's more of an acknowledgement of the confusion that, somehow, by not indulging, Ian can't keep up with the larger world, but at least he can still think, and for him, that's good enough. Oh, and lest I forget, the music kicks ass all the way through! For a record running around twenty minutes, not a moment is spared as Minor Threat made the most of it: killer kick drum rhythms from Jeff Nelson, chugging, borderline thrash riffs from Brian Baker, and Lyle Peslar's lead guitar that may flex on solos but often opened these songs with a sweet melody that ensures the majority of these tunes had an anchor point. That sense of melody is not overlooked across the likes of "Think Again", "Cashing In", and "Look Back and Laugh", but there's also that jagged, rattling riff leading into "Little Friend", the breakneck kinetics between the chorus and verse on "It Follows", and the tonal shift on "Betray" that somehow still keeps it together. Though if I had to highlight someone in particular, it would be Steve Hansgen with his meaty basslines prevalent throughout the runtime, from punching up beneath the melody on "Betray" and "It Follows" to the surging energy given on "Think Again" and "No Reason", and even how he's anchored behind Ian's vocals on the title track. Really, I found nothing to complain about here, as Out of Step is the kind of hardcore record deserving to be called a classic. It may be just over twenty minutes, but it did not waste a moment, with insanely catchy hooks, terrific playing, solid production, and writing that hit the balance between fervor and nuance. This record is absolutely essential to hear if you're into hardcore punk, straight edge, or otherwise.

No standouts

Anyone who's even remotely into punk history (which is just about anyone who's into punk, since it's a shortcut to getting some kind of cred) has heard about how one of the reasons Minor Threat broke up because they had pretty much reached the limits of hardcore as a genre. Which is kind of true, kind of not true, but also blisteringly apparent here. I wore this (and First Two Seven Inches) out when I was in high school and college and know 'em like the back of my hand, but I haven't been back for some fifteen years and it's obvious why. They've pretty much nailed the sound, the energy is great, the musicianship is where it needs to be, but it really feels like it's a monster stuck in a box, outgrown and struggling to break out. So of course we'll get Fugazi. Good album, historically significant, but not a great one.

Fun little punk album

It had a fun energy and didn’t outstay its welcome.

Great classic punk album

If you caught me on a more high energy day (rare) I might’ve enjoyed this more, but as I’m not, I didn’t really like it. Interesting hearing the bands of today in this though.

Its a fun interesting energetic little punk album. It is short but it also doesn't feel short. A little too screamy but I can still get behind it.

Well this was short and sweet! Not something I'd listen to again, but I appreciated the punk rock energy.

The best thing about this album is the running time. At just over 20 minutes I was able to grit my teeth and get through it. In fairness, it is just about listenable, but I highly doubt I would be saying that if it was a double album lasting 90 minutes!

Not my favorite Minor Threat, but it's a black sheep that points towards a post-hardcore future if you squint a little.

Punk, nothing too notable

Didn’t think much of this

Short and to the point, I like it

Solid punk album that sounds like 100 other solid punk albums

Short and punchy, OGs of Hardcore, nothing but respect for this one.

Heard of the name a lot, but not actually heard. Early hardcore punk, which is probably a little noisy for me, but still on the liking it side.

Hardcore punk band, album duurt minder dan 20 minuten. Dit word heel kort en heel hard, die aanname durf ik wel te doen. Oprecht; instrumentaal klinkt dit super strak en vind ik het ook echt wel vet. Ben geen fan van de zanger, maar dat heeft er meer mee te maken dat hij zich als lekker standaard punk schreeuwzanger gedraagt, er zit weinig subtiliteit bij. Dat zit er ook bij de muziek hoor, maar bijvoorbeeld de bassolo op Think Again, heel vet gedaan! Cashing in is een heel vet nummer, verreweg de favoriet van het album. De rest is vooral heel hard en snel, soms werkt het, soms niet. Maar tegen de tijd dat je je irriteert is het nummer al afgelopen. FAVO: Little Friend, Cashing in

I love the five-piece Minor Threat, even more than the classic line-up. I always think of this as an EP so it doesn't come up in album conversatoins often but I think it's perfect!

Interesting the role this album played in the thinking of people around me back in the day. I always appreciated its bass lines and rhythm. And that’s what grips me still. 4 Boolean: True

In like a lion, out like a lion. A really fast lion. Album cover like a lamb. Running away from other lambs. To complete the bastardized saying. I liked it well enough, though wasn’t exactly blown away. But given its impact, I think it’s deserving of a placement on the list, and it certainly didn’t overstay its welcome.

9 songs with 21 minutes total run time? Thank you very much. I appreciate it. However, not my thing. If you a punk, I reckon this is a brilliant album and the gigs were some experience. 2/5 as a bit too trashy and high energy for my sensitive disposition today.

I’m glad this record was only 21 minutes long. Not because it’s terrible, but because I’m not sure I could happily handle much more of Minor Threat’s rage. Every song is aggressive, super intense and full of raw energy, to the point where it feels like an assault on the ears. I like how tight it is, and how punchy the musicianship is, but realistically punk rock this assertive will never be fully my cup of tea. It’s still a solid 6/10 listen, but it’s rare I’ll ever give a punk album high than this.

En vrai un peu punk comme ça pas mal mais hyper répétitif

If you’re looking for influential hardcore albums look no further. There’s an honesty here and despite the rough edges this album is easy to get through.

Demasiada energía para un sesentón. Al menos es breve.

Like someone's just given you a red bull laced with cocaine -Full on energy. Get this on while you're playing Tony Hawk pro skater and you'll have a great time

No me gusta este estilo que sw sienten solo gritos. Ni oara entrenar

I mean, it's 21 minutes so that's good? But it's American punk so I'm glad it's only 21 minutes. If I could decipher things I might have appreciated the lyrics. I was pondering giving it a rare two as it was all a bit "here's some noise now we're done" but the last track Cashing In demonstrated they can actually throw the odd melody and structure in too. Low 3.

this was a fun little EP.

At least it was brief

great early eighties punk rock. Hits all the right tone and groove and angst. Love the closer "cashing in".

Pretty inoffensive. The extreme repetition is fine because none of the songs drag on for too long. They probably have a good message somewhere in there, if only I could understand what the singer is saying. If you had told me in reality there were actually only two longer songs, I would've believed you. I can hardly tell one song from the other. Favs: Betray, Cashing In, No Reason

This album is a really tight 20 minutes. This makes me want to skateboard aggressively. Favorite Songs: Betray, Think Again

I don't like hardcore punk very much and this did nothing to change my mind. It all sounds like one song, and not a good one. I have a lot of time for Ian MacKaye in Fugazi but this just sounds too much like shit. No variety and no vocal appeal for me. I appreciate the spirit, and couple of tracks are OK, but on the whole I'd rather listen to silence. At least it's short!

Loud, fast, shouty, angry and sweary…should be perfect for anyone still enjoying this punk style. If you don’t I guess their response would be “Boo-f****ing-hoo!”

Not my type of punk really and I think I would need to be in a very specific type of mood to enjoy listening to this... I was not in that mood today!

A minor threat to my sanity.

You don't need to scream at me😫

At times, I can hear Megadeth, Nirvana, Big Boys, Green Day, Thrice, AFI. This was an interesting listen but I do not enjoy this vocal style and probably won't listen again

more zealotry that I can't pick up on from DC. can see the influence on modern punk rock but bit shouty for me. interesting to learn about 'straight edge' punk but seems like they also eschew tuneful singing. Cashing In was good, more of that would have been solid 3 as it is I'm torn. 2.5

This was the kind of shit I loved when I was much younger. A blast from the past for me!

DC hardcore pioneers, not their best in my opinion, and a solid runway toward Fugazi

So important but I was never agitated enough to love hardcore. But I love all its grandchildren! Lol

This is my kind of punk. Because ya know, as a middle aged mom, Ian McKay as a teenager is what sings to my heart.

yes, we get it, you're angry