Album Summary
Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme is the third studio album by American music duo Simon & Garfunkel. Produced by Bob Johnston, the album was released on October 24, 1966, in the United States by Columbia Records. Following the success of the re-release of their debut single "The Sound of Silence", Simon & Garfunkel regrouped after a time apart while Columbia issued their second album, a rushed collection titled Sounds of Silence. For their third album, the duo spent almost three months in the studio working on instrumentation and production. The album largely consists of acoustic pieces that were mostly written during Paul Simon's period in England the previous year, including some numbers recycled from his debut solo record, The Paul Simon Songbook. The album includes the Garfunkel-led piece "For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her", as well as "7 O'Clock News/Silent Night", a combination of news reports of the day (the Vietnam War, the civil rights movement, the death of comedian Lenny Bruce), and the Christmas carol "Silent Night". Many critics have considered it a breakthrough in recording for the duo, and one of their best efforts. "Homeward Bound" had already been a top five hit in numerous countries and "Scarborough Fair/Canticle" performed similarly. The album peaked at number four on the Billboard Pop Album Chart and was eventually certified triple platinum by the Recording Industry Association of America. In 1999, the album was inducted into the Grammy Hall of Fame.
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
Oh no... It's... it's really not so great! I listened to this a lot as a teenager, and I'm sad to find it doesn't really hit anymore. Paul, dump this deadweight!
I listened to this during my jog on a cold, gray fall morning with leaves scattered everywhere on the ground, and it seemed to fit the vibe. Simultaneously cozy and melancholy. A good autumn stew of an album. I hadn't heard "Patterns" in a long time prior to this relisten and forgot how much I like that one. I have a hard time picking a favorite Simon & Garfunkel album because my favorite songs of theirs are mostly spread out across their discography rather than focused into one or two classic albums, but if we are excluding greatest hits compilations then this is definitely in contention.
I still think Paul Simon’s solo work is far superior to the work of Simon and Garfunkel.
Felt like I was watching a Wes Anderson movie while at a renaissance fair. 2.5 stars
Some of the best Simon and Garfunkel songs but also probably some of the weaker ones. I did really like the Bob Dylan parody, that was funny.
Man, I wanted to dislike this album. My high school drama teacher made a joke about the spice blend and my understanding made me bias against it. Top that with my distaste for early Folk music and I thought this would be a disaster to listen to. It wasn't! Even the open track bangs. Loved the soft and light tones. This album explored and developed the Folk sound. Favorite tracks were: Scarborough Fair/Canticle, Patterns, The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine, The 59th Street Song, The Dangling Conversation, A Simple Desultory Philippic, and shout out to Silent Night. Couldn't make it through the whole Silent Night track, though.
My dad always had “Si & Gar” playing in his car. He has all of their albums, so this sound reminds me of growing up. 😊
*all-time.
I would have expected a whole album in the style of scarborough fair, but it was way more diverse. An enjoyable listen and doesnt overstay.
My Dad played this all the time, it brought memories of riding around, Scarborough Fair and it's harmonies always had a kind of eerie feel to it, but it is also one of those songs that triggers exactly where you were when you heard it.
A classic and beautifully constructed timeless album. Unforgettable tunes, pitch perfect harmonies. Masters of their craft.
classic
This was very relaxing and chill in a good way.
I do like this album a lot but as always with Simon and Garfunkel, it would be better with more Simon and less Garfunkel
Wow, what a great start to the Simon and Garfunkel music (for both and each of them solo). I enjoyed it a lot and have a big debate if its worth a 5 star, since it's between 4.2 to 4.6 grade. Great melodies, great 60's music (one of my top 3 deceds).
Lots of catchy songs with those instantly recognisable harmonies. Musical and lyrical talent which stands the test of time.
This is probably a hot take but I think this is so weird so far I kinda just didn’t get it; I like Paul Simon’s solo stuff but not a big fan of Simon & Garfunkel it’s almost like corny? Or too whimsical/happy go lucky for me
Not my favorite genre but a beautiful album.
Not really my vibe. The folk rock-forward songs of the album were my favorite. Homeward Bound is probably the best song on the album imo.
I ended up liking this album A LOT more than I thought I was going to. I don't really know what I expected going in but it greatly surpassed any preconceived notions I had about this album. There were a few tracks where I found myself going "Oh I've heard this one!" when I didn't know the name of it. Some of the shorter songs in the middle sounded incomplete on my first listen. Like they were just playing with ideas and not fully fleshing them out. This did not take away from my overall experience with the album which was mainly positive. 4/5
Fantastic early folk
Oh man I was so happy when I saw this was my album for today
Lovely relaxing tunes - thx!
This is an entertaining album with great lyrics and quaint melodies. It's a brief album at less than half an hour, but it's also a consistently good album. The highlight is definitely the closer "The 7 O'Clock News/Silent Night." I love the juxtaposition between a peaceful Christmas classic and news stories of civil rights and the Vietnam War.
A deserved absolute classic. The absence of Scarborough Fair, and Homeward Bound from American music would diminish the whole.
a lean and surprisingly good album. it’s easy to hear why everyone seemed to love their early work. for me, solo simon is light years better, but this is pretty good pop music
Maybe their best album? Hard not to like it.
Final Simon & Garfunkel. It's been a while since my last album of theirs. "Bookends" was precisely 348 albums ago. It's been so long, in fact, that I've pulled my remaining two Paul Simon albums in the time between these two releases. Truly the end of an era... I remember little of these albums. Here goes. Huh. I've just learned that "Elizabeth My Dear" from The Stone Roses' debut album borrows the melody of a traditional English folk song, as does this album with its cover of Scarborough Fair. Unlike my previous two outings with Simon & Garfunkel's music, I feel as though I understood this album a lot more, which I think can be owed to the ornate sound being more personally resonant. The guitars are quite good, lending a plucky and full sound to the album, yet also a ruminating quality on select tracks. Much of the album is carried on the merits of its layered guitarwork, yet the soft, steady percussion underscores and guides the music in a competent direction. I don't care much for the vocals of this album, though I suppose they're distinctive and well-suited to the music. The moments where the music leaned into a rock and roll sound were strange and not particularly gripping. While I do somewhat see why this album is in here, I must admit that I'm not fond of how unsubstantial the songs are, which is where this album begins to come apart for me. The average song length of this album being two and a half minutes lead to a few of the tracks passing by without notice, with my natural level of interest in folk further curbing my investment. All in all, I thought this album was somewhat threadbare and vacuous, though there were elements of it I can appreciate. Book time. The Vietnam war is a centerpiece of this music. "...their first great album". "Indeed, it is the tension between the sense of impending doom and Simon's insistence on emotional connection that makes the album such an enduring work." Unlike the group's previous outing with "Sounds of Silence", Paul Simon had complete creative control and more time to create this album. "...Scarborough Fair/Canticle [is an] intricate, haunting pop masterpiece that rivals any of Brian Wilson's creations." Paul Simon is "...one of the era's most gifted songwriters". "...Homeward Bound [is] arguably the greatest song written about a musician's life on the road." Wikipedia says this album features acoustic pieces written by Simon from his time spent in England the year prior along with some songs that were retooled from his solo debut album. Liked by a handful of critics, though the album doesn't appear to be widely reviewed. The album peaked at No. 14 in Australia, No. 13 in the UK, No. 8 in Canada and No. 4 in the US. As I've said in my other reviews, I'm perfectly fine with Simon & Garfunkel having three list albums, and this album appears to be the best in their remaining discography, so I'm content with letting it through. I cosign this inclusion.
Brilliant folksy sound from one of the most dynamic duo's of all time.
I'm not the biggest S&G fan, but I did enjoy this one.
Simon and Garfunkel are just pretty average for me. Don't love them ... Don't hate 'em.
I was all ready to hate it but Si & Gar really pulled it out the bag.
A very enjoyable album. I’d not heard more than Simon and Garfunkel’s hits so I was pleased to hear some great tracks here. Homeward Bound was a particular highlight, and we get some great political atmosphere here on A Simple Desultory Philippic (I’m guessing a tribute/pastiche to Bob Dylan?) and 7 O’Clock News/Silent Night. Wavered between 4 and 5, but it packs so much into 29 minutes that I’ll be generous.
A wonderful collection of acoustic folk (rock) tunes, with a largely delicate, bittersweet sound and mood. There are moments of levity too, such as the charming ‘59th Street Bridge Song’. But it’s the more serious material that provides the real highlights: ‘Scarborough Fair/Canticle’, the great melancholy folky pop ballad ‘Homeward Bound’ (probably my favourite track), ‘Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall’, and the beautiful ‘For Emily, Wherever I May Find Her’, which features a brilliant vocal from Art Garfunkel. For me, the Bob Dylan pastiche ‘A Simple Desultory Philippic’ is the one misstep. A hair’s breadth from 5 stars.
cool kinda boring
S&G are one of those acts that I assume I have listened to their entire catalogue & my assumption was that although they have a number of transcendent songs that essential to the fabric of American Music, their albums never really blew me away. Turns out I never listened to parsley in full & my bad, this is a near perfect album. My take away from the albums I have listened to initially was always the essential tracks, Sound of Silence, The Boxer etc were the only reason to listen, but the not hit songs on Parsley make the album feel like a complete work of art & beautifully capture the well documented beatnik sound of the mid 60s. The Dangling Conversation makes me feel like I am in Central Park on a lite dose of LSD pretending to enjoy poetry, saying some deep shit to hippy girls for nefarious reasons, only to stop and realize halfway through... oh....I might actually like poetry. Or a simple Desultory Philippic, acknowledging we are all at some point in life trying to be Dylan & only to end with one of the most harrowing songs I have ever heard to end an album in 7 oclock News/Silent Night - did not anticipate to be moved while waiting to board a flight in Mexico. Speaking of American Fabric songs, I am not sure if there is anything better than Homeward Bound, rather than riffing on why the song is perfect, I am going to throw a TV rec at you, The Leftovers. There is an extremely weird dream episode where the main character is a Bond like assassin on a mission until it takes an emotional turn where he sobs doing a karaoke version of Homeward Bound, the scene has stuck with me for years now - and if you havent watched it - its 3 seasons and a work of art. 9.2 out of 10 5 stars.
I started this record thinking about Christopher Guest’s A Mighty Wind. I finished it thinking about Vietnam, Martin Luther King, Robert Kennedy, and the slow disintegration of America’s 1960s innocence. That’s quite a journey for one folk record. I’ll start with a confession: I’m not a particularly big fan of this strain of 1960s folk music. I like folk rock, and I certainly appreciate traditional folk musicians like Woody Guthrie and Pete Seeger, but that earnest, wide-eyed, Peter, Paul and Mary, “Puff the Magic Dragon” variety of folk has never really been my thing. When Dylan went electric at Newport, I would’ve been the guy shouting, “Hell yes!” And having watched A Mighty Wind approximately a million times, I can’t always separate this kind of music from Eugene Levy and Catherine O’Hara earnestly singing “A Kiss at the End of the Rainbow.” Once you’ve heard the parody, it’s hard not to hear it everywhere. And yet, there’s something undeniably magical about Simon & Garfunkel. Something that transcends the genre, the era, and occasionally even my own musical prejudices. Two extraordinary voices, one of the greatest songwriters in popular music, and some of the most beautiful acoustic guitar playing I’ve ever heard. At their best, they produce music that doesn’t merely demand your attention. It stops you in your tracks. The album opens with “Scarborough Fair/Canticle,” a hauntingly beautiful reimagining of a centuries-old English ballad, layered with Simon’s antiwar counterpoint. There’s something almost supernatural about it. The ancient melody, the intertwined voices, the delicate acoustic guitar, the unsettling lyrics. It’s gorgeous, but it’s also ghostly, as if you’re hearing something drifting across centuries. It establishes immediately what these two men are capable of when everything comes together. “Patterns” is good, if not quite great, although I love its hypnotic acoustic guitar progression. There’s something almost Led Zeppelin about it, perhaps a distant cousin of “Bron-Y-Aur Stomp.” In fact, the guitar playing and recording throughout this album are spectacular. The clarity, warmth, and intimacy of the acoustic sound make me want to go out and spend $5,000 on an absurdly expensive guitar, just so I can sit in a room and play these songs. It’s the kind of record that makes you fall in love with the sound of the instrument itself. Unfortunately, Side A doesn’t consistently live up to the promise of its opening. “Cloudy” is probably my least favorite track. It’s breezy, cheerful, and unmistakably influenced by Brian Wilson and the Beach Boys, but it’s also a little too saccharine for my taste. It sounds like Paul Simon took a handful of Lexapro before heading into the studio. “The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine” is a perfectly serviceable slice of mid-60s rock, full of Beatles, Byrds, Who, and Monkees DNA, but it feels distinctly trapped in its time, clever satire notwithstanding. And then there’s “The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin’ Groovy).” I know it’s beloved, but I just don’t connect with it. There’s something painfully earnest about its sunny optimism. When the Flamin’ Groovies call themselves groovy, there’s a knowing wink, a little rock-and-roll irreverence. When Paul Simon sings about feeling groovy, he seems to mean it with every fiber of his being. And for whatever reason, that makes the song feel almost embarrassingly dated to me. It’s the precise sort of thing A Mighty Wind so brilliantly skewers. Of course, there’s an enormous exception to all of this: “Homeward Bound,” which is one of the album’s absolute standouts. It’s a fantastic piece of songwriting, a beautifully constructed pop-rock song that offers a glimpse of the Paul Simon who would emerge as a solo artist in the 1970s and 1980s. There’s a melodic sophistication and accessibility that separates it from the more traditional folk material. You can practically hear his future career taking shape. Unfortunately, this song has been permanently ruined for me. On a family cruise sometime around 2002, my father somehow advanced to the finals of the ship’s karaoke competition. For reasons that remain unclear, he chose “Homeward Bound” as his big number. What followed was one of the most catastrophic vocal performances I’ve ever witnessed. The level to which he failed to sing this song was unprecedented. My family collectively pretended not to know him. Suffice it to say, he did not win. More than twenty years later, I cannot hear this otherwise magnificent piece of music without remembering that horrible evening at sea. So, by the end of Side A, I’m a little conflicted. There are moments of extraordinary beauty, some undeniable songwriting brilliance, and consistently magnificent musicianship. But there are also several songs that exemplify precisely what I don’t particularly care for about 1960s folk-pop. And then you flip the record. My God, what a Side B. It opens with “The Dangling Conversation,” which is so fucking beautiful that it practically commands you to stop whatever you’re doing and listen. The acoustic guitar progression is absolutely mesmerizing, and when Simon’s voice enters, it fits the music as though the two were always meant to exist together. His lyrics paint a still life of a relationship slowly dying: sunlight filtering through lace curtains, two people sitting together, going through the motions of intimacy long after the intimacy itself has disappeared. It’s a heartbreaking meditation on love, or more precisely, the quiet, devastating experience of losing it. Nobody is screaming. Nobody is storming out. Two people simply find themselves emotionally estranged, unable to bridge the distance that has grown between them. The image of kissing someone’s shadow is particularly devastating. The person is still there, physically present, but the person you loved has somehow vanished. And then Garfunkel’s voice joins Simon’s, and the instrumentation begins to swell. The strings rise beneath the vocals with a cinematic grandeur that reminds me of the Beatles’ “She’s Leaving Home,” which would arrive the following year. There’s something almost unbearable about the beauty of the arrangement against the profound sadness of the lyrics. Two voices achieving perfect harmony while describing two people who can no longer communicate. This is what makes Simon & Garfunkel special. This is why the album is a masterpiece despite its imperfections. This is the magic that happens when these two men perform together. “Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall” follows, and it’s another wonderful song, a beautiful little folk-pop confection with a distinctly Beatles-esque quality. I hear echoes of everything from A Hard Day’s Night through Revolver in its jangling acoustic guitars, infectious melody, and exquisite harmonies. Beneath its cheerful surface is a surprisingly philosophical song, full of uncertainty about reality and identity. It’s also another glimpse of the effortless melodic sensibility that would define Simon’s later work. Then comes “A Simple Desultory Philippic,” and I absolutely love it. This is Paul Simon doing Bob Dylan, unabashedly and almost comically. The nasal vocal delivery, the rapid-fire cultural references, the harmonica, that screaming electric organ over the acoustic guitar. It’s a loving, slightly ridiculous impersonation of Dylan at his Highway 61 Revisited peak. The song practically announces its influences with a bullhorn, and it’s great fun. It’s funny, irreverent, and full of attitude. Interestingly, this song is every bit as rooted in the 1960s as “Feelin’ Groovy,” but I love it. The difference, I think, is that there’s some mischief here. Some self-awareness. A little rock-and-roll swagger. It feels alive rather than preserved in amber. And then there’s “For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her.” I don’t know if this is universally regarded as one of Simon & Garfunkel’s masterpieces, but in my heart, it absolutely is. In fact, it might be my favorite song on the record. It’s almost impossibly beautiful. There’s very little to the arrangement. Simon’s delicate acoustic guitar, Garfunkel’s extraordinary voice, and one of the most gorgeous melodies I’ve ever heard. Garfunkel begins almost tenderly, his voice floating above the guitar, and then gradually builds toward this astonishing emotional crescendo. By the end, he’s practically crying out his love, pushing into registers that remind me a little of early-70s Bowie, with the soaring, almost operatic intensity of the Moody Blues’ “Nights in White Satin.” It’s breathtaking. A performance that somehow feels intimate and enormous at the same time. If I ever found myself at a coffee shop open mic with an acoustic guitar, this might be the song I’d choose. Partly because there are no elaborate two-part harmonies to reproduce, and I can’t exactly harmonize with myself. Of course, that leaves the relatively minor problem of having to sing like Art Garfunkel. But there’s something about this song that defies analysis. I can talk about the melody, the arrangement, the vocal performance, the recording, but none of those things adequately describes the way it makes me feel. It just rips your heart out. It’s timeless. It’s the sort of song that reminds you why music matters in the first place. All I know is that in my heart, it’s beautiful. “A Poem on the Underground Wall” is another standout, opening with a cascading acoustic guitar figure that immediately reminds me of the Beatles’ “I’ve Just Seen a Face.” But as the song develops, it taps into something darker and more mysterious. Those haunting harmonies, the minor-key atmosphere, the sense of unease. It’s the same quality that makes “Scarborough Fair,” “The Sound of Silence,” and eventually “The Boxer” so extraordinary. There’s something almost mythological about Simon & Garfunkel at their best. They can take a relatively ordinary image or narrative and imbue it with an extraordinary sense of gravity. Here, a small act of graffiti in a subway station becomes a strange, cinematic little drama. Once again, their voices transform something mundane into something haunting. And finally, “7 O’Clock News/Silent Night.” What an astonishing way to end an album. The premise is deceptively simple: Simon and Garfunkel sing a beautiful, reverent rendition of “Silent Night” while a news broadcast reports the increasingly disturbing headlines of 1966. Civil unrest, violence, Vietnam, political uncertainty. The voices are angelic. The news is horrifying. And as the track progresses, the volume and intensity build until the collision between the two becomes almost unbearable. It’s heartbreaking. It’s brilliant. And it leaves you stunned. What struck me most was how perfectly this final track seems to capture the contradictions of the entire decade, and perhaps the album itself. When we remember the 1960s, we often remember the exuberance: the British Invasion, psychedelia, flower power, the bright colors, the hippies, the music, the extraordinary sense that everything was changing and anything was possible. There’s plenty of that youthful optimism on Side A, particularly in songs like “Feelin’ Groovy.” But there’s another side to the 1960s. A much darker one. The Vietnam War. The struggle for civil rights. The assassinations. The racial violence. The fear, anger, and profound uncertainty about where America was heading. All of that existed alongside the music, the fashion, the exuberance, and the optimism. The decade wasn’t all sunshine and daydreams. There was an enormous amount of sadness, and an increasing sense that something in the country was coming apart. Of course, the album’s two sides don’t divide perfectly along those lines. The ghostliness and antiwar imagery of “Scarborough Fair” are already present on Side A, while Side B has its share of playful moments. But the emotional movement of the record feels meaningful nonetheless. It moves from youthful innocence and romantic possibility toward introspection, loss, and finally a confrontation with the world outside. And what makes the closing track even more devastating is listening to it with the benefit of hindsight. This record came out in 1966. Martin Luther King Jr. was still alive. Robert Kennedy was still alive. Nixon had not yet become president. The horrors of 1968 were still ahead, and the Vietnam War had many bloody years left to run. When the newscaster reports former Vice President Nixon’s prediction of five more years of fighting in Vietnam, we know what the people listening in 1966 couldn’t possibly know. We know how much suffering was still to come. We know the assassinations, the escalation of the war, the political turmoil, and the terrible human cost that would follow. And somehow, hearing all of that history approaching beneath “Silent Night” makes the song more devastating, not less. The carol never stops being beautiful. The headlines never become easier to bear. They simply grow louder together, until the song feels less like a Christmas hymn than a plea the world refuses to hear. I began this album suspicious of the very earnestness Simon & Garfunkel trade in. On the sunnier stretches of Side A, it can sound hopelessly dated, even unintentionally comic. But here, that sincerity becomes the point. They sing without a trace of irony, as if peace and tenderness are still worth believing in, even while the evening news supplies evidence to the contrary. Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme isn’t a perfect record. Its weaker songs keep it from the very highest tier. But when Simon’s songwriting, Garfunkel’s extraordinary voice, and those gorgeous acoustic guitars come together, the effect is transcendent. I started out thinking of A Mighty Wind. I ended in silence, trying to absorb what I’d just heard. 8.8/10
Like Austin said, good songwriting speaks for itself. Not as bold or adventurous as later albums, but a strong entry and easily qualifies as required listening. 8.5/10 Favorites: - Scarborough Fair - Patterns - Homeward Bound - Feelin’ Groovy - The Dangling Conversation - Flowers Never Bend - Poem On The Underground Wall - 7 o’clock News
Good songwriting will never go unnoticed. Paul Simon’s pen is a magic wand that ameliorates each and every song it touches. The sound on this album is less ostentatious than Bridge Over Troubled Water which is the bar for this duo. This album doesn’t quite reach that bar, but that doesn’t lessen my admiration or enjoyment of this LP which I would put as a must listen for all. Favorites - Scarborough Fair - Patterns - The Dangling Conversation - Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall - Homeward Bound Rating: 8/10
I love Simon and Garfunkel!! Rating: 4/5 GEMV (08.11.2026)
The concept is great, but I can't enjoy the execution.
Scarborough Fair is a banger. Patterns is a great look at mundane life. Cloudy takes things a bit lighter until Homeward Bound, another fantastic song. Really catchy. The tempo is definitely brought up by the Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine though. Catchy, great rhythm, and the album really goes a lot of different places at this point. All of which are great. The songs maintain an upbeat feel once Feelin' Groovy plays. While they aren't exactly heavy-hitters, each one is unique feeling and takes you on a trip between tambourines, organs, and harpsichords while Simon and Garfunkel harmonize their bromance to peak perfection. Every song sounds different than the last, a big plus. At times the songs travel into Bob Dylan-y territory but this is not a bad thing by any means. Overall a pretty solid album. I ended up listening to Scarborough Fair on repeat for the better part of a half hour after I finished it...
definitivamente não é muito minha vibe, mas até que curti a experiência, salvei pra dar mais uma oportunidade em um dia menos quente, acho que combina mais com frio
This is pretty much what I thought it would be. I really can’t take Simon & Garfunkel seriously, especially when they’re doing a Bob Dylan beef track.
Ah, back to the golden age..... I know these songs., having grown up with them courtesy of my parents..... i can't really be objective about them in the same way that it's difficult to be objective about the Beatles... Paul Simon spent a year in the UK ahead of recording this album and the influence of the British folk scene is very obvious in some tracks, speaking of which... I will never get bored of hearing Homeward Bound...Widnes railway station's finest hour in popular music...i have never been to Widnes, but if I had, then I would also probably wish that I wasnt there... And i ha e always loved the juxtaposition of 7 O'clock News/Silent Night. Yes it's not their best, (i prefer Bookends) and it can be a bit twee at times, but its still lovely/groovy). 3. stars rounded up... Update.. have removed a star because they ripped of Elizabeth My Dear for Scarborough Fair........why couldn't they write their own tunes...
Really enjoyed this. Homeward Bound is an absolute classic. Rest of the album is surprisingly varied and decent all the way through. I especially liked the Seven O Clock News / Silent Night mash up. Not quite a 5 but definitely a groovy 4.5
Likenm Dylann they went to England, drank from the cup of folk revival but came back and made chamber pop. It's layered, delicate sophisticated. In places downright gorgeous, in others breezily forgettable. Ive played this album many times and there are still four or five tracks that have failed to embed themselves in my consciousness at all. Close but no cigar.
Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme by Simon & Garfunkel was quite an interesting listen, even if it’s not really my usual kind of music. It has a very distinctive sound and a style that feels different from what I normally go for. The folk influences, acoustic arrangements, and beautiful vocal harmonies give the album a unique character. I can definitely appreciate the songwriting and the attention to detail in the music. Some songs stood out more than others, while a few didn't quite connect with me. There’s a certain warmth and simplicity to the album that makes it pleasant to listen to. The lyrics are often thoughtful and sometimes a little unusual, which adds to its charm. I also liked how the music manages to feel both gentle and emotionally rich. That said, I didn't find myself completely drawn into it. Perhaps it's one of those albums that needs the right mood to fully appreciate. I can understand why it's considered an important record in their discography. It may not be something I'll return to very often, but I'm glad I gave it a listen. Overall, a unique and enjoyable experience, even if it didn't fully win me over.
Album #195: Parsley, Sage, Rosemary and Thyme - Simon & Garfunkel Genre (W): Folk rock Singles: Homeward Bound, The Dangling Conversation, Scarborough Fair/Canticle, The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin’ Groovy) I have listened to this album twice before. Thoughts?: Paul Simon is a great songwriter but I feel like the production doesn’t do this album justice. A lot of songs sound standard and not standing out to me. Favorite tracks: Scarborough Fair/Canticle, Patterns, Homeward Bound, The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin’ Groovy), Flowers Never Bend with the Rainfall, For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her
The sentimental soundtrack of my youth. Contains one or two surprisingly bluesy/rocky tunes, too.
meh idk it just sounds old some of them were fine the first one was alr and it kinda went down from there its too 90s movie but not in a good way...
I liked how chill most of it was, not what I would generally listen to but the instrumentals were great
Laaaangweilig
2.5
This is likely my favourite from them - one of the best albums of the 60s
Highlight was flowers never bend with the rainfall, added to a couple playlists. Beautiful. None of the rest of the album stood out too much to me
Homeward bound is my fave :) an enjoyable album A cute, whimsical time, perfect for autumn
I love the lyrics and music but truly feel every song would be better if someone like Joan Baez was singing it. Just don’t like their voices which is crazy cus I love Paul Simon
Paul Simon himself provides the review of this album: “all my words come back to me in shades of mediocrity”. 2/5.
Jamais écouté avant. Troisième et dernier album, pour moi, de Simon & Garfunkel, et un constat finalement assez similaire aux deux autres : Paul Simon, malgré son incontestable talent de songwriter, manque singulièrement de régularité, et sur la longueur d'un album, une fois les meilleurs morceaux passés, on s'ennuie ferme. J'en avais le pressentiment, et l'écoute de ces trois albums du duo me l'a confirmé : Simon & Garfunkel est un groupe de best of, capable de signer des titres franchement géniaux autant que de céder au remplissage mollasson... Top : Homeward Bound Flop : Cloudy
Alright
Pas leur meilleur mais c’est Paul Simon et Garfunkel’s so je suis vendu
No sé. No me encantó. Hubo un par de temas que me gustaron bastante, pero Simon and Garfunkel no son mis favoritos.
A 60s masterclass in folk and folk rock. Some pieces may sound cheesy to today's audiences. An nice musical time capsule.
Solid
Great album, full of excellent folk songs by S&G. You can see where Paul Simon's songwriting was going and you also get the beautiful, aching instrumentation of Garfunkel. For Emily, Whenever I May Find Her is an underrated gem.
Yet another S&G album, this time, once again, with a couple of supernova songs, and some middling songs. Will absolutely listen to again- but this album was where you can tell Paul Simon was thinking "maybe I can do this on my own".
Okay. Fav song: Patterns
First track alone is worth 5 stars, but the rest is pretty awesome as well.
Love "Homeward Bound" and "Scarborough Fair" obviously, but I've always found this one to be the weakest of their post-debut albums. Still really good, because Simon & Garfunkel couldn't be bad, but just not more deserving of this spot than Sounds of Silence. P.S. The Bob Dylan parody gets me every time, "I dropped my harmonica Albert" will never stop being funny to me
Boring
Pretty
Fun
Wonderful. More on it than I remembered but all good.
Again, not for me. Just to boring
So good to hear this album again. A true masterpiece and I still cant believe its from 1966. THere are so many clever studio things being done here that are just beyond impressive. Roy Halee - what a guy. With the songs of Simon and the voice of Garfunkel nothing could be more perfect. (5/5)
It's Simon & Garfunkel. What's not to love?
6.3
Love the music, voices and harmonies
They are classic and this album is a great easy listen.
It's nice but not great
Perfect for the British autumn we are sliding into
10/22
Nice listen 👍
That’s a very good record, but I had to dock points for the goofy Dylan diss track.
I want to believe that Dylan's cover of "The Boxer" is his retaliation for "A Simple Desultory Philippic". 9 keepers in 12 (75%). 75
Great first album. Set up for the rest of their heavy metal career.
Bra men ikke beste fra S&G. 3 av 5
It's a very pretty album, but it isn't really anything more than that. I enjoyed that Bob Dylan parody though.
I don’t have much to say about this one but I did really like it. I wasn’t totally focused on what was going on for whatever reason but I liked what I heard.
Pretty good but Tim Buckley did folk rock better
My affection for S&G continues. Folk rock goodness, little all over the place but that's okay by me. Mostly struck by the choice to open with something as whimsical and traditional as "Scarborough Fair / Canticle" and close with something as chilling as "7 O'Clock News / Silent Night." (update the news stories and it could've been released in this decade... oh wait, Phoebe Bridgers, Fiona Apple, and Matt Berninger did...)
honestly not my favorite. it is too one note. homeward bound is the only one with a more interesting rhythm and IMO is the best song on the album
They’re true all-time classics. Good choice, sir; in all honesty, it’s an album that deserves to be on this list :-)
It has Homeward Bound, and a bunch of stuff I didn't like. I don't know. Scarborough Fair is too Ren Faire for my liking, some songs were just plain dumb (looking at you, Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine), and then there were the songs trying to sound too smart for the room (Dangling Conversation, and whatever that Bob Dylan (parody??) was). Frankly, I could tell by Paul Simon's shirt on the cover I wouldn't care for this album.
im new to folk music, might like it
On balance, not a bad record. Homeward Bound and 59th Street Bridge are good songs, otherwise standard early S&G material.
Having only played the hits, I didn’t realize how silly and pop culture reverential S&G can get. Also didn’t know Phoebe Bridgers ripped the Christmas song/news montage from them.
A very good folk album with all time bangers of "Scarborough Fair/Canticle", "Homeward Bound", and "The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy)". PSRaT also has some of my favorite deeper cuts like "Patterns" and "Cloudy". Even the weaker tracks on the back half of the album sound like they would be top tier stuff on a lesser folk artist's album of the time.
Wow. What a beautiful, gentle record. Favourite tracks: Scarborough Fair / Canticle, Patterns, The Big Bright Green Pleasure Machine, The 59th Street Bridge Song (Feelin' Groovy), The Dangling Conversation, A Simple Desultory Philippic, A Poem on the Underground Wall, 7 O'clock News / Silent Night.