Album Summary
American Gothic is the third studio album by American singer-songwriter David Ackles. It was released on July 4, 1972, by record label Elektra. American Gothic was recorded at IBC Sound Recording Studios in London, England. It was produced by Bernie Taupin and conducted by Robert Kirby. In its retrospective review, AllMusic wrote "American Gothic remains one of those great albums that never found its audience. It waits to be rediscovered." American Gothic was included in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die. Mojo called it "one of the most beautiful but rarely heard albums of his era".
Keywords from Reviews
Rating Over Time
Reviews
When songs veered more towards pure ballads (Love's Enough, Another Friday Night), it was tolerable. I mean, I listen to enough sad sack music that I could understand how someone could enjoy this white man being sad about drinking alone on a Friday night. But the minute it went more theatrical, I was out. I like a musical but the show-tune sounding tracks just sounded dated & a bit cringe, like Doctor Doolittle was about to come in stage right and start dancing around.
Neal Diamond and Billy Joel make a musical and it sucks.
What in the hell is this? I didn't realize "crooner off his meds" was a genre, I just thought scott walker was a one off. Its entertaining in the way a car wreck is. I know he's going to say something racist or mysoginistic or homophobic, the question is when. How do you rate something like that? At the very least I wasn't bored.
Lyrically lacking, musically mediocre, and certainly not an album I would recommend anyone listen to.
In my mind's eye I could see this music being used in a play, musical, or movie. It had a cinematic feel to it, which was interesting. Music-wise, this sound didn't really do much for me. I can't precisely say what it was, but the album left me wanting more - in the sense that I continuously felt like the songs were lacking something.
Good lord this is tedious
This is one of the more unique albums we've had on this list! Really solid collection of, basically, American-focused show tunes, centred on down-on-their-luck characters. The closest comparison I can draw is to Dagmar Krause's album Tank Battles, but even then that's a very loose comparison only really anchored by the theatricality of it all; Krause's album consists of covers of inter-war German cabaret, while this is an original suite of very American-informed sounds. Either way, definitely a fun listen, worth a 7/10, and I'm glad to see more unique stuff represented on here! (Any who've followed my reviews will remember me recently snapping a little bit about the 400 identical punk rock albums festooning the list.)
Felt like I was listening to a musical. There are people out there who enjoy musicals. I am not one of those people.
I'm afraid showtunes are just a hard sell for many people, me included. Standouts: Oh, California! • Blues For Billy Whitecloud
Conflicted because there's a lot on here i like but a lot i don't like. I don't care for the theatrical numbers, but I did like Blues for Billy Whitecloud. I usually like the more introspective numbers but I thought Montana Song was too long. Alas. It's fine.
This was surprisingly unique. The storytelling, the emotions, the thought provoking, I kinda liked it. Very different. I can see why it wasn't popular and didn't go anywhere, but I also can see why it was on this list. Even the kid was pretty good for being background music not intended to contribute.
Reminds me of the Rock Ooera Tommy only Folk and only bad
This was a hard listen.
I feel like Nick Cave nabbed a lot of musical ideas of this guy. I don’t enjoy Nick Cave either. Competent but not for me.
An “album that never found its audience” and it did not find me either. Pleasant enough though. Harmless, rather.
The Good: A Smashing Pumpkin's album! The Bad: No... No... it is a painting! The Ugly: Trying to look cool while sitting in a rowboat while the missus is trying not to laugh her ass off while sitting on the porch which would have been a much better place to sit then a rowboat... You'd think that, based on the above, I really did not like the album... You'd think wrong. What a lovely gem to find in this sea of 1001 albums on which, to my greatest surprise, there is NO Phil Collins album included... Anyway, back to this... To my this felt like a musical... a story being told about how things really aren't that bad, and that it will get better... in Montana... Amazing that we've had 55 years pass, and yet many of the observations about society that are made on this album are just as true today... go figure. Lastly, another album that will increase the average score for the '70s! 5*
Aight
Very theatrical. Sounds like it should be a musical soundtrack. There were some dark and heartbreaking lyrics. The music was good, especially the piano. 2.5/5
Listan logiikka jaksaa hämmästyttää. Miksiköhän tämä on listalla? David Ackles ei ole saanut merkittävää kaupallista menestystä urallaaan Wikipedian mukaan ja tämä albumi on ymmärtääkseni ollut kaupallinen floppi. Ja huono se onkin. Ymmärtääkseni levyä ei kuunnella suoratoistopalveluissa tänäkään päivänä juurikaan. Eli miksi minun pitäisi tällaista roskaa kuulla? On vaikea kuvitella edes levyn kohderyhmää: kenelle tämä on tarkoitettu? Tämä on jotain viiden pennin wannabe-musikaalitaidetta. Yksi huonoimmista listalla ja todella kyseenalainen paikka tällä listalla. 1/5
I’ve completely lost track of the logic behind the compilers of the "1001 Albums" list. David Ackles worked as a songwriter for the Elektra label; he was eventually signed to a five-album deal and even landed a spot as an opening act for Elton John — whose own lyricist, Bernie Taupin, ended up producing this particular record. The result is an incredibly convoluted, piano-driven, theatrical affair. It’s hard to explain: usually, when I enjoy music, I feel as though it’s guiding me along a clear path; here, it’s as if someone is pulling you by the arm in every direction at once, leaving you with no idea where you’re actually supposed to go. It’s like the soundtrack to a bizarre musical whose plot you can’t fathom. The album was a commercial failure upon its release — but let’s set that aside; perhaps he was just a misunderstood genius, and people simply weren’t ready for it back then. The thing is, according to streaming statistics, people aren’t listening to it now, either! Who was this album even recorded for? Why am I supposed to hear it before I die? Questions with no answers.
This album certainly lived up to its name. Whilst the picture suggested something folksy, the lyrics and delivery were a much sharper, Brechtian exploration of the dark and seedy underbelly of American life, with shattered dreams and one night stands and drifting from place to place trying to earn a buck or two. I was intrigued to see that this was produced in collaboration with Bernie Taupin, whose work with the legendary Elton John often had a darker and more melancholy edge than many people realise. I'm not entirely surprised that this wasn't a hit at the time, but it holds up as a significant piece of work in retrospect.
Cool stories! Musically sounds like a combination of Neil Diamon and Leonard Cohen lol
It's a score without a musical. I was hooked from the first track because of the lyrics, and because it was so different from all the records that have come before. 'Oh, California!', 'Another Friday Night', 'Family Band' stood out. I can understand this is not for everyone but I clicked with this and really enjoyed it.
Not a fan. I don't like this type of boomer music in the first place and this was particularly bad.
oh give me a break come on Best Song: Oh, California Rating: 3/10 Stars: 2
What an unusual album, it has moments like a musical and moments of half decent folk tunes. Not sure about this at all. It frankly just doesn't seem right. I don't think I liked it, I just found it 'interesting'.
3/5. An album that made basically no splash upon its release, American Gothic only started getting critical attention and reevaluation in retrospect. You get a blend of folk, rock, blues, and vaudeville-esque showtunes here, and it all totals out to be perfectly fine. I think that part of the reason that this album failed to hit upon release is just that it came out in a sea of much better singer-songwriters, so anyone who would have been interested in this album at the time simply had better options. it’s not bad though I quite liked “Midnight Carousel” and the title track.
I'd rather sign up to be on the bottom of a kidney harvesting pyramid scheme than listen to this shit.
An odd album layered with contradiction. The songs meander and slither around the place but feel too simple to be interesting. There is simultaneously too much going on, but not enough going on. It has that Billy Joel schmaltzy cheese but doesn't feel like it has a tonne of heart in it. David has a nice voice, but there are parts where it falls flat. I can't call this a great album, it's flaws stand out a lot, but at the same time it is kinda charming.
BORING
Haye is all u can say
Sounds more like a musical soundtrack than an album.
Such a melancholic album. I’ve only listened to this now. I know of David Ackles but not his music.
This sounded more like a musical soundtrack than a pop album…
The Wikipedia article refers to this as a "one of those great albums that never found its audience." I can confirm that I am also not that audience. There is a clear line from the work of Bertolt Brecht, Peter Weiss and others within that theatrical tradition in some of the work, but the difference is that I like that work and I don't really like this. Part of it is simply that I'm not a fan of Ackles' voice, but I also don't really like lyrics. The rest can be read through the theatrical tradition, largely sounding like a not very interesting Broadway interpretation of a number of musical traditions. Overall, this song moves from being really dreadful to being not that interesting, for me at least. I will never listen to this again.
Прикольно, но такое на постоянке не послушаю
At least I was able to get this out of the way pretty quickly this morning. His voice is annoying to me, I really don't care for singer/songwriter shtick and the orchestration was annoying as well. Why are we subjected to these terrible albums?
This is like all the slow parts of a Neil Diamond song rolled into one.. and not in a good way....
I gave it two full listens and despite the critical praise I can see why only 2 songs have top 100k streams. this is an album no one listening to. And I dont think its a missed classic.
Overly theatrical for my tastes, but not terrible, I guess
Eh, this was fine. Nothing special but it wasn’t offensive. 3/5⭐️ 298/1089
This was a bit of an epic listening to some of the songs, with storytelling to dig into and sweeping arrangements. Certainly over the top in some places. I struggled with the production in some places where the orchestral parts would seem to rise up and take over the vocals. It was an interesting listen and a valiant effort.
they like creepily ai'd him on the cover to move in the spotify canvas vid. thats the only thing i have to say about this album, its fine
I was dreading this, but I actually enjoyed how theatrical it was. It really played like a soundtrack to a musical, but without cutaways to hacky acting. 3.5/5.0
this was an album for sure. kinda sounds like meat loaf if the bombastic theatrical rock had a folk influence instead. im not sure who its for but im sure its for someone
Is it horrible? No. But would I ever want to listen to this again? Definitely not. Too dramatic, self-important. I suppose if I had heard this back in the day, I'd probably would have liked it more. But now it seems dated and too earnest for my tastes. But still, it's not horrid, just dated and bland. 3 "got better things for my ears to hear" stars.
Feels sooo old fashioned, kind of Scott Walker I guess.
nah.
An interesting cabaret album. Feels like it was very inspiring to many other artists, but simultaneously also not that impressive.
Gross folk, sappy, and musically uninspired.
🤮
There is definitely a mini genre of stuff like this, though I'm struggling to think of others. Clearly American but not country music, self indulgent storytelling lyrics, feels a bit like a dodgy musical. Maybe the guy who does do you know the way to Amarillo fits in to this? Sounds dated even for 1972, felt like it was light entertainment music with an unearned swagger. Not quite a bad as some country music I suppose but not much better.
Jack hit the nail on the head here. Happens I'm currently in Washington DC, so I put this on while I was wandering about. Expected misery. Weirdly somber and theatrical, best track by miles is Family Band, the switch to minor key is tremendous. I can imagine him singing in an old timey bar, horrible piano in the corner, reeks of whiskey. Produced by Bernie Taupin, and once I knew this it felt a bit like Elton John -lite. Like a whole album of Indian Sunsets.
Hmm, this is nice enough, but I kinda agree with the entry in the wiki that says it's an album that never found it's audience.... I really don't know who this is for (it could be Luke). I think it has elements which are pretty good though but I'm never going to listen to this again. 2.5 but probably on the 2 side
Місцями сильний Бродвей-вайб, місцями водевіль-кабере, місцями просто така класична поп-музика. Мені скоріше так, ніж ні. Але не думаю, що повернуся до цього альбому.
Альбом стильний, цікава історія у виконавця (почитав про його звʼязок з Берні та Елтоном), красиві аранжування і красивий вокал. Все це взагалі мені нагадало Скотта Уокера на мінімалках. На мінімалках бо все ж самі пісні не дуже хітові. Але мені було цікаво слухати американську готику, можливо я навіть повернусь до цього альбому колись. 3.5
I don't think this really deserves a 3 but I was only half listening to it. Strong candidate to be edited to a 2.
Muy aburrido
First listen Saved 0/11
Favorite Song: Ballad of the Ship of State Least Favorite: Midnight Carousel
All Music said that this was an album that never found its audience. After about half the album, I think that it needs to keep looking. Dodgy musical theatre.
I assume this is the soundtrack to a really terrible musical. Everything is OTT, even the way he enunciates every word. Can definitely see some bellend on stage performing this in its entirety. Dire.
rym 3.21 Singer-Songwriter/Traditional Pop 娓娓道来的惆怅与喜忧参半的释然,柔软且温暖。后半程有点弱了。 pick: Love's Enough, Oh, California!, Another Friday Night
Great voice
It sounds like a musical score, complete show-tunes vibe. Not bad, but not really into it. Spotify shows that the top track has ~500K plays and nearly all the other ones are below 100K. Unclear why this was chosen for the 1001 list.
Even though I like Elton John broadly speaking, I’ve always felt like I struggled a bit with his music. After listening to this, I now just wonder if I don’t like Bernie Taupin’s songwriting. The guy just wishes he was writing show tunes, and maybe to it’s to John’s credit that he transcends that. The cover of this album is also just unappealing and so bad that I almost come full circle and love it.
Puro teatro, primer album conceptual que me sale, no se por que me recuerda un poco a sobre ratones y hombres
Incredible
I think I need to spend more time with this album to truly appreciate it but I liked what it was doing. And if Elvis Costello says this guy is alright, that's good enough for me.
A lot of angry people in the reviews huh? 4/5
Who is this dude putting out a whole anthology of Broadway caliber bangers!?!?
Cool concept! Enjoyed it, was very different. Top bops: Loves enough Ballad of the ship state One night stand Oh California Blues for billy whitecloud
Erm...no. Weird.
It was a good album. Something I would put on in my free time? Probably not. I wouldn't mind if someone else was playing it. Some solid tracks. 6.3/10
I love show tunes but......
Not terrible but not great either.
This feels like a soundtrack for a musical that doesn't exist. It's pretty good sometimes, I particularly liked American Gothic (the song) and how it felt like a lyrical story, and One Night Stand. That said, Battle of the Ship of State mostly felt kind of dumb, and Midnight Carousel felt like it was trying to be a bad horror song. I didn't hate this, but probably never again.
This is like a vaudeville hosted by both Randy Newman and a suburban version of Scott Walker. The end result is period music for antique shops, which is just jarring to me being contrasted with the digicore music I've been listening to. What makes me dislike this album even more is that last song, "Montana Song". It's too grand and baroque for me. If David stuck to more piano and soft-rock tunes I'd appreciate the cinematic vignettes of American life more (2.5).
What the fuck was that?
Did he bribe the author of the book?
Bon je sais pas peut-être 10 écoutes???
Not sure what to make of this, some of the tracks seems to be mixed poorly with the vocals far to prominent. It sort of sounds like the soundtrack to some pantomime or something. There are some decent moments hidden in there but you have to go digging, overall it’s just not something I would listen to again. 2.0
Not into this. It's like an avant garde musical.
Only enjoyed a single song in the entire record. Not for me.
‘It waits to be rediscovered’ yep, undiscovered more like it
Feels comparable to a b-movie, got me to laugh a few times but probably not intentional
I am not sure I want to hear this again
This is really just not my thing. Nothing stands out in a good or a bad way
thoughts: - I had absolutely no idea what I was getting into here - Ballad of the Ship of State looool what is going on here - this really sounds like a musical, midnight carousel is sooooooooo musical coded
Tucker was right… a theater kids dream :) Also, you can definitely see how this inspired my guy tom waits
oh shit, the group's reviews really shocked me. I loved this tbh, especially the first song. some of the songs were kinda boring or very strange, but I liked it a lot. it was funny how he can go from deep stories with cinematic instrumentals to some very weird stuff, but it was fun
This album ~might have~ influenced Tom Waits, and I ~might have~ enjoyed the album if Waits performed it. The lyrics are good, but the theatrical/musical singing leaves a lot to be desired.
day 6 of not rolling Aja by Steely Dan i think i heard this album at the local community theatre in mercer county where i work sung by some pitchy high school kids
sorry to those who like this. i'm not one.
I think I would've enjoyed this if I saw someone perform it in a one man show format, but I wasn't crazy about it as a standalone album.
Not for me.
I think there’s a timeline where I learn to enjoy this but not today.
A corny musical about America, for people that think Hamilton is too edgy
American Gothic - 7/10. Good. A little weird, but good. Love's Enough - 7/10. Pretty song. Ballad of the Ship of State - 9/10. As relevant as it was in the Nixon times, it is equally relevant and just as bitter an indictment of today and the Drumpf era. One Night Stand - 7/10. Decent song about the life of a musician on the road. Oh! California - 8/10. A fun, twisted show-tune style song. I like it. Another Friday Night - 8/10. I like this a lot. Family Band - 7/10. Very good. Midnight Carousel - 8/10. This sounds like it should be in a musical. Waiting for the Moving Van - 7/10. Solid. Blues for Billy Whitecloud - 8/10. Pretty good. Montana Song - 8/10. I like the idea and the execution of a song telling a family's story. Overall Rating - 3.82/5 (7.64/10). Sounds like Neil Diamond wrote a musical. I can see why it's not for everyone, but it's up my alley.
4/10 Feels a bit embarrassing listening to this - a bit like finding some old guys ill advised sleeve on making a record 23 years ago.