Broken English by Marianne Faithfull

Broken English

Marianne Faithfull

2.9
Rating
23619
Votes
1
8%
2
26%
3
40%
4
21%
5
5%
Distribution

Album Summary

Broken English is the seventh studio album by English singer Marianne Faithfull. It was released on 2 November 1979 by Island Records. The album marked a major comeback for Faithfull after years of drug abuse, homelessness, and suffering from anorexia. It is often regarded as her "definitive recording" and Faithfull herself described it as her "masterpiece". Broken English was Faithfull's first major release since her album Love in a Mist (1967). After ending her relationship with Mick Jagger in 1970 and losing custody of her son, Faithfull's career went into a tailspin as she suffered from heroin addiction and lived on the streets of London. Severe laryngitis and drug abuse during this period permanently altered Faithfull's voice, leaving it cracked and lower in pitch. She attempted a comeback in 1976 with Dreamin' My Dreams, which achieved only minor success. Shortly afterwards, Faithfull began working with musician Barry Reynolds, who produced the songs "Broken English" and "Why D'Ya Do It?". The demos attracted the attention of Chris Blackwell who signed Faithfull to his record label Island Records. The album was recorded at Matrix Studios in London. Faithfull collaborated with producer Mark Miller Mundy on the remaining songs for the album. After the whole album was recorded, he suggested making the music "more modern and electronic" and brought in Steve Winwood on keyboards. Musically, Broken English is a new wave rock album with elements of other genres, such as punk, blues and reggae. Broken English received critical acclaim. It peaked at number 82 on the Billboard 200, becoming her first album to chart in the United States since Go Away from My World (1965) and giving Faithfull a first nomination for the Grammy Award for Best Female Rock Vocal Performance. It reached number 57 in the United Kingdom and entered the top five in Germany, France and New Zealand. Broken English was certified platinum in Germany and France and sold over one million copies worldwide. Two singles were released from the album, with "The Ballad of Lucy Jordan" peaking at number 48 on the UK Singles Chart. The album was included on NME magazine's list of "500 Greatest Albums of All Time" and in the book 1001 Albums You Must Hear Before You Die.

Wikipedia Read more on Wikipedia

Rating Over Time

Per Year Cumulative

Reviews

Sort by: Hot Popular Date Random
Rating: All 5★ 4★ 3★ 2★ 1★
Length: All Short Long

I had no expectations either way going into this, but I ended up liking it.

Without the context of this being a bit of a comeback album I feel like it doesn't really stand out in any way.

Pure garbage. Heard more enjoyable voices at bar karaoke. The Ballad of Lucy Jones is just a Walmart (deeply Walmart) Desolation Row. Why’d Ya Do It might be the worst song on this list so far. The only thing worth a damn on it is the John Lennon song. And even then you’re totally fine with never hearing it.

I get that this album has a good backstory, but for the most part, it sounds like older music dressed up in new wave clothes. The production is very 80s even though it came out in 1979, so that's quite an innovative feat. But more like bad overproduced 80s mainstream rock music than minimal synth or jagged post-punk. The last track was a jump scare - I can't tell if that is in a good or bad way.

I enjoyed this album. The YouTube music album says it’s from 2013, and I was very confused why this 80s album says that. So I looked into it and it’s from the 70s. Very interesting voice and learning her backstory is more interesting. An angry album ahead of its time. Like a 1979s jagged little pill.

Not really into with this one. It's not bad, I just didn't vibe with the voice/style combo. I was actually pleasantly surprised by the final track "Why'd Ya Do It" which I loved!

Revisit again. Great band and poetic delivery.

Kinda washed over me

The album just seemed to be pleasant and pass me by as I was listening. That was until ‘why’d ya do it’ WOW that opened my eyes- I tried getting the lyrics up on Amazon music but it didn’t show them so I had to listen again and again and sure enough what I thought I had heard I absolutely did! Whoever cheated on her to get this song reaction is epic. I hope they share the royalties 🤣 Best track- ‘why’d ya do it’ Worst track- ‘brain drain’ the fact I completely missed it and had to listen again and still zoned out said it all. Average at best I’m afraid. 5/10

Marianne Faithfull - Broken English A different sounding album to so much that is on this list. Has the haunted, menacing sound of European, pre-Glasnost new wave which somehow still sounds like the future. Can imagine Faithfull's voice may not be to everyone's taste, but it has the sound of experience, of life, of wisdom. Weary, worn but defiant. The production on this is understated, ensuring the vocals are always front and centre. Really enjoyed this. Three spins in a single day says as much. Best Track - Broken English but Witches Song and the prickly Why'd Ya Do It? are close behind. Worst Track - wasnt keen on The Ballad of Lucy Jordan even though it was the hit from the album. But the only track that I skipped on later listens was Brain Drain. 7.5/10

A very interesting record that completely melts the boundaries between 70s and 80s sounds. Not so many memorable songs though.

Her singing is fucking terrible

Sounds like Patti Smith and Steevi Nicks’s far less-talented cousin.

Mostly disco-like rhythms, with a Lennon cover, and a crass punk ending.

Olin kuullut Marianne Faithfullilta lähinnä vain Stones-cover As Tears Go Byn ja Metallican Memory Remainsin, jossa hän teki mieleenpainuvan vierailun. Tämä oli aika mielenkiintoinen levy ja hieman erilainen kuin odotin. Saundit ovat lähellä 70-luvun lopun uutta aaltoa ja päätösraita oli melko vihaisesti tulkittu. En ole varma pidinkö aina Faithfullin käheästä äänestä, mutta Broken English on ehdottomasti kuulemisen arvoinen.

Mostly ok whatever but wow that last song ha

Didn't really grab my attention.

I mean… didn’t hate it, but found myself turning down the volume. 2.4

The story behind this is pretty inspiring and Marianne has a really interesting voice that blends well with the 80's style. However, I just am not that into this Favorite Song: Brain Drain

Nope. Some of the songs are interesting lyrically but no way would I ever listen to this again. Thoroughly unpleasant in a way I can’t put my finger on. Highlight: Working class hero

I don’t enjoy the music. The style. Her voice. The lyrics. Just no.

Broken English (sangen): rigtig groovy og moody 4/5. Working Class Hero: virkelig godt cover, måske bedre end originalen. Why'd ya do it: masser af vrede og god guitar Også kæmpe shoutout for at synge med på The Memory Remains 10/10 nanana.

Interesting lyrics and back story, but not really for me. I found her voice a bit annoying and nothing really stood out. Seemed like something she needed to talk about, but I didn’t need to hear.

Prima album

Never heard of this artist, and from what I've read this album is pretty different from her previous works. This opens really strong with a poppy new wave anthem that puts Marianne's vocal immediately on display. I really wanted more like this, but the rest of the album is just experimenting with other styles, most of which diminish the power of her voice. Much of it is still enjoyable, just never hits that high-water line again... Until the closer. It's a weird little punk-reggae (very ‘80s sounding) number where the vocal and lyrics become weaponized. She sounds like Wendy O Williams from The Plasmatics, and commands the same power with her voice. A truly fantastic song.

That was so much better than that god-awful Destiny's Child that I got given yesterday. Listen to it all the way through twice in a row.

This album is a grower for sure. I wasn’t sold by the first few songs, but I was fully invested by the time Working Class Hero and Why’d Ya Do It came on. Interesting reading up about her life as well. It’s clear she had some really high highs and low lows. Amazing that she came out with an album like this after being chewed up and spit out by the industry.

An alright listen. I liked her voice, but there was nothing I felt very strongly about.

Decent enough, not sure it particularly stands out from other similar music though.

Conviction, or something simulating it extremely well.

Really boring...and her voice in honestly awful

I liked this more than I thought I would (and I've always been fond of the song, a staple of early 80s alternative radio).

Man was Marianne Faithful pretty in the 60’s. I knew of her because of her connection with the Stones, but I never really listened to her music. This album was actually pretty good. But I can’t help but feel sadness when listening to it. You can hear the drugs in her voice. Compare this to her cover of “Tears Go By” and it’s staggering. Life destroyed this woman. Reading on her life and hearing songs like “Guilt” is kind of heartbreaking.

An interesting album

Okee. Het is te luisteren. Soms een beetje bombastische muziek en wat monotone zangeres.

Not one for me - few decent sounding tracks but very little that grabbed me.

Definitely in my personal top 100 with "Broken English", and very listenable complementary tunes.

I had to look at the date this came out as I thought it was a 90's album. Way ahead of her time. Some songs are great, some are just ok. Overall, I thought it was a decent album.

Strange, not terrible, but not really my vibe.

Right, to sum it up rather more succinctly: I have three fairly fundamental problems with this album. And then there’s a fourth factor that’s open to debate. The main problem is the sound palette. Call it the arrangements, if you like. This album dates from 1979 and deserves a dubious distinction: it may well be the first record to be completely ruined by eighties production. My God, does this sound ugly. Everything is hollow, empty, artificial, plastic and, above all, just plain ugly. The absolute low point is probably the best-known track on the album, and by far the most streamed: ‘The Ballad of Lucy Jordan’. Who on earth came up with this monstrosity of a sound? The melody is formed, played, whatever, by something I can only describe as a sort of keyboard warbling. It’s an extraordinarily ugly noise, and I honestly can’t think of anything else that sounds quite like it. This brings me to my second objection. In my mind, I had put Marianne Faithfull in the singer-songwriter box, alongside the many artists who emerged in the late sixties and throughout the seventies. The English Joni Mitchell, so to speak. That was what I was expecting. But this is straightforward pop music. With one exception, the songs are pretty standard stuff – call them dull or predictable – and yes, here comes my favourite criticism again: musically, very little happens. Because the music itself doesn't seem to matter all that much; this is thirty-seven and a half minutes of La Faithfull singing songs. Not really my cup of tea. The one exception is the closing track, ‘Why’d Ya Do It’ – or, as I would put it, why didn’t ya do it more often? – where an electric guitar suddenly makes an appearance and we are given a rather violent shake awake in the Chesterfield armchair in which we had by now drifted into a deep sleep. Then there’s a rather curious production decision. The album opens with its three worst tracks. The title track gets away with it, just about; at least there’s some energy in it. The next two songs, ‘Witches’ Song’ and ‘Brain Drain’, are thoroughly miserable low points. And the fourth track, ‘Guilt’, sounds mainly like a mediocre Tina Turner rip-off (which is chronologically inaccurate, since Turner’s solo success was still to come; if anything, the influence would have to run the other way), made even more hideous by some truly dreadful synthesised bass. So anyone encountering the album for the first time – whether listening at home or standing at the counter of a record shop in the old days, putting on a pair of headphones in one of those listening booths – is unlikely to be terribly impressed. Especially if, like me, they happen to be a woman. Though admittedly, ninety per cent of record-shop customers seemed to be men. Have you ever seen a woman in a record shop who didn't have a potential purchase gift-wrapped? Things do pick up considerably after that, starting with the aforementioned ‘The Ballad of Lucy Jordan’. It’s not a bad song, it just sounds so bloody ugly. But I think I’ve made that point already. The John Lennon cover ‘Working Class Hero’ is also worth a listen, as is the closing track, which has as much energy as the other thirty-one minutes combined. Actually, no. More. And then there’s the debatable point, which isn't necessarily a deal-breaker for me but is undeniably something that needs discussing: Marianne Faithfull’s voice. Well. Let’s just call it what it is: wrecked. No doubt the result of years of abuse of just about every substance going. It is rather remarkable, then, that this album was a relatively commercial success. Oh, and singer-songwriter? No way. Clearly, I know next to nothing about Faithfull. She co-wrote three of the eight songs, alongside four or even five other people. On the rest, she simply sings. So why the passing grade? Well, I’ve certainly given it enough listens. My initial verdict was devastating, largely because of that appalling plastic sound. But in all fairness, my appreciation grew, albeit only in tiny increments, with each subsequent listen. I can’t deny that some of the songs – particularly Lucy Jordan – lodged themselves rather firmly in my head. So, in the spirit of occasionally being a little kinder to pop music and female singers, it scrapes through with a pass. Better publish this quickly before I change my mind.

Has such a distinct early 80s sound which is crazy given the state of the london music scene in 1979. in saying that it’s not the most impressive thing i’ve ever heard. i would maybe go back to one or two songs.

Fiz um esforço pra escutar e tentar gostar mas não teve jeito.. não é de todo ruim, mas pra mim, um disco bem descartável.

never has a single album made instantly 'get' an artist as much as this one.

Surprisingly raw, I love the production, even if I'm not that into her vocals.

This is not an album i needed to hear. The musical choices are mostly boring and her voice is not great. Arrogance is when you make an album of songs you don’t have the talent or actual mojo to bring off. I’m not feeling charitable, this is a 1.

Doesn’t, like, seem to be a “singer” or “musician” or “artist”.

Not my cup of tea. Can't picture revisiting this one.

Can hear the influence she had on PJ Harvey and Courtney Love

I go back and forth on this one. On one hand, I really appreciate what's going on here musically, and it sounds very 80's despite this being in '79. So musically this seems ahead of its time. But her vocals reeeeeally aren't working with me on the first listen. I'll settle for a 3. Maybe they grow on you.

There's a good album in there I think but I can't get past the 80s goth synth sound to get to the songs and voice. That might be my issue but it is what it is.

This album rocks. I didn't know about Marianne at all, what a story. "Witches' Song" and "Ballad of Lucy Jordan" are stand outs.

She was oh so very good

It’s alright.

An usher for the 80's sound that was soon to come. I can imagine Faithfull's influence on Kate Bush, Bonnie Tyler, and other distinct experimental pop stars. While not to my particular tastes, I can understand the love and adoration for this record.

hmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmmm

I understand the singificant of this album for Marianne, but this was just generally a miss for me. I couldn't warm up to her voice and generally found the music underwhelming. Generally good lyrics though.

There are a lot of really good albums like this one. There are a lot of really bad albums like this one. There are a lot of really interesting albums like this one. There are a lot of really boring albums like this one. There are a lot of albums that I’ve heard like this one. There are a lot of albums that I haven’t heard like this one. What I can conclude is that this is definitely an album and that’s what it will always be.

First song tricked me into thinking I was gonna love this. A bunch of middling tracks follow, and then I liked the last two again. So I'd call this a mixed bag.

Faithfull's tryout for The Memory Remains 18 years later. But seriously, this is heartbreaking: "After ending her relationship with Mick Jagger in 1970 and losing custody of her son, Faithfull suffered from heroin addiction and lived on the streets of London. Severe laryngitis and drug abuse during this period permanently altered Faithfull's voice, leaving it cracked and lower in pitch."

I like it in moments but this is far more interesting backstory than listening experience.

More forgetable british new wave album with terrible singer yayyyyy. Im so tired of these fucking albums. This is very mid, forgetable, new wave, british and the singer was, in fact, not good. I dont know what to fucking write this is bad.

I had heard her name, but I didn’t know she started in the 60s and dated Mick Jagger. I am really wondering why I don’t hear of her more along with the likes of Joni Mitchell and Carly Simon. Her music seems to have been popular enough. Love her voice, but heartbreaking that it was due to drugs and alcohol. Need to check out her earlier stuff. Good music, great lyrics. Great album, this.

The ballad of Lucy Jordan: the song playing while Thelma and Louise make their epic feminist plunge off the cliff!! My college roommate’s and I watched that movie countless times during our freshman year - so that song feels synonymous with that time in my life. It’s also the reason I bought the soundtrack. It wasn’t until the era of streaming that I finally dug further into Faithfull, loving her Cyndi Lauper-esque tone I was suprised to learn she predated Lauper. I had assumed she was a late 80’s era singer. Standouts also include the punk “why’d you do it” and the album opener, “broken English” which reflects on the Baader-Meinhof terrorism of the Red Army Faction of 1979 - when this album came out. I also read about her bio and learned that after ending her relationship with Mick Jagger in 1970 and losing custody of her son, Faithfull suffered from heroin addiction and lived on the streets of London. Severe laryngitis and drug abuse during this period permanently her voice, leaving it cracked and lower in pitch.

Eh. 1.75

bold and gritty and shocking. i love women especially women with something to say.

Voz particular, sus interpretaciones se salen de la casilla de lo habitual aunque hay algunas que calzan justo en el molde de lo mainstream en este momento Empezó de menos a más a mi parecer La canción más alabada del álbum es la que menos me gustó definitivamente Tiene talento y aprecié la creatividad, simplemente no es mi tipo

This was good. The john lennon cover was something. But overall very enjoyable

The cover of Working Class Hero is really good.

I enjoyed it fine but I wasn’t crazy about it. Her lyrics were the best part for me. I like how explicit they are in their intent; there’s really no beating around the bush with her. But the music itself wasn’t super compelling to me. I’ve long loved the closing track but in the context of the rest of the album it didn’t sound as evocative as it does against other music in a playlist. *Fav tracks: Why’d Ya Do It; Guilt*

Gear: ZMF Bokeh Closed Artwork: 🚬👄👤 Production: 🎛️🥧☺️ Music: 😏🤨🥲 Rating: 🗣️🗣️(🗣️)/5

Parts of this I like a lot on second listen. Pretty visceral lyrics in the last song. Brain Drain and Guilt are both very good songs. The former sounds a lot like Swamp by Talking Heads. Enjoy the funk. Pretty good. 7/10

An interesting listen with songs featuring unique instrumentation. Why’d You Do It is raunchy as hell!

Damn this was good!

This was painful. Someone please put this woman out of her misery (and us, too).

(I know this recording predates her success but it’s as…) If a tired, old Cyndi Lauper who can’t hit all her notes any more made an album. This is not good music. All the songs sound the same. Another whiff on the 1001 list.

The is an interesting collection of genres here …. too bad they all had to be interpreted by Mary Ann Faithful.

Marianne Faithfull has been through the wringer , and now after listening to this so have we.

listened to this on full last year in 2025 a few days after marianne passed away, banger after banger. may her soul rest in peace

Was expecting smokey lounge tunes and that's what I got

Aggressively fine Don't really care for her voice much, honestly. Kinda grating. I take it back, this is some cringe trash.

𝘉𝘳𝘰𝘬𝘦𝘯 𝘌𝘯𝘨𝘭𝘪𝘴𝘩 has a dark, worn-down atmosphere that suits the material well, but Marianne Faithfull’s voice never quite works for me. I understand why its roughness is such a defining part of the album, yet her delivery often feels too flat and limited to keep me engaged. The production is much more interesting, with its cold new-wave edge and electronic touches giving the songs some tension. Unfortunately, I keep wishing the vocals had the same range and movement. A distinctive record, but one where the voice at the centre is also the main reason I struggle with it.

What a fascinating person Marianne Faithfull was. And this is a very good record. Some of the arrangements are, well, very 1979 and not quite my thing, I mostly forgot about them while listening to every word she sang.

Okay album, not a fan of the vocals. Middle of the road and forgettable. 3/5

Was not a fan at all. I like the idea and wish I had liked the music better!

Album #289 Marianne Faithfull: Broken English This is one of the more interesting albums that this list has introduced me to. This almost feels like a sort of proto-Kate Bush, and I can see how it is very influential. It’s also pretty impressive for a 60s artist to adapt so well to the new wave/ post-punk sound, which is a transition that many failed to manage. There are quite a few tracks on this album where I’m fully invested and bought in on the sound; however, there are just as many where I’m left cold and quite bored. I think with albums that try to be dissonant, they sometimes start to become so distant that they lose the listener, and that certainly happened to me a few times on this one. Still a pretty interesting listen with some definite highlights, though perhaps an album more revered for its influence than its quality. Best Songs: Why’d Ya Do It?, The Ballad of Lucy Jordan, Broken English Worst Song: What’s The Hurry Score out of 10: 7

Favorite Track: Working Class Hero

It wasn't my taste, but I can see how she was an inspiration to numerous artists who followed.

This is the woman that *sang* that horrible part in that horrible Metallica song. I wasn't expecting much, nor did this album deliver much.

Pretty good album. I don’t think it’s groundbreaking or anything, but it’s a solid album.

Honestly this album simply didn’t compel me at all

Pretty good album. Probably won’t revisit but enjoyed the listen.

Had it's moments! but probably not something I would revisit.

Some hits, some misses. Might be better on a re-listen. The Ballad of Lucy Jordan is amaaazing though, such a good song. Why D'ya Do It was also a good track. Her voice is weird but I like it.

This one shook me up a bit, especially reading the story of the album and that she struggled with drug addiction and was homeless in London before recording it, an experience which permanently altered her voice, and you can here it cracking in the album, which really makes all her life experiences hit home, and the music is raw and emotional...damn. I just keep thinking about it.

This was pretty good and also her background is crazy.

The working class hero cover out of nowhere was a fun twist

Not bad. Kinda liked

Never had heard of her, but actually wasn’t too bad. Some good stuff some stuff but overall pretty good