Reviews (page 8 of 9)
во первых очень красивая обложка, вау сам альбом тоже классный мне понравился
This album and the band are all new to me, and I really like this work. I read the Wikipedia entries on the album and the band, and it's an interesting history and context. Someone could've played this album for me without any explanation or background and asked me to guess when it was released, and no doubt I would get it wrong. I like their layering of harmonies and rhythms; nothing feels forced or rushed yet it's not sleep-inducing. Very cool.
Annoying, self-indulgent dreck only an album critic could love
The best thing I can say about this is that it was mostly inoffensive. Best track: ?
chill vibe
I got excited when I realized it was going to be all instrumental, but it never really rose above passing the time alright
It’s the kind of music you put on at a party when you want your guests to say “What the f$&k is this?”
Not bad for background noise. Nothing of note, musically.
Centered around a twenty minute opening salvo that combines glitchy electronica, ECM jazz and muted post-rock, Millions Now Living Will Never Die sees Tortoise take their place amongst the ever changing landscape of alternative rock (or whatever remained of it) and forging fertile ground in the process.
Cute, but it felt forced, so no. Glass Museum stood out, but like this album, nothing I would come back to. Maybe to help me sleep?
Not my thing. There were good moments, then sometimes they got ruined. Nothing I’d come back to.
A band called tortoise!? An edgy title!? I think I might like this... Bruh did I get baited into listening to an album's worth of elevator music what the hell is this 20 minute bs. Ok so the rest of the album is great, i like it a lot, but goddamn, 20 of 43 mins being a mid (to be kind) song is heinous, 3.5 bc I'm feeling generous, but it rounds down to a 3... I did really like the rest of the songs tho
This album is just boring. It’s the kind of album I should like. I’m the target audience here. I focus on music without giving lyrics any thought and I like the era and genre. If I can’t find any value in this, I can’t imagine other people do. My music taste would would indicate that I should love this, yet, alas, I do not.
This would absolutely be okay as background music to write to or something, but also, I've heard better video game music for that purpose.
Now that was a bit out there
Elevator música on lsd
Great listening, very complex and it flowed well.
Not my style
10/10 this album has nearly everything I’m a total sucker for complete perfection from beginning to end
The description said post rock, and it definitely is in places, but overall it felt more imo like that kinda krautrock infused sci fi "wavescape" type stuff... either way, really enjoyable for a dawn walk up the beach. Fit surprisingly well. Would listen to the first track in a playlist. 4/5
4.0
Took me by surprise as a solid album. Is it deserving of being on this list? I'm doubtful but I'm glad to have listened to it and so I'm happy with it.
A spooky and atmospheric listen. Perfect for a slow afternoon, though the opening track could have used some editing.
It’s really good
Enjoyed,decent but not something I'd listen to repeatedly
There's no chance I'd like this normally, but it was a vibe while ****
Nice, serene, atmospheric.
Pretty chill instrumental-type album. I saved Glass Museum. Definitely a few sections of Djed that caught my ear too, but 20 mins is too long of a song for me to add and not absolutely love. Cool discovery, never heard of this band before but can see how they would be unique for the 90s.
Fine album
Rock instrumental/ambiental/psicodélico. Rallante. Un 2.
Conocía el anterior. Éste me ha aburrido un poco.
Prefer their later albums that have a bit more oomph. Not a bad listen though.
Interesting………
Great for listening in one go. Driving music. I like the erratic changes, harmony and flow, as well as variety of instruments and rhythms
So it's got a similar ambient vibe as the Aphex Twin album the list just gave me, but the songs are distinctive and not simply a collection a bleeps and bloops with a couple of samples thrown in. This is an album that you can actively listen to and have a satisfying experience, and not just have on in the background and kind of ignore while you're doing something else. You absolutely could have this on in the background, but it's not the only state it functions well in (which was the issue with that Aphex Twin album). I'd equate listening to this with listening to a jazz album instead of using the post-rock label - you can let wash over you, but there's also a lot of interesting musical interplay if you're listening closely. The opener, Djed, has that in spades. A Suvery is built around an ominous bass riff, Glass Museum and The Taut and the Tame have some great chiming keyboards or vibraphone playing off of some heavier guitar. Along the Banks of Rivers has some cool spaghetti western guitar running through it. The drums sound a bit thin throughout the album, which makes things sound a bit more tame, but that's my big quibble with this record.
listened to again good rainy road trip music if you want to zone out for a bit
Super chill. Really liked this.
"Post-rock" holy shit fuck me up fam. Update: This was awesome, loved it! Need to check out more from this band.
I like Post-Rock. I like this. easy really. It's more jazzier and a bit jammier than other bands I like with whiffs of Can and Eno but it hold firm until the end.
Easy listening
Pretty good. I liked how experimental it is.
Good, offbeat, original, electronic.
Interesting post-punk noise. I liked it.
Is there a worse name for a genre than post-rock? The name carries a distinct whiff of pomposity, of rock being beneath it. I know the name post-punk has exactly the same lexical structure, but that at least harked to the contemporary state of affairs: punk had died and the bands inspired by punk sought to construct something new on the ashes. When the first bands got labelled post-rock (admittedly not by themselves, but by critics eager to prove their pretentiousness), rock wasn't on the mortuary slab: if we take the early 90s as when post-rock became codified, we have grunge shooting into alternative on one side of the Atlantic, Oasis proclaiming that they were rock 'n' roll stars, and metal had long been established as rock's hardy perennial. Still, rock has been pronounced dead for as long as rock as been alive (apparently, the rock critic Richard Meltzer declared rock dead in 1968), so perhaps I'm being too harsh on a legitimate ambition to move away from the limitations of the rock template. But even this smacks of reductionism. Rock has always been adaptive and audacious in its experiments and its thefts (the oft-called freakiest album in the canon is Trout Mask Replica, which is obviously an album that belongs within the classification of rock), so I don't buy the line that post-rock bands are aiming beyond rock. "Post-rock" is essentially a euphemism for "rock what's a bit weird". Not that that's a bad thing at all, but why gussy it up? Anyway, Tortoise are a Chicagoan collective ("band" seems to miss the point) that started when a few refugees from hardcore punk and alternative rock decided that they wanted to show everyone that they could really play their instruments. As such, their music claimed inspiration from electronica, dub, krautrock (uh-oh, that pesky work "rock"), ambient, progressive rock (that damned word again) and fucktons of jazz. This, their second album, took plaudits by the gallon in 1996's end-of-year assessments. And it's fine. It's fine. The music is good, engaging, smart. Writing about it beyond that seems to miss the point, or at least it would bore both me and you, my friendly chunkers. The main jab I have to make is that it doesn't truly elevate me. It doesn't send me to the paradisiac realms, unlike my most beloved albums. And bizarrely, I feel that's not quite its intended purpose. Millions Now Living Will Never Die feels like it just wants to be perfectly good, in the sense of having no bad notes whatsoever, and I guess it manages that. But that lack of abrasion makes it almost inhuman, like it's a computer program rather than a piece of music. Voltaire once wrote that the best is the enemy of the good. With Tortoise, the good is the enemy of the best. I want Tortoise to embrace the imperfection of humanity. I want Tortoise to come out of their shell (thanks for the applause, you've been a wonderful audience!).
Chill wordless music, not overly complex. Was good for listening to in rainy walk.
4.5
Interesting enough
It matched the start to my work day. A bit dull and I was glad when it was over. But nah, seriously, it’s just not my kind of music, but I appreciate the effort.
Still like TNT better.
Pretty bad, pretty boring, really odd. Like someone listened to the instrumentals from Radiohead albums and decided to make a tribute compilation.
Ik hou van post-rock. Dus ook dit album was zeer welkom. Lekker instrumentaal, en net vreemd genoeg dat het goed is
First song was ok. Then I thought it had finished, but no! It had devolved into this mushy slow ambient horror. The second song has a good riff, but like all instrumental stuff it sounds like they're jamming but they don't get anywhere. Sounds are OK but I need songs with lyrics.
This is a pretty good instrumental album with some interesting sounds and soundscapes. I'm not a fan of all tracks and this album took me a few listens to get in the groove with it Djed at 21 mins has near on half the runtime of the album. It has some fantastic sections but also has some god awful ones that ruin the listening experience. Sadly this one track is a bit of a downer for the experience. 3/5
4/10 maybe it is a post rock fundamental album, but it is not that great
this has to be sarcastic right? pretty opener to the opening song, but a little hard to listen to while working. Started a 3, but +1 star because it's accoustic.
Interesante
Pretty boring so mayyyybe good cleaning music or something like that
Electronic, post rock 90s music. Not bad. Almost too chill
Boring, over-indulgent.
I'm sure that it is technically very competent. A little like Tangerine Dream in many ways and not just in that some over pretentious musicians like them while it leaves nearly everyone else absolutely cold. I was hoping that the first track was ending but when I checked it was roughly half way through. One I will leave to the afficionados.
In keeping with the sound-manipulation-posing-as-percussion on its central work, Millions Now Living is an exercise in blurring lines. Krautrock worship is easily Tortoise's strongest side: The melodies don't have the compositional or improvisational weight to really recommend them. But if they linger too long, it's a slight offense, and there is some care in the arranging, and all tones retain something more than nil. Half derivative and half niche, the final minutes underwhelm the scales; Still glad I listened for the niche.
This was pretty much an electronic album but done by a band with the instruments of a rock band. Surprisingly that made it a tad better than most electronic albums. I still found this to be relatively boring but slightly enjoyable at times. This album isn’t anything too special and likely won’t be revisited. 3.8/10
I don't have a problem with the genre at all, i like a bit of post rock and i like a bit of ambient, but this straddles the two in a bad way. it's aimless, its neither one genre nor the other. if it was post rock it would have a crushing crescendo, if it was ambient it would create a place but it does neither. either that or the place it creates is a menu screen on a mid quality computer game, which is not particularly a place i want to be.
Hey there Debbie, how's your old man doing? Does he still have to think about me just to get an erection? I feel sorry for the bloke. Poor sod has to sling his limp meat up your festering shit hole too.
Tortoise innit 🐢
Almost a classic but not quite. 4 stars. Tortoise's Millions Now Living Will Never Die presents a bass-heavy, tranquil and intriguing post-rock sound which would come to have a profound influence on the nascent sub-genre, radically expanding the territory of post-rock from that staked out by Talk Talk in years past.* * Yes, I did just copy and paste this after a brief Google search. It's 5am and I am hungover alright, what more do you want from me you pack of pricks!?
Amazing experience, will definitely listen many times again. Great opus.
Thoroughly enjoyed this. This will likely be played more often when working
I enjoyed this one! I’ll have to give it another listen but it sounds like a less developed Godspeed you! Black Emperor, pretty great!
I like lyrics in my music
Immediately lost 2 stars for having a fucking 20 minute track, and didn’t have many stars to begin with. I didn’t know lofi could make it on this list.
Sounded nice, not my bag.
Excellent instrumental album.
Peaceful, exciting, and delightfully complex. I'm glad learned about this band, they provide Can levels of bliss. "The Taut and Tame" blew me away.
Þokkalegt áhlustunar. Einhvers konar undanfari Explosions in the sky.
not bad, if you like this kind of music
Enjoyed this one. Definitely worth another listen
Intressant niet echt mijn stijl
Fuck me sideways, but that was tedious - and I say that as a fan of prog rock. I was all for giving it a 1, but I almost enjoyed Along The Banks Of Rivers.
Enjoyed it. Ambient music-ish
Cool little album. A few of the songs are very ambient to the point where there’s not much going on, but the other few kind of just flow and have some nice moments. 6/10
Very chill but not quite interesting enough
I was very excited when I started listening to this album. I thought it would be another wild electronic-filled album, but as it went on I realized that it was atmospheric guitar music. Decent album, but nothing I would listen to on my own. Best Songs: Glass Museum, Along the Banks of Rivers Worst Songs: NA
rock experimental? nada de especial
I've never heard of Tortoise before and Millions Now Living Will Never Die is all new music to me. The opening track "Djed" started off with sounds that reminded me of Pink Floyd, but as the track moved on I was reminded of some of Wilco's work. "Djed" was the longest track, shifting through a few movements, and my favorite track. Non of the tracks had vocals. The music was acoustic, but it sounded like it was put together with an electronic sensibility. I liked the album enough to listen to the bonus tracks from the Japenese edition. I could come back for a second listen.
I can see why this is so strongly cited as an influential album. One that takes some time and effort, but definitely worth it.
Barely a three. I've always found Tortoise to be the most boring of the first wave post-rock bands. I much prefer Slint or Talk Talk.
C'est pas mauvais, mais je pense que j'indie en général je suis juste moins fan. Je comprends l'engouement par contre, l'aspect atmosphérique est très nice.
I do enjoy instrumental music, but nothing from this album has caught my full attentionThe music was just merely ok, not something that I would seek out or actively choose to listen to. As a background while doing something else it serves a fine purpose.
Gives me pink floyd vibes. I dig the creativity.
Pulling from the likes of Neu!, Tortoise is content with having a strong rhythmic foundation to build upon. This makes for some nice exploration of sound, as different instruments and melodies drop in and out of the space. Then, before you know it, there's a switch. Going from acoustic instrumentation to almost glitchy electronic beats. It feels almost unsettling, moving from one phase to another, existing within stark contrast of each other. All of this is contained within Djeb, the behemoth first track on the album. Then the rest of the album plays out. It's very similar to Djeb but not as long. A lot of it does tend to come across as aimless jams, but the instrumentation choices make up for this I think. To me, Tortoise are like underwater explorers, swimming along different currents and getting acquainted with different wildlife. This is the music they make, and it's worth checking out.
Interesting sound. Never heard of it before... Good music to get something done. Was not expecting so much bass from everything on this album. Only observation would be they it feels like an edging exercise...massive culmination for an unexisting climax. 3*
A bit too conceptual for me. Why is the first track on a 45min album over 20mins long?!
J'ai attendu la durée d'un album que Tortoz pose sa voix sur l'instrumentale. Ce moment n'arriva pas.
Difficile de comprendre ce changement de direction artistique radical de Tortoz. Le fameux compère de Mister V nous propose ici un album dénué de toute sorte de musicalité, après une carrière pourtant bien remplie dans le milieu du rap français.
It's not that it was a bad album I just wouldn't choose to listen to this type of music unless to go to sleep or background music. Maybe that is shallow of me but, eh.
Filmische achtergrondmuziek. Ik vind het wel wat hebben. Melodieuze muziek in een taal die we allemaal spreken: instrumen-taal :-) Grappig hoe 1 nummer een hele wereldreis presenteert. Daarnaast zijn er nog wat nummers die het album opvullen, haha. **
Post rock at its finest. Long drawn out sections blast into strange time signatures and then quiet again. A classic of the genre. Best Tracks: Djed; Glass Museum; Taut and Tame;
2 minutes?
I see how the post-rock stuff done here could influence modern prog metal stuff I like....but this still doesn't do it for me. Weird, but not interesting to me.
It faded into the background like beige emulsion on a wall, it might as well not have been there at all. Not for me.
Jazz rock or post rock? Important question, because then one can determine whether to compare this to - say - Electric Miles and Mahivishnu Orchestra, or to Mogwai and Godspeed! You Black Emperor. Why does this matter? The album is improvison weak, but sonically adventurous. I’m going with Post Rock.
Slowcore music. Jam-type, no lyrics. First song is 20 minutes - FYI. It's meh. Prob 2-3 stars. Not for me
Vaya M
I thought this was interesting. The only post rock I have in my collection is Jambinai, which I don't know if I would call that post rock. The first track probably could have been broken up into different movements as the ideas went along. I have to wonder if they play only portions of it live or not. Instrumentals like this, it's hard to imagine them playing exactly note for note live, because it sounds more like a jam in the studio. Still, it' nice background music and I appreciated it for what it was. Do I need to listen to it again to find deeper meaning? Probably not, but it's there if I wanted to. Up on the high 3's, I think. Rounds up to a 4. I think it may warrant another listen.
Interesting and enjoyable to listen to. I think I knew of Tortoise back in the 90's (friends may have mentioned them) but never listened to any of their stuff. Feels like easy background listening. But not sure I'm going to run out and listen to more of their stuff or go discover the post rock genre. I can see how a non-rock person would find this completely boring.
I bought this album back in the 90s after getting into Godspeed and wanting to explore a bit more of the post-rock genre. It's been a long time since I put this on to listen to. My impressions today are similar to those I had when I first got it. There's a lot of good ideas here and some interesting experimentation. The band is definitely trying to do something new here. The opening track Djed seems a bit disjointed to me though. I like most of what by brain calls "side 2" which is tracks 2 - 6. "Glass Museum" and "Along the Banks of Rivers" being the high points for me.
It was OK. The first song was really tedious but the others were more palatable. I like other albums in the genre better and honestly I don't feel too compelled to ever revisit this.
The post-rock pigeon hole makes it sound more pretentious than it is is. Experimental and much lighter than other post rock offerings like Slint (still love Slint though)
A 24 min track normally disqualifies me from liking an album. Overall I grew to like it with every listen - musicianship is great, the production sublime - but in essence it only serves as pleasant background music in my opinion - it doesn’t grab you and demand you give it attention - and maybe that’s not necessarily a bad thing - but when The Taut and Tame kicks in with a beat resembling The Clash’s ‘I Fought the Law’ my heart pumps every time with expectation and gets dismayed that it’s back to post rock. There is one standout track - the Morricone influenced ‘Along the Banks of Rivers’ to me - the rest is just ok.
experimental wallpaper music. smooth textures, nice driving rhythms and interesting digital sounds and glitchy effects. very psychedelic with unusual arrangements. "glass museum" is heavy. great guitar and drums, cute bell tone. "a survey" is dark, mysterious and foreboding. the chirping insect ambience adds a sense of exploration. "the taut and the tame" sounds like stepping into an arena, ready for the boss fight. perfect accompaniment to the prior track (right down to the same guitar tones). the break and subsequent rhythm - plus unique distorted synth sounds - is great and feels like the soundtrack of a gritty street showdown. the final song, "along the banks of rivers" is the darkest song on the project. incredibly ominous, a vague mood of weary apprehension. the sound of going to hell and back.
Ok-ish background music
Not sure what to do with that title. I think I heard this record in late '90s but it didn't stick. Glad to hear again, though probably unlikely to stick, which means I can’t pack it as a desert-island disc.
A very good instrumental if your into soundscapes
What it sounded like to get a massage in 1996 without a happy ending.
je m’attendais pas à ça
It would be so easy to say "post rock's not my genre", give it a 1 and move on but I sense that if I listened to this more I might find something pretty cool going on here. On the other hand, I might find that it's a complete snoozefest. I'll listen to this again sometime and, who knows, I might even end up forming a point of view. Until then, 3 --
I did something different with this one – I read the review before listening, which wasn’t a good idea, because I became annoyed that someone came up with a genre name as uninspiring as “post-rock”. At least “post-punk” replaced a far worse name, ‘New Wave”, and punk, for the most part, had actually ended, with the exception of those highly irritating American hardcore bands. Anyway, the first listen was drowned out by my sneering, but I became more interested the second time around. I liked the textures and their courage in making a 100% instrumental LP. I didn’t turn off Spotify when it offered up more Tortoise tracks. My co-judge says it’s nice background music.
I'm so glad to find Tortoise on this list as they're not very well known, but are one of my favourite post-rock bands. The bandleader and multi-instrumentalist John McEntire has been so influential in the post-rock world lending his hand to some great groups such as the Sea and Cake, Gastr del sol, and many of Jim O'Rourke's works. The music here is complex, multi-layered and very atmospheric. I think their next album, TNT is slightly better (with one of my all time fav songs I set my face to the hillside), but Millions is also a real gem.
I think I'm just not a post-rock guy.
This was very chill vibes and fantastic as background music at work which was what I was using it for.
First song bad/stressy. Other songs kinda background music-y.
Other than seeing the length of track one I have no idea here hope I enjoy it. The album starts with the song Djed it’s a few minutes short of being half of the entire album ( 21 minutes) it’s very off putting as it’s this really slow building instrumental which kinda lives and breathes throughout. Unlike other long songs I’ve herd on this it doesn’t have any mind blowing stand out moments,actually, the only way I would recommend it is maybe for like study being a really long instrumental. That’s still kinda what I think but then there is the second ten minutes it sounds much, much more interesting and is more a distinct track of it’s own , it’s a harder listen and not really “ study music” like the first half but it’s just better y know; then the third part around 14 minutes in is even harder to listen too stranger and so much more distinctive, I still don’t really like the track but I respect it. There are some other little bits at the end but not much to note. Next is glass museum it’s got a really interesting sound to it the song is mainly this sorta cool instrumental but breaks off intro distinct sections from time to time I still don’t really like instrumental tracks though. Now is the song A survey it’s much shorter but so dull in an album that I don’t really like already. Then it’s the taut and the tame which has this really cool tapping noise in the background kinda like a horse galloping to me. Then it goes in order for normal drums and electronic sounds and just what a way to ruin a cool song. Dear grandma and grandpa is very short for this album it’s quite cool but nothing to change my thoughts on the album. The album end’s with along the banks of rivers it’s well boring to be blunt. The term post rock sounds so cool but when you know what it is it’s so so dull and I wouldn’t even get why anyone would want to make such generally boring music. It’s worse than my one 1/5 so far so I’ll have to give it that.
Classic post-rock album. The amount of electronic elements really sets them apart too.
Big fan of post-rock and this didn’t disappoint
Un dels milestones de l'anomenat postrock, per una de les bandes clau del génere. Hauria de donar origen en els anys posteriors a tot un grapat de propostes semblants, encapçalades comercialment per Mogwai. Un disc interessant i intel.ligent
Nothing like starting an album off with a 20 minute long song. This was not for me...seemed like a glorified jam session for most songs
It reminded me of elevator music with a little extra flair added in. It was good background music but not something that needed active listening.
This is not something anyone really needs to listen to.
Good background music
Verrrry chill music. A little too chill for me. I'm sure it is a nice relaxing album when you're in the mood for something like that.
A perfect album for a rainy day doing nothing...Or is it?
I keep trying to come up with things to say about this album, but it demands more attention than I can give it right now. So, for the time being, I'll say it is an instrumental, shoegazey rock album and I like it.
"Thank you for calling, please wait while we connect your call" [this album starts playing] It's fine, chill, kind of boring at times. I don't have a problem with long songs, but Djed doesn't need to be 21 minutes long when all the cool things happen in the last 8 or so minutes (I really liked that glitchy part). "Dear Grandma and Grandpa" was my favorite song on the album because it reminds me of some ambiance you would hear in an indie horror game - really cool with the weird German(?) voices in the background (obscure reference, but it reminds me of the song "Numbers" from the OMORI soundtrack, which also contains ominous German voices).
Though all parts of it were interesting a 21 minute fully instrumental intro track that had at least 5 different mood swings is not the right way to start an album. After that I was expecting lyrics, but then I read about the genre of Post-Rock. I am usually against instrumental albums because they lack that extra flavor that lyrics add. That being said I do quite enjoy the album because past the lack of vocals I enjoy the musical style. "Glass Museum" and "A Survey" were the top tracks for me. And if "Djed" had been split up into multiple songs a few of them would have fit on there too.
Kind of boring, decent background music.
I loved this when it first came out. This was innovative post rock and turned my head (slowly, like a tortoise) Still enjoy hearing this from start to finish. Still sounds fresh and innovative. Brilliant
I love post-rock. This was a lovely listen.
"Millions Now Living Will Never Die" is not only a very good album, but it also a very important album - as a genre defining record in the post rock genre. Everything that would become a staple for this style is here, specially the focus on textures and timbre in the place of common rock structures like riffs and chords. It's as if rock and roll was becoming free jazz. "Djed" is a 20 minute masterpiece that shows how well Tortoise work together as a band, crafting songs together to create minimalistic sounds, beautiful to the years. In this record, however, they still sound a little crude and it's their next record (1998's TNT) that would show what they were really capable of.
Strange, unusual and occasionally unsettling.
63. Tíunda tugar Indiejazzrokk. Fyrsta lagið er skemmtilegt og rosalega langt. Hin eru ágæt. Fínt, en ekkert brjálæðislega eftirminnilegt.
1990's Krautrock. If you know, you know
This is absolute torture.
Not bad but my taste
I played it while I was working yesterday. It was part of the background… background music (?) I am sure I am doing this wrong
Zzzzzzzz
Background noise.
Sadly rather dull, pleasant enough background sounds but never really excited
It's like these guys have studied how to be the most background of bands.
I'd heard of Tortoise before, but hadn't listened to their albums. I had this one on in the background, and didn't pay much attention to it. Good interesting sounds, nothing that niggled me. Pleasant enough, but no idea when one track ended and the next started.
A post-rock classic
Ingredients: A bit of this.. Hmm. A bit of that too! 3/5.
Post rock. needs more rock and less post, perhaps? I cannot remember a damn thing that happened on this record. Not as clever-clogs as prog, some nice playing and I like the approach to sound, but found it aimless wallpaper. (Full disclosure: I am in a foul mood today, and not prepared to enjoy anything.)
I get it. I get it. I get it. You make experimental music, someone has to listen to it. Dear Grandma and Grandpa seems indulgent. I wonder if they broke out the bubly when they listened to it. Djed was OK for some parts, not OK for the most part. I've spent less time doing my taxes than the length of this song. How/where do you listen to this song? What's a situation where you want time to go on and on? The last 30 seconds of an NBA game? Yeah, it's like the last 800 hours of an NBA game, then. It should be broken down into 16 different songs because I don't know that any parts related to each other. Finally, this album, it seems, will never die.
Eccentric and unusual... thought it never veers too far into unconventional to be too challenging to appreciate. An interesting listen.
like dropping acid while at an aquarium. it's strange, challenging, and your mind wanders, but you find yourself occasionally fascinated by the textures and colors
Nice and mellow and I generally like instrumental music. This skates dangerously close to elevator music territory and quickly fades into the background.
Very cool atmospheric Math Rock. Will definitely be adding this to my “background music while I work” collection.
Very similar to Can's Future Days. This is something to leave on in the background, nothing more.
Right up my alley
A laid back and moody indie rock sound. The tracks are instrumental soundscapes rather than songs… gets boring after a while
Rating: 5/10
Love may they live
I'm not sure how this band or album is important or influential.
Well, I have to say it's remarkable how virtually every postrock album ever (spanning decades, evidenced by the album at hand) manages to deliver this very specific experience: • oh wow what a title/bandname! Clearly master poets at work. • yes, the jams are good (approx t=40 seconds in) • wait, am I still listening to music? where am I? (approx t=somewhere between 40 seconds and 40 minutes in). • looks at the title/bandname, and laments that the music isn't as poetic (not strictly in the literal sense, but in the artistic balance sense) as the labelling attached to it. I'm a postrock fan, but maybe not for the music. I can't say I understand it, either.
Full disclosure: if I had to pick one genre to consign to the garbage bin of history, it would be post-rock. This pompous snoozefest of a genre is a pet hate of mine. I'm already familiar with this Tortoise album and it's better than most of the genre that would come after. There are some strong elements of kosmische/kraut, minimalism, and ambient - all genres I love. But I'd much sooner listen to the originals, rather than have it all filtered through slow-motion indie rock. Having said that, the opening 20-minute track is actually very enjoyable. The five shorter tracks don't really do anything interesting. 2.5*
very experimental electronic and some instrumentals, interesting
Pink Floyd, The Glow Pt. 2, Joy Division; incredible for what it is (instrumental post-rock) but not my favorite genre
Heel speciale instrumentale muziek. Rustig maar intrigerend.
6/10
Chill if it was a rainy day, but it wasn’t a rainy day
Instrumentals are cool but not my style of music to listen to for fun.
It's ambient and okay, but not interesting.
I enjoyed this one - even if as background music I could engage with
12/14/21 - Wonderful, slinky, highly unobtrusive
A really relazxing jazz vibe instumental album. I like it
A lot of people remember the experience of plugging in a casio keyboard for the first time and wanting to try out all the presets and features all at once. Most of us don't try to call that an album though.
First Listen. Really interesting. Need to hear more of this.
Great for putting on while you’re doing something else. Ambient but not dull
This was cool! Never heard of it, will listen again. Great for work and study. The songs run together a bit, but in a good way.
don't hate it but does nothing for me
not terrible - very different
Interesting 90s soundtrack-for-no-movie merging EDM with psych and chillout lounge.
I’m partial to a bit of post rock here and there. Mogwai being my go-to choice. In my mind Every Mogwai album sounds like it should be a soundtrack to a zombie apocalypse film like 28-days later. Tortoise dials down the soundtrack to the end of the world thing, it’s not so bleak…. But it is just as slow burning.
Apparently this is 'post-rock'. It's is one for the musos I think. The intricacies of what it is doing musically goes over my head somewhat. A pleasant enough instrumental album though. 2.5/5.
Post rock? Is that what this is? It's got some interesting music on it. Some of which grabs my attention, some of which keeps me un interested but none of it offends me. I actually like listening to this album especially late at night. 3.5 stars
Laid back, technically complex, chill.
Did nothing for me.
Extremely underwhelmed by this.. Shame
Plenty of variation, solid chill tunes.
Didn't get this at all
They saw a vision and they made that vision happen
Great, experimental, easy going, never boring.
2/5 I don't recall any of these songs. And I heard this album 3 times.
Yo La Tengo meets ambient no vocals
Saw them live at ATP. Great music.
1.5 i don't get it. its just a bunch of noise, like the band felt they needed to use eveyr sound they could think of. its too bad too cause in the middle of some of these songs there's good ideas but they never go anywhere and instead are replaced by something boring or trite.
a bit to avante garde to be called just ambient music 2.5
ambient, jazz, rock
TUBULAR BELLS! Jk. This was a the score to a 45 minute casual chase scene, on foot, in London, and no one is running. Somewhere between film noir, Good Times, and Mr Bean. Someone gave the Pink Panther a synthesizer. C+
I liked some of the build and crescendos in this. Some really nice movie score-like portions of the album. I heard Godspeed You, Tool, Portishead, Yo La Tango. Interesting that they threaded in vibraphone. Do I need lyrics for a 4, maybe.
Meh. Some interesting bits, some boring bits, not too much to say. Maybe I didn't give it enough of a listen, was pretty distracted.
4.5
Really interesting textures and ideas coming together - thought provoking instrument music, great for reading and chilling
This was a nice surprise. Entirely instrumental album that was really chill and enjoyable. Nice Lofi music to study or read.
ethereal, clean, coming of age, both hard and soft, fantastically 90s (cool album name too x)
The first track is 20 minutes of not a whole lot of anything but green museum was very good.
okay?
An ok listen while working/studying. It has a couple of interesting moments and the music is nice enough.
Very clever. Interesting mix of sounds and genres. Fave songs: Glass Museum, Dear Grandma and Grandpa, Along the Banks of Rivers
Guess I’m not that familiar with “post rock” but what the fuck was that?
Yay! Alex Talbot
This was fine, it suffers ,like some classical music, in that even if I wanted to listen to djed again, it's too long and too much of a commitment to put it on a playlist or something. As background music it's generally alright though
I liked it. It's good background music for when I am working. Funny that the first track is 20mins and the rest somewhat normal length.
It's definitely interesting
Some nice post rock, wasn't really in the mood for it at the time but will maybe give another go. Probably very influential etc etc
Maybe this was ground breaking at the time, but now it sounds like every "Alpha Wave Music to Relax and Study" video on youtube. Would put it on in the background and forget about it but there's nothing special about it. Giving it an extra star for any historical relevance it might have.
meh, not really my jam as far as post rock goes, call me when we get to Mogwai
cool. very sea and cake.
Good music to listen to while working.
I'd give it a 3, I like post rock but this had very little emotion. GYBE, Boards of Canada and especially Explosions in the Sky have all done this project to better effect. The 20 minute suite first song is good and the last song was pretty good with the western influence but generally it fell flat. I would listen to it again at night on headphones to see if I maybe was just in.the wrong headspace.
Sounded decent, but i barely even noticed when it finished.
I dig it. It's very hard for me to put into words what I got out of the album but I think it's fairly representative of what this album achieves. There's just loads of good composition, arrangement, choice of instrumentation, and it all creates a really wonderful texture for my brain to get lost into. Lots of mental images, feelings, the kind of abstract things you might feel that you know would be unbelievably contrived to try to articulate. Will probably revisit this album as well as the rest of the Tortoise discography. I'm genuinely surprised I didn't discover and adore this album in high school, it would have been right up my alley. I guess this is post rock? The thing that really strikes me is the obvious krautrock influence, and I fucking love that genre of music. It's what immediately pulled me into the album. Good post rock is usually devoid of obvious, masturbatory build up and crescendos behind walls and walls of reverb and delay as a lazy attempt to create some kind of effective aesthetic and feeling of catharsis. This is a fine example of how to make stunning post rock without those cliche's. I wish I had better words to describe. There are a plethora of moments in this album that really get me into the moment and I'm in that holy trance of jam. There are a lot of unexpected left turns and stylistic choices but they don't clash at all, it never feels inconsistent. Tons of variety. I love this album actually.
Lot's of really cool noises and ambient soundscapes, as well as satisfying glitchy drums - for me, there's a couple too many recycled ideas and lulls in interest to be a great post-rock album, something that would stand toe-to-toe with the likes of GY!BE. I'd give it 3.5 if I could
An album that helped establish post-rock. What is post-rock. I don't know. I thought this was krautrock at first. I listened to their other album "TNT" to get a better idea and all I heard was jazz fusion. Nevertheless, this would be a crowning krautrock album that has a general flow but always changing that kep things interesting and fun. It's one of my favorite instrumentals and something I'll play from time to time.
New one. Seems to be purely instrumental, not really my jam. After listen to it for a while I can safely say: I don't like this record.
Instrumental. A veces guay, a veces parece que se ha roto el CD.
Cool ambient, somewhat weird
Ambient background music, not my cup of tea
experimenteller indie
Not Brian Eno, But better than expected
alright
Sounds a little like jazz Sounds strange with a mix of scifi. 2.5/5, it is hard to stay focused listening to this
It's alright. Seems all instrumental thus far. 2of5
Quite a surprise of an album. Fully instrumental, I could feel the raw emotion throughout. Will definitely be a repeat listen.
Why was this even on the list. Pretty weak.
Really nice listening. A bit experimental at times. Made me think "what's really going on here?"
Enjoyed but won't seek it out. I'll probably forget about it.
really boring, nothing speciall, only to have in the background
Pretty dope instrumentals here. Some went on a little too long but a lot of great bass lines and cool use of sounds. I liked it a lot but it was perfect
Instrumental, good background music. Can't say that I would ever just listen to it without being background music.
Stop making 20 minute songs! No one has time for this! The whole thing is artful but not for me.
Impressively atmospheric and immersive.
Instrumental music that seems like it'd be nothing more than background music. I can't imagine sitting and listening to it intently.
This really didn’t make me feel anything other than bored. It was enjoyable at times, but lost itself trying to find some sort of experimental sound. Not my cup of tea.
tortoise is one of the seminal bands in postrock. this is a must listen album for anyone that likes complex, yet gentle long form songs. in the vein of do make say think, explosions in the sky, godspeed you! black emperor
Not great
4
interesting vibes but no lyrics which is a no for me. 2/5
Unusual instrumentals... Can't imagine picking it up to play as an album but still was interesting background filler
Ugh. Rhythmic noise for the sake of making noise. Just doesn't serve any purpose or have any emotion. The second half of "Glass Museum" was adequate as a song. That, and the fact that it serves as passable background noise, salvages a 2.
Really surprising. Never heard of this band before. It's instrumental, something that wouldn't have spoken to me much when I was younger, but I find it excellent now. So much variety and interesting textural and atmospheric sounds. A deep surprise I'll probably find myself listening to again in the near future and maybe explore the band's other work. Djed is the 20min experimental, progressive wild ride that reminds me of Fear of a Blank Planet yet even better strung together. Just awesome find.
I was a bit dismayed to see a 20 minute track, but this ended up being a quite pleasant sonicscape of noise.
It sounds like muzak. I felt I was standing in a lift, waiting to reach my floor. I can find no redeeming features in this album. It is very bland.
Zzzzzzzzz snooze town
Kept waiting for something to happen. Took like 4 songs to do so. I just felt like the album took way too long to do what they were trying to do.
would use for like background music in yt videos.
*weird noises *probably made around the time before djs so experimenting with new tech and sounds
Not a fan.
Not my thing at all
I liked it. Great to listen to during work. Relaxing enough to feel good about it, interesting enough to not get bored. It was a bit weird how the first song was half of the album and stylistically somewhat different from the second half. The first half I clearly enjoyed more and would have rated it a 4.5 whereas the second half was more of a 3.5 for me.
Lofi classic
Nice chill vibe. Very atmospheric, good for work.
OK, this is weird, 6 songs, but the first track is 20 minutes long. Plus, I've never heard of this, not even sure what the genre is.
Track 1 ‘Djed’ sounds like and is spelt like it was written by an actual tortoise. Musically it’s fine but rest of this album is so blah! Two shitty stars from me. Millions now will never die - that is the exact opposite to my belief system so not only do I not like the music but i can tell me and the band will have fundamental disagreements in our individual philosophies. I did enjoy one track “along the banks of rivers”
Really enjoyed this, will absolutely listen again.
Solid 3.5, gets a 4 because it's better than the other 3s I've rated. When it's good it's excellent, did zone out quite a lot too though
I listened to this one without doing anything else and I really felt my emotions like rise and fall and change with the music, it was nice. The album was really varied and interesting I thought.
Psychedelic sounds
Background noise with no oomph
Caught me in the right mood for this sorta thing this morning. Hugely Hipster, layered indie instrumental. Decent without being something I'd choose to listen to. At points through this i had to check my speakers weren't broken though so loses a point for that. 2/5
Listened to this a few times ages ago but I could only remember the first track. It's sort of post rock but often too jazzy for me
Beautiful as an instrumental album. Great as background. The first track "Djed" is 21 minute opus that goes in several different directions.
Ich liebe Tortoise, bin aber diesem Album sonst eher zwiespältig gegenüber eingestellt gewesen; mag am mittlerweile besser verstandenem Monster Opener „Djed“ liegen, das etwas unfertig, abstrakt, strukturell technoid wirkt. Da wirkt einstige Schwäche plötzlich als starke Besonderheit schlechthin, folgen doch dann Stücke, die der klareren Postrock Struktur folgen, für die ich damals eine stärkere Neigung hatte. Die Balance ist vorhanden, wechseln die Tracks zwischen diesen Polen immer wieder ab und doch liegt mir das folgende Album TNT ein klein wenig mehr am Herzen. 3.8
Meine Güte, das hatte ich ja völlig vergessen, wie konnte das denn passieren? Fühlt sich an wie eine Wiederentdeckung, und zwar vom selben Format wie die Eno-Platte. Wenn ich der 5 Punkte gegeben habe (was ich jetzt gerade nicht mehr tun würde), dann müsste ich das hier auch, weil sie mich genau am selben Nerv erwischt. Krautig, treibend, fordernd, ständig absichtlich verrätselt und natürlich super artsy. Und intellektuelle Rätsel sind ja immer soo schmeichelhaft! Hab aber trotzdem jetzt keine Lust auf volle Punktzahl (wie eben auch bei Eno nicht mehr), weil: ich bin zu erschöpft und zu urlaubsreif und wünsche mir, dass die nächste Platte entweder von Oasis ist, oder was zum richtig glücklichen Abwatschen. 3,6
Tranquilo, relajado, no aporta nada especialmente
Rock instrumental/ambiental/psicodélico. Rallante
never heard of them before now - for good reason
Had some cool beats, liked the experimental nature of this album.
Easy 5 stars for me. Like the "Lo Fi Hiphop" youtube channel, with a bit more experimentation and daring. I loved all the surprising twists and turns this instrumental odyssey took.
Rock instrumental. Un poco psicodélico. Interesante.
an interesting, melodic, instrumental group. very progressive style of rock i think. long drawn out songs with ebbs and flows of feeling. probably a 3.4/3.5 for me
eh
Nope
No lo termine pero iba bien
Surprisingly enjoyable
I didn't love the album, but I didn't hate it. The last song, "Along the Banks of Rivers," caught my attention the most.
Meh
This is my kind of album. Really digging it.
Really interesting instrumentals!
No sé qué decir.
Well that was refreshingly good! Still not sure what post-rock is supposed to mean, but I guess I like it.
Disco relax
This was really good. Kinda psychadelic. 4.5
I have a soft spot for these types of prog rock albums.
Essential Post-Rock album. Opening song Djed spans from electronic buzzing to more rhythmic grooves and driving bass. Pulling in an electric sounding key and devolving into more electronic sound it is the highlight of the album. Halfway through the song it opens into a mix of traditional open guitar and electronic sounds and a xylophone. Background, foreground or whenever you listen to it, it can be on constant repeat.
enjoyed that, not all good but the good bits were good
Feel like once you’ve heard one art rock band you’ve heard them all. Do we really need tortoise when we have mogwai?
This album is great. Purely instrumental with a really engaging, low-key, atmospheric sound. 'Along the Banks of the River' has been my favourite so far. 4 stars, easy.
Liked it a lot. Very different. Nice and chilled