Millions Now Living Will Never Die by Tortoise

Millions Now Living Will Never Die

Tortoise

2.89
Rating
23646
Votes
1
11%
2
25%
3
33%
4
23%
5
7%
Distribution

Reviews (page 7 of 9)

scheiss isch nöd uf qobuz Djed meega lang ui. und s goht au öppe 3 minute bises in fahrt chunt. und au denn nur so halbe. oke s tönt als wer ich chli ufem rhodes am umedrucke. drums sind no cool aber meh. etz isch mega lang afoch sones synthi grüsch wo schneller und langsamer wird. nocher schnell afoch arpeggios mit bassmelodie und denn grüsch time. de david fänds worschinli banhbrechend oder son rotz. pftpft tschktschktshc diuuudiuuu. jetz machts taktwechsel tönt chli proggy? no nice. aber finds immerno insanely seicht. a survey. ahaaa das wörs?? sochli bass melodie?? whattt. the taut and tame isch au afoch ei weirdi melodie? boah gseht nochme 1 uus. dear grandma and grandma isch chli ambient sounds. wooow. along the banks of rivers het e melodie wenigstens.

ahh stiimmt ich hanmer denkt ich vermisse 20 minütigi lieder zum GLÜCK hemmer wiedermal eis oke nachem chli ahstrengende intro hanis na nice gfunde dass d drums so schnell ahfanget und jz ischs eifach chli es vor-sich-her-geplänkel, nöd schlecht, nöd würkli guet erinneret mich ziitewiis chli ah game-musig, chunnt aber nöd ah mario kart musig anne hahaha cover findi ok, rette die fise oke ja ich bruch jz e pause oke glass museum findi scho um einiges spannender isch aber glaub en klassische fall vo "hey ich chegg dete isch das glaub speziell gsi aber us de hütige sicht ischs ener chli langwilig" hey ja s xylophon oder was es au immer isch findi mengisch funny aber ja along the banks of rivers hani sehr geil und moody gfunde, glichzitig chönnts au d übergangsmusig vomene die drei ??? hörspiel sii jaa ich kueg wieni morn gluunt bin aber s letschte lied hets jz glaub gad vomene 2 ufes 3 ufeglupft oke nei figg ihm

21 minute opening track? Get over yourself lol

This is a weird album. First song is 20 min long. It's all instrumental, kinda new age jazz rock.

Not my type of music.

Mellow electronica, which was mostly fine. I could have done without the bit that sounded like the "CD" was skipping/breaking/malfunctioning though.

Honestly fit my mood for the day. For me it was maybe aphex twin meets slow dive meets yo la tengo ?? but more like electronic and progressive?? Cohesive as an album. Rating: V cool I vibe

Don't listen to instrumental much but the shoegaze hit for homework 5/10

This is human music -4/10

Boring, but not the worst thing to listen to when I was getting groceries. But I’m not rocking with a 20 min long song

Pretty funky, it’s very difficult for me to stay engaged when there are no words and I don’t think the instrumentals were all that 4/10

Pretty accessible as far as avant-garde music goes. I don’t really like avant garde music though. Definitely too boring to be the only thing I’m doing, but alright background music. 4.5/10

7.5/10 - Very interesting pieces. The production style was off the charts and the melodies were so much fun to listen to. The first song was way too long but individually the parts were very nice to listen to.

Kinda weird but most of it was enjoyable to listen to 7/10

First song sounds like a 10 year old trying to make a daft punk song in garage band but they don’t know how to start a new song so they just keep piling on to one with all their new ideas 4.5/10

Elevated elevator music. It’s not bad for what it is, but I found myself wanting more.

Just sounded like a garage band noodling around for an hour jam session. Had some catchy bits, but way too long for what it was.

No idea how this shit made the list

Was on in background. Didn’t really grab me.

Glass museum and ‘banks of rivers not bad

Interesting album but the only song really worth listening to is the intro which takes up half the album.

background noise - 3/5 its ok

I had this album for 20 years in my collection and heard eventualy a little bit of it. Now I'm exited to recover ist again. It's excellent.

Previous Familiarity: None! I've heard of the band , but know nothing from them. Post-Rock is a tricky genre. I do not particularly seek it out, as I am never in the right mood or state of mind to find myself enjoying it. It either sits in my subconscious while my mind drifts off to inner thoughts, or I'm too engaged and critical of what is happening with each passing tape-hiss or guitar stab. There isn't structure or melody for me to enjoy. That said, the 14 minute mark of the 20 minute opener "Djed", is magical. The tone changes from rhythmic chiming of vibraphones to a cd-glich dissonance that them morphs into it's own dark atmosphere. It was jarring and beautiful, but really the only moment on the album where I was intrigued.

Godspeed you bland Mogwai! I dunno I guess Tortoise started this gloomy downbeat instrumental thing and I don’t hate it. But it’s not atmospheric enough to enjoy on its own and the lack of dynamics and drama just leave you with a soundscape. Probably good music for driving at night or walking by the sea.

21 min opening track! Woah! A curious album overall and I'm left not knowing quite what to make of it.

Entspannend und mystisch. Angenehm nebenbei zu hören.

Couldn’t get all the way through it. I like instrumental, but this all just sounded like one big song that wasn’t that great.

Alla förutom första låten var bra. Coolt med mycket instrumental

Nice ambient music with fun use of synthesizers I like it but I wouldn't listen to it often

Sounds like ambient piano music for bedtime.

Not a fan.

pra mim, hoje, é não kkk chatão

Too long and experimental for me to get into it

Very reminiscent of The Dirty Three. Beautiful, haunting melodies and the album itself doesn’t sound too dated.

Pleasant but not memorable

Excellent

Gave me a headache. Not my cup of tea.

This is a great post rock album that has strong bonds to prog rock but without going over the top. Especially the percussion helps to keep the music a bit grounded. It has some sort of meditative element that allows you to be shaken up by the world around it.

It’s bad of me, I know, but I struggle with instrumental albums. That being said, this was fine and unobjectionable to my ears but I have very little ability to estimate its musical worth

Prazeroso. Não fiquei incomodado em nenhum momento. É bonito, suave e gostoso, mas não me chamou muito a atenção. Delicious!

Pass. 1.5 stars.

2.5 stars

ASMR album. Not sure why anyone would say that this is an album that everyone should hear before they die. MAYBE everyone should listen to it to help them get to sleep. 1/5

Music to build furniture to

Interesting album. Like most of the instrumental albums on this list, it's more of a mood music piece. Pleasant background music, but not something I can appreciate. 2/5.

Djed is very matrixy Will have to give another listen but solid playing

Random noise would be an improvement on this.

3/5 pleasant but lossless-like walking through an art gallery, you can appreciate but it’s never going to wow unless you’re embroiled in it.

The first track certainly did not need to be 17 minutes. The rest of this was decently enjoyable.

From one experimental album to another. Millions Now Living Will Never Die is quite a bit more experimental than the last album i looked at. Especially with the first song. It took so many twists and turns that it felt like it could be split off into many different songs. I was also surprised when the audio got distorted on the first track which made me believe something was broken at first. I still found quite a bit to like about the experimentation even if some songs didn't have too much to them. I still liked this album and think it is worth a listen if this stuff interests you Best Song: Djed Worst Song: A Survey

Music to fall asleep to

I simply was not built to enjoy instrumental prog rock. Get this out of here.

"We have Godspeed! You Black Emperor at home" type beat

A chill album that was nice for ambient music while doing chores. Definitely a time and place album

Well that was exceptionally irritating. There might be some jams hidden in the midden but it's hard to tell underneath the overwhelming trash-heap of noise. The few times something resembling a song rose to the top of the pile, it was repetitive and boring. And let's talk about that first track. 20+ minutes, guys? And halfway through, it just... changes completely? That's a new track, fellas. And then it changes completely again for the last two minutes? That's another track. This isn't hard math. When the song changes and it never goes back to an earlier musical theme, it's a new song. Saying it's not is just pretentious and frustrating. The ONLY reason this album isn't getting a full-on fail is because "Glass Museum", while repetitive and about two minutes too long, is at least interesting. The rest of the album is garbage.

Went in with an open mind knowing nothing about this, but I’d be lying if I didn’t feel some slight dread seeing that 20 minute opening track, especially since I knew NOTHING about what was ahead of me. But this is fucking amazing, scratched an itch that I didn’t realise was there. This album placed me in a state of total, dreamy euphoria throughout the entire 43 minutes. Extremely calming, gorgeous instrumentals, I actually needed this today.. I don’t really know what else to say, out of all the albums I’ve had from this project so far, this one is my favourite. 5/5

I am about to give up on this list.

Boring electronic music.

There were moments I hot excited about what was happening but nothing ever happened.

5/5. A really great post-rock album, slow-moving and hesitant without ever feeling boring. The best song is the first 20-minute long Djed but the second side of small ideas is also great. They all feel urgent yet basking in their patience hoping the audience will relax with them, and if you do allow yourself to calm down, your experience will be heightened. Although I wouldn't say I would enjoy this all the time, this was one I couldn't really find fault in.

It was just okay.

I could of made this

3 1/2 stars !! good, interesting instrumental prog-rock album, like slint, explosions in the sky, duster more but it's solid!

V pohode to bolo

Pretty cool post-rock/experimental album with krautrock, minimalist and jazz influences. Kinda gives me an instrumental Stereolab or Broadcast vibe at times, which can only be a good thing to this listener. Not an every day album or anything, but it's moody and beautiful and I can appreciate it for that. Probably doesn't deserve to be here over Mogwai or Sigur Ros or Explosions In the Sky or whatever, but I'm not complaining.

4 - really enjoyed it, a great journey

21 minute 90s alternative song - sign me up. I'm all about this nonsense. 10 stars. millions/5

an album with nothing but instrumentals… gross. seriously though, the first song is over TWENTY fuckin’ minutes! what the h? much of this album sounds like a jam session of a college jazz band. a lot of experimental elements. it feels like the musicians are trying to do something profound, i guess, but it just kind of falls flat.

Had a very strong and immediate emotional reaction to this album. None of it was positive. It varied between irritable and irate. I hope everybody associated with the chain of events that led me to listen to this album stops their toe.

Not my jam

Very abstract. Similar to Yes in that it's mostly instrumental. Hard to get into

wtf is this

An instrumental that went fast. Didn't sound critical to me, but ok.

C’est le God Speed You! Black Emperor d’ascenseur. J’adore la musique instrumental, mais ça me tombait vraiment sur les nerfs au bout d’un moment

Instrumental jams

I like it. Reminds me of “Latin” by Holy Fuck, but precedes it by 20 years. I wasn’t totally sold at first, but as it went on, I was impressed by the number of ideas and textures they conjured up. After the first 20 minute track, I was expecting the rest of the album to have a similar sound, but the second track really surprised me by how big it sounded. I wasn’t familiar with the term “post-rock” ahead of this listen, but I like the idea of it. Focusing on timbre, texture, and minimalism—I definitely hear the Steve Reich influence, and about 11 minutes into “Djed” reminded me of Terry Riley’s “In C.”

Descent album solid 5

Not bad at all

dreadful

- I was super intrigued by the fact that I had never heard anything about those folks before, as well as by the interesting title of the album. - Huge disappointment. - This is supposed to sound creative and experimental, but for me it ended up being messy and annoying instead. - One of the few albums that I didn't manage to finish so far.

I like this one. Really cool for ethereal sounds or background music or possibly bedtime.

If that's the music accompanying my immortality, then I'm glad I won't live forever.

I enjoy EITS instrumental but this is a bit soulless. No real chamce to groove or settle in here.

Tortoise is apt name for the band, the music is slow and plodding. Glass Museum is decent, but the opener Dejd isn’t and it’s 25 mins. Most won’t get through it 2.7/10

They have a distinctive sound, that comes off fairly warm and inoffensive for how experimental they're being. I am not immediately hooked but I could see it growing on me. Kudos to them for helping forge a new direction in "post-rock."

Much more than math going on here. They venture out far beyond genres.

Almost reminds me of a more modern Neu! at parts. Pleasant experimental/post-rock. It was a nice soundtrack for a work day.

This isn't a rock album and it's boring as hell

Dreary nonsense. Like a shite Boards of Canada.

Tortoise taught us little.

like four kids in a big coat

Ok but not my fav

Wasn’t bad, though a bit all over the place. Maybe that’s my fault, but I couldn’t tell if it was going for electronic minimalist, or straight jammy instrumental. Good, nonetheless!

tortoise's millions now living will never die is rather a unique instrumental album and listening to it was an interesting journey. each song is distinct and it's easy to differentiate between them. at times, it had a whimsical vibe, other times it was futuristic sounding, and it could get distorted, too. i felt like i was melting into the album at times.

This felt unique, and I was certainly fascinated by all the rather uncommon instrumentation. That said, it really didn't do much for me beyond a little bit of curiosity and intrigue. I would have liked to have been wowed more, especially considering this album's place on the project. Interesting, but not THAT interesting.

The first track is 20 minutes long.

Atmospheric post-rock that's good for moody background music. I enjoyed listening to it while I was working, no vocals to distract. I also like the title, apparently it's a reference to a Jehovah's Witness slogan from the 1920s. Fine for background music, not really my genre. 3.25/5

Not bad, not great.

I enjoyed this a lot, vibey and well produced, very cool listen

So chill!!! Their following album ”TNT” is a personal favourite, and this one is great too!

Tru blassic hade glömt hur bra detta band är

Not something i would play usually but this was a solid album. Standout song for me was Along The Banks of Rivers Just a nice working vibe album.

Side B is a bit listenable, side A however os just 20 min of garbage. Gets an extra star bc that successfully convince you, on multiple occasions, that your stereo is broken

If I wanted to listen to random noise that sounds a bit like a thunderstorm, I'd listen to a thunderstorm.

Instrumental and cool long songs

This is an interesting album, and I’m intrigued by it. I don’t know why the first song DJed is one long track instead of broken up in other songs (which would be much better IMO). The rest of the album has that post-rock cool bass lines and funky drums other sounds. All in all, may listen to this again. Will check out there other stuff.

Atmospheric, kinda spooky. Instrumental guitar, some stuff that feels like it would fit right into a movie

Instrumental - no lyrics

Interesting album, kept my attention

Interesting little instrumental number

Not offensive instrumental music. Would put on in the background to do work.

There’s a peaceful serenity to some of this record. It just gets too samesy for my and lacks true energy. I wanted something to get me going not an album to fall asleep to. Nonetheless for those that love instrumental music there’s some truly enlightening music being made here.

Falls between ambient and post-rock, but doesn't really reach either.

It's not terrible, some of the instrumentals are rather peaceful. However, this is just an album I could not get into.

Meh to the power of meh squared.

Why is this on the list

Not for me

I'd possibly find 1001 instrumental albums worth istening to before this one.

This is pretty nice. Reminds me strongly of Do Make Say Think with a pinch of American Football. No particular tracks stand out; it all just feels like a cohesive piece of work.

As someone born in the last decade of the 20th century, I don't really know a life without this kind of minimalistic math rock-y sound. And it also sounds like its time to me (90s -- it must have been so weird to go to college in the last years of life before everyone was Online....) Its easy to listen to and easy to imagine it playing at a climbing gym or in a yoga class led by a Gen Xer. Pleasant enough music for the background, but not novel or particularly interesting- sounding to me.

Never heard of this album before, surprised it doesn’t even have 3 stars overall, because it’s quite good

Weird, slightly unnerving. Biggest draw was that one of their songs has been used as a segue between stories on NPR.

Not for me

low-key, instrumental, nah

I don’t feel a difference between this and jazz. Instrumental music that meanders around central themes and ideas. Very good.

I was never expecting to like this album, but it's actually kinda cool sounding. Sometimes it was boring, but I found myself enjoying it a decent amount of the time. I think my favourite song was Glass Museum.

Strange: just felt like the demo button on majority of pianos but at the same time it felt so well crafted with it flowing seamlessly at points. I feel rather conflicted when it comes to rating it then bc it is neither bad nor any absolutely extortionary. Just a very average instrumental album for majority of it.

Pretty cool

This is just noise. It is not unpleasant noise but I certainly wouldn't call it a masterpiece at any point. It certainly is not noteworthy. It is just there.

I can recognize the influence, but just not all that interesting. There are better examples of post-rock that take the idea to the next level

if you listen closely, at 14:36 of "Djed," you can hear the sound of the band jerking off as they imagine music nerds pretending like this is listenable

Cool title. If I never died, wouldn't that mean I'd have forever to listen to the 1,001 albums? Unfortunately, I struggle to pay attention to most instrumental music. It was technically good, I guess, but just background music for me.

Pfff als een schildpad op het land, zo saai en traag beweegt deze muziek.

Instrumentaal en experimenteel. Not my cup of tea.

Muziekaal hoor ik wel mooie dingen, maar het is me allemaal teveel van hetzelfde om echt te blijven boeien.

Movie score music. Not particularly interested in this unfortunately.

Never heard or heard of this. Is this another record that's going to annoy me about the exclusion of both Godspeed and Mogwai from this list? There is one Boards of Canada record. I mean, it's a pleasant enough listen, but not essential or standout, for me.

Interesting soundscapes for sure but hard to find a hook that would ever make you want to listen again

Was hyped for an under 45 minute album. But then the first track is the longest song in history and just goes no where.

Sopi videopelin tehofarmauksen taustalle. En kuuntelisi kyllä ilman jotain ajatuksia muualle vievää aktiviteettia.

Paikoin meni kyllä melko erikoiseks. Kiikunkaakun kakkonen

Self absorbed useless cacophony of sound. I want my time back. I want to give 0 stars

How many starts? Really difficult to answer… One moment I think that this is quite boring, other moments I think this is really interesting music. I landed on four stars…

Hard to believe it is almost 30 years ago this was released. I liked it then and I like it now. Favourite song: Djed, of course.

I hadn't listened to any Tortoise in a long while, but this is still a great album. They have this unique sound that I absolutely love.

Thrilling music, full of interesting sounds.

Wow I was not expecting this to be instrumental. Lucky for you, 1001 albums, I actually really appreciate instrumental tracks. 4/5

Weird shit. I don't really get it. I don't doubt that a great deal of thought went into it, but without a deeper understanding of what they were going for it's difficult to have a deeper understanding of the music. Also, how is "Post-Rock" a genre? Rock is still a big deal.

Very slow, and kind of monotonous, yet also kind of dreamy. Would put something like this on a sleep playlist. Best: Glass Museum Worst: Djed 2.5 stars

Eh, it was really just okay. I wouldn’t be upset if this were on or anything, but the song writing didn’t do it for me. It was often very repetitive and where it wasn't it didn’t catch me. So, all in all probably wouldn’t play this again.

As far as jazz fusion goes this is quite disappointing. Thought my AirPods were bugging during the first track but was just the song

A track like “Djed” is interesting to me because it reminds me of jazz in the way it riffs on a melody and the way the music transforms and shape-shifts. But it does so methodically. There’s a calculated feeling here that I associate with electronica or prog-rock. The music straddles the line between organic and mechanical. The album becomes much more organic on the following tracks. "Glass Museum" is gorgeous and sounds more like the product of a full band. And "A Survey" is really cool. It's driven by that ominous, creeping bass line. Cool that one band can go from spacious and laidback on one song to high-strung and tense on the next. Really strong experimental album!

Cool post-rock with interesting moments of experimental noises and SFX. I liked it but felt like I wanted more. I listened to a lot of this while I was at the gym so maybe I wasn't in the perfect headspace for it (this generally doesn't have an affect on me). Also, post-rock is one of my favorite genres and maybe I think this is "pretty good but not great" because I've been listening to this genre for a long time. It's not a bad record though! For this list it's a 3/5 for me which IMO is actually pretty strong. There's other post-rock albums that I am familiar with that I wouldn't even have on this list.

It isn't bad, it just isn't good enough to captivate for the entirety of the album. Some of the musical sections are pretty good, just not enough. 3/5 Would listen to as background music

Interesting, weird and at times mesmerizing

I put this on and forgot it was playing. The song it ended on reminded me that I was listening to something. Not bad to listen to, but no sticky.

Very interesting. This is ostensibly music for the head, as opposed to the heart, yet in its unhurried deconstruction of rock music, it can be quite beautiful. First track 'Djed' sets the scene, dissonance morphing into some pretty cool Krautrock before twisting into yet another sound pretzel - a recurrent theme throughout. Sometimes these shapes are ugly, but always stimulating. And that's not to say that this is a difficult listen; far from it. 'Glass Museum' has a dreamlike quality to it, whilst closer 'Along the Banks of Rivers' could be the dust-spattered soundtrack to a spaghetti western showdown. So - an album that privileges texture and tonality above all the usual business of rock music. It could have been a mess. Instead, it's a triumph.

Man, what's up with the list this week? We get Beck, Queens, Kiss, and Tortoise records, but none of the ones that fans of these bands would call their best work. (Dunno about Taylor; it's why I left her out.) I for sure would choose to listen to "TNT" over this album nearly every day of the week, but I'm again just surprised Tortoise made the list at all. These songs are built to be driven primarily by moments versus the entirety, I think, and there are some beautiful and moodily wonderful moments throughout. The part of "Died" - which, yeah, is 20 minutes freaking long - where the vibes or xylophones or whatever kick in is so damn good that it almost makes up for the rest of the song which is a tad tame. The last song, too. Really liked that one and felt like it could've been in a David Lynch movie somewhere. Like the Queens record, you can sense the coolness to come. Enjoyed it and it made me realize that I've missed listening to post-rock of this era.

Interesting and different album

I think in Tortoise I hear the evolution of all pre-packaged cell phone ringtones. Shout out to the surgically-precise percussion. I liked this, a bit. I think it’s worth two stars.

Achieving Interesting sounds and creating a journey

Pretty chill and mellow, enjoyed driving home listening to this album.

It's not quite TNT but it's still fantastic and very unique.

Real cool post rock. Will revisit.

Interesting stuff, didn't listen to it all though

3/10. Could have just been a pleasant album to listen to in the background despite being a bit boring, but nooo, they had to go and add a whole bunch of unpleasant sounds at the end of the first track to make you pay attention and feel uncomfortable. Not for me.

Actually really boring and bad. 3/10

Pretty cool instrumental album. I am a fan.

Boring but not completely unlistenable

Very good post rock album. A very chill adventure, calmed me down after a stressful day at work. Wonderfully crafted, beautiful tones and slow builds throughout. There’s a certain warmth to this that I really appreciated. Will definitely return to this album. 4 stars

Groovy, ambient almost lo-fi hip-hop before that was a thing.

Also background music that I quite enjoyed but not a huge amount.

Not good. I get that it's trying to be different, but this is just not enjoyable. I am not sure what I was supposed to gain from this album.

Try as they might, they couldn't achieve the same sentiment in a 19 minute song, it had to be 20 minutes and 57 seconds. This is just angsty spa music.

Listened Before? N This sounds like the royalty free soundtrack to a YouTube video. Inoffensive and unremarkable. No vocals. MEH. Added to Library? N Songs added to playlist: A Survey

This is offensive to me

This is really good ambient, mood music

Cool as hell. "Djed" is the standout. 7/10

I felt like I was listening to an album that could have been a really good ambient album. But it sort of missed the mark and instead sounded like a bunch of miscellaneous sounds stitched together, rather than having any sort of cohesion

I’m not one to really listen to instrumentals but the album itself isn’t that bad. I’ve never seen a song that’s twenty minutes long and I really lost interest after the first three but if you want chill background music, this is it.

Once I got over my initial realization that the songs were mostly ambient instrumentals I listened to the music differently. The songs were more like a soundtrack without a movie with interesting atmospheric, experimental sounds and rhythms. Originally, I was ready to write it off as something I normally don't care for, but instead it was an enjoyable listen and worth exploring more of Tortoise.

Takes a while to get into (for me). It is something I'd definitely add to a mood music playlist. But not great. 2.5

Cool as hell

Dig the vibe, but I would never just put this on to listen to

It's mind boggling how someone, anyone, could ever consider giving this more than 3 stars, let alone 5. I knew I was in trouble when I saw the 20+ minute track and spoiler alert: this wasn't good. All instrumental, which doesn't make it bad, but when it's arranged like it had been here... yeah it's not good. 3/10.

Djed alone is worth the price of admission, which it should be as roughly half the run time of this album. What a cool, eccentric, moody assortment.

an ok listen Definitely need to be in the mood

Listen again!

Meio paradao mas ok

This is really damn cool, and exactly the sort of album I was hoping to get recommended. It’s like post-rock/jazz/trip-hop!

It likely I'm just not educated enough in music to get this, but the top review talks about discovering keyboard samples on your cassio keyboard and that's all I can hear now

I thought it was ok at first (admittedly skipped the 21 minute first song), but then it started feeling repetitive

POST-ROCK!! Wasn't sure I'd see any of this on here. I was surprised that it was this album from Tortoise, but after reading how it was one of the more notable entries in early Post-Rock, it makes sense. Album is tactfully written and full of complex emotion. Definitely a good listen

Arty, ambitious, and almost avant-garde, and quite interesting by 1996 standards. Nice balance of organic and electro and an engaging moody/contemplative tone. Certainly worth knowing, though perhaps not quite life-changing or deathbed-worthy.

You know what you're getting when anything is "post-"*insert name of genre here. As expected, technically very accomplished without ever really getting the emotions pumping.

Something about the sounds on the song "The Taut and The Tame" remind me of Land of the Lost, specifically the 70s tv version since that's the only one I've seen. There's also something dark and mysterious about the final song on the album that I'm really into. I'm very much into this album.

What is "postrock"? I don't understand all these meaningless genre names. This sounds like progressive/new age to me. It's not bad, mildly interesting, maybe a bit boring at times. 3 stars.

Got some Civ 3 vibes every now and then.

The opening track was pretty tedious and, especially towards the end, seemed really disjointed. There were some stronger tracks later on but the album had already worn my patience quite a bit by then

The glorious "Djed" is worth four stars alone.

A survey. The taut and tame.

This is great music to work to!

Six songs, 43 minutes. Track 1 is an ambient start - a pleasant building background bop. Doesn't make you stop and listen, it just exists. Track 2 has an uncomfortable drone and jarring sounds on top, it's like a helicopter with lift music, I had to skip it. Track 3= a bit nothing, Track 4=I had an alarm clock that sounded like this. Track 5= promising start, like a drum n bass track that never really takes off. Track 6 = like being underwater, maybe in a submarine. It was certainly an experience, but the only way I would listen again would be to play Track 2 "DJ'ed" to someone who loves music, as an example of how it can make you feel physically sick.

Boa para trabalhar

instrumental

While obviously influential as heck, I feel that a lot of the ideas Tortoise present on their second record are somewhat underdeveloped. Especially 'Djed' feels more like a collage of sound ideas than a coherent composition, and although this is less of an issue on side 2, I am never quite moved in the same way as when listening to other post-rock bands like Mogwai and Godspeed You! Black Emperor.

First and foremost, post-rock needs to move me. That is why I love the genre. The way it affects you emotionally. Tortoise rarely moves me at all. There’s some interesting ideas along the way, but I’m never really engaged. I understand how influential this album has been to some of my favorite artists. It doesn’t change the fact that this blueprint has been improved time and time again.

Djed was such a nice track..

Instrumental, which I don't particularly enjoy but was fairly nice background music for work.

very odd but very cool. lots of unexpected sounds, rhythms, etc.

It was pretty okay

O disco se transforma em um convite a se envolver na experiência musical imersiva. Cria um ambiente sonoro cativante e intenso ao apresentar uma ampla variedade de sons texturais e atmosféricos interessantes.

I forgot how much I loved Tortoise. TNT was on pretty frequent rotation for me back in high school and early college, but I never got around to their other stuff. I'm happy this led me here!

Quite a trip of an album, and honestly surprised by the atmosphere on display.

Will be surprised if I ever go looking for it again, but passed time and didn't dislike it at all

Good listen. Less guitary than expected and better for it.

Very good, I enjoyed most of it

Overall, I liked the low bassy grooves that lived in several of the songs. Djed was half of the album and kind of weak, but I really liked A Survey and The Taut and Tame, especially. I'd listen again.

This is an intriguing album. It's not something to actively listen to, more something to have on in the background as you're doing other things. It's by no means bad, but does have some interesting, if not outright questionable production choices. I'd personally not have gone for quite so much "wibble", but hey, it's not my album.

I typically like my post-rock to have a bit more edge to it, but this is nice. Relaxing. Very Kraftwerk. Bold choice to have the record open with a twenty-minute opus, bolder choice to have it find a groove then cut it off. Would've probably made Andy Kaufman proud. Favorite tracks: "Glass Museum", "A Survey"

I'm not normally one for superlatives but this was a masterpiece

Veldig bra

Strange. But still passive enough for the background. Stays a 3.

Boring, uneventful and unnecessary

El primer track, un embole caprichoso. Cuando entraron los instrumentos se puso un poco más interesante pero no brilló.

I don't see the point of this album being on here. It's instrumentals, which is not bad, but it's not for me and the album is a bit dreary.

weird. 3 stars.

I've heard of Tortoise! It was good, would listen to again for sure.

Sadly a pretty mediocre album. I was hoping for better but you can't win em all. The 2nd and last song were pretty good though. Awesome album and band name as well. Score: 50 Art: 50

Yep, it's post rock. If you love this genre, then you'll probably love this album. For me, I can appreciate some of the sound, but overall, it's a giant snooze fest.

A genuine discovery! I enjoyed this so much

nice and chill - reminds me of Explosions in the Sky

Ik mis de tekst. Het is saai. Daarnaast is 20 minuten erg lang voor een nummer. Je moet er maar van houden.

Album van de post-rock band Tortoise. De muziek is vooral instrumentaal en experimenteel. Niet onaardig om aan te hebben staan, maar ook niet heel bijzonder verder. leukste nummer: Along the Banks of Rivers De album titel is een religieuze slogan dat o.a. bij de Jehovah's wordt gebruikt.

This was an album I found very interesting. I'm not terribly familiar with post-rock as a genre, though I like a lot of the major influences on that genre. There were multiple parts of this album that reminded me of the Krautrock band Neu, just with more noise included in the music. Really cool album, very relaxed. I would not have guessed that it was made in the mid 90s from the sound. It sounds like it was made a few years later than that 4/5

Never heard of Tortoise before today. Upon further research, it became clear as to why I hadn't heard of them. They are a "post rock" band. I was unsure of what the hell that meant, so I researched it a bit. From what I can gather, it is a genre that includes rock style guitars, which are overlaid with shitty electronica music. Fuck sakes, not more obscure electronica garbage... Yes, more electronica garbage. This stuff is perhaps one of the worst helpings of electronica that I've heard thus far. I don't hear the "rock guitar" part, what I hear is static, screeching noises, xylophones, and distorted bass notes...all mixed together in a big shitty mess...and that's just the first song. Also, the first song is....21 MINUTES LONG!!! Why?!? I spent this entire record waiting for something to happen....they had 43 minutes, and NOTHING DID....AT ALL.... Overall, a garbage record, made by a band that sounds like Walmart brand Tool meets up with a game show host. I will never listen to this trash again, and am beginning to wonder who the hell created this list? Obviously someone obsessed with electronica music and obscure British bands, because this has absolutely no reason to be on this list. Favorite song: Along the Banks of Rivers....I guess??? Least favorite songs: Djed, and the rest of this dumpster fire of a record. 1/5

First of all, I think "post-rock" is a really bad term for this genre. Just needed to say that. This has a variety of interesting atmospheres and textures. It feels very modern and sophisticated. There was a kind of cool, jarring moment in "Djed" when I thought my cassette tape was being eaten by my Walkman, but otherwise it was quite soothing.

Interesting and I could see it growing on me, if I gave it a chance. It didn’t thrill me though. After what seemed about an album’s worth I was getting kind of bored and looked to see how much was left…oh, we’re still in the first track… I might give it a second listen sometime for background music while working.

Except when I wondered if my speakers were broken, I very much enjoyed this. Its Steve Reichian rhythms and instrumentation kept me buoyed and focused at work.

The opening track had me instantly excited and intrigued about this group I’ve never heard of. It was an incredible musical journey that was full of little surprises. The rest of the album did not disappoint. I was having some trouble categorizing it in my head (Is this jazz? Lite rock? Progressive rock? ). Whatever it is, I love the use of the vibraphone. I love the occasional squeak of the guitar string. These helped make this album a lot warmer and human than one might expect from something so modern. Excellent!

Phew. This took me all weekend to listen to. It wasn't bad, it wasn't good, it was definitely long.

Probably my favorite album by Tortoise this is a masterpiece!

Background music of no special qualities (and some distinct negative qualities, as per the case of the "experimental" second half of the opening track). By tomorrow I'll forget I ever listened to this album. Turtle, you said?

Vraiment Weird ! C'est pas mauvais et ca met dans l'ambiance. Probablement que je ne me souviendrai plus du tout de cet album dans quelque jours. Donc ca ne m'a pas marqué beaucoup. Note de passage

Ambient 😄

The fact that the first song takes up half the run time is so cool to me, and it’s such a great song too.

That's was a bita fun. Introduction to post rock

When I saw the length of the album compared to the tracks I groaned but these guys were actually really solid

My mate loved Tortoise and I remember dipping in and out of them before but not a proper listen. However I’m sure they had a bit more about them than this. It is good, some decent prts to it (the second track was my favourite), but I’m certain they have better records. I do quite like that jazzy / mathy / post-rocky sound, but parts of this did drift by. Still decent, would return and will revisit their other stuff.

Lots of this was mathy post rock that is exactly my sort of thing, and there were parts where I thought 'this is a nailed on 5/5'. Overall there were a few too many sparse, expansive sections that dragged a bit. Bet this was unbelievably influential though!

Some of the transitions within songs are quite jarring. I enjoyed this more than I thought I would, cannot out my finger on why. I think the variety helps. It doesn't really sound like a jam session either, more like the band are showing each other their skills. Odd samples. I don't know what to think.

Another album with a 20+ min song except this time it sounds like they've just slapped together a load of random sounds. Perhaps this was ground breaking in 1996 but it didn't hold up. I didn't even enjoy it as background music.

Had never heard of tortoise before so had no idea what to expect. I enjoyed listening to it in the background while working. Interesting progressive sound. Found it reminded me a bit of public service broadcasting in parts (I seem to say this a lot). I did enjoy it but I think it goes on the list of music I can have on in the background while working, but probably wouldn't listen to in other situations!

Millions Now Living Will Never Die by Tortoise suffers from a miscataloging. While showing up as 'Alternative' in Apple Music, I'm picking up prog rock, jam-band, jazz, fusion and more. This album was a refreshing listen. It's ambient tones make great background noise while working on a task that requires focus. 4.5/5.

A colossal waste of time.

This is another one of those albums that had to be made so better versions of a similar sound could come after, I guess.. Explosions In The Sky, God Speed You Black Emperor, all that sort of thing that is like this but with a lot more energy and pizzazz. Was fine as background, bit didn't offer an awful lot imo. 2/5.

Enjoyable instrumentals

Does "post rock" mean kind of bland Electronica? Because that's how this struck me... though I was in the midst of an unpleasant driving experience while listening to it so I may not have given it proper attention. I didn't hate it or anything.

Just a grungeband jamming session, instrumental. They got groove but nothing special.

Primitive post rock that makes pretty good use of looping and layering. It's best as an album to play in the background of whatever you're doing.

it's minimalist post-rock. no more, no less. this album walked so godspeed you black emperor could run

I liked this actually - though I'd never heard of it before. The 'instrumental' and 'progressive' nature kind of reminded me of Godspeed You Black Emperor but it was definitely more bite-sized haha The album seems to have been built around the big opener Djed but Taught and Tame was a good one also.

Not too bad. I can’t imagine some dudes getting together to make this - long and kinda weird songs, not a single lyric.

2/5 very slow and no payoff

When this started I had rock bottom expectations, but some of it was actually rather lovely. There’s still a lingering feeling of ‘what makes this special?’, but to be fair, it was probably quite far ahead of its time. The influence on today’s many instrumental post-rock bands (most of whom I’d like, but would only ever listen to in small doses) is clear. 2.5.

Mid. Kinda boring and never really gets going.

Se me hace bola(PSP) Me parece muy acertado el comentario, de hecho no aguante hasta el final (ONB)

why is the first song 20 minutes long? that’s all

This album is one of the most important works of post rock. It experiments with sounds and musical textures in an almost meditative intentional way that allows songs to build, simmer, and dissolve in their own timing. The instrumentation and genre hopping feel like this is almost like a musical laboratory.

I enjoyed the album a lot. It gives off a cold atmosphere. The last track is very haunting sounding too from what I remember. I'll definitely be relistening to it.

Alright ok

Vaya, empieza fuerte "Djed" con 20 minutos seguidos sin avisar. En general se puede escuchar pero es bastante tostón.

Solid. I like it. Atmospheric. 4/5

I'm a bit "square" for "Post rock". Too disjointed and unfocussed.

Good stuff. I got a bit into post-rock in my 20's, but this is a record I'd not heard of before today, and it's pretty great. The occasional, without being gimick-y, inclusion of non-western instruments almost sounds to me like it could be a precursor to Tuatara's Breaking the Ethers. Definitely worth additional listens.

weird album. I didn't care for the huge first track, but the other songs were decent, and even good in places. Gonna average this out to a 3/5, I think

I’m not the biggest post-rock guy most of the time. The music can be incredible, but sometimes I just need more of an edge to my instrumentalists. But I’ve always liked this particular album and think that it’s worth spinning as a sample of how the sound can inspire. Although Lift Yr Skinny Fists is still the GOAT B+

Idk it was pretty good, at first the transitions really irritated me and literally almost made me throw up. But once it moves over it’s pretty dang good. I don’t think I appreciated it as much as I should because it was morning and I needed words not insutrmentals but I liked it

minimalista ambient

I remember me and the guys playing random warm up riffs while we were tuning our kit up... but that was back when I was 15 at school... I never thought of putting an album together of those random riffs... and people would pay money for this! I just don't get it, yes it's easy listening, its just a random miriad of soft sounds, or put you to sleep sounds moreso, but wouldn't even come into my thoughts for a choice of listening.

Brilliant album! Listened to this a few times. My kind of music 👍

I came across this review 'Will definitely be adding this to my “background music while I work” collection' and see what they meant, though I don't agree. I certainly couldn't stand to sit and listen to this as music - I'd have to be doing something and use it as background, and for that purpose some of it is OK. Clearly influencex by Kratrock. which I generally like. Most of this, I dislike.

Ooh this was very nice. For some reason despite loving Mogwai and Godspeed I never got onto Tortoise. Glad I have taken the time to get to know them now. Gloomy, occasionally funky, all very fun.

Not the worst album on the list but it made me think of headphones on while trying to sleep on a 6 hour red-eye flight music. By the time you land, you know it was there for you the whole time but you're still dead tired and you can't remember any of it.

Wow! This is an album out of nowhere for me, but it rocks! I could have predicted a lot of the shade being thrown its way in the reviews but it's really cool and quirky. An experience as much as anything, the opening 21 min track bending and winding its way through the soundscape.

Cool for what it is, but did I enjoy it? Not really.